c
A?
Cleaver
-Brocks’
3232 West
—
(4
4)
359-0600
ree<trs
r,urte
adw a aetn syn
vt.ctcaver-brooss,cmn
May
19,
2006
New
Hampshire Division
of Environmental
Services
Air Resources Division
6 huron
Dr
Concord,
NH 03302
Mr. Regulator
Dear
Mr. Regulator:
Recently we requested
from your Department
NOr and Co
emission
regulation
information
pertammg to
natural
gas
and oil fired boiler
systems. I thank
you for helping
us by providing this
information
as it will
allow us to compare
regulations in different
parts of rho
country.
ISPA
ozone nornattainment
designations
are
having
u significant
nnpaet both on industry and
on regulatory
agencies
such as yours.
Many noroattainment
areas are scrambling
to determine
the
best
available
options
to include
in their State Implementation
Plan, Here
is where I think we
may be able to
help you.
Cleavor4frooks
is the largest producer
of hot water and
steam boilers
in the
US.
We
have spent
the
post
livo
years
developing
a
state of
the
art
burner and boiler
packages that produces
less
than 9 ppm
NOr
when
tiring natural
gas
and less than 70
ppm NOr when
firing distillate oil,
This includes a
rhO UI. labeled
certification test
program for our Model Cl3
too to $00
HP
Ipass
firetubo
boiler
series.
We
cmrently have
over
(20) thirthparty test reports
which
documcnt
compliance to these
limits, In addition, we
offer hnrners
and bunter retrofit kiss
for higher levels
such as
<12,
<15
and
<39
ppm NOr
on
natural
gas. In the
past
three
years
we have sold hundreds of
these
units,
‘fiterefore your
NOr,
and hence
orone,
ambient
concentrations
can be reduced
by
simply tightening
up
yonr
corrent
regulations.
‘t’his in itself
may he enough
to eliminate
a
nonrettainmont
designation.
l’his oquiprnent is available
today
and is vcry
cost competitive,
as evidenced
by she number ot
units
shipped
and
installed,
Finally,
the San loaquin area air district
in GA took this
approach
about two years
ago and reduced their
limits to
<9
ppm NOr for boilers
over 20 MM
8TH and <15
ppm
NOx’ for boilers between
2 MM
8TH
and
<20 MM 8TH, They mandated
that 25%
of
the boiler
population
was
required
to comply with
these
new regulations
each
year,
Titey are
currently
in year
two of
this program
with over (50) taits
completed
and ozone reductions have
occurred,
I wotdd
be happy to meet with
you to
discuss this
option
in
detail. Feel free to call
inc
at 414/43tU5460
if
you have any questions.
have enclosed
some
brochures
on this equipment
for your review,
Sincerely,
RECEIVED
woN
wv1,psHlRE
MAY
252005
Daniel ,l,
Willems,
VP,
Product Development
flU
AIR
gE0lJ00
DlVlJutv
Enclosures
The
CieavertBrooks
Family
Of Companies
C-B Package
Bolter Systems
Nebraska
Bolter
Energy
Rocovory
Internationat
Industrial
Combustion
Natcom
Emission Test Data
For CeaverBrooks
Ultra
Low NOx Boi’ers
And Burners
Table A
Date
Fu&
[
NOx
NOx
Co
Flowrate
Tested
]y
(ppm 3% O)
‘lb!MM BTU,)
scfm)
IypLjze
9ppm NOx
requirements
(natural gas)
Dart
Container
5/27/05
NO
6,5
0.0079
0
3592
29.3
MM
BTH
Cleaver-Brooks Nil
retrofit
—
NO
6.5
(10079
0
3872
NO
6.8
(10082
0
3365
4aS
San Joaquin
5118105
NO
7.4
0.009
1.5
1941
20.9 MM BTH
General
Cleaver-Brooks
CEW
retrofit
NO
6.9
0.0084
8.5
2213
NO
8
0.0097
0,2
1717
,
4t
San
Joaquin
8/11105
NO
6.6
0.008
0
3063
20.9 MM
BiN
General
Ceaver-Brooks,
unit #2
NO
6.8
0.0083
0
2376
NO
7
0.0085
0
2767
,
San
Joaquin
8/11/05
NO
8.3
0.0101
0
2045
20.9
MM
8TH
General
CleaverBrooks,
unit #1
NO
7
0.0085
0
3611
___________
NO
6.7
0.0082
0
3750
Kraft
General
5/23/05
NO
4.4
0.0053
0
767
33.8
MM
8TH IC
Foods
NTD336
retrofit
NO
4.8
0.0059
749
NO
5
0.0061
0
753
..
—-‘-r’7’-’
‘‘
.,.
‘‘
,
,
Delano
5/31/05
NO
4,7
0.0058
1.3
1529
33.8
MM
8TH
Growers
Grape
Cleaver-Brooks
Nil
Products
retrofit
NO
4.7
0.0057
1
1542
NO
4.4
K
0.0053
—
1.4
1524
_______________
.__i,
K
V.
CDI
8120/03
NO
8.2
0.01
2,3
4175
61 MM 8TH
Natcom
NO
8.3
0.01
3
4500
NO
7.9
0,0096
2.4
4269
5k
Foods
10/20/03
NO
5.4
0.0065
0
7737
89.1
MM
8TH
Natcom
NO
5.3
0.0065
0
7618
NO
5.5
0.0067
0
7679
,
‘K
K
,
K
.4
•
I
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Page 1 of 9
Emission
Test
Data For
Cleaver-Brooks
Ultra
Low NOx
Boilers And
Burners
Table
A
Date
Fuel
NOx
NOx
CO
Flowrate
Tested
fljMM__I
(ppm
3%O2
Recot Inc (Frito
5122105
NO
7.7
0.0094
10
2771
72
MM BTH
__
—_________
Natcom
NO
8.4
0.0102
8.3
3605
NG
8.2
0.01
11.6
3625
-
1
z’
Boeing
LB.
3/25/04
NO
7.6
<10
4006
33.8
MM 6TH
GA
Cleaver-Brooks
CEW
retrofit
—___
Kraft
Foods,
6/14/05
NS
3,4
0.0102
0
1955
14.7MM
BTH
i.
Cleaver-Brooks
CEW retrofit
NG
7.5
0.0091
0
1393
NO
7.6
0.0092
1
0
1642
..
,,
William
$/24/05
NO
7.7
0.0094
0
3787
24.5
MM
6TH
Bolthouse
Cleaver-Brooks Nil
Farms
retrofit
NO
7.5
0.0091
0
3386
—————
NO
7.6
0.0092
0
3345
.,
I
Un/fever
Best
5111105
NO
9.1
0.011
1.2
3818
85
MM 6TH
Foods
Natcom
on
B&W
NO
8.5
0.0103
1.3
4512
NO
8.4
0,0103
1.3
2298
tin/lever
Best
7/21/04
NO
8.1
0.0098
1.6
5859
38
MM
6TH
Foods
Natcom on
Nebraska
Boiler
NO
8
0.0097
1.9
5832
NO
7,8
*
0.0095
1.9
5831
SJDaIIa
11117105
NO
7.9
0.0096
0
1430
20.9MMBTH
College
Cleaver-Brooks
retrofit,
unit
#3
NG
8.3
-
0.01
0
1006
—
NO
8.2
001
0
822
‘
.
.
,,
, ,
SJDelta
11/17/05
NO
6.2
0.0075
0
3145
20.9 MM BTH
College
Cleaver-Brooks
retrofit,
unit
#2
NO
7.5
0.0093
0
2379
NO
7.3
0.0089
2.8
797
<
I
—
Morningstar
6/14/05
NG
7.1$
0,0092
2.47
216
26.8
MM BTH
West
Burham
Boiler
retrofit
NO
7.21
0,0092
1.65
170
—
-
NO
j
6.89
0.0088
1.07
242
,
9
‘10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Page
2 of
9
Emission
Test Data
For
Cleaver-Brooks
Ultra
Low NOx
Boilers
And
Burners
Table
A
Date
Fuel
NOx
NOx
CO
—
Flowrate
Taste
ppm
3%
02)
lMM
BTU (pp3%O2
scfn
Tpe1Size
Nestle Food
1fl/17/Oo
NG
o.l
0.0069
1.3
4783
29.4MM
3TH
Hu:s
rro
1
’
NC
5.8
0.u070
0.1
492
NC
5.9
0.0072
0
4550
—
Hilrnar
Cheese
1
1/18/05
NC
7
0.0072
2.2
977
50.2MM
8TH
Caver-8rooks
NG
3
O.00i2
2.2
4713
-
NC
7A
0072
22
4431
Gilroy
Foods
8/79/05
NG
—
7.6
— 0.0092
10.1
3970
63
MM
8TH
Olea--Brcoks
NC
7
8
0.0095
0
4745
—
NC
0.0101
0
4663
4ssoc;ated
/31
05
NC
7.7
0.0093
1.4
H?
19.4 MM
BTlfHu
Feed
Bler
rrc1t
NO
,._____
0.0091
0.
1610
NC
1.9
0.0095
0
1595
Patton
State
12/20’02
NO
6.8
0.0087
13
—
1053
12.2 MM
8TH
HospItal
.
-.
Cver-Brooks
NG
9.5
0.0121
0
--
NC
6.4
0.0082
0
3361
Los Gatos
09/26/05
NO
7
0.O09
3.3
27.78
184
MM
8TH
B&W
Tomato
Products
NC
Jb
-—
0.0097
3j
27284
—-_-
N’
8.2
0.0105
34
?/50
Inland
12,01/05
NO
8.7
0.0111
8
3186
20.9MM
8Th
perbaard
—
-.
Ccier
Brooks
NC
88
0.0113
0
2795
NC
8.6
0.0110
0
3404
International
1111 5/05
NC
8.3
0.0106
0.3
924
20.9MM
8TH
Paper
—
Cleaver-Brooks
NC
——
8.
-
0.0104
. L
0.1
1152
[
NC
8.2
—
0.0105
]
0
1b41
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Page
3 of 9
Emission
Test
Data
For
Cleaver-Brooks
Ultra
Low
NOx
Boilers
And
Burners
Tabie
B
Date
Fuel
[
NOx
NOx
CO
Flowrate
Tested
j
Iy
[Pprn@22Q
2
f
MBTtJIp
3%02
Te
<12
ppm
NOx
requirements
(natural
gas
Suputo
11/13/03
NC
9.8
0.0125
<1
732
16.7
MM
BTH
Cheese
-
York
Shipley
Southg
ate,
Boiler
CA
NC
8.6
0.0110
-1
2004
NC
83
00106
<1
2752
See’s
—
12117/02
NC
11.1
0M12
376
1MM
0TH
Candies
Cea
e-r
joks
1
LX
NC
10
3
0.0132
2
327
NC
99
0.0127
<1
1
146
Baxter
0i0/02
NG
8.9
0.0114
.1
21
20.9MM
8TH
Ilealthcaie
CLvcr
ook
08W
NC
9.8
U.T125
24641
--
NG
8.9
0.0114
4873
1
Lepiino
6’i
3’ns
NC
9.0
1.01
2
0
216$
16.7
MM
8TH
Foods
.
.
reIrol
1
HG
10.3
U.0125
0
26
NC
0b
0.029
3
246
Maxca
1/30,03
NC
11.1
0.6135
0
NA
19.9MM
8TH
Supply
CTver-3rc’o
—
NC
11.6
0.0141
0
NA
NC
06
00117
27.
NA
Boeing-
3/25/04
NC
9.2
0.0118
<10
1834
16.3MMBTH
LB.
CA
I________
Cleaver-Brooks
Boeing-
3/25/04
NO
—
9.8
0.0’25
—-
<10
1
1850
16.3
MM
8TH
Cleave
-Brooks
I
2
3
4
5
6
7
Page
4of
9
Emission
Test
Data
For Cleaver-Brooks
Ultra
Low
NOx
Boilers
And
Burners
Table
C
Date
Fuel
NOx
NOx
Flowrate
Tested
iyj
(lb/MM
BTU)
[yjjze
<15
ppm
NOx
requirements
(natureI
gas)
E&JGallo
5/19/05
NC
10.6
0.0129
2
—
1436
10.2MM
BTH
Win
ety
Cleaver-Brooks
NC
9.7
0.0118
3.9
—
1221
NG
-
8.5
00104
10.8
379
:
. -•.‘
., -,
Cargill-
5126105
NC
12.1
0.0147
0
1282
14.3
MM
8TH
Stockton
Cleaver-Brooks
NC
10.8
0.0131
—
0
1466
—
NC
10,2
0.0124
0
1591
:fr______
..-
.
‘
Memorial
5/5/05
NC
10.9
0.01
33
0
1684
14.7
MM
8TH
Hospital
Cleaver-Brooks
North
unft#1
NC
10.9
0.0132
0
1753
,
NC
10.8
0.0131
0
1499
,
,
:
Foam
5/28/05
NC
7.7
0.0094
0.6
1980
12.6
MM
5TH
Fabricators
—________
,
Cleaver-Brooks
NC
7
0,0085
0
1277
—
_________
NG
—
7.3
0.0089
—
0
1147
Modesto
12/17/04
NG
11.8
0.0143
0
1655
12.6
MM
8TH
Junior
Iron
Ffreman
College
——
boiler
NC
12.1
00147
0
1345
NC
11.3
0.0138
0
1609
f
Georgia
5/31/05
NC
10,7
0.013
0.1
2203
16.3
MM
5TH
Pacific
Corp
Cleaver-Brooks
NC
10.6
0.0129
0.8
2473
NC
11.5
-
0.014
0
1811
Cargili
-
8/8/05
NC
13.8
0.0168
0
1173
14.7
MM
BTH
Turlock
—___________
Cleaver-Brooks
NC
13.4
0.0163
0
379
NC
12.4
0.0151
0
2726
*‘r-
•:--,
Associated
9/20/05
NC
15
0.0182
0
1700
12,6
MM
5TH
Feed
Cleaver-Brooks
. ‘U
110k -
NC
14.9
0.0181
0
1142
NC
14.3
0.0174
0
1702
I
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Page
5
of
9
Emsson
Test
Data
For CleaverBrooks
Table
C
Ultra Low
NOx
Boilers
And
Burners
9
10
11
Date
Fuel
NOx
NOx
Co
-
Flowrate
Tested
j fy
(ppm
3%
02)1
ff1MM
BTUj
fppm
(ä
3%
Q
(dscfm)
yp/Size
<15
ppm
NOx
requirements
(natural
gas,
Associated
7/14105
NG
11
0.01
33
0
977
12.6 MM
Feed
BTH
Cleaver--
Brooks
unit
#2
NC
hA
0,0139
0
1173
HG
11.9
0,0145
0
785
—
Dart
3/2106
NC
11.7
0.0142
0
2804
14.7MM
Container
BTH
East
Boiler
NC
11,9
*
— 0.0144
0
2443
-
-
NG
12.3
0.0149
-
0
2421
Memorial
-
1/17/06
NC
11.7
0.0143
0
2359
14.6MM
Hospital
ET
H
North
Cleaver
Brooks
unit
#2
NC
1
119
00145
0
2277
LJ’-
9
0.0144
0
2241
—.—---
PageS
of 9
Emission
Test
Data For Cleaver-Brooks
Tab’e
0
Ultra
Low
NOx
Boilers
And
Burners
Date
FueJ
NOx
NOx
GO
Flawrate
Tested ]y,p.
ppjj
3%02
1b/MM
8Th)
(p)
f2!)
iyJze
<20 ppm
NOx
requirements
(natural gas)
Paramount
12/22105
NG
194
00236
0
1177
7.9MM
8TH
Petroleum
Rooney Boiler
unit
#1
ND
199
*
0.0242
0
1185
ND
18.2
0,0221
0
1157
Paramount
12/21/05
ND
18
0.0219
23
1318
7.9
MM 8TH
Petroleum
Rooney
Boiler
unit #2
ND
16
0,0194
15
1244
ND
16.9
0.0205
9
1274
Paramount
12/21/05
ND
14.7
0.01 79
0.7
2069
7.9
MM 8TH
Petroleum
Rooney Boiler
unit
#3
ND
15.1
0.0183
0
2166
NG
14.3
0.0173
2.2
2092
.::J
I
2
3
Page
7
of
S
Emission Test
Data For Cleaver-Brooks
Tab’e E
Ultra Low
NOx Boilers
And
Burners
1
Date
Fuel
NOx
J
NOx
CO
Flowrate
j
Tested
(ppm
3%
02)1fiBTU
(ppm
3% 02)
çjj
<30
ppm
NOx
requirements
(natural
gas)
Carpenter
05/20/05
NC
27
0.0328
0.3
735
6.3
MM 8TH
Company
CleaverBrooks
NC
27.2
0.0331
0.3
634
NC
27:7
0.0337
0.3
502
,
S
S.
Lactalis USA
05/21/05
NC
11.1
0.0135
0
947
8.4MM 8TH
Turlock
Superior
Boiler
NC
11,1
0.0135
0
1018
—
NC
11.1
0.0135
0
637
Suputo
11/13/03
NC
22.7
<1
846
13.4MM
8TH
Cheese-’
Johnston
BoHer
Southgate,
A
NC
19.5
<1
1029
NC
18.1
—_______
<1
—
1275
S
:5
S
S
Paramount
12/21/05
NC
23.2
0,0282
46
1934
I3MMBTH
Petroleum
Broach
Boiler
unit#1
NC
23.1
028
78
1874
NC
22.5
0.0273
104
1871
Paramount
12/21/05
NC
20.9
0.0254
10.5
1919
13 MM
8TH
Petroleum
Broach Boiler
S
unit
#2
NC
20
0.0243
15.7
1967
NC
22.9
0.0278
0
2004
,
S
S5-S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
Paramount
12/21/05
NC
27,1
0.033
15.7
2113
13.6 MM 8TH
Petroleum
Kewanee
Boiler
S
NC
26.7
0.0325
7.7
2019
NC
25.8
0.0313
2.4
1986
f,_’SSSS._S__SS___
Bunge
2/15/06
NO
20.1
0.033
0,3
1495
25.1 MM BTH
Foods
Cleaver-Brooks
NO
19.7
0.0325
0.3
1341
NG
19.9
0.0313
1.1
1175
S
S
S
S
4
S
S
S5
5SS
S
S
,
S
S
S
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Page
Bof9
Table
F
Emission
Test
Data
For
Cleaver-Brooks
Ultra
Low
NOx
Boilers
And
Burners
Date
Fuel
NOx
NOx
CO
Flowrate
Tested
[y
{pO1
(lb/MM
BTU43%O
pLize
<
40
ppm
NOx
requirements
(Amber
oiQ
I____
Patton
12/20/02
Amber
ol
30.2
0.0387
<1
2583
20.9
MM
BTH
State
Cleaver
Hospital
-
Brooks
boiler
#3
Amber
ol
73.0
0.382
<1
31
6
Amber
oi
24
0
0307
<1
4475
Se&s
2’i’fl2
Amber
ofl
2.4
0.0364
1
1053
6
MM
B
Candies
C’
Daver
Ar.e
ml
5
6
0.0341
6
2184
Brooks
M4
Amber
oiJ
2b.
0.0360
<1
—
33i
--
--.——-1
-—
-
I
2
Page
9
of
9
