BEFORE THE ILLINOIS
POLLUTION CONTROL: BOARD
IN
THE MATTER OF:
PROPOSED
SITE SPECIFIC
RULE FOR CITY OF SPRINGFIELD,
ILLINOIS, OFFICE OF PUBLIC
UTILITIES, CITY WATER,
LIGHT
AND POWER AND SPRINGFIELD
METRO SANITARY DISTRICT
FROM 35 ILL. ADM. CODE
SECTION
302.208(8)
)
}
R 09-8
(Site
Specific Rulemaking-Water)
N OTICE OF FILING
TO: Mr. John Therriault
Assistant
Clerk of the Board
Illinois Pollution Control
Board
100 West Randolph Street
Suite
11-500
Chicago, Illinois 60601
(VIA
ELECTRONIC MAIL.)
Marie E. Tipsord
Hearing Officer
Illinois Pollution Control Board
James R. Thompson Center
100
West Randolph,
Suite
11-500
Chicago, Illinois 60601
(VIA U. S. NAIL,)
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that I
have today tiled with the Office of
the
Clerk of
the Illinois Pollution
Control Board PETITIONERS'
ADDITIONAL P0S'I'-IILAR1N(.i
DOCUMENT SUBMITTAL,
a copy of Nx-litch are herewith served
u1)0rr yuu.
Respectfully S ubmitted.
C ITY OF SPRINGFIELD,
ILLINOIS,
OFFICE OF PUBLIC UTILITIES,
CITY
WATER, LIGIIT AND POWER,
and
Date: December 3, 2008
Katherine D.
Hodge
Cliristine
G. Zeman
HODGE DW YER
ZEMAN
3150
Roland Avenue
Post Office
Box 5776
Springfield, Illinois 62705-5776
(217)-'523-4900
SPRINGFIELD
METRO SANITARY
DISTRICT,
By:
/s/
Christine
G. Zeman
One of Their Attorneys
T HIS FILING SUBMITTED
UN RRCYCLED PAPER
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
BEFORE THE ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
IN
THE MATTER OF:
PROPOSED
SITE SPECIFIC
)
RULE FOR CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, )
ILLINOIS,
OFFICE OF
PUBLIC
)
UTILITIES, CITY WATER, LIGHT
)
R09-8
A ND POWER AND
SPRINGFIELD
)
(Site Specific Rule - Water)
METRO SANITARY DISTRICT
)
FROM 35 ILL. ADM. CODE
)
SECTION 302.208(g)
)
PETITIONERS' ADDITIONAL POST-HEARING DOCUMENT SUBMITTAL
NOW COME the Petitioners, City of Springfield, Illinois, Office of Public
Utilities, City Water, Light and Power ('`CWLP") and Springfield Metro Sanitary District
(collectively "Petitioners"), by and through their attorneys. HODGE DWYER ZEMAN,
and voluntarily submit to the Illinois Pollution Control Board ("Board") the followirns!
report entitled:
In vestigation o f (`'litigation
S
trategies
fur Boron Increase at O ufall
004, prepared for CWL[' by Ilanson Professional Services Inc. ^
("Investigation R
eport").
This Investigation Report was requested by Ms. Traci Barkley of Prairie Rivers
Network by e-mail; the undersigned provided it to tier by e-mail
attachment
on Monclay.
December I, 2008. Said Investigation
Report is attached hereto as Attachment A, and is
provided to the Board for a record of
all documents provided to participants in this
proceeding.
This Investigation Report is listed in Exhibit I to the "Petition for Site Specific
Rule" at Section
8,0 "References."
See, Technical Support
Document for
Site-Specific
Boron Standard for the Springfield Metro Sanitary
District
Spring Creek
Plant,
S angamon C ounty, Illinois, A ugust 13, 2008,
at page 8-3. It is also referenced generally
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
as having been developed as part of CWLP's Compliance Commitment
Agreement (Pet.
at 127).
WHEREFORE, Petitioners,
City of Springfield, Illinois, Office of Public Utilities,
City Water, Light and Power
and Springfield Metro Sanitary District respectfully submit
this Investigation Report as documentation provided to Prairie
Rivers Network.
Respectfully submitted,
CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, ILLINOIS,
OFFICE OF
PUBLIC
UTILITIES,
CITY WATER, LIGHT AND POWER,
and
SPRINGFIELD METRO
SANITARY
DISTRICT,
Date: December
3.
2008
By: /s/ Christine G. Zeman
One of Their Attorneys
Katherine I). 1Iodge
Christine G. Zeman
I
IODGE
DWYER ZEMAN
3150 Roland Avenue
P.O. Box 5776
Springfield, Illinois 62705
(217)
523-4900
( MI11:002/1if'Additional Post-Hearing
Document
Submittal
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
e undersi
O XY1
1 11,:, ý ýiefl
James R.. I°honipsun
C: I i1 1
lolph
ttacFlied
I ,iI `V,i,_l"
a ctiun
,+le.
C
11i,
ll(irloi;.
rý-O(
sulic
United ,.
l
t,-
1 I
O 'S
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
Lion t 1Cate
O Utfall 004
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
I1.(II
i Ctfetlde' :
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
1.0
2f1
ý.C)
?...1
w -1
:1-9
4-1
6 ,0
2-'
t a : i ZIS
;,I -lity
1,,ve-7;rt
2-;t
i lki.i ~i
= f-flucto
TLd Landfill
3 -7
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
ý? _?
1c,rithly Flaw anti I
rýý-,týs
cýLý < teý-
ýýriýý
_
V JA
tl
or
c Liquid
i'olclc1
2-4
''-9
0
3 ;ý1t!19
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
water
treatment p lant a
n d operates two power stations and
a
potab
ion
re-LILACS
I
s ly
Clý.
n
Ise in tile: C
1- . led While
Futor to the
[rocxl the
1
vvate,r
I
rem the
n.;>fcýý e.= l t
t',,
f`zr,h Pond bcvm Study
D, r0."rs
tW
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
the 2003 season.
siows of this refs,
rt
(I in g the FGD effltaerlt water at id thc. Filter PIa]Its ILIcfgt
I
verified
n May 2004 when
reed.
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
,ý I r
("I'
FACILITY
III R'scriptim f
er
tes a potable water treatment pl,nt
es
a dditi
treattient plactt. The facilities <11'e
eater
charac 1 1 1
E;
'Q.
the wdt ,1
re
sný,,,ctivelv.
aid
32 arc iclc ýC ,al,
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
FM 16, 7.`.f 9.57 AM FJu
1.\0]JJ85\r,550191E'M9hK7\flCIAiC'\f1TJrr_lm
Trf,
5 00
0
500
1000
OC%yr:gtt iiCn<.on Professional 3:rJccs lit'. e:+.4
INVESTIGATION
OF MITIGATION STRATEGIES
FOR BORON INCREASE AT OUTFALL 004
CITY WATER, LIGHT AND POWER
SPRINGFIELD, ILLINOIS
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
xide brctcri the
Lrnit' Me
,,al w ere added
to
all
tlrrcFla llman Unit in
2003. `17he SCRs a re. (Verved from
Power Station lack
rate at 8`i()
p5
P MY
n
i n 1951
I li0neUhly
Skm
mmonl
v
o1", th_
icroms are
pond tin N1
s hy
r
oncl.
i; int p lat t
p ! leachatec callecto' a
14
sct].l.j.
lE.r. i(ill
,:ý
- ýrt
mcls, The south
; i-r
pond,
known
a.,>
the I -i
is Ash T'".
l ',
tart Won
h
.-mm
rr
maon
6tnca w en portion. Oh"
1nik:nbiic fly ash ranch
W
r'"ryi ash duke
water
imcls vu l buy
t
he FCil.)S
of l'lu'`tit
Mm 1)
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
TABLE 2-1
WATER USAGE FOR ASH SLUICING
DALLRIAN
LAKESIDE
DALLNIAN LAKESIDE
i
AVERAGE
D ate
Sluice Pump
33 West'
(Hours)
Sluice Pump
33 East'
(Hours)
Sluice
Pumps
31 and 32
(Hours)
Sluice Pump
Unit 8R'
(Hours)
Sluice Pump
Unit
7/63
(Hours)
Sluice Water
Volume
(Mgal)
Sluice Water
Volume
(Mgal)
Sluice Water
Volume
(MgaVday)
January 2003
586.1
745
745
360
504
187.0
73.8
8.41
i
Februarv 2003
141.0
672
6 73
600
5 76
142.6
100.5
8.68
March
2003
210.9
743
742
192
672
161.2
73.8
7.58
April 2003
0.0
720
720
720
648
142.5
116.9
8.65
May 2003
253.6
744
744
408
552
164.4
82.0
7.95
June
2003
701.6
719
719
7 2 `
7
2
189.7
12.3
6.73
Julv 2003
735.1
744
744
624
624
196.9
106.6
9.79
August 2003
261.0
744
745
720
624
165.0
114.8
9.03
S eptember
2003
0.0
720
719
0
0
142.4
0 '
4.75
O ctober 2003
439.3
745
745
216
288
177.0
43.1
7.10
November 2003
446.2
720
72.1
24
72
175.7
8.2
6.13
December 2003
623.1
744
744
0
168
189.3
14.4
6.57
Pump
rate of 1.62 Mgallday
Pump rate of
3.13 Mgallday
Pump rate of
2.05 Mgal/day
2-4
Tibie
2-1
89S3040C
dir 3:'&`04
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
man Ash Pond. "I"he LaHside
Ash Pond and
the Lakeside East
on Pond. Cc»tbtingi wash-v,aiý
rfloor to various s crutce,
a nd t1,
:1:.ý
-,
,, at er p lant 1
cc atriins
p olymer and
ý (,,
s ý:1
i ii:°)nrtl
polymer is Wd in tW CladficAon
l 4 md it tt-ie, inflow l)oirnl: f()r ý,, .<<,
lh
orn ttt
Or"
),
used
to Qtst III of the Clarification P ond effluent.
f0''I, r, :u
entration
arges t
fjorore.
;11
(tI)=l. `Ibis
a study to e, 11
d i sch'l'
LGlio with M
AW
; w .p,_uLd
solids; die filter pl ant wastes
are
u«r
- ý
settling and ueutr?(i;
U
In I
i w Ducts
x'x and
o W"na and
I :ivel, t,?i t
Moo
Awwwa fCir f'etitio/ rr Adhuae(l Ro/on
A'
CO`;-r
ON
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
l
1, :! ,Cwc
Ir,.J;'Y7ý
I
rN
I, O+!sT !F:,ý;ns
x:S
7n? Fcý
N-sQFY,'MSG
flF. !ý 'w"
r' f7F?p
f .M
W ATER SPIT
PniABLE
:YATEP
I
I
I
- ------
k-c+ur-.-'rcrl^'
------
!5.$ FAGD
L
API
:OF1!I TELn
i-
-------------- .
. A1
i
1
i
FACIUT1
U3E
i NACCOUNTED
22 LIC^- =A4
:tiz'E'
I
I
WA T ?
Fns
DU°INIATION I
ýý
RECOYERY
r
PLAN
I
I
,
I
c;pEE,r+
i9*
K_34
I+ILL:'?
GEF!ý[-[
+FOt lD ý-j
I
trc
tdtý
1
,.,ý+ýcsý'ccn
+ýý-r:ýý
D1
L1ýG
c.; o'
- S ý+,r
;..nom
ý
39 MG.,
I
3 K+Vj
aF
i
2.3 MGl
\
- -
5 "
a"FA
?i*2 :0+D.4
IAGD
C+,' L!'7G
*Aý:Er-
I
_...
1, !I
kýlll
I
I
+
en;+.-o clC+ti
t
rp? !£+:.ý !A:"
C4Cn!!!G
ýys.-_
.-i-
.
TL,
LAVE
frn
I
a:.?,
LAUS!Dr. "''CLUNG
?:LATER
!
,.,ý
1
I
+
1
1
+
SCv: c!AERr_EFiC
r
O_'E?i'LOY_
.D_
AI+,G
"-ý
-
- ^'-j.
-WAN'
^I
Inn
El;.. O° S'+EýT
I SET TU'1
:
I
1Q
!A
LlLSE .°C:ID
-1 f
-
?'-
!
I :o-E:,.
^Lp".'ii
I
A^,4
A_k
I^rpi;gýc_o
i
--
nn
I=CI1p I
FCVID
I,ý"ýr;,rl
+??--
i
I
-7
Lý^.LS
-ý
. -'1
1.!
:1-
,
I
IDIjPOSA'
2 5.
SITE
'
.
,'L WE"L"s
I hý0,-ý
CL
APIFICATI <!
ar r
^n...
i
I
PC{
1`ý
I
!LC
Dýý!
I
,SG!1R
EL!EsP!CY Q1+EF:FLnSý1
- -
' ý L=_`
ErIDE,,ý:
I
1.+1
L+rf+ '
I
I
.D1
I
I On4
I :.ILL WAY
i
I
a+_:6 ASS
nn110
PUYFEi.
'
,+=,D ..r:
L :' 1ý-=c
I I
r"
CWLP COMPLEX WATER FLOW SCHEMATIC
INVESTIGATION
OF MITIGATION STRATEGIES
FOR BORON INCREASE
AT OUTFALL 004
CITY WATER,
LIGHT AND POWER
SPRINGFIELD,
ILLINOIS
.So Mac,
JOB N0, 0355019
FIGURE 2-2
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
l
"lt2Cý Itýl: ;",!l:
s'cPl
b nmn. The falWing
standaN fco 11c1rc1n air now
appliec:Ible: 11.0 t-ngll f-01-r1 CWI.-]"*'Z,, Opt
A the
s ( `f)11
W'11c)1
HTP
7n
e l-, a
tnfall
to 1 00 vards c1^mm
_ ý
:u
u
of the c;oi
trital distallct of ap11ty :
i
i
, ?,1; 1y
Oti~(alls 003 and 004-
into wsugm Decl; awe illustrated i
A sh
Pmd .iii
do OAMW
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
w
l
m
C har
Lakp-
AI
WEST
f
f --
t
D isiS ý_
e
_
f.
'4S
s
0
CopyrighL Hanson Professional Services Inc. 2004
N PDES DISCHARGE POINTS
INVESTIGATION
OF MITIGATION STRATEGIES
FOR BORON INCREASE
AT
OUTFALL
004
CITY WATER, LIGHT AND POWER
SPRINGFIELD, ILLINOIS
NO.
2-8
JOB 0 355019
FIGURE 2-3
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
TABLE 2-2
O UTFALL 004 MONTHLY
FLOW AND BORON CONCENTRATION DATA
D ate
Flow at
CN'VLP
Outfall 004
(Mgal/day)
Boron Concentration at CWLP Outfall 004
(mg/1)
Minimum
A verage
Maximum
Minimum
Average
Maximum
' January
2003
2 .64
5.54
7.70
2 .9
6 .0
9.0
Februarv
2003
4.69
5.30
5.92
0 .2
3 .7
8.4
March 2003
3.61
5.04
5.92
6.2
7.9
9.9
April 2003
3.12
5.60
8.67
8.5
9.4
10.6
M ay 2003
4.69
5.78
6.57
8.5
9.5
11.6
June 2003
3.61
4.93
7.25
11.8
11.9
11.9
July 2003
3.12
8.00
13.42
9.8
11.6
15.4
August 2003
4.69
5.79
7.25
10.1
11.1
11.6
September
2003
-5.92
7.05
8.67
14.7
15.1
15.9
October
2003
3.61
4.88
5.92
10.0
12.4
15.7
November 2003
4.69
5.94
6.57
9.3
10.8
12.0
D ecember 2 003
3 .61
4.52
6.57
11.1
11.6
12.0
Ash
Pond Baron Study
2-9
0355019
Dar 030504
.
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
I Di'N
1 1
iortifty from. Ash Sources wit[
.Iý,11-41.
the C
WLP
ash
pond
s ystem were c ollected while
e in r,_ asiri,(T, boron solubility in the ash
r samples and tilt
L roc solids of slung
samoes
were
s and the
solid anti
1 -1
1-=1.
allman Unit 31
.Fl
1;
,g ,
T 4. Ilallman Unit 32 o
ttmn Ashl
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
3-4. Dalln,an
Unit
33 Bottom Asf-Y
4--1. Lai,_ .-
i ý
ý 1,
4 -2.
Lake
,-.ide
Fly Ash/Sluice W at
6 .
7.
I
ý>
,
L akeside
Iý,,u,ýi ,i
Ash/ nice
'A'aier,
C
"r
)t trihutarv to th-
1ý-entration reSUlts fMnl kYater- sari-;,
,t
i1 3-1. These same hc7rolI c( I
i i
ly, the
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
TABLE 3-1
BORON CONCENTRATIONS OF WATER SAMPLES AND THE LIQUID
PORTION OF SLURRY
SAMPLES
WITH THE SCRs OPERATING
(All Concentrations in mg/1)
0 .
SS
ampl'iec-
t
M'No.
Fý<D<aatee
I
-4
2-2
2-4
3-2
3-4 4-1-
4-4
1 5
6
7
8
9
1 0
12
1 3
14
8/2-8/03
43.8 0.288 30.5 0.356 92.7
1.88
3.38 0.352
1
14.8 3.15 13.9 40.0
4.02 49.9 - 224 21.3
9/3/03
22.4 0.317 41.0 0.348
69.4
2.26
--
--
8.98 -- 17.0 64.3 17.6 47.2 0.325
69.1 11.9
9/4/03
11.7 0.235 88.3 15.6 15.5
1.39 --
- ; 5.66 -- 15.5 48.6 3.12 30.9
0.270 65.6 10.4
9/5/03
146 0.294 86.4 0.348 3.38 31.9 --
-- .10.6 -- 37.6 91.1 2.73
109 1.05 318 37.7
9/8/03
55.0 0.303 52.6 0.381 79.2 1.13 --
-- ! 8.86 -- 15.4 13.5 2.20 96.8 0.490
171 6.74
9/11/03 4.32 0.310 69.6 0.306 21.6 1.36 --
i
-- ' 8 .95
--
12.4 49.5
1.16 39.1 0 .284 259 6.41
9 /12/03
13.4 0.344 27.4 0.367 11.0 1.12 --
-- 9.24 -- 14.5 194 4.21
37.5 0.224 249 7.34
9/15/03
38.0 0.285 27.3 0.306
49.3
1.49 --
-- 7.83 - 15.1 64.6 2.12 37.7 i 0.277 270
15.5
9/18/03
7.63 0.329 105 0.343 27.4 0.964 -- -- 1
11.2
-
19.8 6.75 4.16 39.9 0.231 185
17.7
Minimum
4.32
0.235 27.3 0.306 3.38 0.964 - -- 5 .66 --- 1 2.4 6.75
1.16 30.9 0.224 65.6 6.41
Maximum 146 0.344 105 15.6 92.7 31.9 - -- 14.8 -- 3 7.6
194 17.6 109 1.05 318 37.7
A verage
3 8.0
0.301 58.7 2.039 1 41,1 ` 4.83 3.38 0.352 9.57 1 3.15 ( 17.9 63.6 4.59
54.2 S 0.394 201 15.0
3 -3
A sh Fond Boron Study
0 S5019
Dir030$0 s
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
FIGURE 3-1
B ORON CONCENTRATIONS
OF WATER SAMPLES AND THE LIQUID PORTION OF SLURRY
SAMPLES
3 50
300
1-1
c
0
J
V
c
U
f=
O
C3
2
,R0
.i-
200
150
200
50
1 -2
1-4 2-2
2-4 3-2 3-4
4-2 4-4
5
6
7
8
0 -!--
S ample
t
s
i
I
3
- --------------
I
s
i
i
10
12
13
14
I
A sh Pond Romp Studi"
d i r OOS04
3 -4
0 355019
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
ash pond system
dUring the sarrIPI
mg/l.
Them;
dfiil l .t,
mate
e no. 14), which are tributary to the Dallman
5) ranged between
5.7 and 14-, g/1 and avera,(,Yed 9
A sh
Pond,
i As, thei
1[tr;l
CIO
11
n in the Clari
T11
,ail} Pond boron
and the
Landfill
s mall Umv volume results in an average
is V
thr l rimary cause of bor
P-,
ro
i conc encc
art
In the e°v
ash hgtnell
adaate i
relevant to this studv because it
T ed
W«
relati vely
s'/1,
general water
a rml
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
FIGU
RE 3 -2
C WLP ASH POND
BORON CONCENTRATIONS
1 10 -
100
90
E
0
VV
v
U
0
q
80 -'.
--------
M
Maximum
1
" Minimum I
i
0
Average
Dallman Ash Pond
Lakeside Ash
Pond
Lakeside East Pond
Clarification Pond
Ash Pond Bomn Study
dar030804
3'6
03S5019
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
FIGURE
3-3
B ORON CONCENTRATIONS
- CLARIFICATION
POND EFFLUENT AND
LAKESIDE EAST EFFLUENT
1
10
1 00
80 -
7
0
Cz
s
,
-rs
c
60
J
50 ..,
c
40
0.^
10
-
0
g\ýý`\^ý\'1q\`ý'aý-'ýO)0'c\'1p
\ý\`ý' girt\`L
O\n,9'
q\N\`b
q\c,`ý' C`L\ý' ý\
ý\^J
q\
ýý,:ý\ýf aý1\ý' ýp\ýy
ýR\ý'
ytx\ý' `°.\1' ,\,ý\ý' ,`\`l'
`?\'1'
aý qdqý
q\ c)\ ` q\ý q\
l;ý' On'
per' pOn' p0ý' p0ý'
pýý'
ppn' p 0 p0' pC' pQ' p0 p0 p0' pp'
' pp' pp' pp' pp'
Date
-+- Lakeside East Effluent
! -ý- Clarification Pond
Effluent
A sh Pond Bnmn Study
d ,030804
-ý
0355019
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
FIGURE 3- 4
n
c
1
c
c
a
B ORON CONCENTRATIONS - DALLMAN
POND EFFLUENT AND LANDFILL
LEACHATE
40 ;
1
1
0 ý-
ý
p0ý'
^
ppn'
ý
p' pp"' 0
01
pý
ý1
'p
oý ppý p"'
\ý\ r
^p6'
pp"'
ýc0'
SE) 0
(61'
ýp0' O6,
ýpp^:
p
pý,
Ký'
q\\Ký
,
,ý\n.ý
\t,ý1'
'Ký
.ý 3
ý ,\ ý ý\ " ý,\
ý\
ý
ý
ý
ý
q
"l
ý ` "ýý ý\
ý\
cj\
q\ q\ o,\
q\ q\ q\
D ate
"--+- Dallman Effluent
-w- Landfill Leachate j
A sh Fend Boron Study
darn' 0804
03$5019
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
tSarnples were collected throughout the CYWLF'
!!?_°r 9, ?003
trati
t the PuRust
am! Sn o
n avr
'fable 3-''. While it is cictficult to cl:-.velop
a reliable
ý'rii r :lý
or1s at rrrarav o f
ive Sf
t'<_ation of I Auhlu I :r<:f hmd Innuent Stnatit
M l<>m
ecl
I S
.
FCKQ P urnp
S). The
( Satin
(sarnrle n}.
collcction.
A and 135 mg/l and awnTod W4 nWfl.
I
ida,
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
TABLE 3-2
BORON CONCENTRATIONS
OF WATER SAMPLES AND
THE LIQUID PORTION OF SLURRY
SAMPLES
WITH THE SCRs SHUT DOWN
(All Concentrations
in mg/1)
0 .
p
11V
Z
Sam I-e
N o.
Date
1 -2
1-4
2-2
2-4 3-2
3-4
4-2 4-4 1
1
56
7
8
9
1 0
1 2
13
14
1 0/15/03
47.0 0.375 6.99 0.327 24.3 0.960 -- ---
4.78 --- 8.74 7.31 4.34 24.4 0.317 195 22.3
12/9/03
48.2 0.506 54.7
0.447 14.1 0.800 -- -- f
7 .90 -- 11.6 3.61 15.6 41.8 0.463 240 6.57
M
inimum 47.0 0.375 6.99 0.327
14.1 0.800 ---
-----
4 .78
--
8 :74 3.61 4.34 24.4 0.317 195 6.57
Maximum
48.2 0.506 54.7 0.447 24.3 0.960
-- -- 7 .90 -- 11.6 7.31 15.6
41.8
0.463
240 22.3
A verage
47.6
0.441 30.8
0.387 19.2 0.880 ---
--
6.34 --- 1 0.1 5.46 9.97 33.1 0.390 218 14.4
3-10
A ch
Pond Boron
Studv
0355014
Dar 03080-1
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
TABLE 3-3
BORON CONCENTRATIONS OF SAMPLES ASSOCIATED
WITH
THE LAKESIDE EAST POND
(Ail Concentrations in mg/l)
S ample
Date
L akeside East Influent
(Sample No. 8)
Lakeside East Effluent
(Sample No. 10)
Filter Plant Sludge
(Sample No. 15)
FGDS Pump Effluent
(Sample No.
16)
10/l/03
-
-
I
0.253
-
10/2/03
-
-
0.229
81.1
10/15/03
7.31
24.4
0.219
16.4
1 2/5/03
65.9
35.2
0.212
414
12/9/03
3.61
41.8
0.345
210
1 2/11/03
34.3
46.3
0.225
220
1 2/15/03
135
45.1
0.231
301
1 2/18/03
34.8
53.5
0.245
126
12/23/03
44.2
29.6
0.254
235
Minimum
3.61
24.4
.0.212 ' .
. 16.4
. .
Maximum
135
53.5
:
0.345
414 . .
Average
46.4
39:4
0.246
.
..
200.,-.
- 11
Ash Pond Boron Study
0355019
Dar 030804
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
c! had an awe
o r addition
of` boron it
appears that the significant b
oron curhibutor tea the
pear to indicate that there is
ClUalication
(<ýr4r; frle no. lei), which had boron
concentrations ranqgin
,
fý4Cý:.
ý r;
1<i.4 attd 4-l4 rng/
rttrmi
Q It
S WIM:
iv atcr %
M ""n pump seal wa
eff
i i rv
1?.
W()4 corn!
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
(1t14
E\c_J;t OF
to be abOLIt 200.00(
200,(
u lc{
increase
the boron c oncentration
a
t
MUM and
minimum
I
cie.waterýiýýý
st!.cýer
for (';C;;!; 7f
()")4 to m
cornbirl
) and 837 mg/L. The
(low
rate o¬` this stream is esfm:iied
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
boron,
ccfm
also lie, used t;, rermav,: n,
,st
of the dissoly
DS LyhsLrnrl
ci,-V- ýt -h
for is
nor,
. l,
ý-iivc i
?c]
ant
Waste
and
;,w
v,,;,;rc that COrrlti TKA hL
watc
r
r? ;,
ur,ýýr,r trains, utiliy,1
y. 7`h, r c f, tr-e,,
t -.rhanical
evapcrratOrs tyre Currently
?,. rft
III
a
ffumber of
power plants
III
the United States.
'They
ome systerns are reporter to have scaling problenrs and
,-rcfn
waste stream,
_C;i?r()
r,: fly.
fc):
? eatrnerfL
vailable
I, Wc>uld
u,
,
A1Crrrld
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
'TALL
lie
ash bond s
t ,
al cal 2,780 Mgal cal' sluice water
was
lutCC.
water acl,i ý
n nhs :Jddect 1
I
clll I
I
ý
I "' !
Mo,al of
SILll..
i i 'stalled f01- Unit 33,
. .'( I() 4. These
L b, --3fi
,led I-{ilter
landt-illed rnat
S IEu
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
This relationship can be
se
any slui
I I
t ,(,t ofthe Landfill I-eachat:e would have. been to increase
the boron concentra
that
CIA'-LP consider the added effect that boron in the
Landfill Leachate may
u,rcentrations in the
."!,,l)
ponds when conternhlating
operational changes that
gill
reduc,
ý-du<:
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
rt provides a surrrra
Leachate;.
ý Yl)sc,,
; I
as the effluent frc rr l_:.12ýý-i
.
J,.;
,, at the Dallr,:m 1
fia,a,
i
Pond is apparently the resin
Mlles tale SILIII
ti,)n. AlthlAisi :llificaw.
o mý
er7trat
i cd it the 1
1,1
1
re arc 1: >
data s, _:'.
-Ie result
of
s vstetn
ncl
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
5.
into the Lakeside
and Safety Personnel
at
CO«tfall 00ZL
efforts,
s to dry fly vii, will have
can boron concentrations in the ash and
s
1
I
CoU1
Ciu'-u.rQ .
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Office, December 3, 2008
* * * * * PC # 3 * * * * *
