View Properties

PCB 81-037 05/27/82 Goodman Dissenting Opinion
CARGILL, INC. v. ILLINOIS ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Handle: Document-30165
Owner: Site Administrator (User-2, admin:DocuShare)DS
Wednesday, November 27, 2002 03:06:05 PM CST
Friday, June 13, 2003 09:25:41 AM CDT
Modified By: Site Administrator (User-2, admin:DocuShare)DS
Locked By:
  • ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
May 27, 1982CARGILL, INC., Petitioner,v.
  • ) PCB 81—37
ILLINOIS ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ) AGENCY, Respondent,DISSENTING OPINION (by I.
  • Goodman):
Focusing on industrial waste and its definition as thepollutant, the majority of the Board held that since the originof pollutants contained in Petitioner’s discharge to the FoxRiver could not he traced to Petitioner~sindustrial process,no NPDES permit was required for its point discharge.
  • The nexus between the contaminants
and their origin is irrelevant.
  • Therefore,
I would hold that the contaminants discharged into the Fox Riverby P...
Allowed
Adobe Portable Document Format (.pdf) - application/pdf
OCR0002.pdf
4
198251
No
Appears In: PCB 81-037
Preferred Version: PCB 81-037 05/27/82 Goodman Dissenting Opinion