Skip to Contents

DocuShare

Advanced
Location: Home  Contains  ...  Contains  1980 - 1989  Contains  1988  Contains  PCB Cases  Contains  Cases 88-001 through 88-050  Contains  PCB 88-016  Contains  PCB 88-016 07/13/89 Dumelle / Nardulli Dissenting ... Properties
Document

View Properties

PCB 88-016 07/13/89 Dumelle / Nardulli Dissenting Opinion
ANTHONY W. KOCHANSKI v. HINSDALE GOLF CLUB
Handle: Document-24450
Owner: Site Administrator (User-2, admin:DocuShare)DS
Tuesday, June 4, 2002 09:49:30 AM CDT
Thursday, May 1, 2003 11:19:38 AM CDT
Modified By: Site Administrator (User-2, admin:DocuShare)DS
Locked By:
  • ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
July 13, 1989ANTHONY W.
  • KOCHANSKI,
Complainant,v.
  • ) PCB 88-16
HINSDALE GOLF CLUB, Respondent,DISSENTING OPINION (by J.
  • Dumelle and M.
  • Nardulli):
We respectfully dissent from the majority Opinion and Orderof the Board in this case dated July 13, 1989.
  • This evidence is sufficient for us to find unreasonable
interference. We believe that justice is betterserved where this Board reviews and analyzes the record as awhole, not where this Board summarily dismisses all the evidencesimply because a pro se complainant does not move his lips in acertain way. There is, thus, noreason for the majority to invoke Section 33(c) in i...
Allowed
scantmp3
Adobe Portable Document Format (.pdf) - application/pdf
7.pdf
4
571912
No
Appears In: PCB 88-016
Preferred Version: PCB 88-016 07/13/89 Dumelle / Nardulli Dissenting Opinion