View Properties

PCB 76-186 02/17/77 Zeitlin Concurring Opinion
ASHLAND CHEMICAL COMPANY v. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Handle: Document-34330
Owner: Site Administrator (User-2, admin:DocuShare)DS
Thursday, January 30, 2003 09:07:01 AM CST
Friday, May 2, 2003 01:04:10 PM CDT
Modified By: Site Administrator (User-2, admin:DocuShare)DS
Locked By:
  • ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
February 17, 1977ASHLAND CHEMICAL COMPANY,Petitioner,v.
  • ) PCB 76~186
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,Respondent.
  • Although the majority is correct in stating that res judicata cannot
be the basis of our finding in this case, its conclusion that thedoctrine is wholly inapplicable seems incorrect.
  • The majority’s decision on the matter of the Agency’s motives
(i.e., ‘they are not an issue’), raises serious questions.
  • 20, 1977,
pages unnumbered.) It is clear at least to me that the scheme setup under the Environmental Protection Act envisions just such abinding effect for our decisions.
Allowed
Adobe Portable Document Format (.pdf) - application/pdf
OCR0004.pdf
4
272023
No
Appears In: PCB 76-186
Preferred Version: PCB 76-186 02/17/77 Zeitlin Concurring Opinion