View Properties

PCB 99-191 11/15/01 Johnson Dissenting Opinion
PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS v. PANHANDLE EASTERN PIPE LINE COMPANY
The Board found that respondent violated Sections 9(b), 9.1(d)(1), and 9.1(d)(2) of the Environmental Protection Act (415 ILCS 5/9(b), 9.1(d)(1), 9.1(d)(2) (2000)) and ordered the respondent to pay $850,000 in civil penalties and $115,750.25 in costs and attorney fees, and to cease and desist from further violations.
Handle: Document-15177
Owner: Site Administrator (User-2, admin:DocuShare)DS
Monday, November 26, 2001 10:36:38 AM CST
Thursday, December 13, 2001 04:26:36 PM CST
Modified By: Site Administrator (User-2, admin:DocuShare)DS
Locked By:
  • ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
November 15, 2001PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS,Complainant,v.
  • PANHANDLE EASTERN PIPE LINE
COMPANY,Respondent.
  • I feel that an appropriate civil penalty in this case
must reflect the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency’s (Agency) issuance of inspectionreports finding no violation at Panhandle’s facility from 1989 to 1996.
  • The Agency could have identified the excess
emissions problem by reviewing the reports or by calculating emissions from the provided data.
  • 415 ILCS 42(h)(2) (2000).
  • Panhandle’s diligence in attempting to
comply with the Act was clearly impacted by the Agency’s actions in this matter. Thomas E. JohnsonI, Dorothy M....
Allowed
wilsonb
Adobe Portable Document Format (.pdf) - application/pdf
99-191d111501.pdf
4
68335
No
Appears In: PCB 99-191
Preferred Version: PCB 99-191 11/15/01 Johnson Dissenting Opinion