QRitN*Li
Page
1
ILLINOIS
POLLUTION
CONTROL BOARD
IN THE
MATTER
OF:
WATER
QUALITY
STANDARDS
AND
)
R08-9
EFFLUENT
LIMITATIONS
FOR
THE
)
(Rulemaking
-
CHICAGO AREA
WATERWAY
SYSTEM
)
Water)
AND LOWER
DES
PLAINES
RIVER
PROPOSED
AMENDMENTS
TO
35
ILL.
ADM.
CODE 301,
302,
303 and 304)
TRANSCRIPT
OF
PROCEEDINGS
held in
the
above—entitled
cause at the
James R.
Thompson
Building,
100
West
Randolph
Street,
Chicago,
Illinois,
Room 2-025,
on the
17th
day
of
February,
2009,
at
9:00 a.m.
BEFORE:
MARIA E.
TIPSORD,
HEARING OFFICER,
ILLINOIS
POLLUTION CONTROL
BOARD
100
West
Randolph
Street
Suite
11—500
Chicago,
Illinois
60601
312—814—4925.
Page 2
1
APPEARANCES:
2
3
MS.
MARIE TIPSORD,
Hearing
Officer,
4
MS. ALISA
LIU, Environmental
Scientist,
5
MR.
ANAND
RAO,
Senior
Environmental
Scientist,
6
MR.
G.
TANNER GIRARD,
Acting
Chairman,
7
MR.
SHUNDAR
LIN, Board
Member,
8
MS. ANDREA
S.
MOORE,
Board
Member,
9
MR.
THOMAS
E.
JOHNSON,
Board Member.
10
11
ILLINOIS
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION
AGENCY,
12
1021
North Grand
Avenue
East
13
P.O. Box
19276
14
Springfield,
Illinois 62794—9276
15
217—782—5544
16
MS.
DEBORAH
WILLIAMS,
17
MS. STEPHANIE
DIERS,
18
19
ENVIRONMENTAL
LAW
& POLICY CENTER,
20
35
East
Wacker
Drive, Suite
1300
21
Chicago,
Illinois
60601—2110
22
312—795—3707
23
MS.
JESSICA
DEXTER;
24
Page
3
1
APPEARANCES
(cont’d)
2
3
BARNES
&
THORNBURG,
LLP,
One North
Wacker
Drive
Suite
4400
6
Chicago,
Illinois
60606
7
312—357—1313
8
MR.
FREDRIC
P. ANDES,
appeared
on
behalf of
the
Metropolitan
10
Water
Reclamation
District.
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Page 4
2
WITNESS
ADRIENNE
MEMURA...
PAUL FREEDMAN
6
SAMUEL
DENNISON...
7
PAGE
5
31
84
1
INDEX
8
EXHIBITS
NUMBER
MARKED
FOR ID
10
Exhibit
No. 200
8
11
Exhibit
No. 201
9
12
Exhibit No.
202
20
13
Exhibit
No.
203
21
14
Exhibit
No. 204
30
15
Exhibit
No.
205
58
16
Exhibit
No. 206
60
17
Exhibit No.
207
81
18
Exhibit
No.
208
82
19
Exhibit
No.
209
84
20
Exhibit
No. 210
85
21
22
23
24
Page
5
1
MS.
TIPSORD:
Good
afternoon,
2
everyone.
Let’s
go
ahead
and
go
back
on the
3
record.
4
We
have
with
us
Adrienne
Nemura.
5
And Ms.
Nemura’s
testimony
was previously
at
6
Exhibit
116.
7
I
will
note
that
you
are,
8
therefore,
still under
oath.
And
we
have
9
some
questions
that
we’re
going
to
come
back
10
to.
11
At
this point
I’m
going
to
start
12
with
the IEPA.
13
ADRIENNE
NEMURA,
14
called
as a
witness
herein,
having
been previously
15
duly
sworn
and
having
testified,
was examined
and
16
testified
further
as
follows:
17
EXAMINATION
(Resumed)
18
BY MS.
WILLIAMS:
19
Q.
Good
afternoon,
Ms.
Nemura.
20
I believe
you testified in
21
September
that
you
were
not
making
a
specific
22
recommendation
to
the Board
for
a
wet weather
23
exemption
for recreational
uses.
Is that
correct?
24
A.
Correct.
Page
6
1
Q.
Is it
your testimony that the same is
2
true
for
aquatic
life
uses?
3
A.
That is
true.
4
Q.
I
believe
you
also testified in
5
September
that
you
were not aware
of any UAAs in
6
other
states
that had
been completed that allowed
7
for
the
suspension
of aquatic life
uses
in wet
8
weather. Is that correct?
9
A.
The UAA5
that have been done for
10
aquatic
life haven’t
specifically addressed the
11
issue of wet weather. Although wet weather
periods
12
may have been included in
those UAA5.
13
Q.
Okay.
14
MS. TIPSORD:
Ms. Williams,
would it
15
help if I had premarked
Question 5 marked?
16
MS. WILLIAMS: Well, I think she
just
17
addressed that.
18
MS. TIPSORD:
Okay.
19
MS. WILLIAMS:
That’s why I’m trying
20
to see if -— I think I can skip on
to
21
Question 20.
22
MR. JOHNSON:
What
number?
23
MS. WILLIAMS:
Twenty.
24
t\)
t\)
N)
N)
N)
H
F-
F
l-
HA
HA
HA
HA
c
r’j
o
a)
—J
a)
(fl
J
U)
N)
HA
a)
a
u-i
U)
N)
HA
CD
CD
CD
ft
C)
CD
0
CD
CD
ft
H-
hi
D
CD
CD
ft
I-<
CD
CD
CD
F-
CD
CD
CD
CD
-<
CD
rt
CD
3
ft
HA
ft
CD
0
CD
ct
ft
0.
H-
0
CD
ft
CD
C)
hi
CD
U)
CD
CD
CD
CD
‘t
CD
H
hi
hi
hi
Cl)
hi
CD
CD
Q
hi
J
Ft
h
C)
0
0.
CD
CD
CD
HA
ft
C
0
C
CD
CD
0
CD
0
hi
rt
CD
CD
CD
CD
i
Hi
C)
ft
CD
H-
I
CD
çD
HA
0
it
CD
hi
rt
0
H-
0
CD
HA
I
CD
H
ft
it
hi
CD
ft
hi
CD
0
CD
HA
HA
HA
rt
CD
i—i
CD
Hi
CD
0.
CD
Ft
CD
HA
CD
H
C)
CD
CD
H-
1<
-.
CD
0
hi
Q
CD
L<
c-I
C)
hi
ft
0
hi
:1
ft
ft
CD
F-H
Cl)
CD
hi
CD
ft
U)
Hi
H-
CD
F-
CD
C)
CD
0
ft
U)
it
CD
ft
CD
•
CD
hi
Ft
H-
ft
HA
CD
CD
CD
it
0.
CD
ft
ft
i
H-
ft
ft
CD
h-h
ft
<
CD
o
HA
H
ft
0
0
CD
CD
C)
ft
0.
CD
CD
ft
ft
ft
I-I
0
Z
ft
0.
CD
3
hi
CD
CD
HA
0
CD
CD
hi
H-
0
CD
ft
CD
C)
CD
CD
CD
hi
X
ft
ft
HA
H-
hi
CD
CD
ft
CD
U)
CD
C’]
CD
C)
ft
ft
CD
:3
0.
•
H-
0
hi
0
Cl)
‘C
C)
ft
C)
HA
CD
CD
CD
ft
H-
CD
0
ft
]
CD
CD
CD
0
hi
ft
0
H-
CD
hi
hi
0
l<
CD
3
C)
ft
C)
H-
CD
•
ft
0.
CD
CD
Q
ft
ft
CD
ft
H-
•
CD
H-
HA
ft
hi
CD
CD
N
CD
0
CD
0
ft
CD
Hi
0.
CD
CD
hi
0.
CD
H-
CD
ft
ft
CD
CD
CD
0.
H-
hi
•
hi
CD
hi
CD
CD
hi
CD
Q
H-
CD
0.
C)
H-
H-
CD
C)
CD
0
ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
0
CD
3
hi
CD
3
CD
hi
0
I
CD
CD
Hi
-,
ft
0.
0.
H-
C)
CD
CD
I
Q
CD
H-
ft
—J
CD
CD
HA
HA
ft
Di
3
C]
0.
CD
CD
C’]
•
0
ft
CD
0.
CD
CD
hi
CD
C)
<
t-h
><
C)
Q.
H-
C)
CD
H-
HA
hi
ft
CD
‘d
0
ft
CD
CD
CD
ft
ft
H-
HA
H-
CD
CD
hi
H-
0.
CD
CD
CD
ft
Hi
‘t
Q
0
C)
hi
ft
CD
0.
CD
HA
0
H-
CD
-Q
ft
0
CD
ft
ft
HA
ft
I
hi
CD
F-
CD
C)
hi
CD
0.
CD
ft
ft
I
CD
ft
H-
CD
ft
CD
H-i
HA
H-
hi
0.
CD
CD
0
ft
CD
C)
ft
0
CD
F-
t-h
CD
HA
0
CD
HA
CD
CD
C)
hi
0
hi
ft
CD
H-
‘T]
ft
C)
HA
ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
hi
H-
h-h
3
CD
ft
o
ft
0)
CD
C).
CD
ft
HA
H-
ft
CD
0.
L)
C).
CD
-
ft
ft
CD
ft
ft
CD
ft
CD
H-
CD
CD
U)
C)
CD
Mi
CD
ft
1
ft
—I
CD
hi
ft
ft
CD
CD
CD
ft
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
•
CD
hi
H
CD
ft
CD
ft
ft
I
ft
t3
hi
CD
hi
H-
0
CD
0
ft
CD
I
CD
HA
0
hi
HA
CD
H-
H-
CD
H-
ft
3
<
hi
hi
<
CD
ft
CD
Q
CD
‘c
CD
Cl
Cl)
CD
Page
8
1
MR.
ANDES:
The
document
is an
excerpt
2
from
Maryland
regulations
water
quality
3
criteria
specific
to
designated
uses
4
26.0802.03—3.
5
MS.
TIPSORD:
And
if there
is
no
6
objection,
I
will happily,
and
with
all
7
excitement,
state
that
we will
enter
this
as
8
Exhibit
200.
Seeing
none,
that
is
9
Exhibit
200.
10
(WHEREUPON,
a
certain
document
11
was
marked
Exhibit
12
No.
200
for identification,
13
as
of
2/17/09.)
14
MR.
ANDES:
I believe
we have
201,
as
15
well.
16
MS.
TIPSORD:
All
right.
17
MR. ANDES:
This
is
a
related
18
document,
a
use
attainability analysis
for
19
the federal
navigation
channels
located
in
20
titled
portions
of
the Patapsco
River.
21
MS. TIPSORD:
If there’s
no
objection,
22
we will
mark
the
document
just
identified
as
23
Exhibit
201.
24
MS.
WILLIAMS:
I’m
not
sure
so this
Page
9
1
is from
the
Chesapeake
Bay
also?
I’m
just
2
trying
to
make sure I
understand before
--
3
BY
THE
WITNESS:
4
A.
The
Chesapeake
Bay
UAA was
the
5
regional UAA
for
the
Chesapeake Bay
affecting
6
several
states.
And that document
is also
used as
7
supporting
information
for
states
to
do
specific
8
UAA,
such
as
the Patapsco.
9
MS. WILLIAMS:
I have
no objection.
10
MS.
TIPSORD: With
that, we
will
mark
11
this
as Exhibit
201.
12
(WHEREUPON,
a
certain
document
13
was
marked Exhibit
No. 201
14
for
identification,
15
as
of 2/17/09.)
16
BY THE WITNESS:
17
A.
And
at
the end of the
Patapsco
UAA, it
18
does
indicate
that Maryland’s
proposal
was that the
19
criteria
for the navigation
channel
could
be
zero
20
milligrams per
liter from
June 1
to
September
30,
21
inclusive.
22
BY
MS. WILLIAMS:
23
Q.
Can
you
show me in
200 where the
24
dissolved oxygen
standards
are you’re referring
to?
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
H
W
NJ
H
0
Q
F-’
H
H
F-’
H
I—’
0
-J
0)
(5
s
()
H
F-’
H
NJ
F
0
co
o
0)
0’
CJ
NJ
F
ct
hi
H-
U)
C)
‘-<
tJJ
C)
Ft
Ft
H-
Ft
U)
U)
JJ
CD
U)
H-
hi
C)
F<
LU
3
0
II
H
F<
CD
LU
U)
cQ
H-
Li
U)
U)
U)
ct
U)
CD
H
Q.
U)
Li
3
Ft
Ft
3
Ft
Ft
U)
0
H
U)
hi
U)
CD
H-
CD
H-
Cl)
Ft
U)
U
II
CD
CD
1
Hi
hi
Li
•
çt
L’i
3
U)
H-
U)
C’]
U)
U)
H-
H-
CD
C)
D
C)
It]
3
C])
Ct
U)
H
C)
U)
K)
CD
0
CD
H
U)
U)
CD
0
CD
0
U)
Ct
•
I-I
U)
-
U)
<
ct
U)
CD
•
I-H
C)
Q
j
3
hi
H-
CD
U)
•
H-
<1
H
Ft
U)
C)
CD
h-h
LH
CD
U)
t]
CD
H-
Ft
U)
U)
CD
U)
H-
Ft
C)
I—’
H
U)
C’]
0
H-
H
Ft
CD
hi
cc
CD
CD
hi
CD
0
0
‘t]
0
0
Li
X
U)
H-
CX)
hi
0
Ft
Ft
It]
C/)
3
i
U)
Hi
hi
0
CD
H
Ft
o
CD
CD
H-
CD
H
••
H
Z
cC)
II
CD
U)
Ft
U)
H
CD
Ft
C)
hi
Ci)
•
H
<
Ft
H
Ft
Ft
0
3
hi
Hi
Z
Li
C)
U)
C’]
U)
H
H
H-
Ft
H-
hi
U)
CD
0
H
CD
Ft
hi
H-
C)
‘
CD
0
Li
D
U)
Di
CD
hi
hi
hi
U)
H
0
H-
Ft
Li
U)
0
CD
-,
U)
<
CD
U)
hi
Ft
U)
I-H
I—I
Li
U)
D
H
U)
Ft
Li
C).
H
H
H
‘tJ
I
U)
CD
<
U)
Ft
CD
U)
I
U)
0
CD
Z
C/)
cC)
C)
hi
<1
hi
LU
Ft
CD
H-
<1
Ft
3
I
Ft
CD
Hi
U)
C’]
0
0
CD
U)
U)
hi
U)
><
CD
U)
Li
H-
cC)
C/)
i
Ft
It]
hi
H-
Ft
t
CD
3
CD
Ft
H-
Ft
U)
C/)
1i
Ft
H-
CD
CD
H-
U)
CD
H
•
L<
CD
CD
CD
:J-
••
••
0
3
hi
hi
U)
<
3
U)
U)
Ft
hi
U)
3
CD
Ft
C).
H-
3
U)
C)
H-
3
U)
U)
Ft
Ft
0
‘ii
H-
Q
0
C)
hi
CD
Hi
3
0
H
C)
D
CD
U)
<
U)
C)
Li
C).
CD
H-
•J
0
Li
U)
hi
U)
H-
hi
Hi
I
I-H
F-H
L.Q
U)
U)
U)
hi
1
cC)
0
H-
Li
U)
H-
0
U)
I
•
•
CD
Ft
H
0
H-
3
Ft
0
0
hi
Ft
CD
H-
Hi
3
C)
C)
Li
<
3
CD
It]
CD
Li
H-
Ft
Ui
U)
Ft
Li
CD
U)
H-
Ft
U)
hi
Ft
)<
‘
U)
U)
<
Ft
H-
3
U)
Ft
3
<1
H-
CD
U)
CD
H
CD
0
Ft
H
C)
U)
5
CD
CD
U)
Li
Ft
<
Hi
D
U)
U)
H-
-<
0
H-
‘-<
t]
3
CD
U)
U)
U)
Ft
CD
Ft
3
0
H
U)
U)
C)
H
CD
3
3
Li
Lxi
Ft
U)
-
CD
Li
<
hi
C)
hi
CD
Li
0
3
U)
Ft
CD
U)
CD
H-
U)
‘t]
Ft
Li
U)
3
CD
Li
CD
3
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
H
3
U)
3
Ft
U)
X
C)
H
0
CD
U)
hi
CD
CD
CD
hi
Li
3
Ft
t]
0
Ft
0
hi
CD
3
C)
Li
H
Li
U)
H
<
H-
H
H-
Li
CD
It]
Ft
cC)
U)
H-
Ft
t]
U)
-<
0
CD
CD
U)
3
U)
3
0
U)
0
•
Ft
U)
H-
cC)
3
hi
Li
U)
hi
Ft
hi
Ft
N)
U)
H-
U)
3
CD
cC)
H
<
Li
U)
U)
C)
1
rJ
H
H-
Ft
U)
3
Ft
CD
0
CD
0
H
3
C)
Di
CD
U)
U)
Ft
Li
Li
Hi
Li
C)
H-
0
U)
cC)
3
U)
CD
0
U)
Ct)
U)
CD
CD
Ft
hi
CD
hi
•‘L)
U)
Li
t’O
t’-)
M
M
F-
H
H
F
-
H-
F
F-
H
H
w
r\)
I-
0
C
0)
—J
0)
(ii
N)
5
0
0)
()
N)
C)
CD
-Q
a
CD
çt
F-I
H-
CD
h
It
H-
Q.
CD
H-
C)
i
H
H
0
H
0
(0
h
0
Cl)
Q.
CD
ct
CD
It
CD
LI-
H-
CD
It
CD
0
çt
hi
CD
CD
CD
3
F—i
CD
Fj
hi
CD
It
0
CD
a
CD
It
H-
CD
Q.
<
0
CD
H-
CD
H-
D
H
F—i
H-
It
It
H-
CD
CD
CD
C)
CD
0
CD
<
H
Cl)
CD
CD
CD
CD
H
CD
rt
It
H-
3
CD
<
rt
H-
It
0
C)
CD
0
C
Q
0
-
a
hi
CD
H-
•
H-
•
H-
•
CD
hi
CD
Q
H
I
H-
F
0
hi
It
C)
CD
CD
0
C)
it
(I)
i
H-
‘t
CD
CD
hi
CD
F-F
hi
><
It
C)
H
C).
H-
It
CD
‘-<
CD
It
It
0
CD
CD
CD
•
It
It
It
0
h-h
H
CD
H-
CD
L<
F-F
H-
CD
hi
Cl)
0
H
H
CD
CD
hi
CD
hi
It
CD
3
H-
H
CD
H-
C)
ED
<
D
H
0
H-
0
It
a
H
Q.
hi
It
H-
It
0
CD
C)
It
CD
0
C)
CD
CD
Q
CD
CD
It
CD
CD
CD
H
CD
I-I
D
C)
0
CD
<1
CD
0
a
It
a
C)
3
CD
CD
It
C)
It
CD
It
a
H-
C)
•J
CD
CD
It
H
It
It
CD
0
D
H-
It
It
CD
CD
hi
C).
<
H-
It
H-
H-
CD
H
F-I
CD
CD
CD
<
It
CD
C).
H-
0
a
0
D
It
C)
CD
‘-<
It
I
CD
CD
CD
a
It
CD
<
CD
It
It
Q
0
•
I
H
0
C)
C)
•
hi
CD
It
H
0
CD
CD
H
Cri
J
CD
hi
CD
CD
D
CD
a
CD
0
Cl)
<
0
CD
H-
3
CD
CD
0
Q
0
CD
-‘
•‘J
H
Y
hi
It
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
It
CD
a
H-
It
H-
CD
a
a
3
It
It
Cl)
It
H-
It
H
a
CD
H-
It
CD
CD
It
C)
H
It
CD
<
H-
0
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
><
C)
It
H
CD
CD
It
It
CD
CD
<
‘-<
It
‘-<
H-
0
H
It
It
CD
H-
CD
It
CD
0
CD
Q
CD
H-
0
3
3
0
3
H-
o
CD
CD
CD
3
CD
hi
3
3
Q
0
3
CD
It
F-I
3
3
It
C)
3
a
I
It
-Q
It
H
CD
CD
a
Y
CD
CD
H-
U)
It
I
H
C)
H
‘TJ
hi
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
C)
I—i
CD
It
It
H
0
Cl)
H-
CD
hi
H
It
It
CD
•
hi
I
CD
J
It
C)
It
a
H-
3
CD
It
hi
CD
H
CD
3
H-
0
CD
hi
CD
CD
3
CD
CD
It
CD
a
H
0
<1
hi
a
L<
CD
C)
3_
H-
It
H-
It
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
C)
3
3
C)
3
0
0
•
hi
3
It
3
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
a
0
3
It
C)
3
It
CD
H
It
H
CD
•
It
CD
hi
It
3
It
H
a
a
It
0
hi
CD
It
C)
hi
H
0
It
It
‘-j
0
CD
H
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
LQ
CD
3
CD
It
CD
a
H
It
N,)
NJ
N,)
N,)
NJ
H
I-
F-
F
-
H
F
H
I-
F-
(
N,)
—
C
LO
co
—J
a)
U’
J
Ui
NJ
H
C)
co
Cl)
-j
a)
U’
U)
NJ
H-
H-
0
0
0
h-h
Q
H
H
Di
0
ct
cv
3
x
t
H
Di
H-
Di
D
Q
H-
Q
Di
D
C)
C1
0
<
CD
I-
CD
0
CD
<
<
CD
H-
Q
CD
CD
t5
Di
H
C)
CD
-1
0
>
ct
Di
C)
CD
i
0
Di
Di
Di
CD
H
H-
Q
H-
Ct
3
Q
ct
çt
Ct
CD
CD
C)
H-
it
CD
H
o
0
H
::1)
0
CD
0
.Q
CD
Q
(I)
0
3
CD
o
•
ct
•
it
CD
Cl
C)
C)
H
3
0
C)
Cl
Di
Di
CD
C)
0
“<
H-
CD
it
CD
CD
C)
CD
0
I-h
CD
CD
it
Cl
D’
ct
CD
tJ’
H-
CD
0
CD
CD
Di
H-
Di
CD
-J-
F-
3
‘
H
it
CD
CD
Di
Di
it
h
CD
it
Di
CD
CD
Cl
H-
Ft
<
it
C)
H
H
H
ct
H
Di
D
<
H-
1
C)
ct
H-
ci
çt
Q
ct
C)
o
3
ct
it
0
CD
CD
0
-<
it
CD
C)
D
0
Di
Di
Di
Di
CD
H-
CD
•
H-
Cl
Di
CD
CD
H
3
0
it
it
it
-
it
Cl
CD
CD
C)
H-
0
-
it
pc-’
CD
it
CD
D
CD
0
0
Di
0
3
CD
it
(0
Di
H-
it
C)
CD
ct
-
CD
it
CD
1
H-
Cl)
0
CD
Cl
3
0
it
CD
H-
CD
H-
‘t5
II
CD
it
C)
H-
CD
LQ
H
CD
CD
•
CD
H
H
Di
H
Di
it
it
0
CD
Di
CD
3
H
3
H
it
H-
it
Di
H-
CD
3
C)
O
Di
h-I
CD
CD
(3
0
0
Di
H-
iI
I
CD
H-
CD
Cl
H
13’
‘Zj
0
CD
3
()
ct
t)
CD
3
0
(3
Cl
Di
CD
•
0
H-
it
I
C)
H-
CD
•
CD
CD
C)
Z
C)
Di
D
H-
C)
h
CD
H-
I
-<
C)
3
3
CD
C)
1
H-
H
0
<
CD
H-
it
CD
it
h
Cl
Di
it
it
Cl
Q
Di
CD
it
•
D
it
CD
H-
H-
CD
i—h
CD
I-i
it
CD
I—s
C)
C)
it
CD
3
•\)
it
C)
it
it
3
H-
CD
0
H
H
H-
0
it
Q.
0
0
CD
CD
Di
•
it
CD
C)
çt
Di
‘-<
3
3
H
l—
ct
l-
CD
3’
it
H-
H-
-,
CD
it
Di
CD
H
H-
H-
it
H
H
Cl
Di
it
C)
H
CD
Di
I-I
Di
0
3’
H
CD
it
CD
H
H-
Di
C)
CD
I-
0
CD
Di
><
3’
3
H
it
0
it
‘-<
CD
it
I-
CD
it
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
3’
0
H-
it
CD
C3
h-I
CD
CD
H
H
CD
0
CD
Cl
CD
H-
CD
H
-
CD
CD
it
CD
L<
CD
[-1
3
CD
h
CD
CD
H
Di
CD
H-
CD
CD
Di
H
Cl
CD
Cl
çt
CD
CD
Cl
C)
it
H-
it
CD
H
H-
0
I
I—h
C)
H-
0
3’
it
0
3
I
0
H-
0
C)
CD
0
C)
Di
CD
3
Di
H
CD
Cl
—I
it
0
I
CD
0
Q.
Di
H-
Di
H
Di
0
H
Cl
it
H-
Q
<
H
Cl
CD
H
it
CD
it
0
H
0
H-
CD
[-I
it
CD
CD
H-
Di
CD
CD
çt
•J
H
Q
it
Cl
0
H-
CD
CD
‘-<
çt
h
CD
H-
CD
H-
H-
•
d
H
Di
0
CD
CD
CD
H-
it
3
Cl
CD
0
0
C)
0
Cl
Di
Di
CD
H-
CD
3
CD
it
it
CD
H
H-
•
Cl
0
Di
I-H
CD
CD
it
Cl)
“3
3
H-
H
it
Cl
CD
•
CD
Cl
Page
13
1
Q.
But
what
about
in your
opinion?
2
A.
In my
opinion,
because
you
have
3
continuing
wet weather
problems that will occur,
4
such
as
tributary runoff,
storm water runoff,
you
5
still will
have some
CSO
events
and pump station
6
discharges.
In my opinion,
you
may not
be
able
to
7
meet the proposed
dissolved oxygen criteria
when
you
8
have wet weather
loads within the
Chicago area
9
waterways,
because of the
unique nature of the
10
system.
11
MR.
ANDES:
I think it will
help if
we
12
pass
out
copies of
—- this was Figure
5
in
13
Attachment 4, what
she’s referring
to.
14
BY MS. WILLIAMS:
15
Q.
I don’t think it’s
what you’re
16
referring
to;
is it?
Because we’re talking
about --
17
oh, I
see.
18
Explain
to
me why
you would
say
19
this is what
you’re referring
to now?
20
MS. TIPSORD:
Wait
a
minute.
Let’s
be
21
clear. This is
Figure 5
to
Attachment
4 of
22
Ms. Nemura’s
Exhibit 116 of her
prefiled
23
testimony;
correct?
24
MR. ANDES:
Yes.
N)
N)
N)
N)
N)
I-
F-
F
H
—
F-
F-
H
H-
F-
J
(J
N)
H
0
co
0)
—J
cY
(i
W
N)
H-’
0
co
0)
—J
0
0’
N)
I—’
CD
H-
h
ct
D
CD
C)
C)
It
0
It
F-I
Ct
X
0
CD
C)
CD
F-
I—h
0
CD
H
It
H-
CD
X
CD
<
0
CD
It
CD
H
Hi
CD
0
<
F-
L<
CD
Q
CD
3
CD
hi
hi
CD
Q
H-
NJ
CD
CT)
CD
c
C)
H
CD
hi
H
ct
hi
Cl)
Cl)
0
C)
H-
C)
J
I-
c-h
CD
0
Ct
H
It
CD
C)
Cl)
-
H
It
çt
hi
0
C)
CD
0
CD
CD
‘
Li
-
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
I—’
çt
H
çt
It
0
C)
c-I-
CT)
•
CD
I
It
Q
H-
hi
lD
CD
c-h
ct
0
M-
3
H-
H
CD
3
0
•
I-H
CD
0
CD
<
CD
CD
0
•
CD
It
CD
çt
CD
C)
cQ
H-
Q.
H
hi
Q
CD
I
3
H
CD
0
hi
It
0
‘
C)
Ct
Z
c-h
CD
h
I
ct
CD
Cl)
3
C)
t1
H-
hi
0
0
It
Cl)
H-
It
CD
Cl)
CD
CD
H-
3
NJ
CD
H
H
I—h
CD
CD
C).
It
CD
I-
0
H-
C).
CD
I-<
H-
C)
<
F-h
CD
hi
H-
CD
0
CD
H
-
H
It
C)
H-
CD
It
CD
It
0
C)
H
It
II
I—’
ct
-<
CD
CD
-
3
CD
0
ct
H-
H-
CD
CD
H
-<
0
C).
CD
CD
<1
0
CD
H
C)
It
CD
Ct
0
Ct
CD
H
hi
CD
H
It
C)
I-H
J
CD
CD
C)
i
C)
CD
CD
i
<
U-
3
Q
CD
0
CD
Cl
CD
C)
Y
0
CD
It
Cl)
Ct
CD
H
CD
CD
ct
H-
CD
Cl
ct
0
0
CD
Q
It
CD
C).
CD
CD
ct
•
CD
CD
cC)
H-
H-
Cl)
H-
CD
Ct
Q
CD
tY
-
ct
CD
It
CD
CD
cC)
It
H
0
D
•
H
H
H
CD
0
0
CD
H-
-‘
It
hi
•
CD
C).
H
C
<
Ct
Ct
C).
CD
ci
CD
CD
CD
It
H-
CD
C)
Ct
-<
Ct
It
CD
H
Cl
hi
CD
3
CD
0
H
cC)
CD
CD
<
CD
H
Ct
0
I-H
H
CD
CD
H
3
‘-<
CD
rt
<
X
CD
CD
ct
CD
ct
I—h
H
CD
H-
Cl
hi
CD
It
H-
h
o
o
CD
CD
C).
5
H-
NJ
CD
hi
It
I
H
H-
hi
H,
C)
CD
0
CD
ct
C)
CD
CD
H-
CD
C)
CD
Cl
h-h
CD
CD
H
0
0
H-
çt
0
3
CD
H
I—h
It
H
o
t
0
3
3
CD
0
D
C)
CD
H
-
CD
h-h
J
CD
CD
3
C)
0
CD
CD
CD
<
hi
CD
0
D
C)
0
CD
It
CD
h-h
0
C)
CD
ct
0
Ct
-<
CD
It
0
Cl
It
CD
ct
:3
C)
It
Ct
J
hi
CD
CD
hi
It
3
I—h
CD
3
0
CD
It
o
H-
H
cC)
C).
CD
hi
H-
0
hi
Ct
H
CD
CD
0
It
CD
hi
CD
CD
hi
Cl
CD
It
Ct
CD
tY
It
hi
H
CD
CD
CD
It
H
CD
CD
3
Ct
cC)
It
h-h
Cl
H-
hi
H-
hi
H
<
‘-<
It
CD
H
D
H-
H
CD
0
H-
0
h-h
I-H
H-
i
H-
CD
H-
CD
0
<
hi
CD
CD
0
Q
It
3
I—h
C)
It
CD
0
It
C)
CD
•
hi
Ct
Cl
CD
It
It
‘-<
H
It
CD
Ct
CD
C)
0
CD
H-
H-
H
It
H-
It
C).
cC)
hi
H-
H
H
CD
<
H
CD
CD
C)
CD
Ct
0
CD
C)
H-
H-
It
CD
H-
It
CD
<
CD
CD
CD
It
CD
Cl
0
3
H-
H-
It
Cl)
cC)
C).
I-<
Di
Ct
CD
CD
C)
It
hi
•
0
cC)
CD
hi
H-
It
CD
It
cc
CD
H
CD
CD
CD
H
It
Page 15
1
pipes going out
to
the river,
they can’t divert the
2
storm water and the
sewage into the interceptor,
so
3
it flows
out by gravity
to
the
Chicago area
4
waterways.
5
MR.
ANDES:
So
when
you
talk
-—
to
6
clarify.
When
you
talk
about the gravity
7
CSOs,
it’s the
two main components of the
old
8
CSO system or the pump stations, like
9
Racine Avenue -- enormous
pump stations with
10
a
lot of flow
-- and then several hundred
11
individual
CSO
outfalls; correct?
12
THE WITNESS:
Correct.
13
MR. ANDES:
And
you’re talking
about
a
14
scenario
where you would eliminate every
one
15
of
the several hundred individual
CSO
16
outfalls?
17
THE WITNESS:
Right.
18
BY MS.
WILLIAMS:
19
Q.
But, Ms. Nemura, I
guess
what
I’m
20
getting
at
is,
does
this chart
reflect the modeling
21
that would
happen
without
gravity
CSOs?
But it
22
doesn’t
—- it’s not just gravity
CSO5
that Tarp
is
23
designed
to address; is it?
24
Isn’t Tarp also going
to
address
Page 16
1
the pump station discharges?
2
A.
I’m not familiar
with the specifics of
3
the District’s Tarp program.
4
MR. ANDES:
Is your understanding
that
5
Tarp will
eliminate 100 percent of the
6
gravity
CSOs?
7
THE WITNESS:
No.
8
MR. ANDES:
So this hypothetical is
9
actually very conservative, in terms of
10
assuming that, let’s
see
what would happen
if
11
we
eliminated
every
single one of those
12
several hundred
CSO
outfalls.
13
THE WITNESS:
Correct.
14
So you
can
see that the dash line
15
where that simulation was run, there will
be
16
some wet weather events, even if
you could
17
eliminate the
CSO
discharges
where you would
18
still violate the criteria.
19
BY MS. WILLIAMS:
20
Q.
In the hypothetical
scenarios
that
you
21
eliminate gravity
CSOs, but not the huge volume from
22
the
pump
station discharges; correct?
23
A.
Correct.
24
Q.
Question 32 presents
a quote
from
tJ
M
t\)
H
-
H
i—i
-
-
-
I-’
W
t’J
F-
CD
co
a>
--i
01
C)’
(J
t\)
H
CD
L()
CX)
—J
a>
i
CD
C)
Ft
CD
H
0
X
0
h
0
H-
<1
0
H
CD
Ft
T3
3
CD
1
CD
Cl
F—’
CD
3
‘
CD
CD
[j
H-
CZJ
CD
CD
H-
ct
CD
I
N
CD
Q1
CD
CD
H-
3
rt
I
CD
I-h
Ml
CD
CD
3
3
0
3
h
Q.
CD
0
0
3
F—a
C)
3
H-
•
H-
H-
0
CD
ti
Ft
H
F-
<
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
Ft
CD
CD
F--
I—’
H-
CD
0
rt
CD
I-
1
0
0
II
CD
F-’
5
h-
ct
0
CD
0
I—h
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
)
I
3
0
Fj
CD
CD
it
D
1
I
CD
I-H
C)
ID
C
0
CD
CD
‘C3
CD
Cl)
i
CD
CD
F-
I
CD
•
0
CD
F-
F-’
0
F—’
•
CD
S
rt
Cl
CD
h-
Cl)
Ft
CD
H-
“
it
<
it
Ft
h-
0
CD
it
Ft
HI
CD
H
H-
Hl
CD
D
CD
S
CD
C)
H-
>
it
H-
5
a)
<
I--h
F-
F-I
Z
CD
F-I
H-
F-
CD
CD
0
C)
H-
5
3
F-’
CD
0
J
D
L
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
rt
CD
CD
F-
Ft
0
-<
F-
Cl)
LJ
C)
H-
•
Ft
I—h
CD
H-
Ml
CD
0
Cl)
CD
CD
0
CD
H-
H-I
0
5
Ml
CD
CD
H-
Ft
<1
Q.
Ft
••
D
••
Ft
>s
I-h
H-
H-
Q.
CD
5
CD
Ij
H-
‘-<
CD
CD
S
H-
C)
CD
CD
5
CD
II
CD
CD
0
CD
••
CD
Cl)
F-
D
CD
Q
II
CD
CD
CD
Cl
0
I-I
CD
••
F-
0
Q
CD
H-
C)
I—’
CD
0
II
CD
F-F
CD
•
F—’
CD
CD
•
0
Ft
Ft
H-
1
F-
Ft
CD
•
H-
HI
5
S
0
S
F-
C).
Ft
CD
C)
CD
HI
CD
CD
I--h
F-
<
CD
CD
CD
CD
5
Ft
Z
H-
1
Ft
C)
H-
‘-<
I--s
C).
CD
Cl
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
H
Cl
S
CD
CD
CD
5
0
CD
Ft
CD
CD
CD
5
0
Cl
CD
5
0
C)
Ml
F-
0
H
I-F
Cl
CD
CD
S
S
‘-<
CD
•
Ft
H-
X
Cl
CD
I—F
U-
5
Ft
Cl
•x)
Ft
0
Ft
-<
0
CD
<
CD
H-
I
‘s
Ft
D
CD
CD
CD
Q
S
CD
Ml
CD
I
CD
Ft
F-F
H-
CD
F-F
CD
<
Ml
F—’
Ft
S
Ft
CD
CD
3
0
0
H-I
‘-<
0
CD
II
C)
S
CD
I—F
C)
Q
Ft
Cl
,Q
CD
Ft
C)
0
CD
D
CD
Ij
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
H-
CD
‘-<
I-F
CD
Ft
S
,Q
CD
S
S
S
CD
F-F
CD
CD
CD
H-
0
Ft
Ft
CD
tQ
S
CD
5
Ft
CD
C)
Ft
CD
-<
Cl
Ft
H-
Ft
CD
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
S
0
0
•
Ft
H-
CD
0
0
5
CD
S
CD
C)
CD
CD
H-
CD
Ft
0
Ft
S
CD
H-
CD
LQ
CD
5
II
CD
CD
CD
CD
Cl
-<
HI
N.)
N.)
N)
N..)
N..)
H
F-
H
i-
H
H
-
-
H
-
(i
NJ
F
CD
co
0)
-J
0)
Ui
U)
N..)
I-’
C)
co
0)
-J
0)
Ui
U)
N.)
I-
T
CD
H
Q.
it
h’
-
C)
CD
Di
C)
it
C)
it
it
it
H
CD
Di
0
H-
CD
CD
C
C)
0
Di
J
0
Di
I-
1
0
D
H
h
-<
Hi
CD
CD
d
-
C)
cQ
CD
it
Cl
CD
1<
0
CD
Hi
H-
‘-
Hi
CD
-1
0
D
it
CD
CD
H-
Di
CD
o
H
CD
CD
Dl
0
CD
Cl
H-
Hi
3
Di
0
CD
1
Cl
CD
II
-
1
Q
H-
Di
t
H-
it
CD
cQ
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
C)
C)
CD
it
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
o
CD
C)
D
Q.
H
Di
Di
it
Q
CD
H
0
Hi
H
it
H-
it
H-
0
0
CD
Q.
H
is
0
CD
[-
H-
CD
H-
CD
3
CD
CD
‘
H
C)
CD
it
Li
it
H-
CD
Hi
it
0
II
CD
it
<
0
CD
it
H-
F-
0
‘t5
0
D
CD
Di
CD
Hi
0
3
H
1
<
0
0
H-
Hi
CD
h
Di
C)
CD
[-
CD
Cl
Di
0
H-
CD
Hi
1-H
Q
CD
cQ
C)
it
CD
Hi
it
CD
H-
CD
L<
it
CD
H
H
•
I-
C).
H-
Di
Di
C)
H-
H-
CD
Q
Q
C)
3
CD
H-
CD
it
Z
Cl
it
Di
H-
CD
it
D
L<
it
CD
<
C)
CD
‘C3
it
t3
C)
0
C3
L’J
CD
CD
H-
Di
H-
J
CD
H-
CD
3
H
CD
I-’
it
3
CD
CD
Cl)
<
CD
CD
0
CD
tY
<1
-
CD
it
CD
C).
0
•
C)
CD
0
0
Di
CD
CD
CD
C)
H-
cC)
it
H-
•.
[1
CD
H
Di
‘
H-
<
Hi
CD
H-
hI
0
CD
H-
CD
1
CD
it
F-
Di
H
CD
3
0
Di
CD
CD
CD
cC)
CD
CD
hI
Hi
H
Di
CD
Di
it
i
it
it
‘j
0
CD
H
Q
Di
Di
CD
Hi
D
3
it
H
•
C)
D
0
II
H-
Di
H-
d
it
Di
CD
CD
H-
CD
Cl
it
Cl
CD
Hi
H-
hI
Di
hI
it
0
F-
CL
C)
hI
t)
3
><
Di
CD
C)
CD
C)
CD
CD
CD
L<
it
CD
cC)
t5
Cl
it
Di
Di
CD
Hi
it
it
0
hI
<
CD
it
0
it
H
CD
CD
it
H
cC)
it
cC)
5
C).
it
it
CD
-I
it
Di
CD
Di
CD
CD
it
Dl
CD
0
cC)
CD
J
Di
CD
Di
<
H
H
Hi
3
CD
CD
CD
H
CD
Cl
it
‘T3
H-
0
hI
Di
Cl
Cl
CD
0
it
CD
H-
CD
<
H
CD
it
hI
CD
CD
Di
it
Di
0
o
hI
0
it
hI
0
it
0
CD
Di
CD
hI
0
H-
H
H
CD
C)
0
3
it
CD
l
Q
Di
H-
CD
Di
CD
CD
0
Cl
cC)
Hi
0
I
hI
0
Di
0
CD
it
it
H
cC)
CD
hI
it
3
hI
hI
C
Hi
0
I
CD
hI
hI
Di
Cl
CD
CD
Di
Cl
H-
0
0
H
hI
Hi
CD
<
C)
CD
Di
it
it
it
Di
C
3
Cl
0
CD
0
3
0
o
o
it
CD
it
C)
it
3
H
Di
Di
C
<
CD
Di
hI
hI
it
it
it
-
0
Di
hI
3
it
H-
H
it
it
it
it
it
Di
<
CD
J
it
Di
it
C)
Cl
it
Cl
C
Di
o
CD
3
CD
Cl
Di
Di
CD
3
Di
Cl
H-
Di
hI
‘-
it
3
Cl
C)
it
H-
3
cC)
Cl
H-
0
H-
it
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
CD
CD
M
F’J
M
N)
N)
H
F-
-
F-
I-
F-’
F-
I—’
(i
N)
I-’
0
co
a)
—J
a)
(ii
U)
N)
I-’
0
ç
a)
a-
o’
N)
i—’
J
CD
H-
cC)
H
çt
c-t
Di
CD
CD
Di
Ci
CD
0
ct
Di
U
ct
fr
H-
Ci
I-
0
D
0
Ci
Ci
D
Ci
‘t5
Ci
Hi
Ci
H-
Di
Ci
Ci
0
ct
Hi
C)
CD
0
cC)
H
CD
CD
Ci
CD
H
rt
CD
Cl)
0
Di
rt
CD
0
-<
Ft
H
cC)
Ci
CD
II
Ft
‘Ci
H
H
CD
ii
H-
H-
Ft
CD
-
Ft
)
Ci
Q.
CD
H
CD
h
I—’
0
h
CD
Ft
C)
CD
0
C)
CD
CD
CD
ct
CD
CD
Di
C)
H-
Ci
Q.
Ct
Di
Di
Ft
Ft
0
Ft
Di
Ft
Di
Dl
L<
Di
i—
H-
H-
CD
Ft
Di
‘t
Ci
CD
Ci
CD
CD
Ci
CD
C3
CD
Ci
H
0
ct
0
Hi
<1
C)
H-
Ci
0
Ci
0
Ci
Di
CD
Ci
Q
h
CD
Ci
H-
Hi
CD
H-
0
a
C)
Dl
CD
ct
çt
<
L<
çt
CD
C)
0
CD
Hi
Ci
H
Hi
CD
Ci
0
CD
Di
0
Ci
Ci
C).
0
H-
CD
CD
Di
Dl
Ft
H-
CD
C/)
Cl
Dl
L<
Ft
Di
H-
CD
Hi
C)
C)
Ci
CD
Ft
0
C)
H
Ft
D
C).
‘Ci
0
ct
CD
Ci
H-
H
CD
Ci
0
Q
Ci
CD
-
CD
0
Dl
CD
CD
CD
Ci
CD
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
C)
Ci
II
C)
ct
ct
Di
H-
H-
h’
Di
3
H
çt
0
Di
Di
0
CD
Ci
ct
Ci
Cl
Di
CD
H
CD
CD
H-
Cl
3
Cl
Ci
çt
I—
ID
0
Ci
Cl
H
0
Ft
Di
Ci
Cl
0
Ft
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
H-
CD
Ci
H
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
ct
C)
Ft
Di
çt
CD
0
Ci
3
H
Ft
CD
Ft
()
Cl
C)
CD
çt
Ci
H-
0
‘T
H-
Ci
CD
H-
H
Ci
0
-
Di
CD
H-
CD
H-
C)
H-
0
<
0
Ci
H
ct
cC)
CD
H
Cl
0
CD
C)
Di
Ci
0
<
Ft
CD
H-
C)
ct
0
Ci
ID
Ci
<
CD
C)
X
CD
H-
CD
Ci
CD
CD
Ci
CD
3
CD
H-
CD
0
CD
Di
0
Ci
-<
CD
ct
CD
H
CD
cC)
CD
CD
CD
II
<
H-
Cl
-<
Hi
H-
cC)
0
CD
Ci
Cl
Cl
D
Ci
ct
CD
ID
Hi
Ft
CD
ct
-,
C)
CD
Hi
Di
H
Hi
Ci
CD
C)
II
0
Di
1
0
0
0
Dl
Ci
Ft
Ct
Ft
b
0
Hi
CD
‘Ci
H-
CD
C)
H
0
Cl
X
Hi
X
cC)
Hi
Ci
0
CD
CD
tY
CD
CD
‘Cl
ct
C)
0
H-
L<
h
<
0
C)
H-
Di
H
II
CD
Ft
<
CD
CD
0
ct
H
cC)
0
cQ
C)
CD
Ft
0
Cl
Ci
CD
X
0
-
Di
C)
Ft
—
Di
Ci
H
CD
CD
Di
Ci
Ci
Ci
CD
CD
CD
‘t
C)
h
Ci
CD
Ft
CD
Ci
Ci
Ii
C).
-<
H
<
CD
CD
H-
0
ct
CD
Di
C)
CD
Di
CD
çt
Di
CD
H-
C)
0
Cl
CD
Cl
ct
CD
Ci
Di
Ci
Ci
Ft
Ft
Ft
F-
h
I
it
Cl
Di
Ft
Di
Ci
H
Ci
CD
CD
L<
CD
CD
CD
0
C)
CD
H-
Ci
Y
0
CD
Cl
‘
Ci
Ft
Hi
CD
Hi
Di
it
C/)
0
h
CD
T
I
CD
0
Ci
H-
Ft
h-
Ci
Cl
0
Di
Dl
Ci
Cl
CD
Ft
H-
cC)
Ft
Di
CD
H-
0
Di
H
Ci
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
C).
0
Cl
0
Ft
Ci
Di
Ft
0
Cl
CD
•
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
H-
0
0
Ci
Ft
H-
h-
CD
I-i
Di
Di
Ft
Ci
Ci
3
Cl
Di
Ci
Ci
C)
co
-<
Ft
Ft
Ci
cC)
H
Di
c<
Ii
H-
Di
cC)
Di
U)
Ft
Di
H-
Ci
0
CD
Ci
Ft
‘-<
0
cQ
Ci
CD
Ci
CD
Di
CD
Di
CD
cC)
0
CD
Ci
Ci
H-
Ci
h
Ft
CD
Ci
Cl
Page 20
1
to
protect.
2
MR. ANDES:
And
we have two reports
3
that Ms. Nemura
is referring
to.
The first
4
one is
Behavioral Response
of
Fish
Larvae
to
5
Low Dissolved Oxygen
Concentrations in
a
6
Stratified
Water Colony.
7
MS. TIPSORD: And
that
article is
by
8
D.L.
Wreitburg, from
Marine Biology 1994.
9
If
there’s no objection, we will
10
enter
this
as
Exhibit 202. Seeing none,
it’s
11
Exhibit 202.
12
(WHEREUPON,
a certain document
13
was
marked Exhibit
14
No. 202 for identification,
as of
15
2/17/09.)
16
MR. ANDES:
The second report, titled
17
The
Influence of Fish Size on the Avoidance
18
of Hypoxia and Oxygen Selection
by
Large
19
Mouth Bass.
20
MS.
TIPSORD:
And this is from the
21
Journal
of Fish Biology 2001. If there’s
22
objection, we will mark this
as
Exhibit
203.
23
Seeing none, it’s Exhibit
203.
24
Page
21
1
(WHEREUPON,
a
certain
document
2
was
marked
Exhibit
3
No.
203
for
identification,
as
of
4
2/17/09.)
5
BY
MS.
WILLIAMS:
6
Q.
So,
Ms.
Nemura,
can
you
tell
us
7
whether
this
Exhibit
202
addresses
Channel
Catfish
8
or
Large
Mouth
Bass?
9
A.
They
do
address
Large
Mouth
Bass.
10
Q.
And
202?
11
MR.
ANDES:
Can
we
take
a
copy
back
of
12
202?
Do
you
have
an
extra?
13
MS.
TIPSORD:
Actually,
yes.
There’s
14
some
right
there.
15
BY
THE
WITNESS:
16
A.
No,
I’m
sorry,
Exhibit
202
provides
17
references
that
do
discuss
the
phenomenon
that
I
was
18
talking
about.
And
I
don’t
know
whether
those
19
specific
references
would
—-
the
studies
included
20
the Large
Mouth
Bass.
21
Exhibit
202
is
related
to
two
22
species,
the
Naked
Goby
and
the
Bay
Anchovy.
And
it
23
specifically
addressed
larvae,
which
are
sensitive,
24
as
well
as
the
adult
Naked
Gobies
that
could
Page
22
1
tolerate
.7
milligrams
per
liter
DO
for
seven
hours
2
or
less.
3
BY
MS.
WILLIAMS:
4
Q.
Do we
have
the
entire
document
in
5
front
of
us?
6
A.
It
appears
that
that
is
not
the
entire
7
document.
But
we
can
make
that
available.
8
MR.
ANDES:
We
can
certainly
provide
9
the
entire
document
if
that
--
people
want
to
10
read
it.
11
BY
THE
WITNESS:
12
A.
But
the
gist
of
this
study
is
you
have
13
a
dissolved
oxygen
gradient.
And
the
question
was
14
whether
the
low
DO
that
are
present
in
those
15
gradients
could
be
tolerated
by
fish.
16
BY
MS.
WILLIAMS:
17
Q.
Would
you
agree,
Ms.
Nemura,
that
once
18
you
determine ——
well,
first
of
all,
how
would
you
19
determine
the
list
of
potential
fish
species
that
20
you’d
be
looking
at
under
the methodology
that
you
21
just
described?
22
A.
How
would
I
determine
it?
23
Q.
Uh-huh.
24
A.
You
would
look
at
the
--
as
part
of
r”J
N)
N)
N)
N)
I-
l-
F
F-
I-’
l-
F—i
l-
H-
(J
N)
)-
C)
D
C)
—.J
oi
U’
S
U’
N)
H
C’
co
0)
-J
0
U’
U’
N)
F-’
Cl
Y
a
CD
H-
D
CD
0
CD
CD
Cl)
t-h
CD
C)
CD
ct
Hi
Ft
CD
i
CD
CD
CD
CD
C
Q
F-
h-
çt
Ii
CD
Cl)
CD
I—’
CD
CD
h
CD
CD
Ft
0
H-
Ft
L<
F--’
D
•
Ft
Hi
Ft
i
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
Cl)
CD
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
,Q
CD
Ft
i
0
C
L.Q
CD
CD
H-
Cl
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
Hi
CD
3
CD
Ft
C
3
C
ti
H-
•
CD
1
H-
Ft
Ft
F-’
CD
CD
<
CD
0
Cl)
Cl
CD
Ft
i-H
•
C)
CD
‘
CD
Ft
CD
D
H
Cl
C)
C/)
CD
Ft
Ft
t
0
Ft
CD
Cl)
Ft
H-
C
ti
CD
3
CD
CD
CD
CD
D
Ft
F-’
Cl)
t
CD
Ft
F-
Ft
H
i—’
3
“3
Ft
-<
ti
CD
0
N)
Ft
D
CD
tQ
h
H-
H-
Cl)
Cl)
CD
I-I
3
Ft
CD
3
H-
CD
CD
0
H-
0
H
II
ti
C/)
Ft
F-
C)
CD
Ft
Ft
C/)
H-
CD
CD
-<
Q
H
CD
CD
Ft
0
t
C)
“
Ft
C
CD
CD
‘C
CD
H-
LQ
<
Cl)
CD
Ft
Cl)
0
0
CD
0
C
I
Q
C
‘Cl
CD
I
H-
0
C
F-
CD
l-
CD
C
CD
Cl
F-
CD
tI
Ft
Q
F—’
C/)
CD
CD
Cl
Ft
C/)
F
CD
H-
H-
CD
H-
Ft
3
CD
0
CD
Ft
Hi
CD
Hi
CD
h
CD
C)
0
Ft
Hi
Cl)
0
Cl
Ft
0
C
Cl
CD
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
Hi
CD
H-
Ft
ti
CD
F-’
Ij
h-
II
<
CD
Ft
0
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
3
CD
‘C
CD
0
CD
H
H-
h
CD
h
C/)
CD
0
CD
CD
i-
CD
CD
0
Cl)
CD
H-
<
CD
H-
1
DCl’
CD
CD
CD
Q
Ft
CJ
Ft
CD
C/)
3
H
CD
•
C
Cl
F-
•
CD
H-
CD
F-’
CD
H-
Ft
CD
-<
CD
C)
0
C
i
3
CD
Ft
C)
CD
Ft
H-
CD
Ft
.Q
Ft
H-
0
H-
CD
Ft
CD
CD
C
Cl)
Cl)
0
CD
CD
H-
H-
CD
Ft
C!)
F—’
CD
Hi
Ft
3
Ft
-<
Cl
D
Ft
Hi
C
CD
0
‘-<
Ft
0
H-
H-
Ft
CD
Ft
0
Cl
Hi
C
0
3
J
C
Ft
0
II
CD
h
‘-<
Hi
C
CD
CD
F-
CD
F-
CD
CD
CD
-
CD
Cl
Ft
0
Ft
CD
Ft
C)
0
II
Cl
Cl
•
Q
ii
r
CD
0
Ft
Ft
C
CD
H-
-<
H-
CD
CD
D
D
H-
CD
F-’
Ft
C/)
0
CD
Cl)
H-
H-
0
Ft
Cl
Ft
0
CD
C
Ft
H-
Ft
C)
3
II
0
CD
Cl
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
‘-<
t3
F—’
CD
CD
Ft
Q
0
CD
CD
H-
11
<
Q
H-
0
3
Ft
Hi
CD
3
0
CD
I-
CD
Ft
Ft
Ft
1
H-
Cl
)
Ft
Cl
CD
-<
CD
CD
Ft
H-
CD
CD
CD
Hi
Ft
CD
ii
C)
Ft
Ft
C)
0
Hi
H-
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
0
0
Ft
X
Ft
CD
CD
H-
CD
‘-<
CD
CD
H-
CD
H-
CD
‘13
Ft
Q
CD
F-
CD
C
CD
<
CD
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
C)
‘C
C
CD
Ft
C)
C)
F-’
Ft
0
0
CD
H-
<
CD
H-
0
C
CD
C)
3
C
C)
Ft
CD
I-I
CD
3
CD
C)
0
II
C)
F-
H-
CD
H-
CD
Cl
Ft
Ft
CD
H-
CD
Cl
CD
F-
CD
C
CD
“3
Ft
Ft
CD
F-’
CD
L<
Q
C)
CD
<
‘
CD
Y
CD
Hi
Ft
CD
CD
I-
0
CD
I—-’
•
H
F-
CD
H-
C
CD
CD
Hi
CD
Hi
F—’
i
CD
-
H-
CD
0
H-
C)
CD
Cl
t
Ft
l-<
CD
-
0
H-
L<
CD
CD
Q
Q
Hi
Ft
0
CD
Ft
C
Ft
H-
C
Cl
F—’
Ft
3
CD
Ft
-
0
F-
CD
C)
CD
LQ
CD
Cl
i
CD
CD
<
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
Ft
CD
C
CD
Ft
Hi
0
CD
x
CD
I
F-
CD
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
N)
t\)
N)
N)
N)
-
I-
I-
-
—
F
i—’
I—i
U)
N)
C)
cc
C)
C)
(Si
U)
N)
H
C)
cc
cc
—J
c
Ui
U)
N)
H
CD
()
U.
Hi
iQ
CD
C)
Q.
Ft
Q.
I—a
CD
C)
><
çi
CD
Ci
0
CD
Ci
0
H-
0
H-
H-
CD
CD
Ft
L<
CD
C)
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
Ci
CD
CD
Ci
CD
<
‘<
Ft
Ci
Q
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
Ci
CD
F-
CD
II
F-
CD
CD
H
CD
CD
0
Ft
F-
Ft
Cl
0
CD
Cl
0
L<
F-
3
h
H-
CD
1
0
H-
H-
-
F-’
Ft
cQ
o
F-
CD
CD
0
CD
0
I-
<
-H
<
5
10
Ci
‘<
3
C)
3
H-
Cl)
0
CD
Cl)
Ft
Ci
CD
Ft
CD
CD
<
Q.
Cl
Ii
CD
Ci
D
D
H-
0
Ft
CD
H-
0
Cl)
CD
CD
C)
CD
CD
CD
Ft
Ci
0
0
C)
0
Ft
<
3
CD
CD
CD
H-
II
H
Ft
<
CD
CD
H
<
0
Cl
Ft
Hi
CD
-‘
Ft
CD
CD
CD
Ft
CD
CD
cQ
H-
0
H
Ft
<
CD
F
Z
ii
CD
Cl)
CD
Ci
uJ
Cl)
CD
H-
0
Cl)
Q.
CD
CD
CD
C)
0
CD
3
0
Ft
H-
3
3
CD
0
C)
3’
Ft
Cl
CD
LQ
Ft
3
CD
CD
CD
H-
C)
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
-<
3’
Cl
3’
<
<
Ft
‘-<
3
CD
cQ
C/)
Hi
H-
C)
l
Ft
CD
F<
0
CD
CD
W
Ft
0
0
<
•
L<
3
CD
0
H-
CD
H-
CD
I
0
Ci
Ft
Ft
Ci
•
Ci
Ci
0
-
3
C)
CD
Hi
Ij
I
CD
3’
Ci
CD
Ft
Ci
tY
Ft
C)
CD
H
CD
0
CD
H-
-
-i
p—i
3
3
CD
L<
L<
F—’
0
•
1
H-
H-
CD
Ft
iQ
h
CD
‘-<
CD
CD
Q.
Ft
3
H
Ft
‘-
3
Hi
3
CD
H-
0
CD
CD
CD
Ft
CD
3’
‘-<
CD
CD
CD
Hi
CD
3
Ci
Cl
Cl
Ft
CD
C)
0
<
Ft
CD
I-I
CD
Ft
CD
CD
H
CD
H-
h
CD
CD
Ci
I
Cl
0
3
3
CD
CD
H-
3
Ft
Ft
Fj
CD
F-
0
H-
Cl
Cl
3’
Ci
H-
3’
-<
Ft
cQ
Q
0
0
Hi
CD
l
Ft
CD
Cl
CD
3
3
0
H-
t5
h
Ci
H-
H-
CD
D
CD
C)
Ft
Cl
cQ
0
3
H-
L<
CC)
‘tI
Cl
3
CD
‘T3
CD
0
Y’
0
CD
CD
cQ
3
H-
3
CD
1
Cl)
Cl)
3
H-
H-
Ft
I-
CD
Ci
CD
Ii
Ft
L<
CD
cC)
3
CD
Ft
0
Ft
H
C)
H-
<
H-
Ft
H
CD
3
0
H-
H-
cC)
Ft
H-
Ft
CD
‘Ti
<
C)
CD
Ft
Cl
CD
Ft
CD
Ci
Hi
H-
0
CD
1
3’
o
CD
Cl
3
C)
0
Ft
F-
Ft
Ft
i-ti
3
C)
H
CD
F-
-
I-H
H-
0
H
CD
0
H-
Ft
H-
C)
Ci
CD
0
CD
CD
Cl
0
Cl)
CD
CD
Ft
3
H
CD
Cl
CD
<
‘Ti
CD
3’
0
Ii
CD
3
0
Ft
CD
CD
3
H-
X
<
I—’
CD
II
H-
CD
0
H
Ft
CD
CD
cC)
0
CD
0
0
Ft
3
3’
CD
Ci
CD
CD
H-
H-
<
CD
CD
Ft
L<
Ft
Hi
CD
CD
Cl
3
CD
0
CD
3’
CD
o
o
0
‘Ti
3
H-
Cl)
C)
Ft
Ft
CD
Cl
‘c
Ci
-‘•
CD
3
3
Ci
H
H
•
0
3
C)
Hi
0
I
•
F—’
Ft
<
CD
Hi
cC)
Ft
H-
h
H-
Hi
Ft
Ft
Cl
CD
C)
C)
Ft
CD
CD
h
“<
Ft
H-
3
0
CD
Q
Q
3’
0
Cl
0
0
H-
H-i
3’
CD
0
•
CD
CD
•
F—’
Ci
CD
Ci
Hi
Ft
CD
0
C)
Ci
3’
H-
3
F-
rc
3
F—’
-.
Ft
i-I
<1
0
CD
Cl
CD
Cl
CD
Ft
F-’
CD
C)
cC)
3
Ft
‘-<
Ft
CD
CD
3
FtCD
N)
t’J
NJ
NJ
N)
NJ
H
-
H
I-
H
-
F
F
NJ
F
0
cc
0)
J
a
U’
a
w
r”i
i-
o
—J
U,
J
(i
NJ
F
it
C).
it
h
Di
<
H-
C).
0
H-
CD
0
CD
H-
H-
Q
0
3
0
CD
CD
ct
CD
H
I-I
$3
Di
$3
0
it
CD
CD
Di
CD
Di
it
it
0
a
CD
it
ct
a
ct
cC)
CD
F-
0
1
H-
H-
CD
CD
CD
<1
H-
CD
CD
C)
H-
it
CD
3
$0
it
0
TJ
3
it
CD
CD
$0
•
CD
0.
H
it
(D
F-
3
[-
Di
0
H-
C)
H-
it
0
i.Q
II
H
$-
H-
H-
<
H-
CD
0
CD
H-
3
[—1
I
<
‘-<
it
it
H
<1
CD
I
CD
cQ
CD
CD
$3
CD
CD
CD
D
Q
-
0
F—’
it
CD
0
F-I
IjJ
Cn
xJ
FJJ
CD
3
0
0
H-
3
H-
CD
CD
it
D
$3
$3
0
H-
CD
H-
C)
h
Di
C)
cC)
CD
3
Di
I—a
it
t
cC)
C)
C)
CD
F—a
1
<
h
CD
CD
it
a
Di
D
C)
CD
H-
0
CD
it
it
3
FH
Di
0
Ii
H-
I
0
it
$3
H-
<
it
$3
C)
0
L<
$3
it
3
‘t5
CD
3
Di
3
I
$3
•
CD
L<
CD
CD
CD
it
0
it
Dl
$3
Di
cC)
CD
o
CD
‘-
i
a
$3
H
I—’
Di
3
$3
H-
H-
II
-
it
Di
<
Di
3
H-
CD
‘-<
CD
,Q
0
it
H-
Di
CD
0
<
3
J
‘-<
CD
it
a
it
CD
0
H
$3
5
CD
Di
it
CD
Di
Di
H
H-
Di
$3
H
CD
o
Di
cC)
CD
it
it
CD
0
it
H-
-
CD
it
$3
it
3
0
Ii
C)
a
-
CD
•
3
it
it
H
CD
ci
CD
it
CD
H-
CD
-•
Di
H-
CD
i—i
H-
CD
a
<
C)
F-
CD
it
CD
C)
it
CD
CD
0
CD
0
CD
a
it
CD
H
0
C)
a
3
CD
$3
CD
it
3
it
H
0
H-
it
0
1
0
Di
-
CD
H-
Di
-c
-
Cn
3
$3
CD
3
0
<
Hc
Di
3
Di
it
H-
CD
CD
H
5
CD
H
CD
-
Di
it
CD
CD
I-
<
it
3
it
CD
CD
it
-c
0.
CD
it
CD
-<
0
ci
CD
C)
3
CD
3
CD
a
‘LI
it
CD
a
H-
-
it
CD
it
I
$5
CD
5
it
<1
3
CD
cC)
3
•‘J
CD
H-
I
0
it
0
0
CD
CD
•
it
3
Di
H-
Di
CD
3
$5
CD
CD
it
CD
it
it
it
ci
a
cC)
i—I
CD
it
$5
CD
C)
Di
CD
H
it
‘LI
0
5
C)
‘5
D
hI
0
it
it
c<
D
Di
3
it
cC)
C)
CD
H-
it
0
Di
0
1
‘
0
Di
Di
H-
0
CD
3
ci
0
CD
3
H-
it
it
C)
I-I
Di
ci
it
3
‘5
•
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
CD
CD
CD
‘-<
it
-
Di
it
CD
‘LI
0
a
cC)
C)
CD
C)
0
it
a
CD
t
Di
CD
H
NI
it
CD
it
ci
Di
0
Di
I
‘j
3
H-
CD
1h
•
H-
•3
<
it
CD
I
H-
Di
F-I
C)
•
0
it
H-,
3
CD
NI
Di
Dl
-I
D
0
Dl
Di
CD
Di
CD
‘-<
it
cC)
O
CD
NI
<1
3
it
CD
CD
CD
CD
0.
H-
a
CD
CD
Page
26
1
Q.
Which
we
have
already
determined,
2
already
settled?
3
A.
Yes.
4
Q.
You
agree?
5
A.
Yes.
6
I
think
that’s
all
I was
trying
to
get
7
at,
thank
you.
8
MS.
TIPSORD:
Any
additional
9
follow-up,
Mr.
Andes?
10
MR.
ANDES:
No.
11
MS.
TIPSORD:
Dr.
Lin
has
a
question.
12
DR.
LIN:
You
talk
about
fish
species
13
important
to
DO.
How
about
the
nitrate
14
content
in
fish
--
is
very
important
for
fish
15
species.
Do
you
consider
this
problem?
16
MR.
ANDES:
Are
you
talking
about
17
nitrate
or
nitrogen?
18
MR.
LIN:
Nitrate
and
nitrogen,
same
19
thing.
20
THE
WITNESS:
Okay.
You
would
also
21
need
to
look
at
appropriate
ammonia
and
22
nitrogen
criteria,
because
there
can
be
23
toxicity
with
that.
24
On
the
general
question
of
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
F-
F-’
l-
F-’
I—’
F
H
I—’
W
NJ
I-’
C)
0
CX)
Ci
(3’
(3)
NJ
H
0
(31
(i
NJ
F-’
Di
H
Dl
L<
CD
H
Mi
Cl)
Q
H
h
Di
Di
H-
ct
‘Ti
Di
Di
H-
Cl
‘TJ
L<
It
Di
It
3
It
•
LJ
3
3
<
Di
‘TI
II
3
3
CD
Di
0
0
L<
3
Hi
><
15
‘Ti
CD
0
(1)
It
15
0)
QI
ct
CD
0
H
H-
It
CD
ct
is
Di
F-
It
H-
II
Di
Cl
It
It
is
3
t’i
15
0
CD
15
H-
3
0
CD
H-
CD
J
0
Di
0
0
‘TI
E
CD
CD
CD
Di
CD
••
3
It
Hi
Hi
5
Di
Di
Q.
3
D
<
H-
•
I
3
H-
N-I
I-H
H-
rI-
C)
C/)
It
H-
CD
Di
It
3
CD
C/)
Di
H-,
It
Di
CD
5
<
H-,
It
ct
Cl)
it
0
3
•
‘-<
H-
3
It
Ii
It
Di
0
H-
CD
H-
CD
3i
It
D
3
It
Di
Cl)
Di
CD
It
0
CD
3
3
3
3
Di
CD
H-
F-
Di
C3
It
D
It
Di
0
>
CD
Cl
Di
Cl
It
0
Di
3
‘-<
F-’
L2i
H-
CD
3
‘-<
Mi
3
CD
Di
Di
c
-
I—h
0
‘s
X
Cl
Di
i-h
c
Di
Q.
•
It
F-’
3
II
Di
Di
H
•
3
0
It
H-,
Y
Di
Cl
Di
CD
It
H-,
L<
Q
Di
Di
Di
ti
I-H
Cl
0
Ii
It
0
It
Di
‘-<
i-h
3
0
0
0
<1
Q.
H-
0
0
5
It
‘Ti
Di
It
‘TI
CD
H
•
I5
CD
Di
CD
Cl
Di
CD
F-
It
3
H-
C)
C)
It
-‘
3
Si
3
Cl
It
H-
II
Di
CD
Di
C)
It
D
It
Di
)
CD
It
CD
Di
CD
3
It
Di
Di
CD
0
‘ii
C
Di
It
CD
<
It
-
F-
3
F-
I-h
0
0
CD
CD
F-
CD
t
C)
I
H-
It
F-
It
H-
H-
F-
Di
is
It
Di
CD
is
Si
I
3
Q
Di
3
3
It
CD
,X)
H-
Di
3
3
II
Di
CD
‘
CD
is
5
C)
H-
k<
Di
Di
CD
H-
H-
3
D
0
Di
CD
Di
CD
<
C)
0
It
F-
F-’
3
It
0
CD
Di
F-
‘TI
It
Di
Di
Si
‘-<
Di
CD
5
Si
CD
F-
It
CD
CD
D
is
CD
It
Di
It
C)
is
‘-<
Di
H-
F-
Cl
Di
3
F-
<
Dl
0
3
H-
CD
C3
0
H-
Di
3
Cl
Di
3
-,
F-
CD
It
Cl
H-
Di
Si
0
3
CD
,Q
Si
Di
D
3
C)
F-
Si
Di
It
‘TI
3
It
X
Si
0
Di
It
F-
It
CD
It
Di
‘-<
C)
Di
CD
It
CD
H-
Si
It
3
0
0
3
Di
0
0
It
3’
II
CD
Di
Di
3
F-
CD
0
Di
Mi
Si
H-
CD
F-h
•
is
It
3
C)
Cl
It
H-
It
It
<I
3
It
Di
0
H-
It
F-
C)
CD
It
3
Di
H-
Si
It
is
0
Si
D
CD
Di
D
<
CD
F-
0
It
It
H-
3
It
Cl
CD
H-
It
0
Si
‘-<
is
CD
‘-<
‘-<
It
•.i
0
CD
C)
is
‘-<
Si
F-
Di
F-
H-
Di
0
0
Di
Di
It
CD
0
15
CD
CD
Cl
0
CD
It
Si
Si
Di
Si
i-h
3
3
•
It
Di
It
0
CD
CD
is
CD
It
It
Di
CD
3
3
F-
3
Di
It
-
is
CD
CD
CD
CD
Cl
It
Di
3
3
CD
is
0
It
It
CD
CD
i-h
NJ
NJ
U)
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
H
CD
I-
CD
(ii
Dl
Ft
CD
[1
Di
CD
i—i
I_
Ui
I-
I—’
NJ
[-
CD
CD
—J
CD
U’
H
H
Ft
CD
Il
CD
Ui
NJ
cii
Exi
z
cli
U)
Ci)
Di
Ml
Ml
CD
C)
Ft
CD
a
L<
CD
Ft
CD
Di
Ft
CD
Il
a
H
Cl)
C)
Di
CD
Cl)
CD
CD
Ft
Cl)
x
x
H
a
H-
Cl)
C)
Di
CD
Cl)
Di
II
CD
0
H
Ft
0
H
Di
C)
Ft
C)
0
a
H-
Ft
H
0
Cl)
H-
Ft
H
Ft
CD
Cl)
CD
C)
H
Ml
H-
C)
Di
H-
Ft
CD
Cl)
CD
C)
Ft
Ft
0
Ft
CD
Ft
:
o
ci
Di
Di
Ft
C)
C)
Ft
o
CD
Ft
ci
Cl)
Ml
CD
o
Cl)
II
Di
Ft
:i
a
CD
Ft
U)
Hl
0
Di
CD
C)
Ft
C)
0
II
ci
Ft
H
Ft
Di
CD
CD
Ft
hc
CD
H-
a
Ft
Di
Ft
0
Cl)
0
Cl)
ci
CD
0
I
ci
I
E
CD
a
H-
Ft
CD
CD
CD
-‘
Di
Di
Ft
L<
H
0
ci
CD
ci
Di
Ft
H-
Di
i
CD
a
H-
Di
Cl)
<
C)
CD
Di
Di
Q
Cl)
CD
-<
Cl)
Cl)
Ft
KD
ci
CD
Cl)
Ft
H
0
z
0
01
o
0
ci
Ft
a
Cl)
ci
Di
L.C)
F—’
CD
o
Cl)
Ft
H
Ml
i
H-
iQ
Cl)
Ft
Di
H-
Ft
H
Ft
Cl)
CD
0
CD
o
i
ci
C)
H
L<
a
Di
a
0
CD
Ft
CD
:i
Cl)
Ft
Ft
Di
Ml
ci
H-
a
Cl)
Di
ci.-
M
a
Ml
Cl)
Il
0
Ft
Di
Ft
Di
Q
fr
0
CD
H-
Di
ci
Di
Ft
Ft
0
CD
F-
Di
:1
a
Di
0
Ft
ci
Ft
Cl)
ci
CD
CD
Cl)
Di
Cl)
ci
a
0
ii
C)
a
H-
Ft
CD
CD
tc
H-
Di
Di
Ft
Ft
Ml
Di
0
H-
I-
ci
Di
Ft
F-’
CD
CD
C)
ci.-
H
C)
1
Di
a
0
:l)
H
UJ
C/)
0
cii
0
II
CD
Ml
H
CD
a
ci
CD
Cl)
Ft
H
0
ci
z
0
01
cii
ci
Ft
ci.-
Di
Ft
Di
Cl)
Dl
H
ci
H-
Cl)
Ft
ci.-
Di
Ft
0
ci
H
H
H-
CD
H-
CD
ci
F—’
tQ
Cl)
H-
Ft
ci
0
Di
H
[1
ci
CD
C)
Di
H’
Cl)
ii
a
0
CD
Ml
H-
Ft
ci
ci.-
a
CD
H
C)
CD
ci
0
U)
ci
Cl)
a
ci
Di
t
H-
ci
ci
Di
Q
Ft
H
:
C)
CD
Ft
H’
H
Ml
CD
CD
Di
Ft
Ml
ci.
CD
0
ci
CD
H’
H’
H-
Ft
LQ
0
CD
Cl)
Di
C)
Ft
0
H
Ml
Ft
ci.-
CD
CD
ci
C)
L<
H-
Cl)
Cl)
Ft
Di
ci
a
Di
II
a
Cl)
Cl)
ci.
0
Ii
H’
a
c3.-
CD
Di
a
0
Ft
CD
a
Ft
Di
Ft
0
ci
H’
a
Di
H’
H’
0
0
o
i-c
Cli
CD
NJ
GD
H
ci.-
H-
Cl)
H-
Cl)
Ft
ci.-
CD
CD
Ml
H
H’
CD
a
E’J
‘J
L’J
tJ
N.)
F—i
H
I-’
f-
I-
I-
b-
-
(i
t’J
i-
0
co
a)
-J
Co
(ii
Ci
t’J
H
0
co
Co
-j
ci
‘j
o
rt
Ft
C)
cQ
C)
H-
CD
H-
H-
co
ct
Cl)
C)
C).
<
h
H-
H-
0
Di
CD
CD
H-
Ft
CD
H-
H-
CD
CD
L<
CD
h
CD
H-
3
CD
-
H-
Dl
CD
Cl)
II
H-
Ft
H-
Ft
CD
3
Ft
çt
Cl)
H
0
CD
3
-
3
h-
cQ
0
X
H
Di
I-H
CD
h
()
Di
Ft
cC)
H-
cC)
H-
rt
Ft
Di
Di
CD
C)
I-
H-
C)
C)
C)
0
0
C)
Ft
b
Ft
Dl
C)
H-
CD
Di
Ft
Ft
Ft
Ft
p.
Ft
H-
Ft
CD
Ft
3
N)
Ft
0
CD
3
h
0
0
CD
H
0
H
Di
0
a
cC)
CD
CD
0
H-
-
‘-<
3
CD
H-
C)
D
C)
CD
CD
p.
H-
3
Di
CD
CD
CD
I-
Di
0
Ft
0
H
0
CD
CD
H-
H
‘
C)
H-
ci
Di
h
Ft
Ft
ci
H-
CD
CD
CD
Di
CD
CD
I-
H
Di
D
Di
Di
3
CD
-
3
Ft
cC)
C)
H-
H-
Di
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
0
Ft
I-H
Ft
0
Di
CD
p.
CD
3
Ft
Ft
CD
Cl
CD
Ft
II
3
t’
Ft
C)
L<
3
Di
CD
Di
CD
t
CD
CD
Di
H-
3
D
Ft
Ft
Ft
Cl
CD
‘-<
Ft
Ft
0
C)
Ft
CD
ci
Di
0
]
CD
Ft
I—s
Ft
H
CD
Di
ci
CD
Ft
D
H-
0
0
Di
II
I-h
H-
D
Ft
CD
CD
H
Di
tY
CD
H
CD
Di
Ft
CD
H-
0
Di
CD
CD
Di
C)
p.
Ft
Ft
H-
H-
0
Ft
Ft
Cl
Ft
I-
H
Di
Ft
<
Ft
Ft
C)
H
ci
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
ci
>
Di
CD
0
Y
CD
0
H
H
Ft
C)
0
Di
3
Di
CD
Di
3
Ft
><
H-
ci
CD
CD
CD
Cl
0
cC)
Cl
Ft
Ft
CD
Di
Ft
CD
Ft
CD
‘T5
p.
F-
II
C).
F-
CD
1
h
•
I
‘t
h-
H-
C’
CD
CD
H
Di
H
CD
Di
CD
CD
Ft
H-
H-
CD
I-I
Di
•O
H
Di
Ft
Di
p.
Ft
I—h
Ft
3
3
H-
I-
0
CD
ci
Ft
H-
H-
0
C)
CD
H
Ft
CD
Ft
H-
ci
CD
Ft
D
Ft
CD
0
0
D
CD
H-
H-
Ft
H-
CD
C)
1
CD
CD
CD
Di
-<
p.
CD
CD
Ft
CD
C)
CD
3
I
H-
D
CD
Ft
H
I-
‘Ti
CD
CD
h
H
Ft
H-
CD
0
CD
H
0
H-
H
C)
Di
H
CD
Di
H-
p.
3
Di
N)
Ft
CD
CD
M-
‘-<
CD
0
H
CD
U)
•
Ft
CD
Di
Di
C)
CD
H
Cl
0
‘-<
0
0
CD
H-
ci
Ft
I—s
C)
CD
CD
“J
ci
Ft
0
Di
CD
H-
3
0
H-
Di
H-
0
H-’
Di
Ft
Ft
H-
CD
-J
ci
C).
H-
•i
J
U)
cC)
ci
Ft
0
Cl
k<
0
CD
cC)
CD
H
Di
ci
ci
CD
CD
CD
H-
C).
CD
ci
Di
Ft
H-
Ft
•
Ft
Ft
H
H-
CD
F—’
CD
CD
Ft
II
<
Di
CD
Di
i
Di
Di
Ft
cQ
H
H-
CD
CD
Di
CD
Ft
0
CD
CD
C)
CD
CD
Ft
Cl)
0
CD
N)
ci
Di
Di
Ft
H
0
0
C)
ci
Di
p.
0
H-
II
Ft
3
Di
3
N)
0
C)
Di
0
H
Ft
0
Ft
CD
CD
p.
Di
‘-<
p.
p.
0
Cl
I
t—
0
Di
‘<
Ft
H-
Ft
CD
ci
CD
CD
Ft
‘-<
I
‘
h
CD
0
H-
h-h
3
H
l-
CD
II
Ft
0
CD
ci
Ft
ci
Ft
Ft
CD
H-
CD
0
Di
ci
Ft
Ft
II
Di
Ft
Ft
0
p.
Ft
Di
I—’
‘Ti
-
Ft
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
H-
H-
Ft
H-
ci
-
cC)
cQ
h
CD
Di
Ft
p.
CD
CD
C)
cQ
CD
CD
CD
CD
Ft
CD
•
CD
Di
Ft
Ft
Ft
Page
30
1
Q.
Okay.
2
MS.
DEXTER:
That’s
all
I
have.
3
MS.
TIPSORD:
Anything
further
for
4
Ms.
Nemura?
5
Thank
you very
much
for
coming
6
back.
7
(WHEREUPON, the
witness
was
8
excused.)
9
MS.
TIPSORD:
That
takes
us to
10
Mr. Freedman.
11
(WHEREUPON, the
witness
was
duly
12
sworn.)
13
MR.
ANDES:
Here
is
a copy
of
his
14
testimony.
15
MS.
TIPSORD:
And if
there’s
no
16
objection,
we
will
mark Mr.
Freedman’s
17
prefiled
testimony
as Attachment
to Exhibit
18
204.
Seeing
none,
it’s
Exhibit
204.
19
(WHEREUPON,
a
certain
document
was
20
marked
Exhibit
21
No. 204
for
identification,
as
of
22
2/17/09.)
23
MS.
TIPSORD:
And whenever
you’re
24
ready,
Ms. Williams.
hJ
[‘J
N)
N)
N)
F—i
F-
F
-
H-
F
F
-
W
N)
H
0
o
Co
--i
Co
N)
H
C)
C)
J
Co
(n
()
N)
H
H-
0
C)
CD
hi
H-
ct
CD
CD
0
U)
CD
C)
ii
3
h-h
0
it
CD
hi
CD
0
CD
it
C
M-
F-<
Dl
C)
CD
0
CD
It
It
CD
0
H
H
Di
it
CD
Q.
0
H-
ct
D
Di
Q
CD
It
hi
H
i
Q
H-
H-
H
0
it
H-
It
Cl)
i
CD
a
a
o
a
CD
CD
-
H
H-
CD
-,
a
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
Di
0
L<
H-
CD
0
a
it
CD
hi
a
H
H
3
CD
I-H
Q
Di
H-
Di
It
k<
It
0
H
•
I-H
Di
CD
H-
0
C).
t
H
CD
H
Ui
H
C’)
CD
3
CD
H
Di
‘-<
Di
H-
0
CD
3
H
H-
Di
ht
CD
It
C)
3
It
Q
Q
0
3
U)
CD
It
It
H-
H-
h-h
0
••
X
D
0
C)
It
Di
Di
CD
H
3
cli
It
H-
Di
H-
CD
H-
H-
I-I
It
1
H
Di
0
H
Q
3
0
CD
H
3
It
3
It
CD
3
CD
Di
3
i
CD
H-
3
3
CD
C)
D
CD
-<
t)
Di
hi
C’)
3
CD
CD
C)
0
H-
CD
It
CD
CD
It
U)
j
H-
CD
CD
Di
H-
3
hi
hi
U)
CD
Di
H
H-
0
H
C).
CD
CD
0
3
CD
H-
LQ
0
It
0
Q
H
3
H-
C)
Di
3
hI
•
H
3
Q.
CD
It
0
3
Di
N)
Cl
CD
hi
Cl
CD
C’)
Di
3
It
CD
3
H-
H-
H-
3
<
H
Q
h-h
><
3
CD
3
CD
H
3
CD
3
It
)
Di
It
CD
H-
It
H-
H
CD
Cl
hi
CD
C)
Q
C)
3
3
3
h-h
3
H
-
CD
C)
H
hi
•
H-
H-
CD
a
CD
H
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
Di
I-I
It
H
hi
H-
CD
3
Di
I-I
H-
a
CD
Z
CD
C’
Di
•
CD
C’
h-h
CD
0
H
Di
0
J
CD
It
H
It
0
Ui
It
CD
3
Q
0
H-
H
It
H-
CD
Di
D
H-
hi
Di
CD
‘
It
It
CD
CD
H-
3
I-H
H-
C’
C’)
It
Di
a
C)
CD
h-h
3
3
Di
H
CD
0
CD
CD
C’
Q
0
h-h
Di
C’)
Di
C)
H-
Di
-<
a
-H
C)
H-
C’
It
CD
Q
Z
H-
<
C)
It
‘s
Di
CD
U)
C)
It
CD
C’
3
h-h
H-
It
CD
H-
CD
I-<
0
H-
0
h-h
0
CD
CD
0
It
0
H-
It
C
a
Di
-<
C’
Di
Di
0
H-
a
a
hI
0
C’
0
0
CD
C)
Z
C’
It
hi
C’
C’
H-
C)
It
C’
CD
Di
a
hi
Di
a
a
C’
H-
H
hi
It
C)
Di
CD
CD
It
CD
CD
O
H
It
H-
CD
H-
CD
C’
CD
It
•
CD
H-
CD
U)
h-h
CD
‘c
CD
CD
C’
0
3
C’
‘t)
0
CD
Di
C)
0
H-
CD
H-
CD
hi
H-
C3
C’
Di
C’
C)
CD
0
CD
Cl)
H-
It
H-
C’
0
C’
o
hi
C’
CD
It
H-
a
hi
CD
•.)
CD
CD
C’
CD
H
H
hi
0
C’
H-
It
CD
It
It
CD
H
h-h
o
CD
h-h
It
C’
C)
C’
CD
It
CD
0
0
H
Q
a
Di
CD
0
Di
C’
H-
It
H-
C’
H-
CD
CD
It
CD
C’
H-
It
CD
CD
C)
It
It
0
hi
H
3
a
it
C’
t3
•
It
Di
0
H-
a
It
•
3
H-
CD
H
a
it
-<
CD
Di
a
H-
CJ
CD
CD
It
Di
Di
CD
CD
CD
H
H
CD
0
C’)
H-
CD
3
hi
C’
CD
Ui
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
H
H
H
H
H
I—i
H
I-
F-
W
NJ
H
0
co
0)
-J
0)
(fl
C)
NJ
H
0)
.)
0)
c_)1
W
NJ
H-
0
C)
0
CD
çt
H-
F’-
0
Ft
CD
Cli
Ft
0
Ft
a
<
Di
H-
F—h
0
3
ci
3
Mi
D
Ft
lj
3
D
Mi
cu
H-
0
CD
0
CD
CD
Hi
CD
ci
a
CD
Ft
Di
CD
ci
CD
CD
Ft
II
Ft
C)
0
0
Ft
a
Di
CD
Ft
CD
II
CD
C)
a
H-
F-
F-
J
H-
Q)
3
C!)
-
0
CD
Ft
CD
H-
Di
Mi
Di
CD
CD
CD
Di
L<
tJ
CD
I—’
Q
CD
Ft
H-
Y
CD
Di
CD
CD
i-
a
ci
<
ci
H-
a
Di
•
C)
H-
a
0
Ft
C’]
Ft
C)
II
lD
ci
0
CD
CD
CD
H
Ft
Di
Ft
•
•
H-
‘d
Ft
H-
Di
O
Di
a
CD
<1
CD
CD
F-
Di
H-
0
H-
J
Di
ci
CD
CD
F-
c
Ft
Ft
0
CD
a
L—
Ft
3
Di
H
Ft
H-
0
0
H
0
ci
L<
•‘J
Ft
Ft
Ft
Ft
H-
Di
Ft
H-
><
0
CD
H-’
Di
Ft
CD
Di
0
CD
D
C)
Ft
0
j
L<
3
Ft
CD
H-
Ft
Fj
tH
H-
H-
Hi
ci
CD
H
I
ci
>
a
Di
CD
CD
0
CD
-‘
CD
Di
a
CD
a
H-
I
<
a
L<
3
CD
0
3
a
Ft
Ft
0
-<
a
ci
Di
Ft
Di
a
CD
H-
fr
Ft
a
Ft
0
Ft
Di
I—’
C)
CD
H-
CD
0
CD
“
Mi
Di
J
Ft
X
I—’
3
<
0
CD
Ft
0
-c
I—’
Mi
Ft
CD
0
Di
Ft
3
‘-<
CD
a
CD
Di
Mi
CD
i
H-
CD
CD
CD
a
Di
a
L-Q
a
F-
5
Di
H-
Ft
a
H-
C)
‘—s
c
a
CD
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
Di
Ft
Ft
D
Ft
CD
3
LQ
0
CD
<
CD
H-’
o
I
H-
CD
H-
H-
D
Dl
H-
cC)
•
<
H-
CD
<
ci
I
Ft
3
0
‘-<
CD
Ft
CD
CD
s
Ft
0
Ft
Ft
CD
3
l-
0
cC)
ci
Ft
0
H-
-
0
D
H
cQ
“
ci
D
0
Di
Ft
iQ
H-
ci
F-
CD
i
CD
C!
H-
Di
Di
0
‘
ci
a
H-
<
Y
CD
a
a
Di
Ft
cC)
I
C)
C)
Ft
Di
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
CD
CD
H-
CD
tc
Di
Ft
Ft
a
Ft
CD
F-
D
—u
H-
CD
<
cC)
Ft
Ft
D
CD
H-
F-
CD
Dl
CD
Ft
H-
a
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
Di
0
‘-<
<
0
Ft
C)
Ft
CD
Di
C)
<
F-’
Ft
CD
0
<
H
0
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
o
CD
cQ
D
J
‘-<
Di
0
Di
0
C)
Di
Ft
CD
ci
H-
Ft
‘c
l-
I—’
•
CD
Di
I
H-’
1
‘C5
0
3
D
C)
1
H-
CD
0
H-’
Di
0
F-’
Ft
CD
a
Di
0
LJ-
0
CD
Mi
Q
Dl
C3
F-
0
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
F-
ci
3
CD
Di
ci
Dl
F
3
F-
H
I
a
CD
Ft
F-
CD
Ft
Di
Di
CD
0
I<
L<
CD
a
CD
0
CD
3
D
CD
Ft
CD
3
F-
Ft
Ft
CD
Di
Di
H-
ci
a
CD
C)
3
Mi
Ft
H-
CD
H-
CD
1
L<
CD
H-
Mi
Ft
CD
Ft
H-
H-
Ft
0
0
CD
Ft
H-
CD
CD
Ft
ci
CD
H-
Di
CD
CD
3
‘-<
Mi
ci
C)
Di
Di
Ft
C)
Di
CD
H-’
0
0
F-
F-
Ft
CD
Ft
a
Ft
‘-<
C)
0
CD
3
CD
Ft
a
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
Di
3
C)
a
o
Ft
CD
H-
-Q
0
Di
H-
CD
0
H-
Ft
a
H-
Di
Mi
H-
0
Ft
-c
a
Ft
3
ci
Mi
H-
Ft
Mi
ci
CD
F—’
Di
H-
a
CD
H-
tH
C)
H-
a
3
H-
Di
CD
H-
Ft
Ft
H-
Di
Di
CD
Ft
-
Ft
C)
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
C)
Ft
C)
CD
0
Ft
H-
r
tY
Ft
0
H-
H-
Di
CD
Di
Ft
CD
Di
a
II
H-
Di
H-
CD
H-
h-c
CD
CD
Ft
H-
0
cC)
Ft
CD
CD
cC)
F-
CD
0
H-
i
3
CD
Di
Di
CD
H-
J
0
cC)
Di
Ft
CD
Ft
3
H-
Page
33
1
study.
2
Q.
And
that’s
Limno—tech;
correct?
3
A.
That’s
Limno—tech
in particular.
4
Oh,
I —-
I
want
to
append.
5
There’s
also
the
integrated
water
quality
strategy,
6
excuse
me.
And
we are
involved
in
that
as a
7
subcontractor
to
an
engineering
firm
that’s
working
8
for
the
District.
9
Q.
Which
firm
is
that?
10
A.
CTE,
now
known
as
AE
Comp.
11
Q.
With
respect
to
the
Habitat
and
12
Biological
Assessment
Study,
do
you
know,
were
13
habitat
microinvertebrates,
fish
sediment
and
water
14
quality
data
considered
in
the CAWS
UAA?
15
A.
I’m
sorry,
was
your question
——
16
Q.
I think
what
-— quoting,
“We’re
17
looking
at
the Habitat
Biological
Assessment
18
Study”
-— just
a
second.
19
Okay.
Based
on what
you’ve
stated
20
on Page
12,
the Habitat
Biological
Assessment
Study
21
will
provide
more
comprehensive
data.
22
Do
you
know
what
habitat
23
microinvertebrates,
fish
sediment
and
water
quality
24
data
considered
in
the
CAWS
UAA?
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
I-
H
I-
F-
H
1—i
I-’
H
)—
I-
W
NJ
H
0
co
o
—i
a
(i,
I-
0
O
0
J
O
(
W
NJ
I-
CD
Ci
Ci
‘t5
Ft
CD
H-
H-
t
CD
3
CD
CD
H-
1
-
CD
3
3
L<
H-
CD
a
U.
C)
<
3
CD
0
CD
0
a
t
CD
0
Ci
CD
CD
CD
H-
-h
<1
CD
1
CD
Ci
0
I—’
H
CD
Ci
H-
H-
CD
0
a
h
Fh
0
3
II
ct
CD
it
H
ci
a
CD
Ci
o
CD
t-t
H-
Q
Q
CD
H-
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
H-
H
3
a
C
CD
Ft
C)
H-
>
C
C)
CD
H-
ct
CD
•
Ft
CD
H-
0
CD
çt
CD
D
CD
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
a
0
CD
Ci
a
CD
a
a
CD
CD
0
Fh
I
H
‘
Ft
•o
CD
<
1
CD
CD
Ft
0
it
CD
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
Hf
0
CD
H-
Ft
Ci
Hf
CD
Ft
CD
Ci
I-H
HI
<
o
a
0
C)
CD
CD
-<
-<
CD
CD
H
CD
0
0
‘-<
Ci
0
3
it
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
3
CD
H
CD
a
CD
CD
Y
Ci
Ci
‘-<
I
‘-<
‘-<
Ft
CD
it
CD
‘
H-
F-I
CD
IjJ
Hf
0
CD
CD
CD
a
•
it
3
CD
rt
rt
0
C)
CD
a
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
CD
Ft
3
CD
3
Ft
CD
Ft
3
HI
Hf
0
Ci
‘TJ
C)
CD
-
3
Ii
CD
Ft
a
3
CD
CD
Ft
0
3
3
h
CD
CD
CD
CD
‘-ci
Ft
0
CD
Ft
I
CD
a
CD
Ci
Q
‘-<
0
<
Ft
I-
H-
Ft
H
3
Ft
CD
H-
H-
CD
CD
CD
ij
ci
0
Hf
H-
‘-<
CD
3
CD
3
CD
0
H-
C)
a
Ii
CD
CD
CD
Ft
Ci
CD
3
Ft
0
I—h
CD
CD
Ft
H-
Ft
H-
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
H-
3
Ci
H-
CD
3
D
<
C)
3
H-
h
Ft
a
•
i-i
CD
Hf
CD
CD
Hf
a
0
X
CD
CD
0
H-,
CD
3
CD
CD
CD
Hf
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
0
0
L<
a
H-
CD
H-
3
ci
a
a
CD
CD
CD
Ci
Ii
Ft
a
3
CD
3
3
CD
-h
CD
‘.Q
C)
H-
Ft
3
H-
H-’
a
H-
0
CD
><
0
3
Q
C
H-
Ci
Ft
CD
a
a
a
CD
H-
CD
CD
‘-<
a
‘-<
<
c3
II
CD
CD
Ci
3
‘-1
CD
3
CD
Ft
a
tY
0
Ci
0
CD
Hf
I-
CD
CD
H
Ft
a
CD
h
3
H-
H-
Ci
H-
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
CD
0
CD
CD
C)
CD
0
C)
Ft
CD
Ft
‘-<
Ci
Ft
H-
3
Hf
H-
Ft
1
3
CD
I-
H-
Ft
3
0
>
CD
•
3
0
3
CD
3
H-
Ft
3
a
CD
D
H-
3
•J
Ft
,Q
0
•
ci
Q
0
CD
Hf
a
CD
3
CD
3
CD
Ci
Ci
CD
CD
CD
C)
CD
3
Ft
<
•
Ft
Ft
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
I-H
H
CD
‘
CD
H-
H-
H-
Ft
CD
a
CD
H
h
<
3
0
Ci
H-
H-,
H-
3
CD
a
Ft
Ci
Ci
CD
cn
a
•
Ci
Ci
0
H-
3
CD
ii
H
F--’
Ci
‘<
Ci
I
CD
‘-<
•
a
Hf
C)
H-,
C)
0
CD
UJ-
0
Ft
I
H-
H-
0
CD
0
CD
0
H-
0
Ci
C)
Ci
Ci
CD
CD
Hf
Ci
1
F--’
1
CD
Ft
Ci
-
CD
CD
a
HI
‘<
h
H-
F—’
CD
•
CD
CD
Ft
—
CD
C)
‘-<
CD
Ft
H-
<
H-
CD
Hf
‘-<
CD
Ft
a
0
‘-ci
F-’-
H
CD
Hf
F-
H-
CD
Ci
CD
Ci
H-
Ci
0
Ci
F-
—EQ
CD
Ci
Ft
CD
-
CD
a
a
CD
M
\)
N)
N)
H
l-
H
H
H
H
H
U)
N)
H
0
co
CO
—J
0)
0’
-
U)
H
H
H
N)
H
0
0)
-.-J
0)
01
)
0)
N)
H
it
Cl)
H
0
U)
CD
Hi
it
Q
U)
T
ct
it
D
it
U)
0
H-
Q
U)
U)
Q
3
U)
Hi
U)
0
3
CD
U)
U)
it
it
Cl)
U)
H-
CD
0
H-
CD
1
it
it
CD
Cl)
çt
CD
H
it
H
3
H
C)
C
H
it
CD
CD
it
SD.
-1
0.
F-
Q.
Cl)
H-
0.
H-
LQ
CD
C)
3
U)
II
Cl)
H
U)
Cl)
CD
-5
0
Hi
SD.
J
CD
-5
it
L<
U)
j
•,j
L<
CD
CD
3
tY
H-
Q
H-
Cl)
0
Cl)
Q
0
0
50
U)
CD
C)
U)
it
Cl)
Q
H-
U)
it
3
•
H-
si
U)
I
3
0
•
CD
it
U)
H
CD
‘-<
it
H-
it
it
H-
I
U)
0.
0.
3
h
H
3
3
3
it
CD
C).
CD
U)
H-
U)
CD
-5
U)
1
-1
LQ
H
it
Hi
it
CD
[-5
II
it
3
H-
U)
0
3
0
CD
U)
H-
3
Hi
U)
-<
L<
Cl
Cl)
CM
[-S
Cl
Cl
H-
3
CD
H-
H
-
0
0
0
H
3
H-
3
H-
3
3
Cl)
3
it
H
H
it
CD
Cl)
Cl)
Cl)
U)
CD
C)..
U)
it
CD
ci
Cl)
it
çu
CD
CD
H
CD
U)
CD
3
it
tY
H-
Cl)
3
U)
Cl)
ci
it
Cl)
H
-<
a
3
H
0
U)
it
CD
U)
3
H
3
0
it
“
Hi
CD
C)
CD
3
it
3
H
C)..
it
‘-<
H-
H-i
H-
0
0
H
1
it
•
C)
0
3
Cl)
H
U)
J
3
H
F-5
I
3
H-
3
Cl)
C).
it
Fl
CD
H
0
U)
3
Cl)
H-
ci
H-
CD
U)
51
3
5’i
3
C)..
it
U)
H
it
Q
it
it
Cl)
it
it
H-
3
CD
‘
3
H-
it
tI
‘-<
H-
3
it
CD
3
3
it
C)..
CD
Q
0...
CD
0..
it
3
51
0
H-
U)
Cl)
CD
ci
CD
it
51
H-
0
Cl
U)
it
U)
Cl)
0
H-
1
U)
3
Cl
CD
it
0
3
C)
H-
Q
Cl)
Cl)
D
it
CD
H
Cl)
0.
‘-<
H-
‘
()
0
0
>
CD
0
Cl)
iX
CD
3
Cl)
0
Cl)
‘
C)
Hi
it
b
it
Cl)
H-
0
0
‘-<
LI-
U)
‘TJ
U)
3
Q
3
CD
C/)
0
ci
H
ci
it
it
CD
H-
<
U)
C5
II
U)
CD
I-
•
H
Q
<
it
it
Cl)
CD
C)
CD
C)
ci
H
H-
Cl)
Fl
0
C)
II
CD
0
3
it
1
H-
C)
0
Q..
CD
<
tS
U)
0
CD
it
C)..
U)
H-
U)
Hi
H-
C)
C)
CD
H
CD
0
ci
CD
Cl
0
50
it
Hi
Cl)
H-
Hi
0
H-
Cl)
3
II
H-
X
Cl)
51
0
0
0
H-
C)
H-
ci
ci
it
H-
0
L<
CD
H-
Cl)
0
C)
X
CD
0
CD
ci
it
C)
51
H-
H-
ci
it
H-
CD
0...
CD
‘-<
X
ci
<
Cl)
C)..
ci
3
C)
H-
0
C)
LC)
Cl)
it
II
it
-
0
<
U)
i-C)
it
H-
CD
I-5
I
it
ci
LJ-
H-
CD
it
3
it
ci
i-SD
ci
CD
H-
ci
U)
U)
H-
I
H-
H-
U)
ci
it
Cl
Cl)
CD
H
3
CD
i-SD
ci
0
H-
ci
II
I
it
0
it
ci
Cl)
CD
H-
ci
3
CD
ci
0
0..
Fl
I
CD
it
ci
3
i-SD
ci
it
I
Cl)
it
Cl)
Cl)
Cl)
3
U)
1
D
Cl)
U)
ci
Cl)
H-
U)
it
3
CD
CD
H-
it
o
•
ci
Cl)
H-
U)
it
H-
3
U)
0
<
U)
0
Cl)
it
it
U)
•
ci
it
0
U)
it
Ci)
it
Y
ci
CD
H
CD
ci
ci
U)
ci
CD
CD
it
CD
C)
0
SD..
i-SD
CD
ci
i--J-
51
it
C)..
it
CD
D
H-
I—5
CD
H-
i-Q
U)
3
C)
5D..
ci
U)
ci..
‘-
3
ci..
C)
CD
ci
U)
Hi
H
j
it
H-
U)
Cl)
I—5
CD
‘-<
U)
H-
it
0
CD
H-
C)
51
Hi
II
it
Cl
II
it
Hi
I-H
0
ci
‘-<
C)
Cl)
H-
0..
H
H-
E’i
it
C)
U)
H-
C)
‘d
it
it
r
ci..
U)
U)
i-Q
it
CD
0)
0’
M
E\)
r\)
M
L’J
H
I-
)—
-
I-
-
-
I-
I-
U)
M
H
CD
O
CX)
-J
gi
Ci’
Cii
M
H
C)
C)i
Ci’
U)
‘J
H
C)
Di
0
H-
3
0
0
CD
CD
0
0
CD
I-H
Q
Di
hi
C)
CD
CD
I)
H-
X
3
Ft
Ft
i
Hi
CD
0
H-
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
L<
CD
Di
‘Ti
Q
Hi
Ft
Cl
Ft
Cl
C)
Q
3
Cl
0
Ft
H
H-
CD
Di
CD
CD
C).
<
H-
D
0
C).
C)
Ft
Ft
hi
H
Ft
CD
3
H-
Di
3
0
hi
H-
0
H-
F-
D
Di
0
Ui
CD
hi
CC)
CD
Ft
3
CD
0
Di
k<
Dl
Ft
CD
Ft
CD
C)
Cl
1
C
CD
0
hi
U
Ft
C)
3
Ft
CD
•
0
•
Di
Ft
C)
0
Di
Ft
0
Dl
Di
Dl
•
Hi
CD
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
D
Ft
3
Ft
3
0
H-
Ft
CD
CD
CC)
Ft
Ui
Ft
CD
CD
C).
hi
C).
hi
CD
H-
CD
Dl
CD
0
CD
0
Di
Cl
CD
0
Hi
C)
H-
Di
S
3
hi
Ft
‘<
H-
C)
‘Ti
H-
CD
k<
Di
3
0
F-
H-
CD
Cl
0
Cl)
CD
H-
0
3
3
Di
Ft
‘-<
3
CD
CD
0
CD
Hi
CD
0
H-
CD
D
H-
3
Hi
H
CD
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
H
CD
CD
H
Ft
Di
0
H
CD
3
0
Ft
C)
CD
‘-<
hi
3
0
3
CD
hi
Ui
-
CD
3
Di
Di
0
Ft
0
CD
C)
Di
3
Ft
‘-<
3
H-
C)
Ft
Di
Ft
‘<
Di
H-
CD
Ft
Ci
Di
CD
H-
CD
3
CD
C
0
CD
Ft
3
H-
‘Ti
‘-i-
Ft
3
3
3
Di
CD
Di
CD
H-
CD
CD
‘-<
Di
tY
3
CD
CD
Cl
C)
Ft
H
CD
Ft
CD
CC)
Dl
3
hi
l
0
hi
CD
‘
C)
CD
CD
Ft
CD
CD
CD
H-
C)
CD
Ft
Di
CD
0
Ci
CD
hi
H-
Ft
Ft
Ft
hi
0
C)
H-
Ft
CD
Cl
3
•‘J
CD
“
I-H
Hi
H-
H-
CD
-<
Di
CD
Ft
Ft
hi
CD
Cl
H-
C)
H-
Hi
Ft
CD
3
H
CD
Di
Ft
Di
Ft
0
Di
‘-<
Ft
C)
H-
0
‘l-
Hi
Ft
CD
Ft
Di
H
Di
CD
3
H-
CD
0
Ft
C)
3
CD
CD
0
CD
C)
Di
H-
F-
<
H
0
0
‘Ti
H-
3
Di
<
CD
CD
Hi
Cl
0
hi
Ft
3
0
•
3
H
3
i
Ft
Ft
H
3
CD
Ft
Di
Di
‘Ti
CD
CD
3
3
H-
Hi
H-
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
H
Ft
H-
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
0
0
Hi
3
CD
Ft
0
Ft
H-
H-
Ft
3
I-I
0
CD
CD
CD
Ft
CD
3
C)
H-
CC)
CD
H-
Di
CD
H
CQ
CD
CC)
Cl
Ft
hi
•
C)
0
H
Ft
CD
H-
3
hi
Ft
Ft
CD
Di
•
CD
Di
Hi
0
H-
Ft
CD
CD
Di
CD
hi
Ft
Di
3
Ft
CD
Ft
Di
Di
0
CD
Z
Ft
‘-<
Cl
-
H
0
CD
0
Cl
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
3
hi
Di
CD
Cl
H-
hi
H-
3
0
Ft
CD
Ft
•
Ft
1’
H-
CD
0
Ft
Ft
CD
3
Cl
0
3
Ft
CD
hi
Di
CD
H
3
Ft
3
CD
CD
Di
0
3
•
Ft
Ft
CD
Di
CD
3
CD
CD
CD
Ft
Cl
H-
0
Ft
Di
Ft
,Q
Di
H-
H
3
H
0
H-
Di
3
hi
Ft
Ft
Ft
CD
3
hi
3
Ft
‘-<
Ft
H
Ft
Di
Ft
‘<
Hi
Cl
Di
Ft
hi
Di
Ft
CD
Di
CD
‘<
H-
<1
Ft
Di
0
CD
Ft
CD
3
H
Di
‘TI
Ft
H-
0
‘TI
CD
Di
Ft
hi
hi
0
H-
Ft
0
H-
CD
3
H
Cl
Ft
3
I
Ft
H-
Ft
CD
-
Di
Ft
I
Cli
C
“<
H-
3
Di
Cl
CD
Ft
0
CC)
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
‘-<
0
H-
Di
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
0
3
hi
Cl
3
Di
3
Cl
CD
Page
37
1
Attainability
Analysis,”
is
what
use
and
what
2
criteria
can
actually
attain.
3
So
in
partial
answer
to
your
4
question,
yes,
once
the
habitat
study
is
completed,
5
you
will
begin
to
have
the
foundation
for
how
to
put
6
this,
shall
we
say,
puzzle
all
together.
Put
all
7
those
pieces
together
to
define
both
the
use
and
the
8
criterion.
9
Q.
Question
7.
10
“What
are
the
significant
impacts
11
you
are
referring
to
on
Page
4
of
the
prefiled
12
testimony?”
13
MR.
ANDES:
Do
you
mean
significant
14
impact?
15
BY
THE
WITNESS:
16
A.
I
think
you’re
quoting?
17
BY
MS.
DEXTER:
18
Q
Yes.
19
A.
I
guess
I
would
refer
you
to
Pages
4
20
and
5
of
my
testimony,
as
well
as
Pages
3
and
4
of
21
my
report.
And
there
I
draw
from
the
research
of
22
others.
23
I
talk
about
loss
of
habitat,
flow
24
variations,
which
is
the
loss
of
habitat
Dr.
Mackey
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
I—i
H
U)
NJ
F
0
iQ
I-
I-
F-
H
I—i
H
F
-
U]
U)
NJ
H
0
co
0)
-J
0)
0’
U)
NJ
F
Di
Dl
1
Di
I—’
Q
CD
3
Di
M-
Q.
it
i-h
it
0
0
F-
H-
Dl
CD
0
f-
H-
ii
H-
CD
3
H-
5
H-
D
H-’
Dl
Di
Cl
l
it
F-
X
it
it
ct
Di
Q
C)
Cl
Q
0
CD
0
CD
H-
H-
it
H-
H-
0
(D
CD
CD
F-
3
0
CD
CD
C)
CD
0
C)
3
-Q
II
3
II
H-
H-
h
H-
H-
0
CD
it
it
Ct)
CD
-<
Di
Q
Di
it
it
CD
Di
it
H-
Cl
it
H-
H-
i
Dl
Q.
Cl
it
“
H-
Cl
it
-<
H-
Q
L<
<
Di
H-
Di
i-I
CD
Di
H-
Di
C)
H-
3
CD
CD
it
Di
11
0
C
H-
i
0
it
H-
C)
ii
Di
Di
0
it
it
Cl
IS
H-
H-
CD
F-
CD
Cl
3
3
0
CD
3
H
H-
CD
CD
CD
0
0
0
CD
Di
CD
tY
3
Cl
it
F-’
CD
0
3
-Q
3
Q
it
Cl
CD
C)
H-
Cl
H-
CD
0
I
it
X
it
CD
it
0
H-
5
it
0
H’
CD
it
H-
I
H-
<
Di
Di
it
C)
Di
it
IS
Di
15
F-
it
Cl
CD
H-
1Y
it
0
Di
3
0
H’
II
CD
H-
II
0
CD
CD
0
CD
C)
C)
CD
it
3
I-<
0
CD
Di
M-
it
CD
3
CD
it
ii
H-
0
D
•
H-
H-
CD
H-
3
Di
C)
I—h
D
F-
‘-<
•
Cl
Di
it
0
3
Di
0
H-
F-
C)
CD
F—’
M
it
CD
Di
Di
‘
15
Cl
II
H-
CD
C)
CD
M
II
H-I
it
it
X
Di
3
it
CD
ci
Di
C)
15
ci
H-
it
CD
0
CD
H-
•
CD
H-
H-I
H-
Y
Di
3
C)
C)
Cl)
Cl
Di
Di
0
CD
CD
C)
3
3
CD
H-
Q
0
it
H-
H-
it
31
H-
it
CD
IS
CD
it
C)
‘-<
C)
3
ci
H-
CD
<
CD
d
CD
H-
0
CD
Di
CD
Di
CD
0
Cl
it
Di
it
0
H
CD
[1
CD
0
J
H-
CD
•
C)
H-
Cl
it
CD
ci
H-
3
3
CD
3
:3-
H-
0
3
Di
it
it
it
I-I
Di
0
it
0
CD
it
CD
Di
H-
<
31
Di
Di
3
Cl
CD
it
15
H-
3
Di
15
0
it
H-
e
Di
H-
3
Di
H-
H-
C)
CD
H-
H-
3
3
H-
CD
CD
3
3
Di
IS
it
3
Q
H-
it
5
Di
Cl
CD
Cl
H-
H-
it
C)
0
Cl
Cl
H-
H-
it
CD
CD
Di
5
H-
H-
CD
Cl
CD
3
0
3
CD
3
CD
CD
C)
II
H-
-<
H-
CD
Q
CD
CD
0
CD
Di
CD
‘
15
0
H-
H-
CD
‘C
H
Di
0
it
0
it
<
CD
H-
CD
Q
Di
CD
Q
CD
0
3
Ii
IS
Di
<
CD
M
Di
-<
Cl
it
ii
Di
,-Q
3
-<
Di
‘
II
Cl
3
Di
3
Di
CD
it
H-
CD
CD
CD
ci
H-
CD
ci
it
CD
C)
H-
it
Cl
Ii
it
CD
CD
IS
Di
it
•
CD
CD
-<
II
ci
H-
H-
Di
Di
CD
ci
CD
CD
Cl
Cl
F-
H-
CD
Cl
it
ci
0
CD
Q
H
Di
t:3
3
ci
Cl
CD
CD
H-
0
CD
0
it
H-
ci
CD
•
H-
Di
it
F-
it
Di
it
CD
CD
it
ci
H
Di
0
C)
ci
C)
it
H-
H-
Di
3
ci
H
C)
C)
D
Di
II
ci
Di
CD
Di
CD
0
CD
Cl
CD
Cl
CD
H-
15
hI
0
CD
ci
0
CD
it
ci
it
15
ci
CD
M-
0
H-
H-
Di
i-h
Cl
<1
Di
CD
H-
CD
ci
ci
Di
CD
Cl
CD
CD
ci
0
H-
CD
ci
CD
CD
CD
Cl
ci
<1
<
CD
ci
CD
ci
Di
L<
CD
C)
CD
Cl
0
Di
Di
ci
H-
CD
C)
H-
15
it
it
CD
it
it
H-
H-
it
Di
0
it
CD
0
CD
CD
H-
Di
CD
H-
H-
H-
CD
<
I-I
Di
IS
ci
Di
F—
0
II
C)
ci
Di
I-I
CD
it
F-
Ct)
I-h
Di
H-
it
H-
it
CD
it
H-
Di
Di
H-
CD
ci
it
ci
H-
Di
ci
H-
hI
Di
Di
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
0
C)
CD
it
Cl
ci
i-h
H-
it
Di
N)
N)
N)
N)
N)
H
F
H
H
H
H
H
F-
F
Ui
N)
H
C)
D
CX)
J
X)
Cfl
U)
N)
I-
0
co
C)
—J
cYi
U’
Ui
N)
i-
ft
)
(n
Di
ft
C)
Di
Di
0
[-
H
1
Di
CD
o
si
<
ft
Di
0
Di
ft
ft
3
‘<
Di
Di
H-
hi
0
Hi
Di
Di
Di
i
H-
ft
H-
hi
CD
S
Hi
F-
1
F-
1
ft
ft
H-
Cl)
Q.
Di
C)
Di
ft
<
H-
<
CD
CD
F-
1
Di
o
H-
CD
0
ft
H-
H
ft
CD
hi
Dl
ft
CD
C)
H-
o
ft
S
Di
Cl
C)
Di
CD
CD
Di
i
5
ft
C)
C)
ft
CD
CD
Dl
H-
-1
ft
Hi
ft
ft
0
Di
Dl
CD
ft
hi
Hi
Di
>
H-
C)
H-
CD
Di
H-
H-
hi
ft
C)—
Dl
C)
S
ft
Di
Dl
0
F-
1
•
ft
5
3
0
0
ft
0
u
ft
0
H-
CD
ft
hi
CD
Q
CD
0
II
Cl
3
Di
Hi
0
3
cQ
C).
H-
CD
CD
hi
H-
Di
F-
1
0
C).
ft
Di
0
-_
Di
H-
-<
3
-<
0
H-
i
Di
ft
H-
ft
H1
tY
Di
H-
Dl
•
cC)
0
Dl
Hi
ft
Dl
CD
ft
<
H-
Di
H-
CD
cC)
•
3
<
C).
F-
1
ft
H-
Dl
0
•
3
Di
ft
S
C).
CD
H-
0
Di
ft
0
Hi
C
F-
CD
hi
0
cC)
Hi
0
cC)
C)
ft
CD
3
Hi
0
0
Cl
CD
cC)
Hi
Hi
Dl
H-
hi
Di
CD
cC)
F-
1
ID
Di
hi
CD
ft
5
0
C)
H-
ft
Di
5
0
C)
Hi
H-
CD
S
Di
ft
Hi
C)
S
CD
5
0
0
Di
S
C).
ft
H-
0
5
3
Di
Di
Cl
‘
H-
Si
ft
H
Di
5
ft
Di
0
C)
Di
Di
C).
ft
<
ft
S
Hi
5
ft
ft
-<
Di
Di
Dl
Di
CD
ft
CD
CD
0
ft
-<
Cl
Di
0
CD
0
ft
cC)
Di
Di
Di
ft
CD
Di
CD
S
ft
Di
hi
ft
hi
C)
Si
C)
ft
Dl
-<
C)
0
hi
S
Di
cC)
CD
0
Q
o
Di
Di
H-
0
Di
H-
Si
H-
hi
Di
C).
cC)
5
ft
0
ft
-
CD
ft
F—i
H-
S
Di
S
H-
CD
“l
Di
Di
Di
S
ft
Di
o
ft
Di
Di
F-
1
S
CD
cC)
H-
C).
-
S
CD
CD
ft
Di
CD
ft
‘
CD
Di
CD
Di
CD
5
5
cC)
hi
H-
CD
C5
ft
CD
C)
Cl
Di
0
0.
CD
ft
<
H-
H1
Di
Di
C)
Cl
Di
0
ft
F—’
CD
ft
5
hi
•
CD
S
Di
Cl
ft
Di
-1
0
Di
Si
ft
H-
CD
ft
ft
CD
H-
CD
F-
1
cC)
hi
CD
H-
C)
C)
ft
ft
CD
ft
0
0
CD
Dl
5
0
<
H-
H-
hi
CD
S
Si
hi
H-
3
ft
t
Di
Di
C)
CD
CD
0
H-
0
5
Dl
L<
H1
Di
5
5
CD
ft
ft
5
5
CD
ft
3
ft
ft
Hi
ft
H1
0
0
0
CD
H-
Di
CD
ft
CD
CD
Cl
Di
CD
ft
Dl
CD
H-
ft
Si
0
Hi
Di
S
J
C)
Di
S
Di
S
C)
H-
hi
ft
Di
CD
-
CD
H-
Di
ft
H-
ft
Di
5
5
0
Hi
H-
ft
F-
1
hi
ft
H
1
S
CD
C).
CD
F—a
F’-
Di
CD
Di
Di
Di
Di
ft
H-
ft
C).
‘T3
0
<
F-’
0
C)
H-
ft
<
ft
Di
ft
ft
0
H-
Di
Hi
CD
Di
Di
cC)
H-
Di
H-
CD
CD
‘-<
Di
C)
hi
C)
H-
Di
hi
0
5
I-H
Cl
C)
ft
Hi
CD
C)
0
Hi
5
ft
0
Di
0
Si
Di
H-
F-
1
H-
Di
C)
0
Di
0
ft
ft
ft
Di
Di
ft
S
F
CD
hi
ft
Si
Di
Di
ft
ft
C)
Di
H-
H
1
0
H-
Cl
H-
ft
Hi
H
1
Di
3
0
5
5
-<
0
Di
H-
Si
Di
Di
0
H’
-
5
ft
Di
0.
cC)
H-
ft
ft
ft
H-
CD
Di
CD
ft
H-
I-H
-,
5
hi
CD
S
cC)
U)
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
-
I-
I-
-
F-
I-
-
H-
I—a
0)
NJ
F-
a)
D
CX)
—J
CX)
(ii
U)
NJ
H
0
a)
09
U)
NJ
I-’
Ft
1
Cl
C)
CD
CD
C)
CD
1
<
CD
CD
D-
Cl)
J
CD
0
0
<
H-
Cl)
b<
hi
ct
0
0
CD
Ft
ct
CD
L’i
CD
ct
hi
C)
0
hi
H-
CD
hi
CD
Ft
rt
ti
Ft
CD
hi
h-h
ci
3
CD
X
rt
Ft
F-
-
CD
Ft
CD
hi
Ft
CD
H-
Ft
Q
CD
CD
CD
Cl
hi
CD
H-
CD
Ft
C)
hi
•
U-
hi
CD
Cl
hi
.Q
Q
Ft
CD
Ft
ci
H-
Ft
•o
CD
ci
10
CD
ci
CD
•o
Ft
CD
C
CD
0
CD
H
ci
10
CD
H-
•
Ft
CD
<
•
CD
Ft
•
I-H
<
0
Ft
•
Cl
F-
CD
Cl
t
Ft
t
CD
0
CD
C)
CD
ci
H
CD
F—i
h-h
D
hi
H-
hi
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
H-
0
I-H
CD
0
Ft
H-
Ft
CD
H
C)
CD
-<
Cl
CD
hi
Ft
0
hi
Ft
CD
CD
hi
CD
0
CD
CD
LII
H-
C)
Q
-<
CD
C/)
C)
CD
I
0
I-H
hi
ci
CD
C)
ci
CD
H-
0
hi
••
0
CD
CD
H-
Ft
CD
CD
3
h-h
CD
•
ci
Ft
H
LQ
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
Cl
Ft
•
H-
CD
F-
CD
H-
Cl
ci
ci
hi
hi
‘-<
Ft
H-
CD
3
C)
‘i
Cl
Ft
CD
CD
F-
CD
H-
CD
0
Ft
Ft
LQ
‘-<
0
hi
i
CD
3
CD
CD
Cl
CD
ci
CD
H-
I
LI
CD
3
CD
-
CD
CD
Cl
H-
H-
0
I
ci
ci
Ft
Cl
CD
Ft
CD
0
CD
CD
I-I
0
CD
Ft
C)
3
Ft
Cl
C)
ci
Ft
I-H
CD
Ft
CD
CD
H-
H-
Cl
t—I
hi
H-
F—
Ft
H
CD
Ft
Cl
3
h-h
ci
C)
CD
tY
CD
CD
h-h
Cl
CD
H-
l
H-
CD
H-
Y
CD
hi
CD
I
CD
H-
H-
Ft
0
3
H-
H-
hi
Ft
CD
0
-<
CD
CD
CD
C)
-
I—’
C)
Cl
Ft
3
CD
•‘J
0
CD
ci
Ft
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
C)
ci
CD
CD
ci
I-H
CD
ci
Y
0
Ft
Ft
CD
tY’
Ft
0
C)
CD
3
LI-
CD
-
Ft
CD
‘c
H-
ci
3
CD
H-
CD
H-
CD
C)
CD
CD
Cl
ci
CD
Cl
H-
CD
H-
H-
H-
3
CD
-<
CD
3
3
CD
CD
H-
CD
C)
3
H-
Cl
CD
Ft
•
<
Ft
3
CD
3
Ft
I-I
F-
CD
CD
Cl
Ft
Ft
o
I-H
hi
Q
H-
H
3
CD
CD
5
ci
Ft
0
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
H
Cl
0
CD
Ft
CD
0
ci
CD
H-
CD
3
CD
H-
CD
Ft
•‘.)
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
‘c
H-
CD
3
C)
3
o
CD
Ft
H-
Ft
H-
3
Ft
I-h
CD
0
CD
3
0
Ft
Cl
Ft
<
3
0
CD
CD
0
F-
I-
L<
CD
CD
-
CD
0
-Q
0
L<
o
CD
H-
H-
ci
Ft
h-h
CD
CD
F—i
CD
0
CD
o
3
H-
3
H-
3
3’
0
Ft
C)
H-
H-
3
Ft
CD
CD
Cl
hi
H-
F-’
Ft
H-
CD
CD
hi
F—’
CD
0
•
CD
F-
CD
H-
D
CD
Q
1<
CD
CD
-<
‘-<
H-
0
H-
H-
Ft
CD
ci
0
Ft
C)
0
CD
CD
Z
H-
3
C)
H
5
5
H-
ci
H-
CD
CD
ci
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
Cl
S
CD
hi
0
ci
Cl
hi
Ft
CD
CD
-1-
L<
Ft
ci
S
ci
Ft
CD
hi
Ft
L<
H-
C)
CD
H-
CD
S
0
h-h
CD
Ft
CD
ci
a)
M
N)
N)
N)
N)
F
)—
F-’
H
F-’
H
F-’
F-
H
F-’
W
N)
f-
C)
cc
0)
—J
g
(11
J
U)
N)
H
0
cc
—i
01
C-
U)
N)
I—’
I—h
C)
0
Ft
H
H-
CD
a
‘t3
H-
CD
Di
CD
h
H-i
CD
0
H-
F-
CD
II
CD
CD
cQ
rt
CD
CD
H-
Ft
0
C)
I—a
I--h
0
3
CD
I-
Ft
CD
ct
CD
CD
H-
Ft
-
CD
CD
CD
Z
H
CD
CD
II
CD
Ft
3
CD
rI-
CD
H
Z
(/2
Ii
rt
L<
CD
a
3
CD
C)
C)
3
CD
F-
H
Ct)
Q
3
CD
CD
Ft
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
h
Ft
Q
CD
Ft
Ft
H-
tY
K)
Q.
CD
J
Q
D
•
ct
Ft
H-
•
0
H-
Q
F
CD
H-
H-
CD
3
C)
3
I—’
CD
CD
3
H-
Ft
rt
H-
H
0
0
CD
H-
-
CD
CD
ct
0
I—h
CD
CD
h
ct
rt
CD
p—i
3
Ft
F-
<
‘-<
H-
F-
CD
Ft
CD
I-
CD
CD
H-
-
0
3
0
t
Ft
CD
Ft
H-
-
Ft
Ft
h’
Ft
C)
cQ
CD
CD
ç
C)
Ft
CD
CD
I-H
(/)
•‘J
‘-<
t3
I—’
<
3
H-
3
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
CD
CD
CD
3
Ft
3
Q
CD
H-
CD
3
Ft
t
Ft
C)
CD
Q-
CD
CD
Ft
3
Ft
CD
H-
CD
0
ii
CD
C)
CD
H-
CD
D
•.
3
CD
CD
3
t-h
C
CD
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
H
‘-<
CD
C).
Ft
0
H-
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
1-1
CD
Ft
‘
CD
I
3
CD
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
0
I-H
I
-<
<
Ft
L<
CD
CD
3
CD
CD
‘-<
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
0
0
Ft
Ft
C)
CD
CD
H-
0
3
3
Di
Ft
CD
D
H-
CD
I-
0
CD
3
Ft
CD
Ft
3
H-
CD
F—’
I--s
ht
CD
H-
3
1
•
a
CD
CD
3
3
h
‘-<
a
CD
0
CD
a
CD
Ft
CD
H-
CD
X
CD
3
Ft
CD
I—h
Hi
CD
CD
CD
cC)
F-
CD
0
Ft
0
Q
-
C)
CD
a
C)
0
CD
3
C)
CD
Ii
3
3
Ft
Ft
Ft
0
0
I—’
3
CD
CD
0
I—’
CD
C)
C)
CD
•
Ft
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
II
0
CD
—J-
CD
3
0
F-
Ft
1
‘C3
F—’
CD
a
CD
-<
H-
CD
‘-<
Ft
CD
<
CD
L<
H
H
3
Ft
•
Ft
0
3
C)
C)
CD
0
Ft
0
CD
3
0
Ft
CD
CD
CD
Ft
I-
Ft
i
a
0
CD
Ft
Ft
‘-<
Ft
•J
H-
CD
CD
Ft
3’
Z
‘
CD
5
Ft
Y
a
CD
a
a
Ft
0
CD
0
Ft
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
‘c
0
D
CD
H
H-
CD
<
3
II
Ft
H-
CD
Ft
CD
cC)
CD
Ft
CD
H-
CD
3
CD
H
CD
3
0
Di
l-
II
cC)
Ft
C
Ft
CD
H-
Ft
H-
Ft
l—
0
[1
CD
3
C
a
Ft
Ft
H-
H-
CD
CD
CD
Ft
CD
C)
3
CD
0
CD
3
M-
CD
Ft
CD
H
H-
Ft
H-
H-
F-
h-
C)
CD
CD
3
-
C)
0
Ft
H-
Ft
<1
cC)
CD
a
0
Ft
CD
0
CD
3
CD
CD
0
a
CD
I—’
3
CD
H-
CD
0
CD
C)
Ft
Ft
Ii
H-
a
CD
C)
CD
CD
I-I
CD
Z
H
z
0
ID
3
L’J
Ft
U)
0
h’
CD
CD
Ft
1<
0
0
H
3
Ft
CD
3
a
H
3
cC)
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
CD
Dl
CD
Ft
0
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
H
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
C)
I-
H-
Ft
CD
H
0
Hi
cC)
CD
CD
CD
I-H
a
0
Ft
Di
CD
Ft
CD
CD
CD
C)
H
H-
C)
tj
CD
cC)
CD
H-’
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
F-
F
I—i
H
F
F-
-
H
F
-
w
NJ
i-
0
co
o
ai
cn
W
NJ
0
co
Co
—J
o
c
i
NJ
—
C)
t3
cQ
15
Q
0
15
ci
CD
Q
3
CD
H-
CD
H-
Q.
<
Q.
CD
Mi
H-
CD
Di
H-
ft
j
3
ct
C)
H-
çt
C)
ct
H-
ci
ft
<
Q
Di
C)
ft
Di
ft
Di
0
CD
0
Dl
5
H-
ft
0
0
ft
H-
ct
ct
CD
C)
Q
Di
ci
ft
0
Mi
ft
II
ft
Di
3
H-
CD
0
0
CD
CD
‘C3
Mi
Di
15
Di
ft
0
Di
i
3
15
CD
15
CD
CD
H-
CD
5
H-
ft
3
ç-t
ct
CD
H
CD
15
15
3
C)
0
CD
ft
H
CD
H-
0
H-
ft
CD
Di
ft
ft
Di
-J-
CD
-
Di
H
CD
H
Mi
Di
<
X
H
•.)
CD
ci
X
CD
ft
ft
H-
Di
C))
)J
ft
H
C)
F—i
CD
C)
ft
CD
o
CD
L’l
ft
ft
CD
L1
ct
CD
it
J
Di
Di
CD
H-
CD
C)
H
Di
CD
<
H-
H
)J
çt
CD
Q
II
H-
ft
çt
ft
U)
H-
3
3
CD
cC)
Z
-
I-H
H-
C).
Z
15
CD
I-H
CD
5
0
Z
cC)
C).
H-
cci
H
C)
ci
ft
H-
‘
CD
CD
H
0
CD
CD
ci
Di
CD
X
L’J
it
Z
H
CD
CD
ft
L’J
CD
CD
Z
CD
CD
C)
ti
ft
0
CD
U)
D
L’i
CD
CD
II
CD
CD
U)
CD
Li
CD
-,
<
H
U)
H-
Mi
ft
Q
15
Di
U)
Dl
‘
H-
Cl
Di
0
U)
0
Di
0
-,
H-
CD
ft
U)
0
-<
II
Di
U)
Di
ft
ci
15
3
ft
Mi
-‘
CD
<
ft
3
H-
H-
Mi
I-H
CD
0
CD
U)
-,
CD
ft
CD
CD
Hi
U)
H-
3
CD
CD
Di
ci
ft
CD
‘-<
0
Di
Di
‘-<
0
H-
C)
15
C)
H
ft
H
J
0
<
C)
J
H-
C)
‘<
cQ
H
CD
ft
0
CD
Q
Di
0
ci
H-
CD
0
CD
3
I-’
H-
H-
0.
CD
ci
3
II
Di
15
ft
Mi
Mi
CD
Di
H-
3
Mi
CD
Q
ft
Di
15
ft
ft
•
CD
H
LY
ft
cC)
ft
H-
ft
CD
CD
CD
‘-<
H-
0
H
CD
I-H
0
D
3
Mi
C)
C)
Di
Di
0
0
Cl
CD
15
ft
Mi
Di
cC)
Di
ft
0
ft
ft
CD
0.
ci
CD
cQ
H-
C)
ft
C)
•
ci
•
CD
CD
II
ci
Di
Di
Di
ft
Di
ft
Di
H
C)
CD
CD
Di
CD
ft
3
H
0
ft
Cl
CD
Di
CD
H-
CD
Cl
CD
CD
3
H-
ft
15
CD
0
C).
ft
CD
CD
0
Mi
CD
CD
H-
CD
ii
CD
Di
-<
•o
CD
3
0
cC)
Q.
15
0
CD
Cl
ft
Cl
ci
H
0
Cl
C)
H
CD
Di
CD
ft
ci
CD
H
ci
CD
H
Cl
3
-
15
0
ft
CD
II
I—I
ft
0
ft
CD
Di
15
0
3
3
CD
ft
CD
0
‘-<
ft
CD
ci
Di
0
Di
CD
ft
ft
CD
ft
ci
ci
ft
Mi
CD
II
H-
J
CD
I—
H-
Di
cC)
ft
ft
Di
CD
Di
0
cC)
Di
ft
CD
CD
0
15
DC)
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
ft
3
CD
ft
CD
15
3
ft
NJ
M
N)
t’J
r’J
N)
-
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
-
W
N)
H
CD
D
CD
(3i
Ui
U)
N)
H
0
co
CD
—J
C5
Ui
U)
N)
F-’
CD
çt
CD
X
CD
0
Mi
C)
CD
Mi
CD
it
II
CD
[-
H
(_)
Cl)
CD
it
it
0
it
CD
Di
C
D
Di
it
CD
it
it
CD
Mi
<
it
H-
•
H
0
)<
D
H
Di
<
CD
CD
3
1’l
it
0
H-
it
Di
X
Di
it
Dl
o
i
CD
C
3
CD
it
CD
it
C)
H
CD
HI
Cl)
it
Cl)
it
‘S
it
it
it
it
CD
Di
H-
it
it
CD
Y
H-
Q
it
it
it
-<
Di
Z
CD
CD
CD
CD
H
0
CD
0
C)
it
C/)
Di
•
CD
h’l
C/)
2i
it
Q.
Di
r
Di
Di
3
CD
•
it
CD
CD
•
•
it
L’l
Mi
CD
H-
H-
CD
Di
-
C!)
H-
CD
H
H
it
Q
it
it
Di
C/J
3
it
H-
it
Di
3
F-
H
cC)
1
L’i
Z
Di
CD
3
H
H
cC)
Cl
C).
D
CD
c--)-
CD
Di
H-
CD
CD
><
C3
C)
it
CD
H
•
H-
CD
C
Di
Cl
Di
C/)
C
H
<
CD
it
H
Li
it
c<
z
it
it
F—I
CD
it
CD
0
CD
C)
H-
H-
CD
3
CD
L’J
C!)
CD
[?i
(-ii
0
it
H
Mi
3
CD
0
••
Di
U)
H-
it
it
C).
CD
LD
CD
H-
cC)
H-
H
Di
C!)
Di
3
D
0
0
CD
0
•
Di
CD
CD
CD
CD
it
<
CD
it
H-
CD
Ij
Di
3
Q.
H
C)
H
ç
D
CD
‘-<
it
it
3
CD
cC)
H-
H
i-i
CD
CD
h
0
CD
CD
0
H-
H
it
it
cC)
H-
CD
CD
-
Di
CD
CD
H
Di
i
it
0
0
it
CD
Di
0
Di
<1
i
cC)
Cl
3
CD
C)
CD
D
it
H
it
3
Mi
-
Cl
it
H
H-
it
Di
•
-1
it
Dl
‘ii
Di
3
Cl
Cl)
CD
cC)
3
H-
H
L-J-
H-
it
CD
Di
Cl)
H-
CD
CD
Z
Di
it
j
H-
C)
cC)
Mi
i
‘-<
it
I
h-
cQ
it
Cl)
Di
CD
0
CD
3
0
•
H-
0
CD
0
CD
I
H-
CD
it
0
CD
H-
C)
‘T3
it
CD
C)
‘C5
H-
3
CD
it
3
C)
3
H-
•
H-
it
H
(Ji
Di
CD
CD
Di
c-U
Cl
CD
0
it
Di
H-
0
3
H
Di
3
CD
F-
h
CD
Cl
it
0
3
d
H-
H-
Di
<
Di
Di
h
it
CD
i
H
3
Cl
H-
0
‘s
CD
it
[-
H-
cQ
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
3
CD
Hi
C)
3
Ii
Hi
H-
CD
it
C)
cC)
it
H-
CD
Mi
it
0
Di
CD
cC)
LJJ
3
Dl
0
0
it
CD
3
3
h
Di
3
Dl
H-
H
H
3
cC)
0
C)
CD
it
F-I
‘-<
3
h-
()
H-
13
it
it
1
it
CD
CD
it
‘-<
CD
H-
it
Mi
CD
•
CD
0
Q
it
3
H-
3
C)
3
CD
H-
CD
H
CD
0
CD
3
it
0
3
it
Di
cC)
•‘)
C)
it
•
H
3
CD
H-
it
CD
Di
H-
cl
3
Di
H-
3
1
3
CD
H
<
0
Di
it
3
0
0
H-
it
CD
cC)
<
CD
3
cQ
0
it
3
13
0
3
CD
H
3
-
Cl
it
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
HI
f-
HI
HI
HI
HI
HI
HI
HI
HI
W
NJ
HI
0
co
a)
—J
a)
U,
J
W
NJ
HI
0
cc
—J
a)
U’
U,
NJ
HI
Di
1Zi
a
a
a
CD
Di
C)
CD
C)
Ct
I-C)
a
LI
CD
Cl)
LI
CD
Di
Di
Ct
0
0
Dl
<
a
C)
1<
a
H
CD
0
3
CD
a
CD
LI
C)
LI
H-
Ct
H
H-
C3
LI
CD
it
Cl)
II
CD
CD
Z
II
CD
Di
cC)
LI
LI
LI
cQ
Di
çt
CD
CD
H-
Di
3
CD
CD
0
3
CD
CD
CD
0
Di
CD
H-
CD
H
CD
C).
H,
H-
it
C)
0
H
it
H
0
CD
C)
CD
Cl)
it
C)
H
Di
CD
Di
H
CD
CD
H-
a
a
H-
ct
H-
CD
CD
LI
3
C)
H-
•
H-
H
LI
Di
C)
H-
<i
a
CD
a
it
H-
3
3
Di
CD
CD
it
Di
0
CD
H
•
a
3
cC)
it
CD
Cl)
3
3
Di
Ct
LI
CD
H
H
a
o
c
C)
LI
it
Cl)
<
0
CD
<
3
CD
0
CD
H-
LI
CD
Di
3
0
H
CD
F-I
Di
Di
ID
it
it
CD
Di
3
H
CD
0
H-
Di
CD
H
3
CD
o
it
3
CD
H
CD
CD
0
it
LI
a
C)
Di
H-
H
CD
CD
CD
CD
H-
0
3
1
<
H
C)
CD
H-
Di
C)
3
•
H
‘-<
LI
CD
3
H
Di
CD
CD
Cl)
H
0
0
0
CD
3
3
CD
CD
H
o
it
<
Q
H-
CD
H
CD
<1
it
i
çt
H-
3
CD
c
0
H
CD
it
Di
CD
HI
CD
0
it
H-
H-
C)
CD
it
a
a
Di
3
H
D
Di
ct
3
LI
0
H
3
C)
çt
CD
0
3
it
çt
CD
3
3
H-
D
a
CD
H-
ct
3
0
it
0
H-
it
CD
H-
ct
CD
3
LI
Di
Di
C
Di
CD
H-
H-
‘-<
CD
D
X
C)
J
H-
CD
it
LI
‘ti
CD
3
it
Di
C)
Di
C)
3
3
-
CD
0
-<
LI
3
H
CD
s
CD
it
it
it
a
0
CD
cQ
D
0
LI
0
I-h
it
CD
H-
CD
Di
0
3
Di
CD
CD
Di
CD
Di
CD
Di
H
CD
0
I-h
0
LI
CD
0
a
CD
Di
H-
3
CD
3
t3
cQ
C1
X
a
0
3
H
<1
3
-
Cl)
a
LI
H-
3
H-
it
0
CD
0
CD
Di
H-
it
CD
CD
CD
it
0
CD
a
Ii
Di
CD
H
CD
0
LI
it
CD
0
‘<
3
CD
•
[-I
LI
CD
Di
c
it
CD
3
a
H
H-
it
a
CD
H
it
it
LI
H
3
a
CD
it
H-
H
çt
LI
I-Q
0
H-
0
CD
Di
H
CD
it
0
3
0
3
Di
Di
CD
CD
CD
it
it
it
a
H
0
CD
it
CD
CD
H
C)
3
Di
D
CD
C)
C)
LI
3
LI
Di
•
CD
H-
3
Di
H-
CD
it
3
CD
it
D
Di
H-
3
E
a
Di
1
D
CD
it
CD
CD
a
CD
Cli
3
CD
CD
-f,
0
H
ci-
CD
c<
H
<
CD
H-
CD
C)
Di
3
Di
it
1
C)
-<
0
Di
a
3
CD
CD
CD
3
Di
Di
0
it
cC)
it
C)
Cli
0
0
‘c
II
it
LI
C)
LI
a
CD
it
H-
CD
H-
Di
it
LI
3
‘3
H
3
0
CD
H-
Di
it
CD
CD
LI
0
CD
C)
3
CD
3
0
0
LI
CD
H
CD
it
Di
C)
Di
LI
H-
3
LI
-
H
LI
Di
LI
0
I—I
it
b
it
a
3
CD
H-
LI
LI
Di
it
CD
H-
cC)
Di
1
0
CD
a
a
C)
cC)
3
H-
CD
it
LI
LI
3
Di
H
Di
3
Di
Di
CD
0
‘
Di
CD
CD
C)
3
cC)
CD
3
C)
CD
a
CD
it
it
II
3
H
3
H,
CD
Ci
CD
CD
CD
a
CD
a
Di
a
Ci
a
F-
H
o
Di
CD
r
LI
Di
H-
Di
3
0
Di
it
C)
CD
H
3
a
Di
a
H
i
-
H
Di
H
a
cC)
CD
H
a
H-
3
it
0
it
CD
H
0
H
0
3
a
CD
Di
-
CD
CD
M
E\)
M
I-
i-
F-
H-
I-
H
H
W
N)
H
CD
)
CD
CD
0’
0’
N)
H
0
CD
CD
0’
N)
rt
Di
0
ct
CD
r1
LLI
C)
H-
C)
1h
c-I-
CD
11
CD
F<
0
CD
i-<
CD
CD
CD
Di
h
0
Di
3
c-I-
CD
c-I-
X
Cl)
c-I-
U)
H
0
CD
1
Cl
CD
0
Cl)
H-
CD
H-
TJ
c-I-
CD
Di
CD
CD
Cl
CD
CD
CD
h
0
(D
CD
Y
Di
Ct
J
H-
‘t3
Q.
H-
Q.
0
0
II
CD
CD
c-I-
Di
H
CD
Di
CD
0
•
CD
•
H
Di
C)
•
H
Di
0
CD
CD
ft
Di
c-I-
Di
çt
L’i
c-I-
CD
Dl
(C)
H
c-I-
ct
CD
c-I-
CD
CD
Dl
7i
H-
c-I-
1
Z
CD
CD
CD
D
H-
H-
CD
CD
CD
C)
CD
CD
Lx]
F-
c-I-
c-I-
c-I-
Di
CD
b
Cl
••
CD
C)
C/)
CD
Di
ct
-‘
h
H-
Q
Di
CD
Di
•
0
C/)
CD
c-I-
Z
c-I-
0
çt
C)
H
h
0
3
F-i
•.
CD
X
CD
CD
Xl
Di
Di
H-
Di
c-I-
H-
Cl
i
Di
F-h
Q.
c-I-
Di
U)
CD
•
H-
H-
Ct
Di
H-
Cl
H-
c-I-
CD
3
CD
Cl
<
l
H-
H-
ci
H
Cl
3
c-I-
c-I-
CD
Di
H
CD
3
C)
CD
0
Cl
H-
CD
0
Di
c-I-
Z
0
CD
0
CD
Di
CD
II
0
CD
0
h
H
Z
c-I-
CD
1C3
H
3
<
H
3
CD
Di
çt
3
Lxi
C)
CD
Lxi
CD
CD
Di
Di
H-
i
Ct
h
CD
CD
j
C’]
I-I
CD
U)
F-
H
3
H
3
c-I-
Di
3
0
c-I-
U)
U)
CD
CD
••
ci
ct
ii
Lxi
Cl
H-
CD
CD
0
ct
H-
ti
Di
••
••
c-I-
CD
Lx
Di
d
c-I-
I-
CD
ci
0
Q
0
H-
3
CD
Di
c-I-
Di
-<
H-
Di
CD
H
H-
H-
ci
ci
3
Cl
H
l
rt
CD
C)
<
Cl
c-I-
CD
H
H-
Di
H
H
0
3
H-
ft
C)
0
Di
CD
I
Cl
0
ii
-
II
Cl
3
1
0
II
H
H
3
Di
‘-<
I
I
3
Cl
Di
c-I-
0
3
H-
-
çt
0
I
CD
D
CD
çt
Di
C)
c-I-
Di
C)
c-I-
CD
ci
çt
CD
çt
CD
0
3
H
ct
0
CD
I-
I-I
CD
H-
Di
CD
C)
CD
ci
CD
Cl
3
F-
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
c-I-
Di
Di
CD
Cl
1
Di
H
CD
H-
Di
c-I-
•‘J
3
CD
c-I
Ii
Cl
CD
0
H-
Di
c-I-
CD
CD
3
Di
3
3
H
<
CD
ci
Cl
-
CD
II
C)
H-
H
CD
ct
-
Di
CD
H-
H-
L<
CD
H
CD
I-i
H-
H-
CD
CD
J
0
CD
CD
0
ct
Q.
II
H
Di
H-
H-
Cl
Cl
CD
Cl
II
ci
CD
Di
H-
0
0
CD
II
II
I-i
CD
H-
3
çt
c-I-
ct
ci
C)
Lx
H
0
Cl
F-h
Di
CY
Dl
•
C)
CD
Lx
Lx
Di
Di
CD
Dl
<
c-I
‘<
tQ
CD
H-
H
W
H
it
Di
c-I-
H-
F-h
3
I-i
(1)
it
Lx
H
ci
H
CD
Lx
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
Cl
J
CD
ct
it
-<
Di
C)
Di
H-
Di
CD
CD
I--h
Ct
H-
Q
H-
0
c-I-
CD
F-h
H
H
Dl
CD
Lx
Lx
ft
3
H-
CD
c-I-
H
0
c-I-
H-
c-I-
C)
I
CD
CD
c-I-
H-
CD
Dl
c-I-
Lx
c-I-
I
c-I-
3
3
0
CD
Q
CD
L.Q
CD
Di
c-I-
CD
h
CD
3’
CD
CD
H-
c-I-
I
-
I
0’
Page 46
1
Ms.
Nemura
of how
to
set a
wet
weather
2
standard?
3
THE
WITNESS:
I would concur
with
her
4
comments.
5
BY MS.
DIERS:
6
Q.
Is the
habitat
study
that
you’re
7
involved
in,
would
it
help
one work
on
a
proposal
8
for
a wet
weather
standard?
9
A.
It’s
a
foundation,
but,
in
the
case
of
10
wet weather,
there’s
many
other
complicating
factors
11
that
aren’t
specifically
addressed
in the
habitat
12
study.
13
Q.
And what
are those
complicated
14
factors?
15
A.
I think I
detailed
them
before,
the
16
rising
and lowering
of
flow,
the
existance
of
storm
17
water loads,
what
might
be
happening
with
combined
18
sewer
overflows
and pump
stations, scour
and
19
sediment
deposition
as a result
of
changes
in flow
20
and the
stagnation
conditions.
I think
you’d
have
21
to consider all
those
factors,
when considering
a
wet
22
weather
provision.
23
Q.
Prefiled
Question
12.
24
“In your
prefiled
testimony on
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
I-
F
H
-
F-’
F—’
H
F-’
01
NJ
I—’
CD
co
0)
—J
0)
01
01
NJ
—‘
C)
j
0)
Ui
U)
NJ
I—’
F-I
Dl
H-
C)
C)
it
t3
t1
C)
Di
Cl
F-I
d
CD
C)
Q
CD
Di
D
CD
CD
0
it
CD
CD
H
Di
CD
CD
CD
it
CD
CD
Di
II
3
it
H-’
Q
Di
3
CD
Di
CD
CD
3
it
H
Di
C)
Di
Di
0
H
CD
H-
it
it
H-
Q
0
it
Cl
CD
C)
C)
3
3
CD
Y
H-
H-
‘c3
C)
‘CI
it
it
II
it
H-
h
T
CD
0
I—’
h-
I—’
C)
0
II
Di
II
Di
Cl
3
H-
it
H
I—’
0
-<
zO
3
)J
CD
H
0
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
F-
CD
-,
o
H-’
•
•J
•
it
CD
Cl
3
3
H-
<
Di
it
0
H-
H-
0
Di
CD
0
CD
it
CD
it
L’i
H-
CD
CD
I—h
H-
-1
CD
0
,Q
Di
Cl
it
Cl
H-
3
CD
CD
it
Hi
CD
II
N)
•
0
CD
Cl
Di
0
Cl
it
Di
H-
CD
CD
3
it
I-I
•‘J
it
it
F-
•
Di
it
Di
H-
it
Hi
H
it
CD
HI
0
H-
H-
1
0
it
0
H-F
it
Di
CD
o
Di
CD
H-
Di
C)
Di
it
CD
CD
h
CD
H-
CD
C)
Cl
Di
it
HI
CD
H-’
M
Di
3
Di
Ij
H-
h-h
Cl
H-’
‘-<
CD
it
Di
0
it
it
3
Di
CD
Di
CD
‘C3
3
<
1
0
H-
CD
H
it
Q
CD
Cl
3
Cl
hI
0
0
H-
‘-<
H-
Mi
H-
Hi
Di
CD
hI
CD
it
it
it
CD
0
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
it
Cl
Di
H-
Hi
CD
Cl
CD
hI
‘t
CD
CD
CI
CD
3
CD
3
0
H-
it
it
Hi
CD
H-
lj
CD
I—I
CD
hI
CD
Di
Di
Cl
CD
H
CD
hI
3
CD
C)
0
3
it
CD
Di
0
3
it
CD
CD
Di
hI
CD
0
I—h
0
hI
<
it
H-
it
Cl
it
c
it
‘-<
CD
it
CD
CD
it
H-
0
H-
CD
0
CD
<
0
Di
it
Dl
0
J
F-
Cl
Cl
Cl
it
0
it
Di
t
tY
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
C)
CD
it
‘-<
Di
Di
0
it
hI
hI
,Q
H-’
CD
Cl
‘t3
CD
Cl
CD
‘t
Di
CD
3
hI
tY
CD
0
0
CD
Cl
CD
Di
CD
CD
CD
it
F-I
H-
it
hI
CD
H-
hI
<
CD
it
it
hI
Cl
Di
<
3
CD
F-
CD
CD
C)
CD
0
CD
0
CD
CD
F—h
Y
Di
CD
Di
0
Cl
Q
hI
HI
Di
0
H-’
CD
CD
it
C
CD
it
CD
iQ
Di
CD
CD
H-
Cl
Cl
3
Di
0
Hi
CD
HI
it
3
CD
it
hI
Q
Di
3
CD
3
0
C)
Q
0
Cl
it
0
CD
H-
Di
Cl
CD
it
CD
Hi
0
it
H-’
Cl
H-
hI
3
hI
Mi
CD
Di
CD
it
it
0
H-
L<
C)
CD
CD
H-
0
it
,Q
Di
H-
hI
CD
0
CD
CD
Di
<
H-
•
C)
it
i
H-
it
CD
0
H-
0
H-’
hI
H-
‘-<
0
C)
Di
CD
Di
hI
0
H-
HI
Di
it
‘
it
CD
C)
CD
3
C)
H-’
CD
Di
HI
H-’
CD
it
Ii
H-
H-
JF
0
CD
•‘J
Cl
D
H-’
it
<z
Di
it
H
hI
CD
C)
it
H-
‘-<
H-
Di
CD
it
Di
Mi
Di
CD
C)
C)
Cl
CD
it
it
CD
H-
Q
CD
it
Di
HI
0
H-
D
0
CD
‘-<
CD
F-I
CD
CD
CD
0
it
h-h
-<
C)
CD
H-
CD
0
CD
HI
3
Cl
0
Di
-<
CD
H-’
F-’
CD
it
CD
0
CD
it
F—’
CD
C)
H-
N)
CD
Di
CD
it
‘-<
it
D
L’i
Di
3
LQ
—
it
CD
Di
Di
d
0
3
0
0
C)
CD
Di
<
H-
h-h
Di
it
CD
CD
Cl
CD
CD
3
r,’)
‘J
N)
N)
N)
H
F-
F
H
H
F-
H-
F-
H-
(J
N)
I-
C)
Q
C)
C)
W
N)
I-
0
D
CX)
—J
C)
(ii
W
N)
H
1-h
CD
C3
H-
Di
CD
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
Ft
CD
t-L
CD
o
CD
CD
Ft
ii
Ft
<
Ft
)<
Ft
Lxi
Ft
Xj
<
LI
LI
b
Ft
0
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
Ft
CD
d
CD
Di
Ft
d
a
CD
H-
CD
LI
Ft
Q
Q
Q
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
H-
0
0
CD
H
CD
CD
CD
‘ti
H-
‘
CD
H-
H-
CD
i
CD
3
CD
<
CD
Ft
CD
i
CD
H
3
Ft
Ft
3
Ft
CD
3
CD
Ft
CD
H-
CD
Ft
C)
CD
CD
Ft
D
CD
0
CD
Q.
3
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
J
CD
LY
H
•
F-
H-
‘Q
CD
Ft
CD
H-
‘-<
CD
Q
L<
H
CD
3
H-
Ft
Ft
Ft
H
Ft
LI
-
CD
LI
[H
CD
3
‘t
H
CD
Ft
0
CD
0
0
H-
CD
Ft
LI
0
H
3
LI
Ft
3
CD
3
H
CD
CD
Ft
H-
Ft
H-
CD
<
Hi
CD
CD
0
D
Cl
•
C)
Ft
CD
‘-<
‘-<
Ft
1
H-
CD
Cl
-
0
H-
LI
D
CD
Q
0
a
H
0
CD
LI
H
Ft
0
Ft
0
CD
<
0
Ft
CD
Ft
Hi
CD
Ft
CD
I
0
Ft
i-h
CD
LI
LI
Ft
CD
Ft
Q
CD
CD
H
‘t
CD
Ft
Ft
Ft
Ft
a
J
Ft
Cl
LI
LI
‘-<
Ft
Ft
Cl
LI
Ft
CD
J
J
Ft
CD
H-
CD
Di
H-
H
H
0
CD
CJJ
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
Ft
CD
J
C)
CD
CD
CD
Cl
<1
LI
C
Ft
Ft
o
H-
Q
I—h
CD
CD
0
H-
LY
Ft
H-
H-
Ft
CD
LI
a
CD
Ft
H-
CD
‘-<
H
LI
0
i
Q.
CD
H-
CD
CD
H-
Ft
o
CD
Di
Ft
CD
Ft
0
H-
H
H-
0
CD
H
[H
i
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
0
-,
Hi
H
CD
CD
C)
Ft
Ft
Ft
CD
‘tI
0
CD
CD
H
H
C)
LI
CD
Ft
LY
0
H
H-
CD
C)
CD
CD
CD
Ft
H-
Ci
a
0
0
0
H
3
CD
CD
L
D
CD
0
<
CD
3
0
CD
Ft
LI
0
CD
C
CD
CD
Ft
CD
Dl
CD
CD
‘ti
‘ti
CD
LI
0
a
CD
0
CD
H
•
H-
LI
CD
LI
‘tI
CD
Ft
LI
Ft
H
0
a
CD
Ft
H
0
0
0
Ft
CD
CD
H-
CD
Cl
3
H-
H-
Ft
H
Dl
<1
LI
Ft
H-
LY
<
3
CD
C)
CD
Hi
CD
H
H-
CD
H
Ft
CD
Ft
H-
J
0
CD
CD
‘
Ft
3
Ft
H-,
LI
H
H-
0
Ft
L<
H
-,
Ft
CD
3
H-
0
LI
0
0
CD
Ft
3
LI
‘-<
H-
CD
0
Cl
<
C)
Ft
CD
LI
0
‘-<
CD
‘Cl
3
3
CD
CD
Ft
CD
CD
3
Ft
Ft
CD
H
CD
Ft
H-
Ft
1
Ft
3
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
C)
H-,
CD
Cl
CD
Q
Ft
Cl
CD
CD
0
CD
Ft
0
0
CD
o
•
CD
LI
Ft
Hi
Ft
H-
CD
l
LI
Ft
3
3
H-
Ft
Ft
CD
H-,
H-
0
CD
3
0
Ft
Ft
CD
a
o
3
Ft
H
Ft
CD
CD
CD
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
H-
LI
Ft
0
3
Ft
LI
CD
Ft
Ft
I
CD
3
[H
Ft
3
0
Ft
0
CD
CD
CD
LI
CD
Ft
I
Cl
CD
H
‘ti
a
Ft
CD
D
Ft
CD
H
H-
Ft
H
LI
CD
<
CD
Ft
CD
LI
‘-<
3
CD
Hi
Ft
0
H-
o
Ft
LY
-
H
CD
CD
Ft
LI
CD
Ft
CD
0
CD
LI
CD
L<
CD
H
a
0
CD
CD
‘-<
CD
H-
CD
CD
3
H-
•
CD
Ft
LI
CD
CD
‘rj
CD
Ft
H
L
Hi
0
0
Di
H-
‘
CD
H-
0
CD
0
H-
<
CD
i-h
o
1-h
l
CD
LI
H-CD
3
CD
0
CD
CD
LI
t’J
M
hJ
[\)
hJ
I—i
F
—
H
I-
-
H
I-
$s
()
‘J
H
0
co
CX)
—J
3i
01
03
H
0
CD
—J
CD
01
0)
L’)
-
hi
5i
0
3
H-
T5
IJJ
Ft
Mi
Hi
C)
CJ
ç-t
Ci
Mi
Mi
(I)
CD
Ft
CD
H-
Mi
0
3
3
D
CD
hi
0
H
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
ti
<
Ft
CD
CD
hi
hi
CD
0
hi
CD
H
CD
-I
C)
CD
H-
H-
CD
hi
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
CD
Mi
CD
CD
H
Ft
CD
Ft
H
l
Q.
I-i
CD
hi
3
Cl
hi
CD
0
Ft
3
CD
Ci
H-
Q
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
H-
hi
D
0
Ft
0
H-
Ft
hi
Ft
3
3
-
CD
H-
Cl
hi
H-
hi
CD
CD
3
I—h
Mi
H-
0
CD
tQ
C)
3
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
hi
hi
CD
H-
0
3
tI
()
CD
CD
Cl)
CD
Ft
0
L<
Ft
H
C)
Cl
Cl
Ft
C)
3
L<
3
•
I-
H
CD
H
Ci
0
CD
0
0
Ft
‘
D
CD
CD
CD
Ft
H
3
Cl
CD
Ft
Ci
Ft
Q
CD
3
Cl
hi
CD
Ft
C)
0
CD
3
-
Ci
CD
D
H-
H-
CD
0
0
H-
0
Cl
Hi
CD
CD
Cl
0
C)
CD
CD
3
CD
C5
CD
0
3
0
CD
Ft
Ft
Hi
CD
3
CD
3
C)
CD
0
0
3
Ft
CD
3
CD
CD
Ft
0
Ft
H
Cl
H-
C)
CD
Ci
hi
<
0
C
CD
Ft
H-
hi
3
hi
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
Cl
CD
Ft
Mi
0
0
Ci
Ci
CD
Ft
3
Ft
H
CD
hi
CD
Cl
3
CD
CD
H
3
0
H
Ci
hi
CD
0
CD
0
H
3
Ft
CD
hi
CD
Ft
CD
CD
Hi
H-
0
H-
Ft
D
Ci
H-
)‘
H-
W
hi
C)
Ft
CD
3’
CD
C!)
3
Ft
Mi
3
3
-<
CD
Mi
-<
hi
0
CD
0
H-
CD
CD
0
o
3
CD
CD
CD
CD
H-
Hi
3
Cl
CD
Ci
CD
C)
3
0
C)
Ft
Ci
CD
3
H-
CD
Ft
Ft
H-
C)
0
CD
Cl
I-I
3
hi
0
C)
3
0
CD
C)
CD
Ft
CD
D
Ft
C)
Cl
hi
Ft
H’
H
C)
Cl
H
3
CD
CD
0
Ft
3
tY
CD
3
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
Ft
H
J
H
Ci
F-
Ft
CD
3
CD
[‘1
H’
CD
5
H
CD
S
C)
H-
H-
<
CD
CD
CD
U)
hi
H-
Cl
I-H
hi
‘ij
C)
CD
Ft
CD
H-
<
CD
I--I
0
3
C)
CD
5
H-
•
CD
Cl
C)
CD
H
0
H
CD
.Q
CD
H
H
5
0
5
C)
Ft
Cl
0
Cl
CD
CD
0
Ci
Ft
‘-<
S
S
CD
H
CD
H-
H-
hi
CD
S
H-
3
5
0
ti
Q
Ft
J
CD
Cl
CD
Ft
Cl)
H-
H
CD
C)
CD
Ft
CD
C)
C)
5
Ci
CD
hi
H-
D
Cl)
H-
Ft
H-
CD
3
H
CD
CD
H
J
0
Ft
CD
CD
H
CD
o
C)
CD
C)
H-
.Q
.Q
0
-<
L1
Q
H-
CD
0
3
0
CD
hi
Cl
CD
5
0
CD
H-
‘
‘ii
0
‘
CD
Ft
Mi
hi
CD
CD
o
H
hi
H-
CD
5
Ft
C)
CD
tJ
-<
CD
CD
C)
CD
CD
0
CD
5
CD
H-
D
<
•J
1J
H-
Ft
L<
CD
CD
Ft
H-
CD
S
CD
‘tI
3
H
CD
H-
•\
0
CD
1’I
0
H-
•
CD
D
0
CD
Ft
CD
H
Ci
Cl
0
C)
0
CD
C)
5
5
‘d
Ci
<
CD
CD
Ci
CD
Mi
S
CD
H
Ft
D
Cl
CD
3
J)’
CD
•
CD
hi
Mi
0
H-
Ft
CD
CD
H-
•J
H
Ft
CD
-
hi
hi
CD
I-—1
H-
C)
Ft
S
5
hi
CD
,Q
5
0
C)
-,
0
H
CD
CD
-,
H
‘ti
U)
hi
CD
CD
CD
hi
Ci
Ft
Mi
CD
H-
•
C)
Ft
CD
H
hi
Ft
Ft
Cl
Cl
CD
H-
H
S
H-
CD
‘tI
0
Ft
D
hi
H-
CD
H-
CD
5
•
h-I
0
Ft
CD
Ft
Mi
Mi
hi
hi
S
S
CD
CD
S
Mi
S
•
CD
L’l
Mi
Mi
H-
H
S
0
hi
0
5
CD
Ft
0
H-
hi
H
C)
CD
0
H-
hi
‘-<
H-
CD
‘ti
CD
Ft
CD
CD
H-
H
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
Mi
S
CD
<1
<
0
3
0
CD
CD
S
S
H
C)
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
Cl
Cl
Ci
Ci
Cl
CD
Cl
CD
CD
H-
H-
5
5
3
Ft
‘
CD
H-
Ft
CD
H-
S
Mi
H-
Ft
0
H-
CD
<
Cl
Ft
Mi
S
CD
Mi
S
5
Ft
Q
w
CD
C)
H-
-
0
0
Ft
0
S
Mi
H-
‘-<
3
CD
LO
CD
CD
5
3
Ci
C)
CD
CD
hi
CD
CD
Q
H
CD
Ft
hi
CD
Ft
H-
0
CD
CD
Ft
5
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
-
F
F
-
F—i
H
I-
F
F
F—i
(3
N)
-
0
D
CO
—1
CO
(n
W
NJ
F
0
j
(5
(51
(J
NJ
-
H-
CD
CD
-
Ft
h
Di
C
C
ft
0
J
H-
Q
CD
-h
Cl
CD
HI
CD
Q
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
Ft
0
<
I-I
rt
Q.
F-
3
H
DJ
0
0
0
0
Q)
CD
hi
H-
ct
C
I-i
Q.
CD
Q
CD
C)
CD
CD
D
Ft
ct
ct
Q.
CD
CD
3D
o
C)
CD
0
0
H-
CD
ct
CD
ft
C)
ct
CD
I-I
CD
0
CD
l
0
0
Ft
CD
çt
C
C
h
F-
C
H-
C
ct
CD
C)
C
H
CD
<
CD
Ft
CD
.Q
CD
0
H-
CD
CD
CD
F-
Q.
C)
CD
rt
I-I
HI
CD
0
Cl)
Ft
rt
CD
.0
Ft
D
CD
T3
1’J
Ft
Ft
Cl
CD
hi)
CD
D
H
CD
hi
-ti
Ft
H-
HI
CD
CD
CD
hi)
0
hI
CD
k<
H-
0
DCli
H-
HI
0
Ft
ft
CD
Ft
1
H-
hi
•
CD
<
I—h
LQ
CD
H-
C)
Cl)
C)
ij
0
H-
H-
H-
C).
C
i-i
o
I-I
CD
C)
C)
Ft
CD
0
C)
C)
CD
CD
a
i
Cl
C)
H-
Ft
CD
.0
H-
Ft
HI
HI
H-
HI
-i
HI
CD
CD
Z
0
CD
a
D
CD
CD
CD
CD
C)
H
CD
CD
CD
3
CD
CD
ct
CD
CD
CD
CD
Cl)
H-
Z
CD
CD
Ft
hi
H-
CD
c-I
I-
H-
CD
CD
CD
<
Cl)
Ct
0
CD
Ft
Ct
o
0
H-
Q
CD
Cl)
0
0
CD
CD
hti
CD
<
3
IJJ
ct
C/)
C
CD
<
0
C
C)
CD
H-
H-
CD
CD
CD
••
Ft
H-
CD
CD
h
0
CD
CD
a
HI
C)
Ft
3
Ft
CD
HI
a
C)
H-
-<
CD
3
CD
ct
HI
Dl
C)
X
hi)
CD
CD
H-
3
a
CD
H-
a
CD
Ft
CD
CD
3
CD
H-
C
3
CD
Q
C)
CD
C
CD
CD
CD
a
CD
II
Cl
CD
CD
HI
HI
Q
C)
0
C)
HI
ct
I-I
Dl
C)
HI
CD
Q
CD
Ft
C)
ct
Ft
CD
CD
1’i
C)
CD
C)
CD
0
H-
HI
H-
H-
C)
CD
H-
CD
ct
CD
a
0
ITJ
Ft
HI
hi)
CD
3
Dl
CD
H-
H)
hi
CD
CD
>
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
Ft
H-
Ft
3
Ft
CD
‘
II
CD
II
C/)
‘-<
—-
C
CD
C)
CD
Ft
0
‘-<
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
0
0
C
CD
0
t-h
Ft
H-
H•
Ft
CD
-
N
LQ
H)
C
CD
-.
3
0
0
U.
I
0
a
H-
a
CD
D
H-
HI
CD
Ft
CD
HI
Ft
CD
C
CD
Ft
CD
i
CD
‘-<
Ft
Ft
hI
Ft
HI
3
H-
CD
i
a
I-I
•
0
H-
Dl
D
CD
CD
D
CD
0
CD
F-i
Ft
CD
H-
0
CD
I-I
Ft
C
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
1Y
II
H-
Cl)
CD
a
3
Ft
CD
0
HI
hi)
CD
CD
0
HI
CD
CD
<
•
H-i
a
CD
CD
CD
C
C
H-
H-
H-
C
Ft
Ft
3
C
CD
CD
CD
3
0
CD
HI
3
Ft
t3
CD
C)
CD
t
Cl
HI
Ft
C)
Ft
0
hI
I-h
•
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
a
CD
hi
H
H-
CD
<
•
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
a
H-
H-
I
3
Ft
0
CD
H-
CD
Ft
hi
‘-CI
H-
Q
CD
C
a
0
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
Dl
CD
CD
hi
hi
l
3
J
CD
0
Cl
Ft
-H
a
CD
CD
(I)
‘-<
CD
CD
0
Page 51
1
the Cal
Sag as
having
steep
solid
walls.
You
2
know,
it
sounds
awful similar
to
me.
3
And
as
another
example,
I think
we
4
spent
a
lot of
time
on
Bubbly Creek
about its
5
unique
conditions
and stagnation
and
6
stratification
with Dr.
Melching,
and
7
Dr. Garcia.
And
even Dr. Dennison’s
8
discussion.
9
And the
-- so
the conditions
in
10
Bubbly
Creek
are
unique,
even within
the
11
context
of the
uniqueness of
the
CAWS.
But,
12
furthermore,
I found it
quite
surprising that
13
in
that very specialized
unique area,
that
14
the IEPA had
no
data
on the Bubbly
Creek
to
15
demonstrate
how
it would fit
in any
of the
16
use classifications.
17
So
it
was
my
conclusion that
the
18
IEPA had failed
in
their ability
to provide
19
the necessary
scientific
justification.
20
BY MS.
DIERS:
21
Q.
Question
16.
22
“Row
did
you
term that
the
23
biological
potential
of the Calumet
Sag Channel
is
24
less than
the
biological
potential
represented
by
N)
N)
N)
N)
N)
-
F
H
I-
H
H
I-
H
W
N)
H
C)
co
0)
-J
C)
01
W
N)
H
0
ç
CX)
-J
C)
ui
N)
H
ct
0
t)
t
CD
CD
H-
Cl
r1
It
It
CD
LII
H
It
H-
CD
0
0
:i
CD
3
CD
3
0
D
0
CD
H
o
0
CD
ci
H
cQ
CD
H-
CD
Cl
H
CD
CD
H
ct
H
CD
CD
H
H
H-
H-
0
CD
hL
H-
Hi
CD
H-
CD
t
0
Cl
C).
3
It
CD
Cl
cQ
H-
CD
D
CD
-
0
)
0
H-
CD
H-
3
CD
H
CD
Di
CD
i
CD
h
H-
CD
><
C)
It
CD
CD
I-
çt
H
It
Cl
CD
ct
CD
CD
H
H
H-
H
0
It
H-
H
•
H
D
ci
CD
C)
0
H
H
CD
0
CD
It
C)
F-
Hi
CD
L’l
CD
h
0
Cl
CD
CD
‘-<
•
-
0
cC)
CD
Z
It
CD
It
3
ci
H-
CD
L’i
•
CD
Cl
C)
3
CD
Cl
II
H-
Cl
Cri
H-
CD
0
It
CD
Y
CD
Cl)
CD
ct
C).
H
CD
H
It
D
It
H
0
CD
H
••
CD
H-
H-
CD
CD
CD
H-
3
I_I
0
LY
CD
II
ct
•
Cl
CD
3
<
CD
CD
H-
It
H-
0
CD
Hi
0
C)
1’
It
CD
L
C-
H
It
Q
D
3
CD
CD
3
Cl
cC)
CD
Cl
ci
3
Z
C)
CD
CD
It
CD
H-
Cl
H
Cl
CD
H-
CD
V
ID
CD
CD
It
h-I
It
‘d
H
CD
It
0
It
L’i
CD
L<
It
Cl
CD
CD
C)
H-
Cl
It
C)
H
H
Cl)
Cl
CD
h
0
CD
•
H-
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
!-
It
It
ID
ct
CD
H
3
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
D
It
C)
<
cC)
h
3
o
C)
><
CD
CD
0
Cl
CD
II
CD
CD
CD
0
0
H
ci
CD
H-
ct
CD
çt
CD
H-
It
•
C)
CD
CD
C5
It
CD
0
•
CD
H-
CD
t3
0
ct
0
CD
CD
ct
It
CD
CD
h-I
It
CD
ci
0
CD
H
It
F-’
CD
h±
H
It
tY
ct
It
CD
H
ci
H-
CD
0
I-c
CD
It
H-
C)
o
H
CD
CD
3
I
0
0
I-I
H-
It
><
0
CD
CD
I
cC)
CD
3
CD
CD
N
CD
H
It
CD
It
CD
H-
0
-
3
CD
CD
It
H
3
0
i
CD
CD
‘-<
CD
H
CD
0
It
H-
H-
H
Q
H
<
0
It
H-
I-h
CD
H
CD
CD
CD
CD
H-
0
ci
Cl
0
It
I
CD
It
CD
I-H
H-
Cl
ci
Cl
0
CD
-
ci
3
CD
H
‘c
tJ
CD
D
3
H-
CD
ci
CD
CD
CD
ct
cC)
Cl
3
ci
CD
CD
0
CD
Cl
H-
It
H
CD
CD
It
CD
J
C)
0
It
H
CD
‘TJ
l-
It
It
çt
H-
CD
CD
CD
H
ci
cC)
W
-<
CD
CD
I-h
CD
H-
3
tY
CD
H
CD
cC)
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
0
h
3
0
ct
•
‘TJ
Ij
II
ci
CD
Cl
II
cC)
ci
D
CD
CD
0
CD
H-
It
It
L<
CD
CD
It
It
CD
It
It
I—I
H-
CD
H-
C)
CD
•
It
It
It
D
It
CD
H
It
It
It
CD
0
CD
CD
0
CD
-
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
-
c<
h-I
H-
Di
CD
It
3
-.
•
CD
‘C3
CD
CD
cC)
cC)
CD
Cl
CD
H-
It
CD
NJ
N)
I’-)
N)
H
H
F-
I-
l—
H
I-
H
H
F
W
N)
HI
0
co
CD
-J
(3
(fl
(.J
NJ
HI
0
ç
-J
CD
(31
(3)
NJ
HI
Cl)
C)
H-
Di
J
C)
Q
C/)
C)
C/)
Ft
C)
h-
0
CD
ct
C)
C)
Ft
Dl
HI
H-
0
H-
Dl
CD
H-i
Ft
Di
Di
CD
H-
ct
Dl
h-h
Dl
ft
HI
Dl
Di
Di
Dl
Di
U-
F-
CD
CD
Ct
Di
CD
C/)
H
HI
F-
rt
hi
C)
Di
Q.
ct
0
hi
‘—I-
Cl)
H-
CD
hi
0
CD
H-
Di
hi
(11
Ct
Ft
CD
0
Ft
H-
C)
CD
Q
U-
C)
CD
Di
H-
Cl)
hi
0
h-h
ct
c-t
CD
Di
()
ci)
h-h
Ct
H-
F-
CD
‘
C/)
CD
Ft
tO
H-
CD
Ft
hi
C)
Ct
Ft
Di
t
hi
CD
H
HI
0
C)
CD
C)
Q
Cl)
CD
Di
Cl)
L<
H-
k<
hi
Cl
hi
h-h
H-
Ct
hi
ct
ct
Ft
Di
H-
C)
0
N
0
Di
Di
Q
Di
CD
H-
0
HI
<
0
CD
Di
ci
Ft
t
C)
3
hi
3
CD
H-
Cl)
hi
0
Cl)
CD
C)
ct
0
CD
0
3
CD
Cl
3
t
3
3
0
Di
Di
H-
3
Cl
H-
CD
Di
Ft
Di
hi
F-
ci
0
CD
-<
h-h
H-
H-
HI
HI
C)
çt
Ft
3
CD
0
Ft
Ft
Di
CD
Cl)
Cl)
3
CD
3
3
H-
5
D
Cl
hi
h-h
0
CD
CY
0
CD
Cl
‘-<
3
Cl
CD
o
CD
CD
H-
CD
0
‘-<
0
hi
Cl)
Di
Ii
ct
Cl)
H-
çt
Ct
3
Cl)
I
1<
h-h
t
0
0
0
0
Q
ct
o
ct
-<
C)
3
CD
Di
CD
0
I
0
0
-
<
h-h
3
0
ci
CD
3
CD
CD
Ft
H-
“
ci
Ft
hi
CD
CD
C/)
CD
Di
(Q
3
0
ct
ct
Cl
ft
D
Q
CD
Ft
hi
h-h
CD
3
H-
H-
Cl)
CD
<
3
CD
0
3
3
Di
Di
C)
Cl
Cl)
CD
Cl)
hi
ct
0
CD
Di
0
Cl
0
CD
hi
HI
Di
CD
Ft
Ft
‘
0
CD
ci
C)
ci
-<
<
Cl)
Di
0
3
CD
HI
CD
-
D
H-
CD
3
CD
<
H-
HI
Di
0
Cl)
HI
CD
-
Di
CD
ct
‘-<
Di
l
CD
ci
LJ
CD
Di
CD
HI
0
Q
hi
-‘
hi
ci
CD
C/)
Ft
0
Q
-<
‘ti
•
HI
C/)
CD
3
Di
C)
Di
0
CD
0
CD
hi
H-
CD
C/)
CD
D
ct
<
ci
H-
Cl)
0
HI
C)
C)
CD
HI
Dl
Ft
D
0
Di
Di
Ft
ci
C)
ci
0
ct
‘
hi
CD
CD
ft
C/)
0
CD
<
Ft
H-
-,
H-
Cl
0
CD
H-
Di
C)
CD
HI
CD
Ft
ci
hi
H-
3
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
H-
hi
ci’
Di
ci
0
Di
ci
Ft
CD
3
ct
ct
hi
3
Ft
H-
H-
ft
CD
hi
Q.
Di
hi
C)
Cl
HI
Cl
Dl
Ft
Ft
-
CD
it
H-
ci
N
H-
CD
‘tI
3
(Q
ci
‘-<
—1
H-
H
0
0
ft
CD
Ft
H-
0
(Q
Dl
C)
H-
Di
Y’
hi
Cl
CD
hi
ci
C)
h-h
C)
Di
i
h-h
ci
Ft
ft
Ft
C/)
CD
CD
hi
Di
Ft
CD
Di
0
Ft
Ft
II
H-
Cl)
Di
H-
ft
Q
CD
ci
ft
Ft
Di
ft
ci
C)
Ft
0
H-
Di
Ft
Di
CD
H-
CD
ci
Cl
H-
Di
CD
ft
ci
H-
H-
CD
H-
ci
Cl)
Cl)
ft
b
ci
HI
ci
Ft
ci
hi
CD
hi
Ft
Ft
ci
H-
ci
Di
HI
Cl)
CD
CD
Cl)
CD
Ft
CD
I
Ft
0
Dl
H-
CD
Ft
CD
H-
Cl)
hi
ft
0
Di
ft
ft
ft
h-h
I
Ft
ci
Ft
Ft
Di
Di
Ft
Cl)
Di
Di
CD
0
0
Ft
Cl
•
CD
Ft
CD
0
HI
1Y
CD
ft
•J
Ft
ci
hi
ci
H-
0
0
0
CD
H-
0
h-h
H-
H-
Ft
Di
H-
Cl)
HI
Ft
ci
ci
‘-Q
N
Ft
ft
Ft
Ft
Ft
H-
Ft
Cl
-
I
HI
HI
ft
CD
Di
Di
H-
ft
‘-rj
Di
<
ft
CD
I
Cl
‘-<
ci
CD
Ft
Di
Ft
Ft
ci
CD
Di
Ft
CD
CD
ci
Cl
0
H-
Q
Di
CD
CD
HI
D
Ft
HI
CY
0
CD
CD
CD
I
CD
ft
H-
CD
3
CD
Cl
Di
Page
54
1
along
the
whole
length
of
the
Cal
Sag,
as
well
as
2
all areas
of
the
CAWS.
3
MR.
ANDES:
If
I
can
follow
up,
have
4
you ——
did
you
also
review
and
agree
with
5
Dr.
Makk.e’s
statements
indicating
that
during
6
his
testimony
that
there
might
be
limited
7
areas
of
refuge
but
not for
spawning?
8
BY
THE
WITNESS:
9
A.
I reviewed
his
testimony. But,
you
10
know,
not
being,
again,
a, quote,
“biologic
expert,”
11
I
would
concur
with his
conclusions.
12
But I
haven’t
viewed
all
the
13
habitat
data,
as
Dr.
Mackey
did.
And
so I would
14
rely
on
his
testimony.
15
BY
MS. DEXTER:
16
Q.
Dr.
Mackey
is
not
a
biologist;
17
correct?
18
A.
He’s
a
habitat
specialist.
I
guess
19
I’m
not
here
to speak
through
-- to
his
—-
20
MR.
ANDES:
I
don’t
think
he’s an
21
expert
on Dr.
Mackey.
22
BY MS.
DIERS:
23
Q.
Are
you
a Biologist?
24
A.
No,
I’m not.
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
F
t-
H-
F-
H-
F
1-
F—i
W
NJ
H-
0
cD
0
—J
ai
(A)
-
0
co
0
—3
3i
0’
W
NJ
F-
Hi
h-h
CD
1t1
CII
-H
Ft
C/)
ct
Di
Q.
C)
FH
C/)
c-I-
‘TJ
0
Cli
CI)
Cli
CD
H-
Q
CD
H-
3
CD
H
L<
CD
Cli
h-h
C)
C)
k<
Cl)
CD
Q
Cli
(I)
Q.
h-h
0
H-
H
H
CD
CD
h
çt
çt
CD
CD
0
Ct
H-
H-
H
ct
H-
H-
çt
Ct
Cli
Ft
o
0
Ct
C).
CD
H
CD
t3
0
CD
CD
CD
H-
C)
h-
D
Cl)
Ct
Cli
0
CD
Q
Cl
0
h-I
CD
Cl)
Cli
0
0
h-I
Ct
CD
H-
CD
H-
0
Cli
CII
Ct
CD
ct
Cli
Y
CD
C)
CD
CD
H-
3
Ct
tY
CD
3
Ct
Cli
Ct
Ct
CD
<
Y
C).
çt
Ct
h-h
H-
C)
ct
H
Cli
0
CD
3
‘-<
CD
0
CD
H-
CD
ct
Cli
hI
0
h-h
CD
Ct
CD
H
H
ci
Cli
CD
C)
CD
ct
3
-<
H-
o
(Ai
0
H
Q
0
CD
H
CD
0
CD
H-
H-
0
H
ci
C)
01
CD
3
3
ci
0
CD
CD
Ct
ct
H-
ci
Cl
D
0
ci
Cli
Q
o
<
<
C)
H-
H-
l
H-
Cl)
Ct
CD
CD
Q
ci
o
CD
CD
Cli
Cli
CD
Ct
0
H-
ct
CD
0
c-I-
CD
Ct
CD
ci
Cli
H
Ct
CD
C5
h-I
H
Q
H-
Ct
CD
Cli
CD
CD
H
-<
H-
h-I
ci
0
CD
0
ci
0
Ct
H-
Ct
NJ
CD
ct
C).
CD
CD
CD
Cli
F-I
ci
Cli
çt
Cli
Q
CD
3
CD
CD
Ct
CD
Ct
I-I
H-
CD
Ct
[‘1
Ct
CD
CD
H-
CD
1
3
D
0
H-
i
0
CD
Ci
0
CD
i
Cli
3
C)
H
Cli
Ct
Ct
Mi
Cli
3
h-h
0
Ct
-<
Cli
CD
CD
CD
H-
3
()
Ct
L<
‘-<
H-
ct
D
CD
H-
Ct
H
<
Cli
Cli
0
Cli
3
3
0
Q
CD
3
Cli
CD
Cli
<
CD
Ct
ct
CD
Ct
Ct
L<
CD
a)
Ct
ci
ci
<
CD
Cli
Ct
H-
H
CD
C)
H
D
CD
CD
0
Ct
-
CD
ci
CD
C).
0
0
CD
CD
h-I
C)
Ct
ct
Cli
Hi
Cli
C)
CD
CD
CD
H-
3
‘CI
3
3
C)
Cli
H-
Ct
0
H-
h-I
‘-<
H
Q
C).
0
C)
0
H-
CD
CD
3
i
h-I
ci
3
H-
Ct
H-
H-i
CD
H-
h-h
Ct
0
Ct
Ii
C).
CD
h-h
H
CD
0
3
C)
Ct
-
CD
C).
Ct
CD
C).
CD
C)
CD
Ct
Cli
Cl
H-
3
Ct
CD
0
-<
H
H-
CD
3
‘-<
Cl
C)
3
3
Cli
C)
Ct
C)
CD
3
H
<
0
I
•-J
Ct
0
H-
Ct
Q
CD
Ct
Ct
CD
Cl)
3
3
Ct
CD
3
I
H-
H-
CD
C)
Cli
CD
0
Cli
Ct
CD
CD
H-
hY
Cli
3
Ct
‘TI
Cli
NJ
H-
3
h-
C)
H-
C)
3
H
CD
‘-<
H-
Cli
F-I
H
Cli
Cli
Q
3
Ct
CD
0
HI
Cl)
CD
Ct
H
3
3
Hi
Ct
Ct
I-I
0
Ct
CD
CD
H
CD
H-
H-
CD
Q
Cl
H
3
CD
Cli
0
H-
3
X
Cli
CD
0
3
‘-<
0
Ct
-<
CD
CD
CD
1Y
Cli
3
C)
H-
3
H-
0
C)
Cli
3
Q
CD
0
3
HI
CD
H
I-I
L<
CD
CD
<
3
ci
0
h-I
Ct
Cl
CD
-
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
Ct
Ct
Cli
H
‘-<
Ct
CD
H
Cli
Ci
3
0
CD
H-
Ct
Cl
Cli
0
C)
CD
h-I
CD
h-h
Cl
3
H-
Cli
CD
CD
ci
Q
0
0
<
Cl
0
3
II
C)
CD
0
5
h-h
CD
Cli
CD
‘tI
H-
H-
3
Cli
Cli
H-
0
CD
H-
Cli
‘-<
Ct
Ct
h-I
CD
Cli
3
CD
3
H-
Ct
3
Ct
0
CD
CD
CD
C)
.Q
H-
0
CD
H
C)
Ct
H-
Q
Ci
I-I
h-h
0
CD
CII
Cl
h-h
CD
Ct
CD
3
0
H-
3
ci
Ct
CD
Cl
3
Ct
H-
Cli
H
C).
CD
Cli
0
Cli
CD
0
3
‘-<
CD
H
Ct
Cl
M
t\)
M
H
F-
H
-
—
F
H
F-’
I—’
F-’
Ui
N)
F—’
0
O
0)
-J
0)
(fl
U)
N)
F
0
f-
U)
N)
I—’
Di
ft
CD
H
ft
0
ft
ft
ft
H
0
C)
Q.
h
H,
C)
I-
X
Di
C)
0
CD
D
H-
Lxi
CD
ft
D
Lxi
0
0
H-
H-
0
CD
Di
0
ft
CD
ft
F-d
CD
3
CD
CD
CD
0
H
3
<
Di
Di
<
CD
ft
CD
‘-<
-<
Ii
H-
H
ft
CD
I-I
C5
CD
I
H-
I-
-
0
H-
-,
H
H-
I—
I-I
Di
CD
CD
-
C)
H,
CD
H
H
<
CD
ft
Di
CD
3
H-
CD
Q.
o
Di
Dl
0
CD
CD
CD
Di
Di
CD
ft
CD
Q
Dl
CD
0
Q
CD
H-
CD
CD
H-
CD
‘-<
ft
ft
CD
CD
H
H,
H-
‘-<
d
H
C)
I-<
0
H
Q
CD
H
H-
h
Q.
Q.
0
CD
Di
CD
H-
Q.
H-
ci
CD
0
Di
‘
CD
H,
“
0
I-
çt
ft
I—s
1
H
CD
Di
H
H
H-
<1
H-
Q
3
ft
CD
H
H,
J’
CD
Di
H-
H
Di
Q
ft
CD
ft
ci
-,
H-
C)
Q
0
CD
Di
0
ct
C)
H-
H
-
CD
H
C/)
H-
0
H
CD
çt
H
CD
H
0
C)
C)
CD
0
CD
CD
H-
H-
0
H
<1
CD
C)
H-
CD
CD
0
CD
ft
C)
CD
CD
0
CD
3
ft
•
H
CD
Di
‘-<
C)
CD
ci
-
Di
‘
CD
Di
II
Di
o
H-
3
-<
CD
ft
0
Q
3
Di
CD
ft
ft
Q
ct
CD
CD
CD
o
ft
ft
ft
CD
H-
Q
H-
Di
ci
i
H
ct
CD
•
Cl)
CD
3
-1
Q
Di
I
0
ci
ft
H
I-
C)
‘<
Di
0
E
Q
Di
CD
ci
H-
I
H-
Di
Di
H
Di
H-
‘
CD
CD
II
Di
CD
‘C
0
ft
H
Di
Di
H
ct
ft
Di
Lxi
H
ft
Di
H
‘
H-
CD
3
H
Z
CD
H-
CD
H
H
H
ft
CD
ft
0
Di
3
o
H,
ft
H-
Di
Di
H
‘-<
ft
—
-.
D’
ft
-<
CD
CD
H,
ft
ft
C)
ft
CD
ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
Di
H,
1
H
I-
J
I-
CD
ci
CD
ft
ft
H
H
II
H-
CD
ft
ft
0
CD
II
CD
H-
H
ft
ft
—
H-
0
Di
Di
N
Q
h
ft
0
H-
CD
CD
CD
‘-<
0
C)
ci
Di
CD
CD
J’
ft
CD
Q
H
ft
fr
II
0
H
ft
h-
CD
h
H
H-
ft
0
‘-<
CD
ci
ci
-<
ci
CD
I-
H-
H-
CD
CD
CD
0
o
CD
CD
Dl
H-
0
CD
Q
I-
ft
“
CD
0
C)
0
Q
0
CD
‘-<
‘-<
ft
3
H,
0
3
J
ci
ft
<
H,
CD
H-
H-
CD
CD
ft
Di
CD
CD
CD
Di
CD
H-
H-
CD
H-
H-
F-
H-
Di
h
CD
CD
3
Di
H-
H-
H
CD
Q
H
0
ft
ft
3’
CD
Q
CD
t-
CD
H-
Q
C)
0
0
ft
H
Q
Q
CD
ft
CD
CD
ci
Q
Di
Di
ft
CD
ft
3
CD
ci
H,
Di
0
Q
H,
ft
Di
CD
ft
CD
H
H
CD
H-
CD
CD
ft
CD
-
CD
d
ci
CD
CD
CD
D
I-I
•
CD
H
0
‘-<
J’
Di
ft
CD
ft
ft
I-
CD
CD
CD
H-
ft
0
CD
3
CD
CD
CD
d
CD
H
H
0
CD
H
-i
CD
-
CD
ft
CD
Q
‘-<
H-
CD
C)
C)
Di
CD
CD
Di
0
ft
CD
H
ft
CD
ft
H
‘-<
H-
ft
H-
0
H,
H,
ft
H
H,
ct
H-
ft
<
0
CD
H,
3
H,
H,
H,
Di
‘-<
H
H-
0
C)
H-
CD
Di
CD
Di
0
ft
H-
Di
H-
H
H-
CD
H,
ft
H
Di
i
H
ft
f
CD
C)
ft
Di
C)
ci
CL
‘
H
Q
D
CD
ft
LQ
0
CD
‘-<
•
I
CD
0
•
Di
H-
ft
•
Di
CD
Di
ft
Di
0
0
ft
H-
<
ft
Di
3
II
ft
CD
H
H
H
0
3
H
CD
CD
Y’
H,
CD
ci
CL
CD
(SF
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
H
0)
NJ
CD
co
F-
-
01
0)
NJ
C)
CD
-
Oi
01
0)
NJ
-
C)
0
C)
CD
3
Ft
ct
Z
C)
CD
ci
H
H
0
h
I—h
0
Ft
ci
D
Di
Di
CD
H-
H
0
I
Di
Di
CD
H-
CD
CD
I—h
Hi
<
:3
Y
Ft
-<
:3
C)
CD
CD
CD
CD
ci
h
CD
CD
CD
CD
<
H-
F-
Di
C)
h
CD
D
0
CD
rt
ci
ci
rI-
Q
C)
Ft
Di
Di
ci
CD
CD
CD
CD
1Y
CD
Ft
H-
Di
Ft
H-
3
0
C)
<
0
Dl
CD
CD
Di
Ft
0
Ft
H-
C)
Cl
Hi
0
CD
Ft
‘ci
0
Ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
Dl
Dl
3
CD
C)
ci
II
C)
CD
Ft
Ft
Di
Cl
CD
Ft
J
0
b
ci
0
Dl
Di
H-
Q.
CD
•
H-
Dl
Ft
H-
CD
D
<1
Ft
h-
Dl
CD
‘T5
H-
<
D
3
CD
Di
H-
Dl
CD
CD
CD
0
Cl
CD
Z
CD
CD
CD
Cl
<1
Cl
<
h’
CD
3
CD
C)
0
CD
Cl
CD
i-<
CD
Di
Cl
0
Cl
Ft
H-
C)
Ft
3
Di
CD
CD
Di
Di
CD
•
CD
CD
D
0
CD
Di
CD
CD
0
Hi
C)
0
Di
H
Q.
CD
C
Ft
Ft
‘-<
Cl
‘.
0
Hi
H-
Ft
H
0
C)
Ft
ci
i-I
CD
Di
H-
0
3
H-
d
Di
Z
H-
I-
Hi
Ft
I-
Ft
Di
0
IH
CD
Di
CD
Di
0
Di
CD
H-
3
C
Hi
CD
H-
-
CD
CD
CD
H
Ft
Cl
Cl
Hi
h
Ft
t’i
H-
‘
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
CI
0
CD
CD
ci
0
C)
CD
Q
<
C/)
C)
H
‘-<
3
Di
Q
Cl
0
><
Di
tY
0
Ft
0
0
•
H-
Cl
Ft
h
H-
ci
Di
Ft
<
‘<
3
Hi
CD
ci
Di
Ft
•
H-
Di
D
Ft
C)
Ft
H-
H-
0
C)
CD
Ii
H-
3
C)
ci
Di
H-
Di
H-
Cl
C)
Ft
ci
CD
CD
CD
Ft
I-I
CD
Q.
Di
Ft
C)
H
CD
H
TJ
CD
CD
t5
CD
Hi
fr
H
1
ci
I-I
CD
CD
0
0
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
I
0
0
H
0
H-
0
Di
H
C)
CD
Di
CD
h
CD
Di
3
C)
CD
<
FH
Di
H-
Ft
Hi
Hi
<1
Ii
Di
0
Cl
L<
•J
Q
CD
0
0
Ft
Ft
H-
H-
C)
0
CD
CD
h-I
Di
Hi
CD
CD
CD
Cl
C)
D
Cl
0
D
fr
Cl
Cl
Di
Ft
I
CD
H-
CD
C)
CD
Di
ci
CD
3
H-
Ft
H-
H-
I
H-
Di
H-
Ft
0
Q
C)
H-
<
Di
Ft
ci
Di
CD
Hi
Ft
I
Hi
Di
0
Hi
0
Di
CD
X
H-
Di
Ft
Ft
Ft
Ft
I
H-
i
Hi
‘
Ft
Ft
Di
0
Ft
CD
Dl
H-
Di
C)
0
Ft
Ft
H-
H-
-.
•
H-
0
•
Di
3
CD
Ft
Di
‘CI
CD
H
Ft
CD
H
C)
Ft
-<
F-
Ft
Di
CD
<
H
H-
CD
-
Q
H-
H-
CD
h
Ft
Di
0
CD
CD
3
ci
Cl
Q
ci
0
Di
Cl
Di
Ft
Di
Ft
Ft
h-I
CD
-
3
Di
Q
Di
H-
H-
h
J
CD
Di
Cl
Q
CD
Cl
h-I
ci
Di
CD
Ft
C)
Cl
H
ci
CD
0
0
CD
CD
Hi
I—I
CD
F
Ft
Di
Q
CD
ci
Di
CD
CD
Ft
0
Ft
Ft
Di
‘
CD
H-
Ft
ci
Di
h-
H
h-
ci
H-
CD
Ft
H-
D
Cl
H-
C)
H-
Di
-Q
Di
Cl
0
0
CD
-<
Ft
Di
i
CD
H-
Di
Di
Hi
ci
C)
Ft
ci
h-
CD
Hi
3
LC)
CD
Di
•
C)
h-I
CD
3
CD
H
H-
Di
0
H
Ft
I
CD
Cl
CD
Di
H
C)
Ft
Cl
-<
Di
Cl
-
Ft
Di
0
h-
H-
H
<
Di
Di
CD
3
Hi
C)
)
I-I
Cl
CD
Cl
9
tO
ci
CD
CD
Ft
H-
0
Di
LQ
CD
01
Page
58
1
THE
WITNESS:
I
guess
I would
repeat,
2
Maine
is certainly
an
example,
where
they’ve
3
done
the
tired
aquatic
uses.
4
MR. ANDES:
And
if I can
stop
you
5
there.
6
I
believe
we have
some
information
7
about
the Maine
approach
from
the
IEPA
draft
8
guidance.
9
THE WITNESS:
Yes.
So
if
we could
10
enter
that...
11
MR. ANDES:
These
are
selected
pages,
12
32
to
37,
from
a
draft
EPA
document
entitled
13
Use
of Biological
Information
to
Better
14
Define
Designated
Aquatic
Life Uses
in
State
15
and Tribal
Water
Quality
Standards:
Tier
16
Aquatic
Life
Uses.
17
MS.
TIPSORD:
We
will mark
this
draft
18
USEPA
document
as
Exhibit
205,
if
there’s
no
19
objection.
20
Seeing
none,
it’s
Exhibit
205.
21
(WHEREUPON,
a certain
document
was
22
marked
Exhibit
23
No.
205
for
identification,
as
of
24
2/17/09.)
M
t\.)
i”)
L’J
L\)
I-
H
I-
)—
I-
i-
I-
W
N)
0
co
CD
-J
CD
(Ji
N)
F-
0
ç
CD
—J
Ci
0’
-
(i
N)
I-
Di
CD
C)
3
0
CD
I—h
it
çt
c-h
H
Ci
it
Ii
ci
H
CD
it
CD
‘Ci
it
0
Di
Hi
Ci
0
0
0
0
it
0
CD
H-
0
0
0
0
Q
Ci
Di
it
hi
H
0
H-
H
CD
0
Ci
Di
3
Ci
Di
-ti
CD
it
H-
Q
CD
H-
it
Di
Di
hi
0
Ci
Di
hi
H
it
hi
D
Q.
Ci
hi
Q.
it
CD
ci
Di
Di
hi
CD
Hi
Di
Di
0
it
CD
CD
Di
CD
CD
Ci
CD
CD
H
C)
hi
Di
Di
it
CD
0)
3
i
Cl)
‘tI
‘t
Di
ci
b
0
H-
it
C)
CD
CD
it
C)
C)
it
Di
H
CD
Ci
LQ
73
H
I—h
hi
CD
C)
CD
H-
CD
H-
H-
it
Di
C)
•
it
CD
•
0
C)
hi
h-h
Di
3
it
H
it
it
<
3
Di
0
CD
H-
hi
Q
it
it
M
Di
H-
Di
D
Ci
CD
CD
Di
it
D
CD
H-
CD
Z
it
3
CD
Ci
H-
Q
Ci
H-
C)
CD
0
CD
C)
CI
C).
3
C).
it
H-
Ci
it
0
CD
I-h
73
C)
[‘3
C)
hi
C)
H-
H-
Ci
it
CD
it
CD
H-
H-
C)
Ci
CD
0
<
0
0
CD
H-
hi
H-
it
<
Di
‘x
••
Ci
0
Di
Ci
H-
<
0
it
CD
H-
it
Di
D
ci
CD
0)
CD
H
Ci
C)
Cl)
CD
<1
0)
CD
3
CD
it
0
H-
hi
CD
hi
Ci
CD
H
02
02
CD
it
hi
CD
0)
<
H
•
CD
3
H-
0
‘t
d
H-
CD
hi
CD
H-
CD
CD
D
C)
H-
‘-<
3
d
CD
CD
C)
H
Ci
it
0
CD
CD
hi
it
CD
it
CD
it
C)
C)
CD
Di
3
Ci
Ci
Ci
H-
Z
it
it
Ci
CD
H-
H-
it
0
Di
Di
CD
Ci
it
it
Ci
it
0
C)
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
Ci
it
H
hi
<
CD
CD
it
0
CD
CD
it
CD
CD
h-h
Ci
‘-<
H-
CD
0
CD
hi
Ci
-
I
t5
CD
-
<
CD
H
C).
H-
CD
H
I
ti
CD
Q.
it
it
I
Di
CD
d
it
H
Ci
Di
Dl
Q
LQ
H
C)
I
3
CD
Di
0
‘-<I
H-
it
Di
H-
it
Di
CD
Ci
CD
C)
CD
C)
it
C)
CD
H-
[Y
it
Hi
J
H-
it
H-
Ci
H-
0
it
Ci
hi
t3
i
CD
CD
Di
it
H-
CD
C)
CD
it
H
CD
CD
CD
H
CD
CD
Ci
Q
3
it
CD
C)
0
0
C)
CD
it
0
CD
•
it
Di
CD
Ci
H
0
H-
Di
[-
3
C)
it
tY
I
CI
I—h
hi
it
0
CD
Di
it
Dl
0
it
C)
0
<
CD
I
0
0
CD
CD
D
0
CD
CD
3
CD
Ci
CD
0
CD
CD
H-
I-
hi
Ci
C).
0
CD
‘TZI
II
I
C)
CD
it
ti
CD
it
it
Di
<
Ci
hi
it
H
Ci
Di
Dl
Mi
H-
CD
Di
hi
H-
Di
CD
Di
it
Di
C)
CD
0
CD
-ç
Di
H-
it
CD
Ci
hi
it
Di
it
it
hi
hi
Di
Y
Q
H-
CD
H-
Di
CD
it
it
it
Ci
CD
it
Di
Y
H
Ci
hi
hi
‘ti
‘
CD
Di
it
H
CD
CD
Ci
H-
it
-,
it
CD
H
CD
CD
CD
Di
[3
CD
H-
3
H-
H
CD
0
Ci
it
CD
hi
H
[‘I
H
z
[‘3
CD
CD
Ci
Di
H
Cl)
0
H
H
CD
it
0
0
H
it
H
I-H
tl
CD
0
23
[3
H
Di
0
Ci
hi
hj
hi
CD
CD
i-ti
Ci
Di
Di
CD
Page
60
1
actual
water quality
standards.
The
document
2
is
entitled Upper
South
Platte
River
3
Segment
15
Site—specific
Minimum Dissolved
4
Oxygen
Ammonia
Standards.
5
MS. TIPSORD:
And if
there’s
no
6
objection,
we
will mark
the Upper
South
7
Platte
River
standards
as
Exhibit 206.
8
Seeing
none,
it’s
Exhibit 206.
9
(WHEREUPON,
a certain document
was
10
marked
Exhibit
11
No. 206
for
identification,
as
of
12
2/17/09.)
13
MR.
ANDES:
This
is an excerpt
from
a
14
technical
report
concerning the
Upper
South
15
Platte.
The
title is Final
Technical
16
Memorandum
Responses
Seven
Fish Species
to
17
Diel
Fluctuations
in
Dissolved
Oxygen.
18
MS.
TIPSORD:
If there’s
no objection,
19
we
will mark
this
as
Exhibit
207.
It’s
20
the -- it’s
prepared
for
the
Metro
Wastewater
21
Reclamation
District,
Denver,
Colorado,
by
22
the
University
of
Wyoming.
23
MS.
WILLIAMS:
I mean,
I don’t
-- I
24
guess I’ll
object.
I mean,
I don’t want
to
Page
61
1
be difficult,
but
this is
just
a
table
of
2
contents,
and a
one—page
introduction
to
this
3
document.
I
don’t
understand
for what
4
purpose
it’s being
offered.
5
MR. ANDES:
Just
a
moment.
6
I
would
say
that,
actually,
there
7
were
pages
that were
supposed
to be
copied
8
that
were
not.
9
MS.
WILLIAMS:
Well, we’ll
withdraw
it
10
at
this
time
then
and
present
it
later?
11
MR.
ANDES:
We
can certainly
file
the
12
full
set
of
pages
that were
to be
done.
13
MS.
WILLIAMS:
I don’t
think
that’s
14
reasonable,
because
I
don’t
think
we
can --
15
we can’t
cross—examine
this
witness
on
a
16
document
that’s
not
here
to
look
at;
right?
17
I
don’t think
that’s
reasonable.
18
MR. ANDES:
Mr.
Freedman
can certainly
19
testify
as to
the
water
quality
standard
and
20
his
understanding
for the
basis
for it.
21
MS.
TIPSORD:
We’re
going
to
hold
off.
22
We
will
not mark
this
as
Exhibit
207.
We
23
will
hold
off, and
when
you
get the
complete
24
document,
we can
put
it in.
[‘0
N)
N)
N)
N)
I-
F-
H
F
F-
H
F—i
F-’
-
I-’
W
N)
F-’
0
0
-
O
(i
N)
F-’
0
co
o
i
co
‘j
I-
CD
Q
CD
çt
Ft
C)
CD
Ft
U)
H
ct
I—’
H
0
CD
0
H-
D
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
<1
H-
Di
Di
it
H-
h-
H-
Di
CD
C)
CD
CD
CD
rt
h
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
Ft
<
Ft
h
H-
H
Di
I
3
CD
H-
H1
0
Ft
C)
CD
H-
0
H-
H-
CD
CD
çt
H-
t
Di
çt
‘T
CD
Ft
Dl
Ft
CD
C)
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
H
0
H
•
H-
Z
Dl
Q.
Ft
II
C)
Di
CD
1
U)
U)
H’
Ft
3
X
3
U)
3
CD
U)
H-
H-
h
[‘1
Ft
01
CD
L’J
Di
i—h
CD
1
N
H1
Di
CD
Ft
0
F-
i-<
LQ
H-
>
CD
H-
CD
CD
H
i
U)
0
H
H-
I—s
0
0
C).
3
1
C)
x
><
H’
H’
Q
H-
C)
0
HI
C).
i-H
Z
Di
Di
<
CD
Dl
Di
H
d
Dl
Ft
‘t
C)
H
H-
Ft
CD
Ft
-
3
H-
CD
Z
U)
h
CD
Z
C)
U)
1’j
ID
I—’
Ft
Ft
I-H
0
Li
0
C).
I
CD
Ft
0
U)
CD
H1
Di
0
I—’
CD
F-
H’
U)
2i
CD
1
CD
U)
H-
2i
H-
Ft
H’
C)
CD
CD
U)
ID
t5
1
U)
0
I
I-H
CD
C)
Dl
01
‘-<
Ft
H-
CD
Di
CD
U)
Ft
-
i-I
CD
h
I—’
•
Di
CD
CD
C)
0
U)
0
•
H-
CD
CD
I—’
CD
CD
H-
Ft
0
CD
Ft
0
CD
CD
-<
•
CD
Di
‘-<
H
Ft
H
H1
Iji
h
0
C)
CD
Q
0
1
3
CD
CD
H-
Di
ci
CD
o
CD
UJ
H-
3
CD
Q
Q
CD
CD
C)
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
F-
Ft
CD
3
H1
H-
0
CD
H-’
CD
I-H
3
3
1
1
H-
Di
Ft
3
H-
3
Ft
I-H
i--i
H-’
D
CD
L’J
C)
H-
Ft
Ft
Ft
3
CD
H-
Di
Dl
X
-
H-
Ft
Ft
C)
•
CD
3
CD
3
3
Ft
CD
Di
CD
3
o
3
Y
CD
D
CD
Di
H-
<
0
Di
Ft
H-
Ft
Ft
H
0
CD
Di
Ft
3
3
ci
CD
CD
CD
tY
Y
Di
o
Ft
CD
Q
Ft
Ft
‘-<
0
0
Cl
F-
ci
CD
CD
3
H-
CD
3
CD
0
ci
H-
Cl
Di
CD
1i
CD
Cl
Ft
H-
CD
CD
Di
ci
Ft
I-H
l
CD
ci
H-
3
i-H
Dl
3
C)
3
CD
Ft
-
0
C)
0
ID
h
N)
Q
C)
II
Ft
II
H-’
H-
Ft
ci
0
CD
0
CD
CD
C)
Cl
0
J’
H-
CD
Ft
F-
3
CD
3
0.
-
3
0
-‘
Ft
Ft
Di
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
Di
Ft
ci
3’
U)
CD
3
CD
3
CD
H-
3
CD
F—’
CD
I—i
Cl
L<
0
0
CD
3
H-
Cl
i-I
Cl
CD
CD
H-
Ft
ci
Ft
Cl
CD
3’
-ri
CD
Di
Ft
3’
H-
Ft
ci
Ft
C).
CD
II
H-
Di
Di
C)
Cl
Ft
3
CD
C)
Di
0
CD
‘-<
3’
CD
CD
3’
CD
h-
CD
CD
•
Di
h
Di
CD
CD
Ft
CD
Page
63
1
criteria
for
the CAWS,
I’m
just illustrating
2
the
kind
of process
that
one
would
go through
3
to
do
this and
how
one might
come
up
with
4
different
criteria
than
what
are in
other
5
more
general
use
waters.
6
BY
MS. DEXTER:
7
Q.
Have
these
standards
been
adopted
in
8
Colorado?
I
don’t see
a citation
on
here.
9
A.
Yes,
they
are
adopted.
We
can
get
you
10
the
actual
citation.
11
Q.
Okay.
12
A.
So
we’ll
get
the more
complete
13
documentation and
the citation.
14
MR.
ANDES:
Sure.
That
is
a page
15
taken
directly
for
the
Ohio
regulations
16
online
——
Colorado,
excuse
me.
17
MS.
DEXTER:
I
just
don’t
see
a site
18
here.
19
MR.
ANDES:
They
don’t
site
20
numerically,
unfortunately,
in
the
Colorado
21
regulations.
22
BY MS.
DIERS:
23
Q.
Question
25.
24
“For
the
Cuyahoga
River shipping
N)
N)
N)
N)
H
F-
I-
i-
l-
I-
l-
H
()
N)
I—i
cD
co
CD
—J
CD
0-i
0)
N)
F-
C)
‘SC)
IX)
J
o-
cii
cii
N)
-
Ci)
L
0
a
CD
C)
1D
CD
C)
Y
C)
Di
Ft
Q.
C)
o
Di
h-h
H-
Dl
‘-<
0
Di
X
))J
0
0
Di
D
Di
0
H-
Di
Di
Il
1
Di
H-
Ft
c-h
Di
CD
Cl)
Ft
H)
H-
CD
C)
c-h
H
1
H-
H-
Cl)
C/)
CD
CD
H)
Di
0
H-
H-
Di
C)
Ft
C)
Ft
3
CD
H
i
i
CD
Dl
Cl)
Ft
h-h
CD
Ft
Ft
c-h
h-
H-
C)
II
H
H
Dl
H
Cl)
0
H-
Cl)
H
Di
C)
CD
c-h
H-
H-
H
H-
Di
Cl)
<
Di
•
Ft
Di
3
3
C)
H-
c
C)
3
-<
3
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
•
H
H)
H-
c-h
0
D
Di
•)
h-
0
Q
H-
3
H-
Cl)
h-h
CD
Ft
Di
H-
Di
Ft
F
c-h
0
3
1
Di
<1
Di
l—
H)
3
c-h
H-
CD
3
H-
H-
H-
0
H)
CD
CD
CD
H
CD
5
t
I
0
Cl)
Ft
Di
3
H
3
0
-<
CD
CD
I
3
c-h
-
Ft
‘-<
0
Q
C)
3
ç
(Ft
H
FH
<
CD
Ft
l-
Di
Ft
CD
H-
Di
Di
H-
CD
a
C)
Di
b
3
3
Di
3
<
Q
0
0
‘-<
CD
Di
Q
0
0
Ft
Ft
CD
Di
H-
Ft
Ft
Dl
D
Di
H)
Ft
Di
<
Di
1
C)
Cl)
H
Ft
Ft
3
3
H
CD
J
CD
H
3
3
H
Ft
CD
3
CD
))J
<
3
a
Q
Di
3
a
0
h
3
a
CD
-
Di
o
Ft
CD
0
CD
Ft
•
ct
CD
0
LQ
CD
Di
3
CD
c-h
c
Di
3
(I)
i
CD
CD
3
H-
Di
CD
h
II
II
Di
‘-<
Di
CD
C)
Di
3
CD
C)
C)
H-
•
H
CD
CD
Q
<
-
Dl
Di
c-h
ci
3
3
CD
3
CD
Di
CD
CD
-
Ft
ct
3
H-
CD
C)
L<
-
c-h
C)
3
1
H-
Di
Di
ci
CD
3
C)
CD
0
Ft
H
o
Di
c-h
3
Q
CD
C/)
Q
rt
‘J
CD
11
Di
Ft
Di
ct
1
c-h
3
H
3
CD
Di
CD
0
3
CD
II
0
c-h
D
H-
3
•l
CD
a
0
CD
C/)
Di
a
Di
3
a
1
c-h
CD
Di
Q
0
CD
c-h
Di
II
<
H-
Q
X
C)
3
H-
H
•
Di
Di
3
h-h
H-
Ft
Di
h
H-
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
Di
H-
3’
H-
0
Di
Di
H-
0
Di
h-h
h-h
3
h
CD
C)
ci
Di
H-
Di
H-
Di
Ft
C)
0
3
0
H-
H-
H-
CD
Di
h
Ft
o
H-
Ft
C)
ci
CD
Di
H)
CD
0
C)
CD
3
Di
H
CD
CD
3
3
Di
Di
I
CD
Di
3
h
Ft
3
Q.
Di
C)
h
C)
Di
Di
H-
iQ
I
I-I
Di
Di
‘-<
Di
Di
C)
•
<
0
CD
C)
0
Ft
Ft
Di
3
0
CD
Di
3
Ft
0
Ft
iQ
H-
0
h-h
H-
3
Ft
H-
a
H
C)
3
3
CD
Q
Ft
Ft
3
Ft
Ft
H-
CD
CD
a
CD
0
Di
Dl
Di
0
3
o
3
Di
CD
Ft
Cl)
H-
‘-<
Ft
h
3
Di
‘-<
H-
Ft
CD
Ft
h
0
-<
CD
Ft
Di
Ft
CD
H-
Di
<
II
Di
D
CD
CD
CD
1
Di
H
Ft
H-
tY
Ft
0
t)
H-
Ft
H-
CD
3
C)
I-I
•
Ft
ID
CD
CD
3
Ft
0
0
1
3
H
Cl)
Cl)
CD
0
ci
Di
Di
CD
3
3
Ft
‘-<
Di
CD
H-
0
Di
H
Di
C)
-<
Di
3
•
a
h-h
Di
Di
H
•
3
Ft
0
Ft
3
Di
Di
-<
Di
Ft
h
H
C)
3
H-
H-
Q
CD
H-
11
3
Cl)
G)
Di
0
H-
3
Ft
H
tY
H-
h
C)
h-
0
Di
3
Di
3
Di
CD
0
C)
Di
H-
LC)
Di
Di
h
Di
Cl)
3
<
CD
h-
Ft
3
Di
Q
CD
Dl
3
1
C)
Ft
Di
Ft
CD
<
‘-<
H
0
Di
0
h
•
a
h
H-
H-
H-
Ft
3
CD
a
o
•
H-
Di
C)
Di
CD
Di
CD
L<
CD
CD
3
Page
65
1
area
waterways
are
much
more
severe.
2
I
only
pointed
out
the
comparison
3
because
the
IEPA
did make
a
comparison.
And
I
4
thought
they
were
-—
if
they were
going
to
make
the
5
comparison
-- again,
this relates
to
the
6
comparability
discussion
that
we had
before.
7
That
if you’re
going
to
compare
8
it,
you
ought
to
be
more
comprehensive, which
I
9
don’t
feel
that
they
did.
And that
it
would
be
10
their
kind
of responsibility
to
kind
of look
at
11
similar
systems
and
kind of
make
an assessment.
12
And
I
don’t
feel
that they
--
they
13
did that
job
thorough
enough.
14
BY MS.
DEXTER:
15
Q.
Can
I ask
you,
you
just
-—
you stated
16
how
the
systems
between
the
Cuyahoga
and
the
Chicago
17
area
waterways
differ,
but
I’m
not sure
you
answered
18
the
question
of
how they
differ
in
respect
to
its
19
biological
potential.
20
A.
And
in
terms of
its biological
21
potential,
I
have not
done
a
comprehensive
study
to
22
compare
the
two
of
them,
so
I
don’t
think
I could
23
answer
that
question
thoroughly
and accurately.
24
MS.
DEXTER:
Okay.
Page
66
1
BY
MS.
WILLIAMS:
2
Q.
I have
one
area
I’d
like
to
follow
up
3
on
with
your
testimony,
Mr. Freedman.
And
it’s
4
regarding
Pages
4
and
5
and
your
discussion
of
the
5
Illinois
general
use
designation.
I’m
going
to
6
refer
you
to
Page
5,
the
first
full
paragraph.
7
MR.
ANDES:
Page
5 of
his
testimony
or
8
his
report?
9
MS.
WILLIAMS:
His
testimony
at
this
10
point.
I
think
something
similar
is
in
the
11
report,
but...
12
BY
THE
WITNESS:
13
A.
Yeah.
14
BY
MS.
WILLIAMS:
15
Q.
And
I am
going
to
read
the
second
16
sentence
--
well,
can
you
just
read
the
second
17
sentence
of
that
paragraph?
18
A.
Start
with
further?
19
Q.
Yes.
20
A.
“Further,
general
use waters
are
21
designed
to
protect
communities
predominantly
22
composed
of
pollution
sensitive
species,
where
the
23
CAWS
proposed
aquatic
life
uses
decide
to
predict
24
tolerant
or
intermediate
tolerant
species,
which
Page
67
1
presumably
could
be
supported
by
less
stringent
2
criteria.”
3
Q.
Can you
point
us
to
the
basis
for
your
4
statement
regarding
general
use
water?
You
have
a
5
quote
in
the
middle
of
that.
6
A.
Yeah.
7
Q.
And
it
doesn’t
refer
to what
you’re
8
quoting
from.
9
A.
I’m not
sure
I brought
the
-- I
can
10
give
the
exact
page.
I’m
not
sure I
have
the
11
general
use
criteria
here with
me.
12
Q.
Well,
I
don’t
think it’s
in there,
13
that’s
why I
--
but
you think
you’re
quoting
from
14
the
general
use
criteria?
15
A.
I believe
so. Or
it
might
be
from
the
16
EPA
criteria
document.
17
And
I’m
afraid,
since
that
wasn’t
18
one
of the
supplied
questions,
I don’t
have
the
19
supporting
information
on that.
So
I don’t
think
I
20
failed
to
respond
right
here.
21
Q.
Why don’t
you
take
a
look
at Page
4 of
22
your
report
and
see
if
that
jogs
your
memory
at
all.
23
I think
that’s
where
the same
information
is
24
presented.
Page
68
1
A.
I’m on Page
4 of my testimony.
2
Q.
No, Page
4 of the —-
3
A.
Prom
the
report, excuse
me.
The
4
report,
yeah.
5
Q.
And I think
you do
provide
a
citation
6
there.
And I can show
you
the
section
that
you’re
7
referring
to, if
you
want
me
to.
8
Do
you see
what
I’m talking
about?
9
A.
I
see
exactly
where it gives
an EPA
10
citation.
11
Q.
And what
is that, for the
record?
12
A.
It
says,
“IEPA Title
35,
Part 202,
13
Section 302.105.”
14
Q.
And
why don’t
you
read the sentence
15
again. Can
you
read the
sentence that
precedes
16
that?
17
A.
In this
—- in the report?
18
Q.
Uh-huh.
19
A.
“In contrast,
general
use
waters,
20
which
apply
to
most
Illinois
streams, are
designed
21
to
protect
communities
predominantly
composed of
22
pollution
sensitive
species.
23
Q.
I’m going
to
show
you
--
I hope this
24
is okay,
for reference,
it’s the
Board
regulation.
ro
N)
N)
N)
H
F-
H
H
H
H
H
I—’
H
H
N)
H
C)
co
0)
-J
01
(ii
Li
N)
H
C)
Ft
Q.
CD
CD
H
H
D
CD
H
CD
CD
Di
CD
Hl
CD
CD
C)
3
H-
Ft
Ft
cC)
H
Di
Ft
H-
CD
H
CD
0
Di
H
Q
CD
0
3
cC)
C)
H
cC)
Ft
Ft
H-
K)
3
CD
>
K)
CD
0
Di
Di
CD
CD
CD
D
3
•
H
CD
•
t-h
•
H-
Ft
3
CD
cC)
H-
0
0
Di
CD
cC)
CD
Ft
i
CD
H-
Di
CD
cC)
H-
H
CD
Ft
Ft
)<
CD
Di
Di
Di
H-
Di
Di
Ft
cC)
H
0
Ft
CD
cC)
C)
1
0
CD
3
H-
3
Z
CD
CD
H
CD
Ft
CD
C)
CD
CD
)J
0
Di
C
Cl)
i
c<
CD
0
)i
cC)
3
CD
3
Di
0
Di
3
H-
CD
•
•
•
•
Ft
•
CD
Ft
II
N-)
Q
Q
Di
Ft
C).
CD
CD
CD
H
H-
Ft
0
H-
CD
<
3
H
•)
Ft
‘
Di
Di
Ft
II
C)
C)
-<
C)
H-
H
•
CD
H
H
Z
H
Z
Ft
H
CD
Q
CD
0
0
(ii
Ft
CD
Ft
Di
CD
C)
H-
CD
cC)
II
•
•
CD
Q-
CD
D
Ft
Li
L’i
0
0
t
ci
o
o
Q.
H-
CD
H
CD
H
H
CD
CD
CD
I-I
D
Di
•
LJ-
H
Di
Di
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
Q
H
H-
-
Ft
CD
H
3
II
Di
CD
Ml
ci
Ft
0
‘
CD
CD
cC)
Di
cC)
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
C)
H
H
Di
H
H-
xl
CD
C).
CD
<
0
Di
CD
CD
Ft
CD
C)
H-
0
II
0
‘-<
CD
CD
CD
CD
cC)
0
CD
H-
3
CD
0
cC)
CD
Ml
CD
CD
i-<
h
CD
Ft
•
I-I
<
Ft
H-
•
Di
H-
•
CD
CD
CD
0
Di
Ft
C)
H
3
H-
CD
C)
Di
Ml
CD
Ft
H-
Di
Ft
Di
CD
•
Ft
Ft
Di
H-
Di
‘-<
Ft
3
0
Ft
CD
0
h-I
<1
0
H
0
H
—
cC)
H
CD
cC)
CD
CD
)
H
CD
Ml
H
0
CD
CD
-<
CD
•
H-
0
3
H-
CD
C)
Ft
3
ci
-,
Ft
0
Ft
CD
3
C)
CD
H-
H-
C).
CD
D
j
cC)
ci
0
CD
<
Ml
CD
Di
0
Ft
0
Di
Di
CD
Ft
H-
Ft
H
H-
Ml
N-)
Ft
H
Ft
Ml
CD
H
CD
Di
ci
‘
CD
Ft
0
H
-
H-
C).
H
Ft
CD
h
0
CD
Di
H
Di
ci
CD
H
C)
01
CD
Ft
H-
H-
H-
Ft
Di
Ml
II
Ft
CD
3
3
3
H-
Di
H
c<
ci
CD
Ft
cC)
0
CD
<
0
Ft
Di
Di
CD
H-
cC)
CD
i
ci
Ft
ti
CD
Di
H-
CD
H-
-
Di
Di
CD
Ft
CD
Ft
3
H
Ft
Ft
H-
cC)
-
Ft
CD
Ft
Di
<1
Ft
CD
N)
N)
N)
N)
N)
F-
H
H
H
F-
H
H
H
H
H
W
N)
H
C)
O
0)
—J
0)
(ii
W
N)
H
0
CX)
—J
C)
W
N)
H
Cl)
it
Cl)
I-H
h
it
Fj
H-
CD
Di
C)
Hi
I
H-
C)
Dl
CD
H
1
3
CD
:i
h
C/)
Di
Q
-
CD
Li
II
H-
it
Q.
it
it
C)
10
it
it
0
H
Cl)
0
H-
CD
•
I-H
•
H
II
0
J
CD
D
CD
Hi
1
a
H
0
Di
Dl
Hi
Di
CD
it
Z
C)
it
it
it
CD
Q
it
CD
Di
Cl)
CD
F-
Li
CD
Di
Di
F-
CD
it
I-
C/)
Cl)
C)
H-
Cl)
CD
i
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
C/)
Cl)
‘c
Di
CD
CD
3
CD
it
Hi
0
‘-<
Cl)
C)
C)
C)
1
I-H
a
L<
CD
•.
Dl
0
0
C/)
Dl
C/)
it
CD
Di
H
CD
CD
H-
<
Cl)
3
Hi
i
•
H-
H
H
<
I-
H
H-
•
—
Dl
it
0
0
H-
CD
CD
-
0
I-H
H
ct
H
Q
CD
H
3
H-
H
it
CD
3
0
H
X
Z
CD
3
H
Cl)
0
o
it
Cl)
Ii
a
0
CD
ti
[‘1
C)
I
Cl)
CD
H
Di
CD
CD
Dl
H
CD
-
C/)
7i
Li
H-
CD
H-
Cl)
CD
Cl)
it
Mi
-<
Cl)
H-
HI
0
Li
C/)
3
H-
0
a
10
it
—
-
‘-t
X
3
CD
ti
C)
3
ti
ct
H-
Di
1
it
CD
3
Di
0
Cl)
Q
C)
C)
Cl)
CE)
H
it
CD
Hi
D
Dl
CD
H-
H
3
•
0
••
0
0
it
••
it
Dl
CD
Q
o
Di
3
a
-
a
0
‘-1
Z
0
N)
CD
D
II
ç
II
it
H-
a
Di
“3
a
H
Di
Cl)
H
it
H-
CD
H-
CD
•
I-H
Dl
C)
LY
‘-<
it
H
•
Di
Di
it
Q
it
3
H
1
Di
‘-<
C/i
I-
0
-
Di
it
J
CD
•
[-
H
it
•
.
CD
C
Cl)
3
H-
a
CD
[-
H-
it
Di
H
Cl)
3
HI
Di
Q
H
0
H-
a
Di
0
3
H-
CD
0
3
3
Hi
Q
C
H-
CD
a
C)
H
3
0
Dl
Cl)
Hi
CD
0
it
Cl)
Cl)
CD
CD
3
Dl
Di
0
it
tQ
CD
-
CD
3
H-
H-
Di
•-J
Cl)
Di
-<
3
CD
H
h
CD
3
o
it
a
CD
Cl)
3
a
it
H-
Di
CD
II
it
3
H-
0
CD
‘C
CD
Cl)
3
Di
H-
C)
H
3
CD
0
<
it
H
it
C)
CD
Cl)
çE
CD
Di
Dl
<
CD
Di
Cl)
CD
Di
Di
it
II
II
Cl)
0
it
it
Cl)
Cl)
Di
3
Hi
Dl
CD
CD
CD
-
Di
H-
it
a
H-
Cl)
it
CD
1
3
I-<
3
3
CD
o
CD
Dl
CD
it
H-
II
Dl
0
CD
H
CD
I-h
H
H
F-h
3
C))
3
CD
a
<
HI
H-
o
h-
CD
H-
Di
L<
it
CD
3
0
3
it
a
—
HI
3
H-
H-
-ti
H-
Di
3
it
‘-<
CD
a
H-
3
H-
it
w
C)
Cl)
-,
3
CD
<1
0
3
Cl)
HQ
Dl
L<
it
H-
3
0
CD
it
0
CD
-
Dl
3
it
Page
71
1
potential
than
the Chicago area
waterways
and
to
2
protect
a
different collection
of species. And
3
different
biologic
conditions,
and...
4
Q.
Do
you
understand
what that
potential
5
is?
6
MR.
ANDES: Which
potential?
7
BY THE
WITNESS:
8
A.
I
guess you’d have
to
define
that
for
9
me.
10
BY
MS.
WILLIAMS:
11
Q.
You
said
the larger
point
you
were
--
12
let me
know
if
I’m correct.
13
A.
Well, I want
to repeat
myself.
14
Q.
The
point you
were getting
at
is
that
15
the general
use
standards
were developed
for
16
different
biological
potential.
And
I’m asking
you,
17
do you
know
what biological
potential
is?
18
A.
I
do know that
the Chicago
area
19
waterways
are very different
waterways
and
have
20
different
biologic
conditions
than
do
the general
21
waterways
in the
state
of
Illinois.
And
-- but I
22
haven’t
reviewed
the biologic
conditions
in all
of
23
the
Illinois
waterways
to
characterize
their
24
biologic
condition.
[0
N)
N)
N)
N)
[0
H
C)
F
O
a)
F-’
I—’
F
F-’
I-’
I-
I-
a)
(5’
(5)
[0
I—’
C)
a)
-J
OC
U’
E
(5)
N)
F-’
CD
CD
Q
I—’
E
Cl
C)
a
o
C)
C)
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
Ft
Ft
Q
Ci
I—h
Ft
CD
I—’
Ci
CD
CD
Ci
.,j
Ci
CD
Ci
CD
Ft
CD
C)
Ci
CD
CD
II
h-
CD
II
h
H-
h
I
h
h-
t-
ct
c-t
F-
CD
Mi
CD
Ci
H-
Ci
0
H-
CD
H-
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
>
c
-<
a
‘
Ci
‘-<
Ft
Ct
10
H-
Ci
•
CD
•
CD
CD
a
CD
H-
0
c—t
a
a
çt
CD
Ci
Ci
0
Ci
CD
Ci
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
0
CD
Ci
Ft
CD
-<
a
II
CD
I—’
ct
Mi
Ci
Ft
0
0
CD
‘-<
Ci
a
H-
CD
Hi
Ci
-<
Ii
Ft
CD
C)
0
Z
H-
‘-<
‘-<
0
i-<
CD
CD
CD
CD
Ci
a
1
a
I-<
c1
Ci
Ci
0
Ci
0
CD
Ci
CD
L<
0
H-’
F-
H-
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
Ci
CD
ct
Ci
CD
a
CD
CD
Ft
F-
CD
CD
CD
tQ
[-
Ci
CD
CD
<
Ci
HI
•
CD
.0
-<
CD
L<
C)
CD
Ci
CD
rt
•
CD
CD
H-
F—’
CD
h-
C)
1
C)
I-
CD
ct
CD
•0
<
C)
Ci
F-’
Ij
Ci
CD
Mi
Ci
H-
Cl
-
CD
0
Ci
a
CD
tQ
H-
CD
Ct
a
F-
CD
Ci
CD
Ci
Ci
h-
0
I-i
Ft
0
Ft
Ft
h
H-
C)
CD
0
Ci
CD
CD
CD
Ft
H-
Ci
Ci
Ci
CD
rt
C)
CD
t5
H-
0
CD
H-
‘
0
CD
H-
•
CD
Ci
CD
CD
rt
C)
a
Ci
CD
tQ
CD
C)
0
CD
CD
Q
I—I
‘<
a
F—’
0
H-
it
CD
H-’
CD
Fl
0
Ci
0
CD
CD
Mi
Ci
rt
Ci
C)
CD
1
C)
Mi
CD
H-
Ci
H-
H-’
H-
CD
Ft
I-I
CD
Ci
)<
C)
Ci
II
C)
rt
CD
Ci
H-
it
çt
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
(1
•
tY
Ci
CD
II
Ft
CD
Q
CD
CD
CD
it
H-
CD
Fl
CD
Ci
hi
0
I
CD
I-I
Ft
Ci
Ci
CD
C)
CD
H-
I
CD
CD
H-
CD
C)
it
II
CD
it
CD
0
Ci
Ft
Ci
it
CD
Ci
i-i
C)
Ft
Ci
I
H-
H-
Ci
I-i
CD
C)
CD
CD
CD
CD
Ci
C)
CD
H-
X
CD
CD
hi
0
hI
0
it
CD
CD
Ft
N
it
Ci
Ci
0
Ft
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
Ci
0
CD
hi
Ci
CD
H-
Ci
I
CD
I-I
Ft
Ft
Ci
CD
CD
CD
I
0
Ft
CD
CD
Ci
CD
Ft
CD
F—’
CD
H-
CD
hi
Ci
CD
•
-i
‘-<
a
0
a
Ft
Ci
C)
CD
Ft
CD
Ci
CD
Ci
CD
0
CD
Ft
-
CD
çt
it
CD
hi
F-
CD
0
<
Ci
0
rt
()
CD
Ci
‘
Ci
CD
CD
Ci
Mi
F—’
Ci
CD
Ci
H-
Ft
Ft
Ci
Ci
Ft
CD
Ci
CD
CD
9
0
Ci
CD
CD
0
Mi
0
Ci
hi
Ft
CD
CD
Ft
H
Ci
0
Ci
Ft
CD
hi
‘iJ
CD
Di
-
LQ
CD
CD
CD
Page
73
1
Q.
Do
you
know if in Illinois there are
2
general
use waters that are channelized?
3
A.
I would
expect there are some.
4
Q.
What
about general
use
waters that are
5
primarily
urban industrial?
6
A.
I would expect
there are some,
too.
7
Q.
What
about having areas with stagnant
8
areas?
9
A.
I would expect
there might
be
some.
10
MR.
ANDES:
If I can follow
up
on
11
that.
12
Isnvt
there
a specific provision
13
for
stagnant
areas
in general
use
waters?
14
THE WITNESS:
Yes, there is.
15
BY MS. WILLIAMS:
16
Q.
What provisions
are
you
referring
to,
17
Mr. Freedman?
18
MR. ANDES:
It’s in his testimony.
19
BY THE WITNESS:
20
A.
I believe
it’s referred in my
21
testimony, if I can look
that
up?
22
BY MS. WILLIAMS:
23
Q.
Sure.
24
A.
Let me...
‘J
t’J
N)
N)
N)
H
F
I-
F—’
I-’
F
H
I—’
I-
W
N)
H
0
co
Cx)
—i
C5
()‘
W
N)
H
0
co
co
cii
U)
N)
F--’
LI
(A)
0
IJJ
CD
0
H
LI
CD
NJ
Hi
CD
CD
Ft
H
NJ
LI
U)
X
CD
0
CD
zj
Ft
(A)
H-
CD
Ct)
H-
K)
Z
it
C)
C)
0
it
it
-
LI
CD
3
•
•
H
•
F—I
CD
LI
F-
F-
H-
Hi
LI
CD
J
CD
Ft
it
H
-
H-
CD
CD
CD
CD
it
Q)
C)
-
K)
C)
0)
it
Z
CD
3
LI
LI
Q
Ft
CD
Ft
CD
LI
0
H-
H
H-
H
LI
LI
LI
H-
H-
LI
3
U)
H
Hi
Hi
LI
CD
CD
CD
C)
LI
CD
L
U)
0
CD
Cl)
CD
•
0)
U
C)
CD
H-
CD
H
U)
F-H
••
0
LI
Z
CD
çt
CD
LI
LI
F-
C)
Ft
LI
C)
LI
•
U)
LI
U)
2
Ft
U)
H-
CD
CD
Ai
LI
CD
H-
Hi
CD
CD
H-
•
H-
•
•
H-
•
0
CD
U)
CD
it
Q
LI
0
Hi
LI
LI
CD
LI
“l
CD
0
LI
CD
H-
it
LI
H-
CD
cC)
LI
H
LI
H-
ct
C)
C)
LI
CD
C)
LI
CD
CD
H
I
H
Z
CD
H
LI
0
CD
0)
H
Z
cQ
CD
‘
H-
CD
L<
Ft
Cl)
it
I
(3
it
-C)
LI
Ft
CD
(3
3
CD
H
0
Hi
0
Q
it
U)
[‘1
it
LI
CD
CD
LI
[‘1
tY
C).
CD
LI
LI
0
LI
F-H
0
U)
0
H
CD
CD
j
H-
U)
LI
CD
it
LI
CD
CD
LI
CD
Hi
Ft
H-
CD
3
(3
C)
CD
LI
1
CD
a
U)
H-
U)
0
CD
CD
LI
0
CD
H-
CD
LI
H
CD
••
LI
-
LI
o
H
Q
CD
Ft
cC)
LI
-
Ft
CD
CD
LI
Ft
CD
LI
CD
0)
CD
Q.
H
LI
CD
CJ
C).
Ft
H-
0
Ft
CD
CD
H
CD
>
CD
CD
U-
()
H
CD
LI
H
CD
0
II
Ft
-J-
LI
Ft
CD
LI
CD
H-
Q
CD
<
LI
Hi
CD
a
LI
LI
LI
CD
<
CD
CD
LI
Q
CD
CD
CD
Ft
0
H-
CD
CD
H
Q
H-
Ft
H
H-
CD
cC)
0)
LI
LI
Ft
LI
Ft
H
Ft
CT)
H
CD
CD
H-
LI
-
H-
CD
LI
cC)
H
LI
CD
CD
C)
3
0
Ft
CD
C).
Ft
Ft
LI
LI
CD
H-
CD
Q
Ft
CD
3’
LI
cC)
LI
Ft
3’
0
U)
C<
CD
Ft
3’
CD
‘-<
CD
3’
CD
CD
Ft
LI
CD
cC)
H
CD
Ft
CD
H-
CD
0
CD
cC)
-
o
CD
C)
CD
H
CD
3’
CD
LI
LI
CD
H-
-<
cC)
CD
CD
Ft
LI
Ft
CD
CD
cC)
CD
LI
-
CD
LI
0
H
H
H-
Ft
0
a
LI
LI
C)
H
CT)
Hi
0
Ft
0
LI
0)
LI
Ft
Ft
CD
CD
C<
Q
Ft
LI
0
C)
0
LI
Q
--
Ft
3’
LI
0
H
cC)
0)
LI
CD
I
H-
CC)
0
H-
LI
CD
C)
CD
CD
Ft
C<
CD
I
LI
C)
CD
0
H
0
H-
LI
LI
LI
H-
•
Ft
cC)
Ft
CD
Ft
LI
LI
rj
Q
CD
CD
0
H-
F-I
H-
LI
H
LI
Ft
cC)
CD
CD
LI
<
LI
0
Ft
0
CD
H-
CD
CD
cC)
‘
CD
CD
CD
LI
0
LI
LI
CD
CD
3
CD
H
LI
)
CD
CD
LI
C).
H-
Ft
LI
C)
Hi
E’J
t’J
r’j
tJ
N)
H
F
l-
H-
F-
l-
F-
I-
F
H
(
N)
F
C
D
a)
-J
D)
W
N)
l—
N)
i-
a
CD
çt
ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
1
CD
H-
H-
H-
l-
J
Cl)
0
CD
11
CD
CD
ci
ci
CD
0
.Q
(I)
CD
CD
ct
Cl)
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
h
Q
0
CD
3
C)
CD
1
ft
ft
H-
ci
H-
ci
CD
CD
0
ft
ci
CD
H
Q-
C)
CD
CD
Q.
0
H-
H
LQ
a
CD
Ft
CD
C)
CD
CD
C)
CD
3
ct
CD
H-
D
CD
Cl)
C)
CD
CD
H-
ft
1
ft
3
ft
H-
CD
C)
CD
CD
Q
rt
Cl
L<
C).
0
ft
0
H-
CD
0
ft
CD
CD
ft
•
h-i
-
a
•
CD
0
•
•
CD
•
0
ft
3
CD
0
0
C)
CD
CD
ft
•\)
F
3
Q
I-I
CD
3
ft
tI
0
rt
3
çt
H-
•
H-
CD
Cl)
CD
CD
ct
3
H
J
ct
CD
CD
H
C)
ci
H-
C)-
3
C)
ct
a
0
H-
ft
CD
H-i
0
CD
[1
H-
C)-
s
CD
5
H-
CD
CD
0
CD
Q
ct
CD
Q
çt
CD
3
C)
I-I
‘-<
Ii
3
H-
3
CD
1
CD
Iii
H-
CD
H-
II
a
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
H-
CD
H-
C)
CD
0
CD
ft
o
H-
CD
0
0
ii
Q
ft
CD
ft
3
çt
H-
CD
CD
CD
H-
C)
II
CD
ft
0
Ft
•
ft
Ft
ct
CD
C)
ci
<
CD
h
1
C)
CD
H-
3
Ft
CD
H-
a
3
H-
0
II
CD
tI
CD
a
Ft
0
-
CD
H-
H-
t
3
CD
3
H-
ft
3
CD
a
<
3
3
CD
3
CD
3
CD
Q
‘-<
Ft
Ft
a
0
CD
CD
a
0
LQ
ft
C)
0
ft
CD
ci
0
H-
H-
3
H’
H-
0
CD
ci
Ft
ft
ft
H-
3
CD
x
ii
CD
ID
ft
a
<
I-h
CD
H-
3
CD
Ft
3
H-
C)
<
CD
ct
h
H
H-
CD
CD
H-
ft
CD
CD
ft
ft
0
C)
CD
o
cn
0
CD
a
3
CD
CD
CD
H-
CD
ft
a
CD
Ft
ft
H-
H’
CD
II
ft
a
a
II
3
H’
H-
CD
CD
3
CD
0
3
ci
CD
o
II
CD
CD
0
-
a
CD
1
<
CD
ti
CD
CD
Q
CD
CD
H-
•
C)
X
ft
CD
ti
CD
0
CD
C)-
CD
ft
•O
H-
C)
ft
3
CD
C)
H-
<
Ft
CD
ft
C)
ci
0
H-
C)
0
CD
ft
CD
Q
CD
CD
CD
Ft
ft
0
H
CD
ti
CD
3
3
H’
CD
ft
CD
0
II
<
H-
ti
CD
H’
C)
CD
0
CD
3
ID
H-
ft
CD
CD
CD
CD
iC)
CD
CY
CD
ft
tI
3
CD
CD
CD
H
3
o
h
CD
Ft
ft
II
3
CD
CD
II
ci
ft
CD
ft
ci
t5
0
3
CD
ft
Ft
a
a
CD
0
3
0
a
Ii
H-
3
ft
ti
Cl
L<
C)
Ft
Cl)
CD
H-
H-i
<
ft
C)
CD
3
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
3
CD
L<
CD
ft
ft
ft
CD
Cl
3
ft
Q
ft
H-
H-
CD
ft
Ft
CD
H-
H-
CD
C)
0
0
Ft
1
CD
H-
C)
Ft
0
0
H-
Ft
CD
1
0
H-i
ft
H-
CD
CD
ft
H-
3
3
0
CD
3
3
3
CD
ft
CD
3
I—h
ci
CD
II
CD
Ft
3
Cl
3
CD
CD
CD
II
Cl
CD
CD
ti
a
CD
CD
Q
-Q
CD
CD
C)-
ft
II
CD
Ft
ft
CD
H-
ft
CD
ft
0
‘-<
ft
CD
CD
H’
CD
CD
C)
ft
3
0
ft
CD
3
0
CD
C)
C3
0
Ft
3
Cl
<
0
ft
0
CD
I-fl
H-
ft
Cl
ft
F-
CD
0
ft
‘-<
CD
3
Ft
•J
II
0
CD
H-
CD
ci
ft
CD
CD
CD
3
3
CD
CD
H-
CD
CD
iC)
0
a
Cl
CD
I-h
CD
i-c
Page
76
1
stagnant
conditions
should
be
reflected
in
this
2
rulemaking?
3
A.
I
guess
I can’t
speak
to what
the
4
District
might
be
willing
to propose,
but
it is
my
5
opinion
that those
kinds
of
conditions
need
special
6
consideration.
And
those
special
considerations
7
weren’t
embodied
in
the
IEPA
proposal.
8
I think
you
spent
quite
a
bit of
9
time
this
morning
with
Dr. Garcia
talking
about
the
10
complexities
of
the hydraulics
and
special
11
conditions,
and
I think
those
conditions
are unique
12
in
the
state.
13
MS.
WILLIAMS:
That’s
all I
have
on
14
this.
15
MS. TIPSORD:
With
that,
we
go
to
16
Ms.
Dexter.
17
BY MS.
DEXTER:
18
Q.
I’m
going
to
start
with
my prefiled
19
Question
No.
1.
20
“In
various
parts
of
your
21
testimony,
you
mentioned
temperature
effects
22
proposing
but
not
including
the
IEPA
adequately
23
studied.
What
portion
of
the CAWS
needs
further
24
study
with
regard
to
temperature
effect?”
Page 77
1
A.
I really
only
mentioned
temperature
in
2
the
-— in some
limited
context
in my
testimony.
For
3
example, I
mentioned
temperature
when
quoting
4
others,
such
as
Dr.
Garcia,
as
to the factors
5
affecting
stratified
stagnant
conditions,
which
I
6
think
are
factors that
need more
study.
7
Another
example
I
quoted
was
from
8
the UAA
study from CDM,
which
talks
about
water
9
quality
not
meeting
criteria
and the
need for
10
site-specific
criteria.
So
the
questions
about
11
temperature
were
not really
a focal
point
of my
12
testimony,
but this was
a peripheral
issue.
13
Q.
Do
you
know
who the
significant
14
thermal
discharges
to
the CAWS
are?
15
A.
I didn’t
study the
thermal
discharges
16
in
the CAWS,
so
I
wouldn’t
be
able
to
rely giving
an
17
opinion
on that.
18
Q.
That’s
fine.
19
Are
the current
CSO5 harming
20
aquatic
life in
any portion of
the
CAWS?
21
A.
I really have
not
made
a
study of
CSO
22
impacts on
aquatic
life,
per
se, so
I
-- and I
23
didn’t
testify
to
that,
so
I couldn’t
express
an
24
opinion
about the
effects on
actual aquatic
life.
Page
78
1
Q.
I’ll
skip
Question
4 then.
2
Five.
“Are
you
aware
of
any wet
3
weather
standards
that would
allow
dissolved
oxygen
4
conditions
to
fall
below
one
milligram
per
liter
and
5
provide
information on that
issue?”
6
MR. ANDES:
I
believe
several
examples
7
were
provided
on
that issue.
8
MS.
DEXTER:
Of
what
weather
standards
9
would
allow
--
10
MR. ANDES:
Yes.
11
MS.
DEXTER:
-- dissolved
oxygen
to
12
fall
below one
milligram
per
liter?
13
MS.
ANDES:
Right.
14
MS.
WILLIAMS:
I thought
she
testified
15
she
didn’t
know
of any
wet weather
aquatic
16
life
standards.
17
MR.
ANDES:
The
Patapsco
was
an
18
example,
I
believe,
in
Maryland.
19
MS.
NEMURA:
I
testified
that
what
the
20
UAA
has
done
for aquatic
life uses
were
not
21
specifically
done
with
wet weather
conditions
22
in mind,
but
conditions
addressed
by
the
UAA5
23
could
include
wet weather
conditions.
24
MS.
DEXTER:
We’re
talking
about
the
r’j
N)
N)
N)
N)
F-
H
F-
i-
-
H
H
I-
-
.
W
N)
i-
0
0
-
0
(11
W
N)
F-
0
o
co
—i
co
U’
U’
N)
w
7)
IC
C)
Ft
Dl
Z
Ft
a
t-
Di
Di
C)
W
Ft
CD
<
HI
CD
CD
I—’
Di
0
H-
0
II
Di
Ft
Dl
Q
H
CD
Di
CD
C)
a
F-
H-
H-
‘-<
Di
Dl
II
0
CD
Ft
CD
0
i
Ft
Ft
3
H-
F-I
CD
0
Dl
rt
Ft
Cl)
Di
a
Di
<1
t
C)
i
a
CD
CD
•
Di
3
CD
Di
rt
0
CD
H-
a
Di
-
C)
CD
H
Ft
Ft
•
Di
CD
a
CD
CD
CD
Ft
-<
CD
CD
CD
0
CD
CD
Cl
CD
Ft
•
•
CD
CD
1’I
D
3
t
CD
•
Di
CD
•
rt
Ft
•
CD
CD
Ft
Di
a
Di
Di
Ft
CD
0
H-
it
H
<
H-
H-’
ID
Z
CD
ID
Di
rt
Z
Di
C’i
F-I
CD
CD
CD
HI
CD
3
0
[‘1
L’i
‘t3
Di
LxJ
Y
Ft
CD
H
Q
Ft
><
CD
Z
CD
H
it
CD
CD
D
Z
Ft
H-
CD
ID
CD
H
C)
i—a
ID
Di
[‘l
HI
3
Di
CD
1’i
0
0
CD
x1
CD
[‘1
0
H-
I
H-
CD
CD
CD
Ft
CD
3
CD
<
3
•
CD
I
H-’
H-
H-
CD
Di
CD
•
CD
••
••
••
0
CD
0
0
Ft
•
CD
CD
CD
Z
3
3
CD
CD
CD
a
CD
CD
‘ci
‘C3
CD
H-
H
H
it
H
H-
0
0
CD
F-I
CD
C)
D
CD
Ii
it
CD
C)
Hi
Hi
C)
0
Hi
rt
D
Cl)
II
CD
Hi
Ft
Di
CD
1
Di
Di
H-
Hi
C)
0
CD
CD
Di
CD
3
Ft
Cl
Hi
HI
Di
CD
Ci
CD
t
hi
CD
I-
CD
Y
0
H-
F—’
CD
0
3
CD
0
a
CD
a
CD
•
F-I
CD
C)
Di
H-
Q
Ft
CD
F-
CD
H-
Di
CD
H-
Di
C)
it
CI)
Y
0
Ft
CD
H-
Hi
it
3
‘-<
it
CD
I—I
0
0
CD
Di
3
C)
CD
a
0
Hi
Di
I-I
CD
H-
Hi
II
CD
CD
h-
Q
H-
0
0
CD
CD
Ft
çt
Di
CD
Ft
Di
F-’
CD
F-
ti
a
<
Dl
CD
Ft
it
Ft
-,
D
Ft
-
0
Di
H-
Ft
<
ti
H-
CD
H-
CD
CD
hi
CD
a
‘ti
H-
0
H-
CD
0
Di
H-’
0
a
CD
a
H-
F-
Di
3
H-
C)
Ft
CD
0
CD
CD
-
CD
0
•
h
0
‘t
<
0
CD
CD
<
X
•0
0
CD
CD
CD
Hi
Di
Dl
3
CD
Dl
F-’
CD
1
Ft
II
CD
Di
II
a
Di
Ft
Ft
H-
F-’
H-
H-
H-
CD
tj
Ft
3
•
Di
Di
CD
Di
3
Di
Di
—1
H-
3
Di
3
CD
Ft
C)
C)
CD
0
CD
CD
CD
Page
80
1
testify
that she was
not
aware
that the standards
in
2
Maine
had ever
been
utilized
in practice
anywhere.
3
Do
you
disagree
with
that?
4
BY THE
WITNESS:
5
A.
I don’t
disagree
with that.
I’m
just
6
staying
that the
State
Water
Quality
Standards
7
provide
the allowance
for
that condition.
8
MR. ANDES:
I think
that was
the
9
question.
10
BY
THE WITNESS:
11
A.
And
that
was
all that I was
stating.
12
MS.
DEXTER:
Okay.
13
MR.
ANDES:
We
also have
copies of
the
14
Maine
and
Massachusetts
regulations,
that we
15
can introduce.
16
The
first
document
is from
the
17
Maine
Water
Quality
Standards,
38, Section
18
464
of
classification
of
Maine waters.
19
MS.
TIPSORD:
If
there’s
no objection,
20
we will
mark
the
Maine
Classification
of
21
Waters.
22
MS. WILLIAMS:
I
have an
objection.
23
I’m sorry,
but it
goes
from Page
1
to Page
3.
24
MR.
ANDES:
The
relevant sections
may
Page 81
1
not site all
the various
pages
of that
2
particular
Maine regulation, only the
3
relevant portions.
4
MS.
TIPSORD: With that -- with noting
5
that, I’m
going
to
enter it over
6
Ms. William’s
objection
as
Exhibit 207.
7
(WHEREUPON,
a
certain document was
8
marked Exhibit
9
No. 207 for
identification, as of
10
2/17/09.)
11
MR. ANDES:
The same is true
as to the
12
following exhibit, which
is
from
314CMR4.00
13
Massachusetts
Surface Water Quality
14
Standards. The particular excerpt that’s
15
included
beyond
the first
page is
16
Section 4.06,
that’s the relevant section.
17
MS. TIPSORD: If there’s no objection,
18
we will
site —- we will enter the
19
Massachusetts 31CMR for
Division of Water
20
Pollution Control,
Massachusetts Water
21
Quality
Standards
as
Exhibit 208 -- excerpt.
22
MS. WILLIAMS:
And I would
just like
23
to request for the record that
with regard
to
24
Exhibit 207, that the
District
be
asked
to
Page
82
1
supplement
with
this
Page
2.
Because
I
2
have
——
I think
I have
reviewed
these
regs,
3
and
I
do
think
what’s
on Page
2
is
relevant.
4
Do
you
see
what
I’m saying?
It
5
starts
with
procedures
for
reclassification
6
and
then
it
cuts off.
Would
you
be
willing
7
to
do that?
8
MR. ANDES:
Sure.
I think
the
9
portion,
though,
that
we were
discussing
is
10
the
temporary
removal
of
designated
uses
11
section,
Section
2(b),
sewer
overflows.
12
And that’s
why
we didn’t
include
13
Pages
2
or 5
or
6 or
7. But
I can
certainly
14
provide
Page
2.
15
MS.
TIPSORD:
If there’s
no
objection
16
to
entering
Exhibit
208,
it’s
entered.
17
Seeing
none,
we
will enter
it.
18
(WHEREUPON,
a
certain
document
was
19
marked
Exhibit
20
No.
208
for
identification,
as
of
21
2/17/09.)
22
MS.
DEXTER:
I
have no
further
23
questions
or
witnesses.
24
MS.
TIPSORD:
Anything
else for
Page
83
1
Mr.
Freedman?
2
MS.
DIERS:
Thank
you
very
much,
3
Mr.
Freedman.
4
THE
WITNESS:
Thank
you.
5
(WHEREUPON,
the witness
was
6
excused.)
7
MS.
TIPSORD:
That
moves
us
on
to
8
Dr.
Dennison.
9
Good afternoon,
Dr.
Dennison.
10
I will remind
you
you’ve been
11
sworn
in
at
least
twice
before,
so we will
12
not
do
so
again.
You are still
under
oath.
13
And with that,
we can
do
his
14
prefiled
testimony.
15
MR. ANDES:
Yes.
16
MS.
TIPSORD:
If
there’s
no
objection,
17
we
will
enter
Dr.
Dennison’s
prefiled
18
testimony
in this
section,
which
is
on behalf
19
of
the
District,
concerning
dissolved
oxygen
20
standards
proposed
for
protecting
aquatic
21
life
in
the
designated
Aquatic Life
Use A
22
Waters
and
Aquatic
Life
Use
B
Waters
of the
23
Chicago
Area
Water System.
We
will enter
24
that
as Exhibit 209,
if
there’s
no
objection.
Page
84
1
Seeing
none,
it’s
Exhibit
209.
2
(WHEREUPON,
a
certain
document
was
3
marked
Exhibit
4
No.
209
for
identification,
as
of
5
2/17/09.)
6
SAMUEL
G.
DENNISON,
7
called
as
a
witness
herein,
having
been
previously
8
duly
sworn
and
having
testified, was
examined
and
9
testified
further as
follows:
10
EXAMINATION
11
BY
MS.
DIERS:
12
Q.
Dr.
Dennison, I’m
going
to start
with
13
Question 2
of
your
prefiled
questions.
Can
you
14
please
describe
the
Winkler Titration
Method
15
mentioned on
Page
3 of
your
prefiled testimony?
16
A.
The
Winkler
Titration Method
is
a
17
chemical procedure for
determining the
oxygen
18
concentration
in
a sample
of
water. We
use
the
19
method
as
given
in
standard methods
for
the
20
examination
of
water
and waste
water
method 4500—CC
21
azide
modification.
22
A
300
ml
water
sample
that
is
23
collected and
chemically fixed
in the
field
is
24
brought
to
the
laboratory and
manually
titrated
Page
85
1
using
a
digital
buret.
Dissolved
oxygen
is
2
expressed
in milligrams
per
liter.
3
MR.
ANDES:
And
I have
copies
of
that
4
method.
This
is from
A Standard
Method
For
5
the
Examination
of
Water
and Waste
Water,
6
19th
edition,
1995.
It’s
the
excerpt
7
involving
method
4500—OC
azide
modification.
8
MS. TIPSORD:
If
there’s
no
objection,
9
we
will
enter
this,
Standard
Methods
For
the
10
Examination
of Water
and
Waste Water,
as
11
Exhibit
210.
12
Seeing
none,
it’s
Exhibit
210.
13
(WHEREUPON,
a
certain
document
was
14
marked
Exhibit
15
No.
210
for
identification,
as
of
16
2/17/09.)
17
BY MS.
DIERS:
18
Q.
Question
3.
19
“Why
are
you of
the
opinion
that
20
additional aeration
systems
will
not
increase
the
21
fish
population
in
the
CAWS?”
22
A.
Because
of
the severe
aquatic
habitat
23
limitations
of
the Chicago
area waterway
system,
24
additional
aeration
systems
would
not
be expected
to
[‘J
hJ
hJ
L’J
N)
H
F-
F
-
F-
I-
-
F-
I-
Ui
N)
H
0
co
0
—J
0
i-
C)
ci
Cl)
0
H-i
Di
Q
Ft
NJ
CD
C)
Ft
Ft
Ft
D
C)
CD
it
3
Dl
3
H-
C)
çt
0
3
CD
ci
CD
Di
CD
Ft
C
C)
CD
CD
c)
Di
CD
CD
Y
CD
H
0
Ft
Di
CD
—J
3
it
it
H-
C)
U)
CD
Ft
<
H-
0
3
0
H-
•
Q.
H
C)
H-
H-
H-
it
3
ct
•
3
j
Di
H
Dl
H-
0
-<
Di
H-
Di
Di
CD
H
<
CD
Dl
3
0
0
Ft
3
3
Ft
K)
‘-<
CD
3
Q
3
Ft
3
K)
C)
3
cQ
H
Ft
-
CD
Ft
CD
Q
•
Ft
3
CD
C)
H-
<
II
L<
H
-,
H-
CD
3
Ft
D
H-
H-
<
CD
3
-‘
CD
H-
H-
Di
h-
CD
0
h-h
0
3
CD
0
Di
CD
H
Ft
0
X
H-
H
C)
h
0
‘-<
3
H-
3
H
D
H
H-
3
Di
<
CD
CD
C)
Di
3
0
•
Ft
1
CD
CD
cQ
CD
i.Q
Cl
3
Ft
CD
3
Ft
Di
Di
Ft
hi
CD
CD
C)
CD
K)
3
Ft
i—i
CD
H-
o
3
0
3
C)
Ft
3
CD
CD
0
Ij
CD
1
3
CD
H-
3
3
H-
1
Q
Ft
6
0
H
Ft
H-
0
CD
CD
0
D
1
C)
CD
3
0
Ft
Di
H-
Di
3
0
3
h-h
CD
C)
3
Di
H-
1
CD
I-H
Ft
‘
Ft
H
cC)
3
H-
CD
Ft
Dl
CD
<
CD
CD
Ft
X
3
Ft
3
H-
H-
Ft
II
0
H-
H
CD
C)
Di
D
Ft
Di
Dl
CD
CD
D
‘-<
Ft
Ft
0
Di
Cl
d
0
CD
3
0
6
CD
Di
3
Ft
6
CD
3
3
3
3
Ii
II
3
3
U)
Di
CD
CD
Ft
CD
CS
C)
cC)
Ft
0
CD
CD
C)
C)
H-
C)
Di
3
H
CD
II
H
CD
0
cC)
C)
J
CD
h
CD
H-
‘tI
3
CD
Di
cC)
H-
CD
CD
Ft
C)
CD
CD
Ft
CD
H-
CD
CD
Ft
3
0
cC)
C)..
cC)
•
C)
0
Cl
3
o
3
6
CD
CD
cC)
CD
CD
C)
D
CD
Di
Cl
H
Ft
U)
CD
Di
Di
H-
CD
CD
C)
CD
CD
t
Ft
H-
CD
•
H-
Ft
II
3
Ft
Ft
Cl
Ft
0
Di
F-I
Di
<
H-i
CD
CD
3’
CD
Ft
Ft
CD
Di
CD
Di
U)
3
C).
H-
CD
CD
CD
3
Ft
Di
CD
C)..
Ft
‘Ti
3
0
CD
Ft
Di
C)..
Di
H-
Ft
Ft
H-
H-
H
Di
CD
CD
I-
J
o
Di
•
Ft
Ft
0
0
3
‘-<
CD
0
H-
3
H
3
CD
CD
3
Di
h
3
h
Ft
CD
CD
CD
3
Di
0..
Ft
F-
•
‘TI
6
CD
CD
CD
CD
3
Di
0
CD
3
Di
H-
CD
0
H
H-
0
•
CD
‘TI
t-
H
C)
3
0
0
‘Ti
3
b
Ft
‘-<
6
CD
H-
h
CD
<
CD
C).
3
3
Di
6
C)..
CD
Di
0
3
0
0
CD
H-
0
CD
Di
C)
H
h
Ft
6
C)
H
CD
Ft
‘Ti
NJ
C)..
Ft
CD
H-
0
C)..
H
Di
Di
Di
0
Ft
3
0
C)
3
Ft
3
CD
Ft
CD
0
3i
1
H-
6
3
Di
CD
CD
C)
0
Di
L<
H-
L<
H-
h-h
<
CD
Ft
H
Di
3
II
Di
(.n
X
Ft
Ft
0
3
3
0
Ft
Di
h-h
C)..
<
C)
H
‘-<
3
H-
6
0
Di
3
3
0
H
CD
h-h
CD
CD
CD
Ft
cC)
CD
CD
I-
3
CD
Ft
6
0
CD
Ft
H
3
CD
Ft
<
H
C)..
H
3
Di
i
CD
3
Di
0
h
3
H
H-
CD
3
CD
Ft
H-
0
0
Ft
0
0
C)
h
C)..
0
1
H-
3
Ft
h-h
H-
CD
6
CD
CD
cC)
Ft
CD
CD
0
cC)
Di
0
h
cC)
CD
h-h
CD
Ft
3
3
C)..
H
3
CD
h-h
H-
CD
C)
Ft
<
0
0
CD
Di
Ft
0
H
0
CD
0
3
•‘J
Ft
h
CD
h-h
CD
C)
C)
Page
87
1
important.
2
Q.
Question
5.
3
“What
would
you
recommend
for
CAWS
4
A
waters
with
respect
to dissolved
oxygen?”
5
A.
I agree
with
the testimonies
of
6
Dr.
Mackey
and Melching
and Mr.
Freedman.
7
Q.
I’m
sorry,
could
you
repeat
that?
8
A.
I
agree
with the
testimonies
of
9
Dr.
Mackey,
Dr. Melching
and Mr.
Freedman.
10
Q.
And
did
they
say
they
didn’t
have
a
11
recommendation
for
dissolved
oxygen?
12
MR.
ANDES:
Does
he have
to
13
characterize their
testimony?
14
MS.
DIERS:
I’m
asking
a
question.
15
can’t
remember
what
we talked
about in
16
December.
17
50
if he
can
answer
it,
fine.
If
18
he can’t,
fine.
19
BY
THE
WITNESS:
20
A.
Yes,
I
can’t
be
more
specific
than
to
21
say
that
we
should
wait for
these
studies
to
be
22
completed.
23
BY MS.
DIERS:
24
Q.
Once
these
studies
are
completed,
is
Page
88
1
the
District
going
to
make
a
recommendation
for
2
these
waters
to
the
Board?
3
A.
I
don’t
know.
4
MR.
ANDES:
That
question
can
5
certainly
be
raised
to
Dr.
Grenado
when
he
6
raps
up
testimony
for
the
District.
7
MS.
DIERS:
Can
we
just
have
a
second?
8
MS.
TIPSORD:
Sure.
9
MS.
DIERS:
Thank
you.
10
I
have
nothing
further.
11
MS.
TIPSORD:
Anything
further
for
12
Dr.
Dennison?
13
MS.
DEXTER:
I
have
one
follow-up
14
question.
15
BY MS.
DEXTER:
16
Q.
This
morning, when
we
were
talking
to
17
Dr.
Nemura
about
what
Tarp
could
do,
there
was
some
18
uncertainty
about
whether
or not
Tarp
would
address
19
the
--
CSOs.
Do
you
have
any
insight
on
that?
20
MR.
ANDES:
Is
that
on
—-
21
BY
THE
WITNESS:
22
A.
Could
you
repeat
the
question?
I
23
didn’t
quite
catch
the
last
part
of
the
sentence.
24
Page
89
1
BY MS. DEXTER:
2
Q.
This
morning
when we
talked
to
3
Dr.
Nemura,
she
wasn’t certain
whether
Tarp
would
4
address
more
than
just gravity
CSOs if there
was —-
5
if it
would also
address those
from
the
stations.
6
Do
you
know
more
about
Tarp,
as
an
employee
of
the
7
District,
that
you can
shed some
light on that?
8
MR.
ANDES:
So particularly
with
9
regard
to, say,
pump stations?
10
MS.
DEXTER:
Particularly
with
regard
11
to
the
uncertainty
that
Dr. Nemura
had this
12
morning,
about whether
Tarp would
do
more
13
than
just gravity.
14
MR.
ANDES:
Let
me
see
if I
can
help.
15
Is it
your understanding
that
Tarp
16
will
eliminate
all
the pump
stations
based on
17
your
understanding?
18
THE
WITNESS:
No.
19
MR. ANDES:
It might
reduce
the
20
discharges
from some
of
them?
21
THE WITNESS:
Certainly.
22
MR.
ANDES:
Is
it going
to
eliminate
23
all
of the
CSO discharge
points?
24
THE
WITNESS:
It’s not
understand
that
Page
90
1
it
would.
2
MR.
ANDES:
But it
might
reduce
the
3
number
and
reduce
the
frequency
of
overflows
4
to some
extent?
5
THE
WITNESS:
Yes.
6
MR. ANDES:
Okay.
7
MS.
DEXTER:
I
guess
that’s
pretty
8
good.
9
MS.
TIPSORD:
Anything
else
for
10
Dr.
Dennison.
11
Thank
you
very
much
Dr.
Dennison.
12
(WHEREUPON,
the
witness
was
13
excused.)
14
MS. TIPSORD:
Let’s
go
off the
record
15
for
just
a
second.
16
(WHEREUPON,
discussion
was had
17
off
the
record.)
18
MS. TIPSORD:
Back
on
the
record.
19
Instead
of adjourning
this
hearing,
I’m
going
20
to continue
this
hearing
on
the record
to
21
March
3rd
and
4th,
both hearings
to
be
22
continued
here Chicago.
I’ve
talked
to
23
Mr.
Andes
off
the
record
and
his
witnesses
24
will
be
available
on
those two
days.
And
we
Page 91
1
plan
to
finish
with
the last
five
of the
2
district’s
witnesses
on
March
3rd
and
4th.
3
We
also
will have
a prehearing
conference
on
4
February
27th at
1:00
in the
afternoon
by
5
phone.
And we
will
discuss
at that
point
6
additional
hearings
in
April,
May, June
and
7
what
that schedule
is going
to
look
like.
8
I thank
you
all again
for
your
9
patience
and
for your
willingness
to
10
compromise
and
work
on
these
issues.
If
you
11
all weren’t
as
willing
as you
are
to do
this
12
stuff,
this
could
be
a
very much
more
13
difficult
time
for
all of
us.
So
thank
you
14
all
again.
15
And
with
that,
we will
continue
16
this
on
the
record,
and
we
are
recessed
for
17
today.
Thank
you.
18
And
I will
do
a
hearing
officer
19
order
laying
out
rooms,
time, phone
numbers,
20
all
of
that.
21
(WHICH
WERE
ALL
THE MATTERS
22
HEARD
IN THE
ABOVE-ENTITLED
23
CAUSE THIS
DATE.)
24
M
N)
N)
N)
N)
H
H
H
H
H
H
I—’
H
H
W
N)
H
G’
D
CX)
-
a
(i
N)
H
0
N)
H
o
CD
Di
Di
Di
Di
hi
hi
Q
CD
C)
Di
C)
U)
ci
CD
ci
Ft
ct
CD
CD
Di
ci
X
CD
CD
0
H
Ft
I-
C)
ct
Q.
a
Q.
t3
ct
H
Di
hi
hi
Q.
C)
C)
CD
0
rt
ci
0
Ft
-<
CD
Ft
Z
H
o
Ft
hi
Ft
C)
C)
hi
CD
H-
H-
H-
H
Lxi
0
Di
CD
D
0
CD
çt
hi
CD
<
H
0
CD
Ct
CD
CD
3
Q.
CD
CD
Di
H-
hi
0
çt
-<
Ft
CD
0.
0
Ft
C)
CD
0
o
0
H-
çt
Ft
hi
H-
CD
Q
Ft
H
H-
0
hI
0
H
H
hi
H-
0
CD
H
CD
3
0
H
hi
H
H
Z
hi
hi
CD
3
0
Ft
Ft
hi
Ct
U)
CD
‘
C)
rt
CD
Di
Di
C)
ci
ct
CD
Di
CD
Ft
Di
H-
3
Q
H-
<
C)
Ft
Dl
Ft
CD
ct
‘-<
3
Ft
H-
0
0
Ft
I—h
0
C)
U)
0
H
H
H-
0
3
CD
CD
0
<
hi
0
X
7
Z
H
CD
Ft
0
ci
H
1
Ft
1
CD
CD
Q
Ct
‘.
çt
‘TJ
Ft
ci
0
Z
CD
hI
3
D
H-
hi
CD
Ft
hi
tJ
H
Lxi
Dl
hi
CD
Dl
t5
CD
i
Di
hi
Dl
CD
CD
CD
Dl
Ft
0
U)
U)
C)
CD
C)
CD
H
H-
ct
CD
<
Z
U)
Ft
CD
0
H
Di
CD
CD
Ft
Ft
H-
H-
H-
Cl
H-
ct
ci
-‘
3
C)
Dl
hi
U-
H-
0
h-h
0
0
W
0
CD
0
CD
H-
ci
C)
hi
-<
H-
ci
-h
Li
i
Q.
CD
Ft
Cl
Di
CD
Q
Di
CD
ct
CD
CD
U)
Li
CD
0
Cn
Cl
H
Q
Ft
3
C)
U)
Cl
H
hi
Di
‘•
hi
ci
H
0
D
CD
ç
0
0
Lxi
Li
H-
CD
CD
CD
‘-<
H-
CD
CD
0
hi
0
i
o
hi
H
Di
hi
C)
Di
C)
Q.
3
CD
c-h
CD
0
CD
H-
hi
0
CD
Ft
CD
‘
C)
hi
hi
H
h1-
H-
hi
hi
‘-<
hi
Ft
CD
Di
H-
3
Cl
0
CD
CD
U)
Di
H
H
Di
H
Ft
CD
LQ
CD
H
hi
0
rt
‘-<
3
Di
H-
Cl
0
-<
CD
Di
CD
CD
C)
H-
Di
Z
Q.
-<
Ft
<
‘•
H-
‘
hi
H-
0
Ft
0
o
o
H-
CD
Di
H-
Ft
3
CD
CD
Ft
hi
0
<
CD
Ft
CD
hi
‘
Di
Di
H
CD
C)
hi
Di
Q
ci
CD
H-
0
hi
CD
H-
hi
Ft
CD
CD
Cl)
Ft
Ft
Q.
h±
L<
hi
Li
Ft
0
Di
0
Ft
C)
CD
Cl
Li
hi
CD
Ft
3
Ft
hi
CD
CD
CD
H
fr3
ci
H-
CD
CD
CD
Di
Y
Di
C)
Ft
H
ci
Li
hi
CD
ci
Li
CD
H
CD
Li
0
CD
Di
H
LY
Ft
CD
H
Ft
hi
CD
3
H-
Li
Ft
H-
H
o
C)
Di
Cl
0
H-
Cl
CD
C)
C)
Ft
Ft
CD
Li
H-
Ft
hi
H
-<
CD
H-
Di
hi
CD
Q
C)
CD
H
Ft
0
CD
h-h
0
hi
H
H-
hi
CD
0
H-
CD
-<
H-
‘-<
CD
0
3
CD
Ft
Li
CD
M
Cl
CD
Ft
CD
CD
hi
‘-<
C)
CD
Ft
H-
CD
0
-
H-
H-
CD
CD
0
CD
Ft
hi
Li
Ft
Ft
Li
H-
Q
H-
Li
Di
3
Di
0
H-
0
Di
Di
CD
Li
H-
L.Q
Ft
h-h
CD
Li
CD
Ft
CD
Q.
3
CD
CD
CD
Li
CD
Di
Page
93
1
my hand and
affix my
seal
of office
at
Chicago,
2
Illinois,
this
23rd
day
of
February,
2009.
3
4
5
7
Cook
County,
8
Illinois.
9
My
commission
expires
7/22/2010.
10
11
C.S.R.
Certificate
No.
84-4327
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Page
94
A
addll:1455:12
39:1543:24
37:140:6
80:2
abifity
51:18
addition
31:23
50:4,7
53:19
47:10 48:1
APPEARAN...
ablel3:6
18:20
additionall2:13
54:1055:3
49:2086:17
2:13:1
19:13 23:16
26:832:2
56:13 62:24
ANAND2:5
appeared3:9
53:10 77:16
85:20,2491:6
65:5 68:15
Anchovy2l:22
appearing23:21
about 12:5 13:1
Additionally
83:12 91:8,14
Andes
3:8 7:18
appears 22:6
13:16
15:6,13
49:14
Agency
2:11
8:1,14,17
append 33:4
18:1
21:18
address 11:8
12:2,10
24:20
13:11,24
15:5
applications
24:626:12,13
15:23,2421:9
28:10,13 69:14
15:13 16:4,8
56:23
26:1631:20
88:18 89:4,5
74:2
17:17,2120:2
applylo:10
37:23 38:1,2,4
addressed6:10
Agency’s 11:24
20:16 21:11
56:19 68:20
40:14
43:12
6:17 7:17
12:7,23
22:8
26:9,10
approach
57:4
44:21 48:11
21:23
44:23
ago27:23
26:16 30:13
57:18
58:7
50:13,1851:4
46:11
78:22
agree22:1723:9
37:13 41:3
59:20,22
52:21
58:7
addresses2l:7
25:726:4
42:6,15,23
appropriate
62:1568:8
addressing
34:2241:10
43:545:2,23
26:21
27:13
73:4,775:24
11:22
45:23 54:4
50:1252:3
45:8,21
76:977:8,10
adequate4o:19
87:5,8
54:3,20
57:19
approved57:13
77:2478:24
47:2
ahead5:2 17:20
58:4,1159:23
April9l:6
87:15
88:17,18
adequately
59:2
60:13
61:5,11
aquatic 6:2,7,10
89:6,12
76:22
algae27:4
61:1862:1
12:917:24
above38:11
adjourning
aligned36:17
63:14,1966:7
25:10
28:2
above-entitled
90:19
ALISA2:4
69:14,19
70:8
31:11 39:1
1:1291:22
ADM1:9
allow7:6,15
71:673:10,18
44:1847:3,11
acconunodate
adopt2s:17
28:1,1478:3,9
74:1,978:6,10
47:2049:24
44:8
28:11,13
75:14
79:18
78:13,17
80:8
52:1
57:2,3,4,6
account28:22
adopted 10:6,11
allowance
80:7
80:13,24 81:11
57:9 58:3,14
accurately65:23
28:1
57:9 63:7 allowed6:6
82:8 83:15
58:16
66:23
achievel2:15
63:9
allowslO:779:1
85:3 87:12
75:577:20,22
24:22
Adrienne4:4
79:10
88:4,2089:8
77:24
78:15,20
achieved47:4
5:4,13
alone29:14
89:14,19,22
83:20,21,22
acknowledged
adult
21:24
39:5
along 10:23
90:2,6,23
85:22
10:13
12:1
AE33:10
40:13
54:1
ANDREA
2:8
arbitrary35:5
Act 42:20
43:12
aerate 23:16
already
18:18
another 51:3
area
1:6 10:8
Acting2:6
aerationl2:14
26:1,252:6
64:1977:7
13:815:3
action92:23
48:17
85:20,24 alterations
answer 11:20
17:12
19:3,7
activities 32:6
affect23:14,20
39:21
27:17 29:24
23:3,16
27:12
32:19
39:22
altered38:15,19
32:237:3
28:1251:13
actual29:3 43:4
affected
18:17
42:2 56:4
47:23
65:23
55:5 65:1,17
50:2360:1
28:17,1938:13
72:14
74:787:17
66:271:1,18
63:10
72:23
affecting
9:5
although
6:11
answered
52:3
72:3,9,14
77:24
77:5
32:1857:16
65:17
83:2385:23
actually 11:16
affects
27:2
ambient36:20
anticipation
areas
28:3
53:3
16:921:13
affix93:1
AMENDMEN...
44:5
53:4,1154:2,7
23:21
24:22
afraid67:17
1:8
Antidegradati...
73:7,8,13
36:23 37:2
70:19
anunonia26:21
69:8
Army38:18
59:661:6
after
12:18
60:462:9
anything
17:15
around24:8
acute 18:14
afternoon
5:1,19
analysis 8:18
30:3
82:24
arrive 47:15
adapteds9:12
83:991:4
23:10 25:6,11
88:11
90:9
49:17
again7:2336:6
27:1436:18
anywhere40:22
article20:7
Page
95
asked
43:15
44:1
45:3
50:3
62:11
81:24
asking3l:6
34:2
40:13
41:9
71:16
87:14
aspects
64:7
assemblage
23:19
assess
18:4
assessment
32:1
33:12,17,20
34:12 53:24
55:1965:11
assist3l:10
associated
7:5
17:8
assume
11:4
assuming
16:10
attached
31:13
Attachment
11:11,21
13:13
13:21 29:6
30:17
47:5
55:4
attain37:2
40:19
attainability
8:18
36:18
37:1
39:14
40:641:9
45:17
48:1,10
attainable
25:9
25:14
28:12
35:12
36:23
38:12
39:16,16
40:1,16,21,24
41
:4,15
42:9
42:10,13
45:22
48:4,5
attained
40:9
41:11
47:8,21
48:10,21
49:4
attaining
7:5
attainment
11:13
41:24
42:2
attempting
72:22
attorney
92:20
92:21
attribution
70:20
augmentation
12:14
48:18
August
14:12
available
14:4
22:7
23:4
38:13
90:24
Avenue
2:12
15:9
avoid
19:2,13,16
44:9
Avoidance
20:17
await
32:13
aware
6:5
17:10
56:3
78:2
80:1
awful
51:2
azide 84:21
85:7
a.m
1:15
B
B4:8
49:16,20
50:20,21
52:9
83:22
back5:2,9
21:11
28:10
30:6
38:8
70:11
90:18
backwaters
75:1
balance
27:7
balanced
39:1
barge56:9
64:10
BARNES
3:3’
barrier
64:20,23
base72:8
79:6
based
14:16
33:19
42:18
49:20
55:20
57:3,23
72:10
79:4
89:16
basically
64:15
basis
47:19
61:20
67:3
Bass 20:19
21:8
21:9,20
Bay
7:10
9:1,4,5
18:7
21:22
79:5
becoming
57:15
before
1:17
9:2
38:1
39:17
46:15
53:1
65:6 83:11
92:17
begin
31:7
37:5
behalf3:9
31:6
83:18
Behavioral
20:4
being
45:18
54:10
59:17
61:4
believe
5:20
6:4
8:14
11:15,15
11:17
27:24
29:7
31:12
36:13
41:7
44:22 55:8
58:6
64:1,6
67:15
70:2
73:20
78:6,18
below
44:19
75:1
78:4,12
beneficial
47:7
BERKERY
92:4
best
14:4
32:12
32:12
34:7
53:22
better
24:22
52:23
58:13
between
64:5,2
1
65:16
beyond
81:15
big
23:19
bigger
70:22
biologic
34:3,3
35:2,9
38:16
39:20
52:22
54:10 55:15
70:24
71:3,20
71
:22,24
75:21
biological
31:24
33:12,17,20
34:11
47:13
49:19,21,23
51:23,24
55:10
55:12
57:10
58:13
64:2
65:19,20
71:16
71:17
biologist
52:16
54:16,23
biologists
23:7
biology
20:8,2
1
41:17
biota
39:1
bit 32:21
35:19
76:8
blue
14:15
Board
1:1,18
2:7
2:8,9
5:22
31:10,19
49:10
49:15
53:1
68:24
69:1
75:14,16,24
88:2
bodies
3 8:24
50:15
body
53:8 55:8
57:24
59:8
64:1
both
31:13
37:7
57:9
64:8,9,10
64:10 90:21
bottom
38:22
Box
2:13
branch
14:9
49:12,22
break
70:6
brought
67:9
84:24
Bubbly
14:10
49:11
51:4,10
51:14
86:6
bugs
27:15
Building
1:13
buret
85:1
C
Cal
49:16
50:18
50:19
51:1
53:3
54:1
86:5
calculated
14:8
calibration
14:16
California
57:14
call 49:2
52:15
called
5:14
31:2
84:7
Calumet
51:23
came
70:20
canal
64:1
candid
35:23
capable
52:23
case
46:9
59:4
catch
88:23
Catfish
21:7
cause
1:12
19:6
74:3
91:23
CAWS
28:3
31:11
33:14,24
34:17
35:7,20
42:5
43:19
44:3,6,10,16
45:9 51:11
54:2
55:10,21
59:19
62:23
63:1
64:2,13
64:14,17,20
66:23
75:17
76:23
77:14,16
77:20
85:21
86:2,18
87:3
CDM77:8
Center2:19
27:19
certain
8:10
9:12 19:15
20:12
21:1
30:19
31:17
40:19
50:8
58:21
60:9
75:17
81:7
82:18
84:2
85:13
89:3
certainly
22:8
58:2
61:11,18
72:8
82:13
88:5
89:21
Certificate
93:11
Certified
92:6
certify
92:7
CFOs
14:6
Chairman
2:6
challenges
7:4
change23:19
35:18
Page
96
changes
44:14
74:12
59:21
64:7
54:11
36:21
46:19
Class
50:20,21
comparables
concur
46:3
constitutes
channel9:19
classification
55:19
54:11
92:15
21:7
49:16
49:11
53:19
compare52:8
condition40:20
contact
12:8
51:23
53:3
80:18,20
65:7,22
55:10,12
71:24
contend
48:6
86:5
classifications
comparison
80:7
56:17
62:12
channelization
5 1:16
64:5
65:2,3,5
conditioning
74:2
56:5
Clean
42:20
compendium
57:10
content 26:14
channelized
43:12
32:13
56:2
conditions
14:13 contention
43:1
73:2
clearl3:21
complete36:10
14:17 17:12
50:755:17
channels8:19
43:23
61:23 63:12
19:228:23
contents6l:2
38:1939:4
CODE1:9
completed6:6
35:938:15
contested74:5
50:22 64:9
collected
48:13
11:19
12:2,4
39:23
42:3
context 51:11
characteristics
84:23
12:11,1837:4
45:8 46:20
77:2
38:23
50:19
collection
32:10
86:20
87:22,24
51:5,9
52:22
continue
28:18
59:10
39:1771:2
complex2s:12
53:1759:13,15
90:2091:15
characterizatL..
Colony
20:6
complexities
64:12,24
71:3
continued
90:22
50:20
53:10,15
Colorado
59:4
76:10
71:20,22
74:22
continuing
13:3
characterize
60:21 63:8,16
compliance
75:7,21,22
continuous
52:971:23
63:20
12:1586:9,11
76:1,5,11,11
29:1686:10
72:12 87:13
colunm44:17
86:13
77:578:4,21
contradictory
characterized
72:9,16,19
complicated
78:22,23
49:6
62:15
combination
25:3 46:13
conducive
38:24
contrast
68:19
chart 14:3
15:20
55:21
56:11
complicating
conduct
50:4
contrived56:6
72:2,3,4,7,12
combined
12:9
46:10
conducted
18:9
control 1:1,18
chemical36:21
46:17
57:11
components
18:18
11:5,8 14:6
47:1449:19
come5:963:3
15:7
conducting23:1
29:2249:10
84:17
comes86:24
composed66:22
32:17
81:20
chemically
coming
19:5
68:2
1
conference
91:3
controlled
44:7
84:23
30:5
64:16
comprehensive
Connecticut
cont’d
3:1
Chesapeake
commencement
33:21 34:9
57:14
conventional
7:10,22
9:1,4,5
92:8
53:9,15,16,23
connectivity
57:18
18:779:4
couunents46:4
65:8,21
64:21
Cook92:3,5
Chicago
1:6,13
commission
compromise
conservative
93:7
1:21
2:21 3:6
93:9
91:10
16:9
coordinated
13:8
14:9 15:3
common
40:5
concede
55:15
consider
26:15
32:21
17:12
19:3
52:18
concentration
34:5,8
45:19
copied6l:7
23:3,1627:11
communities
84:18
46:21
75:16
copies7:19
28:11
49:12,22
66:21
68:21
concentrations
considerable
13:12
80:13
55:564:21,24
75:5
14:11 20:5
31:20
85:3
65:16 71:1,18
community
75:3
consideration
copy2l:11
72:3,9,14
48:19
concept57:3
45:11 76:6
30:13
83:23
85:23
Comp 33:10
concern
47:6
considerations
Corp
38:18
90:22
93:1
company
32:17
concerning
39:18
76:6
correct
5:23,24
chronicl8:16
32:24
60:1483:19
considered
6:8 12:24
citation63:8,10
comparability
92:10
33:14,2434:2
13:23 15:11,12
63:13
68:5,10
65:6
conclude47:19
34:242:13
16:13,22,23
69:10
comparable
conclusion
considering
17:9
24:3
clarifyl5:629:8
55:656:12,16
47:1551:17
46:21
25:10,17,18
42:7 74:2,10
56:24
59:20,20
conclusions
49:8
constituents
33:2 40:17
Page 97
41:12,1342:11
77:19
48:950:5
19:2232:14
direction92:14
42:2254:17
currently34:12
51:15
41:1256:21
directly38:8
69:19
71:12
cuts 82:6
demonstration
72:7
63:15 92:22
correctly 24:13
Cuyahoga 63:24
47:3 48:3
developed 23:11 directs 40:23
counsel 92:20,21
64:14,22,23
Dennison
4:6
56:15 59:14
disagree 25:19
County 92:3,5
65:16
17:11 83:8,9
62:21
70:24
80:3,5
93:7
C.S.R93:11
84:6,12
88:12
71:15
discharge89:23
Creek 14:10
90:10,11
developing
discharges
49:1151:4,10
D
Dennison’s51:7
36:1557:22
11:1213:6
51:14
86:6
D4:1
83:17
development
16:1,17,22
criteria7:15
8:3
daily34:16
Denver60:21
32:4 34:10
28:18,19,23
9:19 10:11,12
dams42:3
depending
39:7
77:14,15
89:20
10:14,19 11:7
dash 16:14
79:12
Dexter2:23
discuss2l:17
12:1,2213:7
dashedl4:17
deposition46:19
27:18,18,20
91:5
16:18 19:23
data 17:2 29:14
DES 1:7
28:7 30:2
discussed44:21
23:1025:17,20
29:14,2431:18
describe53:12
37:1743:6
64:1875:19
26:2228:11,21
33:14,21,24
84:14
54:1563:6,17
86:2
35:11 36:24
48:13
51:14
described 22:21
65:14,24
76:16 discusses 12:6,7
37:239:13,24
54:13
38:17 39:10
76:17
78:8,11
discussing82:9
40:9,24 41:12
DATE91:23
44:21
50:24
78:24 79:6,22
discussion39:10
41:2242:9
dayl:1493:2
describes38:18
80:1282:22
51:865:666:4
43:345:16,18
days 17:490:24
describing72:16
88:13,1589:1
90:16
48:12,16 56:22
day-to-day
description
89:10 90:7
dissolved
7:6
59:14,2162:20
32:19
52:1272:10,11
diel8:14
9:2410:18
62:22 63:1,4
death 19:19
descriptions
Diel6O:17
11:13,18
12:4
67:2,11,14,16
DEBORAH
50:23
DIERS2:17
12:12,1513:7
75:11 77:9,10
2:16
designate49:15
31:5 43:16
14:7,11 17:2
79:7,11
December87:16
designated8:3
45:3,1246:5
18:21 19:2,6
criterion7:10
decide66:23
58:14 82:10
51:20 54:22
20:5 22:13
7:11 11:237:8
decided42:16
83:21
63:22 83:2
23:1024:3,10
41:4 42:18
decrease 44:19
designation
66:5
84:11 85:17
24:18,20 25:21
critical64:5
deem43:18
designations
87:14,23
88:7
29:1
32:3,22
cross-examine
deep5o:22
49:18
88:9
35:17,19 36:15
61:15
52:12,13,17
designedl4:24
differ65:17,18
38:6,21
44:19
cruxl7:6
56:5
15:2339:15
differences
60:3,1774:21
CSO11:1213:5
Deer39:8
66:21 68:20
38:11
75:3,10,20
14:20,21 15:8
deficiencies
desfred27:8
different
18:20
78:3,11
79:1
15:11,1516:12
31:15,2136:4
detailed46:15
19:123:22
83:1985:1
16:17 19:5
deficient56:21
detectl9:1
25:13 32:6
86:11,1687:4
44:11 77:21
defme35:937:7
determine22:18
41:16 42:1,14
87:11
79:20 89:23
41:15 58:14
22:19,22
23:5
63:4 70:24
distinction
CSOs14:19
69:2371:8
24:1,2,1425:8
71:2,3,16,19
64:20
15:7,21,22
defmed57:5
27:12 39:15
71:20 75:8,8
district3:10
16:6,21 17:8
69J2,12
41:10 49:21
75:20
11:15 23:1
29:21 56:9
defmes
55:11
determined
differs 49:12
29:3,9,17,19
77:19 88:19
defining5o:18
25:16,23
26:1
64:2
32:21 33:8
89:4
52:10 69:20
determining
difficult 53:18
60:21 75:23
CTE33:10
defmition35:11
24:625:20
61:191:13
76:481:24
currentl4:16
70:1
40:1684:17
digital85:1
83:1988:1,6
17:11 53:6
demonstrate
develop 17:23
direct 32:24
89:7
Page
98
district’s 11:23
drop
19:6
92:19,20
even 10:14
13:22 20:10,11
14:3,22
16:3
Drs86:2
emptying
56:6
16:16 17:4
20:13,22,23
18:319:11
dry44:18
end9:17
48:1851:7,10
21:2,7,16,21
91:2
due 12:9 43:19
engineer
52:17
event44:5
29:7,8
30:17
divert
15:1
duly 5:15 30:11
engineering
events 7:8,17
30:18,20
58:18
Division8l:19
31:284:8
31:18 33:7
13:5 14:12,24
58:20,2260:7
document8:1
92:10
Engineers38:18
16:1628:4
60:8,10,19
8:10,18,22
9:6
duration
18:12
enormous
15:9
79:20
61:22
62:2
9:12 20:12
during7:5,7
44:11
ever80:2
81:6,8,12,21
21:1
22:4,7,9
28:329:3,18
enough35:10
everyl5:14
81:24 82:16,19
30:19
39:3
54:5
86:12
36:2
65:13
16:11
83:24 84:1,3
58:12,18,21
dynamics44:4
ensure27:4
everyone5:2
85:11,12,14
60:1,9 61:3,16
D.L 20:8
enter
8:7
20:10
evidence
48:13
exist 64:22
61:24 62:6
58:10 81:5,18
49:4,5 50:10
existance 46:16
67:16
80:16
E
82:17 83:17,23
52:20
existed55:24
81:782:18
E1:172:94:1,8
85:9
exact67:1069:9
existing4l:19
84:2 85:13
earlier
45:24
entered
62:6,9
exactly 29:11
exists
64:14
documentation
64:19
82:16
68:9
expect73:3,6,9
50:24 63:13
early 48:11,13
entering
82:16
examination
expected
85:24
documents
East 2:12,20
entire
22:4,6,9
5:17 31:4
experience
59:2370:12
easy3s:4
23:1655:7
84:10,2085:5
17:1355:20
doing 18:1
42:24
ecological
39:3
entitled 58:12
85:10 92:9
72:10
53:7
75:4
60:2
examined5:15
expert54:10,21
dominated
56:9
economic
32:7
environmental
31:3 84:8
experts 35:1
64:15
edition85:6
2:4,5,11,19
examplelo:10
52:21,23
72:11
done6:918:6
effectl4:18
17:1927:19
14:723:15
expires93:9
23:925:758:3
76:24
32:7
24:1938:17
explainlo:17,19
61:12
65:21
effective39:6
envision45:13
48:11 50:17
13:18 34:18
78:20,21
86:16
effectively43:3
EPA31:7,16
51:3
52:7
50:13
72:6
downstream
effects
38:20
32:13
47:2,7
57:21 58:2
exposed
18:13
19:8
39:443:19
47:11,2049:13
62:13 77:3,7
19:18
Dr 17:11 26:11
4519 76:21
49:24
58:12
78:18 86:22
express
12:17
26:12
31:20,23
77:24
67:16
68:9
exampless7:7
77:23
32:9 37:24
effluent 1:5 56:8
EPA’s 10:12
62:12
78:6
expressed
34:24
38:1 44:22
64:15
49:15 52:1
exceeded
7:11
85:2
51:6,7,7
54:5
efforts
49:6
establish 49:10
excerpt
8:1 38:6
extent 43:10
54:13,16,21
eggs39:5
established4l:7
43:24
60:13
90:4
64:1875:18
eitherl9:19
79:4
81:14,2185:6
extra2l:12
76:9 77:4 83:8
48:9
56:20,21
establishing
excitement
8:7
extreme
44:14
83:9,17
84:12
elements64:13
31:11
excuse33:6
87:6,9,988:5
eliminate 14:18
establishment
63:1668:3
F
88:12,17
89:3
15:14 16:5,17
38:24
excused30:8
fact 19:12
28:22
89:11 90:10,11
16:21 29:21
evaluate 23:4,13
83:6 90:13
49:6
75:17
draft
50:22 58:7
89:16,22
29:13 45:20
exemption
5:23
factor
55:24,24
58:12,17
eliminated
55:19
exhibit
4:10,11
factors
24:18
drafting57:12
16:11
evaluated43:3
4:12,13,14,15
39:21 42:1
dramatic44:13
elimination
evaluating
14:5
4:16,17,18,19
46:10,14,21
64:17
11:12
28:20
4:205:67:21
55:2277:4,6
draw 37:2 1
embodied 76:7
Evaluation
8:8,9,11,23
86:18
Drive2:203:4
employee89:6
86:22
9:11,13
10:1
failed35:9
51:18
Page
99
56:17,23
67:20
fairly59:18
fall
7:7
44:14
52:19
78:4,12
familiar
16:2
feasible
41:24
February 1:14
91:4 93:2
federal
8:19
feel23:7
55:18
56:14,16,20
65:9,12
feeling
36:1
49:5
felt
32:11
48:2
few
27:23
field
18:11
32:6
57:16
84:23
figure
13:12,21
14:2
Figures
29:5
file
61:11
fill
14:23
filling
56:7
Final
60:15
fmd40:3 69:4
fme
77:18
87:17
87:18
fmish
91:1
firm33:7,9
first
18:2
20:3
22:18
24:1
25:7,11,13
27:22
31:2
40:16
47:9
49:7
55:2
66:6
80:16
81:15
fish 17:7,14
18:4
18:15
19:1,12
20:4,17,21
22:15,19 23:2
23:6,14,19,21
24:1,6,10,14
24:22
25:9
26:12,14,14
27:15
28:14,14
33:13,23
39:5
39:5,7,8 48:19
60:16
62:22
85:21
86:1
fit
51:15
five
78:2
91:1
fixed
84:23
flags
49:2
flipping
24:8
flooding
44:9
flow
12:14
15:10
37:23
38:1,19
41:18
42:3
44:4,14,15
46:16,19
48:1
56:4,5,7,8
64:15
flowing
72:13
flows
15:3
44:12
fluctuations
38:3
44:15
60:17
focal
77:11
focused
36:3
follow
17:22
40:11
42:6
50:12
54:3
57:19
66:2
73:10
79:21
following
81:12
follows
5:16
31:3
38:9
84:9
follow-up
26:9
88:13
follow-ups
17:20
food
27:8,11,14
foolish
40:7
foregoing
92:12
foreseeable
47:8
fork
49:12,22
forth
45:24
found
51:12
74:17
foundation
37:5
46:9
frame
70:19
FREDRIC
3:8
Freedman
4:5
30:10
31:1
40:11
59:1
61:18
66:3
73:17
74:14
83:1,3
87:6,9
Freedman’s
30:16
frequency
18:12
90:3
fresh
10:12
from
8:2
9:1,20
14:23
16:21,24
18:13,15
19:5
19:9
20:8,20
28:2,14
3 1:18
37:21
38:7
43:24
44:8
48:7,7
49:13
58:7,12
60:13
64:2,16
67:8
67:13,15
68:3
69:15
70:20
77:7,8
80:16
80:23
81:12
85:4
89:5,20
front
22:5
41:2
full6l:12
66:6
functions
75:4
further
5:16
30:3
66:18,20
76:23
82:22
84:9
88:10,11
furthermore
51:12
future
47:8
G
G2:6
84:6
gaining23:2
Garcia
32:9
38:1
51:7
64:18
75:18
76:977:4
general
26:24
34:16
35:6
63:5
66:5,20
67:4,11,14
68:19
69:12,21
69:23
70:2,23
71:15,20
72:2
72:13,19
73:2
73:4,13
74:3
74:20,23
75:10
generalization
53:7
geometry
64:9
getting
15:20
43:7
71:14
GIRARD
2:6
gist22:12
give
43:11
67:10
given
59:17,18
84:19
92:15
gives
68:9
giving43:9,10
77:16
go
5:2,2
10:1
17:20
18:1
24:6
35:16
59:2
63:2
70:11
76:15
90:14
goal
10:24
Gobies
21:24
Goby
21:22
goes
28:10
80:23
going
5:9,11
15:1,24
17:18
19:16
28:11,23
29:15
31:7
35:16,18
55:11
61:21
65:4,7
66:5,15
68:23
76:18
81:5
84:12
88:1
89:22
90:19
91:7
good
5:1,19
55:13
83:9
90:8
gradient
22:13
57:10
gradients
22:15
grafts
52:12
Grand
2:12
gravity
11:12
14:19,20
15:3
15:6,21,22
16:6,21
29:21
89:4,13
Grenado
88:5
growing
57:17
growth
18:16
19:20
27:6
39:7
guess
15:19
25:5
34:19
37:19
40:4 41:1
45:15
48:1
50:2
54:18
56:13
58:1
60:24
64:4
71:8
76:3
90:7
guidance
40:4
40:23
41:2
42:1
58:8
H
H 4:8
habitat
18:3
23:1,4,5,8
25:8
31:24
32:18,24
33:11,13,17,20
33:22
34:2,11
36:10,19
37:4
37:23,2439:20
41:17
46:6,11
48:21,22
52:22
53:6,16,24
54:13,18
85:22
86:4,22
habitats
44:18
Halsted
14:9
hand
93:1
happen
15:21
16:10
29:11,20
29:22
happening
46:17
happily
8:6
harming
77:19
hate
53:20
having5:14,15
31:2
38:19
51:1
73:7
84:7
84:8
HEARD
91:22
hearing
1:17
2:3
90:19,20
91:18
92:12,17
hearings
90:2
1
91:6
held
1:11
help
6:15
13:11
46:7
89:14
helps
38:7
7
Page
100
hence 36:24
55:18 56:14,21
inconsistent
intermediate
40:12,13
41:9
herl3:2246:3
58:765:3
42:22
66:24
42:743:6,13
hereto
92:22
68:12
76:7,22
increase
85:20
intermediately
50:16 52:3,7
hereunto92:24
IEPA’s49:3
86:1
52:11
53:11 61:1,5
high24:10
38:5
52:14
independent
interpret47:15
63:1,17
65:15
higher 19:9
ILL
1:8
47:24
50:4
interpretation
66:16
69:6
41:20 42:18
Iffinois
1:1,14
indicate
9:18
49:20
74:2,3,9
80:5
64:13
1:18,21
2:11
53:2
introduce80:15
81:22
88:7
highest
25:14
2:14,21
3:6
indicates 10:21
introduced
89:4,13
90:15
45:22
31:7 47:2,6,11
10:2411:11
52:21
justification
highlighted
47:20
49:9,13
12:10
introduction
36:2,450:9
31:1538:11
49:15,2452:1
indicating54:5
61:262:3
51:19
highlights
38:8
55:7
66:5
indication
12:20 investigation
justified
35:14
highly
12:11
68:20 69:13,15
12:21
49:17
justify36:1
him45:3
70:1 71:21,23
indigenous
12:8
involve25:20
hold 61:21,23
72:23
73:1
28:2
involved
32:16
K
hope
68:23
92:1,5
93:2,8
indirectly
92:22
32:17,19
33:6
lull 18:15
hours
22:1
ifiustrating
63:1
individual
14:24
46:7
kiflflig
17:7
hugel6:21
impact28:23
15:11,15
55:23
involvement
kills 17:14
28:14
hundredl5:10
37:1438:12,15
59:6
32:24
kind4O:742:3
15:15
16:12
impacted44:4
industrial73:5
involves39:17
52:8
57:15,17
hydraulic
32:8
impacts
12:9
Influence 20:17
involving
85:7
59:17
63:2
44:4 64:18
32:7 37:10
information
9:7
isolated
74:23
65:10,10,11
hydraulics
56:6
39:9
43:19
18:19
19:22
issue6:11
50:14
kinds42:475:8
76:10
44:2077:22
23:231:17
57:1877:12
76:5
hydrologic
implement
32:14 34:6,8
78:5,7
know
11:20
38:2344:3
12:13
34:1336:7
issuedl0:22
21:1825:6
hypothetical
implemented
47:14
48:8
issues
52:24
33:12,22
50:2 1
11:2214:17
11:6
49:1950:11
91:10
51:252:17,17
16:8,20 24:19
implication
32:5
52:15
58:6,13
i.e49:11
53:8,14 54:10
Hypoxia
20:18
implying
69:22
67:19,23
78:5
56:10
57:4
important
26:13
initially
69:9
J
69:8
70:5
I
26:1464:19
inputs44:11
Jamesl:12
71:12,17,18
1D4:9
87:1
insight88:19
Jersey57:14
73:1
77:13
identification
improper
42:19
instance 50:17
Jessica
2:23
78:15
88:3
8:12 9:14
improved53:6
64:14
27:18
89:6
20:14 21:3
improvements
instances
10:11
job 65:13
knowledge
86:3
30:21 58:23
48:19,21,22
86:15
jogs 67:22
known
33:10
60:11
81:9
include
7:16
Instead 90:19
JOhNSON
2:9
82:20 84:4
28:2
78:23
insufficient
34:7
6:22
L
85:15
82:12
integrated
32:4
Journal
20:21
L31:1
identified
8:22
included
6:12
33:5
July
14:12
laboratory
18:9
10:18
59:11
21:19 31:24
intending4l:3
June9:2091:6
84:24
86:14
81:15
interceptorl5:2
just6:167:20
lack56:7
identify 18:11
includes
27:14
interceptors
822
9:1
11:14
lacked
31:17
70:20
41:17,17,17,18
14:23
14:10
15:22
Lake64:16,22
IEPA5:1235:8
including39:4
interest32:12
17:18
22:21
lakes75:2
35:24 45:19
42:2
74:24
32:12
34:8
23:15
24:20
language69:4
48:3,8
50:8,24
76:22
53:22
32:8 33:18
69:15,23
70:3
51:14,1853:5
inclusive9:21
interested92:22
35:4,1840:2
70:7
Page
101
large 20:18
21:8
21:9,20 32:13
44:8
53:7
larger
71:11
larvae 20:4
21:23 39:5,8
last
11:14 17:4
43:21
47:1
88:23
91:1
later 61:10
law 2:19 17:19
27:19
laying
91:19
lead38:21
least 12:10
83:11
leaving
62:4
left-hand
72:12
legal 43:7,10,11
length
53:1 54:1
less
18:21 22:2
49:23
51:24
67:1
79:7
let 29:8
70:6
71:12 73:24
89:14
let’s 5:2
11:10
13:20
16:10
23:15 90:14
level2S:21
27:4
27:5
38:2 44:6
55:9
levels 7:7
17:13
18:21 25:13
27:7,13
28:2
41:20 44:14
55:11
life
6:2,7,10
12:9
18:1
25:10
28:2
31:11
47:3,11,20
48:11,13
49:24
52:1
57:3,4,4
58:14,16
66:23
77:20,22,24
78:16,20 83:21
83:21,22
light89:7
like
15:8
19:3
38:1040:11
43:6
59:3
62:16
66:2
69:3
74:3
79:6
81:22 91:7
likely 12:11
limitations
1:5
39:7
85:23
86:4
limited
35:2
38:19 42:17,19
50:10 54:6
74:24
77:2
Limno-tech
33:2
33:3
Lin2:7
26:11,12
26:18
36:20
line 14:15,17
16:14 40:13
52:19 74:5
link7:21
list 22:19
57:23
listed3l:22
liter 7:12 9:20
17:3 18:22
22:1
23:17
78:4,12
85:2
literature
38:14
liters
7:13
little 32:2
1
35:19
64:15
LIU2:4
live
24:2,6,11
25:9
living28:3,15
LLP3:3
load
19:4 44:13
loads
13:8 29:23
46:17
located
8:19
locations
14:21
74:20
Lockport
44:7
long 42:12
long-term
11:5,8
look
22:24 24:11
26:21
27:10
36:19,22
39:19
39:20,24
40:23
41:15,19,23
56:1,17,23
61:16
65:10
67:21
69:3
73:21 91:7
looked 59:6,8,9
looking
22:20
33:17
40:6
53:16
70:12
74:1,15
looks 32:5
loss
37:23,24
lot 15:10
24:17
24:17
32:1
34:13 51:4
64:10,11
low
17:3,13
18:12,21
19:2
19:8,13,16,19
20:5
22:14
38:5,21
62:20
86:15
lower 1:7
10:11
10:14 62:23
75:20
86:13
lowered
44:6
lowering
46:16
lowest 86:10
M
Mackey
31:20
31:23 37:24
54:13,16,21
86:2
87:6,9
made
24:9
55:18
70:18
75:22
77:21
magnitude
18:12
main 15:7
Maine
57:9 58:2
58:7
79:16
80:2,14,17,18
80:20 81:2
maintain
74:2
1
maintained
75:2
major 44:5
53:5
53:21
make
9:2 22:7
53:18
65:3,4
65:11
70:23
88:1
making
5:21
74:8
Makke’s
54:5
management
44:5 45:9
manmade
3
8:23
39:4
56:4
manually
84:24
many 39:2
46:10
64:6,24
86:17
March
90:2 1
91:2
MARIA
1:17
MARIE
2:3
Marine
20:8
mark 8:22
9:10
20:22 30:16
58:17 60:6,19
61:22
80:20
marked
4:9
6:15
8:11
9:13
20:13
21:2
30:20
58:22
60:10
81:8
82:19 84:3
85:14
Maryland
8:2
10:11
78:18
Maryland’s
9:18
Massachusetts
79:17 80:14
81:13,19,20
match
35:10
matched
43:4
45:21
material
19:5
48:7
matter 1:2
52:24
matters 91:21
92:11
may6:12
11:12
12:2,4,13
13:6
18:17
19:12
23:7
25:12,12
52:16
55:14
79:14 80:24
91:6
maybe62:5
69:9
mean
14:20
23:24
24:21
34:20,21
37:13
52:16
60:23,24
meaning
18:14
measure
29:14
measured
29:15
measurements
29:3 47:24
50:5
meet
11:1 13:7
meeting
77:9
Melching
51:6
86:3
87:6,9
Melching’s
44:22
Member
2:7,8,9
Memorandum
60:16
memory
6
7:22
MEMURA
4:4
mentioned
76:21 77:1,3
84:15
86:4
met 10:15
11:19
12:2,4,20,22
48:16
79:13
method
84:14
84:16,19,20
85:4,4,7
methodology
22:20
methods
84:19
85:9
Metro
60:20
Metropolitan
3:9
Michigan
64:16
64:22
microinverteb...
33:13,23
middle
67:5
might
39:22
41:21 42:1
46:17 48:20
53:11
54:6
55:16
56:19
63:3
67:15
73:9
75:20
76:4
89:19
90:2
miles
53:8,8
Page
102
milligram
7:12
18:22 78:4,12
milligrams
7:13
9:20
17:3
22:1
23:17
85:2
mind 59:21
78:22
86:24
minima
34:17
minimum
34:17
60:3
62:8
Minnesota
57:14
minute
13:20
minutes
27:23
mistake
70:18
mistakenly
69:10,11
mixed
43:8
mixing 38:20
ml 84:22
model
11:23
14:4,8,14,16
14:22
29:9,12
29:19,20
modeled 29:4
modeling
15:20
32:3,8,22
modification
84:21
85:7
modifications
42:4
modified
7:3
64:9
moment
61:5
monitoring
32:3
86:10
monitors
29:16
MOORE 2:8
more
25:3
33:21
34:9
36:7
50:13
53:9
63:5,12 65:1,8
77:6
86:15
87:20
89:4,6
89:12
91:12
morning
32:9
38:2,4
64:19
75:19
76:9
88:16 89:2,12
mortality
39:5
most23:11
24:16
25:22
68:20
86:24
Mouth 20:19
21:8,9,20
move
19:8
moves
83:7
moving
19:17
much
30:5 65:1
83:2 90:11
91:12
multiple
36:16
must 41:11
74:21 75:2
MWRDGC
12:13
myself
71:13
N
N 4:1
Naked 21:22,24
native 59:7
62:22
natural
72:17
75:4
naturally
72:13
75:19
nature
13:9
59:19
64:4
navigation
8:19
9:19
38:19
39:442:4
navigational
64:8
necessarily
24:21
41:19
necessary
12:13
25:21
51:19
55:18
need
23:11,13
24:2,3
26:21
28:20
35:3
36:7,19,22
41:23 42:9
53:9
76:5 77:6
77:9
needed
34:13
45:1,4
needs
27:8 39:12
45:10
76:23
negative
39:3
Nemura
5:4,13
5:19
15:19
17:21 20:3
21:622:17
30:4
40:13
46:1 78:19
79:3,9,24
88:17
89:3,11
Nemurats
5:5
13:22
41:8
new 32:13
50:8
57:14
nitrate
26:13,17
26:18
27:1
nitrogen
26:17
26:18,22
none 8:8 20:10
20:23 30:18
58:20
60:8
82:17
84:1
85:12
nonnatural
56:6
North
2:12 3:4
Notary 92:4
93:7
note
5:7 7:20
43:6,13,15
noted
43:14
nothing
72:24
88:10
notice
62:17,19
noting
81:4
number 4:9
6:22
24:21 31:22
32:6
35:5 36:5
36:7
49:1,2
57:12
86:23
90:3
numbers
91:19
numerical
45:16
numerically
63:20
numerous
31:15
34:24
nutrient
27:1,7
27:13
nutrients
27:1
0
oath 5:8
83:12
object
60:24
objection
8:6,21
9:9
12:12
20:9
20:22
30:16
58:19
60:6,18
74:8
80:19,22
81:6,17
82:15
83:16,24
85:8
observed
17:14
obtain
18:2
obtained
47:12
Obviously
70:18
occur
13:3
occurring
86:12
off 61:21,23
82:6 90:14,17
90:23
offensive
74:22
offered
61:4
office
93:1
officer
1:17 2:3
91:18
oh 13:17
33:4
Ohio 57:8
63:15
64:1
okay
6:13,18
26:20
30:1
33:19 34:14
63:11 65:24
68:24
69:2
70:7,8
80:12
90:6
old 15:7
once
22:17 23:9
25:16
36:10
37:4 41
:8,10
42:8 87:24
one
3:4 7:12
15:14
16:11
20:4
27:22
36:14,17
39:12
46:7
48:12,23
50:18
52:7,8
52:10 56:3
59:24 62:6
63:2,3 66:2
67:18
72:2
78:4,12
79:7
86:24
88:13
ones
3
1:23
one-page
61:2
ongoing3l:19
32:4
36:9
86:20
online
63:16
only 19:15
27:21
32:23 36:19
39:19
53:16
65:277:1
81:2
open 64:23
operates
29:17
operating
29:17
opinion
12:17
13:1,2,6
3 1:16
34:6
35:8,13
35:15
41:14
43:11
45:7
76:5
77:17,24
85:19
opinions 43:7,8
43:10
order 12:15
36:6
41:14
91:19
organisms
52:11
57:6
other 6:6
23:7
23:20 24:17
25:1 29:23
35:1
36:21
39:2
44:23
46:10
48:15
52:12,20,21,23
53:23
55:6,8
56:1,16,18,23
57:12
62:12
63:4 72:4,11
86:14
others
37:22
77:4
86:23
otherwise
50:11
ought
65:8
out
13:12
15:1,3
19:5
35:5
36:21
56:18
62:16
65:2
91:19
outcome
92:23
outfalls
14:21
15:11,16
16:12
Page
103
outlined 31:12
81:1 82:13
phone 91:5,19
position
36:11
prevention
39:6
31:14 48:22
86:8
physical 38:22
possibility
55:16 previous 50:3
outlines
42:1
para27:6
47:13 49:19
possible
24:10
92:8
over 14:11,21
paragraph
7:2
Ph.D
52:16
56:23
69:11
previously
5:5
70:12 81:5
17:1 43:21
pick24:20
possibly4o:20
5:14 84:7
overbank44:9
47:449:8 55:4
piece
36:14
47:21
70:3
priinarily73:5
overflow 12:9
66:6,17
pieces
36:17
potential 22:19
problem 26:15
overflows
44:8
part
7:9 22:24
37:7
35:3 38:16
problems
13:3
46:18 82:11
27:14
39:23
pipes 15:1
39:22
49:21,23
19:20
90:3
45:11
68:12
place92:18
51:23,24
55:9
procedure 57:17
overlaying
88:23
places 34:24
55:12,15,19
84:17
29:24
partial
37:3
PLAINES
1:7
64:3 65:19,21
procedures 82:5
own 52:14
particular
10:8
plan 11:6,9
71:1,4,6,16,17
proceedings
oxygen
7:7
9:24
10:22
33:3
48:23 91:1
potentially
1:11 92:16
10:18 11:13,18
57:5,11 81:2
plant27:6
18:10
process25:19
12:5,16
13:7
81:14
platoral44:18
Powerhouse
39:23
50:14
14:8,11
17:2
particularly
Platte59:5,10
44:8
63:2
70:12
18:21 19:2,6
57:23 89:8,10
59:15,2460:2
practice57:16
produced 14:3
20:5,18 22:13
parties92:21
60:7,1562:7
80:2
productivity
23:10 24:3,10
parts
76:20
please
34:18
precedes 68:15
27:2
24:18,21
25:21
pass
13:12
44:2 79:22
predict66:23
program
16:3
29:1 32:3,22
passage 10:20
84:14
predominantly
18:7
35:17,19
36:16
Patapsco 8:20
plots 29:5
66:21 68:21
programs 48:17
38:6,21
44:19
9:8,1778:17
plucking35:5
prefiledl3:22
promulgated
60:4,17
74:21
79:5
pockets
19:13
28:5,8
29:2,6
57:17
75:3,10,20
patience9l:9
19:16,19
30:17 31:8
propagation
78:3,1179:1
PAUL4:531:1
point5:11 12:3
34:14,1637:11
23:6
83:1984:17
people22:9
40:2259:3
43:1746:23,24
proper53:18
85:1
86:11,16
per7:12,13
9:20
62:16
66:10
47:549:855:3 properly42:16
87:4,11
17:3 18:22
67:3
70:22
55:476:18
proposal9:18
oxygen-dema...
22:123:17
71:11,1477:11
83:14,1784:13
31:1746:7
19:4
77:2278:4,12
79:891:5
84:1586:8
49:1375:24
85:2
pointed36:20
prehearing9l:3
76:7 86:13
percent
10:7,8
56:18
65:2
premarked6:15
propose
35:18
P3:8
16:5 79:10
points 89:23
premature
35:20,22,24
page4:37:2
performed
policiesl7:19
34:2435:15
36:5,1140:8
10:1
12:617:1
47:10,2449:17
Policy2:19
prepared6o:20
76:4
33:2037:11
periodlo:9,22
27:19
75:23
proposedl:8
43:21,22 47:1
18:23
pollutant44:13
present22:14
11:2,17 12:1
47:449:755:2
periods6:11
pollutionl:1,18
23:327:842:5
12:11 13:7
55:463:14
7:1629:18
49:1066:22
57:2461:10
18:539:24
66:6,7 67:10
peripheral
68:22
81:20
69:24
75:24
45:1647:3,7
67:21 68:1,2
77:12
population
presented 67:24
47:11,13,20,22
72:1 74:15,17
personal
86:3
24:22
25:10
presenting
25:6
49:15,24
52:1
80:23,23 81:15
92:14
39:1 85:21
presents
16:24
62:23
66:23
82:1,3,14
perspective
86:1
presumably
83:20
86:11
84:15
18:16
portion 76:23
67:1
proposing 48:20
pages
31:14
phenomenon
77:20 82:9
pretty 90:7
50:8 62:24
37:19,2058:11
21:17
portions8:20
prevent28:14
76:22
61:7,1266:4
Phiten27:6
81:3
42:2 74:21
prospective
Page 104
18:14
33:5,14,23
R
record
5:3 7:21
relative 92:19
protectl8:6
35:436:23
R1:12
38:11
68:11
92:20
20:1 23:11,12
38:13,15 39:23
Racine
15:9
69:7
70:11
release44:7
24:3,15
25:17
40:20 41:18,20
rain44:5
81:23 90:14,17
relevant 14:2
25:2141:13
41:2145:17
rainfalll4:23
90:18,20,23
80:2481:3,16
42:1066:21
58:1560:1
raised88:5
91:1692:15
82:3
68:21
71:2
61:19 77:9
ran29:9
recreational
rely54:14 77:16
protected
24:15
80:6,17 81:13
Randolph
1:13
5:23
remember 87:15
41:11
81:21
1:19
red49:2
reniind83:10
protecting
25:22 question
6:15,21
RAO 2:5
redirection
56:4 removal
82:10
83:20
11:10,21
16:24
rapid44:15
reduce89:19
repeat58:1
protection2:11
17:6 22:13
rapidly44:6
902,3
71:13 87:7
48:11
75:9
23:19,2424:5
raps
88:6
reduced92:14
88:22
protective
19:24
24:13,17
25:3
rates
86:11
refer
37:19 66:6
replete 38:14
prove 48:4
26:11,24 27:17
rather
43:23
67:7
report
20:16
proves47:10
28:6,8 29:2
49:16
reference7:24
31:13
37:21
provide22:8
31:8,9 32:2
reaches
53:9
68:24 70:3,19
38:18
60:14
33:21
48:3,8
33:1534:1,14
read22:1038:6
referenced86:9
66:8,11
67:22
50:951:18
35:1637:4,9
38:1047:16
references2l:17
68:3,4,17
57:7,2168:5
43:15,1744:2
66:15,1668:14
21:19
reported92:13
78:580:7
46:23 47:9,17
68:15
69:4,4,6
referred7:23
Reporter92:6
82:14
47:23
49:7
ready3o:24
31:23 73:20
reports2o:2
provided47:2
50:3
51:21
70:10
referring9:24
represented
50:2478:7
55:1,1257:1
realistically4o:9
1313,16,19
14:2249:24
provides2l:16
63:2365:18,23
really56:15
20:337:11
51:24
34:13
74:14
76:19
77:1,11,21
39:10 43:20
reproduction
provision
45:7
78:1
80:9
reasonable
68:7
73:16
18:17
46:22 48:23
84:13 85:18
61:14,17
75:11 86:21
reproductive
73:12
86:7 87:2,14
reassessed
10:23
reflect 7:4 15:20
19:20
provisions 45:21
88:4,14,22
receive 44:11
reflected 76:1
request
81:23
73:16
75:21
questioning
recess 70:9
refuge
54:7
required
74:22
79:17
74:6
recessed 91:16
regard
75:6
requires
43:12
Public
92:4
93:7 questions 5:9
Reclamation
76:24 81:23
resay5o:3
publications
27:21
31:6,8
3:10 60:21
89:9,10
research 18:8,10
39:3
67:18 74:8
reclassification
regarding
59:24
18:18,24 19:14
pump 13:5
15:8
77:10 82:23
82:5
66:467:4
37:21
15:9 16:1,22
84:13
recognition
regional
9:5
reservoirs
75:2
44:12 46:18
Quiescent74:23
38:14
regs 82:2
reside23:7
56:9
89:9,16
quite5l:12
recognize75:7
regulated56:7
resided59:8
purpose
61:4
62:20 76:8
reconunend
regulation
68:24 resident
23:6
put37:5,661:24
88:23
49:9,1475:16
69:181:2
59:1275:5
puzzle37:6
quote7:3 16:24
87:3
regulations8:2
resolved3l:18
P.02:13
17:1 54:10
reconunendati...
63:15,21
69:13
respect 28:24
67:5
5:2287:11
6916701
33:11
64:2
quoted69:17
88:1
80:14
65:18
87:4
qualified43:11
77:7
reconunended
reiterated 47:6
respects 64:24
quality 1:4
7:4
quoting
33:16
49:18
related
8:17
respond
67:20
8:210:23
37:1667:8,13
reconimending
21:2150:2
70:15
11:18,23 14:3
77:3
75:13
59:9
response2o:4
17:2432:3,5
relates38:865:5
44:10
Page
105
Responses
60:16 R08-91:4
82:11 83:18
seven
10:7,8
16:15
responsibility
sections
80:24
22:1
60:16
simulations
45:1948:2,4
S
sectors74:23
79:10
29:10
65:10
S
2:8
4:8
sediment
33:13
seven-day
34:17 since
44:1 67:17
rest47:16
Sag49:16
50:18
33:23
38:20
several 7:3
9:6
70:21
restoration
50:19 51:1,23
44:17
46:19
15:10,15
16:12
single
16:11
10:19,2479:3
53:354:1
86:5
53:17
17:478:6
site56:15
63:17
79:9
same
6:1
26:18
sedimentation
severe
39:6
65:1
63:19 81:1,18
restore
11:1
29:18
55:9
56:8
85:22
sites29:4
result 11:12
67:23
70:4
sediments
64:11
severely
56:4
site-specific
17:718:3
81:11
see6:2011:10
sewagel5:2
19:2335:3
44:12,1646:19
sample84:18,22
13:1716:10,14
sewer46:18
56:2257:22
Resumed5:17
SAMUEL4:6
23:1863:8,17
82:11
60:362:8,14
resuspension
84:6
67:22
68:8,9
shallow
53:3,12
77:10
38:5 44:17
saying24:1,9,12
69:9,24 82:4
shallows
56:7
situation
11:22
64:11
24:16
27:23
89:14
shape53:17
19:3
return53:20
28:1629:10
Seeing8:820:10
SHARON92:4
s1x39:2142:1
56:13
39:1242:8,23
20:23
30:18
shed89:7
Size2O:17
returning
53:19
59:20 74:4
58:20
60:8
shipping
63:24
skip
6:20 78:1
reversal
56:5
82:4
82:17
84:1
shoreline
53:3
sloughs75:1
reversals 56:8
says 7:2
12:3
85:12
short 18:22
solid5l:1
52:8
review
54:4 70:6
56:14 68:12
seem40:5
shortcoming
52:15,18
53:12
reviewed54:9
7219
seems74:575:7
53:5
solids38:5
71:22 82:2
scenario
15:14
segment
10:8
Shorthand92:6
some
5:9 13:5
revision
18:5
scenarios
14:5
60:3
62:8,17
show9:23
17:2
16:16
17:19
re-evaluated
16:20 29:13
62:18,21
79:12
47:7,10 68:6
21:14
31:20
11:3,5
schedule9l:7
segments23:22
68:23
32:2,21
39:5
right 8:16
15:17
scientific
31:18
selected
58:11
showing
69:1
42:17
43:7
21:1423:24
39:243:8
Selection20:18
shown29:5
48:849:6
24:4,2425:2
49:1750:5,9
Senior2:5
showsl4:11,15
50:1053:4,11
25:1461:16
51:1953:18,24
sense40:552:18
14:1748:8
56:1657:7
67:2072:9
5718
sensitive2l:23
SHUNDAR2:7
58:662:20
78:13
scientifically
23:11
24:16
side
19:17
72:2,4
64:12
70:12
rigorous 50:5
349
25:22 66:22
significance
73:3,6,9
75:7
ripples56:8
Scientist2:4,5
68:22
10:20
77:2
88:17
rise44:13
scour46:18
sentence
11:14
significant
89:7,20
90:4
rising
46:16
scouring
44:16
12:17
47:1
37:10,13
38:12
something
53:5
riverl:78:20
se77:22
55:266:16,17
43:1844:13
66:1075:14
14:1015:1
seal93:1
68:14,1588:23
77:13
somewhat50:2
49:12,23
59:5
second
20:16
SEPA32:7
significantly
sorry
21:16
60:2,7
62:7
33:18
40:12
separate49:10
72:14
33:15
45:2
63:24
47:449:3
55:3
September
5:21
similar
51:2
50:20
80:23
role
35:24
50:8
66:15,16
88:7
6:5 9:20
55:15
56:18
87:7
Rooml:14
90:15
set4l:2142:8,9
64:665:11
sort27:11,22
rooms9l:19
secondaryl2:8
42:15,1843:2
66:1070:3
42:1743:15
rulemaking
1:5
section 10:2,17
45:24
46:1
75:14
sounds
51:2
11:24
76:2
11:1 68:6,13
61:12
79:7
similarly 12:10
sources
29:23
run 16:15
69:7 70:4
92:24
simulated
14:13
south
14:9 49:11
runoff
13:4,4
7422
80:17
setting
56:3,22
29:18,19
49:12,22,22
14:23
81:16,16
82:11
settled26:2
simulation
59:5,10,24
Page
106
60:2,6,14
62:7
spoke
32:8
52:6
41:10
43:21
41:16
42:14
supplied67:18
spatial
10:7,9
52:24
47:667:4
strike
11:16
support25:8
79:10
Springfield
2:14
statements
stringent
67:1
36:7
48:20
spawning
39:6
SS
92:2
45:24
48:15
studied
76:23
75:4
54:7
stage
57:13
54:5
studies
18:3
supported 67:1
speak
14:5
stages
48:12,14
states
6:6
7:3,6
21:19
31:12,19 supporting
9:7
19:1224:7
stagnant73:7,13
9:6,7
10:18
31:2232:11,15
48:752:14
36:854:19
75:1876:1
31:938:22
36:853:23
67:19
62:5
76:3
77:5
47:10
55:7,9
86:20,21
87:21
supports
18:24
speaking 32:11
stagnation
38:3
57:2,12
79:16
87:24
supposed
61:7
35:1452:23
46:2051:5
stating69:14
study22:1223:1
74:7
speaksl0:6
stand35:15
80:11
31:1032:1,18
sure8:249:2
special45:10
standard
10:6,9
station
13:5
16:1
32:23
33:1,12
63:14
65:17
75:21
76:5,6
11:13
35:4,17
16:2244:12
33:18,2034:12
67:9,1073:23
76:10
35:19,2336:12
stationsl5:8,9
36:11
37:4
82:888:8
specialist54:18
36:16
44:19,24
32:7
46:18
39:14
46:6,12
Surely62:1
specialized
45:4,14,18
56:9
86:10,14
53:5,7,16
59:4
surface
19:17
51:13
46:2,8
57:15
86:14,1689:5
62:15
65:21
81:13
species
18:4,13
59:21
61:19
89:9,16
76:24
77:6,8
surprising
51:12
18:20
19:1,15
62:3,979:2
statistics86:9
77:15,21
86:23
suspension6:7
19:2421:22
84:1985:4,9
statusl2:18
stuff9l:12
79:18,19
22:19
23:2,6,7
standards
1:4
staying
80:6
subcontractor
swings
64:18
23:1224:14,16
7:4,15,199:24
steep5o:2251:1
33:7
sworn5:15
25:2226:12,15
10:23
11:18
52:7,15,17
subPlatte59:16
30:1231:3
36:2039:20
12:12,16
17:24
53:12
substantially
83:11
84:8
57:6,23,24
18:528:1,13
stenographica...
86:1
92:10
59:6,7,11,12
32:14
34:10
92:13
substrate
38:22
system
1:6
13:10
60:16
62:14
35:6,24
50:9
step25:11
44:16
15:8
27:3,5,9
66:22,24 68:22
57:22
58:15
STEPHANIE
sudden
14:18
27:16
28:17,18
71:2
60:1,4,763:7
2:17
44:18
29:15
35:2
specific5:21
70:24
71:15
sticking35:6
suffer
19:19
39:22
41:16
7:108:39:7
78:3,8,16
still5:813:5
sufficient74:21
45:10,2253:10
21:1935:9,10
79:1880:1,6
16:1883:12
75:3
55:6,656:2
35:11,11,22
80:17
81:14,21
stop58:4
suggest86:19
59:18
75:17
36:5,7
40:8,8
83:20
86:12
storm
13:4
15:2
suggesting28:13
83:23
85:23
41:145:16
start5:1123:21
44:10,1146:16
34:15
systems55:14
56:1559:4,14
66:1876:18
storms44:9
suggestsl8:19
56:1,16,18
62:21,22
72:24
84:12
strategy32:5
19:15
50:11
64:765:11,16
73:12
79:17
starts
82:5
33:5
suitable23:5
85:20,24
87:20
state
7:3
8:7
stratification
36:19
specifically6:10
32:12
34:8
38:3,2051:6
Suite
1:202:20
T
7:17
11:8,21
40:847:1
56:10
3:5
T4:8
21:23
24:18
53:22
55:5
stratified
20:6
summer
29:4
table
61:1
28:2432:15,19
57:2258:14
75:1877:5
supplement
take2l:11
55:23
45:1546:11
59:571:21
streams68:20
18:1019:14
56:1067:21
78:21
75:676:12
Streetl:13,19
79:1482:1
70:6
specifics
16:2
80:692:1,5,6
14:9
supplemental
taken29:3
63:15
specified92:18
stated33:19
stress64:13
48:17
69:1092:17
spent3l:19 32:1
40:3
65:15
stressors 23:14
supplemented
takes
30:9
51:476:8
statement38:8
23:2025:1
19:9
talkl5:5,626:12
Page
107
37:23
48:11
talked
38:1,4
87:15
89:2
90:22
talking
12:5
13:16
15:13
21:18
26:16
31:20
38:2
50:17
52:21
68:8
76:9
78:24
88:16
talks
77:8
TANNER 2:6
Tarp
11:19
12:2
12:4,11,18
15:22,24
16:3
16:5
88:17,18
89:3,6,12,15
taxa
57:6,11
technical
60:14
60:15
technologies
12:14
tell 21:6
29:24
temperature
76:21,24
77:1
77:3,11
temporal
10:7,9
79:11
temporary
79:19
82:10
ten-minute
70:6
term
10:20
35:13
36:24
51:22
terminology
34:21
terms
16:9
36:23
41:2445:17
65:20
tested
59:13
testified
5:15,16
5:20
6:4
17:11
31:3
78:14,19
84:8,9
testify
61:19
77:23
80:1
92:10
testimonies
44:23
87:5,8
testimony
5:5
6:1
12:7
13:23
17:1
19:11
29:6
30: 14,17
3
1:13,14
34:16
35:1,23
36:3
37:12,20
38:7
39:11
41:8
43:23
44:22
46:24
47:5
49:9
53:21
54:6,9,14
55:3
55:5
56:19
64:4
66:3,7,9
68:1
69:18
72:1
73:18,21
74:15
76:21
77:2,12
83:14
83:18
84:15
86:5,9
87:13
88:6
92:15
testing
59:7
tests
32:6
Texas
57:8
thank
17:16
26:7
30:5
43:5
59:1
70:8
74:19
83:2,4
88:9
90:11
91:8,13,17
their
7:3 18:16
47:1048:12
50:10
51:18
59:8,13
65:10
71:23
75:4
87:13
theme
53:20
thermal
77:14
77:15
thermodline
75:1
thing
26:19
70:4
things
42:3,4
49:1
52:10
think
6:16,20
13:11,15
23:23
25:6
26:6
27:22
33:16
35:1
36:6
37:16
39:16
40:12
43:11,20
43:22
44:21,24
45:18
46:15,20
51:3
52:3,6,22
53:4
54:20
61:13,14,17
62:14
65:22
66:10
67:12,13
67:19,23
68:5
69:22
70:10
74:11,14
76:8
76:11
77:6
79:24
80:8
82:2,3,8
86:23
THOMAS
2:9
Thompson
1:12
THORNBURG
3:3
thorough
34:10
36:2
53:24
65:13
thoroughly
65:23
though 10:14
82:9
thought
35:23
43:23
45:3
50:14
65:4
78:14
through
14:12
25:24
29:5
32:24
54:19
63:2
86:12
throughout
44:17
86:18
thrust
53:2 1
Tier
58:15
tiered
57:3,9
time
10:9,15,22
17:3,5
18:23
23:18
29:15
3
1:20
32:1
51:4
61:10
70:19
76:9
79:11,13
91:13
91:19
92:18
times
7:14
19:18
TIPSORD
1:17
2:3 5:1
6:14,18
7:20
8:5,16,21
9:10
10:3
13:20
17:18
20:7,20
21:13
26:8,11
28:5
30:3,9,15,23
43:14
58:17
59:1
60:5,18
61:21
62:2,10
70:5,10
74:11
76:15
80:19
81:4,17
82:15
82:24
83:7,16
85:8
88:8,11
90:9,14,18
tired
58:3
title 60:15
68:12
69:6
titled
8:20
20:16
titrated
84:24
Titration
84:14
84:16
today24:23
36:8
91:17
together
3 7:6,7
tolerance
59:9
59:14
tolerant
52:11
52:11
66:24,24
tolerate
18:20
22:1
tolerated
22:15
tool
14:4
towards
75:14
toxicity
26:23
traffic
56:9
64:10
transcript
1:11
92:12
treatment
12:14
Tribal
58:15
tributary
13:4
true
6:2,3
81:11
92:15
truly
35:2
truth
92:10
trying
6:19
9:2
18:6
19:24
23:12
24:7
26:6
29:20
70:23
74:9,11
Twenty
6:23
twice83:11
two
14:12
15:7
17:3
20:2
21:21
27:21
52:10
59:23
64:6
65:22
90:24
type27:15
types
18:11
75:24
typewriting
92:14
typically
27:3
U
UAA7:10,22
9:4
9:5,8,17
11:7
33:14,24
34:3
36:18
39:12,14
39:21
40:4,15
41:24
48:22
53:2
77:8
78:20
UAAs
6:5,9,12
78:22
Uh-huh
22:23
68:18
uncertainty
88:18
89:11
under
5:8 10:2
17:11
22:20
42:20
72:19
83:12
92:14
understand
9:2
34:1
61:3
71:4
89:24
understanding
16:4
40:15
61:20
89:15,17
understands
74:14
understood
24:13
underway
34:12
unfortunately
63:20
unique
13:9
35:2
44:3
45:9
51:5,10,13
Page
108
55:6,11,21
28:21
31:11
27:3,1533:4
83:22,2287:4
50:23
52:23
56:11,14,15,22
38:12,1639:16
41:2147:16,18
88:2
59:11,1261:7
59:10,18,18
39:1640:16,18
60:2468:7
waterwayl:6
61:7,8,12
76:11
41:11,13,15
71:13
36:1655:5
62:12,2064:18
uniqueness
42:9,10,13,15
wanted 7:23
85:23
65:4,4
70:11
51:11
43:447:7,11
43:13
waterwaysl3:9
70:2471:11,14
United55:7,9
47:2048:3
wanting48:20
15:4 17:12
71:1577:11
University 60:22
49:4 50:8 57:3
wasn’t23:24
19:3,7 23:3,17
78:7,20 82:9
unjustified
57:4,5,958:3
55:13 64:5,5
27:1228:12,24
88:16 91:21
34:22,23
58:14,1666:23
67:17 70:21
38:13 64:21
weren’t76:7
unplanned
78:20
82:10
89:3
65:1,1771:1
91:11
48:23
using85:1
waste84:2085:5
71:19,19,21,23
Westl:13,19
unstable38:21
utffized80:2
85:10
72:3,9,11,15
wet5:226:7,11
until2:10
Wastewater
72:1775:15,17
6:117:5,7,16
unwarranted
V
60:20
way
25:7
56:20
13:3,8
14:12
34:18,20 35:13
variance 10:19
water 1:4,6 3:10 weather
5:22
16:16 17:23
Upper59:24
10:20,21,24
7:4
8:2 10:12
6:8,11,11
7:5,7
27:24 28:3,17
60:2,6,1462:7
791,3,9
10:23
11:18,23
7:16 13:3,8
28:19,22
29:23
upstreaml4:10
variations37:24
13:414:315:2
14:12 16:16
43:1944:4,12
19:10
38:1
17:24,2419:8
17:23 27:24
44:2445:4,8,9
urban73:5
various76:20
19:920:632:3
28:3,17,19,22
45:13,2046:1
use 8:18 18:8
81:1
32:5 33:5,13
29:23
43:19
46:8,10,21
25:10,15,17
veryl6:917:2
33:2335:4
44:4,12,24
78:2,15,21,23
32:1434:16
18:2026:14
36:2338:2,12
45:4,8,9,14,20
79:19
35:6,13,20
30:535:3
38:15,23
39:22
46:1,8,10,22
wetlands74:24
36:18,24,24
51:13
55:13,14
40:20
41:18,20
78:3,8,15,21
we’1153:23
61:9
37:1,739:14
56:11
59:19
41:2142:17,20
78:2379:19
63:12
40:8,2141:4,8
64:1571:19
43:1244:6,7
web27:11,14
we’re5:913:16
42:17,1945:18
83:290:11
44:11,14,17
website7:22
33:1661:21
45:2247:3,14
91:12
45:1746:17
weekl7:4
62:378:24
49:10,15,16,18
VI10:3,4
50:1,1452:2
weigh3l:10
what-ifl4:5
50:151:16
view48:2
53:855:8
weil6:167:9,12
29:13
52:1 58:13
viewed54:12
57:24
58:15
8:15 10:21
WHEREOF
62:1363:5
violatel6:18
59:860:1
21:2422:18
92:24
66:5,20 67:4
violated7:15
61:19 64:1
23:6
25:5 27:5 while
74:1
67:11,1468:19
12:12
67:477:880:6
28:1032:2
whole24:17
69:12,21,23
violationsl2:8
80:1781:13,19
35:2236:13
27:1154:1
70:2,23
71:15
volume
16:21
81:20
83:23
37:20
44:1
56:1
92:10
72:2,2073:2,4
84:18,20,20,22
49:3 50:16
Williams2:16
73:13
74:3,20
85:5,5,10,10
54:1 55:14
5:18 6:14,16
74:2475:11
Wacker2:203:4
waters35:21
56:1961:9
6:19,237:1
83:21,2284:18
waitl3:2049:3
36:1245:1,5
66:1667:12
8:249:9,22
used9:619:21
53:2286:19
45:1447:12,21
71:1386:15
10:1613:14
19:2229:13
87:21
50:2163:5
went62:15
15:1816:19
57:1059:22
walled50:22
66:2068:19
were5:216:5
17:1521:5
69:2372:6
wails5l:152:8
69:12,21,24
14:13
17:23
22:3,1630:24
USEPA38:22
52:13,15,18
70:272:13,23
23:1627:7,22
40:1041:6
40:23
58:18
53:13
56:5
73:2,4,13 74:3
29:17,18
33:12
60:23
61:9,13
uses5:236:2,7
wantll:14
74:4,20,24
36:138:439:9
66:1,9,14
7:5 8:3 28:11
17:21 22:9
75:1 80:18,21
44:20,21
48:23
69:17,20 70:13
Page
109
70:16
71:10
73:15,22
74:7
74:13,18
76:13
78:14
79:21,23
80:22
81:22
William’s
81:6
willing
55:15
76:4
82:6
91:11
willingness
91:9
Wmkler
84:14
84:16
withdraw
61:9
witness
4:3
5:14
9:3,16
10:4,5
14:1
15:12,17
16:7,13
17:16
18:2
21:15
22:11
26:20
28:9
30:7,11
31:2
37:15
42:12,21
43:1
43:9
45:6
46:3
50:16
52:5
54:8
58:1,9
59:3
61:15
62:5,11
66:12
70:14
71:7
73:14,19
74:16
79:14
80:4,10
83:4,5
84:7
87:19
88:21
89:18,21,24
90:5,12
92:9,9
92:24
witnesses
82:23
90:23
91:2
worded
55:13
wording
52:9
words
69:9
work
46:7 91:10
working
33:7
wouldn’t
18:14
29:24
77:16
wraps
27:22
Wreitburg
20:8
wrong
69:10
Wyoming
60:22
yeah 43:22
66:13
67:6
68:4
years
55:20
86:12
young
39:8
1
19:2076:19
80:23
1.0
79:12
1.7
7:12
79:11
1:0091:4
100
1:13,19
16:5
1021
2:12
1147:1
11-500
1:20
116 5:6
13:22
29:7
1187:21
12 23:17
31:14
33:20
46:23
47:4
1331:1449:7,7
1300
2:20
15
60:3
62:8,18
1651:21
17th
1:14
1855:1
1957:1
19th 85:6
19276
2:13
1986
10:12
1994 20:8
1995
85:6
2
229:5
47:5
55:4
55:4
82:1,3,13
82:14
84:13
2(b)
82:11
2-025
1:14
2/17/09
8:13
9:15 20:15
21:4
30:22
58:24
60:12
81:10
82:21
84:5
85:16
20
4:12
6:21
200
4:10 8:8,9
8:12
9:23
10:1
14:21
2001
14:13
20:21
29:4,11
29:17
2005 86:12
2007
86:13
2009
1:15
93:2
201
4:11 8:14,23
9:11,13
202 4:12
20:10
20:11,14
21:7
21:10,12,16,21
68:12
203
4:13
20:22
20:23
21:3
204
4:14 30:18
30:18,21
2054:15
58:18
58:20,23
206
4:16 60:7,8
60:11
62:2
207 4:17
60:19
61:22
81:6,9
81:24
208
4:18
81:21
82:16,20
209
4:19
83:24
84:1,4
214:13
210 4:20
85:11
85:12,15
217-782-5544
2:15
23rd93:2
24th
14:12
2563:23
26.0802.03-3
8:4
27th91:4
3
37:2
17:1
31:8
37:20
80:23
84:15
85:18
86:8
3rd 90:21
91:2
30
4:14
9:20
300
84:22
301
1:9
302 1:9
302.105
68:13
302.203
74:23
302105
69:1,5
70:7
303
1:9
304
1:9
314:5
11:10
31CMR81:19
312-357-1313
3:7
312-795-3707
2:22
312-814-4925
1:22
314CMR4.00
81:12
32 16:24
58:12
351:82:20
55:20
68:12
3758:12
3880:17
4
4 11:11,21
13:13
13:21
29:6
34:14
37:11,19
37:20
55:2
66:4
67:21
68:1,2
72:1
78:1
86:7,8
4th
90:21 91:2
4.06 81:16
4400 3:5
4500-OC
84:20
85:7
46480:18
5
54:4
6:15
10:1
13:12,21
17:1
28:6,8
37:20
43
:21,22
66:4
66:6,7
82:13
87:2
584:15
6
6
10:2 35:16
82:13
604:16
60601
1:21
60601-2110
2:21
60606
3:6
61
12:6
62794-9276
2:14
7
77:2
18:22
22:1
29:2
37:9
82:13
7/22/2010
93:9
8
84:10
814:17
824:18
844:6,19
84-4327
93:11
854:20
94:11
29:6
43:17
9th
14:12
9:00
1:15
X4:1,8
Y
z
zero
7:7
9:19
17:3
9
x