Ct

tL.

ll. Norrl-t!

Flilip l!.

lr'rii

.

"

Cru;

1|".'(lr!t1

..

;

Tlcr

L.Crxrnr

l;oi<I

!'.

!|ri!l):

,

RicL.{

E-lL^

:

llillhr

S, lhrby

i,Crrrld

ilrir:

litrpkn

A.Tr|lr.,

Mtqr.ft

Ar l'!'f!E

(.-

Cterf

Ori-iru

:

tilirbcd

.|. Enrr

.|. CLy

(br:

"

:

T.

Xct Cnlrn

,

O.ry

A. &ora

I

TKC:dc

'

'Enclosures.

(

)rli;in.rl

!).,

\

jor

Rero.Jv{

Siirrling,

Northru

p,

l-lannn,

:

flricJ

,

(-)ochril11,

[=ztd.

Arrotncyr, *r

l:n-

l'.,rr

()flicc

tlo.

"lil

Seir.

t:ratrr

t lun.trrd

.

:

lllittort

llvil,linl

'

'1

Sptrngficld,

lllirrors tltT()$

Arc.

(

i,J. ?t.

'lrlt;Sarr

f4i-||44

Cullcn

. {hrl

All'rl'rg

: dJ{;rd

^*iifi.t:.-o

iiJ

l;.rrts

'i

:

illrt

ttr!i

tl

la:*r {'itra,lr-

i{l{{

-

r$a:

t*q

lt' rht'n

.iD+f

:f

ri

.

.

.

::_.:

llovcml:er

17,

198i

christan,

L,

l'lof

fett

C

Ierk

Illinois

Pol.l.ution

Control.

Board

309 West

Washington

Street

Suite

300

Chicago,

Illinois

60606

RE:

Central

eompany

Contro'

f

ll-inois Publ

ic

Service

v,

Iilinoi,s

PoIluEion

Board,

PCB

No.,??-i58

Dear

Ms. Moffett:

Please

f ind

encl.osecl

ten

(10)

copies

of thc

Anrendecl

Petition

for

Regulatory

ltearing

uncler

-Ru]e

203

(i)

(

l0]

(cc]

,

chapter

''3,

Rules

and Regulations,

rlrinois

pol

l.ution

contr:or

Board,

filed

by

Central

IIIinois

public

Servicc

Company

as

Petitioner.

As

your

review

will

indicate,

lve

havc

not'att_ached

Exhibit

B to

the Petitiorr

in that Exhibit

Ir

is

a

corrtinuous

computer

printout,

approxinla

tely 1

I

"

X 15

,,

,

iiiA

r.pr;;;;;.J

i t

in

order

to

provide

ten

copies would

be

both

ti.me-consumin{

a1d

expensive.

-

Petitioner

also makes

reference

to

a

survey

conducted

by

thg

rlrinois

Naturar

survey

on

the

environmental-

aspecLs

of

: ,:

coffeen. Laker

which we

will.

be admitting

into

evidence

at

the

hearing. rn view

of

the size

of

the

survey,

which

consists

of

three volumes

and

is approxinratery

B"

thick,

we

are

not

attaching'ten

copies

of

the

survey

to

tne

petition.

After

!h"

hearing,

-the

survey

wil.l

be

part

of the rccords

available

for

the Board's

review.

.

t

aPEreciate

your

consideration

in

this

matter

in

allowing

us

to not furnish

ten

copies:of

the

temparature

data

anci

the.

Natural,History

Survey.

-

'

.,'

cc,:

.

Wa1tbr

:::::,

Sincerely

yours,

Y,{,fi"l-

T.

fKent

Cochran

I

---

*n*''

l=;+

itl:

F:-=:r'.til

CIi}ITRA!, ILT.IHOIS

PL'BI,]C

SERVICE

collPANY,

PeLit_joncr,

VS'

i

ILI,II*IOTS

:,OI,L['TICIIf

CONTF.OI,

BOARN.

:

t:

-11

I}CB

i{r: ?7-I5B

-:'

:.

'.'

AMEN!]ED

PETITION

FOIi

RECUI,ATQP:f

llll/TRING

UNDER RULE 203

(i)

(10)

(cc)

,

CHAPTER

3, RlJf-ES

liND REGUI,ITTfONS,

ILLINOIS

POLLUTION

CONTROL ITO/ilil)

-

Now

Comes

central

rlrinois

public

scrvice

compsny, an

rllinois

corpor;rtion

(hereinaf

ter

callc<i

"cIps',)

,

ancl for

i

ts

Amended Petition

hercin

states

as

:.oIlows:

1.

On or

al)out

May

31, lg71

,

CIpS f

ilcri

its

;:ctition

for

Requlabory

ltearing

under:

Itule

203

(

i)

(1.0)

{cc)

n.'rql

thcreaf

t:c'r-

on

September'

13

ancl

L4,

197-?

,

hearings were

he

l<l orr

Lhc

aforemcnLioned

petition

after

which

crps,

as

pctitjone'r,

and

Illinois

Environmental

Prot.ection

/rqcncy, as'rlesponclent,

filcd

their

respective

Briefs

and"Reply

Br:ief

.:

2.

on

or

about

aprii

27

,

t

9ZB, Lhe

I tlinois

pol

t-uLion

control

Board

(hereinafter

calleel

the

,,Board"),

aft:er

hcaring

test.inony, reviewing

the documenLnr:y

crridcncc,

cxh

j

bi l-s

ancl

demonstra[\ions

trresented at the lreari

ng, ancl

eonsideri

n<.1 Ltie.'

St:j

ef

s of

Lhe

Pet.it.

joncr

and

llcsl:ondent

ctrter:crl

an

Orclcr,

that statcd the

following:

It is

-the

Order of

the

pollution

Control

Boarcl'that:

---

1,,.t

'

!:'.

'

i".

-

::i.

:',

']:

:

.a.

!'::

:

:

t

'

'iJ..;',:

I

=,..

=::'-.,

:=r:::,i

Jt:

:.:

4..:::.

:'.

,;-.;',',

ta.a::'a--

=::'::,1

't:=:..','"

::l:

j::

':'

;::'

:.

-'

t-:

't'

=:..:.

.,1

{

I

}

l'clr

thr-,

i.'er

icrd

cf

t

in",n

(:t'}{.:

:

r'r{i

t,h:

r,r,

}r(:i.tr's

fram

lhe

{:irte r)f

this

i-ilrlc::,

i }rr.;

t.hc:-niirl

clischar<:c

to

Cof fcr:n

L;rrlc, frc:-'r'c!-!'t,et.r

SLation

shaji

nct rr!sult.

;::;l

t_r:r,1'r,1-n1,,r,,

mea

sr:re(_l

'

;tt

tlre

outs

i

dr-:

cti<,-c.

r:f

t,

ht:

ni

x

r

n+

zone

in

Cof feen

Lake

exccL-rirnrJ

gBnF

rlur.inri

moru

tharr

8,21

of

tlre lroiir-s

i

n

t

lrc.

!

w'f

1..'{'

tnonCh

l

eriorl

etlcl

j

nq wi

tl:

ar.lf iront

h,

a!-lri

j

n

.U1y

cvent

shall

aL

tlo

t.in,c cr:cer:d l0got'.

,

,

i;l)

1f at

Llrc

encl of

l-lrc

three

)i€.1

r

[,r.'r

iocl

rtr:,,c.j

in

(t)

abovc,

Cen!,ral.

Iliil:ois

prr!:lic

scrr'-ice

i)r'csrlnts

ev r

cicnc-.c. whi.ch

con\rirrccs

tl.le

Boa

l-ci

Lhat

Cof

feren

Lake mcet.s

tl:e

eri

tciri

a

o!.

Rule

203(i)(f0),

the

intcrim

limited

norc

Iri

(I)

al)ove

shall

l>ecome

l)()r;r:ancnt

s1:ecif

ic

thermal

sl-anclarrls

f

or

t'o!'f

oen

Lal:c.

Not.cr:

A

co1>y of

atLa,che<l

3. Subsclc;uclti-

to

thg tloardrs

Qreier, CIFS

cont:!:act-ed

w*i

Lh

t-hc Illinois

Natrrral

llistory

srlrvey

to conclrrct

tt c()rll.rl.rJhensive

Lhr:ee-yeal:

Lacol.r:o

jcaL

sLucly of

C:of f s-'en

Lal:e

f

r.om Jrrly

I,

lgTB

through

June

30, I981.

'llhc

1,>rimar:y

F,url:ose

of

khis

sL.ildy

l_rt:

j

ncl

to

determi.ne

wlrctlrer

Cof

tecn

l,akc

js

env

j

r:onmrjntnIll,

.

accepLalrle

in

terms

of

supportinq

slrel.lfjsh,

!:ish

and

wiI llrt.,

ancl

recreational

uses,

consisl-cn{-

wiLh <-toocl

manaqclrncnt-

f}fa:.iiccs

4. On or abouL

'April.

22,

I98I,

CIPS

f ited

its

Mocion

,!g-Ppen

iearing

an{

Takq

AddiLional

TesL-i":nsuty

tor

rhe

purpose

of ciking

acldibi.onal.

t-estimony

[)er

r:he

Boarcl's

Ag:ril

'27

t

lg'lB,

orcler',

arrd

exLenclecl

the interim

thermal

li

mi t-s .rpl)r6ve<l

by the

Boar<l on Apri I

27,

l

gBI

,

unt

j.l

lr

t=inal

r.csolut.iolt

of

Lhc

203

(i)

(1.0)

Regulatorlr

llear:inq. 'fhj.s

l.lotion was

not-

objcct.r,.d

t.c)

by the

rl,linoi.s

Environmental

I'rotecLion

n-qency

(hcr:einagtcr

call€d:

the

'rAqency'1;

and a

heari-nc1

was'subsequcnLly

sab by

-,,.i;'

.a

,'a

',,

aa

'

,::: .

..

,,:

a:

the

lloardrs

hpr:!l 21

,

l!l?8,

f,rrdsl'

is

hereto

ir s

f,xhi

lti L

ri .

---

::

i:

:'.

:t,

.,

.

,,,,

...a

a

.-

agrcement

of

clPSi anci

tlre

/rqcncy

f

ol'

ltorvcmbcr

30, lgBr, at,

,

l

9:'3.0,-4.:rnl

in

Springf

iel<1,

-f

llinois,

Room

l2ZIr

o.flthr:

,

'

.

..

:

capiuc,i'tluilding,

.','

,'5.'.

The

oriq.inal

203(1)

(I0)

<lcn:cnstrr:eLion

for

L-'of

fcen,'.

'

Lake

requested

a

specific

thcrmal

standard b.rsed

on

typical

,I'

,,,

t

-

actual

operating

conditions

cxper:ienceql

at

coffeen

power:

Station

f

rom

1965

through

t

976. Tlrosr:

therrnal

sLandarclsr

are

:

:

.

.no

longer

inclicaLi.vu

of

cof feen Lake

concjitions

based on

'''

'

.1

teml:erature

clata.

qather:ed

f

ronr l.9??

Lhrough

I

9Bl

,

sce tl.re

attached

Exhi.bit.

B

(herei

naf

ter refer:recl

to as

i'Temtrerature

..

Data"

)

.

6.Anana1ysisofthesurveyandt.het.em1>craturcdata

shows

that

cof feen

i,ake

is capable

of

suppot't

i rrg

sherr

f

i sh;

'

':t,.

.

.

fish

anci wildrifer

ord recreationar

uses consistent

with

good

.'

rnanagenlent

practices,

ilr accor:dance

with

ltute

203

(i

)

(r0)

tc-c)

(1)

,,

,.

at the

-tgmperatures

reflected

in

t.he

Teglperature

Data.

,.!,t,..

,

7.

It is

the

posi.tion

of

the

petitioner

that

specific

i'

,,,

,:i

:

:

,1,,,.

.thermal

st-'andar:ds.be

adopted

for

Coffcen

'l,ake

tlrat are

.

-,

'.,

'representative

of

the actual

conditions

existing

in

C'of

feen l,ake

.l:

.Prior:

to

ancl ciuring'

the

course of

the

three-year

environ*ui*ul'.,.,'

...

study.

Accordingty, PeLitioner proposes

anci

rcquests

Lhe Boardl'

I

:'

to,establish Lhe

forlowing

specif

ic thermal

standard f61'.

jfs,',

:'

:

Cof

feetr

.

take:

.'

.

.

.:.

'.

:::i:ri:,j:

:l

.,t;,"':

'

''

:t-ltri

::

.

i.

:;.',.-'.'

,'.

,

. .11:.

.

.

-:

::.::

i.i.:

.

.

:

,i

,,

i.=

!='.:::

:--

:::-

,

'

-3-

::

.;

---

The

thermal

tliecharsc

to

Cof feen t,al..c f

or

Central

Ill

inoi,g

Pull.l

ic

Scrvi

ce

Companyr s

Coffeen

Power.

SLaLion

shatl

rioL resill.t i.rr

a

temperature,

measurecl

aL

t.he

out s iclc

ecicle

of

the rnixing

zone

in

Cof f ecn

La).,e,

which

exceecls

104 degrees

Fahrenlrei

t as a

rnonLhl

y

average

and

l1'2

degrees

Fahr:enhej

L

as

a

maximum

for

more than

lt

of the

hours in

t.he 12

month

period

ending

with any

month.

CENIIRAL TI,I,TNQIS

PUBI.IC

.SIiRVICE

COI'!PANY, PeLj

bj.oner

BY:

Soriing,

Northrup,

Hanna,

Cullen

&

Cochran.,

Ltd.

T. Kent

Cochranr.of

Counsel

Suite

800

-

Illinois

Brrilding

Springfield,

IIIinois

6270I

Telephone:

(2L7'l

544-1144

---

CPIIT

IF

ICATE Oi-

.

SF]RVIC:D

a'a

:':

,1

The,,undersi.gned

hereby

cer:iti

f ies

that a

copy

of

rirrr

foregoing

tunended

lretition

was

servecl

hy hancl

clei.iver:inq

a

copy

iof

same to

Davicl

Reiser

of

the

F:nvj.ronmantal

pr:ot-ecti.on

A,Jglgy,;,'22.00

Churchill,,

lload,

Springf

iel<i, tllinois

*ncl by

maillng

ten

(IO)

copies

of the'Amendect

petition

to thc

Clerk of

t,he

Boar<i

at 309 W. Washington

Street,

Suite 300,

Chicago,

IlIinois,

by

t>utting

same

in the

Unite<J

St,ates mai.I

ancl

hand

del

iver.ing

and ma

j.f

inq all

on the

ITth

<iay of

November,

1981

.

':j

:.

':

:.1.

i'

:l

-,.

.

.;;

.

.,.

*.it,

i;':;

.t