BEFORE
THE
ILLINOIS
POLLUTION
CONTROL
BOARD
IN
THE
MATTER
OF:
WATER
QUALITY
STANDARDS
AND
EFFLUENT
LIMITATIONS
FOR
THE
CHICAGO
AREA
WATERWAY
SYSTEM
AND
THE
LOWER
DES
PLAINES
RIVER:
PROPOSED
AMENDMENTS
TO
35111.
Adm.
Code
Parts
301,
302,
303
and
304
Marie
Tipsord,
Hearing
Officer
James
R.
Thompson
Center
Illinois
Pollution
Control
Board
100
West
Randolph
Street,
Suite
11-500
Chicago,
Illinois
60601
PLEASE
TAKE
NOTICE
that
I have
filed
today
with
the
Illinois
Pollution
Control
Board
Affidavit
of Mr.
Chris
0.
Yeder
a copy
of
which
is
herewith
served
upon
you.
ILLINOIS
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROT
C
ION
AGENC
BJJÜJ
7
?JL/?
OLL/)
Dated:
September
17,
2008
1021
North
Grand
Avenue
East
P.O.
Box
19276
Springfield,
Illinois
62794-9276
(217)
782-5544
)
)
)
RO
8
O
9
aking
)
(Rulem
—
Water)
)
)
QF,c
SEP
19
2008
To:
John
Therriault,
Clerk
Pollu0,-
STATE
OF
Control
ILLINQI
Board
NOTICE
OF
FILING
SEE
ATTACHED
SERVICE
LIST
Counsel
THIS
FILING
IS SUMBITTED
ON
RECYCLED
PAPER
STATE
OF
OHIO
)
CLRjD
COUNTY
OF
FRANKLIN
)
IC
EP
1
9
2008
AFFIDAVIT
POllUtion
OF
Cfl
I,
Chris
0.
Yoder, attest
to
the
following:
At
the
hearings
in
January 2008,
various
parties
asked
for
me
to
provide
additional
information
related
to
questions
that
were
asked of
me.
In
response,
I
am
providing
the
following
information:
1)
Comments
I received
from
U.S.
EPA
on
my
draft
Temperature
Report
can
be
found
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37
as
several
Microsoft
Word
files
in the
folder,
“U.S.
EPA_Others
Comments”..
Hearing
Exhibit
37
is
a
compact
disc,
with
several
files,
that
was
provided
to
the
Board
and
hearing
participants
at
the
April
2008
hearings.
2)
I
was
asked
to
provide
notes
on
how
I determined
temperature-limit
averages for
white
sucker,
log
perch,
and
bluntnose
minnow.
I was
able
to
determine
which
studies
were
used
by
relating
each
FTMS
endpoint
to
the
data
in
Appendix
Z.1
of
the
report,
“Re-evaluation
of
the
Technical
Justification
for
Existing
Ohio
River
Mainstem
Temperature
Criteria”
(Hearing
Exhibit
16).
Hence
the
values
used
in
the
Des
Plaines
River
FTMS
were
determined
by
re
examining
the
data
compiled
in
Appendix
Z.
1.
For
the
bluntnose
minnow’s
upper
incipient
lethal
temperature
(“UILT”),
the
value
of
32.4
degrees
Celsius
used
in
the
FTMS
is
the
average of
the
most
applicable
and
geographically
relevant
values
available,
from
studies
by
Stauffer
et
al.
(1974;
33.3
degrees
Celsius),
Stauffer
et
al.
(1975;
32
degrees
Celsius)
and
Cherry
et
al.
(1977;
32
degrees
Celsius)
at
the
recommended
acclimation
temperature
of
25-30
degrees
Celsius.
The
logperch
is
not
a
Des
Plaines
River
Representative
Aquatic
Species,
and
the
white
sucker
value
was
based
on
the
two
studies
submitted
to
the
Board
at
the
March
2008
hearings.
documents
attached
to
the
March
4,
2008
Illinois
EPA
filings).
3)
I was
asked
to
provide
a
copy
of
the
detailed
study
plan
referenced
in
the
“Quality
Assurance
Project
Plan:
Fish
Assemblage
Assessment
of
the
Lower
Des
Plaines
River”,
Hearing
Exhibit
8).
The
maps
that
were
provided
at
the
March
2008
hearings
and
marked
as
Hearing
Exhibit
23
are
the
original
maps
and include
attending
notes.
These
maps
served
as
the
detailed
study
plan.
The
sites
were
jointly
selected
by
Alex
Johnson
of
the
Midwest
Biodiversity
Institute
(“MBI”)
and
Ed
Hammer
of
U.S.
EPA,
Region
5.
A
meeting
was
held
at
Region
5
prior
to
the
first sampling.
Aerial
views
of
the
stream
portions
that
were
sampled
(electrofished)
are
provided
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37
in
the
Microsoft
Powerpoint
file,”Des
Plaines
Tracks.ppt”.
In
this
file,
each
slide
is
an
aerial
photograph
that
shows
the
path
followed
by
the
electrofishing
boat
within
each
site, the
stream
name
and
site
code
(both
labeled
directly),
and
the
River
Mile
(indicated
at
the
lower
right).
4)
I
was also
asked
to
provide
field-activity
logs
and
field-data
sheets.
There
are
no
field-activity
logs
per
Se;
the
crew
leader
kept
a
daily
calendar,
but
that is
no
longer
available
as
it
was
discarded
when
the
employee
departed
MBI
2
and
it only contained
work
time
data
that
is
recorded
elsewhere.
The
field-data
sheets
for
the
electrofishing
samples
and
the
Qualitative
Habitat
Evaluation
Index
(“QHEI”;
Hearing
Exhibit
7)
are
the
principal
documentation
that
the
sampling
actually
took place
and
for
the
type
of
information
required
by
the
Quality
Assurance
Project
Plan.
5)
At
the
March
2008
hearings,
the
Illinois
EPA
was
asked
about
a
safety
factor
used
in
determining
the
thermal
endpoints
presented
in
“Temperature
Criteria
Options
for
the Lower
Des
Plaines
River”
(Hearing
Exhibit
15).
The
safety
factor
used
by
the
MBI
methodology
is
addressed
on
p.
5
of
that
report
(Hearing
Exhibit
15).
To
account
for
an
inherent
over-estimation
of
lethality,
I
used
a
safety
factor
of
2°C
for
the
critical
thermal
maximum
(CTM)
endpoint.
6)
At
the
hearings
in
January
2008,
a
request
was
made
for
vouchers
and
pictures
of
five
fish
species
reported
in
the
2006
MBI
fish
data
that
were
submitted
as
part
of
Attachment
S
(5th
through
75th
page)
of
the
Illinois
EPA’s
“Statement
of
Reasons”:
Silver
shiner
(one
individual
identified
at
one
site,
RiverMile
265.00,
in
Illinois
River),
blacknose
shiner
(one
individual
identified
at
one site,
RiverMile
276.40,
“Moose
Island
Slough
DP-09,”
in
Des
Plaines
River),
highfin
carpsucker
(17
individuals
from
seven
sites
in
Illinois
River),
black
redhorse
(27 individuals
from
five
sites
in
Illinois
River),
and
brown
bullhead
(5
individuals
from
2
sites,
RiverMiles
279.50
and
290.00,
in
Des
Plaines
River).
Because
the
latter
three
species
are
known
to
occur
in
lower
Des
Plaines
River
or
upstream
in
the
Chicago
Area
Waterway
System
(e.g.,
Heating
Exhibits
28
and
48; Attachments
LL
and
MM
of
Illinois
EPA’s
“Statement
of
Reasons”)
and
3
are
quite
distinctive
and
thus
readily
identifiable
in
the
field
by
a
trained
biologist,
no
voucher
specimens
or
photographs
were
taken
of
the
specified
individuals.
Nonetheless,
representative
photos
of
a
black
redhorse,
highfin
carpsucker,
and
brown
bullhead
collected
by
MBI
in
rivers
from
the
Midwest
(some
by
members
of
the
same crew)
are
provided
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37.
The
photos
of
the
black
redhorse
and
the
highfin
carpsucker
show
the
distinctive
features
that
are
relied
on
to
make
the
identifications.
The
brown
bullhead
photos
may
not
reveal
these
features
as
well,
but
were
nonetheless
present.
Upon
re-examination
of
a
voucher
for
“silver
shiner,”
this
record
of
one
individual
was
changed
to
emerald
shiner,
and
this
change
is
represented
on
page
5
of
the
file,
“Despl
Fish
Species
2-28.pdf,”
in
HGaring
Exhibit
37.
We
collected
a
voucher
for
the
single
individual
that
was
originally
identified
as
a
“blacknose
shiner”.
However,
The
Ohio
State
University
Museum
of
Biodiversity
has
thus
far
been
unable
to
locate
the
specimen
that
was
deposited
by
MBI
into
their
collections.
This
record
of
one
individual
of
“blacknose
shiner”
was
revised
to
pallid
shiner
(as
represented
on
page 40
of
the
file,
“Despi
Fish
Species
2-28.pdf,”
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37),
which
is
a
morphologically
similar
species
that
has
been
identified
in
previous
fish
samples
from
the
same vicinity.
7)
In
the
fish-IBI
data
reported
by
MBI
from
sampling
in
Illinois
River,
Des Plaines
River,
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal,
and
Grant
Creek
in
2006
Hearing
Exhibit
21),
the
fish-lBl
metric
called
“Percent
of
Individuals/Simple
Lithophils”
was
incorrectly
derived
because
emerald
shiner
was
mistakenly
categorized
and
counted
as
a
simple
lithophil
under
prior
guidance
by
Ohio
EPA.
4
Specifically,
for
each
fish
sample
that
includes
emerald
shiner,
this
error
may
result
in
a
higher
value
for
the
metric,
“percent
of
individuals
as
simple
lithophils.”
In
turn,
in
some
(but not
all)
cases,
this
change
may
result
in
a
higher
standardized
metric
score for
“percent..
.simple
lithophils”
and
consequently
a
higher
total
IBI
score.
Corrected
metric
values,
metric
scores,
and
total
lBl
scores
were
provided
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37
as
the
file,
“DesPlaines
IBI
2006
pMar3_08.pdf.”
For
the 26
fish
samples
from
Des
Plaines
River
(twelve
sites)
or
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal
(one
site
at
River
Mile
290.00;
incorrectly
indicated
as
Des Plaines
River)
that
best
pertain
to
this
rulemaking,
corrections
in
scoring
changed
only
six
fish-IBI
scores,
none
by
more
than four
points.
More-recent
review
of
the
fish-lBl
scoring
data (i.e.,
the
file
“DesPlaines
IBI
2006
pMar3O8.pdf”
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37
revealed
a
need
for
the
following
additional
corrections:
a)
The
latitude
value
reported
for
one
location
(“Dst. Olin
Co.
DP-06”)
on
page
3
is
incorrect
due
to
a
typographical
error.
It
should
be
41.483920
rather
than 41.438920.
b)
The
table
heading
should
read
“Table
1.
Boat
181
scores
and
metrics
at
boat
sites in
Illinois
River,
Des Plaines
River,
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal,
and
Grant
Creek,
sampled
by
MBI
in
2006”
rather
than
“Table
I.
Boat
IBI
scores
and
metrics
at
boat sites
in
Des
Plaines
River
sampled
by
MB! in
2006”.
c)
On
page
4,
the location,
“DP-01,”
at
River
Mile
290.10
is
incorrectly
identified
as
Des
Plaines
River.
This
location
is
actually
within
the
last
0.1
5
mile of
the
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal
before
it
flows
into
Des
Plaines
River.
8)
Two
QHEI
summary
tables
(Hearing
Exhibits
5
&
6;
Hearing
Exhibit
37,
in
part) have
been
revised
to
reflect
changes
that
MBI
made
as
a
result
of
scoring
discrepancies
first discovered
during
the
January
2008
hearing.
These
discrepancies
primarily
resulted
from
inability
of
a
specific
computer
program
in
MBI’s
database
to
correctly
incorporate
the
modifications
made
to
the
QHEI for
assessing
physical-habitat
conditions
in
large,
impounded
rivers.
Secondarily,
for
the
“Riparian”
metric
of
the
QHEI, it
was
discovered
that
the
computer
program
did
not
score
each
stream
bank
separately.
These
problems
arose
directly
from
how
the
QHEI data
were
stored
and
processed
by
the
computer
database.
The
problems,
for
the
most
part did
not
emanate
from
the
field
sheets
themselves.
To
achieve
consistency
with
the
large-river
modifications
made
to
the
QHEI, the
computer
program
has
been
revised
to
correct
these
problems.
Consequently,
attached
to
this
affidavit
(See
Attachment
A)
are
the
final
revised
versions
of
the
two
QHEI tables
that
are
currently
represented
on
the
record
as
Hearing
Exhibits
5
and
6
and
again (as
revised
versions)
as
part
of
Hearing
Exhibit
37.
In
Hearing Exhibit
37,
the
revised
version
of
Hearing
Exhibit
5
is
the
file,
“Desp
QHEI Metrics
Feb
28-08.pdf,”
and
the
revision
of
Hearing
Exhibit
6
is
“Desp
QHEI Report
Feb
28-08.pdf.”
Attachment
A
of
this
affidavit
includes
the
final
versions
of
these
two
tables
plus
two
corresponding
spreadsheets,
each
of
which provides
a
record
and
explanations
of
revisions
made
to
these
tables.
These
two
explanatory
spreadsheets
are:
6
QHEI
RecordOfRevisons_ToMetricsTable_08082006
.xls
and
QHEI RecordOfRevisonsToAttributesTableO8082006.xls.
These
revisions
did
not
necessitate
any
changes
to
the
QHEI field-data
sheets
(Hearing
Exhibit
7)
because
these
sheets
were
correctly
filled
out.
9)
In
some
of
the
originally
submitted
(as
part
of
Attachment
S
to
Illinois
EPA’s
“Statement
of
Reasons”)
tables
of
fish
data
collected
by
MBI
in
2006
in
Illinois
River,
Des Plaines
River,
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal,
and
Grant
Creek
the sampling-site
latitude
and
longitude
coordinates,
county,
or
both
were
inadvertently
missing
or
incorrect.
This
information
has
been corrected
as
necessary
in
the
file,
“Despi
Fish
Species
2-28.pdf,”
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37.
For
additional
detail
about
the
fish-sampling
locations,
aerial
views
of
the
specific
stream
portions
that
were
sampled
(electrofished)
are
provided
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37
in
the Microsoft
Powerpoint
file, “Des
Plaines
Tracks.ppt”.
In
this
file,
each
slide is
an
aerial
photograph
that
shows
the
track
followed
by
the
electrofishing
boat,
the
stream
name
and site
code
(both
labeled
directly),
and
the
River Mile
(indicated
at
the lower
right).
Since
the
fish-data
tables
were
submitted
as
the
file, “Despl Fish
Species
2-28.pdf’
in
Hearing
Exhibit
37,
additional
review
has
revealed
the
need
for
the
following
corrections:
a)
On
page
33
of
the file
“Despl
Fish
Species
2-28.pdf”
in
Exhibit
37,
“#
of
Fish”=
0
for
“Species
Name...”
=
Gizzard
Shad
has
been
corrected
from
0
to
49;
all
other
sums,
percentages,
or
averages
that
depended
on
this
datum have
been
corrected.
These
corrections
are
attached
to
this
affidavit
as
“Despl_Fish_RM283.9_Aug
I 0.pdf.”
7
b)
Also
on
page
33
and
on
page
34
of
the
file
“Despl
Fish
Species
2-
28.pdf”
in
Exhibit
37,
the
latitude
(“Lat.”)
of
this
Des
Plaines
River
location
(RiverMile
283.90,
“Dst Olin
Co, DP-06”)
has
been
corrected
as
explained
earlier
in
this
affidavit.
c)
On
pages 25
and
26
of
the
file
“Despl
Fish
Species
2-28.pdf’
in
Exhibit
37,
the
location,
“DP-02,”
at
River
Mile
290.00
is
incorrectly
identified
as
Des
Plaines River.
This
location
is
actually
within
the
last
0.1
mile
of
the
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal
before
it flows
into
Des
Plaines
River.
The
stream
name
has
been
corrected.
10)
At
the
hearings
in
January
2008,
Dr.
Girardasked
if
I could
provide
documentation
on
how
to
address
impoundment
effects when
scoring
the
Qualitative
Habitat
Evaluation
Index
(“QHEI”)
in
larger
rivers,
such
as
Des
Plaines
River.
A
recent
revision
of
the
QHEI for
use
in
larger
rivers
includes
a
new
category
called
“Impounded”
within
the
“Channelization”
submetric
of
the
“Channel
Morphology”
metric.
This
category
was
also
added to
the
“Morphology”
submetric
called
“Pool/Glide
and
Riffle/Run
Quality”.
These
modifications
can
be
seen on
each
QHEI field
sheet.
Hearing
Exhibit
7).
The
reason
for
adding
this
category
is
that
the
habitat
modification
caused
by
the
impoundment
effect
of
a
low-head
dam was
not
previously
accounted
for
in
these
two
submetrics.
Without
this
revision
for
scoring
the
QHEI in
impounded
larger
rivers,
the
“Channelization”
submetric
would
typically
score
the
maximum
possible
points
(i.e.,
6,
unless
there
is
an
obvious
channelization
impact—which
is
rare
in
large
rivers),
thus the
overall
QHEI
score
could
be
artificially
higher,
despite
the
8
presence
of
an
impoundment.
Similarly,
addition
of
the
“impounded”
category
in
the
“Pool/Glide
..
. Quality”
submetric
accounts
for
the
influence
of
impoundments
for
this
submetric.
By
adding
this
scoring
category,
the
QHEI
now
appropriately
reflects
the
habitat
modification
imparted
by
impoundments
in
larger
rivers.
-
Chris
0.
Yoder
/
SUBSCRIBED
AND
SWORN
TO
BEFORE
ME
This
ay
of
My
cmssion
has
no
eir
Sec.
14
O3c
Public
9
C)
I
m
z
Page
25
Gizzard
Shad
Common
Carp
Emerald
Shiner
Spoffin
Shiner
Bluntnose
Minnow
Channel
Catfish
Yellow
Bullhead
Blackstripe
Topminnow
Western
Mosquitofish
Largemouth
Bass
Green
Sunfish
Bluegill
Sunfish
Orangespotted
Sunfish
Pumpkinseed
Sunfish
Hybrid
X
Sunfish
Freshwater
Drum
Round
Goby
0
MG
G
0
MG
T
N
I
N
I
MG
N
0
MG
T
F
MG
I
MG
T
MG
E
I
F
C
MG
S
I
MG
T
S
I
MG
P
S
I
S
I
MG
P
5
iO.00
2.82
28
56.00
15.82
12
24.00
6.78
11
22.00
6.21
1
2.00
0.56
2
4.00
1.13
22
44.00
12.43
1
2.00
0.56
1
2.00
0.56
5
10.00
2.82
55
110.00
31.07
11
22.00
6.21
1
2.00
0.56
7
14.00
3.95
8
16.00
4.52
P
1
2.00
0.56
6
12.00
3.39
177
354.00
16
0.41
0.13
41.20
125.74
39.05
2,245.36
0.14
0.04
6.00
0.12
0.04
5.45
0.00
0.00
2.00
184.14
57.18
46,035.00
5.78
1.79
131.36
0.05
0.02
26.00
0.01
0.00
3.00
0.08
0.02
8.00
2.29
0.71
20.84
0.42
0.13
19.09
0.04
0.01
20.00
0.42
0.13
29.71
0.49
0.15
30.50
1.80
0.56
900.00
0.10
0.03
8.33
322.03
River
Code:
95-010
Stream:
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal
Sample
Date:
07/21/2006
River
Mile:
290.00
Location:
Dst
Lockport.
DP-02
Invalid
Sample:
Time
Fished:
3126
sec
Drainage:
1000.0
sq
mi
Depth:
Data
Source:
01
DistFished:
0.50
km
Basin:
Flow:
C
Sampler
Type:
A
Lat:
41.559820
Lat:
-88.077920
Species
lBl
Feed
Target
#
of
Relative
%
by
Relative
%
by
Ave(gm)
Name
/
ODNR
status
Grp
Guild
Spec.
Tol
Fish
Number
Number
Weight
Weight
Weight
E
MG
Date
Total
Number
of
Species
Number
of
Hybrids
Midwest
Biodiversity
Institute
08/11/2008
Page
26
0
MG
G
0
MG
T
N
I
MG
T
N
N
I
MG
N
0
MG
T
F
MG
I
MG
T
MG
T
I
MG
E
MG
F
C
MG
S
MGP
S
I
S
MG
P
E
MG
Date
Total
Number
of
Species
Number
of
Hybrids
52.00
6.18
24.00
2.85
2.00
0.24
532.00
63.18
18.00
214
78.00
9.26
12.00
1.43
32.00
3.80
8.00
0.95
2.00
0.24
2.00
0.24
6.00
0.71
26.00
3.09
6.00
0.71
16.00
1.90
24.00
2.85
2.00
0.24
421
842.00
16
1.38
2.31
26.54
38.24
64.11
1,593.33
0.00
0.01
2.00
1.42
2.38
2.67
0.06
0.09
3.11
0.16
0.27
2.05
9.04
15.15
753.33
2.42
4.06
75.63
1.86
3.12
232.50
0.00
0.01
2.00
0.58
0.97
290.00
1.62
2.72
270.00
1.16
1.94
44.62
0.06
0.10
10.00
0.60
1.01
37.50
1.04
1.74
43.33
0.01
0.01
4.00
59.65
River
Code:
95-010
Sfream:
Chicago
Sanitary
and
Ship
Canal
Sample
Date:
09/10/2006
River
Mile:
290.00
Location:
Dst
Lockport.
DP-02
Invalid
Sample:
Time
Fished:
2423
sec
Drainage:
1000.0
sq
mi
Depth:
Data Source:
01
Dist
Fished:
0.50
km
Basin:
Flow:
C
Sampler
Type:
A
Lat:
41.559820
Lat:
-88077920
Species
IBI
Feed
Target
# of
Relative
%
by
Relative
% by
Ave(gm)
Name/ODNRstatus
Grp
Guild
Spec.Tol
Fish
Number
Number
Weight
Weight
Weight
Gizzard
Shad
Common
Carp
Golden
Shiner
Emerald
Shiner
Spotfin
Shiner
Bluntnose
Minnow
Channel
Catfish
Yellow
Bullhead
Brown
Bullhead
Blackstripe
Topminnow
White
Perch
Largemouth
Bass
Bluegill
Sunfish
Orangespotted Sunfish
Pumpkinseed
Sunfish
Hybrid
X Sunfish
Round
Goby
26
12
266
9
39
6
16
4
3
13
3
8
12
Midwest
Biodiversity
Institute
08/11/2008
Table
2.
QI-IEI scores
and
metric
values
for
sites
sampled in
the
bes
Plaines
&
Illinois Rivers
by
MBI
in
2006.
WWH
Attributes
MWH
Attributes
0
High
Influence
oderate
Influence
Key
(L1IZT
a)
W
-
-
S(I
._
>
—
U)
u
LU
S
0
c
0
Cmponents
a
-
-
U
E
-‘
.‘
0v
a)CJ
River
Gradient
0
U-
-
.
Mile QHEI
(ft/mile)
i
.
(95010)
Chicago
Sanitary
Ship
Canal
Year:
2006
Location:
Dst Lockport.
DP-02
Latitude:41.55982
Longitude:
-88.07792
290.04550
0.10
EZ;:3
.
1
:!a,
30.50
1.25
(95650)
Illinois River
Year:
2006
Location:
Ust Grain
Silo,
DP-16
Latitude:41
33984
Longitude:
-88.79339
242.1
55.00
0.10
•
•
a
3
1
R
B
•
5 0.50
1.75
Location:
Dst
Marker
243.3,
DP-15
Latitude:41.3
1986
Longitude:
-88.69300
243.3
49.50
0.10
•
•
3
1
•‘
‘
•
4
0.50
1.50
Location:
Dst
Marseilles
Tailwater DP-14
Latitude:41.32791
Longitude:
-88.721
16
246.5
72.50
1.00
••
•
aaa
6
1
U
2
0.29
0.57
Location:
Ust
Marseilles
Dam,
DP-19
Latitude:4j,3
1986
Longitude:
-88.69300
247.8
61.50
0.10
‘
a
-
•
6
0
•
2
0.14
0.43
-
Location:
at
Rat
Run,
Dst
Senaca
DP-21
Latitude:4l.30450
Longitude:
-88.63049
251.4
56.25
0.10
a
a
a
4
1
U a
•
4
0.40
1.20
Location:
Ust Barry
Island,
DP-20
Latitude:
41.32282
Longitude:
-88.55295
- -
-
256.1
5975
0.10
a
aa
a
5
1
a
a
3
0.33
0.83
Location:
Ust
Mouth
Peacock
Slough
DP-13
Latitude:41.36
120
Longitude:
-88.39145
265.0
54.75
0.10
•
U
U
3
1
a
U
a
• a
U
6 0.50
2.00
Location:
Dst Aux
Sable Creek,
DP-12
Latitude:41.37904
Longitude:
-88.33760
268.0
57.00
0.10
a
a a
U
4
1
••
a
•
4
0.40
1.20
Location:
Dst Dresden
Tailwater,
DP-11
Latitude:4l.39917
Longitude:
-88.28506
271.1
86.00
1.00
• a
U
U
U aaa
9
1
0 0.20
0.20
(95656)
besPlaines
River
Year:
2006
Location:
Ust
Kankakee
River,
DP-18
Latitude:41.38731
Longitude:
-88.25261
273.5
57.00
0.10
•
•
a
a
5
1
a
•
a
4 0.33
1.00
08/06/2008
1
Table
2.
QHEI
scores
and
metric
values
for
sites
sampled
in
the
bes Plaines
&
Illinois
Rivers
by
MBI
in
2006.
WWH
Attributes
MWH
Attributes
HighInfkienceModerateInfIuence
I,
r.ey
0)
w
-
Lt.Q)
_U
E
‘
>
)
C
—
-
‘‘
C -, —
..L
A
v
lver
Gradient°
‘-‘
) ..
—
U
Mile
QHEI
(ft/mile)
E
o&
(95656)
besPlaines River
Year:
2006
Location:
Dst
Stone
Fishing
Pier,
DP-17
Latitude:
41
.38331
Longitude:
-88.24078
274.0
49.50
0.10
a
2
4
1
a
a
6
0.67
2.67
Location:
Moose
Island
Slough
DP-09
Latitude:41.40877
Longitude:
-88.22430
276.4
38.00
0.10
a
a
2
4
1
a
a
•
a
6
0.67
2.67
Location:
Moose
Island
DP-08
Latitude:41.40904
Longitude:
-88.21543
276.5
51.75
0.10
•
•
•
3
1
II
•
a
I
6
0.50
2.00
-
Location:
Power
Lines
at
RM
279.5,
DP-07
Latitude:
41.43953
Longitude:
-88.16969
279.5
68.00
i.oo
m
a
a
a
4
0
a
a
a
a
4
0.20
1.00
Location:
Dst
Olin Co.
DP-06
Latitude:41.48392
Longitude:
-88.13369
-
-
283.9
35.00
o.io
a
1
4
•
2
a
a a
aa
a
6 1.50
4.50
Location:
Dst
Brandon
Tailwater
Latitude:41.49920
Longitude:
-88.10695
285.8
81.50
1.00
a a
•
a
a
a
a.
8
4
1
•
2
022
Location:
Dst
Jefferson
St.
DP-04
Latitude:4l.52160
Longitude:
-88.08707
287.9
21.00
o.io
a
1
4
4
2
a
a a
a
a.
•
7 1.50
5.00
Location:
Upst
Ruby St.
DP-03
Latitude:
41.54044
Longitude:
-88.08368
289.0
46.00
0.50
a
a
a
3
•
•
2
a
aa
aa
a
6
0.75
2.25
Location:
DP-0
1
Latitude:
41.55936
Longitude:
-88.08092
290.1
68.50
1.00
•
a
ai
a
a
6
4
1
a
aa
3
0.29
0.71
Location:
Site #
107
Latitude:
41.65449
Longitude:
-88.06121
297.0
83.00
i.00
a a
aaa
a
aa
8
0
a
a
a
3
0.11
0.44
Location:
Dst
Lemont
Rd.,
Site #
93
Latitude:
41.66732
Longitude:
-88.04491
298.3
61.00
o.io
a
a
a.
a
4
4
4
2
a
a
a
a
5
0.60
1.60
(95657)
Grant
Creek
Year:.
2006
Location:
Grant
Creek
DP-10
Latitude:
41.38341
Longitude:
-88.22690
0 1
5200
0
10
a
a
a
3
1
a
aa
I
a
6
050
200
08/06/2008
2
Appendix
Table
1.
QHEI
metric
scores
for
stations
sampled
in
the
Illinois
and
DesPlaines
Rivers
during
2006.
QHEI
Metrics:
River
Gradient
Mile
QHEI
Substrate
Cover
Channel
Riparian
Pool
Riffle
&
Score
(95010)
Chicago
Sanitary
Ship
Canal
Year:
2006
290.0
45.50
13.0
9.0
4.0
6.50
7.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
(95650)
Illinois
River
Year:
2006
242.1
55.00
15.0
14.0
6.0
8.00
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
243.3
4950
16.0
9.0
6.0
6.50
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
246.5
72.50
15.0
7.0
16.0
10.00
12.0
4.5
1.00-(8)
247.8
61,50
16.0
17.0
9.0
7.50
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
251.4
56.25
17.0
14.0
6.0
7.25
6.0
0.0
O.10-(6)
256.1
17.0
12.0
8.5
9.25
7.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
265.0
15.0
13.0
6.0
8.75
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
268.0
57.00
16.0
14.0
5.5
9.50
6.0.
0.0
0.10.(6)
271.1
86.00
20.0
11.0
17.0
10.00
12.0
8.0
1.00-(8)
(95656)
DesPlaines
River
Year:
2006
273.5
57.00
10.0
16.0
9.0
10.00
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
274.0
49.50
9.0
15.0
5.5
8.00
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
276.4
38.00
3.0
14.0
4.0
10.00
1.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
276.5
51.75
11.0
15.0
6.0
7.75
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
279.5
68.00
19.0
17.0
7.0
10.00
7.0
0.0
1.00.
(
8)
283.9
35.00
1.5
11.0
3.0
7.50
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
285.8
81.50
17.5
13.0
16.0
8.00
12.0
7.0
1.00-
(
8)
287.9
21.00
1.0
3.0
2.0
3.00
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
289.0
46.00
11.0
11.0
6.0
5.00
7.0
0.0
0.50-(6)
290.1
68.50
14.5
9.0
14.0
7.00
9.0
7.0
1.00-(8)
297.0
83.00
15.5
16.0
16.5
10.00
10.0
7.0
1.00-(8)
298.3
61.00
6.0
13.0
16.0
10.00
10.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
(95657)
Grant
Creek
Year:
2006
0.1
52.00
9.0
15.0
6.0
10.00
6.0
0.0
0.10-(6)
08/06/2008
.
1
Page
33
Date
Total
Number
of
Species
Number
of
Hybrids
River
Code:
95-656
Stream:
DesPlaines
River
Sample
Date:
07/22/2006
River
Mile:
283.90
Location:
Dst
Olin
Co.
DP-06
Invalid
Sample:
Time
Fished:
2056
sec
Drainage:
1000.0
sq
mi
Depth:
Data
Source:
01
Dist
Fished:
0.50
km
Basin:
Flow:
C
Sampler
Type:
A
Lat:
41.483920
Lat:
-88.133690
Species
IBI
Feed
Target
#
of
Relative
%
by
Relative
%
by
Ave(gm)
Name
/
ODNR
status
Grp
Guild
Spec.
Tol
Fish
Number
Number
Weight
Weight
Weight
Gizzard
Shad
0
MG
49
98.00
28.16
6.70
10:52
68.37
Smallmouth
Buffalo
C
I
10
20.00
5.75
19.22
30.17
961.00
Common
Carp
G
0
MG
T
12
24.00
6.90
24.34
38.20
1,014.08
Goldfish
G
0
MG
T
1
2.00
0.57
0.88
1.38
438.00
Spottail
Shiner
N
I
MG
P
2
4.00
1.15
0.01
0.02
2.50
Spotfin
Shiner
N
I
MG
1
2.00
0.57
0.00
0.01
2.00
Bluntnose
Minnow
N
0
MG
T
15
30.00
8.62
0.06
0.10
2.13
Channel
Caffish
F
MG
2
4.00
1.15
3.72
5.84
930.00
White
Crappie
S
I
MG
1
2.00
0.57
0.08
0.12
38.00
Largemouth
Bass
F
C
MG
9
18.00
5.17
4.03
6.33
224.00
Green
Sunfish
S
I
MGT
13
26.00
7.47
0.54
0.84
20.62
Bluegill
Sunfish
S
I
MG
P
52
104.00
29.89
3.55
5.58
34.15
Orangespotted
Sunfish
S
I
1
2.00
0.57
0.01
0.02
5.00
Pumpkinseed
Sunfish
S
I
MG
P
2
4.00
1.15
0.10
0.16
25.00
Hybrid
X
Sunfish
4
8.00
2.30
0.47
0.74
58.75
63.71
174
348.00
14
Midwest
Biodiversity
Institute
08/06/2008
Spreadsheet
2.
Compassan
etC/tEl
total
sceres
(‘QhhEl’(
and
warmwater
aynibutes,
high
influence
enaditied
habitat
attributes
and
maderate
influence
habitat
attrihgtes
amaeg
three
different
versians
at
the
table
titled,
Appeedia
Table
t””Appendia
Taste
t”
depicts
QHEt
data
catlented
by
Midwest
Sicdiversity
lestitute
in
Iltisais
River.
Des
Pleiees
Riven,
and
Grant
Creek
iv
2006,
Catumes
highlighted
in
grey
indicate
scaring
discrepancies
amang
verswss.
Pan
the
and
GHEI
scare
çGHE7)
and
tar
each
GHEt
campaseet
metric
(e.g..
oobstnate.
CaaaC).
the
snares
in
the
calamn,
3/ieal
Versian:
represent
the
mast
aanarete
scares.
Twe
previsas
sets
at
snares
acid
as
the
hewing
tecard
in
Eahibfi
heed
in
Eahibb
27
tin
pest),
rech
represented
by
additianal
naismas.
Par
we
meows,
Cavet
and
tredient
&
Scare,
scenes
did
eat
differ
at
aep
site
amasg
the
Ieee
versiess
at
Appesdbr
Table
1’.
“H
Atteibatea”
MWH
Attributes
-
High
tettateca”
River
Eohtbit
37
(is
part):
Eahibtt
37
(Ic
part):
Ft
t
t
Eahtbit
37
(te
pare):
F
t
V
Stroem
Name
MitC
Eahibig
6
Attributes
Feb28.
Attachment
5(rn
buhibit
6
Att46eh28.
Allenhsreeth(is
Eahiblt
Attributes
Peb2S-
Attanhmeetttçn
bahtbit
ftc
(a
a
evil
p
(a
a
eat
-
g54t
pafl(
at
affidavit
lilinais
River
2421
05.6
60%
0650
3.0
3.0
3.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
b.fl
Ittleals
Ricer
2433
fit
6
4606
46.56
30
3.0
tamale
Rrver
246.5
705
732/0
7250
60
6.0
2476
61.0
50,60
6)00
60
6.0
6.0
2514
60.0
05,26
6026
40
4.0
4.0
266
1
600
56.79
00.76
50
5.0
9.0
2650
54.6
5376
54.75
30
3.0
3.0
2660
60,0
00041
57,60
40
4.0
4.0
271.1
5g5
87.0
6655
90
9.0
6.0
2735
570
5700
0700
50
50
5.0
274.0
46.0
45_So
45.50
70
20
2_fl
2754
38.0
57.06
09.00
20
2.0
2.0
2765
61,6
60,79
91
76
30
3.0
3.0
2790
670
65.06
6800
dO
4.0
4.0
2839
335
3405
35.60
10
1.0
1.0
2658
815
8106
6106
50
5.0
5.0
40
050/1.00
050/1h0
050/ISO
2.0
0.431071
6,261957
0204087
Changers
the
Riffle
mdcc
aed
Rigs
lsfluesoe
Aoribctrs
and
Relies
ameng
each
at
the
Exhibits
resented
data
entry
errars
that
were
carseuted
tar
the
final
version
(Attochmeel
5).
20
014/043
014/043
0
1dt043
4.0
0461120
040/120
040/120
2.0
033/003
033/053
033/083
6.0
000/200
05012.00
000/200
4.0
040/120
0461120
0401120
00
020/020
020/020
020/020
4.5
0331150
0331100
0331100
Efl
067/267
067/267
067/297
0_fl
067/267
067/267
0.67/2.67
5.0
0601200
050/200
0.90/2.00
40
0201100
020/100
020/tOO
60
1501459
1501400
1001450
20
03310,95
0.22/044
0.231044
Change
in
the
High
leflueene
Attributes
end
Relics
emusg
each
a?
the
Exhorts
reflected
date
entry
seers
that
were
narrented
tar
the
fled
verswn
(Attuabmeet
5).
70
7,0
7.0
150/500
160/500
100/500
60
9.0
60
575/220
075/225
679/225
3.0
3.0
30
0.5011.25
*
76/1.60
0.0010.25
Change
in
the
Rifile
mettle
end
High
Isfinenne
Attributes
and
Relics
among
each
or
the
Exhibits
reflected
data
entry
errors
that
were
retreated
tsr
the
tisal
versics
(Attanhereet
5).
3.0
30
30
0291071
6261071
0261071
30
30
30
0.22/066
0.11/044
6,11/044
Charge
in
the
Riffle
metrIc
and
High
Influence
Attributes
end
Ratiss
among
each
at
the
Exhibits
retlected
data
entry
errors
that
were
cerrected
tar
the
Oral
verstee
(Attachment
6).
50
50
00
060/165
066/1
60
060/I
60
6.0
60
60
6,6041,50
5
50d2.0fl
05012.00
Chaege
in
the
Riffle
metxrc
and
High
Influence
9/tributes
and
Relies
among
cache)
the
Exhibits
serrated
data
entry
errors
that
were
corrected
tar
the
final
aers’xe
(Attachenest
B).
Illinois
Ricer
liliseis
Ricer
Illinois
Roes
Illinois
Roes
tllievis
Roer
ltlieais
Ricer
Des
Ptaieas
Ricer
Des
Plaieeo
Rrxer
Des
Plaisos
River
Des
Plaises
River
Des
Pteiees
River
Des
Plumes
Ricer
Des
Plaises
Rrver
“MWH
Attributes-
Moderate
tettoesre”
Exhibit
27
(In
part):
Vereise
=
Deep
CHEf
Attenhseest
B
(in
Attnibutee
Peb2t-
part)
ci
affidavit
60
“Mod/tied
Ce
WesewaterAftetbute
Retise
Exhibit
37
(is
part)m
Pied
Veraioo
=
Exhibit
B
Deep
t2REI
Afteibutre
Altexhmenl
Beessee
tsr
Scsrtsg
Diseropoectee
emoeg
Versions
Feb2S-0S.pdt
pafl)
at
agmdavit
0.50/1.75
0.50/1.75
0.50/1.75
Car
Plaices
Ricer
Des
Ptaiers
River
Chicags
Chicago
Saeitesy
Ship
Ceeal
(had
bees
coded
as
Des
Pleises
Ricer)
Des
Plabses
Ricer
Des
Pticcss
Rices
36
1.0
is
to
60
2.0
to
i.s
00
00
00
10
tO
10
10
1.0
to
to
to
io
10
10
10
10
10
tO
10
tO
so
10
10
10
10
10
10
to
is
to
00
05
00
20
20
20
as
to
is
5.0
to
50
20
26
20
3.0
3.0
30
20
20
20
3.6
3.0
30
to
20
to
60
og
60
iS
10
10
50
00
50
1.0
00
00
DesPlaineeRicer
2903
98.6
622/5
01.09
40
40
45
20
20
20
Greet
Croeh
01
856
52.50
52,60
4.0
3.0
3.5
2.0
1
0
1.0
40
4.0
2.0
2.0
2.0
2.0
4.0
4.0
30
30
6.0
60
40
4.0
0.0
00
40
4.0
6.0
6.0
s_fl
6.0
90
60
4.0
4.0
6.0
6.0
20
20
2579
21.0
20.00
25.90
2090
45.0
45.00
48.00
2900
44,0
4500
45.50
2001
655
6050
5850
2970
SOt)
5406
83.00
Illinois
River
268.0
60.0
(lenPlemeeowrr
2050
016
RI
50
RI
50
175
Don
Flames
Roar
2070
21 0
20.00
21.00
1
Chicago
Chicago
Sanoary
Ship
Canal
(had
bean
ceded
an
Des
Flames
River)
Eok)klt
37
(In
ped(m
Final
Varsien
a
Eohib)t
S
gasp
OHM
Metrics
Anechmeri
A (in
EatribdIg
FaIa2a-E5.pdf
pad)
of
aihdaxii
S
10-)o(
‘Riporarrmeirc
ononccinnen
incnnecinchalohibbccaioeoi
computer
progiem
cci
ecoring
noes
cock
eeparoini(c
nine
ShruV
moire
001
pinned
dorng
dais
proehcg,
cia
mi
cieanip
ha
ii
ioekn
an
liii
a
checked
nnncnnnea
copy
olEehibO
7.
ida
nnpieim
charged
in
scorn
010.6)
Ripaean
maico
icon
scorn
wan
irc000ci
ne
Exlrihc
hcaoauna
ol
computer
prngiarrtl
noi
ncedng
each
bach
eaparaiely
Change
an
the
50ooT
maidc
beiween
)hrnd
roperle
roflecin
change
iciho
imperarided
nuccompoconi
01
poet
metro
Thin
man
conaci
no
ongina)
raped
)Echib
is),
ircnrmcily
wISed
(or
the
roped
on
Eehibd
37
Noce
checked)
ard
changed
back
flora”
unoheckedi
for
the
Fine)
Vernon
I
00-10)
Ripenan
metric
anon
soote
man
incorrect
on
Eehibi(
37
bocaonr
el
oempuier
pingrom
rol
sesim)irg
meornum
seece
ie
10
Ctrerge
in
ihn
“Fool”
moire
haiweac
three
mpeds
rnloein
charge
in (ho
imp00000d
nehcmmpena’rt
ot p00)
metro
Ties
mae
correct
en
nnginai
roped
)Eehihd
5),
ircomacfly
ndi)ad
(or
ice
roped
on
Euhibi)
37
(“None”
chackod)
and
chaogad
beck
(“(done”
ecchocksd(
(or
the
Fire)
Version.
Cherge
in
the
Rose
moire
among
eeoc
of
ho
Eehibi)n
snfacted
data
entry
0mm
that
mom
corrected
0
tO.
)fo
Ripener
rmtcc
roan
seem
oee
ircomec)
or
Echibrl
c
haceoen
computer
progmrs
not
ncenng
eecc
bark
oapemteiy
Charge
in
the
“Feel”
metro
beiuroen
thee
repels
reflects
charge
in
(ha
impeuoded
schcompenen)
nI
poet
caine
This
man
cneooi
on
ongixe)
roped
(hchibd
6),
i000irnct)y
edited
(or
the
mpxd
on
Eehibd
37
(“None”
oheeked)
ard
charged
back
rNoamof
eroheckedi
fem
the
Firal
Version
010-56)
Ripacen
metoc
moo
seem
eras
inceisoci
en
Eulubit
b
bahuusn
compeier
pmgmm
ret
scecrg
aech
bark
sapaeaieiy
Clianga
km
iha
“Peer
meine
bniwonn
iheee
repeds
rnllecis
change
in
ihn
imporanded
nuboomporeed
e)
—
maine
The
wee
ccrsexl
ee
argira)
roped
)Exhibl
5),
incemecdy
edited
bribe
roped
en
Echibd
37
(“None”
chocked)
end
charged
back
flono”
aneheckodt
(or
the
Fine)
Version.
0(0-
)R)
Ripener
ma)mic
wee
score
wan
reenact
on
Eehibd
0
beoaunn
compeine
pmgrem
eel
sceong
each
bark
sapaaeieiy
Change
in
he
“Peer
meidc
ba)eeen
three
mpeds
raflecin
change
in
(he
enpeanded
subeempecrari
o(
pee)
metro
The
eras
cooed
en
cogmet
sep00
)Eehibd
0).
meoonndg
ndknd
(or
(ha
roped
or
Exhibit
31
rhbono”hhacead(
and
charged
back
(“Nerof
urohecked(
for
(he
Fire)
Vemion
0
(5.
)6(
Ripenen
moicc
005
seem
em
incomac(
on
Eehib(
5
beceusa
eamputer
prngme
not
sccnrg
each
beck
sayamieiy
Chongo
1
ice
“Peer
maims
beieeeo
000a
raprols
inflocto
change
an
the
impounded
subcompereoi
of
peal
melrc.
lion
anon
curroci
on
originot
ropod
(Exhibit
6).
ineonao)ly
edited
for
iho
mpeg
on
hckici(
31
(“clone”
checked)
and
changed
bach
(“nIece”
aroheoked)
(or
(he
Fire)
Vemien.
0.10-16)
Change
in
the
“Pee)”
me)nc
boi000n
three
mpedo
moods
charga
in
(ho
“ronof
under
the
carronl
subcompenor)
of
pee)
ma)dc
and
data
entry
eirnm
that
mom
eogecled.
The
mas
ireorreot
en
original
roped
(Echibil
b(
becauua
ol
gala
enby
errors,
incornoxily
edited
(en
the
mpeg
en
hohibi)
31
rPbona”
cheeknd(
aed
changed
back
(“bore”
unchecked)
(or
the
Firat
Version
I
so-
8)
Charge
in
(he
Riperor
Metre
reflects
a
dote
eh(ry
ener
reflected
in best
roport
(Fchibd
0)
that
em
hoed
in Erhibi(
37
end
the
Firoi
Version
Chenge
in
ecem
(or
Foe)
mfee)s
change
in
pmgmm
to
)imi(u
meeimum
0001
00010
(012.0
0.10-
)6(
Change
in
the
Riparian
Melne
reflects
e
date
entry
000r
reoec(nd
0
cmi
roped
)Eohicd
b(
that
roes
(died
xc
Eehibmt
37
and
the
Final
Ve,’mon
C
harge
in
the
“Peer
metro
boioean
thee
epeos
ro)iec)n
change
io
time
impourdad
nuboompenert
of
peel
ma)nc
This
roan
conoci
no
engine)
reped
(hchibd
b).
inconoctly
odded
(or
the
roped
en
Echibd
37
(“None”
ehecked(
and
ehan5oe
bacc
l”None”
unnheekedi
(or
(he
Fine)
Version
5(0’
(b)
Ripenan
meidc
wan
room
man
inceereci
00
Ecbibii
5
becausn
computar
program
eel
e0000g
each
bark
neperotaip
Change
in
the
“Peer
metre
beimeoo
three
repeOa
roiiex)s
charge
in
ha
impounded
naboompeneot
nI
pool
nettle
This
mao
correct
on
ongirai
mpeg
(Exhibit
b),
incomeccy
egdnd
(or
the
mpeg
on
Eohibi(
37
(“bore”
chocked
(and
ehargna
hack
(“north
urcheokog(
(es
(he
Fine(
Version.
010-10)
Charge
in
the
“Poor
mainc
betrouar
throa
ropods
schools
cbargm
‘nice
enpmaogad
nubcompcoeni
01
pool
mninic
and
a
gala
eniry
eirnr.
This
roes
reenact
on
ongina)
mpeg
)Eohibii
5.
‘01mW
not
chesked(.
mcorredoy
ed(ed
(or (ho
loped
00
Einubi(
37
(“sore”
checked)
crag
changed
back
(“None”
unehoeixed
end
“51mg’
checked(
(or
the
Finet
Vernon.
5.10-
)6(
Rip
anon
metric
man
500m
man
incoimei
en
Exhibit
S
bocauss
computer
pmgmm
not
eoonog
each
cork
eepamlely.
Changain
ice
“Peel”
melee
bnimeer
three
ropela
rnflou)e
ohange
in
(ha
impeundad
nuboempeono)
of pool
mettle.
Thin
men
cemeci
em
onginai
roped
(Exhibit
5).
inconacily
edi(ed
(er)he
raped
on
Eohthil
37
(“Nona”
chrokod(
and
cherigag
hack
)“(dara”
uncheeksd(
(or
(he
Fine)
Vnrsion
I
00-
(0)
Ripadan
metro
macseem
aces
irc0000)
on Exhibit
b
because
computes
pmgmm
was
net
ecerng
“Vary
Wale”
bark
correctly
0
(0-
(6)
Chennot
metre
ores
ncoro
ores
reenact
or
hohibi(
S
because
of
dote
nr)sy
aishT
cooroci
00
hohibi)
37cM
Final
Varsieo
Change
in
the
‘Fool”
metre
balween
tines
mpeds
sheets
change
in
the
impounded
suboempeneot
of
peat
metro
Thk
eves
caomx(
on
engine)
ropes
)Eohihii
5),
irconeciiy
ed(ad
(or
Ice
roper
en
Exhibit
37
(“0000”
checked)
end
changed
back
)“None
anehnckrd)
Icr
the
Fine)
Version.
I
(IT-tOt
0(0
- )R(
Charge
in
(he
“Poor
mo)no
beiwean
lhroa
rapegs
rooeals
chemgo
or
the
impounded
suhoompmren(
oO
pool
maine
resumes
correct
00
eeginai
ropeg
(Eokibi)
5(,
incoinncily
added
(or
(he
report
en
Eidubd
37
rNone”
oheuked)
end
changed
bask
(“((one’
uochrckeg(
(or
(hr
Final
Versoe.
000-6)
Chenge
me
the
“Poor
me)nc
hntoeoen
thee
ropegn
m)oclu
change
in
the
impourdeg
suboompenent
o(
pool
mettle.
This
cors
000ec(oe
oogioai
mpeg
(Eohib’)
5),
incerroc)ly
edited
far
(he
roped
en
Exhibit
37
flene”
nhoeked)
ord
ehorged
hook
(“None”
unebeckedl
(or
(he
Finn)
Voiroon
0(0-
)R)
DiPerooca
in
(he
Chernor
metro
seom
compared
in Eohibr)
37
compered
ie
Eohihi(
N
or
Fmal
Report
omen
data
coned
error
Ripener
meiox
mao
scom
men
incerreci
on
ExhibitS
beoause
computer
pmgrom
re(
ocoeng
each
kook
separably
Change
in
the
“Feol”
motne
be)e.mon
them
mpego
rehacls
charge
in
the
mmpeordad
ecbeomporaoi
of
peat
mettle
This
oae
xonea(
an
engina(
roped
)Eohibg
N),
incorrectly
ndited
(or
(he
roper)
on
Oehibrl
37
rswre”
checked)
end
changed
back
(“(done”
anohexkcgi
(or
the
PinO
Version
01-
lOt
1.00-
(0)
Ripenan
metric
man
scere
roes
iooaneu
on
Eehibi(
31
bnoeese
of
comeiger
nrooorm
nor sestdctmro
maeoruor
soere
to
10
010
-(0)
Subotrota
maIne
seem
on
Eahihl)
6)65)eias
incemee)
bneeuea
01
dote
entry
emer
Rip
elan
mn)ne
roes
seem
was
incameci
or
ExbEg
37
boeeusa
of
compa(nr
program
ret
me(rc(mg
macroars
scoro
to
(0.
Chenga
mica
l’oor
metro
betwsen
Exhibit
band
Eniebi)
37
and
Ice
Final
Vnrsor
ices
des
to
a
data
entry
amer
thai
crab
conentsg
S.tO-)0)
C
haeoel
maircin
Echmbil
N
roilecied
)edcro
Ia
chaek”lmpeundeg”
nelactien
Riparan
metro
man
score
ices
income)
on
Eehibi)
37
beneune
et
enmyater
pogrom
not
restricting
manimurs
500m
le
(0
Charga
in
lbs
‘Poor
moIre
be)roear
lhron
rspamts
rofeets
change
rica
mnrpeecaed
nubeempexari
ol
peel
moine
erd
data
entry
amer.
This
roan
ircoireci
en
onginat
mpeg
lflahibi)
5,
“Oloac”
ret
checked),
inoornext)y
edited
for
the
mpeg
or
Eigribm(
31
(“Nero”
chackag)
and
changed
beck
(“None”
unoheckoa
end
“Sleeo”
checked)
fee
the
Final
Version
-Qopi”
“Oassleatth
“tracer”
EeMbR
37(10
paet(m
Final
Verolase
Ealrdbit
0
Deep
QHEI
Metrics
Aflaehment
A
(10
Fa528-E5.pdf
par)
of
athdaxr(
15.0
ISP
(55
(6.0
160
(40
(4.0
‘Tikenmel”
“Riperhso”
“Riser
ExkIMI
37
(In
pert3m
Final
Versiase
MI(a”
Eak(bhI
b
Denp
QHEI
Melons
Ageebmeni
A
(in
Fa528-et,pdf
pee)
01
ellidacit
0
0
or
2d2(
N55
8550
0050
SromRea
2433
o)o
4650
49611
I)
R
2460
ISmO
7550
laep
I
eRoex
2470
RIO
0050
61513
III
0
201
a
SEO
052k
$625
Illmooe
Rivor
2b0.t
60.8
6075
60.75
(5.0
150
“Fear
(00
160
“Dregienl
S
beeea”
irs
(70
(To
(TO
(liroin
Ricor
2660
54.0
0070
Den
Flames
Near
273
b
57.0
5700
b7
00
(0.0
Des
Flames
Ricer
274.0
400
gobS
Don
Plaicos
Rican
2764
30.0
37.00
Sproagshset
I
Compannon
of
COOl
blab
scomn
fillET)
endeac
S
c(
seeorol
metro
neoms
)o
g ,
“Nabsimul
a”(amon
g
icree
gireroxl
uemmcns
01
(he
tabln
Imiled,
‘Aypordo
Tabin
1 “
“Apperdox
fabln
5”
deymels
DOE)
dole
collected
by
Midroani Biedmaaomly
instiluta
in
lilnois
Ricer,
Doe
Plemrso
Ricem,
and
Drort
Croak
in
2000
Colemnc
hmghlmghbad
in
groy
mndixe)e
oconno
dmocrop 000maoa
0
crgaamionn
.
For
the
total
Cebi
00050
(“DOEI”(
00
g
or
each
CfiEi
comnp
0000)melne
(o
0 -
‘Smabn)m)e’,
“Coven,
the
nooms
mc
Ihe
cclumr,
“Fmral
Veroion,’
mproaact
1k
ameelaccu
lola
seems.
Ton
prooi
Service
List
for
R08-9
Elizabeth
Schenkier
Keith
Harley
Chicago
Legal
Clinic,
Inc.
205
W.
Monroe,
4
th
Floor
Chicago,
IL 60606
Susan M.
Franzetti
Nij
man
Franzetti
LLP
10 South
LaSalle
St.
Ste.
3600
Chicago,
IL 60603
Katherine
D. Hodge
Monica
Rios
MatthewC.
Read
Hodge
Dwyer
Zeman
3150
Roland
Ave.
P.O.
Box
5776
Springfield,
IL 62702
John Therriault,
Assistant
Clerk
Illinois
Pollution
Control
Board
James
R.
Thompson
Center
100
West
Randolph,
Ste 11-500
Chicago,
IL
60601
Susan
Hedman
Andrew
Armstrong
Office
of the
Attorney
General
Environmental
Bureau
North
69
West
Washington
Street,
Suite
1800
Chicago,
IL
60602
Jeffrey
C.
Fort
Ariel
J.
Tesher
Sonnenschein
Nath
&
Rosenthal
LLP
7800
Sears
Tower
233
S.
Wacker
Drive
Chicago,
IL
60606-6404
Ann
Alexander
Senior
Attorney,
Midwest
Program
Natural
Resources
Defense
Council
101
North Wacker
Dr., Ste.
609
Chicago,
IL
60606
Fredrick
M.
Feldman
Ronald
M.
Hill
Margaret
T. Conway
Metropolitan
Water
Reclamation
District
of
Greater
Chicago
111
East Erie
Street
Chicago,
IL
60611
William
Richardson,
Chief
Legal
Counsel
Illinois
Department
of Natural
Resources
One
Natural
Resources
Way
Springfield,
IL
62705-5776
Marie
Tipsord,
Hearing
Officer
Illinois
Pollution
Control
Board
James
R.
Thompson
Center
100 West
Randolph,
Ste
11-500
Chicago,
IL 60601
Albert
Ettinger,
Senior
Staff
Attorney
Jessica
Dexter
Environmental
Law
& Policy
Center
35
E.
Wacker
Dr.,
Suite
1300
Chicago,
IL 60601
Jennifer
A. Simon
Kevin Desharnais
Thomas
W.
Dimond
Thomas
V.
Skinner
Mayer
Brown
LLP
71
South
Wacker
Drive
Chicago,
IL
60606-4637
Service
List
for R08-9
Continued
Fredric
P.
Andes
Carolyn
S.
Hesse
David T. Ballard
Barnes
&
Thornburg
LLP
One North Wacker
Drive
Suite 4400
Chicago, IL 60606
Kristy A.N. Bulleit
Brent Fewell
Hunton
&
Williams
LLC
1900
K Street,
NW
Washington,
DC 20006
Marc
Miller
Office of the Lt. Governor,
Pat
Quinn
Room
414
State
House
Springfield, IL 62706
Cathy
Hudzik
City of Chicago,
Mayor’s
Office of
Intergovernmental
Affairs
121 North
LaSalle Street
City
Hall Room
406
Chicago,
Illinois 60602
Stacy
Meyers-Glen
Openlands
25
E. Washington,
Ste. 1650
Chicago,
IL
60602
Jack Darin
Cindy
Skrukrud
Sierra
Club,
Illinois
Chapter
70 East Lake
Street, Ste
1500
Chicago,
IL
60601
Traci Barkley
Prairie
Rivers
Network
1902 Fox Drive,
Suite 6
Champaign,
Illinois 61820
Lyman
C.
Welch
Alliance
for the Great
Lakes
17
North State Street,
Suite 1390
Chicago,
Illinois 60602
STATE
OF ILLINOIS
)
)
SS
COUNTY
OF
SANGAMON
)
)
PROOF OF
SERVICE
I, the undersigned,
on oath state
that I have
served the attached
Affidavit of
Mr.
Chris
0.
Yoder upon the
person
to whom
it is directed
by
placing it an
envelope
addressed
to:
John
Therriault, Clerk
Marie Tipsord,
Hearing
Officer
Illinois
Pollution
Control Board
James
R.
Thompson
Center
100
West
Randolph Street,
Suite 11-500
Chicago,
Illinois
60601
SEE
ATTACHED
SERVICE LIST
and
mailing it First Class
Mail from
Springfield, Illinois
on September
17, 2008, with
sufficient
postage affixed.
SUBSCRffiED AND
SWORI’ TO
BEFORE ME
This
day of
hi4008
3iI
ôe{
Notary
Public
OFFICIAL
SEAL
:
BRENDA
SOEIiNER
t
:MYcoMusj
NOTARY
PIJBUC,
EXPIRES
STATE
OF
1142Oog
ILLINOIS
)
THIS
FILING IS SUBMITTED
ON
RECYCELD
PAPER
