ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
FOX MORAINE, LLC
)
)
Petitioner,
)
)
v.
)
)
UNITED CITY OF YORKVILLE, CITY )
COUNCIL
)
)
Respondent.
)
PCB No. 07-146
(Pollution Control Facility Siting
Appeal)
MOTION TO DISMISS
Respondent, the United City of Yorkville ("Yorkville"), by its attorneys and pursuant to
415 ILCS 5/39.2(n) and 35 Ill. Admin. Code 107.502(b), hereby requests that the Pollution
Control Board dismiss Petitioner's ("Fox Moraine") Petition for Review for its failure to pay
costs of preparing and certifying the record of proceedings below. In support of its Motion,
Yorkville states as follows:
BACKGROUND
1.
On June 27, 2007, Fox Moraine filed a petition asking the Board to review a
decision by Yorkville denying Fox Moraine'sproposed siting of a landfill within Yorkville.
2.
By order dated July 12, 2007, the Board accepted Fox Moraine's petition for
hearing, noting that, "Petitioner must pay to Yorkville the cost of preparing and certifying the
record," citing 415 ILCS 5/39.2(n) and 35 Ill. Admin. Code 107.306 and 107.502(b). (The
Board's7/12/07 Order is attached as Exhibit A.)
3.
The record in this matter is voluminous, running 19,897 pages. Board rules state
that, "Seven copies of the transcript and one original and 9 copies of all other documents in the
record must be filed with the Board." 35 Ill. Admin. Code 107.304(c).
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
4.
To save significant time and expense and to reduce the amount of paper filed with
the Board, Yorkville sought relief from the filing requirements and proposed filing one paper
copy
of the record along with a disk. Fox Moraine agreed with the filing of the motion. (Acopy
of Yorkville'smotion is attached as Exhibit B.)
5.
The Board granted the motion in part, directing Yorkville to file an original and
two paper copies
of the record and one disk. (A copy of the Board's 8/9/07 Order is attached as
Exhibit C.) The Board's ruling meant that only approximately 20 percent
of the otherwise
required amount
of paper was filed with the Board (two, instead of seven, copies of the
transcript, and two, instead
of nine, copies of all other documents were filed with the Board.
This saved the cost
of filing over an additional 110,000 pages with the Board, which, at $0.08
per page, the cost charged by Yorkville'soutside vendor, would have been $8,800.)
6.
As petitioner, Fox Moraine is required to the cost of preparing and certifying the
record of the proceedings below. The Environmental Protection Act specifically provides:
In any review proceeding
of a decision of the county board or governing body of
a municipality made pursuant to the local siting review process, the petitioner in
the review proceeding shall pay to the county or municipality the cost
of
preparing and certifying the record of proceedings. Should the petitioner in the
review proceeding fail to make payment, the provisions of Section 3-109 of the
Code of Civil Procedure shall apply.
415 ILCS 5/39.2(n).
See also
35 Ill. Admin. Code 107.306 ("petitioner must pay the costs of
preparing and certifying the record to the Board.")
7.
Section 3-109 of the Code of Civil Procedure further provides:
If the statute under authority of which the administrative decision was entered
provides or requires that the plaintiff in the review proceeding shall pay to the
agency the costs of preparing and certifying the record of proceedings before the
agency, the failure to make that payment
...
shallbe authority for the entry of
an order
by the court, on motion therefor by the agency or any other defendant,
dismissing the complaint.
2
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
735 ILCS 5/3-109 (emphasis added).
See also
35 Ill. Admin. Code I07.502(b) ("Upon motion
by
any unit of local government that is required to prepare and certify its record alleging that any
petitioner required to pay costs
of preparing and certifying the record of the proceedings has
failed to pay those costs, the Board may enter a dismissal or other order
as allowed by Section
39.2(n)
ofthe Act.")
8.
Yorkville, through its attorneys, engaged the services of an outside vendor, C
2
Legal, to assist it in preparing the record. C
2
Legal scanned the documents in the record and
made disks and paper copies. C
2
Legal'sinvoices for its services total $6,282.96. (A copy of C
2
Legal's invoices is attached as Exhibit D.)
9.
On September 5, 2007, Yorkville provided the invoices to Fox Moraine and
requested payment.
(See
~
4 of Attorney Dombrowski Affidavit, attached as Exhibit E.) Fox
Moraine did not pay.
10.
On April 24, 2008, Yorkville again requested payment. As of the date of this
motion, Fox Moraine still has refused to pay.
(See
~
5 of Dombrowski Affidavit.)
11.
Fox Moraine should have paid these costs of preparing the record six months ago.
It
has stalled long enough, and the Board should dismiss Fox Moraine's petition for review for
failure to pay these costs of preparing the record.
3
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
WHEREFORE. Respondent, United City of Yorkville, respectfully requests that the
Pollution Control Board grant its motion and enter an order dismissing this appeal, and for
further relief as the Hearing Officer deems
just and fair.
Respectfully submitted,
UNITED CITY OF YORKVILLE, CITY
COUNCIL
By:
lsi
Leo P. Dombrowski
One of their Attorneys
Dated: May
1, 2008
Anthony G. Hopp
Thomas
1.
Matyas
Leo P. Dombrowski
WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON LLP
225 West Wacker Drive
Chicago, Illinois 60606
Telephone:
(312) 201-2000
Facsimile:
(312) 201-2555
hopp@wildman.com
matyas@wildman.com
dombrowski@wildman.com
4
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
EXHIBIT A
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
July
12,2007
FOX MORAINE, LLC,
Petitioner,
v.
UNITED CITY OF YORKVILLE, CITY
COUNCIL
Respondent.
ORDER OF THE BOARD (by G.T. Girard):
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
PCB 07-146
(pollution Control Facility
Siting Appeal)
On June
27,2007, Fox Moraine, LLC (petitioner) timely filed a petition asking the Board
to review a May 24, 2007 decision
of United City of Yorkville City Council (Yorkville).
Yorkville'sdecision concerns petitioner'sproposed siting
of a pollution control facility in
Yorkville, Kendall County. For the reasons below, the Board accepts petitioner'spetition for
hearing.
Under the Environmental Protection Act (Act) (415 ILCS
5/1
et seq.
(2006)), before the
Illinois Environmental Protection Agency can issue a permit to develop
or construct a new or
expanding pollution control facility, the permit applicant must obtain siting approval for the
proposed facility from the local government
(i.e.,
the county board if in an unincorporated area
or the governing body of the municipality if in an incorporated area). If the local government
denies siting or approves siting with conditions, the siting applicant may appeal the local
government'sdecision to the Board.
See
415 ILCS 5/39(c), 40.1 (a) (2006); 35 Ill. Adm. Code
107.
In this case, Yorkville denied petitioner's application to site a pollution control facility in
Yorkville. Petitioner appeals on the grounds that Yorkville'sdecision
was fundamentally unfair
and the findings on criteria
i,
ii, iii,
v, vi, vii, and ix
(see
415 ILCS 5/39.2 (2006)) were against
the manifest weight
of the evidence. Petitioner'spetition meets the content requirements of 35
Ill. Adm. Code 107.208.
The Board accepts the petition for hearing. Petitioner has the burden
of proof. 415 ILCS
5/40.1 (a) (2006);
see also
35 Ill. Adm. Code 105.506. Hearings will be based exclusively on the
record before Yorkville. Accordingly, though the Board hearing affords petitioner the
opportunity to challenge the local government's reasons for its decision, information developed
after the local government'sdecision typically
is not admitted at hearing or considered by the
Board. However,
if relevant, evidence may be introduced on (1) the local government's
jurisdiction over the siting application and (2) the fundamental fairness
of the procedures used by
the local government in reaching its decision.
See
415 ILCS 5/40.1(a) (2006); Land
&
Lakes v.
PCB, 319 Ill. App. 3d 41, 48, 743 N.E.2d 188, 194 (3d Dist. 2000).
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
2
Hearings will be scheduled and completed in a timely manner, consistent with the
decision deadline
(see
415 ILCS 5/40. 1(a) (2006», which only petitioner may extend by waiver
(see
35 Ill. Adm. Code 107.504; 35 Ill. Adm. Code 101.308). If the Board fails to take final
action by the decision deadline, the petitioner "may deem the site location approved." 4151LCS
5/40.1(a) (2006). Currently, the decision deadline
is October 25,2007 (the 120th day after June
27,2007). See
35 Ill. Adm. Code 107.504. The Board meeting immediately before the decision
deadline is scheduled for October 18, 2007.
Yorkville must file the entire record of its proceedings within 21 days after the date of
this order.
See
35 Ill. Adm. Code 107.302. The record must comply with the content and
certification requirements
of35 Ill. Adm. Code 107.304,107.308. Petitioner must pay to
Yorkville the cost of preparing and certifying the record.
See
415 ILCS 5/39.2(n) (2006); 35 Ill.
Adm. Code 107.306, 107.502(b).
IT IS SO ORDERED.
I, John T. Therriault, Assistant Clerk
of the Illinois Pollution Control Board, certify that
the Board adopted the above order on July 12,2007, by a vote of 4-0.
John T. Therriault, Assistant Clerk
Illinois Pollution Control Board
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
EXHIBITB
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
'. " .'
.' ..
.~
..
": :"
.:.
.
-:
,~
-
•••• I
~;
'\-.
••
~'.'
:- .. ;.: t•.;
"~'.
'.
....
' ...'
'.
. '.', .
.'
.. '..:': " ., ..
' .. '.
'. '... ' .
. '. ;...... ,. .
:'.~.
....
:..... '.' -'..'
:.' ... '
'
..
..
' ..
'.
~..
.;",
:' ..
",
.
.' .' '.
~'
.
. .
~.
. . :
.....
' .. ' ..'
.. '
~.
:"~'.'
.
' ...'
.'.
,.I'
'.';
.
.' ..
. .:':."
. .'. '.'
;.: ...
,.:.
..'
..
..-
.. ' .
.
~
,
:
.
." .'.;.:....
:.~
..'<."
'..
.
'. ".' '.".'. .>:
·~·~lJiSFi~ing
is.
~~b·inilt~d~~ l®~PQ~.t-~·~~~~~er::Re·~YC)~~·.pa~~~
.:.'-:,.. :'.. ':'.''::'
.
•
.
• :
~..,
. .' :'::'.
..,.
." ....
t.
. ..,
.
-:.
.
.... ;.'
...
~
.
.' ;.
.'
. ,',
.:•... "
'.
~':'
"
'.
.,'.
...
.;
.:
~
..
~
....
.
"~
.. ;"
"
.......
;
. ;.' ','
-
'.~.
..•• :, . .
I•
.........
,';'
." '..
.' .
. ,
.
. ..
, '.
. '.' :':,
......
.....
.....
....
'.
.~.'
. "
'.
" ..
.
~.
. .
::'
.'..
.
:.'~
...
~
",- .. -
.....>:.....
..,'
~
.. :.; .. :.. :-.
::.,:'.'
... ' .: /". ,...':
,.':SEllORETI:IE .:;:: :, .'
"'REeElv" ;."':.'.,
'.:'
...... <.'.-:'.'
.:.:ILLI,NOIS
POLLy'qONGQ~~'T~()L'~OARI)"
:CLERKIS'OFF~E~;~'>'
~ "~'
. ". .' .
.
.
.'
.
·~OXMQ~.~~;
'.''.':.' ;.
:·P·e~it~~nef~·
.:-:
'/i,"T'
.' .... : .. ' ) :..
':-
'
'
...•....•..
"':ST~~~ !:I~~~Ofs'>
'(
. .... ....
Pollllti<)/l Contro:! Board
. .. '.
..:.':' .:.
'.. .
...." .". . --: '." ,,: ::.),:..\0'. .'.: :. '.'
~"'.:
...::'... ..',: .
v
: ..:
.'"
'
)..
PC~No.
07)46....
..
'. '
.
....
... ".,., -::.
.. r' .
(P'ollutio.h Control Facility'Sitiiig... .; '
~
..
.....:... :.
..... :-- ... ,... , .:...."', .-,' .. -)" Appeal)"":'.: :: '. : ":: .. ' .:. :.....
.. .' ': .., ". '. . UNtiED CITY OF
Y:ORKVILL~,
"CiTY ;)....
.... ..
;..' ....
.' .
.
.....
. '.
CO~CIL;,;
::: : :
:.:~.:
.....••...:.'..::
:";')~"
.....:.:i....:.:.:: :.......:...'..:..
"....,'
',.'•••.•.•. \
,: .•
...•...•...•. ,.. '.' .
;.'. :..:....::..:::..'..,..
;:~.'.Respotid.~rif..'.··
... .
.'.....: "'.'
....
., .....
....
; :
..
:-.:
',::' :',
",
..
.':.'....
·'.'~TED'(TIy~1i'Yo~i~;s~O;I()N}lQR~L~£·
...,....•• ' •
.'.' .• '..,>, ... FROM CERTAIN:LANDFILL SITING-RECORD REQUIREMENTS' ,,: ." . .
.... .'
.. •
•
•
.:
~.
• .",.
.
" :.,
•• 0'.
.
~.
• -. ' .• " •• :. .; ",
".
i'
. .
'.:. ..' •
.': ;: '. '.. '.
:.<....;....
_. :..... :. . '1Ifl...
: ..: ".....:;'
....':..
R¢spon4~nt,
t1).e United City'of Yorkville
("Y6r~vill~~'),
by and through its" . '.
.
'."
'. '.: .
·~tto~~}rs; r~s~~ctfuII~~~·ve~:·ilie·.P·~1;luti~~.6oritr~1·B.;6~d:
~~/~rt'
~'rdet'
~~h~~g,~b~l0riiie
':'.'
:
. .. ' '; "
:'r~I'i~ffioince~ai~
;~q~i~~P1en~~:~e~a;di~~th~.p~ep~ati~~·~d
fiii~~·.·Ofthe.f~C9;d,\~.:
~"
..:,"'\'.:
...... :..
.
su~port ~fits ·~~iiO~; ~o~~vilie':~t'~tes .~ t(jll~~S:'
::.'. '. ;:'.:'.
'.
.. .'
'-:'::.. :......
:
. ..
.:. .'.
~'
:
'
'.
...
.
.;' ."
.
.'
. :. .
~.'
~
.'
'.
,'J
.' .'" ,
.. ,..
, .
•. ' .' ,.:'... ; .':'-.> •• : :' .
::'~'
. '.
'll:'.. :....:,.",
. ;:. •
..~
::'.' ,....
..' '.: ':.,. ..:'. '.
;''.
• •
"
'....;.... ...:L:....: :Thci'record'inthis.rii.atte'tisl1o'\\< due
o~l:Or
before'Augusfl6,.
i007,
~.
-;" .;;..
.... >....
..
'.'
'::·:'~:".:':""'Bo~r~
~le~~~~t~
that,
,~·Sev~n':Co~t~8~H~e·'~~n~criP~
~d: ~~~:'~r~g{~~I'an~'
.'
-; eovies
oian;'~~docum~nl~i~ lli~~o~d m~l 'e.lil~ wi~'~~ aoard;'~.
as,ut>".
". ,..•.",
."'::.
·.·~mriiii·
..
¢~~~ §:1.07.3·04(~)·:.
Bo·~r(h:uI¢~.al~~
st~~~ tha~'tPe:'re~~td"~~ti~t
b~ ~i~ce4
itt
.:... ::: .'
.......\<.: .:.'
·~ii~~l~giC~r~eq~eri~e.:·';d
..
~~ ~·~·O~7.30,4(b).·':.··:>·~
.:.> :':.'::..
::-:',.~>.':~
.'.
'>.: ":':.,.
.'." .. ''.--.
. ,
.. :,..' ., .-:,::
: ".'..
'.~:.
:'"
·:.r~e·i~c·~~d·in·~hi~·.~att~~
~s'~oiU~i~6us:
..
;I1~ la~dijir ~~Pli~:~ti~~.:~o~e'·:::,::.
~. ;~:
...... "..
. '.' :;
~ :.<.>:~
::.' :.'
:
:.::..' :-:- ,.: '..,'.:.:"
.:: .. '"
:.: , :,'..::.:.
. fills
apP:t:6~dmately
tw:o
boxe~.
yorkville
h~ld
.public hearings. 9n.23. days on the. ....
.' ". :'.
.:
c,~~::~;.~,;:;..
;,~'.~~~;.::
".
:m)11?-et~us
exliibi~s file~' 8:~ p~'
ofthe
req~rd'by
various.
p'~~SOIi~.
.;'.
Addi.~on~~~y;
tIioli~'~nds"
: .. ,'....;..'
~
..
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
....: .
.. , ..
. .
:';
.;
~.
."
.-
....
..
;~
..
. ".:;
".:."
,
.
...•
.'..
~
:. :
.
;.
.....
'.'
'. ,.,
':.'.
......
l;
.
. . ':.'
.: .
-.
r'
'" .'
.
:,.'
~
.. ' .....
,"..
..
.:.
' ..
"\
: ..
,,:
;
. ' ..
".' ," :.
"."
•• ;.. '. .
.f. •
• '". '"
.~
.-:". :..' '". ". '",':.
.~.
'._ . . •
~.
•
.'
. •
:': •. ' '.
., •
• ": •. ' '.
• '. I.'.
.. .
.
.:.
:' '; '.'
.
~.:--'
.
:.'.rif;~~e·~
of
P9~t.ihe~drik·c~ttim6~~s\~ei~~ul?¥i~ed/Y6t~ine' ~~tir~;~~esth~t~thei~~otd:',
:.::
"' ..
.' :
.. :
~
~. ···~:s~ell·o~~~.i.6~oO~·p'a~~s
··~.
:
'... .
..~.:.:
:
" ': .:,.: .'..
.
....:.:
' :
.. :. :::
.... :.... :: ,>.,:
,i-':...'
.··:·:·.:B~caus~::~f
~h~' .~~~~ '~f th~' ~e~6i~>yLk~lill~ req~~~t~ ~r~li~{~~~ '~~':~>
...
"~'.'
.' :.
. .
,
·:::n~~~~;:O.~.~oPies·~eq~ir.~~
t~ b~·'fi~e~:~~re~J~~tS"that
~t'he:~~te~~~~~~'~~:'~~
·o~~·
..
"
,
,,:::P~~t~OPYO{~¢retorda19ng\Vjfu~nedwk:F~~one~~Or~6iAtho~c~~:.~~g'
,',: "
.
:..,
,
'..with orie
diskwo~.I1d··eliminate
.ove(one
liU:ndr~d. t4ou~and
pages.of
pap~r
-to
:be
fil~d
with . .' ': :--....
','
:','
th~~~d:¥~~Jcyin~~elievesth';fi~~~r~0t4;j~
!hi~:wa;~OU1~;:();~n~,~e~,'
,.'.,',,' ,
. ..
':.:'.,:
dtotl1e.rWis-e:n~g~tiveIy·
.'
.'..
i~I;actthe.sepr~6.eedirig~b~fore:th~.B6ard.·
:
.~.
....
. .: ',.
.
~
.
'. '. "
.,..
., \.':'
:
.: .:
:.. ' .
'. :.
. ";
:.:.
. "'..
~
.'
..
.'.':
.\"'
'~.
,
.
~·.As::t9 th,~.thronol~.gic~ls~qu~n~e
. '.
",
requ~r,~e~t,'¥~tk;,iil~
". ....
.
.....
\'.
wi1i:.&~~ai~IY
"
'.
:.
file:'..
.
", ,-
.,: ':'.
.,
';: " . ,,"
...' ." "
"-. ":.:" '", '" ,,'
....
"....
" ....:
.
.'
th~'rec6id docuirientS·su.chas.th~
host.agreetti.ent,:Hmdfill
app1i~atiQn,
4eari~g fran~cnpts.,.,
." ..• :. "..:: :":
".
..,'., .:'.
"P6st-lle~g ro~~, ~~iiI'lsOfcityc~nnoil,~peci~ Mee~~ ~d
Cityc:,:cil '.•'.", "
" •
'.'
'. :,,:
':':'..
·;Re~·o~~t~~~jh.C~~dl~gf~~l.'se~~~~~~·.
H~~~ver,,~o;~il1~~~I1~:~s't~at'~~girig'~h~':
:>
~.'.<
:.:
'.
.:- ,:::.",
';(~
-;
;~~',
• .'
•••• "'.
.:'. ••••
..:.
.'
••••
0" ""
•• ' •• ,,\.
..,.:........ • ••••
."'.. :.' '.' :'.':"
a~cording
to -date
s~bmitted~"
For'example; soini.parties;s)lch as
.~endall
Countx"and .the . .' .,'....... '.
.'....
,
:'.
'~.'.:
Vlll~~~·ifP.t~~mieid,
sU~~itt~d ~~~ibi~s·m6r~~h~n·:~nc~·an~·~~~di~fe~~~t.~ates
..
,~
.... "
.. ,.''.'::'.',
-:..":"
..
.' ....::.
·There~or~;.·YO;~il~·~~~~:
i~~ ;~~~ef'~~I~
t~~ ~hro.~~IO~lC~l-s~q~~nChig
r.e~~i;~~~~t
.fo~
;
'~.'
".
","..
•
,"..•• '
••
•
• '.
", •
...."
~
"0.
• ..••
': • •••••
.'. ". ':
"
.~:::
'. :..... <:, '.these'
exI1ib~ts:·,~,.>
~.'
:~.
'. .. '.:. ';':'0: "':
,<,;<. ":. :
.... '. ....':
~.:.:'::
':....;."...<;.
.
.-:,. .' . .:.: ': .':
". ::. :'
:
6. :.".
;·:.:Ptiri:rt~.th~
t~lePh~ni~·.~t'~;ti~·
co~~~ren6~ ~n.
jury. l's,
:2901;G~~rge
M~e'~le{
"::. .
. ".
.
':.": ..':: .,.
..
':"~a~time~'
~~r:~~t;iiO~~;'FO~
'M~r~in~~"i~~i~:ated:'~h~t:;~X
~~i~~~ ·4ad··n~ ~bJeeti~n: i~:.mi~
' :
,
.
•
'.'.: • •••• .): ",,;':,:.
:
~"":.:,
• :.' .' • .......'
• :.
,';
: '
:
"
> .' •
• ..:.,
-', :.' '.
•
•
• •• '"
'".' ."
:
. -' .
~>.,
.: .:'.'
: ..',. : .. '..
~
.:.
.' ",...
. ';'.
..' '.
. .
........;..
.:' ..M..':t.:"':-::.",' '
,
.,,'.. ' '.
. :
: ;. '.:.'.': . ..
.;.
.
"', ". ":.:.,:
.,o.
..
:..
. .' .. OI9n:.:
:'.
i ,." ....
.... .....
". '. '.'
.~
;
; ..• "','
: ..;... '. '.:.-;' .. ;.
. ..
....:. ".
> , ..
• •
• .0..
•••••
'••• '. •
e.
": oW
• '.' .. .:• .":.
" •••• ':;.:
• :.:.
'~':'
•
.'.
.,•• ", ".:'- "
: :::' •
•
:"'~
:., ;:".
::.
" .' .. '
'.
,,", ' •• 0"
• '.: • ::
~.~'
••••• "
• .;...
.i......
.".~
- .
'", ':.
.;
'~""
".'
....
~
..
~
.....
":," '..:'
~'. ~". ~.
.f. ' ..,
.:";.':':
.....:.
.' '.-
.;....;...
.•...
.: ..
~
','"
:.;
':
.~.
'. ," :... ::':'"
"':. ,',
. :','.
,"..", .". .
.. '," " :
.. : ..
:
...: ....
. .'.. '
,.,,'
"
. :.
. '
..
' .
. .\
':- .
"
,.. .. ::.
: "
.:
"
~'.
"."
~.
.,,'.
:.~,.'
:.:
. "
." .
'. . .
. .' ..: , .":". .......
:,'.
-':' .
.'.'
.'
..
-
..
~:' ~:'
: "
,~.
.
~
".
',; '."
.~
'. .... , '.
. ..... .
'.:.
t."
.
.~..
-....
,"
....'",.
. .
...
:"
.~
.
..
.."
.
•.. '
",
",..... :. ":.
,:,. .:
. '. '.
.
. ":.. :.....: ;"
~...
.
'.
.
;..'.;<"
...• .'.'
'',: ". : ,.0:: : /'.
"_
.,-
. '..
. .;.";.
I'
'.
. .'"
' ••••.... ';
. '. .;
~ :~"
.:',
;'
_:.'
'.
.
. .' .
..
;~'
.. ,
.•. :
,':.' "..'
: ....•
:~
:
:- ..,
'
).
~-
..•.. _ .. _,
.
;.~l·,·.:
'•..
~
::..
:::
.' .'., .'.
..
~.
.'
: .,: ..:
. '.' '.
'.. ' ..:.
...
.
. : '.
'.'
'. '.
~
.
"
:
'
-
"
.'
.
. . " ;.:
'
·i.~
..
,,-,:,
.' :':.
,~
This
F.iJin~.i~S~bJ1litt~d.~ri\~O·2.~Po~~~oris~rn~f.~d~y~~~:d.~a~~r:
.. ,.
"~
,.,.::~.'
,
:::
.
'. .
,'.
. ,
..
i
,....::
"" ..... '......
.:".:"~".
"!. - .-.. , '.' : ..... -' :.: ..
.' ,
'...' '.
•
. • :. '.
'•• :' .: .
. .": .; '.
~. ~
•
.
'. •
: '.
• ..• ' ••••••.• ' .'. ': .
,,,
"
• ;":":. -. -.:" .' •
: • >.' •• :.
• .-....
.
~":
.. '
;"
:.
..
.
..
..•.
.
.
....;. .
.' .
.._
..
•... :...
<."
..•• ,: ... ' .
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
. ' ',' .
"
.
~.'"
;,'
".
,,-
.
....
. " ......
...'
. ,,'
. . .
. :'..;.
~
......
",
.,
.
. .
•
~
::"..
• ',•• :.
_ •.•• '. ,:
• .. ....
" a' .
.'. -: .. "';.
.• •
-, .:
:: : ::.. .
", "" ".
",
.: .:- •
':,':'
'.,
:......".
. :,' .. ; "
. "
"
', .. '"
"':
:..
.
:.-
.", .,
;..
.,..
,',
.' ',,:
...
."
~~~F6~~: i~sPb~deri~; t~e·Unite4. ~it~ ~rY'or~~ll~~:~~~P~~~fuliy
~OV~~·:·
':.'':" ' ..
'.:.
. .....
"..
.....
.
, .'
.' .
." .
.
",
....
-'
... ",
.;
.
.'.
.~'::
.; .' . ':'
.
.
",:' .
. ':." .'
". '. •. ' :....
I,,'..
. ..
,~'
.....'
.
~
.. , ..
'."
. ,
..... . " "" .'
. .....
.
'.,'
.... .:.:
"
"
~.
'.
......
..
" ....
:' ..'.
:'.
'~
..'::
...
.'.,": .
. .:'. : .:
.....
; .
,.. . .
.. .'
"~'
...... " /" .. '
'.
"'~
:"~.:: .~'
./ >'. '"
.
. .. ;"',;. '..
-.
". \
,
'
.. '.
.: .... :.
,'.'
..
:. '.'
......
'." .'
. '.'::
, .. ' .:.: .. '
:......
.. .....
.....•.
, .:
'.' ..'. ",
':'
. ' '\
.'
.
.
:.;.
"':.' ..
'.
'.:.'
.'
. ..
~.:
..' .....
;..'....
......
..... .
.
'
~
. ..
.
.
. ":.,
:.
:,. :.
'., ..
........ '
.' . ",".
"
.
~
.
.......:
. ...
~
c., .::: :';.
.. :'.: .'
;..
"
.;
.
....
I:.
.
:'
"
".
....: '
........
:.'.
'";., .
..:.' ....
.... .... : :",
.:.
.......
..';.
. ", .
. .. .
" ," " .....
..
..
:
;"".
.
. .:
..
\
.
".
.. ..
~
.
~
.
.·.R~~p~~t~ii~·.~~~~~e~,
::-
.'
..
..
'.
'. ....
. '.
."
'.
. . ..."/
~ ~.
. . .,
. :
~
.' ':'.' '. ."... . . '.
-.~
.
.'
. .."..
~:
.. "' .
~.
. "
..
' ...
:
.
~
' ..
,': "
. .., .
. ," :t .•
' .. '
:
....
. :."
';' .. " ..
......
.........
....
. : ..
". ' ...:.,
" '....
::
..
.." "., . ",'.
. .
~
.
~.'
.
".
~.:
',".' .'
':.:.
"
."
..
'
~
..
:.
"
..... :
':."
.
~
' .. ,
...., .•..
..
~'.
..'
"'Dat~d:
:.:'
~
..,.::.
-.
JuiY'20,
....-
'.
'....
2ooi:.
'.
:
~
.
".
. '. :'
'..... ,,'
"
.
.. .... "..',
. ",.'
... , .....
..
",
. '. '. " '. ..
"~
:::., '.
'. .
~
': .
',.
",
..
'.
~.
'. .
~.
.
.'
...:.
, ". '. .': /...;.
theB~~rd: fofai{O~dt~r:
-,,: ',''. ':.' .
....' '....
..... .•... . . ..:. . ,-
•• '. :',:, '., ,._.':..•.•
". '. '"
."
" .'. • .. •
:..
'4
.••.. '
•
•.•.
•
.
.: . .
~'.
:.... ...
·~;.::·1)·Granti~git.le~~~tO.flleorie~~peFC6pYOfthet~¢o~d·~iOrig'.w.ithone·.d~~~;···
......'
,.
.
....• "" ,
.~)r~:~::U~;Y::~~~p,'~h.;:exh'bt&~habetiC~1;a:cording·~:
..•••••..•........ -: ..
'.'
"'..... J).For:further
reliefaS·t~e.Board;deemsjU.Stand'ptoper.·:
'. . .. ":";. .
."'.:.:
.'
. .
.
.
\
•
..'
• • •. " .
~.
• •
~.:
••
~'
;'"t
;. .. .'
0'. :.'. •
.. , .. :-'. '. -t.....
....
.'
:."
....
.....
. (,,'
. . ".
'.:' .
... :
.....
.....
.
~.
.."
Of. •
•
~
'". '.
. . .....
. ',".
:',
..
.
:1'. " ...
.. ",
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
EXHIBITC
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
August 9, 2007
FOX MORAINE, LLC,
Petitioner,
v.
UNITED CITY OF YORKVILLE, CITY
COUNCIL
Respondent.
ORDER OF THE BOARD (by G.T. Girard):
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
PCB 07-146
(Pollution Control Facility
Siting Appeal)
On
June 27,2007, Fox Moraine, LLC (petitioner) timely filed a petition asking the Board
to review a May 24, 2007 decision
of United City of Yorkville City Council (Yorkville).
Yorkville's decision concerns petitioner'sproposed siting
ofa pollution control facility in
Yorkville, Kendall County. On July 12,2007, the Board accepted the petition for hearing
On July 20, 2007 Yorkville filed a motion for relief from certain record requirements
(Mot). Yorkville seeks relief from filing an original and nine copies
of the record in this
proceeding and the original and seven copies
of transcripts as required by the Board'srules at
Section 107.304(b). Yorkville maintains that the record is voluminous and seeks leave to file
one paper copy of the record with one disk. Mot at 2. In addition, Yorkville requests permission
to file pre-hearing exhibits and comments alphabetically rather than chronologically.
Id.
The Board grants in part Yorkville'smotion for relief. Specifically, the Board will allow
Yorkville to file a limited number
of copies of the record; the Board directs Yorkville to file an
original and two paper copies and one disk. Yorkville may also include pre-hearing exhibits and
comments in alphabetical order rather than chronological order.
The Board notes that the record
is due to be filed on August 16, 2007, by hearing officer
order. As petitioner has waived the decision deadline in this matter to January 24, 2008 and a
hearing has not yet been set, the Board extends the filing deadline to August 30, 2007.
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
2
IT IS SO ORDERED.
I, John T. Therriault, Assistant Clerk of the Illinois Pollution Control Board, certify that
the Board adopted the above order on August 9, 2007, by a vote
of 4-0.
John T. Therriault, Assistant Clerk
Illinois Pollution Control Board
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
EXHIBITD
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
2Q N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago, IL 60602
(312)425-8066
Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225
W. Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago, IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089075-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2 Legal
of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark St. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
Tax
10: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525-002
Item Number
DVD's
Signature:
Date:
Job
#
IM198
Cu~tomer
Name
~::da:~Y
credit card please fill in and fax to 312-425-8078
bXPires on
Card Type:
1
Invoice Tota':
1,470.00
Please pay from this invoice
-
Terms: net 30 days from invoice date!/
Digital Imaging. & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Utigation Copying
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Detroit
Houston
www.c2legal.com
National Accounts
New York City
On-5ite Staffing
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
. 20 N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago,
Il 60602
(312)425-8066
Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
8oldTo:
Wildman Harrold
225
W.
Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago, IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089073-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remitlo:
C2 Legal of f1finois LLC
20 N Clark
81. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-41S2
Tax 10: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525-002
Item Number
Compact Disc
.Signature:
Date:
Job#.
IM197
Cu~tomer
Name
~::~y
credit card please fill In and fax
to
312-425
0
8078
6Pires on
Card Type:
1
Invoice Total:
300.00
Please pay from this invoice. Terms: net 30 days from invoice daten
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Litigation Copying
National Accounts
On-Site Staffing
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Detroit
Houston
New York City
WoNW.
c2legal. com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
C:
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago,
IL 60602
(312)425-8066
Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225
W. Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago, IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089074-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2
legal of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark
St
Sui~e
300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
Tax
ID: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525..002
Item Number
Blowback of Scanned Images
Job
#
IM-196
CU$tomer Name
Signature:
Date:
~::a:~y
credit card please fiJI in
~ndfax
to 312-425-8078
kXPires on
Card Type:
1
Invoice Total:
1,504.32
Please pay from this Invoice'. Terms: net
30
days from invoice datelf
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Utigation
Copying
Detroit
Houston
National Accounts
New
York City
On-6ite Staffing
www.c2legal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
--..;l~
.
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago,
IL 60602
(312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225 W. Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago. IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089096-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2 Legal
of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark St. Suite 300
Chicago. IL 60602-4192
Tax 10: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
.00525-002
Item Number
Blowbacksof
Sca~ned
Images
Job
#
428
~ignature:
Date:
~::a:~y
credit card please fill In and
fax
to 312-425-8078
bXPires on
Card Tvpe:
1
Invoice Total:
3.008.64
Please pay from this invoice- Terms: net 30 days from invoice datell
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Chicago
Dallas
Denver .
Litigation Copying
Detroit
Houston
National Accounts
New
York City
On-Site Staffing
www.c2legal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
EXHIBITE
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
FOX MORAINE, LLC
)
)
Petitioner,
)
)
v.
)
)
UNITED CITY OF YORKVILLE, CITY )
COUNCIL
)
)
Respondent.
)
PCB No. 07-146
(Pollution Control Facility Siting
Appeal)
AFFIDAVIT OF LEO P. DOMBROWSKI
Leo P. Dombrowski being first duly sworn deposes and states as follows:
1.
I am a duly admitted and practicing attorney and a partner at Wildman, Harrold,
Allen
&
Dixon LLP ("Wildman Harrold").
2.
I am one of the attorneys of record engaged to represent the interests of the United
City of Yorkville ("Yorkville") in this matter.
3.
In August 2007, Wildman Harrold, on behalf of Yorkville, retained C
2
Legal, a
document management company, to assist Yorkville in preparing the record on appeal. As
shown in C
2
Legal's invoices, C
2
Legal scanned the documents in the landfill siting record and
made disks and paper copies.
4.
On September 5, 2007, I wrote to George Mueller, one of the attorneys of record
for Fox Moraine, providing him C
2
Legal's invoices and requesting payment by Fox Moraine.
(A copy of the 9/5/07 letter is attached hereto as Exhibit 1.)
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
5.
Because Fox Moraine had not paid, I again wrote to Mr. Mueller on April 24,
2008, providing him the invoices and requesting payment by Fox Moraine. (A copy
of the
4/24/08 letter is attached hereto as Exhibit 2.)
6.
On May 1, 2008, I spoke with Peter Hill, National Accounting Manager for C
2
Legal. He told me that the C
2
Legal invoices in this matter remain unpaid. He confirmed this in
an e-mail to me, which is attached as Exhibit
3.
AFFIANT SAYETH FURTHER NOT.
/s/ Leo
P. Dombrowski
Dated: May 1,2008
Under penalties as provided
by
law pursuant to Section 1-109 of the Code of Civil Procedure, I certify that
the statements set forth herein are true and correct.
2
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
EXHIBITE-l
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
Wildman
t
Harrold
Attorneys and Counselors
Wildman. Harrold, Allen
&
Dixon
LLP
225 West Wacker Drive
Chicago. Illinois 60606-1229
3 12-20
I
.2000
312-201-2555
fax
www.wildmanharrold.com
Leo P. Dombrowski
312-201-2562
dombrowski@wildmanharrold.com
September 5, 2007
VIA EMAIL andREGULAR MAIL
George Mueller
Mueller Anderson, P
.C.
609 Etna Road
Ottawa, Illinois 61350
george@muelleranderson.com
Re:
Fox Moraine LLC LandfIll Siting Appeal
Vendor'sInvoices for Preparing Record
Dear Mr. Mueller:
I enclose four invoices from
an outside vendor, C
2
Legal, whom we hired on
behalf ofthe United City of Yorkville ("Yorkville") to prepare and copy the Record on
Appeal, which was filed with the Pollution Control Board (the "Board") on August 30,
2007. The invoices total $6,282.96.
As the Petitioner "must pay the costs ofpreparing and certifying the Record to the
Board" (35 lAC 107.306), we are forwarding these invoices to you so that Fox Moraine
may pay C
2
Legal directly.
It
is requested that these invoices be paid within 21 days with
a
copy ofthe payment to the undersigned.
As you know, Yorkville moved for relief from certain ofthe Board'sfiling
requirements, and instead
of Yorkville having to prepare and file seven copies ofthe
hearing transcripts and the original
and nine copies of all other documents in the Record
(35 lAC 107.304(b), the Board granted Yorkville'smotion and required the filing of only
the original, two paper copies and one disk ofthe Record. Yorkville'smotion saved Fox
Moraine a significant amount ofmoney.
Note that these invoices constitute only a portion of Yorkville'sattorney'sfees,
City stafftime and expenses, and, by providing these invoices, Yorkville does not waive
its right to invoice Fox Moraine for its remaining expenses, past, present and future,
including but not limited
to those incurred in preparing and filing the Record.
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
George Mueller
September 5, 2007
Page 2
t
Please let me know if you have any questions regarding this.
Very truly yours,
WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN
&
DIXON LLP
J::
l~~:JI-4W;;
LPD:sh.
Enclosures
cc: Michael M. Roth
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street,
sre
300
Chicago,
IL 60602
(312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225 W. Wacker Dr.
SuitE! 3000
Chicago,IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089075-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2 Legal
of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark St. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
Tax
10: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525-002
Job#
IM198
Customer Name
Ryan Aldrich
SalesDerson
..• "Jessie O'Neal
Item Number
. Ordered
Amount
DVD's
42.000
.35.000
1,470.00
Signature:
Date:
~:~::~y
credit card please fill In and fax to 312-425.8078
bxPires on
Card Type:
1
Invoice Total:
1,470.00
Please pay from this invoice. Terms: net
30
days from Invoice date!!
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Litigation Copying
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Detroit
Houston
www.c2/egal.com
National Accounts
New York City
On-8ite Staffing
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street. STE 300
Chicago,'IL 60602
(312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225
W. Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago, Il 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089073-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2 Legal of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark St. Suite 300
Chicago,
IL 60602-4192
Tax
10: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525-002
Item Number
Compact Disc
Job#
IM197
.Ordered
20.000
Customer Name
Salesoerson
Ryan Aldrich
Jessie O'Neal-
..Prlce.
Amount
15.000300.00
,Signature:
Date:
~::~y
credit card please fill In and fax to 312-425-8078
bXPires on
Card Tvpe:
1
Invoice Total:
300.00
.Please pay from this invoice'
-
Terms:
net
30
days from invoice date!!
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Litigation Copying
National Accounts
On-Bite Staffing
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Detroit
Houston
New York City
www.c2Iegal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street, STe 300
Chicago, IL 60602
(312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225 W. Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago, IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089074-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2 Legal of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark St. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
Tax 10: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525-002
Item Number
Job
#
IM-196
.Ordered
Customer Name
Ryan Aldrich
Salescerson
:- -- ,:- Jessie O'Neal
.Pd~.
__
Amount
Blowback of Scanned Images
18,804.000
0.080
1,504.32
Signature:
Date:
~:::~YCredit
card please fill in and
fax
to 312-425.8078
bXPires on
Card Tyee:
1
Invoice Total:
1,504.32
Please pay from this invoice- Terms: net 30 days from Invoice datell
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Litigation Copying
National Accounts
On-8ite Staffing
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Detroit
Houston
New York City
www.c2legal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago,IL 60602
(312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225 W. Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago,lL 60606
fnvoice
Invoice Number: 0089096-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007 .
Remit to:
C2 Legal of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark St. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
Tax 10: 75.2705044
Client Matter
#
Job
#
00525.002
428
Item Number
. Ordered
Blowbacks of Scanned Images
37,608.000
Customer Name
Ryan Aldrich
Price
0.080
Salesoerson
Jessie O'Neal
Amount
3,008.64
Signature:
Date:
~:~::~v
credit card please fill in and fax to 312-425-8078
bpires on
Card Type:
1
Invoice Total:
3,008.64
Please pay from this invoice- Terms: net
30
days from invoice date!!
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Litigation Copying
National Accounts
On-8ite Staffing
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Detroit
Houston
New York City
www.c2legal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
EXHIBITE-2
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
Wildman
t
Harrold
Attorneys and Counstlors
Wildman. Harrold, Allen" Dixon
LLP
225 West Wacker Drive
Chicago, illinois 60606-1229
312-201-2000
312-201-2555 fax
www.wildmanharrold.com
Leo P. Dombrowski
312-201.2562
dombrowskl@wildmanharrold.com
April 24, 2008
VIA EMAIL andREGULAR MAIL
George Mueller
Mueller Anderson, P.C.
609 Etna Road
Ottawa, Illinois 61350
george@muelleranderson.com
Re:
Fox Moraine LLC Landiill Siting Appeal
Vendor'sInvoices for Preparing Record
Dear Mr. Mueller:
By letter dated September
5, 2007, I sent you four invoices from an outside
vendor, C
2
Legal, whom we hired on behalfofthe United City ofYorkville ("Yorkville")
to prepare and copy the Record on Appeal (copy ofthe letter and invoices are attached).
The invoices total $6,282.96. They remain unpaid.
As the Petitioner "must pay the costs ofpreparing and certifying the Record to the
Board" (35 IAC 107.306), we request that these invoices be paid by April 30, 2008, with
a copy
ofthe payment to the undersigned. :
If
they remain unpaid, we will file a motion to
dismiss the appeal with the Board (35 IAC 107.502(b».
By providing these invoices, Yorkville
does not waive its right to invoice Fox
Moraine for any remaining expenses, past, present and future, including but not limited to
those incurred in preparing and filing the Record.
Very truly yours,
~~LEN&DIXONILP
Leo P. Dombrowski
LPD:sh
Enclosures
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
Wildman
t
Harrold
Attorneys and Counselors
Wildman.
'rold, Allen
&
Dixon
LLP
225 West Wacker Drive
Chicago, Illinois
60606~
1229
312-201-2000
312-201-2555
fax
www.wildmanharrold.com
Leo P. Dombrowski
312-201-2562
dombrowski@wildmanharrold.com
September 5,2007
VIA EMAIL and REGULAR MAIL
George Mueller
Mueller Anderson, P.C.
609 Etna Road
Ottawa, Illinois 61350
george@muelleranderson.com
Re:
Fox Moraine
LLC Landfill Siting Appeal
Vendor'sInvoices for Preparing Record
Dear
Mr. Mueller:
I enclose four invoices from an outside vendor, C
2
Legal, Whom we hired on
behalf
of the United City of Yorkville ("Yorkville") to prepare and copy the Record on
Appeal, which was filed with the Pollution Control Board (the "Board") on August 30,
2007. The invoices total $6,282.96.
As the Petitioner "must pay the costs
ofpreparing and certifying the Record to the
Board" .(35 lAC 107.306), we are forwarding these invoices to you so that Fox Moraine
may pay C
2
Legal directly. It is requested that these invoices be paid within 21 days with
a copy
ofthe payment to the undersigned. . .
As you know, Yorkville moved for relief from certain of the Board'sfiling
requirements, and instead
of Yorkville having to prepare and file seven copies of the
hearing transcripts and the original and nine copies
of all other documents in the Record
(35 lAC 107.304(b), the Board granted Yorkville's motion and required the filing of only
the original, two paper copies and one disk
of the Record. Yorkville's motion saved Fox .
Moraine a
signific~t
amount of money.
Note that these invoices constitute only a portion
of Yorkville's attorney's fees,
City staff time and expenses, and; by providing these invoices, Yorkville does not waive
its right to invoice Fox Moraine for its remaining expenses, past,.present and future,
including but not limited to those incurred
in preparing and filing the Record.
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
George Mueller
September 5, 2007
Page
2
Please let me know if you have any questions regarding this.
Very truly yours,
WILDMAN, HARROLD,
ALLEN
&
DIXON LLP
~f.~~
Leo P. Dombrowski
.LPD:sh
Enclosures
cc: Michael M. Roth
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago, IL 60602
{312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225 W. Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago, IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089075-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2 Legal
ot
Illinois LLC
20
N ClarkSt. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
Tax
ID: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525-002
Item Number
DVD's
Signature:
Date:
Job#
IM198
Customer
Name
~:;:::bY
credit card please
fill
In and fax to
312-425-8078
bXPires on
Card Type:
1
Invoice
Total:
1,470.00
Please
p.jn~
from this invoice
-
Terms: net 30 days from invoice date!l
Digital Imaging. & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Utigation Copying
National Accounts
On-5ite Staffing
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Detroit
Houston
New York City
www.c2legal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
....
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago, IL 60602
(312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225 W. Wacker Dr.
Suite
3000
Chicago,
IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089073-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit
10:
C2 Legal of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark
S1. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
TaxID:75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525-002
Item Number
Compact Disc
.Signature:
Date:
Job
#
IM197
CU$tomer Name
~:~da:~Y
credit card please
fill
In and
fax
to
312-425
0
8078
bXPires on
Card Type:
1
Invoice Total:
300.00
Please pay from this invoice. Terms: net 30 days from Invoice daten
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic .Data Discovery
Utigation Copying
National Accounts
Dn-Site Staffing
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Detroit
Houston
New York City
www.c2legal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
C
2
legal
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago,
It 60602
(312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-S078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225
W.
Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago, IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089074-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2 Legal
of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark St. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
Tax 10: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
00525-002
Item Number
Blowback of SCanned Images
Job
#
IM-196
Signature:
Date:
~::a:~y
credit card please fill
in
and fax to 312425-8078
bXPires on
Card Type:
.
1
Invoice Total:
1;504.32
Please pay from this Invoice.. Terms: net
30
days from invoice datel!
Digital Imaging & Coding
Bectronic Data Discovery
Chicago
Dallas
Denver
Utigation
Copying
Detroit
Houston
National Accounts
New
York City
On-5ite Staffing
www.c2legal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
--...;l\
.
C
2
Legai
Digital Document Management
20 N Clark Street, STE 300
Chicago,
IL 60602
(312)425-8066 Phone
(312)425-8078 Fax
Sold To:
Wildman Harrold
225 W. Wacker Dr.
Suite 3000
Chicago, IL 60606
Invoice
Invoice Number: 0089096-IN
Invoice Date:
8/27/2007
Remit to:
C2 Legal
of Illinois LLC
20 N Clark S1. Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60602-4192
Tax 10: 75-2705044
Client Matter
#
.00525-002
Item
Number
Blowbacksof Scanned Images
Job #
428
CU$tomer Name
~ignature:
Date:
~::~y
credit card please fill In and fax to 312-425-8078
bpires on
Card
Tvpe:
1
Invoice Total:
3,008.64
Please
mw
from this invoice- Terms: net 30 days from invoice datefl
Digital Imaging & Coding
Electronic Data Discovery
Utigation Copying
National Accounts
On-Site Staffing
Chicago
Dallas
Denver' Detroit
HoustOn
New York City
www.c2Iegal.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
EXHIBITE-3
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
Message
Dombrowski, Leo
From:
Peter Hill [peter.hill@c2Iegal.com]
Sent:
Thursday, May 01, 2008 11 :31 AM
To:
Dombrowski, Leo
Subject: Outstanding Invoices
Page 1 of 1
As
of May 1 2008 at 11 :30 am the outstanding invoices related to the United City of Yorkville matter
has not been paid and are seriously past due.
<Peter:M..
1fi£(
National Accounting Manager
Copy Corps of Illinois
dba
C2
Legal of Illinois
Ph: 312-252-5303
Fax: 312-425-8078
E-Mail peter.hill@c21egal.com
5/1/2008
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Susan Hardt, a non-attorney, certify that I served a copy of the foregoing
United City of Yorkville's Motion to Dismiss,
on all Counsel of Record and the
Hearing Officer, listed on the attached Service list, via e-mail on May
1, 2008, before
5:00p.m.
sf
Susan Hardt
[x]
Under penalties as provided by law pursuant to ILL. REV. STAT.
CHAP. 110 - SEC 1-109, I certify that the statements set forth
herein are true and correct.
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008
Fox Moraine, LLC
v.
United City o/Yorkville, City Council
PCB No. 07-146
SERVICE LIST
Bradley
P. Halloran
Hearing Officer
Illinois Pollution Control Board
James
R. Thompson Center, Suite 11-500
100 W. Randolph Street
Chicago, Illinois 60601
hallorab@ipcb.state.il.us
George Mueller
Mueller Anderson, P.C.
609 Etna Road
Ottawa, Illinois 61350
george@muelleranderson.com
Charles Helston
Hinshaw
&
Culbertson, LLP
100 Park Avenue
P.O. Box 1389
Rockford, Illinois 61105-1389
chelsten@hinshawlaw.com
Michael
S. Blazer
Jeep
&
Blazer, LLC
24 N. Hillside Avenue, Suite A
Hillside, IL 60162
mblazer@enviroatty.com
Eric
C.
Weiss
Kendall County State's Attorney
Kendall County Courthouse
807 John Street
Yorkville, Illinois 60560
eweis@co.kendall.il.us
James
J. Knippen, II
Walsh, Knippen, Knight
&
Pollock
2150 Manchester Road
Suite 200
Wheaton,IL 60187
heather@wkkplaw.com
Electronic Filing - Received, Clerk's Oiffice, May 1, 2008