EXHIBIT LIST
IN THE MATTER OF:
)
)
WATER QUALITY STANDARDS AND
)
R08-9
EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS FOR THE
)
(Rulemaking - Water)
CHICAGO AREA WATERWAY SYSTEM
)
AND LOWER
DES PLAINES RIVER
)
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
TO 35
ILL.
)
ADM. CODE 301, 302, 303, and 304
)
Exhibit 1
Prefiled testimony of Rob Suiski
Exhibit 2
Prefiled testimony of Scott Twait
Exhibit 3
Prefiled testimony of Roy Smogor
Exhibit
4
United
States
Environmental
Protection Agency letter from Linda
Holst to Toby
Frevert
of the Illinois Environmental
Protection
Agency, dated May
3,
2007
Exhibit 5
Appendix Table 1 .QHEI metric scores for stations sampled in
the Illinois and
DesPlaines
Rivers
during 2006
Exhibit
6
Table 2. QHEI scores and metric values
for sites sampled in the Des Plaines
&
Illinois Rivers by MBI in 2006
Exhibit 7
MBI Qualitative Habitat Evaluation
Index Field Sheet QHEI Score (contains
23
pages)
Exhibit 8
“Quality Assurance Project Plan: Fish Assemblage Assessment
of the Lower Des
Plaines River” Effective Date July
1, 2006, Center of Applied Bioassessment
&
Biocriteria P.O. Box
21561
Columbus, OH 43221-0561
Exhibit 9
Publication:
HERALD-NEWS,
Publication date: 8/19/2002 “Fishermen
died
by
drowning”
Exhibit
10
Three Rivers Manufacturers’ Association
letter to Toby Frevert dated
June 6,
2003
Exhibit 11
United States
Environmental
Protection Agency
MEMORANDUM
on
“Improving
the
Effectiveness
of the Use Attainability Analysis
(UAA)
Process”
from Ephraim
S.
King to Regional
Water
Division Directors. Dated March
13,
2006
Exhibit
12
“Review
of ‘Technical
Memorandum
1WQ-Disingection
Evaluation
Prepared
on
Behalf of
the
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of
Greater
Chicago”
Prepared
for United
States
Environmental
Protection
Agency
by Science
Applications
International
Corporation
Exhibit 13
Prefiled
testimony
of Chris
0.
Yoder
Exhibit
14
Curriculum
Vitae
of Chris Yoder
Exhibit
15
“Temperature
Criteria
Options
for the Lower
Des
Plaines
River”
Final Report
to
United
States
Environmental
Protection
Agency
and Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency
by
Chris
Yoder
and Edward
Rankin
Exhibit
16
“Re-evaluation
of
the Technical
Justification
for Existing
Ohio
River Mainstem
Temperature
Criteria”
Chris
Yoder,
Brian
Armitage
and
Edward
Rankin
Exhibit
17
“Thermal
Discharge
form a Nuclear
Power
Plant: Predicted
Effects
on Lake
Erie
Fish”
Jeffrey
Reutter
and Charles
Herdendorf
Exhibit
18
Pages
2-98 through
2-102
from
the
Lower
Des Plaines
Use
Attainability
Analysis
(Attachment
A to proposal)
Exhibit
19
Table
1. Number,
CPE (no.1km)
and
Relative
Abundance
of
all Fish Taxa
Collected
Electrofishing
from
the Lower
Dresdan
Pool
Exhibit
20
MBI
Fish
Data
Sheet (contains
35 pages)
Exhibit
21
Table
1
Boat
181
scores and
metrics
at boat sites
in the Des
Plaines River
sampled
by
MBI
during 2006
Exhibit 22
R08-9
Illinois
Pollution
Control
Board
hearing
Question
for
the Illinois
EPA
(2-1-
08)
Exhibit
23
“Illinois
Waterway
Navigation
Charts” Map
Nos.
94-114.
Exhibit
24
“White
Sucker (Catostomus
commersoni)
Embryo
Development,
and Early
Growth
and
Survival
at Divergent
Temperatures”
by
J.
Howard
McCormick,
Bernard
R. Jones and
Kenneth
E.F. Hokanson
Exhibit
25
Map
entitled
“Chicago
Area
Waterway
System
and
Des Plaines
River
UAA
Segments”
Exhibit
26
Map
entitled
“Proposed
Aquatic
Life
Use Designation”
Exhibit
27
Map entitled
“Proposed
Recreational
Use Designation”
Exhibit
28
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
table entitled
“Total
Number
of Fish
Collected
from
Each
Sampling
Station
in
the
Chicago
Area
Waterway
System
form 2001
through
2005 as
part
of
the
ambient Water
Quality
Monitoring
Program”
Exhibit
29
UAA Factor
Application
to the
Lower Des
Plaines
River and
CAWS
Exhibit
30
U.S.
Army Corps
of Engineers
Maps
of Illinois
Waterway,
Map Nos.
109,110,
111
Exhibit
31
Illinois
Department
of
Natural Resources
Lake
Michigan
Tributaries
Fish
Population
Survey,
July
27-31,
2006
Exhibit
32
Qualitative
Habitat
Evaluation
Index
Scores
in the Upper
Dresden
Island Pool
of
Des
Plaines
River
Exhibit
33
Edits
to the
Lower Des
Plaines UAA
(Attachment
A to
the JEPA’s
Statement
of
Reasons)
Exhibit
34
Information
on Impaired
Segments
of the
Lower Des
Plaines River
and the
CAWS
Exhibit
35
“Evaluation
and Development
of Large
River Biological
Assessment
Methods
and
Standardized
Protocols
for Region
V” by Rob
Tewes, Erich
Emery,
and
Jeff
Thomas
Exhibit
36
Meeting
Minutes
from the
Lower
Des
Plaines
River Workgroup
and
the
CAWS
Stakeholders
Group
Exhibit
37
Compact
disc
titled “Yoder
CD”
Exhibit
38
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District of
Greater Chicago,
Research
and
Development
Department
Report
No.
03-20
“Comparison
of Fecal Coliform
concentrations
and Trends
in Two
Urban Rivers:
The
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal
and The
Des Plaines
River” October
2003
Exhibit 39
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of
Greater
Chicago,
Research
and
Development
Department
Report
No. 04-10
“Estimation
of the Escherichia
Coli
to
Fecal
Coliform
Ration
in Wastewater
Effluents
and
Ambient
Water of the
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago”
July 2004
Exhibit
40
Chart
titled
“Illinois
Department
of Natural
Resources
DuPage
River
Basin
Survey
Stations
Exhibit
41
Chart
titled
“Illinois
Department
of Natural
Resources
Fish Community
Sampling
Results and
Index of
Biotic Integrity
(fBI),
2003
Des Plaines
Basin
Survey
-
mainstream
stations”
Exhibit
42
Chart
titled “Illinois
Department
of
Natural
Resources
Fish
Community
Sampling
Results
and
Index of Biotic
Integrity
(fBI), 2003
Des
Plaines
Basin
Survey -
tributary
stations (includes
data
from
2002
surveys)”
Exhibit
43
Chart titled
“Illinois
Department
of
Natural
Resources
- Fisheries
Division
Kankakee
River
Fish
Population
Survey
Results
- July,
2005”
Exhibit
44
“The Des
Plaines
River:
Monitoring
the
Fish Resources
of an
Urban River
(1978-
1990)
by
David
M. Day August
12, 1991
Exhibit
45
Table
with
headers
“Name”,
“10-Digit
HIJC”, “IEPA
Basin”, “Assessment
Unit
ID”,
“Size (miles)”,
“Cat.”,
“Designated
Uses/Attainment”,
“Causes”,
“Sources”
Exhibit
46
Compact
Disc
titled
“MWRDGC
continuous
DO and
temp
data for
selected
CAW
stations”
Exhibit
47
Group
of
letters from
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
starting with
letter
to
Michael Garretson,
dated
August
18, 2006
on
reported fish
kills
Exhibit
48
Group
of tables
beginning
with
table titled
“Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
Ambient
Water Quality
Monitoring
Program
Sample
Stations”
Exhibit
49
Letter
to Toby Frevert
of IEPA
from Linda
Hoist
USEPA
dated
May
3,
2007
Exhibit
50
Draft
comments
from
Midwest
Generation
dated
02/12/07
at
bottom
Exhibit 51
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
Comments
on
]EPA
Chicago
Area Waterways
Use
Attainability
Analysis
Draft
Standards
dated March
16, 2007
Exhibit 52
IEPA
document
titled “Chicago
Waterway/Lower
Des
Plaines
River UAA
Major
issues
related
to comments
from
March
20, 2007 meeting
in Joliet
Exhibit
53
Environmental
Law
& Policy
Center
comments
to Toby
Frevert
on Use
Attainability
Analyses
for the
lower Des
Plaines
and the
Chicago
Waterway
System,
dated
April 6, 2007
Exhibit
54
email
from Phillip
Moy
to
Toby Frevert
dated
3/23/2007
Exhibit
55
Alliance for the
Great Lakes
“Protecting
Public Health, Caring
for Chicago’s
Waters”
Exhibit
56
Group
of documents with
email
cover
sheet from
Deana
Poe to CAWS
UAA;
UAA - Des Plaines
dated January
26, 2007.
Exhibit
57
“Reconnaissance
Report Great Lakes
Navigation
System Review
Appendix D
Chicago
Sanitary & Ship Canal”
Army
Corp
of Engineers, June
2002
Exhibit 58
Settlement
Agreement between
Natural Resources
Defense
Council and USEPA,
and
the National Association
of
Clean
Water Agencies
Exhibit 59
Letter
from Louis Kollias,
Director
Research
and Development,
MWRDGC,
to
Marcia
Wilihite, Bureau
Chief, JEPA, dated
September
5, 2008
Exhibit
60
Prefiled
Testimony of Richard
Lanyon
Exhibit
61
Attachment
1 Openlands
Questions, color
photos
Exhibit
62
Prefiled
Testimony
of William
J.
Stuba
Exhibit
63
Table entitled “Annual
Summaries
of Recreational Activities
Observations”
Exhibit
64
Trip Log dated
7-16-08, Patrol CAL
DO
NPDES
Exhibit
65
Prefiled Testimony
of Samuel
G.
Dennison on
Recreational
Designations
Exhibit 66
Color
Photo of Barge on
Calumet-Sag
Channel
looking west
from 104th Street
Bridge
Exhibit 67
email from
Fredric Andes to
Marie Tipsord
and
Susan
Hedman
listing links
to
MWRDGC’s
2007
and
2008
budget
books
Exhibit 68
Prefiled Testimony
of
Chriso
Petropoulou
Exhibit 69
Prefiled Testimony
of Charles
P. Gerba
Exhibit70
Prefiled
Testimony
of Keith
Tolson
Exhibit 71
Report
prepared
for
MWRDGC
by Geosyntec
entitled
“Dry
and Wet Weather
Risk Assessment of
Human
Health
Impacts
of
Disinfection vs. No
Disinfection
of
the Chicago Area
Waterways
System” April 2008
Exhibit
72
“Dry Weather Risk
Assessment
of Human Health
Impacts of Disinfection
vs.
No
Disinfection
of the Chicago Area
Waterways
System” Review conducted
fro
US
EPA Region 5,
Office of Water
Exhibit 73
Compact
Disc titled
USEPA Correspondence
Exhibit
73a
Compact Disc
that is attachments
to USEPA
Correspondence
Exhibit
74
“Health Effects
of white-water
canoeing”
by L. Fewtrell et
al, from
The
Lancet
dated June
27, 1992
(cover page)
Exhibit 75
Table
1 entitled
“Illnesses
acquired
by ingestion of water”
Exhibit
76
Report
prepared for
MWRDGC
by Geosyntec
entitled “Interim Phase
I Dry
Weather
Risk Assessment
Human
Health
Impacts
of Disinfection vs.
No
Disinfection
of the
Chicago
Area
Waterways
System” November 2006
Exhibit 77
Compact
Disc
entitled
“Appendices”
“Dry and Wet Weather
Risk
Assessment
of
Human
Health Impacts
of Disinfection
vs.
No
Disinfection
of the Chicago
Area
Waterways
System”
April
2008
Exhibit 78
Cover
page and
one
page excerpt from “Environmental
Microbiology”
by Maier,
Pepper,
and Gerba
Exhibit
79
“The
Health Effects
of Low-Contact
Water Activities
in Fresh and Estuarine
Waters” by Fewtrell
et al. February
1994
Exhibit
80
“Bathroom
research reveals surprising
data” by
Amanda Riddle June
11,
1997
Exhibit
81
MSNBC.com
Interview
“Is your workplace a
bacteria
cafeteria”
Feb. 16, 2005
Exhibit
82
Openlands
Attachment
1 to Prefiled Question
of Keith Tolson,
color photo
Exhibit
83
“Lease Amendment
Agreement
Ronan
Park Expansion”
September
19,
1990
Exhibit 84
Table entitled
“Summary of Recreational
Season
(Chlorinate/Dechlorinated)
Effluent Fecal Coliform
May
1 through October 31”
Exhibit 85
Compact Disc entitled
“Raw Data”
Exhibit 86
USEPA Document
entitled
“Ambient
Water
Quality
Criteria for
Bacteria - 1986”
EPA44O/5-84-002
(January 1986).
Exhibit
87
Color Photo
of two-person
Jet Ski
Exhibit
88
September
12, 2008
letter
from Chriso Petropoulou
of Geosyntec
to Thomas
Granto of
Metropolitan Water
Reclamation
District of Greater
Chicago
Exhibit 89
September 22, 2008 letter from
Chriso Petropoulou
of Geosyntec to Thomas
Granto of Metropolitan Water
Reclamation District
of Greater Chicago
Exhibit
90
September 22, 2008 letter from Louis
Kollias of Metropolitan
Water Reclamation
District
of Greater Chicago to Marcia
Wilhite of the Illinois
Environmental
Protection Agency
Exhibit
91
Twelve tables
beginning with “Jan. 2005
Daily Precipitation
Counts
(inches)”
one
table for each
month
Exhibit
92
Eight tables beginning with “Jan. 2006
Daily Precipitation
Counts (inches)” one
table for each month through
October
Exhibit
93
Prefiled testimony of Earnest
R. Blatchley III,
with attachments included
on
compact disc
Exhibit 94
California Health Laws Related
to Recycled Water “The Purple Book”
Excerpts
from the Health and Safety
Coed, Water Code
and Titles 22 and 17 of the
California Code of Regulations
June 2001 Edition
Exhibit
95
Color Chart entitled “Facility
D - -St. Petersburg 2°
without Nitrification;
Filtration”
Exhibit 96
Article entitled “Wedeco Wins
Order In Munich”
Exhibit 97
Article entitled “Rinsend
(SBR) Wastewater
Treatment Plant Overview”
Exhibit 98
Article entitled “Effects of Disinfectants
on Wastewater Effluent
Toxicity”
by
Earnest R. Blatchley III et al.
Pergamon 1997
Exhibit
99
Article entitled “Effect of
Wastewater Disinfection
on Human Health”
by Earnest
R.
Blatchley
III
Exhibit 100
Prefiled testimony
of Samuel Dorevitch
with compact disc of attachments
Exhibit 101
“Health Effects
of white-water canoeing”
by L. Fewtrell et al,
from
The Lancet
dated June 27, 1992 (complete
copy)
Exhibit
102
Article entitled
“Bacteriophages
are
a
Better Indicator of Illness
Rates than
Bacteria Amongst Users
of a White
Water Course Fed by a Lowland
River”
by
J.V. Lee et al. Pergamon 1997
Exhibit 103
Article entitled
“A Probabilistic Risk
Assessment of Cryptosporidium
Exposure
Among Baltimore Urban Anglers”
by Jennifer
D. Roberts et al. Journal
of
Toxicology
and Environmental Health,
Part A (January 1, 2007)
Exhibit
104
Article
entitled
“Health
Hazards
Associated
with
Windsurfing
on
Polluted
Waters”
by
Eric
Dewailly
eta!.
Public
Health
Briefs
June
1986
Exhibit
105
Article
entitled
“Results
of
the
First Pilot-Scale
Controlled
Cohort
Epidemiological
Investigation
into the Possible
Health
Effects
o Bathing
in
Seawater
at Langland
Bay,
Swansea”
by F. Jones
eta!.
(February
5, 1991)
Exhibit
106
Two
color
charts
on
one
page
entitled
“CAWS
activity
distribution,
2007
n=350”
and “GUW
activity
distribution,
2007
n=142”
Exhibit
107
Two
pages
with
three
Figures,
Figure
1 entitled
“Aged
distribution
of
unexposed
participants,
2007”,
Figure
2
entitled
“Aged
distribution
of
CAWS
participants,
2007”
and
Figure
3 entitled
“Aged distribution
of
GUW
participants,
2007”
Exhibit
108
Flow
Chart
entitled
“CHEERS
participant
Flow”
Exhibit
109
Chart entitle
“Example
of
‘dose-response’
graph”
Exhibit
110
Color photo
chart
entitled
“Sources
of Risk, by
Group”
Exhibit
111
Color
Charts
entitled
“QMRA”
Exhibit
112
Prefiled
testimony
of
Susan O’Connell
Exhibit
113
Prefiled
testimony
of
Greeta Rij
al
with compact
disc
of
attachments
Exhibit
114
Charts
entitled
“Figure
18: Geometric
means
of Fecal
Coliform
Bacteria at
North
Area
Stations
Each
Day
After
Heavy
and Light
Rainfalls
for Three-Day
Periods
Compared
with Dry
Weather Densities”
Exhibit
115
Two
charts
on one page
entitled
“Figure
1:
Estimated
FC
densities
downs
stream
of
the North
Side and
Calumet
WRPs
during
dry
weather
(0) and wet
weather
([X]with]
or [without
disinfection
conditions”
Exhibit
116
Prefiled
testimony
of
Adrienne
D.
Nemura
Exhibit
117
“Citations
for
Statues
and
Regulations
Referred
to in
Pre-Filed
Testimony
of
Adrienne
D.
Nemura”
Exhibit
118
A
link to a web
site
on the UAA
for
Chesapeake
Exhibit
119
Four
page document
beginning
with
“Please
refer
to
Report No.
05-15
for
Figure
and
Table
Numbers”
Exhibit
120
Indiana
Department
of Environmental
Management
Letter
from
Bruno L.
Pigot to
Tinka
Hyde
USEPA
Region V
dated
March
17, 2008
Exhibit 121
USEPA Letter from
Bharat Mathur
to Bruno L. Pigot Indiana Department
of
Environmental Management
dated June
9, 2008
Exhibit 122
Regulatory language headed
at top of page “314
CMR
$:00
Division of
Water
Pollution Control”
Exhibit 123
Ohio River Valley Water Sanitation
Commission “Wet
Weather Standards
Proposal”
Exhibit
124
Document entitled “Background
Summary
of
Proposed
Revisions”
Exhibit
125
State of California,
State Water Resources Control Board
ORDER
WQO
2005-
0004
In the
matter
ofown motion review
offailure to modj5’ recreation
use
standards for Ballona Creek
Exhibit 126
Compact Disc titled
“Blatchley Report”
Exhibit 127
USEPA Memorandum
dated Jan. 24, 1992 on “Request
for Views on Allowable
Duration of Water Quality
Standards
Variances”
Exhibit
128
Water
Quality Standards Academy Key
Concepts “A Variance: Temporary
Modification
to
Water Quality Standards”
Exhibit 129
Rules of Department of Natural
Resources Division 20 - Clean
Water
Commission Chapter
7 - Water
Quality
Exhibit 130
Department of Natural Resources
Code of State Regulations
beginning with
“Table
A”
Exhibit 131
“Water
Quality Standards: Wet
Weather Issues and Recreational
Use Protection”
by Ephraim King of USEPA
Exhibit 132
Indiana Department of Environmental
Management “Agency
nonrule policy
document” Effective
April 11, 2008
Exhibit 133
Prefiled
testimony and attachments
of Stephen F. McGowan
Exhibit
134
Document entitled “Exhibit
1”
Exhibit 135
Document from website, first line
“eGRID FAQ Clean Energy
US EPA”
Exhibit 136
20 ILCS 3855/1-75
Exhibit 137
220 ILCS 5/16-127
Exhibit
138
Document
entitled “Exhibit
2”
Exhibit
139
Compact
Disc
entitled
“MWRD
Precipitation
Data”
Exhibit
140
Byappanahalli
and
Whitman
USGS, Great
Lakes
Science
Center,
Lake
Michigan
Ecological
Research
Station
“Escherichia
coli
Sources
and
Microbiological
Quality
of Water
Above
and
Below
the Northside
Wastewater
Reclamation
Plant
(NSWRP),
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
(MWRDGC)”
Project
Period
July
15, 2008-July
14,
2009
Exhibit
141
Two
tables,
first
entitled
“Mean
Escherichia
Coli Concentrations (MPN/1
OOML)
in the Water
from
the
North
Shore
Channel
Segment
Above and
Below the
North
Side
WRP”
Exhibit
142
Three
tables,
first
entitled “Coliform
Bacteria
Levels
(MPN/lOOmL)
in the
Storm
Sewer
Samples
Collected
During
Rain
Storm
Event on
09/04/08”
Exhibit
143
“Electricity
Sources
and
Emissions”
Integrys
energy
service
Exhibit
144
Prefiled
testimony
of
Charles
Haas
Exhibit
145
OEM online
“Distribution
and
determinants
of trihalomethane
concentrations
in
indoor
swimming
pools H. Chu
and
M J
Niuwenhuijsen
Exhibit
146
Prefiled
testimony
of
David
R.
Zenz
Exhibit
147
Letter
to
Toby
Frevert of
Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency
dated
June
22,
2006
from
Richard
Lanyon
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of
Greater
Chicago
Exhibit
148
“Review
of
“Technical
Memorandum
1WQ
- Disinfection
Evaluation
Prepared
on
Behalf
of the Metropolitan
Water Reclamation
District
of
Greater
Chicago”
Final
Report
October 2006
Prepared
by
Science
Applications
International
Corporation”
Exhibit 149
“UV
Disinfection
Cost Study
Cost
Study
Report
for
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
Volume 1
of 2
North
Side Water
Reclamation
Plant”
January31,
2008” Prepared
by CTE
AECOM
Exhibit
150
TJV
Disinfection
Cost Study
Cost Study
Report for
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
Volume
1 of 2
Stickney
Water
Reclamation
Plant”
September
9,
2008”
Prepared
by CTE
AECOM
Exhibit
151
One
page
document
entitled
“Prefiled
Questions
of the
People
of the State
of
Illinois
to
David
R. Zenz”
question
number
2
Exhibit
152
Table
entitled
“UV Disinfection
- Capital
Cost Estimates”
Exhibit
153
Prefiled
Testimony
of
Thomas
E. Kunetz
Exhibit
154
Compact
Disc
entitled
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
North
Side Master
Plan September
9,
2008”
Exhibit
155
MWRDGC
-
Stickney
WRP
Infrastructure
& Process
Needs Feasibility
Study
“Executive
Summary”
Exhibit
156
Selected
pages
from
2007 Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
2007
Budget
Exhibit
157
Selected pages
from
2008 Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
Budget
Exhibit
158
“Selected
Plan
Technical
Memorandum
12
Master
Plan
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago North
Side
Water Reclamation
Plant and
Surrounding
Chicago
Area
Waterways”
June
2007
submitted
by CTE AECOM
Exhibit
159
Prefiled
testimony
of John Mastracchio
Exhibit
160
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of Greater
Chicago
2007 Budget
book
in
its
entirety
Exhibit
161
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District of
Greater Chicago
2008
Budget
Book
in its
entirety
Exhibit
162
“Water and
Wastewater
Pricing
An information
overview”
U.S.
Environmental
Protection
Agency
Office of
Wastewater
Management
EPA 832-F-03-027
Exhibit
163
Response
to
Question
#1 from
Environmental
Law
and Policy
Center and
the
Sierra
Club
Exhibit
164
“POTW Nutrient
Removal
in Illinois”
Illinois
Association
of Wastewater
Agencies
2003
Study
Summary
Exhibit
165
“Analysis
of
Nutrient
Removal
Costs in
the Chesapeake
Bay
Program and
Implications
for the
Mississippi-Atchafalaya
River
Basin” Submitted
to
Water
Environment
Federation
for 2008
WEFTEC
Conference
Chicago, Ii
Exhibit
166
“Public
Commentary”
Submitted
to
the Science
Advisory
Board Hypoxia
Advisory
Panel
Draft Advisory
Report
Submitted
by O’Brien
& Gere
Exhibit
167
Compact
Disc entitled
“Mississippi
River, Whole
Body
contact Recreation
Use
Attainability
Analysis,
July
2005”
Exhibit
168
“Use Attainability
Analysis Mobile
River Final” Alabama Department
of
Environmental
Management January
2001
Exhibit 169
Prefiled testimony of
Charles
S.
Meiching
Exhibit
170
Compact
Disc entitled
“Other Meiching
Exhibits”
Exhibit
171
One page document
entitled
“Information
for Meiching Response
to JEPA
Question 13”
Exhibit 172
One page document entitled
“WEB LINKS
iN RESPONSE TO 1EPA
QUESTIONS
FOR
MELCHING”
Exhibit
173
One page document
entitled
“Information
for Meiching Response
to JEPA
Question 40.A.”
Exhibit 174
One page
document entitled
“Information for Meiching
Response
to IEPA
Question 14.G.”
Exhibit 175
“The Qualitative
Habitat Evaluation
Index [QHEI]: Rationale,
Methods, and
Application”
by Edward T. Rankin dated
November 6, 1989
Exhibit 176
One
page document entitled
“Information for Meiching Response
to IEPA
Question
1
8.A.”
Exhibit 177
One
page document entitled
“Information for Meiching Response
to IEPA
Question 1 8.D.”
Exhibit 178
One page document
entitled
“Information
for Melching Response to IEPA
Question 43.B.”
Exhibit 179
Prefiled testimony
of Scudder D. Mackey
Exhibit 180
Chart entitled “Physical
Characteristics of
Aquatic Habitat (identical to Figure
1
in Exhibit
179)
Exhibit
181
Two charts, first entitled
“Original
QHEI Scores” and
second “Corrected QHEI
Values”
Exhibit
182
Calumet-Sag Channel
Sidescan Sonar
Data State Route
83 Sampling Site
Exhibit 183
Table entitle “QHEI
Metrics in the CAWS”
Exhibit 184
Table 1. Data Availability,
Metrics and Methods
(identical
to Attachment
3 to
Exhibit 179)
Exhibit
185
Sidescan
Sonar
Mosaic
Calumet-Sag
Channel
Exhibit 186
Lower
Sandusky River
Northwest
Ohio
Exhibit 187
CD Rom of
prefiled testimony
of Jennifer Wasik
Exhibit
188
“Development
and Evaluation
of Consensus-Based
Sediment Quality
Guidelines
for
Freshwater
Ecosystems”
by D.D.
MacDonald,
C. G. Ingersoll, T.
A. Berger,
January
13, 2000
Exhibit 189
Picture
of Hester
Denby
Exhibit 190
“Illinois
Benthic
Macroinvertebrate
Collection method
Comparison
and Stream
Condition Index Revision”
Prepared
for Illinois Environmental
Protection
Agency
by
Tetra Tech,
Inc. November 2004,
Revised July
2005.
Exhibit 191
Prefiled
Testimony
of Samuel
G.
Dennison
on Classification
of
the Calumet-Sag
Channel as an Aquatic
Live
Use
B Water
Exhibit 192
Prefiled Testimony
of Samuel
G.
Dennison
concerning
Justification
for an
additional Aquatic
Lie
Use Tie
r for Bubbly
Creek.
Exhibit 193
Prefiled
Testimony
of Marcelo
H. Garcia,
Ph.D
Exhibit
194
“Upstream
Intrusion
Effect
of
CSO
Event
in Bubbly Creek,
IL”
Xiaofeng
Liu,
Sumit
Sinha, Davide Motta,
and Marcelo
H. Garcia
Exhibit 195
Chart
entitled “Upstream
Intrusion Induced
by
CSO
Events”
Xiaofeng
Liu and
Marcelo
H. Garcia
Exhibit 196
Research
Proposal
entitled
“Chicago
Waterway
System Environmental
Modeling”
by Marcelo
H. Garcia
Exhibit 197
Environmental
Fluid Dynamics
Code
(EFDC)
Exhibit 198
List
of know EFDC
Applications (as
of January 2004)
Exhibit 199
“Two-dimensional
BOD and
DO water quality
model for engineering
applications: the
case of Bubbly
Creek in Chicago,
Illinois”
by Davide Motta,
Jorge d. Abad, Xiaofeng
Liu
and Marcelo
H. Garcia
Exhibit
200
.03-3 Water
Quality
Criteria
Specific
to Designated
Uses
from
www .dsd.state.md.us/comar/26/26.
08.02.03-3
.htm
Exhibit 201
Use Attainability
Analysis
for the
federal navigation
channels
located in tidal
portions
of the
Patapsco
River.
Exhibit 202
“Behavioral
response
to
dish larvae to low
dissolved
oxygen
concentrations
in a
stratified
water
column”
by
D.
L. Breitburg
Marine
Biology (1994)
Exhibit 203
“The influence
of
fish sixe on the avoidance
of hypoxia
and oxygen
selection
by
largemouth
bass”
by M.L. Burelson,
D.R.
Wilhelm,
and
N.J.
Smartresk Journal
of
Fish
Biology (2001)
Exhibit
204
Prefiled
Testimony
of Paul L.
Freedman,
P.E., BCEE
Exhibit
205
USEPA
document
entitled
“Use
of Biological
Information to Better
Define
Designated
Aquatic
Life Uses in
State and Tribal
Water
Quality
Standards:
Tiered
Aquatic
Life
Uses”
Exhibit
206
Upper
South Platte
River Segment
15
Exhibit
207
38
§464. Classification
of Maine
waters
Exhibit
208
414
CMR 4.00:
Division
of
Water Pollution
Control Massachusetts
Surface
Water
Quality Standards
Exhibit 209
Prefiled Testimony
of Samuel
G.
Dennison
concerning Dissolved
Oxygen
(DO)
Standards Proposed
for
Protecting Aquatic
Life
in
the
Designated Aquatic
Life
Use A Waters
and
Aquatic
Life
Use B
Waters of the Chicago
Area Waterway
System
Exhibit 210
“Standard
Methods
for the Examination of
Water and
Wastewater”
prepared and
published jointly
by American
Public
Health
Association,
American
Water
Works
Association
and Water
Environment Federation
Exhibit
211
Prefiled Testimony
of Stephen
F. McGowan
“environmental
Assessment
of
Supplemental
Aeration
and
Flow Augmentation
Technologies
for Increasing
Dissolved Oxygen
Concentration
in
the Chicago
Area
Waterways”
Exhibit
212
From Integrys Energy
services
“Electricity
Sources and Emissions”
includes
table
entitled
“Average
Amounts
of Emissions and
Amount of Nuclear
Waste
from
1000 kilowatt-hours
(kWH)
Produced form
Known
sources
for the
12
months
ending September
30, 2008”
Exhibit
213
Midwest ISO
Corporate
Information
Exhibit
214
Table entitled
“Sources
of Electricity
Supplied”
Exhibit 215
Table
entitled
“Comparison
of
GHG
Emission Estimates
Based
on
Original
and
Updated
Emission
Factors”
Exhibit 216
Table entitled “Summary
of
Electrical
consumption
and Air Emissions
for
Dissolved
Oxygen Aeration”
Exhibit
217
Prefiled
testimony
of
David
R. Zenz
“Dissolved
Oxygen
Enhancement
Studies”
Exhibit
218
Map
entitled
“CAWS
Aeration
Station
Locations,
Overview
of
the Waterway
System”
Exhibit 219
Table entitled
“Table 4 Locations
of the proposed
new aeration
stations in the
Chicago Area Waterway
System”
Exhibit 220
CD Rom entitled
“David
Zenz
Technical feasibility
and cost to
meet nutrient
standards
in
Illinois (Consoer Townsend
Envirodyne
Engineers,
Inc. April 14,
2003).”
Exhibit
221
Map entitled “CAWS
Aeration
Station
Locations,
Upper North
Channel Aeration
Stations”
Exhibit
222
Map entitled
“CAWS Aeration
Station
Locations, South Branch
Chicago
River,
Bubbly
Creek, Chicago
Sanitary and Ship
Canal Aeration
Stations”
Exhibit 223
Prefiled testimony of
John Mastracchio
“Economic Assessment
for
Dissolved
Oxygen
Enhancement
Facilities”
Exhibit 224
CD Rom entitled
“John
Mastracchio
Skokie Park
District
2007
Annual Report,
Hanover Park 2007
Annual Report”
Exhibit 225
Page of Charts
entitled “Attachment
5”
Exhibit 226
Westlaw
33
U.S.C.A.
§
1284 (four
page
document)
Exhibit 227
Westlaw 40
C.F.R.
§
35.929-1 (five
page
document)
Exhibit 228
Appendix
B
to Subpart E of Par
35 - Federal
Guidelines
—
User Charges for
Operation and Maintenance
of Publicly
Owned
Treatment Works
Exhibit
229
USEPA
document entitle
“User Charge Guidance
manual
for Publicly-Owned
Treatment
Works” (two
page
document)
Exhibit 230
Prefiled
testimony
of Jennifer
Wasik
“Cyanide
Standard”
Exhibit 231
Metropolitan
Water Reclamation
District
of Greater Chicago’s
Response
to
Certain
Questions
from
December 3, 2008
Hearing Regarding
Limitation
for
Dredging
in the
Chicago Area Waterway
System
Exhibit 232
MWRDC’s
document
by Research
and Development
Department
“Report No. 04-
8 2003 Bubbly
Creek
Water
Quality
Improvement
Demonstration
Project” June
2004
Exhibit 233
Prefiled
testimony
of
Marc H. Gorelick, M.D.
Exhibit 234
Prefiled
testimony
of
Peter Orris, M.D.,
M.P.H.
Exhibit 235
Public
Health Risks
Associated with Wastewater
Blending
Rachael Katonak
and
Joan B. Rose,
Final Report
November
17, 2003
Exhibit
236
Wastewater
Blending
House
of Representative,
Committee
on Transportation
and
Infrastmcture,
Subcommittee
on
Water Resources
and Environment,
Washington,
D.C. Wednesday
April
13, 2005
Exhibit
237
Cryptosporidium
spp. Oocyst
and Giardia
spp. Cys occurrence,
concentrations
and distribution
in Wisconsin
waters Published
1995, Wisconsin
Dept. Of Natural
Resources
by J.R. Archer
Exhibit
238
Memorandum
City
of Milwaukee Health
Department
April 28, 2006 to
Milwaukee Journal
Sentinel From
Bevan K. Baker
Exhibit
239
CDC MMWR September
12, 2008
Surveillancefor
Waterborne Disease
and
Outbreaks
Associated
with Drinking
Water and Water
not Intendedfor
Drinking-
Unites States 2005-2006
Exhibit 240
Prefiled testimony of
Dr.
William
Van Bonn
Exhibit
241
BioScience
Sea Sickness:
The Upsurge
in Marine Diseases
by
Yvonne
Baskin
Exhibit 242
Unhealthy
Landscapes:
Policy Recommendations
on Land
Use Change
and
Infectious
Disease Emergence
by Jonathan
A. Patz
et al.
Exhibit 243
Over-achievers
by Bob Bluett Outdoor
Illinois
January
2007
Exhibit
244
Two
articles,
the
first
On the Otter Hand
and the second
Otter-ly amazing
“They ‘re everywhere”
Exhibit
245
Commentary
Sea otters in a dirty
ocean
by David
a. Jessup et al.
Exhibit
246
Development
and Application of
Dfferent
Method
for the Detection
of
Taxoplasma
gondii
in Water
by
Chritaina
Kourenti
et
al.
Exhibit
247
USEPA Letter
to Mr. Roger Briggs,
California
Regional Water
Quality Board
Central
Coast Region from
Alexis
Strauss
Director
of
Water Division
Exhibit
248
Determining Sources
ofFecal Bacteria
in Waterways
by Tao Yan
and Michael
J.
Sadowsky
Exhibit
249
Prefiled
testimony of Dr. Marylynn
V. Yates
Exhibit 250
Indicators
for Waterborne Pathogens
committee
on Indicators
for Waterborne
Pathogens,
Board on Live
Sciences,
Water Science and Technology
Board,
Division
on Earth live Studies,
National
Research
Council
Exhibit 251
Validity
of
the Indicator Organism
paradigm
for pathogen
Reduction in
Reclaimed
Water and Public
Health Protection
Valerie
J.
Harwood,
Audrey
d.
Levine,
Troy M. Scott, Basanta
Chibukula,
Jerzy
Lukasik,
Samuel R. Farrah,
and
Joan
D. Rose Applied and
Environmental
Microbiology, June
2005
Exhibit 252
Predicted
Public Health
Consequences
ofBody-contact Recreation
on
a Potable
Water
Reservoir
by
Mic H. Stewert, MaryLynn
v. Yates,
Michael A. Anderson,
Charles
P. Gerba, Joan
B.
Rose, Ricardo
De Leon, and
Roy L. Wolfe Watershed
Management May 2002
Exhibit
253
A Serosurvey
of Water-Borne Pathogens
amongst
Canoeists in South
Africa M.B.
Taylor,
P.J.
Becker,
E.
Janse
van
Rensburg,
B.N. Harris, I.W.
Bailey,
W.O.
K.
Grabow Cambridge
University
Press Epidemiology
and Infection
Vol. 115,
No. 2
(Oct. 1995)
Exhibit
254
Color
Chart entitled “Schistosomiasis”
Exhibit
255
Norwalk
Virus: How Infectious
is It? by
Peter F.M.
Teunis,
Christine L. Moe,
Pengbo
Liu,
Sara E. Miller,
Lisa Lindesmith,
Ralph s. Baric,
Jacques Le
Pendu,
and
Rebecca
L. Calderon Journal
of Medical
Virology 2008
Exhibit 256
Analysis
ofthe United States
Environmental
Protection
Agency ‘.s’ Non
Compliance
with the Beaches
Environmental
Assessment and
Coastal Health
Act
by
Marylynn
V. Yates and Rachel
T. Noble
Exhibit 257
Sensitive
populations:
Who is at the greatest
risk? by
Charles P. Gerba,
Joan B.
Rose,
Charles
N.
Haas International
Journal
of food
Microbiology 1996
Exhibit
258
Microbial risk
assessment: don
‘tforget the children
by Nena
Nwachuku and
Charles
P.
Gerba Current
Opinion
in Microbiology
2006
Exhibit
259
Prefiled testimony
of Margaret Frisbee
Exhibit 260
United
States Canoe
Association Competition
Events
USCA Sanctioning
Guidelines
Exhibit
261
Brochure
entitled
“Chicago Area
Waterways
Health Precautions”
Exhibit
262
Brochure
entitled
“It’s
Our
River Day
A celebration of Illinois
watersheds
through Education
Recreation
Conservation
Saturday
September 19, 2009”
Exhibit
263
CD-Rom
entitled
“Illinois
Bureau of
Tourism Commercial”
Exhibit 264
Series
of pictures
and
maps with cover
page “Boat Launches
Clark
Park (1) to
River North
Park (47) Direction:
South
to
North
Number of Launches:
47
(45
private
— red, 2 public
— green)
Exhibit
265
Series
of pictures with cover
page “Egress
Points on the
CAWS”
Exhibit
266
CD-Rom
entitled “CAWS
Circle tour Photos”
Exhibit 266(a)
Pictures
from CD-Rom with
cover page
“CAWS
Circle
tour Photo Handouts”
Exhibit 267
Chart
entitled “Friends
of the Chicago
River Individual
Canoe
Trips
by Reach
1998-2008”
Exhibit
268
Chicago
River
Canoe and Kayak Liveries
Exhibit 269
Crew
Teams
on
the Chicago
River
Exhibit
270
Chart
entitled “Friends
of the
Chicago River
— Chicago Park District
Canoe
Trips
2005-2008”
Exhibit 271
Letter
to Margaret Frisbee
from
Cathy Hudzik
Assistant to the Mayor,
City of
Chicago
dated
November 7, 2008
Exhibit
272
Pictures
of Chicago
River with Marina
Towers in
one picture
Exhibit
273
Pictures
with cover
page “Bubbly Creek
— May 15,
2008”
Exhibit 274
Memorandum
of
the Chicago Park District
dated
December
17,
2008 on FOIA —
Chicago River Projects
Exhibit 275
Map entitled
“Ping tom Shoreline
Improvements”
Exhibit
276
Chicago River
Agenda City of Chicago
Richard
M.
Daley,
Mayor
Exhibit 277
Sum Times
column from Neighborhoods
with
Mark
Konkol entitled
“River
Rats”
Exhibit
278
Chart entitled
“Public
comments:
Friends
of
the
Chicago
River v. Non-members
as of April
24, 2009”
Exhibit 279
Series of pictures with
cover page
“Wading on the CAWS”
Exhibit
280
Chart entitled
“Total
Number
of Fish Species
Collected From the Chicago
and
Calumet
River Systems Between
1972
and
2005”
Exhibit
281
Chart
entitled “Birds
Of the Chicago River”
Exhibit
282
Chart
entitled
“Fishes
of the Chicago Waterways
System”
Exhibit 283
Series
of pictures
with
cover page “Wildlife
on the
CAWS”
Exhibit 284
Prefiled
testimony
of
Thomas J. Bamonte
Exhibit
285
Prefiled
testimony
with
CD-Rom of James
E. Huff
on
behalf of Citgo Petroleum
Corporation
and PDV Midwest,
LLC