Page 1

ILLINOIS

POLLUTION

CONTROL

BOARD

DECEMBER

8, 2009

CLERKS

OFFICE

THE MATTER

OF:

REASONABLY

AVAILABLE

CONTROL

TECHNOLOGY

FOR

VOLATILE

ORGANIC

MATERIAL

)

STATE

LLIN(

EMISSIONS

FROM

GROUP

)

CONSUMER

AND

COMMERCIAL

)

R10-8

PRODUCTS,

PROPOSED

AMENDMENTS

ILLINOIS

ADMINISTRATIVE

CODE

211, 218,

and

219.

REPORT

PROCEEDINGS

the

hearing

the

above—entitled

cause,

taken

before

Rebecca

Graziano,

Certified

Shorthand

Reporter

within

and

for

the County

Cook

and

State

Illinois,

the

Thompson

Center,

Room

9-040,

Chicago,

Illinois,

commencing

the

hour of

9:00

a.m.

the

8th

day

of December,

A.D.,

2009.

Page

APPEARANCES

ILLINOIS POLLUTION

CONTROL BOARD

Mr. Timothy

Fox

Ms. Carrie

Zalewski

Mr.

Tanner Girard

Ms. Andrea

Moore

Mr.

Anand Rao

Mr. Gary

Blankenship

ILLINOIS ENVIRONMENTAL

PROTECTION AGENCY

Ms. Dana Vetterhoffer

Mr. David

Bloomberg

Page

MR.

FOX:

Good morning

and

welcome

this

Illinois

Pollution

Control

Board

hearing.

name

Tim

Fox, and

I am

the hearing

officer

for

this

rulemaking

proceeding,

which

entitled,

the

matter

of Reasonably

Available

Control

Technology,

RACT

-- pronounced

RACT

-- for

volatile

organic

material

emissions

from

group

to consumer

and

commercial

products,

proposed

amendments

Illinois

Administrative

Code

211,

218, and

219.

want

introduce,

also present

from

the

board

today,

the

following:

At my

immediate

right

Board

Member

Andrea

Moore,

who

the board

member

assigned

this

rulemaking.

her right

the board’s

acting

chair,

Dr. G.

Tanner

Girard.

To my

far

left

is Board

Member

Gary

Blankenship,

and

my immediate

left

Anand

Rao

of the

Board’s

technical

unit.

We are

expecting

also

see

Board

Member

Carrie

Zalewski

-—

spelled

Z—a—1—e—w—s—k—i

——

who

has

let

us know

that

the inclement

weather

has

delayed

her

a moment

or two.

Moving

on,

the board

docket

number

for this

rulemaking

is R1O—8.

The

Illinois

Environmental

Protection

Agency,

IEPA,

filed

this

E’s)

t”)

r\)

‘J

F-

F-’

I—’

-i

0’

[‘J

I-’

—J

0’

c”)

F-

H-

LII

(I)

H-

H-’

H-

LI)

H-’

H-

ç-t

H-

(I)

H-’

H-

LI)

H-

Cl)

H-’

•

çt

H-

H-’

H-

•

H-

F-h

fr3

—J

H-’

3’

H-

I—’

H-’

F-

çt

•

C-

H-

F-h

H-’

H-

I—’

Cl)

LI)

ci-

F-

H-

I—h

cC)

H-

‘-<

H-

LII

H-

‘-<

—I

‘

I-h

‘-<

F—’

H-

III

H-

cC)

H-’

I-i

LI)

H-’

H-

cC)

H-

F-

H-

LI)

H-

•

H-

cC)

H-’

H-

cC)

H-

cC)

F-

H-

I-i

H-

L’l

-LI

H-’

H-

C-i

()

—

cC)

Cl)

F-

C’

‘D

—J

Ci]

Cii

CI)

‘-<

M-

H-

h-h

LJ-

Cl)

h-h

H-

çt

H-

‘

H-

F—’

H-

‘

‘0

‘(3

H-

‘t

h-h

H-

h-h

H-

‘-<

H-

Cl)

‘

H-

F—’

I-H

h-h

H-

‘-<

H-

•

CI)

H-

h-h

•

H-

I—’

tJJ

h-h

I-

CC)

H-

‘-<

•

I—’

h-h

H-

‘

C).

H-

h-h

H-

‘-<

F-

I—I

H-

‘-<

h-h

F—’

H-

‘c5

C).

•

H-

F-’

Crni-

H-

H-’

Ci)

H-

‘-<

H-

•

C).

H-

‘

H-

F-

H-

‘ci

CI)

H-

‘C3

H-

h-h

CC)

H-

h-h

H-

‘t5

H-

I-’

F-

l—

I—’

U’

)

U’

H-

-Q

i-h

(I)

F-

CT)

F-

H-

Cl)

H-

C).

I-h

H-

çt

H-

Cl)

C).

H-

F—i

H-

Cl)

F-

H-

•

I—

F-

H-

‘

H-

•

H-

I—h

Li-

H-

F—i

H-’

I—h

‘-<

H-

C).

H-

‘-<

H-

i-h

I-i

‘-<

H-

I-h

—

H-

‘CI

I-h

H-

‘-<

H-

I-Y

h-h

H-

‘-<

-h

H-

LC)

H-

‘-<

H-

I—’

•

H-

‘-<

h-h

I-I

H-

F-

‘t3

H-

F-

H-

‘t3

H-

‘

H-

I—i

h-h

‘-<

‘i

h-h

H-

•

F-

I-

F-

F—’

I-’

—J

F—’

—1

I-H

h-h

F-

H-

F-

F—

H-

‘s

F-’

H-

F-

H-

h-h

cC)

H-

h-h

L’i

h-h

I-i

H-

F--’

H-

‘ti

h-h

cC)

H-

‘c

h-h

H-

‘

H-

C’)

F-’

‘-<

•

H-,

H-

—

H-

h-h

cC)

H-

••

h-h

F—’

H-

U’

F-H

1’l

‘-C)

F--’

H-

cC)

H-

‘-<

h-h

)

H-

h-h

‘-<

“J

h-h

‘-<

‘-C)

H-

‘

H-

L’J

H-

h-h

F-H

h-h

•

H-

Lt)

F--’

‘tJ

H-

cC)

h-h

Ci)

H-’

•

H-

cC)

—i

‘-<

—

•

‘t5

‘-<

‘ti

H-

h-h

H-

F-’

—

‘C3

H-

‘-<

H-

h-h

H-

F--’

‘t3

F-

•

h-h

cC)

H-

F-

H-

F--’

h-h

F--’

F—i-,

H-

h-h

H-

cC)

h-h

‘-C)

F--’

—

F-

I-

I—i

F-

I-

F-

—1

‘

I-

-J

H-

I-ti

H-

I-h

H-

F-

LC)

C).

‘

H-

•

H-

LC)

—J

H-i

‘

H-

ljJ

H-

c-h

tC)

Cl)

H-

c-h

H-

h-h

‘ci

H-

Cl)

H-

•

H-

•

—1

H-

•

H-

Cl)

‘t3

H-

IJi

H-

l)i

H-

•

H-

LC)

H-

•

H-

1r1

H-

H-i

H-

Cl>

L\i

t’J

F-

—

I-

—

I-

-J

U’

F-’

H’

H-

tti

‘-<

H-

I-h

L_J.

H-

‘

H-

‘-<

I—’

çt

‘C3

H-

F-

()

‘.

‘

H-

1Ji

•

H-

‘-<

H-

I-H

H-

I-I

H-

‘-<

-H

H-

F-h

‘C

H-

F-h

H-

I—’

H-

F-h

‘)

F-h

H-

Cl)

H-

•

H-

C).

H-’

H-

•

‘-<

cC)

H-

cC)

H-

“j

‘

F-h

H-

‘-<

F-h

H-

‘-<

H-

C)..

F-h

cC)

CIJ

C).

H-

cC)

‘-<

•

H-

‘<

H-

(51

‘3

cC)

F-h

•

H-

0..

•

H-

C)..

F-h

H-

C)..

I—’

‘-<

H-

H’

‘-<

cC)

‘-<

cC)

0..

F-

F-’

—J

—1

u-i

F-’

H-

‘TJ

F-

H-

‘-<

Cl)

F-

I-h

F-

H-

çt

Ct)

F—

çt

H-

F-

‘c

H-

F-

()

F—

F-I

‘d

H-

Ct)

[—

H-

F-

‘j

I-I

H-

J•

h-h

H-

I-I

F-

H-

—

1:-I

‘-<

I-h

F-

‘ci

h-h

•

H-

F-

F-’

h-h

-i

H-

h-h

H-’

I-h

F—’

H-

H-’

H-

F-

•

H-

cC)

H-

cC)

h-h

H-

cC)

H-

h-h

H-

F-’

-‘

H-

cC)

I-h

F—

“

cC)

F-

H-

F-H

H-

H-’

H-

cC)

‘-<

F-

H-

F-’

H-

cC)

H-

‘-<

H-’

H-

cC)

‘l

cC)

H’

Page

this

very

brief

hearing,

and

for

your help and

for

your testimony

including

the

first hearing.

Thank

you

again, and

can

adjourn.

Page

STATE

ILLINOIS

COUNTY

OF COOK

REBECCA

GRAZIANO,

being

first

duly

sworn

oath

says

that she

court

reporter

doing

business

in the

City

of Chicago;

that

she

reported

shorthand

the

proceedings

given

at the

taking

said

hearing

and

that the

foregoing

true

and

correct

transcript

of her

shorthand

notes

taken as

aforesaid

and

contains

all

the

proceedings

given

said

hearing.

REBECCA

GA’IO,

CSR

29 South

LaSalle

Street,

Suite

850

Chicago,

Illinois

60603

License

No.

084—004659

SUBSCRIBED

AND

SWpRN

befoe

this

(—‘

day

KMBERLYA.MEEKS

A. D.,

2009.

MISSION

EXPS

(

Nota

Publiô-

Page 13

Anand2:5

8:20,23

9:4 commercial

DCEO

8:7,15 event 6:16

about5:96:l

3:17

9:5,17,18

1:43:8

8:17,20

everyone’s

6:24 10:2

Andrea 2:5

9:23 10:5

complete

deadline

9:10

7:17

10:11

3:12

10:18

6:18

December

expect9:6

above-entit...

anyone 5:17

board’s 3:14

compliance

1:1,14 4:9

10:18

1:9

5:24

6:9

3:17 4:11

7:9

4:23 8:1

9:5 expected

absence 5:17

7:18,21

5:21 6:13

conclusion

9:7,8,15,17

9:16

6:5

8:18

9:22

6:19 9:20

6:3,20

decision6:19 expecting

accepted 4:2

10:11

9:24 10:14

conduct 8:7

delayed 3:20

3:18

Act8:4

appear7:18

brief 11:1

8:15

6:9

explanation

acting 3:14

appropriate

Bureau 7:9

conducting

department

8:10

8:14

7:1,4

business 12:7

8:11

8:5,6

action 9:3

arrived 8:24

consequently

Departmen...

addition9:21

aspects 10:12

5:23

8:10

far3:15

additional

assigned 3:13

C 2:1

consumer 1:4

develop 6:18

feel

7:4

5:22,24

assure6:9

care7:11

3:7

directed4:19

file9:22

10:19

assures5:22

Carrie2:4

contactl0:8

4:22

10:3

filed3:244:4

address 4:13

August 4:2

3:18 8:23

10:14

discussion

4:9

8:1 9:18

9:1 10:21

8:13

cause 1:9

contains

7:14

9:24

addressing

available 1:3

Center 1:12

12:11

docket 3:22

filing

9:2

7:23

3:5 7:20

certainly

Controll:1,3

5:1

10:2,8

adjacent5:6

8:11 9:17

10:23

2:23:2,5

doing8:22

filings

10:4

adjourn9:2

9:19

Certified

Cook Lii

12:7

fmallylO:4

10:22 11:3

A.D1:14

1:10

12:2

done5:7

first4:16

Administr...

12:20

chair3:14

COOL

10:1

door5:5

5:23 7:16

1:53:9

a.ml:13

chairman

10:2

Dr3:158:14

11:212:5

admitted

8:14

copies

9:16

8:24

following

6:15

Chicago

1:12

correct 12:10

due 9:15

3:11 9:11

adopts 8:8

based 4:22

12:7,16

County 1:11

duly 12:6

foregoing

aforesaid

before 1:9

Christmas

4:17 12:2

12:9

12:11

6:228:8,12

9:9

course6:4

Fox2:33:1,3

after5:226:2

9:1,310:7

Cityl2:7

9:9

E2:1,1

7:11,16

again 9:16

10:22 12:19

clarifies 9:13

court 5:6

economic 8:3 free

7:5

10:7 11:3

begin5:15

clear6:18

12:6

8:6,7,9,15

Friday9:6,8

Agency2:7

beingl2:5

clearly5:10

CSR12:15

Edwardsvi...

9:17

3:24 5:14

blank 7:22

7:22

customarily

4:17

from 1:4

3:7

6:1 7:3

Blankenship clerk

9:23

5:19

9:8

either

8:9

3:11 8:17

10:24

2:6 3:16

10:8

C-O-O-L

electronic

8:20

Agency’s 4:2

Bloomberg

clerk’s 9:24

10:1

10:2,5

2:97:8

10:3,8

electronica...

7:23 9:3

ahead7:5

Blumberg

Codel:63:9

9:24

G24315

7:8

commencing Dana

2:8 7:6

emissions 1:4

Gary 2:6

Air7:9

boardl:12:2

1:13

date4:14

3:7

316

allow 6:9

always 10:13

3:2,11,12

conunent6:4

8:16

9:15

ending9:5

Girard2:4

amend4:5,10

3:13,15,18

8:199:5,7

dated4:i,6

ensurel0:9

3158:15

7:24

3:22 4:2,5

comments

4:18 8:13

entities 10:7

8:24

amended6:i

4:10,12

9:2,14,22

David2:97:8 entitled3:4

givenl2:8,12

7:23

9:3

5:13,13

9:23

dayl:139:9

Environme...

go6:7,237:5

amendments

6:16,178:5 Commerce

12:19

2:7 3:24 8:4

7:12

1:53:8

8:8,9,14,16

8:6

days8:12

EPA7:7,10

going7:17

Good 3:1

Page

governed

5:17

persons 10:6

questions

6:13

indication

Madison

oath 12:6

physically

4:22

5:3,8

granted 4:5

10:23

4:17

October4:6

718

5:20,226:1

Graziano

information

make8:9

4:17,18

place4:16

6:3,7,11,17

1:10 12:5

6:14

10:14

12:15

inside 5:5

manager 7:9

off 6:7,23

please 4:3,8

7:19 10:1

materiall:3

7:12,15,17

7:410:8

10:11,23

group 1:4 3:7 intended

3:7

8:3

point 5:17

quickly

9:19

6:18

matter 1:2

offer 5:12 6:4

Pollution 1:1

intention6:5

3:5

6:107:19

2:23:2

hands 10:22

interest 8:22

having6:8

interested

matters 7:12

7:21 8:19

pose

7:19

R21

10:20

office 10:1,3

post-hearing

RACT

3:6,6

7:11

7:22

hearing 1:8

introduce

may 6:4 9:22

10:9

9:2,4

Rao 2:5

3:17

3:2,34:3,16

3:10

9:2310:12

officer3:3

present3:10

5:21

member3:12

4:199:12

5:12,247:3

reachl0:13

4:19,20 5:3

introductory

3:13,16,18

10:6,13

pre-file 4:20

Reasonably

5:23 8:12

8:21 9:12

8:23

once9:18

4:225:16

1:23:5

issue 8:2 9:2

10:6,13

9:12

members

one5:127:22

pre-filed

Rebeccal:9

11:1,212:9

5:136:16

8:11

4:235:2,7

12:5,15

12:12

might7:18

onto 8:2

5:15,206:6

receive9:6

hearings

2:3

7:21

open 9:4

privileged

received 8:17

10:17,19

judgment

minutes7:13 opens4:12

6:15

recentl0:9

help

6:18

6:20

moment 3:20 Opportunity

probably 7:1

record 5:1

11:1

July4:1

6:7

8:7

procedural

67,12,16

her

3:14,20

just 5:5 6:12

Monday 9:5

oral 6:6

4:11 6:13

6:19,23 7:2

12:10

7:1

9:11,15

order4:1,6

10:12

7:13,15,17

hold9:4

Moore2:5

4:18,21

proceeding

8:22

9:13

holding4:15

3:12

9:13

3:4 6:13

9:21

10:16

holiday 9:9

kind 10:20

moot 5:17

organic 1:3

proceedings

10:22

hour 1:13

knOW 3:19

morning 3:1

3:7

1:8 6:24

reflect

5:11

known8:6

5:136:5

other5:13

12:8,12

6:208:23

most 10:9

6:6 10:16

products 1:5

regarding

identify 7:2

motion

4:4,5

otherwise

3:8

6:20 8:19

IEPA 3:24

LaSalle

4:10,12,13

8:19

pronounced

relevant 6:14

4:4,8

12:16

7:24

3:6

remains 7:21

Iffinois 1:1,5

later 4:14,21

move 8:2

proposal 4:1

repetitious

1:11,122:2

4:23

Moving3:22

P2:1,1

4:3,5,11 6:1

6:15

2:73:2,9,23

least8:11

must89105

paperlo:5

6:217:24

REPORT1:8

4:18 7:7,10

left3:15,16

part5:20

8:16 9:4

reported

12:1,16

7:20

6:10

proposed 1:5

12:8

immediate

let 3:19

2:1

participant

3:8 8:8

reporter

1:10

3:12,16

letter 8:13

name

3:3

5:2,3

Protection

5:6 12:6

impact

8:3,7

let’s

7:12

Neither 8:21

participants

2:7 3:24 8:4

representat...

8:10,16

License

next8:24

4:19,226:4

provide5:4

5:147:3

inclement

12:17

Notary 12:21

9:14 10:21

public

6:4

request

8:5

3:206:8

like5:68:18

note4:3,8

patience7:17

8:119:22

8:18,19

including

10:21,24

notes 12:10

pens 5:5

12:21

requested

11:2

linel0:1

nothing8:17

period4:12

push9:10

815

indicated

list 10:7,10

November

9:7

required

8:5

6:22

listed 10:14

4:21

permit 6:2

responding

indicating

number 3:22 person 5:11

question 6:24

8:17

Page

response

solely6:18

Tim3:3

8:1

8thl:13

4:12

some7:12

time6:2,23

850

12:16

resume7:13

South 12:16

7:4

right 3:12,14 spelled 3:19

Tianothy2:3

Zalewski2:4

rooml:12

SS12:1

today3:11

3:188:23

9th4:1

5:5

staff 5:14,21

4:15

5:4

Z-a-l-e-w-s...

9-040 1:12

rulemaking

6:17

transcript

3:19

9:00 1:13

3:4,13,23

state 1:11 9:9

9:6,16,19

4:10,16

12:1

12:10

9:23 10:12

Street 12:16

travel

10:24

084-004659

10:17

study8:3,8

truel2:10

12:17

rules4:11

8:10,16

turn5:19

6:148:8,9

subject5:8

two3:216:8

run 9:8

SUBSCRI...

llth9:7,17

R10-81:4

12:19

14th4:4

3:23

substance

ultimate 6:19

14-day 4:12

4:13 7:23

Under4:11

9:7,10

Suitel2:16

unit3:177:9

157:13

S2:1,5 3:12

sworn5:8

unopposed

15th4:6

same4:21

12:6,19

4:6

17th4:21

saysl2:6

until9:8,10

19988:3

schedule

10:18

take6:10

scheduled

taken 1:9

version 10:10

208:12

10:17

7:11 12:11

very9:13,19

2009 1:1,14

seated8:24

takes9:3

11:1

4:1,2,4,7,9

second4:10

taking

12:9

Vetterhoffer

4:17,18,21

4:15,20

Tanner2:4

2:87:1,6,7

4:24 8:14

Section8:4

3:15

volatile

1:3

9:18 12:20

see3:185:10 technical

3:6

2111:63:9

seeing8:21

3:175:21

2181:63:9

10:22

Technology

2191:63:9

September

1:3

3:6

want 3:10 8:2

25th

9:8

4:4

testify8:18

8:22

9:1

27th4:17

served 10:6

testimony

weather

3:20

27-B 8:4

servicel0:7

4:20,235:2

6:8

28th4:189:5

10:10

5:4,7,9,12

website920

9:11,15

sheet5:5

5:15,156:3

10:15

2912:16

7:20

6:6,6,11

welcome3:1

sheets 5:11

7:19,21

while 9:7

short6:23

11:2

wish5:4,18

3rd4:23

shorthand

thank 7:16

6:10 7:19

351:5 3:9

1:10 12:8

10:24 11:2

7:21

12:10

their 5:9 7:24

wishes

5:11

6th4:2 8:13

shortly9:13

10:24

5:24

60603 12:16

shows 5:1

Thompson

wishing 4:19

sign-up

5:4

1:12

witnesses

5:6

5:10 7:20

through

8:14

written 9:22

7th4:9

8:1

simply

6:7

9:24 10:2

Since8:3

10:13

yesterday4:9

81:1