BEFORE
THE ILLINOIS
POLLUTION
CONTROL
BOARD
OF
THE
STATE
OF
ILLINOIS
)
TOYAL
AMERICA,
NC.
,
formerly
known
as
ALCAN-TOYO
AMERICA,
INC.,
a
foreign
corporation,
)
)
Respondent.
)
NOTICE
OF
FILING
TO:
Christopher
Grant
Assistant
Attorney
General
Environmental
Bureau
69
West
Washington
Street,
18
th
Floor
Chicago,
IL
60602
John
Therriault,
Assistant
Clerk
Illinois
Pollution
Control
Board
100
West
Randolph
Street
Suite
11-500
Chicago,
IL
60601
Bradley
P.
Halloran
Hearing
Officer
Illinois
Pollution
Control
Board
James
R.
Thompson
Center,
Suite
11-500
100
W.
Randolph
Street
Chicago,
IL
60601
PLEASE
TAKE
NOTICE
that
on
Wednesday,
November
26,
2008,
we
filed
the
attached
Exhibit
List
with
the
Hearing
Officer,
a copy
of
which
is
herewith
served
upon
you.
Respectfully
submitted,
Roy
M.
Harsch
Lawrence
W.
Falbe
Yesenia
Villasenor-Rodriguez
DRINKER BIDDLE
&
REATH
LLP
191
N.
Wacker
Drive
Suite
3700
Chicago,
IL
60606-1698
Telephone:
(312)
569-1000
Facsimile:
(312)
569-3000
TOYAL
AMERICA,
INC.
By:
PEOPLE
OF
THE
STATE
OF
ILLiNOIS
Complainant,
V.
RECEVED
)
CLERK’S
OFFlCE
)
N0V262008
)
PCB2000-211
)
(Enforcement)
)
)
STATE
OF
ILLINOIS
Pollution
Control
Board
THIS
FILING
IS
SUBMITTED
ON
RECYCLED
PAPER
BEFORE
THE ILLINOIS
POLLUTION
CONTROL
BOARD
OF
THE
STATE
OF
ILLINOIS
PEOPLE
OF
THE
STATE
OF
ILLINOIS
)
Complainant,
)
)
PCB2000-2H
v.
)
)
TOYAL AMERICA,
NC.,
formerly known
)
as
ALCAN-TOYO
AMERICA,
NC.,
a
)
foreign
corporation,
)
Respondent.
)
EXHIBIT
LIST
Toyal America,
Inc.,
(“Respondent”)
by
and
through
its
attorneys,
Yesenia
Villasenor
Rodriguez
and
Drinker
Biddle
&
Reath LLP,
submit
this
exhibit
list
in
accordance
with
the
Illinois
Pollution
Control
Board’s
directive.
Respondent’s
Exhibits
1.
Resume
of
Barry
Van Hoose,
Toyal
America,
Inc.
2.
Resume
of
Raymond
Malmgren,
Toyal
America,
Inc.
3.
Resume
of
Dennis
Debrodt,
Toyal
America,
Inc.
4.
Resume
of
Steve
Anderson,
Admiral
Environmental
Services
5.
Resume
of
Christopher
McClure,
Navigant
Consulting
6.
Toyal
Aluminium,
Inc.,
December
31,
2007
Financial
Report
7.
Expert
Report
of
Christopher
McClure
of
Navigant
Consulting
dated
November
24,
2008
with
supplementary
documentation
8.
Resume
Of
Gary
Styzens,
Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency
9.
Deposition
of
Gary
Styzens,
Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency
dated
November
17,
2008
THIS
FILiNG
IS
SUBMITTED
ON
RECYCLED
PAPER
CHOL
25265416.1
10.
Memorandum
from
Gary Styzens
to
Alec
Messina,
of
Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency
dated
March
29,
2006
re:
Revised
Economic
Benefit
Analysis
11.
Navigant
Consulting
Analysis of
Economic
Benefit
dated
November
22,
2005
12.
U.S.
Environmental
Protection
Agency’s
Federal
Register
Notice
dated June
18,
1999
64
FR
32948-
Calculation
of
the
Economic
Benefit
of
Noncompliance
in
EPA’
s
Civil
Penalty
Enforcement
Cases
13.
U.S.
Environmental
Protection
Agency’s
Memorandum
dated
July
23,
1995
from
Kathie A.
Stein
to
Regional
Division
Directors
re:
Clarification
of
the
Use
of
Appendix
I
of
the
Clean
Air
Act
Stationary
Source
Civil
Penalty
Policy
14.
January
2001
Toyal
Permit
Application
15.
April
5,
2001
Permit
Denial
16.
May
30,
2001
Toyal
Construction
Permit
17.
March
8,
2002
Toyal
Revised
Construction
Permit
18.
November
18,
2002
Revised
Construction
Permit
19.
Clean
Air
Engineering,
Inc.,
2003
Stack
Test
Report
20.
July
2003
Toyal’s
Federally
Enforceable
State
Operating
Permit
(“FESOP”)
Application
21.
November
25,
2003
Toyal’s
FESOP
22.
March
2005
Toyal
Permit
Application
23.
June
6,
2005
Toyal
Construction
Permit
24.
Clean
Air
Engineering,
Inc.,
2005
Stack
Test
Report
25.
January
2006
Permit
Application
26.
Raymond
Malmgren
notes
from
meeting with
Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency
dated
January
21,
2003
27.
Agenda
from
Toyal
and
Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency
Meeting
dated
March 27,
2003
28.
April
8,
1999
Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency’s
Permit
Denial
29.
Chronological
Data
for
Installation
of
VOC
unit
at
Toyal
facility
in Lockport,
Illinois
dated
June
24,
1999
30.
Information
presented
to
Illinois
Environmental
Protection
Agency
from
Toyal
dated May
2,
2007
31.
Information
requested
by
Illinois
Environmental
Protection Agency
from
Toyal
dated
May
2, 2007
(updated)
32.
Chronology
of
Fires
and
Explosions
at
Toyal
Facility
33.
Information
Concerning
Solvent
Recovery
34.
U.S.
Aluminum,
Inc.
in
Haskell,
New
Jersey
Air
Permit
and
Related
Documentation
35.
Silberline,
Manufacturing
Co.,
Operating
Permit
and
Permit
Documentation
located
in
Hometown,
Pennsylvania
(Permit
No.
54-0004
1)
36.
Silberline,
Manufacturing
Co.,
Operating
Permit
and
Permit
Documentation
located
in
Lansford,
Pennsylvania
(Permit No.
13-000
14)
37.
United States
Bronze
Powders,
Inc.
in Haskell,
New
Jersey-
Air
Operating
Permit
and
Related
Documentation
38.
February
6,
1992
Illinois
EPA
Notice
of
Incompleteness
(“NOT”)
39.
March
9,
1992
letter
Toyal
to
Don
Sutton
acknowledging
receipt
of
NOT.
40.
May
29,
1992
Toyal
Response
to
NOT.
41.
April
20,
1995
Construction
Permit
Application
number
95040070
42.
1996
Clean
Air
Act
Permit
Program
Permit
(“CAAPP”)
Application,
excerpts
43.
February
27,
1995
Request for
Additional
Information
from
Illinois EPA
44.
February 25,
1997
Toyal
Approval
for
Plant
Projects
documents
45.
March
13,
1998
Toyal
(BVH)
letter
to
Tllinois
EPA
requesting
delay
in
permit
application submission.
46.
May
22,
1998
RCO
Permit
application
(Excerpts).
47.
December
30,
1998
Toyal
letter
cancelling
stack
test.
48.
April
18,
2001
Permit
Application
/Report,
excerpts
49.
February
19, 2002
Toyal
letter
requesting
stack
test extension
50.
February
26,
2002
Toyal
letter
51.
August
19,
2002
letter
regarding
additional
test
delay
52.
November
1, 2002
Report
on
Control
letter
53.
Request
to
Admit
Facts
and
Toyal
Response
54.
Toyal
responses
to Complainant’s
Interrogatory
Requests
55.
May31,
2000
Complaint
Respectfully
Submitted,
Dated:
November
26, 2008
Roy
M. Harsch
Lawrence
W.
Falbe
Yesenia
Villasenor-Rodriguez
DR1NKER
BIDDLE
&
REATH
LLP
191
N. Wacker
Drive Suite
3700
Chicago,
IL
60606-1698
Telephone:
(312)
569-1000
Facsimile:
(312)
569-3000
By:
attorneys
CERTIFICATE
OF
SERVICE
The
undersigned
certifies
that
a
copy
of
the
foregoing
Notice
of
Filing
and
Exhibit
List
were
filed
by
hand
delivery
with
the
Hearing
Officer
and
served
upon
the
parties
to
whom
said
Notice
is
directed
by
first
class
mail,
postage
prepaid,
by
depositing
in
the
U.S.
Mail
at
191
North
Wacker
Drive,
Chicago,
Illinois
on
Wednesday,
November
26,
2008.
Yesenii11asenor-Rodriguez
THIS
FILING
IS
SUBMITTED
ON
RECYCLED
PAPER
CHO1/
25265563.1