SECOND NOTICE
1)
Agency:
Pollution Control Board
2)
Title and Administrative Code Citation: “Control of Emissions from Large Combustion
Sources”, 35 Ill. Adm. Code 225
3)
Date and Citation to Illinois Register: May 19, 2006 (30 Ill. Reg
.
9281)
4)
Text and Location of any Changes from First Notice: See Attachment A
5)
Response to Codification Recommendations: No changes were requested by the
Secretary of State.
6)
Incorporations by Reference: All incorporations by reference are pursuant to Section 5-
75 of the Illinois Administrative Procedures Act (5 ILCS 100/5-75). The central listing
for the materials incorporated by reference in this rulemaking is Section 225.140,
“Incorporations by Reference.” As required by 1 Ill. Adm. Code 220.600(a)(6), a copy of
the front page of each material incorporated by reference in this rulemaking is included
with this second notice package.
7)
Final Regulatory Flexibility Analysis:
A)
Summary of Issues Raised By Small Business:
The Board did not receive any comments from any self-described small
businesses.
B)
Description of Actions and Alternatives Proposed by Small
Business during First Notice:
None
8)
Compliance with Section 5-30 of the APA and 1 Ill. Adm. Code 220.285:
The Board placed the proposal on the Board’s Web site. The Board also notified the
public through the Board’s Environmental Register. The Board did not receive a
comment from the Small Business Office.
9)
A)
List of Commenters:
The Board received 7,286 public comments in this rulemaking. Due to the
volume of comments received in this rulemaking, the Board is attaching a listing
of the comments, as they were docketed by the Clerk’s office, to this second
notice submission as Attachment B.
These comments range from lengthy post-hearing comments from the participants
to postcards and notes from citizens of the State. The overwhelming majority of
the comments support the adoption of the Agency’s proposal.
B)
Issues Raised
The following is a summary of the issues that were raised in this rulemaking. The
Board’s November 2, 2006 opinion in this rulemaking (Docket R06-25) provides
a greater level of depth and detail to both the issues that were raised in this
rulemaking and the Board’s consideration of the issues. A copy of the 146-page
opinion and order is included with this second notice package.
The Board received comments from throughout the State and specifically from the
following organizations or public officials in support of the proposed rule:
Sinai Health System (PC 6322)
Ounce of Prevention Fund (PC 6321)
Northern Illinois Public Health Consortium, Inc. (PC 6320)
Metropolitan Chicago Healthcare Council (PC 6319)
Illinois Public Health Association (PC 6318)
Illinois Maternal and Child Health Coalition (PC 6317)
Illinois Environmental Council and Alliance for the Great Lakes (PC 6316)
Illinois Division of the Izaak Walton League, Illinois Council of Trout Unlimited,
National Wildlife Federation, Natural Resource Defense Council,
Prairie Rivers Network (PC 6315)
Illinois Academy of Family Physicians (PC 6314)
Citizen Action Illinois (PC 6313)
Children’s Hospital of Illinois (PC 6312)
Child Care Coalition of Lake County (PC 6311)
American Lung Association of Metropolitan Chicago (PC 6310)
American Bottom Conservancy (PC 6309)
American Academy of Pediatrics, Illinois Chapter (PC 6308)
Access Living (PC 6307)
Advocate Health Care (PC 6306)
Sierra Club, Illinois Chapter (PC 6305)
Citizens Against Ruining the Environment (PC 6304)
Kathryn Tholih of Center for Neighborhood Technology (PC 6303)
Susan Spengler, President, League of Women Voters, Palatine Area (PC 6285)
April K. Holden, Village Clerk, Village of Downers Grove (PC 6276)
Sadhu A. Johnston, Commissioner, Chicago Department of Environment (PC
6232)
Illinois Public Interest Research Group (numerous comments)
Chicago Clean Power Coalition (numerous comments)
Representative Barbara Flynn Currie (PC 44)
Michael D. Belsky, Mayor, City of Highland Park (PC 3)
Mayor Richard H. Hyde, City of Waukegan (PC 2)
Governor Rod R. Blagojevich (PC 1)
Generally, the supporters of the rule discuss the issues concerning health effects
from ingestion of methylmercury. Many note that coal-fired plants are the main
stationary source of mercury in the State. The supporters urge the Board to adopt
the proposal submitted by the Agency. Among the public comments are a
substantial number of post cards, which echo the concerns about the health effects
of mercury ingestion.
Hearings
The Board held ten days of hearings in Springfield and 8 days of hearings in
Chicago in this rulemaking during the first notice period. At the hearing, the
following people testified in support of the proposed amendments:
On behalf of the Agency;
Jim Ross , Dr. Deborah Rice, Jeffrey W. Sprague, Marcia Willhite, Dr. Thomas
C. Hornshaw, Dr. Gerald J. Keeler, Christopher Romaine, Richard E. Ayers,
Esq., Robert J. Kaleel, Sid Nelson, Jr., David C. Foerter, Dr. James E. Staudt, and
Dr. Ezra D. Hausman.
Dr. Michael W. Murray testified on behalf of the Environmental Law and Policy
Center.
Mr. Michael L. Menne and Dr. Anne E. Smith testified on behalf of Ameren.
The Board has also received the following comments in opposition to the
proposal:
Phillip M. Gonet, President, Illinois Coal Association (PC 6295)
Eugene M. Trisko, General Counsel, Unions for Jobs and the Environment (PC
6286)
Scott Wiseman, Vice President, Center for Energy and Economic Development,
Inc. Midwest Region (PC 6286)
Generally the opponents rely on economic reasons for their opposition to the
proposal. They express concerns about the increased costs of generating
electricity in Illinois and the impact on consumers and businesses as a result. The
opponents urge the Board to adopt the federal CAMR rule instead of the Agency’s
proposal.
The following people testified at the hearings in opposition to the proposed rule:
On behalf of Midwest Generation; J. Edward Cichanowicz, Dr. Ishwar Prasad
Murarka, William DePriest, James Marchetti, Krish Vijayaraghavan, Dr. Peter M.
Chapman, Dr. Gail Charnley, and Richard D. McRanie.
Additionally, Mr. C. J. Saladino and Mr. Andy Yaros testified on behalf of
Kincaid in opposition to the proposal.
The Board received final comments from the following participants, which will be
included in the discussion of the issues below:
Prairie State Generating Company. L.L.C. (Prairie State) PC 6294
City of Springfield, City Water Light & Power (CWLP) PC 6296
Environmental Law and Policy Center (Environmental Advocates) PC 6297
Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (Agency) PC 6298
Kincaid Generation, L.L.C. (Kincaid) PC 6299
Midwest Generation, L.L.C. (Midwest Generation) PC 6300
Ameren Energy Generating Company, AmerenEnergy Resource Generating
Company, and Electric Energy, Inc. (Ameren) PC 6301
Illinois Environmental Regulatory Group (IERG) PC 6302
Illinois Chapter of the Sierra Club (Sierra Club) PC 6305
Specific Issues Raised in Comments
Section 27 of the Act (415 ILCS 5/27) requires that the Board must determine that
a rule of general applicability is economically reasonable and technically feasible
before adopting the rule. While two utilities (Ameren and Dynegy) support
adoption of this rule as amended during the first notice proceeding, other utilities
still challenge the rule. The major challenges to the rule are that the Agency has
not demonstrated that the rule is technically feasible or economically reasonable.
In challenging technical feasibility, the opponents raise the following issues: (1)
the availability of the control technology, (2) the feasibility of measuring
emissions reductions, and (3) the compliance flexibility in the proposal. In
discussing economic reasonableness the opponents discuss issues concerning: (1)
the deposition of mercury and modeling of deposition, (2) the health effects of
mercury and whether control of emissions will result in positive health effects, (3)
the fish advisories, and lastly (4) the costs of compliance.
Participants also challenged the legal basis for adding a proposed Section (Section
225.233, “Multi Pollutant Standard”) to the proposal without first providing notice
of the amendments pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) (5 ILCS
100). Participants also questioned whether the amendments conform to federal
law.
Technological feasibility and availability
In the technical support document (TSD) that accompanied the proposal that was
originally filed with the Board, the Agency classified coal-fired EGUs in Illinois
into five categories depending on the pollution control equipment coal type. For
the EGUs utilizing coal type and control figurations other than powdered river
basin (PRB) units with cold-side ESPs, the Board agreed with the Agency that
these units will be able to comply with the proposed mercury regulation by
utilizing co-benefits, MPS, temporary technology based standards (TTBS), and
control devices such as fabric filters. The Agency’s agreements with Ameren and
Dynegy (which comprise the text of the proposed Section 225.233) also support
this view. However, the main concern of the utilities opposing the Agency’s
mercury proposal relates to the Agency’s preferred control technology for PRB
coal-fired units with cold-side ESPs, namely HCI (halogenated activated carbon
injection). HCI for mercury control in an EGU uses halogenated powdered
activated carbon (PAC) to bind and remove mercury.
When challenging the Agency’s position on the use of HCI, Midwest Generation,
Kincaid, and Prairie State referred to the Agency’s preferred control technology
for PRB coal-fired units with cold-side ESP as activated carbon injection (ACI).
However, the Agency in its TSD distinguished between ACI and HCI. The TSD
noted that early experience with untreated PAC raised questions regarding
mercury removal rates on units firing subbituminous coals using untreated PAC.
TSD at 123. Thus, the TSD notes that the focus of subsequent testing has been on
new sorbents such as halogenated PAC. Dr. Staudt also stated that unlike
untreated PAC, halogenated PAC sorbents were formulated specifically to address
the mercury capture needs of coal-fired boilers. Exh. 50 at 6. Based on the
results of the additional testing with halogenated sorbents described in the TSD,
the Agency concluded that mercury emissions reduction of 90% or greater is
achievable on PRB coal-fired units with cold-side ESPs using sorbent injection of
halogenated PAC or HCI. PC 6298 at 6. To avoid any confusion regarding the
sorbent type, the Board will refer to the Agency’s preferred control technology as
halogenated activated carbon injection (HCI) in the following discussion.
As described in the TSD, sorbent injection technology is a well-established
method to control mercury emissions for municipal waste combustors (MWC)
that is now being applied to coal-fired power plants.
See
TSD at 118-22. The
system consists of a storage silo, metering valve, pneumatic conveyor system, and
series of pipes that direct the sorbent that is blown into the plant ductwork. TSD
at 120. The commonly used sorbents include untreated PAC and chemically
treated sorbents such as the halogenated PAC. While untreated PAC has been
found to be very effective in controlling mercury emissions from municipal waste
combustors, halogenated PAC has been found to be very effective in controlling
mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants.
The issues raised by the utilities concerning the application of HCI to control
mercury emissions for Illinois EGUs can be grouped as follows: (1) HCI will not
be able to achieve the required mercury reductions as advertised; (2) HCI
performance is affected by the size of the SCA; (3) HCI has not been sufficiently
tested; and, (4) the proposed absolute emissions limits cannot be met. The Board
will discuss these four issues in the subsection below before rendering conclusion
at the end of this section.
Midwest Generation, Kincaid, and Prairie State all argue that HCI alone will not
achieve 90% mercury reduction on a consistent basis. However, the Board notes
that the proposal does not contemplate that HCI alone will work for all units.
Also, the Agency does not argue that HCI alone will always provide sufficient
control. As noted above, the Agency’s position regarding the application of HCI
pertains to only PRB coal-fired units with cold-side ESPs. Other affected units
would have to comply with the proposed regulations through co-benefit (
e.g.
, use
of flue gas desulfurization scrubber (FGD), selective catalytic reduction (SCR),
etc.), MPS, TTBS, or installation of control equipment (
e.g.
, HCI, fabric filters,
etc.).
In fact, the Board found that the TSD and Dr. Staudt’s testimony contain
extensive information relating to other technologies. Some of those technologies
include coal washing, boiler flue gases air pollution control equipment and air
pollution control equipment designed to remove particulate matter, or FGD
systems. Based on the record, all of these technologies can provide a co-benefit
for mercury removal from coal. Thus, the Agency did anticipate that, while HCI
is one technology, co-benefits from other technologies could also be used to
remove mercury from coal.
As to the HCI technology, arguments are made that the technology is still
developing and may not be commercially available. Kincaid and Midwest
Generation rely on the testimony of Mr. Cichanowicz concerning the probability
that the injection of sorbent will result in 90% removal of mercury. Kincaid lacks
confidence that 90% reduction can be achieved consistently with sorbent injection
alone. Midwest Generation notes that even Dr. Staudt believes that the
technology is evolving and Midwest Generation believes more testing is necessary
to establish that the technology will work and is commercially available. Prairie
State notes that there has been a lack of testing of sorbent injection with high
sulfur coal, which Prairie State plans to use.
Midwest Generation concedes that the technical feasibility of installing and
operating the HCI hardware is not being questioned; rather, the level of mercury
reduction that can be achieved is the issue.
See
PC 6300 at 36. Given this
concession by Midwest Generation, the Board looks to determine if the record
supports the proposition that 90% reduction or an emissions standard of 0.0080
lb/GWh can be met using HCI. The TSD devotes several pages to field tests of
HCI, both completed and in progress that demonstrate 90% removal occurs with
sorbent injection.
See
,
e.g.
, TSD at 122-30. Also, the TSD discusses the control
technologies at Illinois plants and even list the technologies the Agency
anticipates will be used for each EGU at each plant in Illinois.
See
TSD at 147-
62. Thus, unlike the general concerns raised by Midwest Generation and Kincaid,
the TSD specifically addresses controls at each plant in Illinois.
See
TSD at 162-
63, Table 8.9.
Both Dr. Staudt’s testimony and the TSD indicate that at least some of the units in
Illinois will be able to achieve 90% mercury emissions reduction with HCI.
See
Exh. 50 at 6, TSD at 162-63. The units where 90% reduction may not be
achieved are those that have PM control issues, or units that use sulfur trioxide
(SO
3
) as flue gas conditioner. The Board agrees with the Agency that the units
whose performance is affected by SO
3
can overcome the adverse effect by
injecting SO
3
downstream of mercury sorbent injection or by using alternative
conditioning methods. The units with PM issues can use TTBS or averaging to
comply with the regulations during the period of optimization of controls and
operation.
The TSD also provides evidence as to the actual commercial availability of
sorbents and the continued development of sorbents.
See
TSD at 139-44.
Specifically the TSD indicates that sorbent injection systems can generally be
fully installed and commissioned within six months of placing an order. TSD at
139. The TSD refers to at least one guarantee from a vendor that sorbent injection
will result in 90% removal. TSD at 140-41. The TSD indicates that activated
carbon sorbents are available from a number of suppliers and that there is long-
term experience with sorbent injection of municipal waste incinerators. TSD at
142. The TSD also notes that work is underway to improve sorbents. TSD at
143. Thus, the record contains detailed information on the commercial
availability and development of sorbent injection controls. Further, the Board
notes that the proposed rules allow a period of almost three years for the affected
units to achieve compliance. Based on the record, the Board finds that HCI
technology is available to meet the requirements of the proposed rules.
The Board notes Prairie State’s comment concerning the lack of information on
high-sulfur coals and reliance on statements by DOE is of concern to the Board.
However, Prairie State acknowledges that with changes to the TTBS, most of
Prairie State’s concerns could be addressed.
See
PC 6294 at 15. The Board will
therefore address the concerns of Prairie State under the discussion of TTBS
below.
Midwest Generation expresses concerns that the injection of sorbents may cause
issues with particulate matter. The TSD acknowledges that sorbent injection has
the potential to affect particulate matter control devices. TSD at 134. However,
the TSD notes that dozens of tests programs have been run where the sorbent is
injected upstream of the ESP and in only one has there been adverse impacts
observed.
Id
. Again the record contains evidence of actual test data
demonstrating that increased emissions of particulate matter will not occur.
However, if PM issue does come up at plant, the Board notes that the affected
plant may utilize the flexibilities allowed in the proposed regulations, such as
TTBS and averaging, to comply with the rules during the period of optimization
of control equipment.
Size of the SCA. Midwest Generation raises an issue, based on Mr.
Cichanowicz’s testimony concerning the effect of SCA size on mercury
reductions. The Board does not find evidence to support this concern. Mr.
Cichanowicz concedes: “Figure 5-2 is not intended to reflect any fundamental
theorem of carbon HG absorption or ESP residence time, but rather projects an
anecdotal relationship.” Mr. Cichanowicz offers his opinion that achieving 90 to
93% mercury removal on larger units such as St. Clair and Meramac, with ESPs
of 720 and 400 SCA, respectively “portends the same result on small ESPs at
stations such as Will County and Hennepin.” However, Mr. Cichanowicz’s
opinion is not supported by the evidence in the record. Actually, the record
indicates that the variations in effectiveness of sorbent injection shown in Figure
5-2 (Exh. 84 at 39) submitted by Mr. Cichanowicz are explained by other factors,
including choice of sorbent, coal type, and coal sulfur content. Further, the record
suggests a strong relationship between the amount of halogenated sorbent and
mercury removal. Therefore, the Board finds that the record does not demonstrate
that the size of the SCA will impact mercury reduction HCI.
Length of Tests. Midwest Generation, Kincaid and Prairie State argue that the
short-term duration of the field testing is insufficient to establish that 90%
reduction of mercury can be consistently achieved over the long term. Midwest
Generation attempts to distinguish the single 12-month test included in the record
from any potential applicability in Illinois. The Board is cognizant that the short-
term testing is not a substitute for long-term testing. However, the results of
multiple field tests of HCI on PRB coal-fired units with cold side ESPs have
demonstrated 90% or better removal at sorbent rates of 3 lb/ million actual cubic
feet (Mmacf). Further, the Board believes that the three-year compliance period
allowed by the proposed regulations provides sufficient time for utilities to install
HCI systems, and optimize sorbent rates and plant operations to comply with the
standards. Therefore, the Board finds that the short-term testing is sufficient to
demonstrate technical feasibility.
Absolute Emissions Limit
.
Kincaid and Prairie State both express concerns about
the Board establishing an absolute emissions limit. Kincaid argues that setting an
absolute emissions limit is a guess by the Board that technologies will develop to
achieve the required reductions, while Prairie State believes that Board should
adopt the CAMR trading provisions and layer the Illinois rule on top of trading.
As to Kincaid’s assertion that the Board will be “guessing” that technology will
develop to achieve an absolute emissions limit, the Board disagrees. As discussed
above, the Board has ample evidence to demonstrate that HCI, either alone or
with other technologies, can achieve 90% reduction of mercury. Further, the
Board finds no merit in Kincaid’s suggestion to include specific language in the
proposed regulations allowing affected plants to seek an adjusted standard or a
site-specific rule; the proposed regulations do not prohibit an owner or operator of
a power plant from seeking site-specific relief pursuant to Sections 27 or 28.1(c)
of the Act. Therefore, the Board does not share Kincaid’s concerns about
absolute emissions limitations.
Because the Board believes that 90% reduction can occur, given the record before
the Board concerning the state of the technology, the Board does not see the need
to consider a trading program for mercury emissions. And, as will be discussed
below, the Board also does not believe that there will be an issue for Illinois to
achieve the CAMR budgeted limits. Therefore, trading will not be included in the
rule.
Measurement of Mercury Removal
Before addressing the arguments made concerning CEMS, the Board notes that
the proposal incorporates the USEPA provisions for mercury monitoring and the
provisions are nearly identical. Prairie State has suggested that the Board simply
incorporate the USEPA rules without including specific mercury monitoring
requirements in the proposed rule. The Board has reviewed the 40 CFR Part 75
rules and the Agency’s proposed rules. The Board is not convinced that the minor
differences warrant a change in the language. Further, incorporation of the Part
75 rules may not alleviate the concerns of Prairie State as the APA requires that
incorporations be date-specific. Accordingly, changes to Part 75 will not be
automatically included in Board rules.
See
1 Ill. Adm. Code 100.385; 5 ILCS
100/5-75 (2004). Since the proposed intent of monitoring requirements is to track
the federal rules, the Board expects the Agency to propose amendments to the
monitoring provisions if the federal rules are revised as a result of a court
decision. The issues raised by Midwest Generation and Prairie State concerning
measurement of mercury removal are all directed at the use of CEMS. Further,
both Midwest Generation and Prairie State rely on the testimony of Mr. McRanie.
However, the Board has concerns about the testimony of Mr. McRanie. While
Mr. McRanie testified about problems with continuous emission monitoring
systems CEMS, contrasting evidence includes the USEPA’s decision to adopt the
Part 75 monitoring requirements and evidence that contradicts some of Mr.
McRanie’s testimony. Based on the evidence in the record, the Board finds that
mercury monitoring technology is technologically feasible. The Board also finds
that the technology is currently available. Therefore, the Board will proceed to
second notice without substantively amending the monitoring requirements in the
proposal.
Regulatory flexibility
Averaging. Midwest Generation does not believe that averaging eliminates
concerns about HCI achieving 90% reduction, because to average 90% reduction
mathematically, at times, even higher than 90% reduction may be required.
Midwest Generation also has concerns about measurements of mercury
reductions. Midwest Generation and Kincaid maintain that systemwide averaging
will not add real flexibility because of the over compliance which may be
mathematically required and for Kincaid, they will be forced into a seller’s
market. The Board appreciates the concerns of Kincaid and, as will be discussed
in more detail below, the Board believes Kincaid is uniquely situated in Illinois.
As to Midwest Generation’s concerns, while the Board recognizes that
compliance based on an average would involve reductions higher than 90% at
some EGUs, the Board notes that the standard also allows units with lower than
90% to come into compliance. As noted above, the record indicates that
technology capable of achieving greater than 90% mercury reductions is
available. Further, the Board has found that 90% mercury reductions, and
monitoring requirements for measuring such reductions to determine compliance
are technically feasible. Therefore, the averaging components of the proposal add
flexibility for utilities and the Board finds that the record supports their inclusion.
MPS. Midwest Generation believes that because Ameren and Dynegy proposed
the MPS, Ameren and Dynegy do not believe the underlying rule is technically
feasible. Further, Midwest Generation believes that Ameren and Dynegy are
concerned with financing and timing of installation of equipment. Kincaid
believes that the MPS is imposing emissions standards for nitrogen oxides (NO
x
)
and sulfur dioxide (SO
2
) that other companies have been adhering to and that the
MPS is tailored for Ameren and Dynegy. The Board does not share these
concerns. First, as indicated above, the record in this proceeding indicates that the
Agency has always understood that mercury reduction can be achieved through
co-benefits. The Board finds that the MPS is memorializing a type of co-benefit
and that any company in Illinois may take advantage of the MPS. The MPS
simply offers companies alternatives for compliance that may be more
economically reasonable.
The Agency’s final comment includes calculations for Midwest Generation and
the calculations demonstrate that if Midwest Generation were to utilize the MPS,
the NO
x
and SO
2
emissions would be similar to those for Dynegy and Ameren.
The decision to utilize the MPS is voluntary and the MPS, like the TTBS, is an
alternative compliance option in the rule. As the Board stated above, the
inclusion of alternative compliance options does not render the rule technically
infeasible. Furthermore, Ameren and Dynegy have specifically stated that the
MPS is technically feasible for their companies, and although Kincaid may not be
in a position to utilize the MPS, other companies may. Therefore, the Board finds
that the rule with or without the inclusion of the MPS is technologically feasible.
Additional concerns including the MPS involve the relationship with Clean Air
Interstate Rule (CAIR) and with other sources. The Agency, Environmental
Advocates, and Ameren all addressed the relationship between CAIR and the
inclusion of the MPS. All point out that the MPS is voluntary and nothing in the
language of the MPS can be viewed as implying that compliance with the MPS
equates with compliance with CAIR. Further, both Environmental Advocates and
the Agency agree, that if a company utilizes the MPS for mercury control, the
company must still comply with the requirements of CAIR. Based on these
discussions and the Board’s review of the MPS language and the CAIR proposal
(
See
Proposed New Clean Air Interstate Rules (CAIR) SO
2
, NO
x
Annual and NO
x
Ozone Season Trading Programs, 35 Ill. Adm. Code 225.Subparts A, C, D and E
R06-26), the Board agrees that the proposed MPS does not conflict or in any way
abridge the Board’s authority in CAIR.
The remaining issues raised have to do with the surrendering of allowances and
the impact of the MPS on other sources. Both Prairie State and CWLP suggest
that rather than surrendering and then retiring allowances, the Agency use those
allowances for new facilities. IERG raises a concern about the language that any
additional reductions will be sought from other sources.
The Board is not convinced that requiring that allowances be surrendered and then
retired will have a detrimental impact on new facilities. Allowances for SO
2
and
NO
x
will be available pursuant to CAIR and the record in this proceeding does not
support the change requested by Prairie State and CWLP. As to the impact on
other sources, any additional reductions will be accomplished through rulemaking
proceedings and at that time other sources can challenge the changes. Nothing in
the MPS automatically reduces emissions for sources that do not elect to utilize
the MPS.
The Board has reviewed the issues raised about the technical feasibility of the
MPS and inclusion of the MPS in the proposed rule. Based on the record, the
Board finds that the MPS is technically feasible and the Board will proceed to
second notice with the rule including the MPS. The Board will include the
changes to the MPS suggested by the Agency in PC 6298 and agreed to by
Ameren.
Board Conclusion.
The Board finds that the record demonstrates that the
mercury emissions controls proposed in the rule are technically feasible. The
Board has found evidence that the affected utilities are afforded a number of
alternative options to comply with the proposed mercury limitations, including
control technology, co-benefits, averaging, and the TTBS. Regarding mercury
control technology, the Board finds that sorbent injection with halogenated PAC
or HCI is technically feasible for PRB coal-fired units with cold side ESPs to
comply with the proposed mercury limits. Field tests at multiple sites have
demonstrated that 90% removal is achievable over 30-day testing and although
short-term testing is not always optimal, in this instance, the testing is sufficient to
demonstrate technical feasibility. The evidence in the record does not support
potential problems with particulate matter or concerns about the size of the SCA.
The technologies are commercially available from several vendors and at least
one vendor testified in the proceeding and will provide guarantees for 90%
removal.
In addition, the Board finds that co-benefits achieved through the use of FGD,
SCR or selective non-catalytic reduction (SNCR), and installation control
equipment including fabric filters are technically feasible options for EGUs
utilizing coal type and control configurations other than PRB coal-fired units with
cold-side ESPs. Also, the rules allow sufficient time for plant operators to install
control equipment and optimize operations to comply with the mercury emissions
limits. And finally, the record demonstrates that an absolute emissions rate is
viable, can be achieved and trading is not necessary.
The Board agrees that compliance with the rule as proposed, even with the
inclusion of the MPS and TTBS, is not feasible for Kincaid due to the unique
circumstances of the facility in Illinois. The Board has reviewed the amendments
offered by Kincaid, but the Board does not find the record adequately supports the
changes suggested by Kincaid. Therefore, the Board recommends that Kincaid
seek relief from this rule of general applicability using the variance, adjusted
standard or site-specific rule provisions of the Act.
See
415 ILCS 5/28, 28.1, 35
(2004). The Board notes that both Section 28.1(e) and Section 38(b) of the
provide an automatic stay of the rule of general applicability if the petition for
adjusted standard or variance is filed within 20 days of the adoption of the rule.
415 ILCS 5/28.1, 38(b) (2004). This avenue for relief for Kincaid, will allow
Kincaid, or any other source, to work with the Agency to develop a complete
record for the Board’s consideration.
Economic Reasonableness
Deposition and Modeling Midwest Generation disagrees with the Agency’s
conclusion that significant mercury emissions reduction in Illinois will yield
significant reductions of mercury deposition in Illinois. Midwest Generation’s
concerns about modeling and mercury deposition focuses on three main areas: (1)
the Agency’s reliance on results of studies performed in other parts of the country
such as Ohio, Florida, and Massachusetts that are not specific to Illinois; (2)
appropriateness of using receptor models instead of chemical transport or
deterministic model; (3) whether the predicted local deposition of mercury is
significant enough to warrant mercury controls on Illinois coal combustion plants.
The Board will address those concerns below.
Reliance on Studies Not Specific to Illinois. Midwest Generation asserts that
none of the studies relied upon by the Agency’s expert Dr. Keeler show whether
Illinois EGUs impair Illinois waters or whether the proposal will have an effect on
the level of any impairment. Midwest Generation argues that the results of the
studies relied upon by the Agency are not applicable to Illinois because of
differing weather systems, geographic settings, and coal types. The Board notes
that the Agency relies on the results of the Florida and Massachusetts studies to
support the Agency’s assertions. However, the Agency primarily relies upon Dr.
Keeler’s Steubenville study and his hearing testimony to conclude that reduction
of mercury emissions from EGUs will result in a reduction of local wet deposition
of mercury.
Although the studies relied upon by the Agency were not Illinois specific, the
Board notes that it is not unusual for the Board to adopt regulations relying on
such studies. The Board routinely adopts regulations based on regional or
nationwide modeling performed by the USEPA that are not specific to Illinois. In
light of this, the Board will consider the studies submitted by the Agency in
evaluating the merits of the Agency’s proposal. Initially, the Board recognizes
that while the sources of mercury emissions considered in the Florida and
Massachusetts studies were primarily incinerators, the Steubenville study dealt
with coal combustion sources. Although all the three studies support the
Agency’s contention that reduction of mercury emissions from coal combustion
plants would significantly reduce local mercury deposition, the Board will discuss
the issues raised by Midwest Generation concerning the Steubenville Study, since
Agency’s justification is largely based on that study.
Regarding the Steubenville study, the Board considers whether the conditions in
Steubenville, Ohio make the results so unique that the results are not applicable to
any area other than Steubenville. The Board notes that Dr. Keeler provided
testimony as to why the results of Steubenville study are applicable to Illinois. He
testified that “conditions [in Steubenville] are not unique or anomalous to make
them so they are not usable or transferable to conditions that we would have in
Illinois.” 6/16amTr. at 84. Dr. Keeler explained that the Great Lakes are
dominated by synoptic meteorological transport, which is the large-scale
movement of the “highest and low pressure systems” across the Great Lakes.
Id
.
Therefore, as long as specific meteorology that occurs in a location is taken into
account, the controlling factors are not that much different for Illinois than Ohio.
Id
. at 84-85
.
With respect to coal type, and the form (elemental or reactive) of mercury
emissions, Midwest Generation argues that Illinois EGUs primarily burn PRB
coal, which results in the emissions of mostly elemental mercury in contrast to
mostly reactive mercury emitted by sources in the Steubenville area. Elemental
mercury is less readily deposited and less likely to undergo methylation. Dr.
Keeler testified that while municipal and medical waste incinerators emit greater
than 80% reactive mercury, coal-fired utilities emissions of reactive mercury
range from approximately 52 to 82%. The lower end of the range represents
emissions from sub-bituminous (PRB) coal-fired plants. 6/14Tr. at 244.
Although the proportion of reactive mercury in emissions from PRB coal burning
plants is less than bituminous coal-fired plants, the Board notes that the proportion
of such emissions from PRB coal plants are still greater than 50%. Further, Dr.
Keeler testified that recent studies pertaining to mercury chemistry suggests that
in certain environments, such as downwind of urban areas, elemental mercury is
rapidly transformed to reactive mercury. 6/15Tr. at 192. He noted that
observational evidence at Steubenville indicates this phenomenon. 6/15Tr. at 193.
In light of the above, the Board finds that reliance on the findings of the
Steubenville study to evaluate the impact mercury emissions from Illinois utilities
on Illinois waters is appropriate.
Receptor Model v. Chemical Transport Model. Midwest Generation argues that
the Board should consider AER’s modeling results presented by Midwest
Generation’s expert, Mr. Vijayaraghavan. Midwest Generation asserts that the
receptor modeling performed by Dr. Keeler reflects what is actually in the
atmosphere and cannot predict future deposition. PC 6300 at 72. Midwest
Generation maintains that the chemical transport or deterministic model called
TEAM used by AER predicts the impact of mercury emissions from Illinois
power plants on Illinois water bodies. PC 6300 at 64. Midwest Generation
maintains that the Agency did not present any chemical transport or deterministic
modeling to demonstrate that the target of the rule is the source of the perceived
problem; or that the proposed rule will have the desired effect of reducing
deposition from Illinois power plants to Illinois waters. PC 6300 at 64-65.
The Board notes that regulating agencies routinely use models for evaluating
impacts of various emissions reduction levels on air quality, or apportioning the
sources of a specific contaminant. However, the type of model relied upon
depends on the purpose of the evaluation. In this proceeding, as noted by
Midwest Generation, the first question that needs to be answered is whether the
Illinois coal-fired utilities (the target of the rules) are the significant source of
mercury impairment of Illinois water bodies. In order to answer this question, the
Board must determine that the mercury emissions from Illinois coal-fired plants
are a significant source of mercury deposition in the state. The record indicates
that while receptor models have been used successfully to apportion sources of
mercury deposition, the chemical transport or deterministic models are limited by
large uncertainties in emissions inventory, and lack of speciated mercury
emissions profiles, atmospheric mercury chemistry and accurate deposition
parameterization.
Mr. Vijayaraghavan, who performed AER’s modeling exercise, recognized
shortcomings in the deterministic models. He acknowledged that there are few
actual measurements of mercury emissions from EGUs and that “there is some
level of scientific estimation that goes into this emissions modeling.” He further
agreed that a number of factors influence mercury emissions from EGUs, leading
to “some level of uncertainty in emissions.” Also, he states that the chemical
transformation of mercury in the atmosphere is not understood with complete
certainty and that the TEAM model must make some assumptions regarding that
phenomenon. Mr. Vijayaraghavan also acknowledged that the TEAM model fails
to account fully for thunderstorms, resulting in underestimation of mercury
deposition.
To the contrary, the record indicates a multivariate statistical receptor models
have been used successfully in Ohio, and Florida to apportion sources of mercury
deposition. These models use statistical methods that are implemented by relying
on observations of deposition at a site or receptor. Further, receptor models are
not dependent on source profiles or emissions inventories. In this regard, the
Board notes that Dr. Keeler provided extensive testimony regarding the
Steubenville Study, which involved the use of receptor models to determine
sources contributing to mercury in wet deposition. This study found that coal-
fired utilities contributed approximately 70% of the mercury wet deposition at the
Steubenville site. Although this study was not Illinois specific, as noted above,
the Board found that the study results are applicable to Illinois. Therefore, the
Board finds that the Agency correctly relied on the receptor modeling to
demonstrate that Illinois utilities are a significant source of mercury deposition
within the state.
Whether the Predicted Local Deposition of Mercury Warrant Mercury Controls.
As noted above, the Steubenville study results indicate that coal combustion
sources accounted for approximately 70 percent of the wet deposition of mercury
at the Steubenville site. Further, Dr. Keeler’s analysis showed that “a substantial
amount of the mercury deposition found at the Steubenville site was due to local
and regional sources.” PC 6298 at 16, citing Exh. 10 at 3. Although the
Steubenville study addressed wet deposition, Dr. Keeler noted that “[e]levated
ambient mercury levels near large sources suggest that dry deposition would also
be elevated and likely to be similar in magnitude to the wet deposition.” Exh. 10
at 5. Accordingly, he concludes that “reductions in emissions from coal
combustion sources in the region would have a significant impact on the amount
of mercury deposited via both wet and dry deposition.”
Id.
Testifying on the issue of deposition on behalf of Midwest Generation, Mr.
Vijayaraghavan did not persuasively undermine Dr. Keeler’s conclusions on that
issue. Although Mr. Vijayaraghavan performed deposition estimates based on a
Eulerian model known as TEAM, he did not dispute the validity of the source-
receptor model used by Dr. Keeler. In fact, he agreed that Dr. Keeler’s source-
receptor method produced results comparable to and within the range of his own
estimate of mercury deposition contributed by coal-fired EGUs.
Addressing the effects of the proposed regulation in 2010, Mr. Vijayaraghavan
agreed that the Agency’s proposal would result in an additional decrease in
mercury deposition in comparison with the federal Clean Air Mercury Rule
(CAMR_ rule. Stated another way, Mr. Vijayaraghavan agreed that, in 2010, the
federal CAMR rule would result in higher levels of mercury deposition for
virtually the entire State of Illinois. He also stated that the Agency’s proposal
would by 2010 reduce mercury deposition by approximately the same amount that
CAMR would reduce it by 2020. Mr. Vijayaraghavan also agreed that Illinois
would receive most of the benefits of the rule. Applying the TEAM model to the
single year of 2010, Mr. Vijayaraghavan acknowledged that the Agency’s
proposal would reduce mercury deposition in Illinois by 321 pounds more than
the federal CAMR proposal.
In addition to the above modeling studies, the Board notes that mercury
deposition study in the Florida Everglades showed that within a few years after
state and federal requirements reduced mercury emissions, mercury measured in
the tissues of largemouth bass “showed substantial declines.” TSD at 81-82. The
Agency further states that the relation between atmospheric mercury load to the
Everglades and the body burden of largemouth bass has been modeled to be
nearly one-to-one. TSD at 84-85; 6/14Tr. at 205-08 (Keeler testimony); Exh. 20
at 68. Similarly, significant reductions in mercury emissions resulted in a steep
decline in fish tissue levels from the waters of northeastern Massachusetts within
five years. TSD at 86; Exh. 20 at 14; TSD at 86 (Figure 5.8: Representative Fish
Tissue Mercury and Incinerator Emissions Changes Versus Time in NE MA).
The Board recognizes that the Florida and Massachusetts study dealt with
reduction of mercury emissions mostly from incinerators. However, both the
studies lend support to the Agency’s contention that significant reduction in
mercury deposition results in reduction of mercury levels in fish tissue.
Based on the above evidence, the Board finds that the record strongly supports the
Agency’s contention that mercury emissions from Illinois utilities contribute
significantly to mercury deposition on Illinois waters. Further, the Board finds
that a reduction of mercury emissions from Illinois utilities would have significant
impact on the amount of mercury deposited on Illinois waters.
Board Conclusions on Modeling and Deposition. The Board finds that the record
in this proceeding, including the testimony of Dr. Gerald Keeler, demonstrates
that a reduction in mercury emissions in Illinois will result in reduction of
mercury deposition in the State. Although the Agency relies heavily upon Dr.
Keeler’s Steubenville study (PC 6292), the Board believes that that study
persuasively demonstrates that local and regional coal combustion sources
contribute significantly to the wet deposition of mercury. The Board finds that the
results of the Steubenville study are valid for evaluating the impact of mercury
emissions from Illinois utilities on Illinois waters. Further, the use of receptor
models is appropriate for apportioning the sources of mercury deposition. Finally,
while the Florida and Massachusetts studies may be based upon factors such as
geography and sources that are different from Illinois, the Board finds those
studies support the Agency’s contention that a reduction of mercury deposition
will result in a reduction of mercury levels in fish tissue.
On the basis of the record, the Board concludes that that a reduction in mercury
emissions in Illinois will result in reduction of mercury deposition in the state.
The Board notes that, compared with CAMR, the Agency’s proposal reduces
those mercury emissions more quickly and more deeply. Accordingly, the Board
finds that the Agency’s proposal can be expected to result in reduced mercury
deposition in the state and the expected result supports adoption of the proposal.
Health Effects
With regard to the health effects of methylmercury, the Board must determine if
the reduction of mercury emissions, leading to less deposition of mercury, will
result in health benefits to the citizens of the State. Midwest Generation agrees
that there is no dispute that methylmercury, consumed in fish or seafood at high
enough levels can be a health risk for certain sensitive portions of the population.
The Board agrees and clearly the record in this proceeding, including the
testimony of Dr. Rice, demonstrates that mothers’ intake of methylmercury has
detrimental effects upon the development of their children. Both cross-sectional
and longitudinal prospective studies have shown an association of methylmercury
exposure with decreased IQ and with deficits in areas including memory,
attention, and fine motor coordination. Although the Seychelles Islands study did
not confirm this association, that study may have measured methylmercury
exposure less precisely than similar studies.
The Board notes that Dr. Rice’s testimony also indicates that methylmercury is
associated with cardiovascular or coronary heart disease, including heart attack
and death. She noted that studies in Finnish men found an association between
hair mercury levels and myocardial infarction, cardiovascular disease, and death.
The Board notes that Dr. Charnley stated that various entities have developed a
range of exposure limits for methylmercury. The Board accepts her view that this
range is not attributable to fundamental scientific error but instead results from
differences in opinion, interpretation, and policy choices. Accordingly, the Board
cannot conclude that the results of the studies cited in the record are based upon
an invalid and unreasonably low exposure limit. However, the Board places
significant weight on USEPA’s reference dose. The Board has adopted a number
of regulations setting standards based upon USEPA’s reference doses for various
chemical contaminants, including water quality standards, groundwater standards,
and soil remediation levels.
Even as the proponent in this proceeding, the Agency acknowledges that there is
not likely to be an exact correspondence between reducing mercury emissions and
reducing human health effects. As noted previously under discussion of mercury
deposition, the record indicates that coal-fired utilities are a significant source of
local mercury deposition. Further, the studies presented by the Agency suggest a
strong correlation between reduction of mercury emissions from local and
regional sources and lower mercury levels in fish tissue. Therefore, on the basis
of the record, the Board concludes that improving public health and reducing or
eliminating fish consumption advisories are not likely to occur without reducing
mercury emissions from Illinois utilities. The Board notes that, compared with
CAMR, the Agency’s proposal reduces mercury emissions from Illinois utilities
more quickly and more deeply. There is no guarantee under CAMR that mercury
emissions would occur in Illinois since the rule establishes a nation-wide cap and
trade program. Accordingly, the Board finds that the Agency’s proposal can be
expected to result in additional health benefits and that those benefits support
adoption of the proposal.
Fish Advisories
The Board notes that the record in this proceeding, including the testimony of Dr.
Hornshaw and Ms. Willhite, indicates that the Agency’s proposal can be expected
to result in reductions in fish tissue mercury concentrations in Illinois. In this
regard, the Board has previously found that the evidence in the record supports the
Agency’s contention that Illinois coal-fired EGUs represent a significant source of
mercury deposition on Illinois waters. Further, the record supports the Agency’s
position that reduction of mercury emissions result in lower mercury levels in fish
tissue. Consequently, the Board believes that adoption of the proposal can be
expected to result in delistings from the Special Mercury Advisory, and to reduce
the number of waters listed as impaired due to mercury.
The Board notes Midwest Generation’s argument that the Agency’s witnesses
may not have described the expected results of this proposal with perfect
consistency. However, those descriptions do not irreconcilably conflict with one
another and do not undercut the Agency’s general rationale for the proposal. The
Board notes that even if reduction of mercury emissions from Illinois utilities does
not result in the reduction of mercury levels in fish tissue on a one-to-one basis,
the record supports the Agency’s position that the proposal will result in a
significant reduction in fish tissue mercury levels.
The Board concludes that reducing fish tissue mercury concentrations and
reducing or eliminating fish consumption advisories are not likely to occur
without reducing mercury emissions. Compared to CAMR, the Agency’s
proposal reduces mercury emissions from Illinois utilities more quickly and more
deeply. Accordingly, the Board finds that the Agency’s proposal can be expected
to result in reducing fish tissue mercury concentrations and reducing or
eliminating fish consumption advisories and that those benefits support adoption
of the proposal.
Economic Compliance
With regard to the economic reasonableness of the Agency’s proposal, Midwest
Generation has acknowledged that “[t]here is only a limited dispute as to the costs
of various mercury control equipment.” PC 6300 at 54. Instead, the Agency and
the opponents of the proposal strenuously disagree about the control equipment
that must necessarily be installed in order to comply with the proposal. The
Agency states that “the evidence from actual test programs supports the
conclusion of Illinois EPA that sorbent injection will allow PRB coal-fired units
to meet the requirements of the proposed Illinois rule, supporting Illinois EPA’s
cost estimate.” PC 6298 at 14. The Agency estimates that “[t]he yearly additional
control costs associated with the Illinois rule are $33 million.” Exh. 51 at 8. In
his testimony on behalf of the Agency, Dr. Hausman translated that amount “into
an average cost increase for the Illinois coal plants of $0.375/MWh.”
Id
. Dr.
Hausman further noted that “current retail prices in Illinois are about
$70.00/MWh and are likely to increase if price caps are removed as proposed.”
Midwest Generation argues that testing to date has not shown that sorbent
injection alone is sufficient to comply with the Agency’s proposal. Accordingly,
Midwest Generation believes that EGUs cannot rely on sorbent injection alone
and will have to install additional mercury control equipment in order to avoid
facing an enforcement action. Midwest Generation argues that the Agency’s
proposal will result in capital costs of more than $1 billion more than those
required by CAIR/CAMR. PC 6300 at 56. Including non-capital costs, Midwest
Generation claims that the Agency proposal would cost EGUs approximately
$200 million each year for ten years in addition to the costs required by
CAIR/CAMR.
In the preceding section of this opinion and order, the Board extensively
addressed the technological feasibility of the Agency’s proposal. The Board
found the Agency’s proposal technically feasible by considering sorbent injection
as the means to achieve required reductions in mercury emissions for PRB coal-
fired units along with the flexibility offered by TTBS, MPS and averaging. Based
on this finding, the Board believes that the annual incremental cost of compliance
with the proposed rules instead of CAMR will be consistent with the Agency’s
estimate of $33 million rather than the compliance costs presented by Midwest
Generation and Kincaid. The Board recognizes that the cost for some units such
as those opting into MPS may be higher, but those costs also represent the cost of
controlling SO
2
and NOx. In view of the significant reductions in mercury
emissions expected by the implementation of the proposed rules, the Board finds
that the Agency’s proposal as amended is economically reasonable.
Board Conclusion on Economic Reasonableness
The Board fully recognizes that the Agency proposal will result in costs for
Illinois EGUs and that those costs will exceed those required by implementation
of CAMR. Nonetheless, the Board noted above that, compared with CAMR, the
Agency’s proposal reduces mercury emissions more quickly and more deeply than
CAMR. The Board concluded above on the basis of the record in this proceeding
that the proposed rule can be expected to result in reduction of mercury deposition
and to benefit the public health in the state. Therefore, the Board finds that when
the Agency’s estimated compliance costs are weighed against the expected
benefits, the proposed rule that the Board adopts today is economically
reasonable.
Board Discussion of Illinois and Federal Administrative Law
The legal challenge to adopting the MPS is simply that regulation of NO
x
and SO
2
is not a logical outgrowth of the regulation of mercury. If the MPS required every
EGU in the State to comply with NO
x
and SO
2
emissions standards, the Board
might agree with the arguments presented by Kincaid and Midwest Generation.
However, the MPS does not require every EGU in the State to comply with
emissions standards for NO
x
and SO
2
. Rather, the MPS establishes mercury
emissions limits and to achieve those emissions limits, EGUs may elect to utilize
co-benefits realized from emissions reductions of NO
x
and SO
2
. An EGU that
does not choose to comply with the mercury rule using the MPS is not subject to
NO
x
and SO
2
reductions as a result of this rulemaking.
Control of mercury emissions and limits on those emissions is the subject of this
rulemaking. During the public rulemaking process, Ameren, Dynegy and the
Agency put forth an alternative method for compliance with the mercury
emissions limits proposed in this rulemaking. The proposal of this alternative,
from the public and the proponent, is exactly the type of change the Board
anticipates when developing a rulemaking through the Board’s public process.
After reviewing a proposal, members of the regulated community may raise an
alternative with which the proponent can agree. The alternative is then suggested
to the Board. Ultimately, the Board’s acceptance of the MPS is a result of the
public participating in this proceeding and suggesting an alternative that better
serves the individual companies proposing the change, while meeting the goals of
the proposal. Ameren, Dynegy, and the Agency have suggested an alternative
mercury emissions control plan, which happens to include limits on other
pollutants; but in the end, the alternative is a plan for the control of mercury
emissions. This rulemaking was proposed to and includes limits on mercury
emissions. Therefore, the Board finds that the suggested addition of the MPS
from Ameren, Dynegy and the Agency is a logical outgrowth of the process.
The record contains extensive comment from participants indicating that there are
co-benefits from controlling SO
2
and NO
x
emissions that reduce mercury
emissions.
See
TSD at 199; 6/21pmTr. at 45-46, 51. Thus, the proposal of an
alternative, designed to take advantage of those co-benefits, is logical and an
appropriate amendment to the rule.
The next challenge involves the timing of the proposed amendment. Kincaid
argues that by proposing such a significant departure from the original proposal,
Kincaid did not have sufficient time to prepare a response. PC 6299 at 29.
Kincaid asserts that for the Board to believe that Kincaid could respond is
arbitrary and capricious.
Id
. The Board believes that Kincaid has overstated the
nature of the MPS proposal. The MPS is an alternative method for compliance
with the underlying standard, not a replacement of that standard. The inclusion of
the MPS will not change the underlying requirements that Kincaid must meet; the
MPS is merely an alternative for companies to consider. Nothing in the MPS
would require any company to utilize the MPS, each company must determine
that on their own.
Thus, the proposal of the MPS by Ameren and the Agency at the time that prefiled
testimony was due for the second Board hearing was appropriate.
The participants had time to examine the language change and prepare questions
for Ameren before the prefiling deadline of August 7, 2006, for questions and
hearing began on August 14, 2006. Many questions were prefiled and Ameren
and the Agency answered several follow-up questions. The participants then had
until September 20, 2006, the deadline for public comment, to file written post-
hearing comments and further address the issue of the MPS. Both Kincaid and
Midwest Generation have filed extensive comments.
For the reasons discussed above, the Board finds that adding the MPS language to
the proposed rule is consistent with federal and state administrative law. Further,
the Board finds that the submission of the joint statement at the time that prefiled
testimony was due for the second Board hearing did allow meaningful time for
other participants to review the language and develop questions.
Section 27 of the Act
The Board has reviewed the record and based on the information in the record
found that the MPS is technically feasible and economically reasonable. As will
be discussed below, the Board is aware of the issues facing Kincaid in complying
with any part of this proposed rule. However, the individual problems faced by
Kincaid can be addressed in other forums. Generally, the Board believes the MPS
offers a viable alternative for compliance. Therefore, Kincaid’s argument that
adoption of the MPS would violate Section 27 of the Act (415 ILCS 5/27 (2004))
is not persuasive. The Board finds that because the Board has taken into account
the technical feasibility and the economic reasonableness of the MPS, the
adoption of the MPS is allowed under Section 27 of the Act (415 ILCS 5/27
(2004)).
The Board also rejects Midwest Generation’s argument that the rule violates
Section 27 of the Act because the rule is not technically feasible and economically
reasonable as defined by the court in Commonwealth Edison Co. v. PCB, 25 Ill.
App. 3d 271, 323 N.E.2d 84 (1st Dist. 1974). The Board finds that the regulated
community with one exception, Kincaid, can comply with the proposed rule as
amended at second notice. As discussed below, the Board believes that Kincaid
should seek relief from the rule requirements.
As to Ameren’s position that the Act allows the Board to adopt “exceptions” in a
rule of general applicability, the Board agrees with Ameren. The court in
Commonwealth Edison stated:
Substantive rules of this nature are promulgated for general, not
special, application. Consequently, investigators for the Board
gather facts and solicit expert advice in regard to pollution
problems affecting all types of companies in a particular trade. In
a case like the present one, the Board would have been charged
with investigating facts and operations of all types of generating
units -- single-and multi-unit, commercial, industrial, and public
utility -- and from these surveys extrapolate the appropriate
principles and propose the necessary regulations. The Board
cannot be expected to research, evaluate, and make allowance for
every special, unusual, or unique problem involving every
producer of electrical energy. Where one fails to challenge the
rules generally and instead seeks to relax their enforcement against
him exclusively due to arbitrary and unreasonable hardship, the
legislature has determined that the appropriate remedy is for the
aggrieved party to seek a variance in accordance with Title IX of
the Act. If that is denied, the aggrieved can petition to this court
for review based on the record at that proceeding. We hold,
therefore, that Commonwealth's ‘as applied’ argument cannot be
raised at this stage of review. Commonwealth Edison 25 Ill. App.
3d at 281, 323 N.E.2d at 90.
Plainly, the court’s finding is that an individual company cannot challenge the
Board’s rules of general applicability based on hardships associated with that
individual company. However, nothing in the court’s statements, nor the Act,
limits the Board’s ability to develop compliance alternatives for companies in a
rule of general applicability.
The Board finds that the authority of the Board pursuant to the Act does allow the
Board to amend a rule of general applicability to create exceptions. In this case,
the MPS is available to all companies operating in the State. The Board is aware
that Kincaid, due to its unique circumstances, may not be able to utilize the MPS;
however, that fact does not limit the Board’s authority to adopt the MPS.
Section 10 of the Act
The Board is unpersuaded by the argument that Section 10(B) of the Act (415
ILCS 5/10(B) (2004)) prohibits adoption of the MPS. Section 10(B) of the Act
(415 ILCS 5/10 (2004)) provides that the Board “shall adopt sulfur dioxide
regulations and emissions standards . . .” for the State, except for Chicago, St.
Louis, and Peoria Metropolitan areas, that are “not more restrictive than necessary
to attain and maintain” the primary NAAQS SO
2
and within a reasonable time the
secondary NAAQS SO
2
. 415 ILCS 5/10(B)(1) (2004)).
Kincaid and Midwest Generation’s arguments must fail because the Board is not
adopting sulfur dioxide regulations in this rulemaking. The Board is developing a
rule which limits the emissions of mercury in the State. One compliance option
for mercury emissions limitations is the use of the MPS. The MPS will allow a
source to voluntarily reduce SO
2
emissions to allow for co-benefits that limits
mercury emissions. If a source does not choose to use the MPS for mercury
control, there are no new emissions limits for SO
2
. Thus, the Board finds that
Section 10 of the Act does not prohibit the adoption of the MPS language.
Supremacy Clause and Commerce Clause
The Board is not convinced that the adoption of the MPS will violate either the
Commerce Clause or the Supremacy Clause. Midwest Generation and Kincaid’s
reliance on
Clean Air Markets v. Pataki, 194 F. Supp. 2d 147 (N.D.N.Y. 2002) is
misplaced, as the facts of that case are obviously distinguishable from the facts
surrounding the MPS. In
Clean Air Markets, the New York statute clearly limited
the ability to trade allowances by among other things requiring that a restrictive
covenant be placed on an allowance when traded. The Clean Air Markets court
found that the restrictions on trading violated both the Commerce Clause and the
Supremacy Clause. However, that is not the case with the MPS. The MPS does
not restrict trading; rather, an allowance is surrendered to the Agency, which in
turn retires the allowance. Agreeing to participate in the MPS and thus placing
the company in the position of surrendering an allowance is voluntary. If a
company does not participate in the MPS, nothing in the rule limits the ability to
trade, sell or purchase NO
x
and SO
2
allowances. Therefore, the MPS is factually
distinguishable from the New York statute and is not contrary to the Commerce
Clause or the Supremacy Clause.
As previously discussed, the Board finds that the MPS is voluntary. Nothing in
the language of the MPS requires a company to utilize the MPS. And in fact, the
proposed rule includes other options for compliance such as the TTBS and
averaging. Therefore, the Board finds that adopting the MPS is not contrary to the
court’s decision in U.S. v. Butler, 297 U.S. 1 (1936).
Due Process Clause
The Board finds that the rule does not violate the Due Process clause of the
Constitution. As discussed above, the measurement methods included in the
proposal are nearly identical to the measurement requirements of CAMR. Thus,
even if the Board were to adopt CAMR, the regulated community would be
subject to the same requirements for measurement. Further, the Board has found
that the measurement methods proposed are technically feasible and will allow for
the measurement of mercury emissions. Therefore, the rule does give proper
notice as to what will be noncompliance and accordingly does not violate the Due
Process Clause.
C)
Change in the Rule:
The Board made two major changes to its first notice proposal, namely the
addition of two new Sections to propose the temporary technology based
standards (TTBS) and a new Section to address the multi pollutant standards
(MPS). In addition to these new Sections the Board made the suggested changes
to the TTBS language that were proposed by Prairie State. Because the Board
published the TTBS rule language as a separate first notice proposal, the Board is
sending the TTBS Sections to second notice in a separate package that will be
filed concurrently with this second notice package for the Part 225 rule. The
changes to the TTBS language, made in response to Prairie State’s comments, will
be discussed in that filing package.
The MPS provisions were proposed on July 28, 2006, by Ameren and the Agency
in a joint statement asking that the Board include a multi-pollutant standard in the
proposed rule. On August 21, 2006, Dynegy and the Agency also filed a joint
statement with Dynegy joining in supporting the MPS and suggesting changes to
the MPS.
The MPS is a voluntary provision that allows Illinois units to comply with
mercury reductions using co-benefits from SO
2
and NO
x
emissions reductions. A
source must commit to reducing SO
2
and NO
x
emissions and, in exchange, the
source has additional time to achieve the mercury emissions standard of 0.0080
lb/GWh or 90% reduction of mercury. The MPS requires that SO
2
and NO
x
allowances necessary to meet the requirements of the MPS be surrendered to the
Agency for retirement. The MPS requires specific reductions of SO
2
and NO
x
emissions rates and imposes deadlines for installation of HCI controls. Ameren
and the Agency anticipate that installing and operating pollution control
equipment pursuant to the MPS will achieve significant reductions of SO
2
and
NO
x
emissions beyond those required by existing regulations and beyond the
federal Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR). Ameren and the Agency state that the
MPS is both technically feasible and economically reasonable and that the level of
SO
2
and NO
x
emissions reductions will contribute to Illinois’ efforts to achieve
attainment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS). Ameren also
testified to the technical feasibility and economic reasonableness of the MPS.
Dynegy’s joint statement with the Agency echoes the comments concerning the
reduction of SO
2
and NO
x
emissions made by the Ameren and the Agency in their
joint statement. Dynegy and the Agency also indicate that the revised proposal is
economically reasonable and technically feasible.
The Board added the MPS provisions to the rule as new Section 225.233.
Additionally, the Board made a number of nonsubstantive changes to the text of
the rule to clarify the rule language and to ensure consistency within the rule and
with the general style standards of the Board and the IAPA.
D)
Public Hearing Requests:
As previously stated, the Board held 10 days of hearings in Springfield (from June
12 through 23, 2006), and eight days of hearings in Chicago (from August 14
through 23, 2006). On August 24, 2006, Midwest Generation filed a motion for
additional hearings, primarily to discuss the MPS proposal. On August 31, 2006,
the Agency and Ameren responded in opposition to the motion for additional
hearings. Also on August 31, 2006, Kincaid Generation, L.L.C. (Kincaid) filed a
response supporting Midwest Generation’s motion.
The Board found that Midwest Generation had sufficient time to prepare
extensive questions on the MPS proposal for the Board’s second hearing in the
rulemaking and that holding another hearing would not aid the Board in
developing a full record. The Board denied the motion for an additional hearing.
10)
Justification and Rationale:
A)
Changes in Statutory Language: None
B)
Changes in Board Policy, Procedures or Structure: None
C)
Citations to Federal Laws, Rule or Regulations, or Finding Requirements: This
rulemaking is proposed to meet certain obligations of the State of Illinois under
the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 7401
et seq
.; specifically, to satisfy Illinois'
obligation to submit a State Implementation Plan to address the requirements of
the Clean Air Mercury Rule (CAMR), 70 Fed. Reg. 28606.
D)
Court Decisions: None
E)
Other Reasons: While this proposal is intended to satisfy the federal
requirements under the CAMR, the proposed rule has emission limits and
timelines that are more stringent that those found in the federal CAMR. The
Agency explained that while the proposed rule is consistent with CAMR, the
proposal addresses serious deficiencies present in the CAMR including the
unnecessary delay in achieving mercury emissions reductions, the inherent
concerns associated with a cap and trade program to control a persistent,
bioaccumulative toxin, the inadequate mercury reductions contained in the
CAMR, and the legal basis upon which CAMR was adopted.
11)
Name of Agency Representative:
Marie Tipsord
Illinois Pollution Control Board
100 W. Randolph, Suite 11-500.
Chicago, IL 60601
(312) 814-4925
AGENCY ANALYSIS OF ECONOMIC AND
BUDGETARY EFFECTS OF PROPOSED RULEMAKING
Agency: Illinois Pollution Control Board
Part/Title: “Control of Emissions from Large Combustion Sources”, 35 Ill. Adm. Code 225
Illinois Register Citation: May 19, 2006 (30 Ill. Reg
.
9281)
Please attempt to provide as dollar-specific responses as possible and feel free to add any
relevant narrative explanation.
The Mercury Rule in Brief
The proposed mercury rule would be effective upon filing. The rule as proposed requires
compliance beginning July 1, 2009 with a mercury emissions standard of 0.00801 lb/GWh or a
90% reduction from input mercury. The rule also includes a temporary technology based
standard (TTBS) and a multi-pollutant control system (MPS). There is already a federal rule
requiring mercury control, the Clean Air Mercury rule (CAMR) that takes effect if Illinois does
not adopt its own mercury rules. So, there would be costs to industry to comply with federal
mercury rules even if Illinois does not adopt its own mercury rules.
In letters of June 26 and 29, 2006 responding to the Board’s request for an economic impact
study, the Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity stated it did not have the
resources to perform economic impact studies on this rulemaking.
The record created at hearing and in public comments indicates that, for some electrical
generating units (EGUs), installation of the control technology to reach compliance with another
existing federal rule will have the “co-benefit” of achieving compliance with the mercury rule.
That other federal rule (that also takes effect if Illinois does not adopt its own rule) is the Clean
Air Interstate Rule (CAIR) requiring additional controls on emissions of nitrous oxide and sulfur
dioxide.
The testimony from 18 days of hearing and over 7,200 public comments led the Board to
conclude that the proposed rules is economically reasonable and technically feasible. The Board
has included a detailed economic analysis of this proposed rule in its November 2, 2006 opinion
and order in Docket R06-25. The entire opinion and order is included with this second notice
package. The following responses are briefly summarized from the extensive discussion in the
Board’s opinion.
1.
Anticipated effect on State expenditures and revenues.
(a)
Current cost to the agency for this program/activity.
$ Unknown, The Board does not break its costs down by case type or program,
and so cannot determine how many enforcement cases, permit appeals, or
variance requests may be attributable to this new rule.
(b)
If this rulemaking will result in an increase or decrease in cost, specify the fiscal
year in which this change will first occur and the dollar amount of the effect.
As early as FY 07, the Board could see requests for variances and adjusted
standards, as the rule is stayed as to sources that file such requests within 20 days
of a rule’s effective date. See 415 ILCS 5/28.1, 38(b). Beginning in FY 09 and
10, the Board could see mercury enforcement actions or permit appeals, as well as
additional requests for variances or adjusted standards.
(c)
Indicate the funding source, including Fund and appropriation lines, for this
program/activity.
N/A
(d)
If an increase or decrease in the costs of another State agency is anticipated,
specify the fiscal year in which this change will first occur and the estimated
dollar amount of the effect.
While the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency did not present testimony to
quantify any changes to its costs as a result of the proposed rule, the Board
anticipates that the Agency will likely see an increase in its permit review and
enforcement expenses regarding electrical generating units.
(e)
Will this rulemaking have any effect on State revenues or expenditures not
already indicated above? Specify effects and amounts.
N/A
2.
Economic effect on persons affected by the rulemaking.
(a)
Indicate the economic effect and specify the persons affected:
This rule will impose new expenses on owners and operators of large electrical
generating units (EGUs), but will also have an economic benefit to the citizens of
Illinois by reduction of adverse health effects from ingestion of mercury in fish.
Dollar amount per person: See below
Total Statewide cost: See below
Industry-wide, owners and operators of large EGUs are estimated to incur yearly
additional control costs of $33 million. The testimony translated that cost into an
average cost increase for the Illinois coal plants of $0.375/MWh, but each power
plant will incur greater or lesser costs to their site-specific configuration. The
Board recognizes that the cost for some units such as those opting into MPS may
be higher, but those costs also represent the “co-benefit” cost of controlling SO
2
and NOx.
(b)
If an economic effect is predicted, please briefly describe how the effect will
occur.
The proposed rule will require many EGUs to use different emission control
technologies, which will result in new costs that the Board assumes will be passed
on to consumers.
The positive effects are estimated to result from the decreased levels of mercury
in the waters of Illinois, with a resulting drop in the mercury levels in the fish.
This is anticipated to result in fewer fish advisories for the waters of Illinois,
benefiting sports and subsistence fisherman alike.
(c)
Will the rulemaking have an indirect effect that may result in increased
administrative costs? Will there be any change in requirements such as filing,
documentation, reporting or completion of forms? Compare to current
requirements.
The mercury rule is a proposed new rule; therefore all of the reporting and
recordkeeping requirements are new requirements. But, EGU’s are already
required to have air permits that subject them to various other reporting and
recordkeeping requirements. The mercury requirements are, however, in line with
the federally mandated (CAMR) reporting requirements for control of mercury
emissions.
ATTACHMENT A
FIRST NOTICE CHANGES
AGENCY: Pollution Control Board
RULEMAKING: “Control of Emissions from Large Combustion Sources” 35 Ill. Adm. Code
225; May 19, 2006 (30 Ill. Reg
.
9281)
1) After line 28 add
225.233 Multi Pollutant Standard (MPS)
2) In lines 50, 55, 129, 189, 190, 194 (twice), 243, 282, 300, 305, 311, 328, 331, 335, 338, 368,
386, 388, 392, 401, 412, 422, 462, 514, 548, 549, 557, 567, 571, 587, 626, 632, 637, 649,
665, 670, 674, 681, 707, 721, 724, 753, 762, 822, 828, 832, 851, 855, 874, 879, 881, 885,
939, 954, 977, 982, 996, 1004, 1007, 1016, 1027, 1030, 1034, 1041, 1048, 1055, 1058, 1061,
1079, 1084, 1095, 1103, 1108, 1119, 1126, 1129, 1139, 1145, 1155, 1158, 1160, 1164, 1166,
1178, 1192, 1197, 1200, 1236, 1237, 1238, 1242, 1245, 1345, 1353, 1355, 1359, and 1360
change “shall” to “must”
3) In line 58 after “CAAPP Clean Air Act Permit Program” add “CEMS
continuous
emission monitoring system”
4) In line 58 after “lb
pound” add “MPS
Multi Pollutant Standard”
5) In line 58 after “SO
2
sulfur dioxide” add “TTBS
Temporary
Technology Based Standard”
6) In lines 62 through 65, change “The definitions contained in this Section apply only to the
provisions of this Part. Unless otherwise defined in this Section and unless a different meaning
of a term is clear from it’s context, the definitions of terms used in this Part shall have the
meanings specified for those terms in 35 Ill. Adm. Code 211.” To “The following definitions
contained in this Section apply only to for the provisions purposes of this Part. Unless otherwise
defined in this Section
and unless or a different meaning of for a term is clear from it’s its
context, the definitions of terms used in this Part shall have the meanings specified for those
terms in 35 Ill. Adm. Code 211.”
7) After line 66 add
“
“Agency” means the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency.
[415 ILCS
5/3.105]”
8) After line 69 add:
““Base Emission Rate” means, for a group of EGUs subject to emission standards for
NOx and SO
2
pursuant to Section 225.233, the average emission rate of NOx or SO
2
from
the EGUs, in pounds per million Btu heat input, for calendar years 2003 through 2005
(or, for seasonal NOx, the 2003 through 2005 ozone seasons), as determined from the
data collected and quality assured by the USEPA pursuant to the 40 CFR 72 and 96
federal Acid Rain and NOx Budget Trading Programs for the emissions and heat input of
that group of EGUs.
“Board” means the Illinois Pollution Control Board.
[415 ILCS 5/3.105]”
9) In line 85 change “chemical process” to “chemical processing of coal”
10) In line 91 after “turbine” add “of which both of the following conditions are true”
11) In line 93 change “Having equipment used” to “It uses equipment”
12) In line 97 change “Producing” to “It produces either of the following”
13) In line 97 change “starting” to “beginning”
14) In line 98 add “subsequent” after “”any”
15) In line 98 add a comma after “electricity”
16) In line 98 change “after the calendar year in which” to “after that”
17) In line 101 add “, both of the following” after “unit”
18) In line 103 change “5” to “five”
19) In line 111 change the period after “output” to “; or”
20) In lines 126, 133, 159, 163, 185 change “with regards to” to “for the purposes of”
21) In lines 127, 130, 139, 141, 146, and 161 change “Electrical Generating Unit” to “EGU”
22) In line 204 change “60.49a(k)(1), 60.49a(p)” to “60.49a(k)(1) and (p)”
23) In line 209 after “ASTM.” Add “The following methods from the”
24) Change lines 212 through 213 to read:
“ASTM D388-77
(approved February 25, 1977), D388-90 (approved March 30,
1990), D388-91a (approved April 15, 1991), D388-95 (approved January 15,
1995), D388-98a (approved September 10, 1998), or D388-99 (approved
September 10, 1999, reapproved in 2004), Classification of Coals by Rank”
25) In lines 238, 268, 290, 291, 297, 302, 305, 307, 321, 324, 329, 331, 335, 338, 348, 349, 364,
378, 381, 386, 388, 392, 400, 411, 417 (twice), 422, 428 (twice), 434, 439, 454, 462, 468, 475,
493, 498, 499, 544, 547, 549, 558, 665, 672, 797, 803, 838, 887, 907, 1046, 1053, 1115, 1139,
1204, 1236, 1247, 1261, 1277, 1288, 1299 add “B” after “Subpart”
26) In line 239 add “operating” after “units”
27) In lines 248, 252, 255, 259, and 263 after the closing parenthesis add “, incorporated by
reference in Section 225.140”
28) In line 299 change “under” to “of”
29) In lines 313 and 314, change “This period may be extended for cause, at any time prior to the
end of five years, in writing by the Agency” to “This period may be extended, in
writing by the Agency, for cause, at any time prior to the end of five years.”
30) In line316 change “information,” to “information gathered”
31) In line 317 delete “of this Subpart”
32) In line 339 change “and” to “or”
33) In line 357 change “by” to “on or before”
34) In line 372 add “U.S. Department of Energy” before “Energy Information”
35) In line 428 in the definition of “I
i
” change “pounds” to “lbs”
36) In line 432 change “with one of the above” to “with the”
37) In line 438 change “For this purpose” to “For the purpose of demonstrating compliance with
the alternative emission standards of this subsection (b)”
38) In line 467 change “an EGU” to “multiple EGUs”
39) In line 473 change “For this purpose” to “For the purposes of the alternative emission
standard of subsection (d)(1) of this Section”
40) In line 500 change “that shows” to “that demonstrates”
41) In line 514 change “be determined” to “be demonstrated”
42) In line 515 delete “of this Subpart” after “(d)(2)”
43) In lines 516 and 517 change “rather than only” to “rather than by using only”
44) In line 529 delete “Electric Energy, Inc., ID 127855AAC;”
45) After line 560 add,
Section 225.233
Multi-Pollutant Standards (MPS)
a)
General.
1)
As an alternative to compliance with the emissions standards of Section
225.230(a), the owner of eligible EGUs may elect for those EGUs to
demonstrate compliance pursuant to this Section, which establishes
control requirements and standards for emissions of NO
x
and SO
2
, as well
as for emissions of mercury.
2)
For the purpose of this Section, the following requirements apply:
A)
An eligible EGU is an EGU that is located in Illinois and which
commenced commercial operation on or before December 31,
2004; and
B)
Ownership of an eligible EGU is determined based on direct
ownership, by the holding a majority interest in a company that
owns the EGU or EGUs, or by the common ownership of the
company that owns the EGU, whether through a parent-subsidiary
relationship, as a sister corporation, or as an affiliated corporation
with the same parent corporation, provided that the owner has the
right or authority to submit a CAAPP application on behalf of the
EGU.
3)
The owner of one or more EGUs electing to demonstrate compliance with
this Subpart B pursuant to this Section must submit an application for a
CAAPP permit modification to the Agency, as provided in Section 225.,
that includes the information specified in subsection (b) of this Section
and which clearly states the owner’s election to demonstrate compliance
pursuant to this Section 225.233.
A)
If the owner of one or more EGUs elects to demonstrate
compliance with this Subpart pursuant to this Section, then all
EGUs it owns in Illinois as of July 1, 2006, as defined in
subsection (a)(2)(B) of this Section, must be thereafter subject to
the standards and control requirements of this Section, except as
provided in subsection (a)(3)(B) below. Such EGUs must be
referred to as a Multi-Pollutant Standard (MPS) Group.
B)
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the owner may exclude from the an
MPS Group any EGU scheduled for permanent shutdown that the
owner so designates in its CAAPP application required to be
submitted pursuant to subsection (a)(3) of this Section, with
compliance for such units to be achieved by means of Section
225.235.
4)
When an EGU is subject to the requirements of this Section, the
requirements apply to all owners and operators of the EGU, and to the
designated representative for the EGU.
b)
Notice of Intent.
The owner of one or more EGUs that intends to comply with this Subpart B by
means of this Section must notify the Agency of its intention by December 31,
2007. The following information must accompany the notification:
1)
The identification of each EGU that will be complying with this Subpart B
by means of the multi-pollutant standards contained in this Section, with
evidence that the owner has identified all EGUs that it owned in Illinois as
of July 1, 2006 and which commenced commercial operation on or before
December 31, 2004;
2)
If an EGU identified in subsection (b)(1) of this Section is also owned or
operated by a person different than the owner submitting the notice of
intent, a demonstration that the submitter has the right to commit the EGU
or authorization from the responsible official for the EGU accepting the
application.;
3)
The Base Emission Rates for the EGUs, with copies of supporting data
and calculations.;
4)
A summary of the current control devices installed and operating on each
EGU and identification of the additional control devices that will likely be
needed for the each EGU to comply with emission control requirements of
this Section, including identification of each EGU in the MPS group that
will be addressed by subsection (c)(1)(B) of this Section, with information
showing that the eligibility criteria for this subsection (b) are satisfied; and
5)
Identification of each EGU that is scheduled for permanent shut down, as
provided by Section 225.235, which will not be part of the MPS Group
and which will not be demonstrating compliance with this Subpart B
pursuant to this Section.
c)
Control Technology Requirements for Emissions of Mercury
:.
1)
Requirements for EGUs in an MPS Group.
A)
For each EGU in an MPS Group other than an EGU that is
addressed by subsection (c)(1)(B) of this Section for the period
beginning July 1, 2009 (or December 31, 2009 for an EGU for
which an SO
2
scrubber or fabric filter is being installed to be in
operation by December 31, 2009), and ending on December 31,
2014 (or such earlier date that the EGU is subject to the mercury
emission standard in subsection (d)(1) of this Section), the owner
or operator of the EGU must shall install, to the extent not already
installed, and properly operate and maintain one of the following
emissions control devices:
i)
A Halogenated Activated Carbon Injection System,
complying with the sorbent injection requirements of
subsection (c)(2) of this Section, except as may be
otherwise provided by subsection (c)(4) of this Section, and
followed by a Cold-Side Electrostatic Precipitator or Fabric
Filter; or
ii)
If the boiler fires bituminous coal, a Selective Catalytic
Reduction (SCR) System and an SO
2
Scrubber.
B)
An owner of an EGU in an MPS Group has two options under this
subsection (c). For an MPS Group that contains EGUs smaller
than 90 gross MW in capacity, the owner may designate any such
EGUs to be not subject to subsection (c)(1)(A) of this Section. Or,
for an MPS Group that contains EGUs with gross MW capacity of
less than 115 MW, the owner may designate any such EGUs to be
not subject to subsection (c)(1)(A) of this Section, provided that
the aggregate gross MW capacity of the designated EGUs does not
exceed 4% of the total gross MW capacity of the MPS Group. For
any EGU subject to one of these two options, unless the EGU is
subject to the emission standards in subsection (d)(2) of this
Section, beginning on January 1, 2013, and continuing until such
date that the owner or operator of the EGU commits to comply
with the mercury emission standard in subsection (d)(2) of this
Section, the owner or operator of the EGU must install and
properly operate and maintain a Halogenated Activated Carbon
Injection System that complies with the sorbent injection
requirements of subsection (c)(2) of this Section, except as may be
otherwise provided by subsection (c)(4) of this Section, and
followed by either a Cold-Side Electrostatic Precipitator or Fabric
Filter. The use of a properly installed, operated, and maintained
Halogenated Activated Carbon Injection System that meets the
sorbent injection requirements of subsection (c)(2) of this Section
is defined as the “principal control technique.”
2)
For each EGU for which injection of halogenated activated carbon is
required by subsection (c)(1) of this Section, the owner or operator of the
EGU must inject halogenated activated carbon in an optimum manner,
which, except as provided in subsection (c)(4) of this Section, is defined as
all of the following:
A)
The use of an injection system designed for effective absorption of
mercury, considering the configuration of the EGU and its
ductwork;
B)
The injection of halogenated activated carbon manufactured by
Alstom, Norit, or Sorbent Technologies, or the injection of any
other halogenated activated carbon or sorbent that the owner or
operator of the EGU has demonstrated to have similar or better
effectiveness for control of mercury emissions; and
C)
The injection of sorbent at the following minimum rates, as
applicable:
i)
For an EGU firing subbituminous coal, 5.0 lbs per million
actual cubic feet or, for any cyclone-fired EGU that will
install a scrubber and baghouse by December 31, 2012, and
which already meets an emission rate of 0.020 lb
mercury/GWh gross electrical output or at least 75 percent
reduction of input mercury, 2.5 lbs per million actual cubic
feet;
ii)
For an EGU firing bituminous coal, 10.0 lbs per million
actual cubic feet or for any cyclone-fired EGU that will
install a scrubber and baghouse by December 31, 2012, and
which already meets an emission rate of 0.020 lb
mercury/GWh gross electrical output or at least 75 percent
reduction of input mercury, 5.0 lbs per million actual cubic
feet;
iii)
For an EGU firing a blend of subbituminous and
bituminous coal, a rate that is the weighted average of the
above rates, based on the blend of coal being fired.; or
iv)
A rate or rates set lower by the Agency, in writing, than the
rate specified in any of subsections (c)(2)(C)(i),
(c)(2)(C)(ii), or (c)(2)(C)(iii) of this Section on a unit-
specific basis, provided that the owner or operator of the
EGU has demonstrated that such rate or rates are needed so
that carbon injection will not increase particulate matter
emissions or opacity so as to threaten noncompliance with
applicable requirements for particulate matter or opacity.
D)
For the purposes of subsection (c)(2)(C) of this Section, the flue
gas flow rate must be determined for the point of sorbent injection;
provided that this flow rate may be assumed to be identical to the
stack flow rate if the gas temperatures at the point of injection and
the stack are normally within 100
o
F, or the flue gas flow rate may
otherwise be calculated from the stack flow rate, corrected for the
difference in gas temperatures.
3)
The owner or operator of an EGU that seeks to operate an EGU with an
activated carbon injection rate or rates that are set on a unit-specific basis
pursuant to subsection (c)(2)(C)(iv) of this Section must submit an
application to the Agency proposing such rate or rates, and must meet the
requirements of subsections (c)(3)(A) and (c)(3)(B) of this Section, subject
to the limitations of subsections (c)(3)(C) and (c)(3)(D) of this Section:
A)
The application must be submitted as an application for a new or
revised federally enforceable operating permit for the EGU, and it
must include a summary of relevant mercury emission data for the
EGU, the unit-specific injection rate or rates that are proposed, and
detailed information to support the proposed injection rate or rates;
and
B)
This application must be submitted no later than the date that
activated carbon must first be injected. For example, the owner or
operator of an EGU that must inject activated carbon pursuant to
subsection (c)(1)(A) of this subsection must apply for unit-specific
injection rate or rates by July 1, 2009. Thereafter, the owner or
operator of the EGU may supplement its application.
C)
Any decision of the Agency denying a permit or granting a permit with
conditions that set a lower injection rate or rates may be appealed to the
Board pursuant to Section 39 of the Act; and
D)
The owner or operator of an EGU may operate at the injection rate or rates
proposed in its application until a final decision is made on the
application, including a final decision on any appeal to the Board.
4)
During any evaluation of the effectiveness of a listed sorbent, an
alternative sorbent, or other technique to control mercury emissions, the
owner or operator of an EGU need not comply with the requirements of
subsection (c)(2) of this Section for any system needed to carry out the
evaluation, as further provided below:
A)
The owner or operator of the EGU must conduct the evaluation in
accordance with a formal evaluation program submitted to the
Agency at least 30 days prior to commencement of the evaluation;
B)
The duration and scope of the evaluation may not exceed the
duration and scope reasonably needed to complete the desired
evaluation of the alternative control technique, as initially
addressed by the owner or owner in a support document submitted
with the evaluation program.;
C)
The owner or operator of the EGU must submit a report to the
Agency no later than 30 days after the conclusion of the evaluation
that describes the evaluation conducted and which provides the
results of the evaluation; and
D)
If the evaluation of the alternative control technique shows less
effective control of mercury emissions from the EGU than was
achieved with the principal control technique, the owner or
operator of the EGU must resume use of the principal control
technique. If the evaluation of the alternative control technique
shows comparable effectiveness to the principal control technique,
the owner or operator of the EGU may either continue to use the
alternative control technique in a manner that is at least as effective
as the principal control technique, or it may resume use of the
principal control technique. If the evaluation of the alternative
control technique shows more effective control of mercury
emissions than the control technique, the owner or operator of the
EGU must continue to use the alternative control technique in a
manner that is more effective than the principal control technique,
so long as it continues to be subject to this subsection (c) of this
Section.
5)
In addition to complying with the applicable recordkeeping and
monitoring requirements in Sections 225.240 through 225.290, the
owner or operator of an EGU that elects to comply with this Subpart B
by means of this Section must also comply with the following additional
requirements:
A)
For the first 36 months that injection of sorbent is required, it must
maintain records of the usage of sorbent, the exhaust gas flow rate
from the EGU, and the sorbent feed rate, in pounds per million
actual cubic feet of exhaust gas at the injection point, on a weekly
average;
B)
After the first 36 months that injection of sorbent is required, it
must monitor activated sorbent feed rate to the EGU, flue gas
temperature at the point of sorbent injection, and exhaust gas flow
rate from the EGU, automatically recording this data and the
sorbent carbon feed rate, in pounds per million actual cubic feet of
exhaust gas at the injection point, on an hourly average
.; and
C)
If a blend of bituminous and sub-bituminous coal is fired in the
EGU, it must keep records of the amount of each type or coal
burned and the required injection rate for injection of activated
carbon, on a weekly basis.
6)
In addition to complying with the applicable reporting requirements in
Sections 225.240 through 225.290, the owner or operator of an EGU that
elects to comply with this Subpart B by means of this Section must also
submit quarterly reports for the recordkeeping and monitoring conducted
pursuant to subsection (c)(5) of this Section.
d)
Emission Standards for Mercury.
1)
For each EGU in an MPS Group that is not addressed by subsection
(c)(1)(B) of this Section, beginning January 1, 2015 (or such earlier date
when the owner or operator of the EGU notifies the Agency that it will
comply with these standards) and continuing thereafter, the owner or
operator of the EGU must comply with one of the following standards on
a rolling 12-month basis:
A)
An emission standard of 0.0080 lb mercury/GWh gross electrical
output; or
B)
A minimum 90-percent reduction of input mercury.
2)
For each EGU in an MPS Group that has been addressed under subsection
(c)(1)(B) of this Section, beginning on the date when the owner or
operator of the EGU notifies the Agency that it will comply with these
standards and continuing thereafter, the owner or operator of the EGU
must comply with one of the following standards on a rolling 12-month
basis:
A)
An emission standard of 0.0080 lb mercury/GWh gross electrical
output; or
B)
A minimum 90-percent reduction of input mercury.
3)
Compliance with the mercury emission standard or reduction requirement
of this subsection (d) must be calculated in accordance with Section
225.230(a) or (d).
e)
Emission Standards for NO
x
and SO
2
.
1)
NO
x
Emission Standards.
A)
Beginning in calendar year 2012, and continuing in each calendar
thereafter, for the EGUs in each MPS Group, the owner and
operator of the EGUs must comply with an overall NOx annual
emission rate of no more than 0.11 lbs/million Btu or an emission
rate equivalent to 52 percent of the Base Annual Rate of NO
x
emissions, whichever is more stringent.
B)
Beginning in the 2012 ozone season and continuing in each ozone
season thereafter, for the EGUs in each MPS Group, the owner and
operator of the EGUs must comply with an overall NO
x
seasonal
emission rate of no more than 0.11 lbs/million Btu or an emission
rate equivalent to 80 percent of the Base Seasonal Rate of NO
x
emissions, whichever is more stringent.
2)
SO
2
Emissions Standards.
A)
Beginning in calendar year 2013 and continuing in calendar year
2014, for the EGUs in each MPS Group, the owner and operator of
the EGUs must comply with an overall SO
2
annual emission rate
of 0.33 lbs/million Btu or a rate equivalent to 44 percent of the
Base Rate of SO
2
emissions, whichever is more stringent.
B)
Beginning in calendar year 2015, and continuing in each calendar
year thereafter, for the EGUs in each MPS Grouping, the owner
and operator of the EGUs must comply with an overall annual
emission rate for SO
2
of 0.25 lbs/million Btu or a rate equivalent to
35 percent of the Base Rate of SO
2
emissions, whichever is more
stringent.
3)
Compliance with the NO
x
and SO
2
emission standards must be
demonstrated in accordance with Sections 225.310, 225.410, and 225.510.
The owner or operator of EGUs must complete the demonstration of
compliance before March 1 of the following year for annual standards and
before November 1 for seasonal standards, by which date a compliance
report must be submitted to the Agency.
f)
Requirements for NO
x
and SO
2
Allowances.
1)
The owner or operator of EGUs in an MPS Group must not sell or trade to
any person or otherwise exchange with or give to any person NO
x
allowances allocated to the EGUs in the MPS Group for vintage years
2012 and beyond that would otherwise be available for sale, trade, or
exchange as a result of actions taken to comply with the standards in
subsection (e) of this Section. Such allowances that are not retired for
compliance must be surrendered to the Agency on an annual basis,
beginning in calendar year 2013. This provision does not apply to the use,
sale, exchange, gift, or trade of allowances among the EGUs in an MPS
Group.
2)
The owners or operators of EGUs in an MPS Group must not sell or trade
to any person or otherwise exchange with or give to any person SO
2
allowances allocated to the EGUs in the MPS Group for vintage years
2013 and beyond that would otherwise be available for sale or trade as a
result of actions taken to comply with the standards in subsection (e) of
this Section. Such allowances that are not retired for compliance or
otherwise surrendered pursuant to a consent decree to which the State of
Illinois is a party, must be surrendered to the Agency on an annual basis,
beginning in calendar year 2014. This provision does not apply to the use,
sale, exchange, gift, or trade of allowances among the EGUs in an MPS
Group.
3)
The provisions of this subsection (f) do not restrict or inhibit the sale or
trading of allowances that become available from one or more EGUs in a
MPS Group as a result of holding allowances that represent over-
compliance with the NO
x
or SO
2
standard in subsection (e) of this Section,
once such a standard becomes effective, whether such over-compliance
results from control equipment, fuel changes, changes in the method of
operation, unit shut downs, or other reasons.
4)
For purposes of this subsection (f), NO
x
and SO
2
allowances mean
allowances necessary for compliance with Sections 225.310, 225.410, or
225.510 40 CFR 72, or Subparts AA and AAAA of 40 CFR 96. This
Section does not prohibit the owner or operator of EGUs in an MPS Group
from purchasing or otherwise obtaining allowances from other sources as
allowed by law for purposes of complying with federal or state
requirements, except as specifically set forth in this Section.
5)
Before March 1, 2010, and continuing each year thereafter, the owner or
operator of EGUs in an MPS Group must submit a report to the Agency
that demonstrates compliance with the requirements of this subsection (f)
for the previous calendar year, and which includes identification of any
allowances that have been surrendered to the USEPA or to the Agency,
and any allowances that were sold, gifted, used, exchanged, or traded
because they became available due to over-compliance. All allowances
that are required to be surrendered must be surrendered by August 31,
unless USEPA has not yet deducted the allowances from the previous
year. A final report must be submitted to the Agency by August 31 of
each year, verifying that the actions described in the initial report have
taken place or, if such actions have not taken place, an explanation of all
changes that have occurred and the reasons for such changes. If USEPA
has not deducted the allowances from the previous year by August 31, the
final report must be due, and all allowances required to be surrendered
must be surrendered, within 30 days after such deduction occurs.
g)
Notwithstanding 35 Ill. Adm. Code 201.146(hhh), until an EGU has complied with the
applicable emission standards of subsections (d) and (e) of this Section for 12 months, the
owner or operator of the EGU must obtain a construction permit for any new or modified
air pollution control equipment that it proposes to construct for control of emissions of
mercury, NO
x
, or SO
2
.”
46) In line 563 delete “of this Subpart” after “225.230(a)”
47) In line 564 change “as follows” to “as described in this Section”
48) In lines 566 and 567 change “The owner or operator of an EGU for which this Section is
being relied upon shall by no later than” to “The owner or operator of an EGU
that relies on this Section must complete the following actions before”
49) In line 569 change “Illinois EPA” to “Agency”
50) In lines 571 and 572 change “shall be accompanied by” to “must include”
51) In line 582 change “permit(s)” to “permits”
52) In lines 586 and 587, change “for which this Section is being relied upon shall by no later
than June 30, 2010” to “that relies on this Section must, before June 30, 2010, complete the
following actions”
53) In line 590 change “addressed by” to “described in”
54) In line 593 change “permit(s)” to “permits”
55) In lines 601 and 605 change “units” to “unit”
56) In line 610 change “Illinois EPA” to “Agency”
57) In line 610 change “such” to “the specified”
58) In lines 614 and 615 change “in which case the date for shut down of the EGU may be
extended” to “in which case the Agency may accept the demonstration as substantiated and
extend the date for shut down of the EGU”
59) In line 618 change “units” to “unit”
60) In line 620 change the period to “; or”
61) In line 623 change “units” to “unit”
62) In lines 630, 631, 633, 636, 638, 658, 684, 692, 775, 783, 792, 811, 833, 836, 847, 868, 877,
946, 1023, 1035, 1048, 1055, 1190 delete “of this Subpart”
63) In line 662 change “shall” to “will”
64) In lines 664 and 665 change “continuous emission monitoring systems” to “CEMs”
65) In line 666 change “in terms of calendar months” to “based on calendar months”
66) In line 672 after “CFR 75” add “(sections 75.80 through 75.84), incorporated by reference in
Section 225.140”
67) In lines 683, 690, 705, 716, 740, 752, 761, 767, 797, 825, 828, 835, 846, 857, 887, 889, 907,
922, 931, 938, 949, 951, 957, 958, 971, 1002, 1009, 1010, 1023, 1079, 1097, 1119, 1149, 1152,
1156, 1218, 1348 change “under” to “pursuant to”
68) In line 695 change “quality-assure” to “assure the quality of”
69) In line 700 change “also” to “it must”
70) In line 704 change “(f), and submit” to “(f). Also the owner or operator must submit”
71) In line 706 change “Illinois EPA” to “Agency”
72) In line 708 change “conducted by the” to “conducted by the applicable of the”
73) In lines 723, 726 change “the following” to “the applicable of the following”
74) In line 740 change “(2)” to “(b)(2)”
75) In line 747 add a period after “Data”
75) In line 754 add “the” after “report”
76) In line 754 add “the” after “as appropriate”
77) In line 755 add “the” before “stack gas flow”
78) In line 755 add “the” before “stack gas moisture”
79) In line 763 add “as set forth” after “procedures”
80) In line 770 add a period after “Prohibitions”
81) In lines 772, 780, 786, 795 change “shall” to “may”
82) In line 774 delete “any”
83) Inline 780 change “the” to “its”
84) In lines 786-787, 796, 823, 824, 832, 845, 856, 859, 861, 867 change “continuous emission
monitoring system” to “CEMS”
85) In line 816 change “applicable provisions of 40 CFR 75” to “provisions of 40 CFR 75.4 and
75.64 relating to”
86) In line 825 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75.15”
87) In line 827 change “low mass emissions” to “low-mass-emissions”
88) In line 828 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75.81(b)”
89) In line 828 add “set forth” after “procedures”
90) In lines 835 and 836 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR
75.80(d)”
91) In line 850 add “, each incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75”
92) In line 852 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75.20(b)”
93) In line 860 after “include” add “, but are not limited to,”
94) In line 866 after “through” add “(a)(3)”
95) In lines 868 through 872 change “For recertifications, replace the words "certification" and
"initial certification" with the word "recertification", replace the word "certified" with the word
"recertified", and follow the procedures in 40 CFR 75.20(b)(5) in lieu of the procedures in
subsection (a)(3)(E) of this Section.” To read “For recertifications,
replace the words
“certification” and “initial certification” with are to be read as the word “recertification”, replace
the word “certified” with is to be read as the word “recertified”, and follow the procedures set
forth in 40 CFR 75.20(b)(5) are to be followed in lieu of the procedures set forth in subsection
(a)(3)(E) of this Section.”
96) In line 882 add ““, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75.63”
97) In line 886 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75.20(a)(3)”
98) In lines 899, 912, 916, 932 change “will” to “must”
99) In line 903 change “such a notice” to “ a written notice of approval or disapproval”
100) In line 906 add “which” after “and”
101) In line 924, 936, 993 change “shall” to “will”
102) In line 929 add a comma after “40 CFR 75”
103) In line 940 change “certification in” to “certification set forth in”
104) In line 952 change “then” to “the owner or operator must fulfill the following requirements”
105) In lines 954 and 955 delete the commas after “values” and “system” and add “and” after
system
106) In line 957 change “75.21(e) and” to “75.21(e), “
107) In line 959 add “, each incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “75.20(a)(5)(i)”
108) In lines 963, 970, and 975 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40
CFR 75”
109) In lines 1002 through 1005 change “The owner or operator of an EGU qualified to use the
mercury low mass emissions excepted methodology under 40 CFR 75.81(b) shall meet the
applicable certification and recertification requirements in 40 CFR 75.81(c) through (f).” to read
“The owner or operator that has elected to use the mercury-low-mass-emissions-excepted
methodology for a qualified EGU pursuant to 40 CFR 75.81(b) must meet the applicable
certification and recertification requirements in 40 CFR 75.81(c) through (f), incorporated by
reference in Section 225.140.”
110) In line 1015 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75”
111) In line 1017 add “, each incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75”
112) In line 1025 change “will” to “must”
113) In line 1027 add “(b)” after “subsection”
114) In line 1042 change “report heat” to “report the heat”
115) In line 1042 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75”
116) In line 1055 change “shall:” to “must fulfill the following requirements”
117) In line 1061 change “such a manner so as to provide” to “a manner that provides”
118) In lines 1066, 1069, and 1073 change “or equivalent” to “or an equivalent method”
119) In line 1096 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140 (as a segment of 40 CFR
75)” after “40 CFR 75.61”
120) In line 1097 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR
75.82(b)(2)(ii)”
121) In line 1106 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75.84”
122) In line 1150 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75”
123) In line 1153 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75”
124) In line 1156 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75.84(f)”
125) In line 1170 add “, incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR 75”
126) In line 1187 change “Relative Accuracy Test Audit(s)” to “RATAs”
127) In line 1244 change “certification” to “it must certify”
128) In line 1245 add “appropriate data as set forth in subsections (d)(2)(A) through (d)(2)(E) of
this Section, together with the data set forth in subsection (d)(2)(F) of this Section” after
“following”
129) In line 1348 add “,incorporated by reference in Section 225.140” after “40 CFR
75.82(b)(2)(ii)”
SECOND NOTICE
1)
Agency:
Pollution Control Board
2)
Title and Administrative Code Citation: “Control of Emissions from Large Combustion
Sources”, 35 Ill. Adm. Code 225
3)
Date and Citation to Illinois Register: July 28, 2006 (30 Ill. Reg. 12706)
4)
Text and Location of any Changes from First Notice: See Attachment A
5)
Response to Codification Recommendations: No changes were requested by the
Secretary of State.
6)
Incorporations by Reference: This rulemaking does not include any materials
incorporated by reference.
7)
Final Regulatory Flexibility Analysis:
A)
Summary of Issues Raised By Small Business:
The Board did not receive any comments from any self-described small
businesses.
B)
Description of Actions and Alternatives Proposed by Small
Business during First Notice:
None
8)
Compliance with Section 5-30 of the APA and 1 Ill. Adm. Code 220.285:
The Board placed the proposal on the Board’s Web site. The Board also notified the
public through the Board’s Environmental Register. The Board did not receive a
comment from the Small Business Office.
9)
A)
List of Commenters:
This second notice package is intended to be read in conjunction with the Board’s
submission for the remainder of the mercury emission control regulations in
proposed new Part 225. The following list of commenters comes from the general
list of comments that were received in the Board’s rulemaking docket
Proposed
New 35 Ill. Adm. Code 225 Control of Emissions from Large Combustion
Sources (Mercury) (R06-25). A specific summary of the comments that were
directly related to the temporary technology based standards (TTBS) Sections
follows the general summary of commenters.
The Board received 7,286 public comments in this rulemaking. Due to the
volume of comments received in this rulemaking, the Board is attaching a listing
of the comments, as they were docketed by the Clerk’s office, to this second
notice submission as Attachment B.
Those comments range from lengthy post-hearing comments from the participants
to postcards and notes from citizens of the State. The overwhelming majority of
the comments support the adoption of the Agency’s proposal.
B)
Issues Raised
The Board added the TTBS provisions in response to the Agency’s May 18, 2006
request for the Board to supplement the original Part 225 rule (proposed to the
Board on March 14, 2006).
The Board has received comments from throughout the State and specifically
from the following organizations or public officials in support of the proposed
rule:
Sinai Health System (PC 6322)
Ounce of Prevention Fund (PC 6321)
Northern Illinois Public Health Consortium, Inc. (PC 6320)
Metropolitan Chicago Healthcare Council (PC 6319)
Illinois Public Health Association (PC 6318)
Illinois Maternal and Child Health Coalition (PC 6317)
Illinois Environmental Council and Alliance for the Great Lakes (PC 6316)
Illinois Division of the Izaak Walton League, Illinois Council of Trout Unlimited,
National Wildlife Federation, Natural Resource Defense Council,
Prairie Rivers Network (PC 6315)
Illinois Academy of Family Physicians (PC 6314)
Citizen Action Illinois (PC 6313)
Children’s Hospital of Illinois (PC 6312)
Child Care Coalition of Lake County (PC 6311)
American Lung Association of Metropolitan Chicago (PC 6310)
American Bottom Conservancy (PC 6309)
American Academy of Pediatrics, Illinois Chapter (PC 6308)
Access Living (PC 6307)
Advocate Health Care (PC 6306)
Sierra Club, Illinois Chapter (PC 6305)
Citizens Against Ruining the Environment (PC 6304)
Kathryn Tholih of Center for Neighborhood Technology (PC 6303)
Susan Spengler, President, League of Women Voters, Palatine Area (PC 6285)
April K. Holden, Village Clerk, Village of Downers Grove (PC 6276)
Sadhu A. Johnston, Commissioner, Chicago Department of Environment (PC
6232)
Illinois Public Interest Research Group (numerous comments)
Chicago Clean Power Coalition (numerous comments)
Representative Barbara Flynn Currie (PC 44)
Michael D. Belsky, Mayor, City of Highland Park (PC 3)
Mayor Richard H. Hyde, City of Waukegan (PC 2)
Governor Rod R. Blagojevich (PC 1)
The supporters of the rule discuss the issues concerning health effects from
ingestion of methylmercury. Many note that coal-fired plants are the main
stationary source of mercury in the State. The supporters urge the Board to adopt
the proposal submitted by the Agency. Among the public comments are a
substantial number of post cards, which echo the concerns about the health effects
of mercury ingestion.
The Board has also received the following comments in opposition to the
proposal:
Phillip M. Gonet, President, Illinois Coal Association (PC 6295)
Eugene M. Trisko, General Counsel, Unions for Jobs and the Environment (PC
6286)
Scott Wiseman, Vice President, Center for Energy and Economic Development,
Inc. Midwest Region (PC 6286)
The opponents rely on economic reasons for their opposition to the proposal.
They express concerns about the increased costs of generating electricity in
Illinois and the impact on consumers and businesses as a result. The opponents
urge the Board to adopt the federal CAMR rule instead of the Agency’s proposal.
Comments specific to the Temporary Technology Based Standards
Both Midwest Generation and Kincaid feel that the TTBS does not offer genuine
flexibility. Kincaid notes that the Kincaid facility is not eligible for the TTBS.
Midwest Generation maintains that to be eligible for a TTBS, a unit must install
the same control equipment as necessary to achieve 90% reduction. Further,
according to Midwest Generation the inclusion of the TTBS demonstrates the
Agency does not believe that the general rule is technically feasible.
The Board disagrees with Midwest Generation. Simply because a general rule
offers flexibility and alternative ways to achieve compliance does not mean the
rule is not technologically feasible. The Board has reviewed the record and as
discussed above, the Board finds the evidence supports the proposed standard of
90% reduction or 0.0080 lb/GWh emissions standard. As pointed out by the
Environmental Advocates, the inclusion of multiple avenues for compliance,
including the TTBS, is additional evidence to support the Board’s determination
that the rule is technically feasible.
Prairie State argues that because of the lack of long-term data, a technology based
standard must be included in the rule. Prairie State believes that such a standard
is necessary to bridge the gap between what technologies are capable of in 2009
versus 2018. Prairie State concedes that the short-term tests may be promising;
however, Prairie State believes that the tests are insufficient to conclude that the
standards proposed can be sustained on a daily basis. Prairie State asserts that
USEPA took into account timing in adopting its Clean Air Mercury Rule
(CAMR), while the Agency did not. Prairie State argues that a rule requiring
compliance in 2009 will have to be based on technology available today given
permitting, procurement and installation issues. Prairie State opines that if the
Agency is correct and the technology will be capable of 90% reduction, a
technology based standard may never need to be used. However, Prairie State
believes that without a technology based standard, facilities will be “required to
shut down, greatly curtail operations, or face enforcement actions” because the
facilities cannot comply with the standards.
Prairie State believes that the TTBS needs improvement and delineates five
different areas of concern. First, Prairie State argues that eligibility should not be
tied to the use of a particular sorbent as such language is too restrictive and
ignores new technologies and reagents. Prairie State argues that the preliminary
data on high sulfur coal indicated that halogenated activated carbon may be less
effective than other activated carbons and the rule should not require an EGU to
go through an alternative process to use other sorbents. Prairie State opines that
the rule should allow the Agency to approve various sorbents and allow an EGU
to use such approved sorbents. Prairie State suggests language to reflect this
idea.
Second, Prairie State asserts that the TTBS should allow an optimization study to
determine the optimum injection such as the one Prairie State performed in its
construction permit. An optimization study would allow for consideration of
variables that affect mercury removal and Prairie State argues that it is unclear if
variables were considered in the proposed TTBS. Further, Prairie State asserts
that the provisions of Prairie State’s construction permit should be an acceptable
alternative to the default rates in the TTBS. New facilities, whose construction
permits already include a provision regarding mercury control and the use of
sorbent, should not be required to repeat the permitting process under a TTBS.
Third, Prairie State believes that the TTBS should allow for a lower injection rate
if particulate matter emissions are adversely impacted. Prairie State
acknowledges that new units should not have the same particulate control device
size concerns as existing units; new units may still experience problems given the
lack of long-term data. Prairie State also recommends that “safety issues” be
added as a basis for lowering injection rates, given the testimony concerning a
fire at a TOXECON baghouse.
Fourth, Prairie State has some confusion regarding the requirement to record the
activated carbon feed on an hourly average basis. Prairie State asserts that there
does not seem to be a rationale for requiring a facility to average the activated
carbon feed on an hourly basis. Further, Prairie State maintains that as the
mercury content of coal cannot be feasibly monitored and recorded on an hourly
basis, knowing the injection rate will provide no useful information.
Fifth, Prairie State is concerned about potential timing issues with the TTBS.
Specifically, Prairie State notes that under Section 225.237 compliance with the
proposed standard commences on the date of the initial performance test. Prairie
State further notes that application for the TTBS must be made at least three
months prior to compliance with Section 225.237 has to be demonstrated and
must be included in a Title V air permit. Prairie State maintains that theoretically
a facility would need to submit the Title V application to comply with the TTBS
three months after initial start-up and before the compliance period is complete.
Prairie State recommends that the rule be clarified.
The Board finds that the rule offers flexibility allowing the regulated community
to choose alternative methods for compliance with the rule. Including alternative
compliance methods does not somehow render the underlying rule technically
infeasible. Rather, the inclusion of such flexibility solidifies the technical
feasibility of the rule proposal. Therefore, the Board finds that the proposed
inclusion of alternative options for compliance is appropriate.
C)
Change in the Rule:
As discussed above, Prairie State lists five particular concerns with the TTBS and
suggests language to address these concerns. The Board has reviewed the
language changes suggested and examined the language proposed. The Board is
convinced that the changes suggested by Prairie State will clarify the intent of the
TTBS. Therefore, the Board will make the suggested changes.
D)
Public Hearing Requests:
The Board held 10 days of hearings in Springfield (from June 12 through 23,
2006), and eight days of hearings in Chicago (from August 14 through 23, 2006).
On August 24, 2006, Midwest Generation filed a motion for additional hearings,
primarily to discuss the MPS proposal. On August 31, 2006, the Agency and
Ameren responded in opposition to the motion for additional hearings. Also on
August 31, 2006, Kincaid Generation, L.L.C. (Kincaid) filed a response
supporting Midwest Generation’s motion.
The Board found that Midwest Generation had sufficient time to prepare
extensive questions on the MPS proposal for the Board’s second hearing in the
rulemaking and that holding another hearing would not aid the Board in
developing a full record. The Board denied the motion for an additional hearing.
10)
Justification and Rationale:
A)
Changes in Statutory Language: None
B)
Changes in Board Policy, Procedures or Structure: None
C)
Citations to Federal Laws, Rule or Regulations, or Finding Requirements: This
rulemaking is proposed to meet certain obligations of the State of Illinois under
the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 7401
et seq
.; specifically, to satisfy Illinois'
obligation to submit a State Implementation Plan to address the requirements of
the Clean Air Mercury Rule (CAMR), 70 Fed. Reg. 28606.
D)
Court Decisions: None
E)
Other Reasons: While this proposal is intended to satisfy the federal
requirements under the CAMR, the proposed rule has emission limits and
timelines that are more stringent that those found in the federal CAMR. The
Agency explained that while the proposed rule is consistent with CAMR, the
proposal addresses serious deficiencies present in the CAMR including the
unnecessary delay in achieving mercury emissions reductions, the inherent
concerns associated with a cap and trade program to control a persistent,
bioaccumulative toxin, the inadequate mercury reductions contained in the
CAMR, and the legal basis upon which CAMR was adopted. The alternatives
proposed in the Temporary Technology Based Standard (TTBS) Sections are
intended to provide additional flexibility to the regulated community.
The TTBS must be read in conjunction with the Board’s proposed new Part 225
(published in the
Illinois Register
on May 19, 2006 at 30 Ill. Reg. 9281), which
the Board is sending to second notice in a separate package. The Agency
presented the TTBS language to stakeholders at the outreach session held prior to
the Agency submitting a rulemaking proposal to the Board for first notice. The
TTBS is intended to provide additional regulatory flexibility for compliance with
the proposed rule. A limited number of comments were received on the proposal
at the outreach sessions; however, no stakeholders stated that they would utilize
such a standard.
However, after the Board filed first notice in this rulemaking proposal, a number
of stakeholders requested the provisions of the TTBS. In addition, further review
by Agency staff and an expert retained by the Agency identified additional
circumstances related to practices and configurations of sources in the State that
warrant the inclusion of the TTBS.
The TTBS, as proposed, addresses both new and existing sources with EGUs. In
order to provide additional, appropriate flexibility for compliance by both new
and existing sources with EGUs, separate provisions encompassing the TTBS are
warranted. Those EGUs that satisfy relevant eligibility requirements may
demonstrate compliance with control requirements for mercury emissions via the
TTBS provisions for a specified and limited time frame.
11)
Name of Agency Representative:
Marie Tipsord
Illinois Pollution Control Board
100 W. Randolph, Suite 11-500.
Chicago, IL 60601
(312) 814-4925
AGENCY ANALYSIS OF ECONOMIC AND
BUDGETARY EFFECTS OF PROPOSED RULEMAKING
Agency: Illinois Pollution Control Board
Part/Title: “Control of Emissions from Large Combustion Sources”, 35 Ill. Adm. Code 225
Illinois Register Citation: July 28, 2006 (30 Ill. Reg. 12706)
Please attempt to provide as dollar-specific responses as possible and feel free to add any
relevant narrative explanation.
The Mercury Rule temporary technology based standard (TTBS) in brief
The proposed mercury rule would be effective upon filing. The rule as proposed requires
compliance beginning July 1, 2009 with a mercury emissions standard of 0.00801 lb/GWh or a
90% reduction from input mercury. The rule also includes a temporary technology based
standard (TTBS) and a multi-pollutant control system (MPS).
The original IEPA proposal did not include the TTBS—the Agency amended the proposal to add
it in response to input it received from industry prior to the Board’s hearings on the proposal in
June and August 2006. The TTBS is intended to provide additional flexibility to owners and
operators of large electrical generating units (EGUs).
There is already a federal rule requiring mercury control, the Clean Air Mercury rule (CAMR)
that takes effect if Illinois does not adopt its own mercury rules. So, there would be costs to
industry to comply with federal mercury rules even if Illinois does not adopt its own mercury
rules.
In letters of June 26 and 29, 2006 responding to the Board’s request for an economic impact
study, the Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity stated it did not have the
resources to perform economic impact studies on this rulemaking.
The record created at hearing and in public comments indicates that, for some electrical
generating units (EGUs), installation of the control technology to reach compliance with another
existing federal rule will have the “co-benefit” of achieving compliance with the mercury rule.
That other federal rule (that also takes effect if Illinois does not adopt its own rule) is the Clean
Air Interstate Rule (CAIR) requiring additional controls on emissions of nitrous oxide and sulfur
dioxide.
The testimony from 18 days of hearing and over 7,200 public comments led the Board to
conclude that the proposed rules is economically reasonable and technically feasible.
The Board has included a detailed economic analysis of this proposed rule in its November 2,
2006 opinion and order in R06-25. The entire opinion and order is included with this second
notice package. The following responses are briefly summarized from the extensive discussion
in the Board’s opinion.
1.
Anticipated effect on State expenditures and revenues.
(a)
Current cost to the agency for this program/activity.
$ Unknown, The Board does not break its costs down by case type or program,
and so cannot determine how many enforcement cases, permit appeals, or
variance requests may be attributable to this new rule.
(b)
If this rulemaking will result in an increase or decrease in cost, specify the fiscal
year in which this change will first occur and the dollar amount of the effect.
As early as FY 07, the Board could see additional requests for variances and
adjusted standards, as the rule is stayed as to sources that file such requests within
20 days of a rule’s effective date. See 415 ILCS 5/28.1, 38(b). Beginning in FY
09 and 10, the Board could see additional mercury enforcement actions or permit
appeals, as well as additional requests for variances or adjusted standards.
(c)
Indicate the funding source, including Fund and appropriation lines, for this
program/activity.
N/A
(d)
If an increase or decrease in the costs of another State agency is anticipated,
specify the fiscal year in which this change will first occur and the estimated
dollar amount of the effect.
While the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency did not present testimony to
quantify any changes to its costs as a result of the proposed rule, the Board
anticipates that the Agency will likely see an increase in its permit review and
enforcement expenses regarding electrical generating units.
(e)
Will this rulemaking have any effect on State revenues or expenditures not
already indicated above? Specify effects and amounts.
N/A
2.
Economic effect on persons affected by the rulemaking.
(a)
Indicate the economic effect and specify the persons affected:
Generally, the mercury reduction rule will impose new expenses on owners and
operators of large electrical generating units (EGUs), but will also have an
economic benefit to the citizens of Illinois by reduction of adverse health effects
from ingestion of mercury in fish.
The TTBS Sections are a compliance option, intended to provide additional
flexibility to owner and operators of large EGUs. These rules were proposed in
order to help offset some of the initial costs associated with upgrades that may be
necessary to comply with the new mercury emission standards in Part 225.
Industry spoke in favor of the rules, but did not quantify the cost savings from use
of the TTBS option.
Dollar amount per person: See below.
Total Statewide cost: See below.
The TTBS regulations are intended to provide flexibility to the regulated
community in complying with the new general mercury standards. TTBS is a
compliance option.
To comply with the new general mercury standards, industry-wide, owners and
operators of large EGUs are estimated to result in yearly additional control costs
of $33 million. The testimony translated that cost into an average cost increase
for the Illinois coal plants of $0.375/MWh but, each power plant will incur greater
or lesser costs to their site-specific configuration. The Board recognizes that the
cost for some units such as those opting into MPS may be higher, but those costs
also represent the “co-benefit” cost of controlling SO
2
and NOx.
(b)
If an economic effect is predicted, please briefly describe how the effect will
occur.
The proposed rule will require many EGUs to use different emission control
technologies, which will result in new costs that the Board assumes will be passed
on to consumers.
The positive effects are estimated to result from the decreased levels of mercury
in the waters of Illinois, with a resulting drop in the mercury levels in the fish.
This is anticipated to result in fewer fish advisories for the waters of Illinois,
benefiting sports and subsistence fisherman alike.
(c)
Will the rulemaking have an indirect effect that may result in increased
administrative costs? Will there be any change in requirements such as filing,
documentation, reporting or completion of forms? Compare to current
requirements.
The mercury rule is a proposed new rule; therefore all of the reporting and
recordkeeping requirements are new requirements. The TTBS rules are a
compliance option, and chosen alternatives must be documented for review by the
Illinois Environmental Protection Agency. But, EGU’s are already required to
have air permits that subject them to various other reporting and recordkeeping
requirements. The mercury requirements are, however, in line with the federally
mandated (CAMR) reporting requirements for control of mercury emissions.
ATTACHMENT A
FIRST NOTICE CHANGES
AGENCY: Pollution Control Board
RULEMAKING: “Control of Emissions from Large Combustion Sources” 35 Ill. Adm. Code
225; July 28, 2006 (30 Ill. Reg. 12706)
1) In line 53, add a period after “General”
2) In lines 57-58 delete “as an alternative to compliance with the mercury emission standards in
Section 225.230 of this Subpart,”
3) In line 60, after “2015” add “as
an alternative to compliance with the mercury emission
standards in Section 225.230”
4) In line 60 delete “further”
5) In lines 64, 68, 120, 191, 308, 312, add “B” after “Subpart”
6) In lines 64, 66, 74, 114, 136, 189, 199 (twice), 202, 257, 258, 292, 308, 318, 411, 417, 420,
450, 466, 467, 501 change “under” to “pursuant to”
7) In lines 69-70 change “by means of this Section is not excused from applicable monitoring,
recordkeeping, and reporting requirements in Sections 225.240 through 225.290” to “by means
of the temporary alternative emission standards of this Section is not excused from any of the
applicable monitoring, recordkeeping, and reporting requirements set forth in Sections 225.240
through 225.290”
8) In lines 71, 129, 142, 164, 302, 315, 370, 386, 413 delete “of this Subpart”
9) In line 73 add a period after “Eligibility”
10) In lines 74, 83, 91, 135, 143, 189, 195, 219, 240, 246, 262, 273, 277, 284, 290, 318, 335,
342, 363, 371, 387, 411, 431, 451, 456, 471, 475, 482, 486, 493, 499 change “shall” to “must”
11) In line 84 change “shows” to “has demonstrated”
12) In line 86 after “rates” add “set
forth in subsections (b)(2)(A) through (b)(2)(D ) of this
Section”
13) In line 88 change “with” to “using”
14) Change the proposed language in lines 90-91 from “For this purpose, flue gas flow rate” to
“For
this the purpose purposes of this subsection (b)(2), the flue gas flow rate”
15) In lines 97 and 100 change “pounds” to “lbs”
16) In line 155 change “value below” to “of the following values”
17) In line 119 change “such” to “the”
18) In line 124 delete “Electric Energy, Inc., ID 127855AAC;”
19) In line 128 change “such” to “the”
20) In line 131 and 133 add a period after “Requirements”
21) In line 145 add “it must” before “maintain”
22) In line 150 add “it must” before “monitor”
23) In line 158 add “it must maintain” before “records”
24) Change lines 168 through 174 to read:
“A)
Written notification prior to the month in which any of the following events will
occur:
i)
the The EGU will no longer be eligible to operate under this Section due to a
change in operation;
ii)
the The type of coal fired in the EGU will change; the mercury emission standard
with which the owner or operator is attempting to comply for the EGU will
change; or
iii)
operation Operation under this Section will be terminated.”
25) In line 190 change “that” to “on which”
26) In line 208 add “the EGU” after “operated”
27) In line 210 add “225.234” after “Section”
28) In line 218 add a period after “Application”
29) In line 219 change “operate pursuant to this Section” to “operate an EGU pursuant to this
Section 225.234”
30 ) In line 221 change “EGU and include the following” to “EGU, and it must include the
following documents and information”
31) In line 250 add “together” after “measure,”
32) In line 260 change “as further provided as follows” to “subject to the following limitations”
33) In line 263 add “that it” after “program”
34) In lines 264, 278 change “Illinois EPA” to “Agency”
35) In line 264 change “in advance” to “prior to beginning the evaluation”
36) In line 266 change “evaluation shall” to “formal evaluation program must”
37) In line 269 add “that it has” after “document”
38) In line 270 change “evaluation program” to “formal
evaluation program pursuant to
subsection (e)(1)(A) of this Section”
39) In lines 279, 280, change “evaluation” to “formal evaluation program”
40) In line 286 add “control” after “comparable”
41) In line 296 add a period after “General”
42) In line 310 change “such” to “the temporary technology based”
43) In lines 32-313 change “means of” to “pursuant to”
44) In line 314 change “in” to “of”
45) In line 317 add a period after “Eligibility”
46) In line 322 change “oxides and particulate matter and” to “oxides,
and particulate matter,
and the EGU”
47) In line 326 change “of halogenated activated carbon” to “sorbent or other mercury control
technique (e.g. reagent) approved by the Agency”
48) In line 330 change “activated carbon” to “a sorbent or other mercury control technique
approved by the Agency”
49) In line 332 change “halogenated activated carbon” to “a sorbent or other mercury control
technique”
50) In line 333 change “by” to “pursuant to”
51) In lines 334, 336, 339, change “halogenated activated carbon” to “sorbent or other mercury
control technique”
52) In line 337 change “shows” to “demonstrates”
53) In line 338 change “following rates” to “rate set forth in the appropriate of subsections
(b)(2)(A) through (b)(2)(C) of this Section”
54) In line 342 change “this purpose” to “the purposes of this subsection (b)(2)”
55) In line 342 add “the” before “flue”
56) In lines 343, 374, add “or other mercury control technique” after “injection”
57) In line 345 change “or may” to “, or the flow rate may”
58) After line 357 add:
D)
A rate or rates set on a unit-specific basis that are lower than the rate specified in
subsections (b)(2)(A), (B), and (C) of this Section, to the extent that the owner or operator of the
EGU demonstrates that such rate or rates are needed so that sorbent injection or other mercury
control technique would not increase particulate matter emissions or opacity so as to threaten
compliance with applicable regulatory requirements for particulate matter or opacity or cause a
safety issue.
59) In lines 359, 361, 368, 384 add a period after “Requirements”
60) In lines 373, 376 change “activated carbon” to “sorbent”
61) In line 380 add “maintain” after “EGU,”
62) In lines 381-382 change “halogenated activated carbon” to “sorbent”
63) After line 382 add:
“C)
If a mercury control technique other than sorbent injection is approved by the Agency,
monitor appropriate parameter for that control technique as specified by the Agency”
64) In line 385 change “in” to “of”
65) In line 408 add a period after “Deadlines”
66) In line 427 change “activated carbon” to “sorbent or other mercury control technique”
67) In line 430 add a period after “Application”
68) In line 433 change “EGU and the following” to “EGU,
and it must include the following
information”
69) In line 445 change “carbon” to “sorbent or other mercury control technique”
70) In line 452 change “activated carbon” to “sorbent or other mercury control technique”
71) In line 466 change “need not comply” to “does not need to comply”
72) In line 469 change “as further provided as follows” to “further subject to the following
limitations”
73) In line 472 add “that it has” after “program”
74) In line 473 change “Illinois EPA at least 30 days in advance” to “Agency at least 30 days
prior to beginning the evaluation”
75) In line 478 add “that it has” after “document”
76) In line 479 change “evaluation program” to “formal evaluation program pursuant to
subsection (e)(1)(A) of this Section”
77) In line 487 change “Illinois EPA” to “Agency”
78) In lines 488, 489 change “evaluation” to “formal evaluation program”
79) In line 492 add “was” after “than”
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
11/1/2006
Comments of Tess Rogers of Carbondale, IL (PC #7092)
10/30/2006
*Comments of Susan Frazier of Park Ridge, IL 60068 (PC# 7091)
9/22/2006
*Comments of Little Village Environmental Justice Organization - Maria
Delgado (PC 7045); Jeticia Chacop (PC 7046); Undecipherable Signature (PC
7047); Nartina Davila (PC 7048); Victoria Ocoste (PC 7049); Jovita Flora (PC
7050); Elena Balcazas (PC 7051); Sofia Gonzales (PC 7052); Joselina Cavillo
(PC 7053); Consuelo Diaz (PC 7054); Rosario Martinez (PC 7055); Rosalia
Contraras (PC 7056); Esperanza Duran (PC 7057); Juana E. Gonzalaz (PC 7058);
Lucila Ochoa (PC 7059); Mara Orizuela (PC 7060); Benjamin Royas (PC 7061);
Undecipherable Signature (PC 7062)
9/22/2006
*Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coaliton - Guadalope Garcia (PC 7063); L.
Ochoa (PC 7064); Lourdes Padilla (PC 7065); Alejandro Bonilla (PC 7066);
Indecipherable signature (PC 7067); Elizabeth Luna (PC 7068); Martha Alonzo
(PC 7069); Guadalupe Espanza (PC 7070); Concepcion Cervantes (PC 7071);
Francisca de Hecto (PC 7072); Rosario Loza (PC 7073); Luz Macedo (PC 7074);
Serjio Ochoa (PC 7075); Adriana Reyes (PC 7076); Donaldo Rojas (PC 7077);
Jovita Flores (PC 7078); Juana Rodriguez (PC 7079); Guillermina Diaz (PC
7080); Indecipherable signature (PC 7081); Sandra Barajas (PC 7082); Alberto
Ochoa (PC 7083); N. Reyes (PC 7084); Celia Ramirez (PC 7085); Brenda
Vasquez (PC 7086); Ruben Zura (PC 7087); Victor Castillo (PC 7088); Benjamin
Rojas (PC 7089); Luanna Leghner (PC 7090);
9/22/2006
Comments of Little Village Environmental Justice Organization - Viviana ruiz
(PC 7001); Amy L. Maldonado (PC 7002); Griselda Ramirez (PC 7003); Mayra
Contreras (PC 7004); Ninfa Reyes (PC 7005); Fernando Barrientos (PC 7006);
Samuel DelaRosa (PC 7007); Mauriero D. Roman (PC 7008); Volio Torres (PC
7009); Irmando Medina (PC 7010); David Mauyando (PC 7011); Victor Rosales
(PC 7012); John Mayida (PC 7013); Oscar Almania (PC 7014); Robert Welch
(PC 7015); Rogelio Rivera (PC 7016); Antonio Jiminez (PC 7017); Jose
Monarrez (PC 7018); Eduardo Villegas (PC 7019); Gerardo Pantojas (PC 7020);
Julio De La Rosa (PC 7021); Rosa Ramirez (PC 7022); Rosarie Hernandez (PC
7023); Mary H. Santana (PC 7024); Lorena Lopez (PC 7025); Guadalupe Santos
(PC 7026); Margarita De La Torre (PC 7027); Ennelises Saia (PC 7028); Maxi
Granja (PC 7029); Erika Ortiz (PC 7030); Norma Emererrio (PC 7031); Lisa
Shariah Nichols (PC 7032); Maria Elizabeth Salinas (PC 7033); Alejandra
Ramirez (PC 7034); Adriana Alvarez (PC 7035); Carmen Alvarez (PC 7036);
Deisy Romano (PC 7037); Fanny Garcia (PC 7038); Valeria Pena (PC 7039);
Pedro Cervantes (PC 7040); Alma Violeta Pina (PC 7041); Maria Lopez (PC
7042); Daneda Alvares (PC 7043); Maria M. Serrato (PC 7044)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Dale Von Ohlen (PC 6970); Earl Bley, Jr. (PC
6971); Kate O'Brien (PC 6972); Emily Hodge (PC 6973); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6974); Stacey Van de Voort (PC 6975); Indecipherable signature
(PC 6976); Nancy Hollmeier (PC 6977); Terry Ward (PC 6978); Mary Ann
Gilkerson (PC 6979); Bruce Washer (PC 6980); Matt Czarik (PC 6981);
Indecipherable signature (PC 6982); Tim Behland (PC 6983); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6984); Vicki Wasthey (PC 6985); Tracey C. Beckley (PC 6986);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Donna McDonald (PC 6987); Lois Prindle (PC 6988); Dan Carr (PC 6989);
Indecipherable signature (PC 6990); Virginia C. Babcock (PC 6991); Jeff
Stoneback (PC 6992); Jeff Potter (PC 6993); Shane Cole (PC 6994); Judith P.
Luken (PC 6995); Colleen Riehe (PC 6996); Nancy Weiss (PC 6997); Terri
Hoenhne (PC 6998); Al Drover (PC 6999); Indecipherable signature (PC 7000)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Illinois PIRG - Reebie Ryan (PC 6966); Galestam (PC 6967);
Stacey Rosenfeld (PC 6968); David Kahn (PC 6969)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Shannon Knight (PC 6917); Lisa Kamp (PC 6918);
Annice Tatken (PC 6919); Maureen Geoghegan (PC 6920); Nancy Johnson (PC
6921); Robert Johnson (PC 6922); Mitzi Ulrich (PC 6923); Robert Ulrich (PC
6924); Domnall MacTorcaill (PC 6925); Patrick G. O'Donnell (PC 6926); Tyler
Griffin (PC 6927); Herman Franklin (PC 6928); Lena Franklin (PC 6929); Sarah
Franklin (PC 6930); Roger Konecke (PC 6931); Karen Rawlins (PC 6932);
Loretta Brendel (PC 6933); Richard E. Sparks (PC 6934); Pam Guinn (PC 6935);
Nathan Shetley (PC 6936); Debbie Jones (PC 6937); Carl Kamp (PC 6938);
Catherine A. Greig (PC 6939); Vicky Hlady (PC 6940); Elaine Sieben (PC
6941); Ernest L. Kimmel (PC 6942); Ashley Rodgerson (PC 6943); Richelle
Browning (PC 6944); Elizabeth Heady (PC 6945); Treva Cubbage (PC 6946);
Keisa Ealey (PC 6947); Henry Franklin (PC 6948); Erin Kaye Sanders (PC
6949); Susan Kessler (PC 6950); Dick Colman (PC 6951); Charlotte Lipp (PC
6952); Pam Lipp (PC 6953); Zach Kiley (PC 6954); Emily Kiley (PC 6955); Fred
Lipp (PC 6956); Amy Taylor (PC 6957); Richard Hlady (PC 6958); Sheila
Rhodes (PC 6959); Tonia Manning (PC 6960); Donna Morgan (PC 6961);
Christine King (PC 6962); Steve Rhodes (PC 6963); Kristen Pearson (PC 6964);
Robert Wehrle (PC 6965)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Gina Brown (PC 6866); Darlene Vinicky (PC 6867);
Derek Davies (PC 6868); Tom Osran (PC 6869); Lisa Conry (PC 6870); Katie
Alusic (PC 6871); Dalia Satas (PC 6872); Melinda Gruska (PC 6873); Michael
Donnelly (PC 6874); Georgianne Kamberos (PC 6875); Lois Preston (PC 6876);
Natasha Oshurkova (PC 6877); Megan Bonner (PC 6878); Jessica Leving (PC
6879); David Hurwitz (PC 6880); Joshua Noehrenberg (PC 6881); Victoria
Salkrit (PC 6882); Daniela Olszewska (PC 6883); Jennith Kial (PC 6884); Liz
Pendelton (PC 6885); Lisa Hoffer (PC 6886); Rory Malone (PC 6887); Maggie
Seratin (PC 6888); Anneliese Tiessen (PC 6889); Naomi Currie (PC 6890); Chris
Writz (PC 6891); Cyndy Fike (PC 6892); Jason Kluga (PC 6893); Erica Emme
(PC 6894); David Spear (PC 6895); Paul Kyell (PC 6896); Dave O'Keefe (PC
6897); Alan Mather (PC 6898); DeShonda M. Sisco (PC 6899); Cyntoya
Campbell (PC 6900); Undecipherable Signature (PC 6902); Mary Jane Boltz (PC
6903); Susan Anderson (PC 6904); Jami Pashtan (PC 6905); Jason Huntress (PC
6906); Chris Hoss (PC 6907); Justin Kreindler (PC 6908); Rob Hick (PC 6909);
Sarah Saheb (PC 6910); Tom Conway (PC 6911); Undecipherable Signature (PC
6912); Matt Schwarz (PC 6913); Ellen Sausser (PC 6914); Vanessa Soyenson
(PC 6915); Danae' Wirth (PC 6916)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Scott Goska (PC 6816); Marsha Cabaj (PC 6817);
Glen Stucke (PC 6818); DAvid McCarthy (PC 6819); Shayna Rodman (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
6820); John Dorn (PC 6821); Michael Coughlin (PC 6822); Dean Schraufrayel
(PC 6823); Lucas Kahun (PC 6824); Aidan Phillips (PC 6825); Michelle J. Elson
(PC 6826); Lauren Schrader (PC 6827); Amy Carlson (PC 6828); Mike
Andrews( PC 6829); Mark Mateka (PC 6830); Robert Plavtz (PC 6831); Beth
Baker (PC 6832); Michelle Hickey-Fonts (PC 6833); Jim Slacia (PC 6834); Tony
Bustamante (PC 6835); Roxanne Renicker (PC 6836); Ronald Noon (PC 6837);
Dave Newman (PC 6838); Carol Newman (PC 6839); Natalia Bednarck (PC
6840); Mark C. Mazzuca (PC 6841); Paulette Mazzuca (PC 6842); Erin O'Neal
(PC 6843); Nancy Miles (PC 6844); Leslie G. Vloedman (PC 6845); Eric Wilcox
(PC 6846); Amy Lieberman (PC 6847); Ed Matone (PC 6848); Mike Pocius (PC
6849); Steven L. Leavitt (PC 6850); Michael Meyer (PC 6851); Alex
Moschopoulos (PC 6852); Eric Duquene (PC 6853); Magdalena Danko (PC
6854); D. Lamonte (PC 6855); Neal Davies (PC 6856); Amy Lohmolder Davies
(PC 6857); Amy Miller (PC 6858); Ed Gruber (PC 6859); Laura Barnes (PC
6860); Roberta Matejka (PC 6861); Paul Holzman (PC 6862); Denise Hollis (PC
6863); Erik Joerns (PC 6864); Melanie Mitchell (PC 6865)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Rachel Shah (PC 6766); JennySlatlery (PC 6767);
Zaina Jalaid (PC 6768); Jeff Schutt (PC 6769); Tobias Cortese (PC 6770); Joe
Sullivan (PC 6771); Dylan Sturkey (PC 6772); Quinn Root (PC 6773);
Indecipherable signature (PC 6774); Rick Harpin (PC 6775); Natalia Tranjowski
(PC 6776); Monica Goze (PC 6777); Janine Tanner (PC 6778); Roberta Dahmer
(PC 6779); Cathy Torres (PC 6780); Paul Masonick (PC 6781); Mary Alice
Masonick (6782); William H. Vincent Jr. (PC 6783); Raymond Vincent (PC
6784); Buckley Hamman (PC 6785); Gayle Kamberos (PC 6786); Graham Rosby
(PC 6787); Erin Satarraho (PC 6788); Colleen O'Grady (PC 6789); Jules Tucker
(PC 6790); C. Severinsey (PC 6791); Steve Marshall (PC 6792); Lily Beurs (PC
6793); Peter Blomgren (PC 6794); Justin Vick (PC 6795); Jordan Zeichner (PC
6796); Edward Tsiknetsis (PC 6797); Ashley Arnone (PC 6798); Tony Adams
(PC 6799); Laura Pearson (PC 6800); Brioan Fisher (PC 6801); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6802); David Cory (PC 6803); Steph Tai (PC 6804); David Dudley
(PC 6805); Sophie Nicholas (PC 6806); Stephan Branne (PC 6807); Eric Masi
(PC 6808); Vanessa Wishart (PC 6809); Robert Guzman (PC 6810); Jennifer
Garcia (PC 6811); Alex Moore (PC 6812); Michael Sumrall (PC 6813); Marcus
Talley (PC 6814); Jeremy Shulkin (PC 6815)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Kathy Kramer (PC 6716); Lara Tochor (PC 6717);
Emily Trinks (PC 6718); Melissa Stewart (PC 6719); Robert Zolna (PC 6720);
Enrique Cataldo (PC 6721); Erin Frumet (PC 6722); Christina Alexis (PC 6723);
Bill Holubeck (PC 6724); Michael Pitulla (PC 6725); Adam Wolak (PC 6726);
Jesse Manwis (PC 6727); Ben Viirre (PC 6728); Erica Foster (PC 6729); Colin
Stanley (PC 6730); Undecipherable Signature (PC 6731); Dan Roen (PC 6732);
Erik Breitenfeldt (PC 6733); Carly Vendegna (PC 6734); Jeff Savage (PC 6735);
Mike Seadwa (PC 6736); J. Burke (PC 6737); Debbie Stoper (PC 6738); Michael
Denslow (PC 6739); Jeff Takaki (PC 6740); Undecipherable Signature (PC
6741); Kendra Pickard (PC 6742); Toner Gal (PC 6743); Matt Williams (PC
6744); Eric Dawe (PC 6745); Annika Seitz (PC 6746); Noah Armstrong (PC
6747); Bailey Spaulding (PC 6748); Holly Meyer (PC 6749); Brian Rubinstein
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 6750); Eric Jensen (PC 6751); Imran Khn (PC 6752); Emily Dennison (PC
6753); Laura Lassiter (PC 6754); Bobby Ziegler (PC 6755); Undecipherable
Signature (PC 6756); Becky Lipson (PC 6757); Randi Stella (PC 6758); Jordyn
Pfalzgraf (PC 6759); Mike Musinski (PC 6760); Julie C. Miller (PC 6761);
Morgan Leiby (CP 6762); Steve Lipson (PC 6763); Ed Perkins (PC 6764);
Jessica Perkins (PC 6765)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Dana Karraker(PC 6666); Suzy Dees (PC 6667);
Clarissa Marks (PC 6668); Molly Nelson (PC 6669); Ted Vickers (PC 6670);
Lisa Humphrey (PC 6671); Matt Carlson (PC 6672); Moira McNellis (PC 6673);
Jason Chochola (PC 6674); Mike Phillips (PC 6675); Alexandra Thebert (PC
6676); David Shuey (PC 6677); Mitch Kessles (PC 6678); Khanuengnit Tawitsri
(PC 6679); Kevin Prochot (PC 6680); Ron Crouch (PC 6681); Cristy Borjon (PC
6682); John White (PC 6683); Joseph Langab (PC 6684); Josh Iselin (PC 6685);
Mark Hong (PC 6686); Scott Hillkirk (PC 6687); Kiersten Hillkirk (PC 6688);
Chris Cutlie (PC 6689); Madeline Nusser (PC 6690); Lindsey L. Delahanty (PC
6691); Faik Morreau (PC 6692); M. Horn (PC 6693); Fran Langner (PC 6694);
David Miller (PC 6695); Jared Sherman (PC 6696); Julie Clement (PC 6697);
Kathy Bayer (PC 6698); Diane Laud (PC 6699); Kathleen Hill (PC 6700); Tim
Laud (PC 6701); Padlek (PC 6702); T. Strohm (PC 6703); Dave Mongin (PC
6704); Marianne Majens (PC 6705); John Benediel (PC 6706); Paul Wilke (PC
6707); Lauretha Scott (PC 6708); Johnathan Hand (PC 6709); Barnabus Davis
(PC 6710); Jeannie Tanner (PC 6711); Val Seilheimer (PC 6712); Helen Boley
(PC 6713); Jessica Gardner (PC 6714); Ann Jolicoeur (PC 6715)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Diana Roysdon (PC 6616); William Roysdon (PC
6617); Richard Gibbons (PC 6618); Romayne and Dave Culp (PC 6619); Gary
Swick (PC 6620); Cindy Skrukrud (PC 6621); Mary Herman (PC 6622); Tim
McCoutly (PC 6623); Tony Chabi (PC 6624); Lorena Loni (PC 6625); Deb
Chabi (PC 6626); Sally Seiller (PC 6627); Michael Holand (PC 6628); Todd
Underwood (PC 6629); Jan Underwood (PC 6630); Johanna Vincent (PC 6631);
Cheryl Gills (PC 6632); Candis Purcell (PC 6633); Teresa Clark (PC 6634);
Corenna Vanderweele (PC 6635); Monique M. d'Avis (PC 6636); Jack Krupi (PC
6637); James Elmore (PC 6638); Steph Niemeyer (PC 6639); Eric Schumacher
(PC 6640); Terri Grams (PC 6641); Maureen Kennelly (PC 6642); Cora Adams
(PC 6643); Jim Korakis (PC 6644); Matt Zito (PC 6645); Faith Bowman (PC
6646); Setarreh Massihzadegan (PC 6647); Ric Almeda (PC 6648); Jaclyn Pruit
(PC 6649); Jim Mosley (PC 6650); Sara Heiderich (PC 6651); Jenny Grobeski
(PC 6652); Allen Ansay (PC 6653); Stephanie Anderson (PC 6654); Deanne
Vega-Brynes (PC 6655); Armando Alamicu (PC 6656); Mark Spurgis (PC 6657);
Anna Liljas (PC 6658); Melissa Marquez (PC 6659); Rachel McCamey (PC
6660); Katie Helt (PC 6661); Tammy Proctor (PC 6662); Brian Lanigan (PC
6663); Oriaitn Ryan (PC 6664); Derek Sepeda (PC 6665)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Indecipherable signature (PC 6566); Heather
McCarty (PC 6567); Matt Danzlman (PC 6568); Liz Kitzerow (PC 6569); Brian
Slattery (PC 6570); Susan Hayden (PC 6571); Gena Wing (PC 6572); Kim
Ashcraft (PC 6573); Paula M. Neal (PC 6574); Mary A. Ashcraft (PC 6575);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Rachel Newman (PC 6576); Tiffany Wells (PC 6577); Mickey Bass (PC 6578);
Rose Granfontz (PC 6579); Micahel Sinner (PC 6580); Sam Newman (PC 6581);
Kathleen Scanlan (PC 6582); Amy Ornee (PC 6583); D. Rossi (PC 6584);
Douglas Chien (PC 6585); Michele Gurgas (PC 6586); Alyssa Eisenstein (PC
6587); Omhar Bhatt (PC 6588); Ben Slivnick (PC 6589); James Matwien (PC
6590); Karleen Katena (PC 6591); Mike Alfano (PC 6592); Charlotte A.
Goodwin (PC 6593); Stefanie Rogers (PC 6594); Matt Hay (PC 6595); Karl
Adam (PC 6596); Sandra Saberman (PC 6597); Dominic Vignolo (PC 6598);
Heather Laverty (PC 6599); Brenden Barnett (PC 6600); Samantha Kurek (PC
6601); Anna Sromek (PC 6602); Jose Napoles (PC 6603); Duane Freeman (PC
6604); Taya Cromley (PC 6605); Tim Thomas (PC 6606); Rebecca Farber (PC
6607); Ben Seligman (PC 6608); Suhail Khokhar (PC 6609); Dna Weiner (PC
6610); Stephen Scott (PC 6611); Elizabeth Morlock (PC 6612); Rebecca Geitner
(PC 6613); Paul Dees (PC 6614); Kyle D. Karraker (PC 6615)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Bozena Zabana (PC 6516); Beverly Mruch (PC
6517); Shari Dudych (PC 6518); Jeff Beck (PC 6519); Jon Beck (PC 6520);
David Baker (PC 6521); Terry Baker (PC 6522); James P. Wyslak (PC 6523);
Dan Stevens (PC 6524); Cathy Hogle (PC 6525); Brandon Knox (PC 6526);
Larry Bealmstar (PC 6527); Randy Schietzelt (PC 6528); Brian Dianis (PC
6529); Sheera Carthaus (PC 6530); James Tucker (PC 6531); Ranee Wu (PC
6532); Raoul Clements (PC 6533); Brad Bullock (PC 6534); Sara Haack (PC
6535); Noah Lewis (PC 6536); Lori Simmons (PC 6537); Brian Mateas (PC
6538); Jamie Bender (PC 6539); Andrea Kessler (PC 6540); Francis Mangayao
(PC 6541); John Barry (PC 6542); Charles Hagman (PC 6543); Bill Dawson (PC
6544); Jon Weber (PC 6545); Shelby Cieslinski (PC 6546); Josh Cieslinski (PC
6547); Fran Marschke (PC 6548); Peggy Sutton (PC 6549); Beverly Alderfer (PC
6550); Nancy Lanyon (PC 6551); Gary Mitchiner (PC 6552); Ellen Winick (PC
6553); James Binney (PC 6554); Ed Kugler (PC 6555); Vera Leopold (PC 6556);
C. Barry (PC 6557); Steve Pincuspy (PC 6558); Matt McCarty (PC 6559); Lesley
McCain (PC 6560); Harold London (PC 6561); Rhonda Winn (PC 6562); Penne
Huxtable (PC 6563); Barbara Stevenson (PC 6564); Dan Durbin (PC 6565)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Dorie Smith (PC 6466); Azeem Pasha (PC 6467);
Fasian Balcazar (PC 6468); Chevy Guido (PC 6469); Natalie Graketzer (PC
6470); Amy E. Wolf (PC 6471); Jennifer O'Brien (PC 6472); Thomas Geneza
(PC 6473); Anthony Mckes (PC 6474); Katherine Shropshire (PC 6475); Chris
Copinio (PC 6476); Brett Burwell (PC 6477); Undecipherable Signature (PC
6478); Emily K. Smith (PC 6479); Katie Tuter (PC 6480); Caroline Fickett (PC
6481); Caroline Bank (PC 6482); Max Miller (PC 6483); Claire Sandahl (PC
6484); Undecipherable Signature (PC 6485); Nora Duran (PC 6486); Carolyn
Groeneword (PC 6487); Maribeth Groenewald (PC 6488); Joseph Crawford (PC
6489); Katherine Boyle (PC 6490); Luke R. Bergkoetten (PC 6491); Kyle Scott
(PC 6492); Kennon Brown (PC 6493); Kyle Gagliardi (PC 6494); Greg
Herschling (PC 6495); Jimmy Zimmerman (PC 6496); Joseph McNulty III (PC
6497); Jennifer Noinaj (PC 6498); Carolynn Travis (PC 6499); Mike Brunner
(PC 6500); Alice Buttnck (PC 6501); Clayton Lewis (PC 6502); Adam Morley
(PC 6503); Neal Mahoney (PC 6504); Keith Claxton (PC 6505); Marnja
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Yoshimura (PC 6506); Paul Balik (PC 6507); Mayce Mansour (PC 6508); Jerek
Roller (PC 6509); Daly Stevens (PC 6510); Alejandra Guerrero (PC 6511); Julie
Baron (PC 6512); Allison Felus (PC 6513); Ryne Eslwing (PC 6514); Nagisa
Kondo-Turner (PC 6515)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club - Cathy Seczlevian (PC 6416); Mark P. Erdmann (PC
6417); Frankie Raobstits (PC 6418); Rose Gonnam (PC 6419); Dan Erickson (PC
6420); Mary Lou Pleet (PC 6421); Dan Wahl (PC 6422); Jimmie T. Jones (PC
6423); Steve Eriksen (PC 6424); Indecipherable signature (PC 6425); Wayne
Lyon (PC 6426); Rich Luehler (PC 6427); Indecipherable signature (PC 6428);
Michael R. DeSantis (PC 6429); Amber Hansell (PC 6430); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6431); Indecipherable signature (PC 6432); John Jastrom (PC
6433); Bob Matusek (PC 6434); Indecipherable signature (PC 6435); George
Prattoni (PC 6436); Jennifer Carrier (PC 6437); D. Petrausek (PC 6438);
Indecipherable signature (PC 6439); Frank March (PC 6440); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6441); Indecipherable signature (PC 6442); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6443); Indecipherable signature (PC 6444); Steve Shirley (PC
6445); David Jackinier (PC 6446); Wilbert Thiel (PC 6447); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6448); Dale Jackson (PC 6449); Raymond Holland (PC 6450);
Robert Brite (PC 6451); Bob Coppoth (PC 6452); Arthur Edlund (PC 6453);
Michael A. Popp (PC 6454); Linda Gray Sonner (PC 6455); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6456); Barbara Zoha (PC 6457); Karen Kosky (PC 6458); Denny
Franzon (PC 6459); Indecipherable signature (PC 6460); Indecipherable
signature (PC 6461); Jeanne Harms (PC 6462); Sue Price (PC 6463); Britta
McKenna (PC 6464); Charles Briegel (PC 6465)
9/20/2006
*Comments of (indecipherable signature) (PC 6366); Deb Phillips (PC 6367);
Mary E. Phillips (PC 6368); Ronald Mildard (PC 6369); Kelli Hubert (PC 6370);
Jossi DeMartin (PC 6371); Dorothy Patzer (PC 6372); Tom Wangler (PC 6373);
Elaine M. Bouchard (PC 6374); Francis Figreroa (PC 6375); Katt Valle (PC
6376); Ben Hudetz (PC 6377); Robert T. McPeek (PC 6378); Kevin C. Summis
(PC 6379); David Konie (PC 6380); Tegan Carr (PC 6381); Tina Robinson (PC
6382); Joan McImes (PC 6383); Carol J. Janus (PC 6384); Alta Hundly (PC
6385); Ed Sconse (PC 6386); (indecipherable signature) (PC 6387); Ken
McDermett (PC 6388); Vicki Haigh (PC 6389); Jessica Oruno (PC 6390); Ryan
Belgungy (PC 6391); D. Thomas (PC 6392); Roger Ricketts (PC 6393); Ruth
Kuestner (PC 6394);Clifford Tebean (PC 6395); Joseph Coleman (PC 6396);
Nathaniel Stelton (PC 6397);Terry Murray (PC 6398); Daniel L. Fors (PC 6399);
Christine Winscott (PC 6400); R.A Johnson (PC 6401); Luanna B. Blereans (PC
6402); Cathy Watson (PC 6403); Gene Schultz (PC 6404);Anne Roberts (PC
6405); Matthew Roberts (PC 6406); Gene B. Rose (PC 6407); Greg Lakebrink
(PC 6408);Jennifer Sublett (PC 6409); Jake Zhao (PC 6410); Wei Luo (PC
6411); Victor Liou (PC 6412); (indecipherable signature) (PC 6413); Todd
Mesez (PC 6414); Bob Arndt (PC 6415)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Environment Illinois - A. Glicksberg (PC 6323); Laurel May
Daniel (PC 6324); Danny Scollan (PC 6325); Alex Schabel (PC 6326); Barbara
Walsh (PC 6327); Aki Kudo (PC 6328); Brigitte Werder (PC 6329); Deb Clark
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 6330); Maureen Balluff (PC 6331); Elissa Patterson (PC 6332); Gordon P.
Grant (PC 6333); Shirley Bayliff (PC 6334); Octavia Bragg (PC 6335); James
Mastaler-Gutermuth (PC 6336); Valerie Archambeau (PC 6337); Sarah Novey
(PC 6338); Gayle Stripling (PC 6339); Laura Doyle (PC 6340); Nan Warshaw
(PC 6341); Danielle Diamond (PC 6342); Mary Hogan (PC 6343); Kristen Holub
(PC 6344); Daniel Hebreard (PC 6345); Linda Kruhmin (PC 6346); Eric Murken
(PC 6347); Daniel Shaughnessy (PC 6348); Robert Schultz (PC 6349); Andrew
Heiberger (PC 6350); Dean Martin (PC 6351); Stephan Donovan (PC 6352);
Vladimir Gedgafov (PC 6353); Mark Berggren (PC 6354); Nancy L. Cowger (PC
6355); Lanie Costeas (PC 6356); Maire Catherine Considine (PC 6357); Lana
May (PC 6358); D. Meyer (PC 6359); Barbara Cochrane (PC 6360); Susanne
Richter (PC 6361); Kelly Grigg (PC 6362); Ray & Patti Chabot (PC 6363); Alan
Vuong (PC 6364); Brian Urbaszewski (PC 6365)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sinai Health System (PC 6322)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Ounce of Prevention Fund (PC 6321)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Northern Illinois Public Health Consortium, Inc. (PC 6320)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Metropolitan Chicago Healthcare Council (PC 6319)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Illinois Public Health Association (PC 6318)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Illinois Maternal and Child Health Coalition (IMCHC) (PC 6317)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Illinois Environmental Council and Alliance for the Great Lakes
(PC 6316)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Illinois Divison of the Izaak Walton League, Illinois Council of
Trout Unlimited, National Wildlife Federation, Natural Resource Defense
Council, Prairie Rivers Network (PC 6315)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Illinois Academy of Family Physicians (PC 6314)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Citizen Action Illinois (PC 6313)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Chilcren's Hospital of Illinois (PC 6312)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Child Care Coalition of Lake County (PC 6311)
9/20/2006
*Comments of American Lung Association of Metropolitan Chicago (PC 6310)
9/20/2006
*Comments of American Bottom Conservancy (PC 6309)
9/20/2006
*Comments of American Academy of Pediatrics, Illinois Chapter (PC 6308)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Access Living (PC 6307)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Advocate Health Care (PC 6306)
9/20/2006
*Comments of Sierra Club, Illinois Chapter (PC 6305)
9/20/2006
Comments of Citizens Against Ruining the Environment (CARE) (PC 6304)
(electronic filing)
9/20/2006
Comments of Kathryn Tholih of Center for Neighborhood Technology (PC
#6303)
9/20/2006
Motion to Correct Transcripts (electronic filing)
9/20/2006
Comments of IERG (PC #6302) (electronic filing)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
9/20/2006
Comments of Ameren (PC #6301) (electronic filing)
9/20/2006
Comments of Midwest Generation (PC #6300) (electronic filing)
9/20/2006
Comments of Kincaid Generation (PC #6299) (electronic filing)
9/20/2006
Comments of Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (PC #6298) (electronic
filing)
9/20/2006
Post-Hearing Comments of Environment Illinois and Environmental Law and
Policy Center (PC #6297)
9/20/2006
City of Springfield, City Water Light & Power's Post-Hearing Comments (PC
#6296) (authorized fax filing)
9/20/2006
Comments of Phillip M. Gonet, President, Illinois Coal Association (PC #6295)
(electronic filing)
9/20/2006
*Prairie State PHC Post-Hearing Comments (PC# 6294) (electronic filing)
9/15/2006
Midwest Generation's Post-Hearing Comments: Additional Information (PC
#6293) (electronic filing)
9/13/2006
*Comments: Sources of Mercury Wet Deposition in Eastern Ohio, USA
(Stubenville Report) PC 6292)
9/11/2006
*Comments of Marie Balducci (PC #6291)
9/8/2006
Michael Murray References in Support of Oral Testimony and Changes to
Written Testimony References (PC #6290) (electronic filing) (Due to their
volume, the references noted in this filing are not included in the viewable file.
You may contact the Clerk's Office at 312/814-3629 to view or purchase a copy)
8/29/2006
*Comments of Betty Jane Mydill (PC #6289)
8/28/2006
*Comments of Janel Wager (PC #6288)
8/25/2006
*Corrected Exhibit #88 of Sid Nelson, Jr. President, Sorbent Technologies Corp.
(PC #6287)
8/25/2006
*Comments on Proposed Mercury Emission Controls for Electric Generating
Units in Illinois by Eugene M. Trisko, General Counsel, Unions for Jobs and the
Environment (PC #6286) (electronic filing)
8/25/2006
*Comments of Susan Spengler, President, League of Women Voters, Palatine
Area (PC #6285)
8/23/2006
Corrected Joint Statement of the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency and
Dynegy Midwest Generation, Inc. (electronic filing) (PC #6284)
8/21/2006
Joint Statement of Illinois Environmental Protection Agency and Dynegy
Midwest Generation (a revision of the New Section 225.233 Multi-Pollutant
Standards) (PC #6283)
8/18/2006
*Comments of Scott Wiseman, Vice President, Center for energy and Economic
Development, Inc., Midwest Region (PC# 6282) (electronic filing)
8/15/2006
*Comments of Beth & Chris Graham (PC #6281)
8/4/2006
*Comments of Anne Waltner (PC 6279) and Michael Zucker (PC 6280)
8/1/2006
*Comments of Chris Parson (PC #6278)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
7/31/2006
Post-Hearing Comments of the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (with 1
copy of IPM Modeling Data CD) (PC 6277)
7/25/2006
*Comments of April K. Holden, Village Clerk, Village of Downers Grove (PC
#6276)
7/24/2006
*Comments of Roy & Lucille Ott (PC #6274) and Tina McNomee (PC #6275)
7/20/2006
*Comments of Joe Miller (PC #6273)
7/19/2006
*Comments of Thomas J. Kluk (PC #6272)
7/18/2006
*Comments of Barbara J. Mitchel (PC 6269); Debby Storms (PC 6270); and
Tracey Martin (PC 6271)
7/14/2006
*Comments of Mary Waltner (PC 6266); Philip Eisenbeis (PC 6267); and John
Manning (PC 6268)
7/11/2006
*Comments of Walter E. Weiss (PC 6265)
7/10/2006
*Comments of Sarah & Joe Takash (PC #6264)
7/7/2006
Post-Hearing Comments of the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (PC
#6263); Illinois Environmental Protection Agency's First Errata Sheet to its
Rulemaking Proposal; Written Answers to Pre-Filed Questions for Sid Nelson, Jr.
(electronic filing)
7/6/2006
*Comments of Bonnie Ryszka (PC 6245); Dirk Gillespie (PC 6246); Kathy Roe
(PC 6247); Michael A. Monestero (PC 6248); Russ Sahagian (PC 6249); Michael
Green. (PC 6250); Peter Santoro (PC 6251); Collin Dezord(PC 6252); Claudia
Zelechowski (PC 6253); Tim Dull (PC 6254); Ben Helphand (PC 6255); Anton
C. Seda Jr (PC 6256); M. Waite (PC 6257); Rebecca Bailey (PC 6258); Tyler
Thompson (PC 6259); John-Henry Scherck (PC 6260); Mark Loewy (PC 6261);
Erry Beem (PC 6262)
6/29/2006
*Comments of Jackie Fischer (PC #6244)
6/28/2006
*Comments of Tara M. Dull (PC #6243)
6/26/2006
*Comments of Liz Driscoll (PC #6242)
6/19/2006
*Comments of Marjorie Leopardo (PC# 6241)
6/19/2006
*Comments of Conazd Bedard (PC# 6240)
6/16/2006
*Comments of Mary Koziel (PC #6239)
6/15/2006
*Comments of Susan D. Lannin (PC # 6238)
6/15/2006
*Comments of Ann Gadzikowski (PC # 6237)
6/14/2006
*Comments of Paula F. Cowan, MD (PC #6236)
6/13/2006
*Illinois PIRG - Comments of Ronald Jankowski (PC #6235.151); Zach Yarnoff
(PC #6235.152); Dana Odorizzi (PC #6235.153); Rosetta Colbert (PC
#6235.154); Lor Merlz (PC #6235.155); Thomas Ward (PC #6235.156); John
Skrip (PC #6235.157); Joe Kaltsas (PC #6235.158); Laura Jacobs (PC
#6235.159); Kris Massanari (PC #6235.160); Michael Cameron (PC #6235.161);
Tenaida Somera (PC #6235.162); Camby Kaltsas (PC #6235.163); Teresa
Santiago (PC #6235.164); Al Schactman (PC #6235.165); Carol Schectman (PC
#6235.166); Sara Fisher (PC #6235.167); Carolyn Schotz (PC #6235.168); Vicki
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Kaminsky (PC #6235.169); Larry Kaminsky (PC #6235.170); Jamie Oline (PC
#6235.171); Brad Cornelius (PC #6235.172); S. Friedman (PC #6235.173); Paul
Gilbert (PC #6235.174); James Brysten (PC #6235.175); Carl W. Schunil (PC
#6235.176); Janice M. Schunil (PC #6235.177); M. Jane Burns (PC #6235.178);
Barb Turk (PC #6235.179); Clarita Santos (PC #6235.180); John Lucudum (PC
#6235.181); Stuart Thompson (PC #6235.182); Jennifer Collins (PC #6235.183);
Craig Soule (PC #6235.184); Ted Collins (PC #6235.185); Meredith Dodd (PC
#6235.186); Melissa Cornelius (PC #6235.187); Jennifer Evans (PC #6235.188);
Gregory Flanders (PC #6235.189); Karl Smith (PC #6235.190); Glenys Craig
(PC #6235.191); Patricia Cotter (PC #6235.192); Celia Reyes (PC #6235.193);
Gary VanMoffaert (PC #6235.194); Seth Thomas (PC #6235.195); Sandy Rusch
(PC #6235.196); Mark Hauser (PC #6235.197); francie Lightfine (PC
#6235.198); Judy Johnson (PC #6235.199); Jim Mazzolini (PC #6235.200)
6/13/2006
*Illinois PIRG - Comments of Betsy bouchard (PC #6235.101); Harvey Maden
(PC #6235.102); Mike Indecipherable (PC #6235.103); Michael Swanson (PC
#6235.104); Sowren Bhatiachanze (PC #6235.105); Paul Babinec (PC
#6235.106); Joseph Lee (PC #6235.107); Erica Schwab (PC #6235.108); Michael
Scholub (PC #6235.109); Sara Furner (PC #6235.110); G. Schubert (PC
#6235.111); Catalina Sanchez (PC #6235.112); Mike Nicholas (PC #6235.113);
Lorna Johnson (PC #6235.114); Kay Anderson (PC #6235.115); Caroline Benson
(PC #6235.116); Josephine Giancarlo (PC #6235.117); Tim Schell (PC
#6235.118); Shari Pergricht (PC #6235.119); Drina Nikola (PC #6235.120); Rita
Hall (PC #6235.121); Bob Juenger (PC #6235.122); Mark Nesli (PC #6235.123);
Loemor Levin (PC #6235.124); J. T. Atterberry (PC #6235.125); Jan Meyers (PC
#6235.126); Stephanie Ficalti (PC #6235.127); Kayla Cohen (PC #6235.128);
John Colbert (PC #6235.129); Deborah Haralz (PC #6235.130); Susan Androfp
(PC #6235.131); Catherine Schmidt (PC #6235.132); Val McCann (PC
#6235.133); Christine Reilly (PC #6235.134); Mel Zucker (PC #6235.135);
Connie Kris (PC #6235.136); Ct Lewis (PC #6235.137); Alan Soe (PC
#6235.138); Michael Weaver (PC #6235.139); Jennite Haywood (PC
#6235.140); Elizabeth Todorovic (PC #6235.141); Milos Todorovic (PC
#6235.142); Rose Houston (PC #6235.143); Sheila Parekit (PC #6235.144);
Katherine Choi (PC #6235.145); Kerry Galson (PC #6235.146); Polly Knudsen
(PC #6235.147); Ron Schuler (PC #6235.148); Michael Kramer (PC #6235.149);
Frank Sipos (PC #6235.150)
6/13/2006
*Illinois PIRG - Comments of Carlos Melian (PC #6235.51); Nancy Darling (PC
#6235.52); Michael Zucker (PC #6235.53); Chloe McCuhie (PC #6235.54); Eric
Patterson (PC #6235.55); Sean McCuhie (PC #6235.56); Jacqueline Boyer (PC
#6235.57); Kelly Viti (PC #6235.58); Betty Zucker (PC #6235.59); Julie Zwiebel
(PC #6235.60); Abigail McGlothen (PC #6235.61); Tony Young (PC #6235.62);
Diane Levy (PC #6235.63); Kelly Marshall (PC #6235.64); Gail Donnelly (PC
#6235.65); Linda Kruhmin (PC #6235.66); David Sack (PC #6235.67); Hymen
Bayer (PC #6235.68); Tom Reiter (PC #6235.69); Caroline Winkler (PC
#6235.70); Gladys N. Bryer (PC #6235.71); Mary Cohen (PC #6235.72); Dolores
Hannan (PC #6235.73); Jane Madejczyk (PC #6235.74); Ellen Patterson (PC
#6235.75); Victor Palumbo (PC #6235.76); Ann Brigham (PC #6235.77); Tom
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Williams (PC #6235.78); P. Guinsitze (PC #6235.79); Laura Maloney (PC
#6235.80); Rose Thomas (PC #6235.81); Harriet Russell (PC #6235.82); David
Jones (PC #6235.83); Reuben Thomas (PC #6235.84); Aislinn Ryan (PC
#6235.85); Christa Suk (PC #6235.86); Nick Beem (PC #6235.87); Deb Palmer
(PC #6235.88); Ann Haslet (PC #6235.89); Dana Riess (PC #6235.90); James
Hamlet (PC #6235.91); Leah Barnum (PC #6235.92); Margarite Indecipherable
(PC #6235.93); Kevin Glynn (PC #6235.94); Matt Kleinschmidt (PC #6235.95);
Eva Penar (PC #6235.96); Jeanette Ho (PC #6235.97); A. Cerda (PC #6235.98);
Serafina Riegel (PC #6235.99); Martha Szczesnt (PC #6235.100)
6/13/2006
*Illinois PIRG - Comments of Diane Trenbeth (PC #6235.0); Jane Kelley (PC
#6235.1); Hal Mead (PC #6235.2); Marcia Bernsten (PC #6235.3); Marvin
Bassan (PC #6235.4); Linda Kruhmin (PC #6235.5); Andrew Fisher (PC
#6235.6); Debbie Hillman (PC #6235.7); Michael Zucker (PC #6235.8); Marjorie
C. L. Fisher (PC #6235.9); Joel Freeman (PC #6235.10); Andrea Orault (PC
#6235.11); Peter Laundy (PC #6235.12); Verria Todd (PC #6235.13); Annie
Martin (PC #6235.14); Rodney Erickson (PC #6235.15); Walter M. Rozak (PC
#6235.16); Terrence Delaney (PC #6235.17); Yvonne Jarrett (PC #6235.18);
Mary P. Taylor (PC #6235.19); Bernie Turner (PC #6235.20); Greg Primosch
(PC #6235.21; Laurie Davidson (PC #6235.22); Dan Heck (PC #6235.23); Tanya
Tuck (PC #6235.24); Gale Dreas (PC #6235.25); Brianna Jones (PC #6235.26);
Shelley Banik (PC #6235.27); Trudy Horvath (PC #6235.28); Linda Pratt (PC
#6235.29); John Kozenzur (PC #6235.30); Elizabeth C. Galfer (PC #6235.31);
John Kim (PC #6235.32); Terry Syor (PC #6235.33); Mary Burke-Peterson (PC
#6235.34); Alex Hansen (PC #6235.35); David Victorson (PC #6235.36); Denise
Ahlquist (PC #6235.37); Tani Strain (PC #6235.38); Lynne Lasser Marcus Thiser
(PC #6235.39); B. Polonus (PC #6235.40); Kyle Kaminsky (PC #6235.41); Liam
Palmer (PC #6235.42); Connie Salamone (PC #6235.43); Dan Salamone (PC
#6235.44); Amanda Buchbinder (PC #6235.45); Jane Thomas (PC #6235.46);
Marit Lidvall (PC #6235.47); Sheldon Cohn (PC #6235.48); Les Stahl (PC
#6235.49); George Bond (PC #6235.50)
6/12/2006
*Comments of James Maginel (PC #6234)
6/12/2006
*Comments of Astrid Kosowski (PC #6233)
6/12/2006
*Comments of Sadhu A. Johnston, Commissioner, Chicago Department of
Environment (PC #6232)
6/6/2006
*Comments of Carrie Atiyeh of KFx, Inc.(PC #6231)
6/6/2006
*Comments of W. T. Ortlund (PC #6230)
6/5/2006
*Comment of Lynn Lawson (PC #6229)
5/31/2006
*Comments of Barbara McKasson (PC #344)
5/30/2006
*Comments of Marty Jacobson (PC #343)
5/30/2006
*Comments of Joy Ann Kist (PC #342)
5/26/2006
*Comment of Jay Hassert (PC #341)
5/25/2006
Comments of Robert L. Fick (PC #340); Rich Knapik (PC #340.1)
5/24/2006
Comments of Julianna S. Alioto (PC #339); Danny Yara (PC 339.1)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/23/2006
*Comments of Linda Fitshugh (PC #338); Ron Diters (PC #338.1); John Daum
(PC #338.2); Lyn Calhoun (PC 338.3); Marlene B. Redard (PC #338.4);Chris
Jackson (PC #338.5); Mike Armstrong (PC #338.6); Cody Walker PC #338.7;
Indecipherable signature (PC #338.8); Michelle Maher (PC #338.9); Phyllis
Mooney (PC #338.10); Lori Williams (PC #338.11)
5/22/2006
Comments of T.P. Dean (PC #337); Donna Hassert (PC #337.1)
5/19/2006
Comment of Kathleen A. deGeirs (PC #336); Barbara C. Hill (PC #336.1)
5/19/2006
*Comments of Elizabeth Sohn-Hirsch (PC #335)
5/19/2006
*Comments of Ray Hollmann (PC #334)
5/18/2006
Comment of Donna Richno (PC #333); Judy Lewis (PC #333.1); Lynn Rymarz
(PC #333.2); Jill S. House (PC #333.3)
5/18/2006
*Comments of Joyce Seul (PC #332)
5/18/2006
*Comments of Eileen Wiviott (PC #331)
5/17/2006
Comment of David Kvernes (PC #330); John Achwegman (PC #330.1); Martha
Scwegman (PC #330.2); Donna Mann (PC #330.3); T. Tim Werner (PC #330.4);
Scott Thorne (PC #330.5); Laura Magnussen (PC #330.6); Kristal Craig (PC
#330.7); Mary Dunne (PC #330.8); Anthony Trevino (PC #330.9); Gloria
Bowman (PC #330.10); Kristal Craig (PC #330.11)
5/16/2006
Comment of Sharon Collins (PC #329); Donald A. Lawrence (329.1)
5/16/2006
*Postcard of Jannin Retzloff (PC #328)
5/15/2006
*Postcard of Laura Mudd (PC #327)
5/15/2006
*Sierra Club Comments - Nicky Drennan (PC #326); Vince Naz (PC #326.1);
Diana Hayes (PC #326.2); Angie McNeill (PC #326.3); Laurel Tourssant (PC
#326.4); Marilyn M. Good (PC #326.5); Rod Tally (PC #326.6);
5/12/2006
Pepi Camerlingo (PC #323.19)
5/12/2006
Public Comments of Indecipherable signature (PC #323); Indecipherable
signature (PC 323.1); Bethany Boyer-Pechlin (PC 323.2); Rick Fry (PC #323.3);
Indicipherable signature (PC 323.4)Janet Graves (PC #323.5); Mark Oldridge
(PC 323.6); Indecipherable signature (PC 323.7); Andrew Fick (PC #323.8);
Joyce Fry (PC 323.9); Indecipherable signature (PC #323.10); Jim Wolf (PC
323.11); Sean Keane (PC 323.12); David Brookman (PC #323.13); Walt
Robinson (PC 323.14); Michelle Coble (PC #323.15); Indecipherable signature
(PC 323.16); Pat Parrish (PC 323.17); Indicipherable signature (PC 323.18;
5/12/2006
*Comments of Susan Talling (PC #324)
5/12/2006
Comments of the Earth Team of Belle Aire School: Patricia Burke, MD (PC
#322); Melody (PC #322.1); Harrison (PC #322.2); Justine (PC #322.3); A.J.C.
(PC #322.4); Alex (PC #322.5); Sam (PC #322.6); Lauren (PC #322.7); Ericka
(PC #322.8); Justin F. (PC #322.9); Jori (PC #322.10); Leo (PC #322.11);
Elizabeth (PC #322.12); Veronica (PC #322.13); Allison (PC #322.14); Rose (PC
#322.15); Amanda (PC #322.16); Monica (PC #322.17); Ronald (PC #322.18);
Carly (PC #322.19); Taylor (PC #322.20)
5/11/2006
Comments of Sierra Club - Rochelle Wyatt (PC #321); Diane Ahrens (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
#321.1); Jennifer Subleh (PC #321.2); L. Ruth Cooper (PC #321.3); Jill Pope (PC
#321.4); Zac Gill (PC #321.5); Troy Tucker (PC #321.6); Ellen Robinson (PC
#321.7); Martha Tucker (PC #321.8); Richard Rice (PC #321.9); Indecipherable
signature (PC #321.10); Loraine Creek (PC #321.11); Bob Gromm (PC #321.12);
Indeciperable signature (PC #321.13); Derrick Reed (PC #321.14); Patricia Mees
(PC #321.15); Peg Elmore (PC #321.16); Indeciperable signature) (PC #321.17);
Sherie Smith (PC #321.18); Dawn Heath (PC #321.19); Jean Morgan (PC
#321.20); Johm Dickerson (PC #321.21); indiciperable signature (PC #321.22);
Geraldine Davis (PC #321.23); Debbie Wyant (PC #321.24); Donna Gambach
(PC #321.25); Timothy W. Cooper (PC #321.26); Barb Crew (PC #321.27); Patty
White (PC #321.28); Christina Mahert (PC #321.29); W Koch (PC #321.30);
Terri Treacy (PC #321.31); Timmy Yara (PC #321.32); Margaret Schroeder (PC
#321.33); Amber Gustafson (PC #321.34);Jane Kelley (PC #321.35; Debra J.
Downs (PC #321.36); Maureen Cooke (PC #321.37); H. Vanderlinde (PC
#321.38); Ryan E. Campbell (PC #321.39); Mickey Stewart (PC #321.40);
Robert Dawson (PC #321.41); Kim M. Davis (PC #321.42)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Dr. Harry Miller and Lucie Miler (PC # 320)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Jean Whitmore (PC # 319)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Susanne Schwinn (PC # 318)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Wil Root (PC # 317)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Sarah Beck (PC # 316)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Mighan Nigra (PC # 315)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Chris Clarer (PC # 314)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Kingsten Kordecki (PC # 313)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Rich Whitney (PC # 312)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Indesciferable (PC # 311)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Justin Skord (PC # 310)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Lynne Wycoro, RN (PC # 309)
5/10/2006
*Comments of John Koch (PC # 308)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Cliff Dambrow (PC # 307)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Tom Clark (PC # 306)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Susan Truesdale (PC # 305)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Erin C. Stern (PC # 304)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Josh Stern (PC # 303)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Elissa Johnson (PC # 302)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Michael Wagner (PC # 301)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Megan R. Pulliam (PC # 300)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Paula Bradshaw (PC # 299)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Jeremy Jones (PC # 298)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Shelby Pepper (PC # 297)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/10/2006
*Comments of Abigail J. Breeser (PC # 296)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Colleen M. McGaugh (PC # 295)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Jessica Tibbets (PC # 294)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Selena Johnston (PC # 293)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Emily Astor (PC # 292)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Paul & Jennifer Zielinski (PC # 291)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Jessica Brandhaw (PC # 290)
5/10/2006
*Comments of The Rev. Ms. Barbara Pescar (PC # 289)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Sandi Carr (PC # 288)
5/10/2006
*Comments of Linda Kruhmin (PC # 287)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Elizabeth Geaslin (PC # 286)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Barbara Mitchell (PC # 285)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Alison L. Gerlach (PC # 284)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Rachelle L. Brooks (PC # 283)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Dale Griffin (PC # 282)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Adam Lutman (PC # 281)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Bob Morley (PC # 280)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Sharon Colman (PC # 279)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Lia Kaydus (PC # 278)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Rex Poe (PC # 277)
5/9/2006
*Comments of Liz Harrison (PC # 276)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Sheila Leadbetter (PC 6200); Steve Adler (PC
6201); Alan Shannon (PC 6202); A Shannon (PC 6203); Alana Macary (PC
6204); Alex A. Bobroff (PC 6205); Andy Lewis (PC 6206); Anthony Schmitt
(PC 6207); Alice Guzman (PC 6208); Alice Reich (PC 6209); Alicia Dodd (PC
6210); Andrew Glicksberg (PC 6211); Angeline Heisler (PC 6212); Amy Hijjawi
(PC 6213); Andrew Huffer (PC 6214); Aine Rock (PC 6215); Allan Johnston (PC
6216); Alejandra Javiera Caballero (PC 6217); Andrew Schwarz (PC 6218);
Anne Kiraly (PC 6219); Alissa Andrew (PC 6220); Bill Abernethy (PC 6221);
Amy Lazzeretti (PC 6222); Anthony Bisciglia (PC 6223); April Abon (PC 6224);
Amy Converse (PC 6225); Andrew Cuming (PC 6226); Jan Adamczyk (PC
6227); Susan Schlitz (PC 6228)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Andrew Hodgman (PC 6150); Leslie Babson (PC
6151); Jason Maratina (PC 6152); Jay Kalawadia (PC 6153); Graeme MacDonald
(PC 6154); Jeff Granger (PC 6155); Robert Green (PC 6156); Gregory Jarosz
(PC 6157); Gregor Sosnowski (PC 6158); Joanne Blumberg (PC 6159); Geoffrey
Guzynski (PC 6160); Sandy Rusch (PC 6161); Garth Lewis (PC 6162); Georgia
Gebhardt (PC 6163); Craig Shapiro (PC 6164); George Kocalis (PC 6165);
Gloria Lasley (PC 6166); Glenn Hagemann (PC 6167); Drew Barrett (PC 6168);
Gloria Linville (PC 6169); Gerald Fleetwood (PC 6170); Jan Kirsch (PC 6171);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Jason McAllister (PC 6172); Jay Owens (PC 6173); Jean Macary (PC 6174);
John Krapf (PC 6175); JoAnne Bogacz Boyle (PC 6176); Justin Burt (PC 6177);
John Armstrong (PC 6178); Jane Drews (PC 6179); Gregory Hardigan (PC
6180); Jerry Wray (PC 6181); Mary Anne Madeira (PC 6182); Kathy Boyens
(PC 6183); Sarah Johnson (PC 6184); Brian Shehan (PC 6185); Barbara Zaniolo
(PC 6186); Cynthia Fey (PC 6187); Greg Burnet (PC 6188); Jamie Pollack (PC
6189); Jeanette Hernandez (PC 6190); Jan & Don Barshis (PC 6191); Jane Lewis
(PC 6192); Jane Driesen (PC 6193); Kurt Ro (PC 6194); Michael Zucker (PC
6195); K Taira (PC 6196); John Zbesko (PC 6197); Caroline Wayne (PC 6198);
Sue Eberhardt (PC 6199)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Fredrick Holland (PC 6100); Jeanne Klein (PC
6101); Lois Snyder (PC 6102); Kathryn Waecker (PC 6103); Kathi Wotal (PC
6104); Lisa Wand (PC 6105); Lucy Elliott (PC 6106); Laura Lapinskas (PC
6107); Lanlan Hoo (PC 6108); Julia Rosenthal (PC 6109); Elizabeth Scheet (PC
6110); Ellen Simsohn (PC 6111); Everett (PC 6112); Chris Klarer (PC 6113);
Julie Barbosa (PC 6114); Alexis Adler (PC 6115); Robert Davis (PC 6116); Tim
McKeever (PC 6117); David Feurzeig (PC 6118); Michael Finley (PC 6119);
Frederick Simon (PC 6120); Gregory Lapin (PC 6121); Gretchen Gharrett (PC
6122); Gary Weune, Jr. (PC 6123); Gail Merritt (PC 6124); Gale Grossman (PC
6125); Eric Cartier (PC 6126); Erin Roberts (PC 6127); Erin Maiorca (PC 6128);
Eric Rogers (PC 6129); Scott Dalebroux (PC 6130); hristine Kamradt (PC 6131);
Rena Baldwin (PC 6132); R. Baldwin (PC 6133); Frank Shannon (PC 6134);
Frank Paulo (PC 6135); Mark Foisy (PC 6136); Margaret Nagel (PC 6137); Felix
Owen (PC 6138); Frank Kalmar (PC 6139); Karen Groom (PC 6140); Paul
Hofferkamp (PC 6141); Vladimir Gedgafov (PC 6142); Matt Gebhardt (PC
6143); Lizzeth Montejano (PC 6144); Glen Depke (PC 6145); Nicolas Galindo
(PC 6146); Robert L. Hopper (PC 6147); Gabriel Gardner (PC 6148); Andrew
Fisher (PC 6149)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Elizabeth Stange (PC #6,050); Kathryn Hutchinson
(PC 6051); Karen Sandefur (PC 6052); Karl Hjerpe (PC 6053); JoEllen Kames
(PC 6054); Karen Berg (PC 6055); Karen Turek (PC 6056); Karie Ellison (PC
6057); Catherine Donlon (PC 6058); Kathy Petrauskas (PC 6059); Juliet
Sosnowski (PC 6060); Julia Bathon (PC 6061); Melissa Feorstel (PC 6062);
Jacqueline Van Cleave (PC 6063); Joy Phillips Blocki (PC 6064); Sherry Liles
(PC 6065); Jason Yee (PC 6066); Carolyn Chapman (PC 6067); Geri Baumblatt
(PC 6068); Joan Bradford (PC 6069); George Kruchten (PC 6070); Karen
Schenkenfelder (PC 6071); Karen Sewick (PC 6072); Karen Stacey (PC 6073);
Catherine Ballew (PC 6074); Mary Jo Kuffner (PC 6075); Kurt Weissenborn (PC
6076): Earl G. Bley Jr. (PC 6077); Kerry Nelson (PC 6078); Juliet Sosnowski
(PC 6079); Kathy Mrzlak (PC 6080); James Kosharsky (PC 6081); Michael
Kreuser (PC 6082); John Kriegshauser (PC 6083); P. Christine Schmidt (PC
6084); Kris Aune (PC 6085); Kristi Sloniger (PC 6086); Kristine Miller (PC
6087); Kalyn Lambert (PC 6088); Kenneth Schmidt (PC 6089); Leslie Peet (PC
6090); M. Rivera-Rogers (PC 6091); Larry Goldstein (PC 6092); Kjerstine
McHugh (PC 6093); Kristofer Kiszynski (PC 6094); Katherine Krasin (PC 6095);
Karen Truskowski (PC 6096); Katherine Robandtk (PC 6097); Karin Nelson-
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Rogers (PC 6098); Kate Ogden (PC 6099)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jenny Stierman (PC #6,000); June Tanoue (PC
6001); Joe Taylor (PC 6002); John Trecka (PC 6003); John Tykol (PC 6004);
Judith Pieper (PC 6005); Judy Stringer (PC 6006); Judy Johnson (PC 6007);
Judith Lithota (PC 6008); Juli Langelund (PC 6009); Joyce Varona (PC 6010);
John Pappas (PC 6011); Julie Denham (PC 6012); John Macke (PC 6013); Jack
C. Richmond (PC 6014); J. Rothstein (PC 6015); Judy Rubenstein (PC 6016);
Jeff Salkas (PC 6017); Jennifer Satterlee (PC 6018); Jacob September (PC 6019);
Karen Fresco (PC 6020); Maureen Wolf (PC 6021); Kim Kuesis (PC 6022);
David Johnsen (PC 6023); John Carr (PC 6024); Joe Lyerla (PC 6025); Hans
Jostlein (PC 6026); Kate O'Rourke (PC 6027); J. Shiflett (PC 6028); Joyce Lopez
(PC 6029); Kathleen Crittendan (PC 6030); Kingsley Day (PC 6031); Kathleen
Diviak (PC 6032); Kelly Lehmann (PC 6033); Ken Gilmour (PC 6034); Ken
Follett (PC 6035); Kerry Doyle (PC 6036); Kevin Womac (PC 6037); Kevin
SMith (PC 6038); Kathryn Fosher (PC 6039); Kathy Stefans (PC 6040); Kathy
Chan (PC 6041); Katherine Kuffner (PC 6042); Kathy Ruopp (PC 6043); Kathy
Ruopp (PC 6044); Ken Aud (PC 6045); Kay Trevarthen (PC 6046); Keith Bailey
(PC 6047); Karen Claus (PC 6048); Kewana Colquitt (PC 6049)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jeffery Biss (PC 5950);Jeff Palmer (PC 5951);
Joshua Harris (PC 5952); Jemmie Dolan (PC 5953); Jennette N (PC 5954); Jerry
Umlauf (PC 5955); Jerome Leber (PC 5956); Jeremy Sobek (PC 5957); Surak
Guneralp (PC 5958); Paula Propst (PC 5959); Theodore Steck (PC 5960); Allen
Lewis (PC 5961); Marion Grendzinski (PC 5962); Debbie O'Neill (PC 5963);
Umar Shakur (PC 5964); Tom Caravette (PC 5965); Glenn Neumann (PC 5966);
Jason Shepherd (PC 5967); Trisha Boyce (PC 5968); Todd Smith (PC 5969);
Christine O'Neil (PC 5970); Elaine Thomopoulos (PC 5971); Chris Silva (PC
5972); Thomas Hurrle (PC 5973); Tim Sheridan (PC 5974); Timothy Montague
(PC 5975); Barbara Tipton (PC 5976); Karen Bourne (PC 5977); Theresa
Czernik (PC 5978); Theodore Jackanicz (PC 5979); Thomas Kuczmarski (PC
5980); Elaine Thomopoulos (PC 5981); William LeRette Kauffman (PC 5982);
Tim Thomas (PC 5983); Tim Dean (PC 5984); Nick Gullo (PC 5985); Susan
Lannin (PC 5986); S Lannin (PC 5987); Tom Czubernat (PC 5988); Thulani
LeGrier (PC 5989); Jodi Kahn (PC 5990); Jane Huth (PC 5991); John Hegner
(PC 5992); Alison Lo (PC 5993); Barbara Waldron (PC 5994); Dan Mueth (PC
5995); Nancy Herron (PC 5996); James Perkins (PC 5997); Rachelle Lopez (PC
5998); Peter Reagel (PC 599)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Joyce Morimoto (PC 5900); Jackie Richards (PC
5901); Jaclyn Zawacki (PC 5902); Jeanne Davies (PC 5903); Joy Jaeger (PC
5904); Jean Dust (PC 5905); Sara Kerastas (PC 5906); Jody Martiniak (PC
5907); Jamie Gould (PC 5908); James Spreitler (PC 5909); Lisette Mroz (PC
5910); Isaac Bloom (PC 5911); Ilana Kaplan Shain (PC 5912); Eric Murken (PC
5913); Ingrid Haugen (PC 5914); Julianna Walo (PC 5915); Isiah Dalton (PC
5916); Israel Friedman (PC 5917); Jules Kaplan (PC 5918); Jason Koontz (PC
5919); Lauren Selcke (PC 5920); David Hilkes (PC 5921); Hannah Lissauer (PC
5922); Helen Douglas (PC 5923); Lilija Martinka (PC 5924); Helen Myers (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5925); Holly Dyer (PC 5926); Andrew Houle (PC 5927); Hussain Nomanhbhai
(PC 5928); Allison Sacerdote (PC 5929); Rachel Benoit (PC 5930); Hayley
Murphy (PC 5931); Henry Calamia, Jr. (PC 5932); Heidi Jecklin (PC 5933);
Helen Osterman (PC 5934); Cindy Herula (PC 5935); Helen Escobar (PC 5936);
Barry Lasswell (PC 5937); Halimah Muhammad (PC 5938); Lynn Higbee (PC
5939); Paula Propst (PC 5940); Kerry Hall (PC 5941); Laura Williams (PC
5942); Karl Smith (PC 5943); Harry Rurup (PC 5944); Janet Harden (PC 5945);
John H (PC 5946); Harry Hazelton (PC 5947); Michael Hartke (PC 5948);
Kristen Brown (PC 5949)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Bonnie Zouras (PC 5850); Yumi Ishihara (PC
5851); Craig Williams (PC 5852); Yvonne Hedeker (PC 5853); Yale Wolk (PC
5854); Gary Adams (PC 5855); Janelle Reach (PC 5856); Dale Medendorp (PC
5857); Daniel Puralewski (PC 5858); Dan Johnson Weinberger (PC 5859); Frank
Harrison (PC 5860); Gerald Kaiser (PC 5861); William Kerins (PC 5862); Debra
Adelson (PC 5863); Robert Smith (PC 5864); Warren Scaman (PC 5865); Nancy
Shook (PC 5866); Wilson Shook (PC 5867); Warren becker (PC 5868); Clement
Juris (PC 5869); Mary Hirose (PC 5870); Daniel Tietzer (PC 5871); Robert
Sellke (PC 5872); Carolen Welch (PC 5873); Angela West Blank (PC 5874);
William Freeto (PC 5875); Jean Brennan (PC 5876); Mark Brown (PC 5877);
Cheryl Widman (PC 5878); Eileen Hand (PC 5879); Val Anderson (PC 5880);
Vladimir Mikhelson (PC 5881); Vinita Ricks (PC 5882); Suzana Preradovic (PC
5883); Veatrice Grady (PC 5884); Barry Seth (PC 5885); Tauni Reinschmidt (PC
5886); Warren Schoen (PC 5887); Natalia Pavlov (PC 5888); Todd Drefcinski
(PC 5889); Mary Brown (PC 5890); Francie Lightfine (PC 5891); Umeeta
Sadarangani (PC 5892); Amanda Foster (PC 5893); Valerie Krejcie (PC 5894);
Alex Vazquez (PC 5895); Vazquez (PC 5896); Robert Chesrow (PC 5897);
Linnzi Hodel (PC 5898); Lori Roberts (PC 5899)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Don Mahnke (PC 5800); Steven Spagnolo (PC
5801); Amanda Helm (PC 5802); Suzanne Kim (PC 5803); Roseanna Newby
(PC 5804); Vivien Beirne (PC 5805); Edward Maex (PC 5806); Edward Marx
(PC 5807); Larry Epke (PC 5808); Nicholas Wilson (PC 5809); Shira Belenke
(PC 5810); Susan Lee (PC 5811); Lori Reicin (PC 5812); Scott Roos (PC 5813);
Sharon McBride (PC 5814); Sandra McCoy (PC 5815); Sandra McGee (PC
5816); Shayle Miller (PC 5817); Susan Oros (PC 5818); Patricia MacGregor (PC
5819); Stephanie Kevil (PC 5820); Rebecca Thomas (PC 5821); Susanna Lang
(PC 5822); Deanne Turim (PC 5823); Alexandra Sipiora (PC 5824); Rosiland
Baldwin (PC 5825); Steven Francque (PC 5826); Stephanie Frantz (PC 5827);
Aandrea Jones (PC 5828); Candice Skedel (PC 5829); Dan Novak PC 5830);
Deborah Davis (PC 5831); Shobba Sharma (PC 5832); Malcolm Harsch (PC
5833); Sheryl Barajas (PC 5834); Shel Sagan (PC 5835); Shelley Swanson (PC
5836); Amy Franco (PC 5837); Simone Bullen (PC 5838); Paul Manning (PC
5839); Daniel Kuruna (PC 5840); Dan Guzman (PC 5841); Dan Busemeyer (PC
5842); Terri Voitik (PC 5843); Steven Leopldo (PC 5844); Thomas Cummings
(PC 5845); Timothy Foley (PC 5846); Thulani LeGrier (PC 5847); Tim English
(PC 5848); Ted Morrison (PC 5849)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/8/2006
*Comments of Patricia Czach (PC 5750; Ron Sherman (PC 5751); Ronald
Werner (PC 5752); Rose Buchanan (PC 5753); Tom Rossen (PC 5754);
Rosemary Maziarz (PC 5755); Richard Scoles (PC 5756); Richard Kramer (PC
5757); Sarah Takash (PC 5758); Sarah Wiedel (PC 5759); Elizabeth Grimwade
(PC 5760); Amy Hilarides (PC 5761); R.S. Pineknot (PC 5762); Ralph Steinmeir
(PC 5763); Ronald Elkins (PC 5764); Richard Winship (PC 5765); Jennifer Ryan
(PC 5766); Lucia Spinelli (PC 5767); Sandra Hale (PC 5768); Pedro Sanchez (PC
5769); Sandra Taenzer (PC 5770); Sarah Burden (PC 5771); Tamar Shapira (PC
5772); Tara Mark (PC 5773); Tom Seals (PC 5774); Terry Clarbour (PC 5775);
Trudy Diepholz (PC 5776); Mary Harvey (PC 5777); Susan Nicholson (PC
5778); Ellen Multack (PC 5779); Seth Urbanowitz (PC 5780); Celia Bucci (PC
5781); Leslie Warner (PC 5782); Kim Ogle (PC 5783); Susan Reed (PC 5784);
Marie France Russell (PC 5785); Sandra Schwartz (PC 5786); Barbara Stout (PC
5787); Susan Straus (PC 5788); Susan Crawford (PC 5789); Stella Kukadia (PC
5790); Steve Burns (PC 5791); Steve Blank (PC 5792); Carol Gulyas (PC 5793);
Bob Ronkese (PC 5794); Susan Meiers (PC 5795); Arlene Hardy (PC 5796);
Susan Daniel (PC 5797); Grace Hanania (PC 5798); Sue Lafferty (PC 5799)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Roberta Nash (PC 5700); Rosemary Armocida (PC
5701); Rob Putnam (PC 5702); Robert Coleman (PC 5703); Rose Kaiser (PC
5704); Christine Schopieray (PC 5705); Robert Berry (PC 5706); Brett Goad (PC
5707); Rebecca Cohan (PC 5708); Faigie & Robert Tanner (PC 5709); Paul
Saydak (PC 5710); Stephanie Baker (PC 5711); Sara Belskis (PC 5712); S. Fram
(PC 5713); Richard Johannsen (PC 5714); Richard j. Selfridge, Jr. (PC 5715); R
Selfridge (PC 5716); Robert Kastigar (PC 5717); Robert Kusel (PC 5718);
Robert Lubotsky (PC 5719); Alexandra Schabel (PC 5720); Shelby Childress (PC
5721); John Galdun (PC 5722); Ken Schmidt (PC 5723); Marius Clobanu (PC
5724); Steve Dlugo (PC 5725); Suzanne Carlson (PC 5726); Susan Dziekan (PC
5727); Suzanne Flynn (PC 5728); Sean Lynch (PC 5729); Katherine Moseley
(PC 5730); James Senhauser (PC 5731); Sally Parry (PC 5732); Sandra Lehner
(PC 5733); Sarah Guernsey (PC 5734); Sharon Buazard (PC 5735); Joyce Rhea
(PC 5736); Richard Byrne (PC 5737); Ritchie Trull (PC 5738); Jennifer Shroder
(PC 5739); Subir Trivedi (PC 5740); Kimberly Nicosia (PC 5741); Paul Saydak
(PC 5742); Susan Rahija (PC 5743); Susan Raffel (PC 5744); Suzanne Bouzo
(PC 5745); Beth Rich (PC 5746); Stephanie Yablonsky (PC 5747); Kathy Smith
(PC 5748); Thomas A. Culak (PC 5749)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Phoebe Bower (PC 5650); Philip Hult (PC 5651);
Peter Kuehnel (PC 5652); Philip Kritzman (PC 5653); Pat McHughes (PC 5654);
Ed Homeier (PC 5655); Jane Beak (PC 5656); Penny Edwards (PC 5657); Peter
Valicenti (PC 5658); Peter Fassett (PC 5659); Pat McHugh (PC 5660); Patricia
Caldwell (PC 5661); P. Huelsman (PC 5662); P. Gallardo (PC 5663); Patricia
Turrise (PC 5664); Patty Ruback (PC 5665); Paula Ladin (PC 5666); Paul Avers
(PC 5667); Paul Ring (PC 5668); Diane Stein (PC 5669); Michael Yannell (PC
5670); Patricia VerStrat (PC 5671); Ellen Moriarty (PC 5672); Nora Liu (PC
5673); Timothy Donaghy (PC 5674); Tim Quirk (PC 5675); Rudolph Gartner
(PC 5676); Rachel Strohm (PC 5677); Rachel McClain (PC 5678); Scott Baker
(PC 5679); Nancy Pollack (PC 5680); Moira Bateman (PC 5681); Phil Rider (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5682); Pat Salecki (PC 5683); Margaret Wedoff (PC 5684); RoseMarie Berg (PC
5685); Rose Weidner Lundemo (PC 5686); Rebecca Moschorak (PC 5687);
Steven Burkhard (PC 5688); Teresa Hjerpe (PC 5689); Richard May (PC 5690);
Rebecca Poteet (PC 5691); David Rechs (PC 5692); Maureen Quaid (PC 5693);
Bill Hoglund (PC 5694); Richard Eveleth (PC 5695); Richard Falzone (PC
5696); Reginald Gibbons (PC 5697); Richard Acker (PC 5698); Patricia Berry
(PC 5699)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Nancy Brandt (PC 5600); Nicholas Bianchi (PC
5601); Nickolas Daniels (PC 5602); Konrad Bis (PC 5603); Nathaniel Macke
(PC 5604); Nancy L. Cowger (PC 5605); Nikki Limper (PC 5606); N.M. Bush
(PC 5607); Natalie Topinka (PC 5608); Noreen Snead (PC 5609); Nancy Hejna
(PC 5610); Bonnie Horzepa (PC 5611); Philip Ceisel (PC 5612); Peter Lock (PC
5613); Natalia Trawkowski (PC 5614); Nicole Baird (PC 5615); Nicole Bosak
(PC 5616); Nancy J. Cline (PC 5617); Nathan Hasselhorst (PC 5618); Neva
Frank (PC 5619); Richard Turrise (PC 5620); Karen Parker (PC 5621); Rev.
Rebecca Gordon (PC 5622); Pat Hanna (PC 5623); Pat McHugh (PC 5624);
Nancy Bloom (PC 5625); Nancy Lee (PC 5626); Nancy Strand (PC 5627);
Natalia Petraszxzuk (PC 5628); Diane Moeller (PC 5629); Shari Gullo (PC
5630); Brent Barrow (PC 5631); Colleen O'Connell (PC 5632); Alexander Tarsi
(PC 5633); Orzin Merritt (PC 5634); Christopher Qualiardi (PC 5635); Orchestra
(PC 5636); John Hactel (PC 5637); John Cara (PC 5638); Denise Akason (PC
5639); Pamela Lamaster-Millett (PC 5640); Nina Neitzke (PC 5641); Connie
Steinhoff (PC 5642); Norbert Honermeier (PC 5643); Ken Brown (PC 5644);
N.Schabes (PC 5645); Natalie Schmitt (PC 5646); Noreen Sherwood (PC 5647);
Natasha Shpiller (PC 5648); Neil Martin (PC 5649)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jack Benton (PC #5,550); Joy White (PC 5551);
Jullie Nold (PC 5552); Joanna Metzger (PC 5553); Joan Ladie (PC 5554); Joanne
True (PC 5555); Joan Hickey (PC 5556); Joseph Philip (PC 5557); Alice
Schroeder (PC 5558); Joe Nast (PC 5559); Jennifer Hammer (PC 5560); Jen
Hanis (PC 5561); G.L. and J.E. Hicks (PC 5562); Jim Hinckley (PC 5563);
Joanna Challacombe (PC 5564); Jeffrey Cohen (PC 5565); Julie Montague (PC
5566); Carolyn Tomkinson (PC 5567); Jeanne Doherty (PC 5568); Jeanne
Zasadil (PC 5569); Joseph Lenti (PC 5570); John S. Wayne (PC 5571); John
Andrews (PC 5572); John Koch (PC 5573); Johnnie Jordan (PC 5574); Griselda
Jordan (PC 5575); Jessica Spruyt (PC 5576); Carol Tota (PC 5577); David
Gorman (PC 5578); John Horvath (PC 5579); Keith Kusterer (PC 5580); Douglas
Bermudez (PC 5581); Jim (PC 5582); Jim Beckwith (PC 5583); Mary Spranze
(PC 5584); John Kavalunas (PC 5585); Julie Laffin (PC 5586); Jessica Heiden
(PC 5587); Jaime Stringer (PC 5588); Jenifer Lugar (PC 5589); Marie Perkins
(PC 5590); Jack and Patsyk Kernan (PC 5591); Victor P. Garbonkus (PC 5592);
Richard Heinlein (PC 5593); Rimas Petrauskas (PC 5594); Mary Anne Warnecke
(PC 5595); Bary Wagner (PC 5596); Carrie Garcia (PC 5597); David Aaron (PC
5598); Sachin Mahajan (PC 5599)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Michelle Hodalj (PC #5,500); Michael Gallagher
(PC 5501); Michelle Uting (PC 5502); Mike Kaszynski (PC 5503); Mark
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Lundholm (PC 5504); Nancy Bender (PC 5505); Nicolas Cherix (PC 5506);
Nancy Hughes (PC 5507); Nancy Banaszak (PC 5508); Michelle Hodalj (PC
5509); Jay Mittenthal (PC 5510); Michelle Chesebro (PC 5511); Morgan Jencius
(PC 5512); Mary Mulcahy (PC 5513); Mary Mckiernan (PC 5514); Michelle
Katz (PC 5515); Molly Hales (PC 5516); Mike Klupchak (PC 5517); Mary Sue
Kruchten (PC 5518); Mary Sue Kruchten (PC 5519); Molly O'Donnell (PC
5520); Mike Lenkowski (PC 5521); Sara Miller (PC 5522); Christian Munoz (PC
5523); Michelle Bradley (PC 5524); Mary Liss (PC 5525); Marsha McClellan
(PC 5526); Marlene Turvill (PC 5527); Cynthia FitzHarris (PC 5528); Melissa
Nicholson (PC 5529); Mark Plante (PC 5530); Liza Dore (PC 5531); Michael
Redikop (PC 5532); Henry Calamia III (PC 5533); Aanand Kumar (PC 5534);
William Leonard (PC 5535); Mary Rodich (PC 5536); Rochel Cutler (PC 5537);
Michael Sesterhenn (PC 5538); Mary Southard (PC 5539); Mollie Reed (PC
5540); Cliff Cleland Jr. (PC 5541); Monica Halle (PC 5542); Phyllis Sugar (PC
5543); Morgan Granata (PC 5544); Robert Moschorak (PC 5545); Liz Moses (PC
5546); Jean Woodman (PC 5547); Mary Peplinski (PC 5548); Mary Peplinski
(PC 5549)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - John A. Bochnak (PC #5,450); Theresa Butler
Bodee (PC 5451); Bridget O'Neill (PC 5452); Anne Boullerne (PC 5453);
Emalou Boyer (PC 5454); Brent Cabrera (PC 5455); Elaine Suhre (PC 5456);
Barbara Reader (PC 5457); Brenda Breitenstein (PC 5458); Brian Davis (PC
5459); Heather Lewis (PC 5460); Michelle Arnold (PC 5461); Brian Mooney
(PC 5462); Brennan Madden (PC 5463); Brennan Madden (PC 5464); Brian
Laskey (PC 5465); Bridget McGill (PC 5466); Bob Hagele (PC 5467); James
Dolmage (PC 5468); Patty Boblick (PC 5469); John Massman (PC 5470);
Kimberly Kowalski (PC 5471); Jane Seibert (PC 5472); Elizabeth Czechanski
(PC 5473); Beth Braun (PC 5474); Blair Harvey (PC 5475); Blair Harvey (PC
5476); Bertrand Henne (PC 5477); Marjorie and William Birch (PC 5478); Brad
Hulick (PC 5479); Beatrice Kay (PC 5480); Barbara Cochrane (PC 5481); Ellen
Rendulich (PC 5482); Besta Castaneda (PC 5483); Lisa Beemsterboer (PC 5484);
P. Jackson (PC 5485); Bridgitte Knapp (PC 5486); Debra Bendis (PC 5487);
Mary Bennett (PC 5488); Amy Berger (PC 5489); Rebecca Rossof (PC 5490);
Bonnie Rowell (PC 5491); Brett Peterson (PC 5892); Bruce Anderson (PC 5493);
R. Bruce Williams (PC 5494); Bryn McCoy (PC 5495); Brian Sheehan (PC
5496); Linda Wang (PC 5497); Allison Liwanag (PC 5498); Brian Noshay (PC
5499)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Angela Berry (PC #5,400); Angela Reeks (PC
5401); Anita Bednarz (PC 5402); Alan Jenks (PC 5403); Audrey Petty (PC
5404); Aaron Rester (PC 5405); Ardith Reed (PC 5406); Ann Leeds (PC 5407);
Anna Gentry (PC 5408); Alexandra Sipiora (PC 5409); Andrea Moonsammy (PC
5410); Amanda Slawkowski (PC 5411); Maria Waskin (PC 5412); Rick Ferguson
(PC 5413); Amy Riggins (PC 5414); Ryan Anderson (PC 5415); Andrew Turner
(PC 5416); Andreya Grozik (PC 5417); Angela Moreno (PC 5418); Angela Berry
(PC 5419); Nancy Baranowski (PC 5420); Barbara Singer (PC 5421); Barbara
Bochnak (PC 5422); Abe Lapson (PC 5423); Asher Margolis (PC 5424);
Adrienne Mazique (PC 5425); Amber McKown (PC 5426); Amber Bond (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5427); Amber Waksmundzki (PC 5428); Jacquelyn Abbatiello (PC 5429); Alison
Smith (PC 5430); Nadia Kanhai (PC 5431); Rani Dube (PC 5432); Ravi Grover
(PC 5433); Peter Gunther (PC 5434); Barbara Keer (PC 5435); Blake Anderson
(PC 5436); Michael Finley (PC 5437); Brian Hicks (PC 5438); Todd Bapton (PC
5439); Barbara Rieffel (PC 5440); Britt Cain (PC 5441); Shelly Hope (PC 5442);
Andrew Ritter (PC 5443); Ann Ruth (PC 5444); Aislinn Gagliardi (PC 5445);
Sandra Gates (PC 5446); Allen Streicker (PC 5447); Emmett Finneran (PC
5448); Abigail Sutkus (PC 5449)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Daniel Puetz (PC #5,350); David Pellissier (PC
5351); David Price (PC 5352); Dale Lubotsky (PC 5353); Jen Swenson (PC
5354); Chris Soroka (PC 5355); Christopher Rosen (PC 5336); Chris Latta (PC
5357); Christopher Riff (PC 5358); Carl Ichikawa (PC 5359); Charles Mies (PC
5360); Cecelia Ungari (PC 5361); Catherine Zukowski (PC 5362); Cheri Wilcox
(PC 5363); Marti Swanson (PC 5364); Cynda Alderton (PC 5365); Cyndi Elliott
(PC 5366); Yvonne Czarniak (PC 5367); Czerina Salud (PC 5368); David Millett
(PC 5369); Christine Pacocha (PC 5370); Clara Piecuch (PC 5371); Cynthia Pry
(PC 5372); Candi Ausman (PC 5373); Raymond Gicela (PC 5374); Michele
Racioppi (PC 5375); Peggy Schramm (PC 5376); Cheryl Laursen (PC 5377);
Cecelia Samp (PC 5378); Chris Schneider (PC 5379); Loretta Koperdak (PC
5380); J. Langston (PC 5381); Catherine Grandalski (PC 5382); Celeste Minella
(PC 5383); Charles Holtquist (PC 5384); Clark Sells (PC 5385); Carlos Munoz
(PC 5386); Andrea Friedmann (PC 5387); Heidi Bresilge (PC 5388); Brett Coy
(PC 5389); David Earley (PC 5390); David Rahija (PC 5391); Dave Bergeron
(PC 5392); David Edsey (PC 5393); Dawn Silver (PC 5394); Dana Brink (PC
5395); Lanie Costeas (PC 5396); Jennifer Clarke (PC 5397); Claudia Christensen
(PC 5398); Cleo Burtis (PC 5399)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - C. Postuma (PC #5,300); Jonathan Burden (PC
5301); Mark Burger (PC 5302); Randall Schietzelt (PC 5303); Vikki Bevan (PC
5304); Brian Wells (PC 5305); Benita Ulisano (PC 5306); Clark Bullard (PC
5307); Bunita Berg (PC 5308); Brook Herman (PC 5309); Sonia Ness (PC 5310);
William Ceisel (PC 5311); Carter Cleland (PC 5312); Anne Reeves (PC 5313);
Caitlin Kilcullen (PC 5314); Maria Wanamaker (PC 5315); Craig Compton (PC
5316); Robert Weston (PC 5317); Caroline Koclanes (PC 5318); Bob Wendling
(PC 5319); Carole O'Connell (PC 5320); Carole Mark (PC 5321); Caroline Ishida
(PC 5322); Caron Allen Taira (PC 5323); Colette Carter (PC 5324); Robert
O'Brien (PC 5325); Cate Allen (PC 5326); Catherine McKee (PC 5327); Clark
James (PC 5328); Mary F. Warren (PC 5329); Charles Zine (PC 5330);
Charmaine Mazzeffi (PC 5331); Cherie Lindskog (PC 5332); Cheryl Davis (PC
5333); Carole Carbone (PC 5334); Carole Rebeiz (PC 5335); Colleen Wisniewski
(PC 5336); Christopher Lange (PC 5337); Cathryn Bulicek (PC 5338); Carol
Freeman (PC 5339); Cindi Bogacz (PC 5340); Cinday Peesel (PC 5341); Clark
Andelin (PC 5342); Charles Rogers (PC 5343); Christopher Kowal (PC 5344);
Claire Herdeman (PC 5345); Cheryl Doros (PC 5346); Christine Favilla (PC
5347); Mary Jane Culak (PC 5348); Christy Grant (PC 5349)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Marjorie Lewis (PC #5,250); Mark Shumow (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5251); Faith Spencer (PC 5252); Mark Pietroski (PC 5253); Mark Wilcox (PC
5254); Mark Wilcox (PC 5255); Marolyne Williams (PC 5256); Marshall
Browning (PC 5257); Martize Allen (PC 5258); Margaret Jordan (PC 5259);
Matthew Winston (PC 5260); M. Schaye (PC 5261); Smita Mahajan (PC 5262);
Ryan Mahoney (PC 5263); Eric Spielman (PC 5264); Michelle Albaugh (PC
5265); Samantha Malusky (PC 5266); Marcia Biasiello (PC 5267); Dawn
Vandiver (PC 5268); Marie Considine (PC 5269); Carol Meers (PC 5270);
Melody Shimada (PC 5271); Stephanie Mertens (PC 5272); Harriet S. Meyer (PC
5273); Margaret Brady (PC 5274); Mary Fox (PC 5275); Marcel Franciscono
(PC 5276); Parker Whiteway (PC 5277); Michael Clark (PC 5278); Michele
Danielson (PC 5279); Michelle Bardas (PC 5280); Mathew Morgan (PC 5281);
Matt Zivich (PC 5282); Marianne Avery (PC 5283); Lana May (PC 5284);
Maureen Balluff (PC 5285); Christina Hilgen (PC 5286); Richard McNamara
(PC 5287); Marianna Delinck (PC 5288); Julia Glahn (PC 5289); Julie Peterson
(PC 5290); Julie Pin (PC 5291); Jean Hoegler (PC 5292); Joan C. Hubbs (PC
5293); Joan C. Hubbs (PC 5294); James Stuhlmacher (PC 5295); Margaret Wood
(PC 5296); Margaret Wood (PC 5297); Michael Prym (PC 5298); Lynn Lazarus
(PC 5299)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Robert Lehmann (PC #5,200); Leigh Kelsey (PC
5201); Leo Murphy (PC 5202); Leanne Pavel (PC 5203); Leo Murphy (PC
5204); Leslie Moncayo (PC 5205); Leslie Simmer (PC 5206); Leslie Ritter-
Jenkins (PC 5207); Loretta Foster (PC 5208); Lauree Garvin (PC 5209); Laura
Dick (PC 5210); Laura Northcraft (PC 5211); Laura WIll (PC 5212); Laurel
Spindel (PC 5213); Laurel Hamilton (PC 5214); Louise Friedenson (PC 5215);
Layna Portugal (PC 5216); Amy Anderson (PC 5217); Linda Dorken (PC 5218);
Lee Mishkin (PC 5219); Linda Zaba (PC 5220); M. Seyedin (PC 5221); Mark
Tortoriello (PC 5222); Mary Ann Bartoli (PC 5223); Andi Berkowitz (PC 5224);
Amanda Dones (PC 5225); Maggie McCoy (PC 5226); William Maddex (PC
5227); Margaret Veranga (PC 5228); Lynne Parson (PC 5229); Lisa Schrag (PC
5230); Lawrence Stange (PC 5231); Laura Selesky (PC 5232); Leah Simoni (PC
5233); Lorena Neal (PC 5234); Laura Urbaszewski (PC 5235); Laura Kracum
(PC 5236); Lucretia Marriott (PC 5237); Larry Lundy (PC 5238); Mary Baechle
(PC 5239); Mary Gabb (PC 5240); Mary Susan Chen (PC 5241); Russell Murphy
(PC 5242); Loretta Mathews (PC 5243); Lisa Gee (PC 5244); Lara Scarborough
(PC 5245); Tom Long (PC 5246); Lou Storino (PC 5247); Louise Pappageorge
(PC 5248); Marilyn Wollenmann (PC 5249)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - G. Trubow (PC #5,150); Aaron Neal (PC 5151);
Eberhard Veit (PC 5152); Elizabeth de la Baume (PC 5153); David Dunand (PC
5154); Durango Mendoza (PC 5155); Dawn Verucchi (PC 5156); Denise Simons
(PC 5157); Donald W. Wood (PC 5158); Donald Zouras (PC 5159); Erica Lopez
(PC 5160); Eric Peyer (PC 5161); Erin Daughton (PC 5162); Emily Edlynn (PC
5163); Maureen Ugolini (PC 5164); Maureen Ugolini (PC 5165); Edward Ferroni
(PC 5166); Elizabeth Foeller-Pituch (PC 5167); Elizabeth Wyman (PC 5168);
Edward Herdrich (PC 5169); Barbara van Davis (PC 5170); Elyse Friedman (PC
5171); Elizabeth Darovic (PC 5172); Eric Michals (PC 5173); Erin Michel (PC
5174); Emily Lake (PC 5175); Emily R. Massulo (PC 5176); Alice Englebretsen
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 5177); Nikolas Spayne (PC 5178); Elissa Patterson (PC 5179); Betsy
Dynako (PC 5180); John O'Brien (PC 5181); Robert Khoshaba (PC 5182); Alicia
Proulx (PC 5183); Elin Gasperik (PC 5184); Elisa Ringholm (PC 5185); Teresa
Bondavalli (PC 5186); Lisa Elkins (PC 5187); Ellen Hazard (PC 5188); Ellen
O'Rourke (PC 5189); Lannie LeGear (PC 5190); Audrey Samuelson (PC 5191);
Lilia Rissman (PC 5192); Linda Hurst (PC 5193); Linda M. Kehres (PC 5194);
Peter Linett (PC 5195); Lisa Moss (PC 5196); Lisa Sugent (PC 5197); Lisa
Phillips (PC 5198); Alyssa Larson (PC 5199)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Diana Parmeter (PC #5,100); Diane Melton (PC
5101); Diane Vandiver (PC 5102); Deborah Ditkowsky (PC 5103); Diane
Jackson (PC 5104); Steve Deichstetter Sr. (PC 5105); Darcy Chadwick (PC
5106); David Schalliol (PC 5107); Dave Gliva (PC 5108); Daria Corbett (PC
5109); Delicia Dunham (PC 5110); Dennis Nelson (PC 5111); Dennis Nelson
(PC 5112); Dwight Roepenack (PC 5113); Derek Fraser (PC 5114); Denise
McIntosh (PC 5115); Don Goerne (PC 5116); Dan Hebreard (PC 5117); David
Holst (PC 5118); Bulmaro Martinez (PC 5119); Donna Conroy (PC 5120);
Frances Nohling (PC 5121); Scott Doot (PC 5122); Don Morris (PC 5123);
Doreen Mercades-Hult (PC 5124); Doreen Mercades-Hult (PC 5125); Richard
Kuenkler (PC 5126); Dana Lubotsky (PC 5127); David Jordan (PC 5128); Donna
Koranek (PC 5129); Dora Winchester (PC 5130); Dorothy Frew (PC 5131);
Laima Parada (PC 5132); Dan Lagesse (PC 5133); Deb Klein (PC 5134); Diane
Mataragas (PC 5135); Donna Conroy (PC 5136); Douglas May (PC 5137); Debra
Miller (PC 5138); Diane Niesman (PC 5139); Julia Chosy (PC 5140); Patricia
Fox (PC 5141); Patricia Fox (PC 5142); Ed Chubin (PC 5143); John Metzger (PC
5144); Elise Shalda (PC 5145); Diane Thodos (PC 5146); Dona Henderson (PC
5147); David Seidman (PC 5148); Daniel Steinhelper (PC 5149)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Taunikkau Teamer (PC #5,050); Jean R. Cleland
(PC 5051); P.A. Clausing (PC 5052); Raymond F. Kearney (PC 5053); Scott F.
Johnson (PC 5054); Becky Ludrens (PC 5055); Nicholas Sudbury (PC 5056);
Clay Fraley (PC 5057); Indecipherable Signature (PC 5058); Marci Kulbak (PC
5059); Philip Strazzante (PC 5060); Christine Eskandar (PC 5061); Jack Siskovic
(PC 5062); Lauren Dillon (PC 5063); Paul A. O'Dell (PC 5064); Andreas
Kuechel (PC 5065); Karen Moy (PC 5066); Athena Bianchi (PC 5067); Joseph J.
Woods (PC 5068); Lily M. Yon (PC 5069); Andrew Zalon (PC 5070); Kent
Suhey (PC 5071); Lee Portolenlis (PC 5072); Indecipherable Signature (PC
5073); Grace Pantelios (PC 5074); Lori Schulz (PC 5075); Muriel J. Fox (PC
5076); Fred Riordian (PC 5077); D. Pantelios (PC 5078); Mary Jo O Donnell (PC
5079); J.M. Cupoli (PC 5080); Maureen Smith (PC 5081); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 5082); Indecipherable Signature (PC 5083); CS Winkler (PC
5084); Sarah Rabbitt (PC 5085); Brenda LaDuke (PC 5086); Cliff Guist (PC
5087); Indecipherable Signature (PC 5088); C.A. Kluck (PC 5089); Rose A.
Depke (PC 5090); Diane Garvey (PC 5091); M.I. Jancovic (PC 5092); Steve
McChesney (PC 5093); John Lee (PC 5094); Sheila Hurly (PC 5095); Maria and
Stephen Fatum (PC 5096); Susan Hicks (PC 5057); Jeff Hamilton (PC 5098);
Tim Wray (PC 5099); Kathy Kelly (PC 5099.1); J. Reyes (PC 5099.2); Barbara
Knoff (PC 5099.3); Carolyn White (PC 5099.4); Lisa Hrgnek (PC 5099.5); Ario
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Tabrizi (PC 5099.6); Ashley Gittes (PC 5099.7); Gloria Callari (PC 5099.8);
Patrick Cole (PC 5099.9); Riley Hastings (PC 5099.10); John Mobley (PC
5099.11); C. Ellis (PC 5099.12); P. Val Strehlow (PC 5099.13); Mike Voitik (PC
5099.14); M. Freese (PC 5099.15); D. Mahoney (PC 5099.16); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 5099.17); Janet Schneider (PC 5099.18); Angie Ford (PC
5099.19); Lindsey Greenwell (PC 5099.20); C. Smith (PC 5099.21); Heather
Sparr (PC 5099.22); Dorothy Oilvier (PC 5099.23)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Tracey Mitchell (PC #5,000); Toni Butsford (PC
5001); Indecipherable Signature (PC 5002); Indecipherable Signature (PC 5003);
Shelonda Montgomery (PC 5004); Marion Scott (PC 5005); Marilyn Villegas
(PC 5006); Indecipherable Signature (PC 5007); Indecipherable Signature (PC
5008); Debbie Singleton (PC 5009); Josh Copes (PC 5010); Maribel Galvez (PC
5011); Courtney Johnson (PC 5012); Bonita Lathan (PC 5013); Kevin Smith (PC
5014); Shannon Jenkins (PC 5015); David Barrientos (PC 5016); Stephanie
Hernandez (PC 5017); Kristin Straw (PC 5018); Pravin (PC 5019); Richard
Brown (PC 5020); Daniel Hekel (PC 5021); Ann Kibler (PC 5022); Deborah S.
Dunteman (PC 5023); Lionel Brown (PC 5024); Kenneth Cook (PC 5025); April
Rose (PC 5026); Cassandra Gray (PC 5027); Robert D. Hoffman (PC 5028);
Matt Barnhurst (PC 5029); Mack Giannini (PC 5030); Chris Anderson (PC
5031); Cindy Villagram (PC 5032); Indecipherable Signature (PC 5033); Ty
Golden (PC 5034); Ebony Palmore (PC 5035); Anthony Powell (PC 5036); Jade
Parsons (PC 5037); Melody Johnson (PC 5038); Eric Juanes (PC 5039); D. Nunn
(PC 5040); Tameka McClain (PC 5041); Theodore K. Poneikes, M.D. (PC 5042);
Cheri Brooks (PC 5043); Albert Williams (PC 5044); Christine Clark (PC 5045);
Tyieshia Presley (PC 5046); Andrew Hunber (PC 5047); Lucy Fabio (PC 5048);
Robert Mueller (PC 5049)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Scott Will (PC #4,950); W. Strauss (PC 4951);
Ursula Lopez (PC 4952); Sean King (PC 4953); Indecipherable Signature (PC
4954); Deborah Spann (PC 4955); John Shonkwiler (PC 4956); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4957); J.C. Haverstahl (PC 4958); Andrea Lyon (PC 4959);
Pauline Ng (PC 4960); Bret Renaud (PC 4961); Amanda Seibel (PC 4962); M.A.
Haas (PC 4963); Cat Renar (PC 4964); Anne Lambry (PC 4965); Eric Griswold
(PC 4966); Lucille Hermann (PC 4967); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4968);
Matthew Taylor (PC 4969); M. Kelly (PC 4970); Kenneth Gunther (PC 4971);
Eric Phillips (PC 4972); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4973); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4974); Nikki Goldwater (PC 4975); Davd Longaker (PC 4976);
Hausheer (PC 4977); Jason Erickson (PC 4978); Finlay Graham (PC 4979); Barb
Gimbel (PC 4980); Andrew Hernandez (PC 4981); Shanae Williams (PC 4982);
Brandi Kneedly (PC 4983); Jimmy Rushing (PC 4984); Harold Leffridge (PC
4985); Debbie Arnoni (PC 4986); Douglas T. Belles (PC 4987); Nancy
Schlosberg (PC 4988); Mary Rosic (PC 4989); Marjorie R. Fairman (PC 4990);
Joane Dumke (PC 4991); Barbara Clements (PC 4992); Indecipherable Signature
(PC 4993); Mary Gilligan (PC 4994); Patricia Regan (PC 4995); L. Hick (PC
4996); Ellyn J. Landman (PC 4997); John Grier (PC 4998); K. Protofamusis (PC
4999)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Brandon Harpe (PC #4,900); Kevin Koopurta (PC
4901); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4902); Jacquelin Wedell (PC 4903); David
Wille (PC 4904); Cathy Bloss (PC 4905); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4906);
Robert Matuszek (PC 4907); Lori Pritchett (PC 4908); Franklin Laggiano (PC
4909); Bob Romberg (PC 4910); Ted Soenksen (PC 4911); Charlotte Kaven (PC
4912); George Heady (PC 4913); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4914); Toni
Longbardi (PC 4915); Brad Tenkin (PC 4916); Craig Dudek (PC 4917); Roberta
Brooks (PC 4918); V. Rooney (PC 4919); G. Ousley (PC 4920); Jay Nelson (PC
4921); Sharon Adelman Keyes (PC 4922); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4923);
Victor Rivera-Nieves (PC 4924); Hal Stallworth (PC 4925); Norm Zuefle (PC
4926); Karen Kirk (PC 4927); D. MacDonald (PC 4928); Robert MacDonald (PC
4929); Kerry Ferrgro (PC 4930); Sean Morrison (PC 4931); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4932); Chris Simmons (PC 4933); Ralph Levaccare (PC 4934);
Jonah Gaster (PC 4935); Tobiah Gaster (PC 4936); Mrs. Bruce Cooper (PC
4937); M.A. Cusick (PC 4938); William Vandercook (PC 4939); J. Nachenson
(PC 4940); Chris Chilas (PC 4941); Albert L. Koger (PC 4942); Blake Foster (PC
4943); Dan Condon (PC 4944); Betti Goldberg (PC 4945); Jason Schmidt (PC
4946); Richard and Lois Leonard (PC 4947); Tom Conroy (PC 4948); Janine
Bradshaw (PC 4949)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Rebecca Moore (PC #4,850); Sarah Olson (PC
4851); Dorothy Horton (PC 4852); Rachel A. Stipanuk (PC 4853); Anna Perkins
(PC 4854); Jake Smith (PC 4855); Katherine McFall (PC 4856); Dan Davison
(PC 4857); Nancy Jacobson (PC 4858); Deborah Leslie (PC 4859); Samantha
Moore (PC 4860); Mark Elsen (PC 4861); Don Tiffany (PC 4862); Barry Youngs
(PC 4863); John Xolas (PC 4864); Bruce Mack (PC 4865); S. Fitzgerald (PC
4866); Nancy L. McCormick (PC 4867); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4868);
Abayhan (PC 4869); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4870); Frances Siensa (PC
4871); Mark Adamczyk (PC 4872); Brenna Hond (PC 4873); Shayla Fay (PC
4874); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4875); Phil A. Roehrborn (PC 4876); M.V.
Brown (PC 4877); S. Ross (PC 4878); Holly Aitchison (PC 4879);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4880); S. Russell (PC 4881); Sarah Urbansky (PC
4882); Harold Moore (PC 4883); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4884); Virgil
Roberson (PC 4885); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4886); Juan Pablo Bustos
(PC 4887); Dion Maxwell (PC 4888); Connie Schmidt (PC 4889); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4890); John Henderson (PC 4891); Indecipherable Signature (PC
4892); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4893); Melissa Tierney (PC 4894); John
Jones (PC 4895); L.K. McCarty (PC 4896); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4897);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4898); Brian Sisk (PC 4899)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - David Calabro (PC #4,800); Michael C. Maddox Jr.
(PC 4801); Sylvester Davis (PC 4802); Scott Siddens (PC 4803); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4804); Dr. Robert Moore (PC 4805); Matthew Klionsky (PC
4806); Friar Bomarenture Lassier (PC 4807); Katie Spelberger (PC 4808);
Barbara H. Cathey (PC 4809); Aaltje Baumgart (PC 4810); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4811); Hunter Ferguson (PC 4812); Carol Jean Brown (PC 4813);
Sharon Hunter-Smith (PC 4814); Alexis McBride (PC 4815); Chester McSwan
(PC 4816); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4817); Kim Dickerson (PC 4818);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Megan Lanigan (PC 4819); Robert Herman (PC 4820); B. Chapin (PC 4821);
Marcie Alexander (PC 4822); Tania Strelkova (PC 4823); Asha Thomas (PC
4824); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4825); Roy Bixler (PC 4826);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4827); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4828);
Charles Comey (PC 4829); Swarovda Iyengar (PC 4830); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4831); Tal Fegan (PC 4832); Alex Rocklin (PC 4833);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4834); Charlotte Woods (PC 4835); Jonathan A.
Frieson (PC 4836); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4837); Samuel E. Farwell (PC
4838); John Power (PC 4839); Stanley Selinger (PC 4840); John Links (PC
4841); John Roppy (PC 4842); Kent Narum (PC 4843); Adam Stubbendick (PC
4844); Lisa Shives (PC 4845); Wm. White (PC 4846); Katherine Hutek (PC
4847); Robert McGuire (PC 4848); Clifford Johnson (PC 4849)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Paul A. Usesh (PC #4,750); Emily Langerak (PC
4751); Perry K. Lewis Jr. (PC 4752); John Brown (PC 4753); Jason Nigel (PC
4754); Blessing Williams (PC 4755); Natasha Y. Shubrick (PC 4756); Kelly
Crost (PC 4757); Anthony Wolff (PC 4758); Jerome Altman (PC 4759);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4760); Elise Johnson (PC 4761); Melissa Plucinski
(PC 4762); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4763); Jenny Smith (PC 4764);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4765); Violeta Fernandez (PC 4766); Teddy
Williams (PC 4767); Emily Mott (PC 4768); Yiu Sung Lau (PC 4769);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4770); Robert Body (PC 4771); Leah Abadia (PC
4772); Rachel Vigen (PC 4773); Brittany Ragan (PC 4774); Lex Lande (PC
4775); Mitch Molstad (PC 4776); Sarah Shapiro (PC 4777); Nina Bulatovic (PC
4778); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4779); Alma J. Smith (PC 4780); Peter
Freeman (PC 4781); Rebeca Hisatomi (PC 4782); Frank Gilbert (PC 4783);
Noelle Bonneau (PC 4784); Michelle Boern (PC 4785); Adam Grosshuosch (PC
4786); Ashley Kern (PC 4787); Christine Hooper (PC 4788); Christopher Bodly
(PC 4789); Lisa Reyes (PC 4790); Todd Carter (PC 4791); Aaron Dillon (PC
4792); Elliott Saxton (PC 4793); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4794); Christine
Fahrenbruch (PC 4795); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4796); Hanna Brown (PC
4797); John Payne (PC 4798); William Hernandez (PC 4799)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Josefin Henninger (PC #4,700) Marsy Henriksen
(PC 4701); Ingrid Henninger (PC 4702); Danny Kern (PC 4703); Monita Eng-
Milton (PC 4704); Ronnie Wadall (PC 4705); Kamil Washington (PC 4706);
Matt Meier (PC 4707); Pete Miller (PC 4708); Kenney Townson (PC 4709); Jiri
Dvorak (PC 4710); Valerie Rietveld (PC 4711); Indecipherable Signature (PC
4712); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4713); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4714);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4715); Bong Shin (PC 4716); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4717); Ricardo Ny (PC 4718); Maria Degillo (PC 4719);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4720); Ashley Trotter (PC 4721); Steve Besic (PC
4722); Colin Milton (PC 4723); James Nieman (PC 4724); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4725); Ian Carlson (PC 4726); Jessica Grimes (PC 4727); Ben
Raybin (PC 4728); Peter Muller (PC 4729); Valerie Santiago (PC 4730); Kathy
Grell (PC 4731); CJ Laity (PC 4732); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4733); Brian
Karcher (PC 4734); Jeff Bladt (PC 4735); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4736);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4737); Anthony Reynoso (PC 4738); Kelly Tobin
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 4739); Denver Clark (PC 4740); Dustin Tonne (PC 4741); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4742); Chris Reynoso (PC 4743); Matt Bricker (PC 4744); Diane
DeCoeq (PC 4745); Pamela Higginbotham (PC 4746); Lucretia Lyons (PC
4747); LaCee Groetken (PC 4748); Cristen Calwn (PC 4749)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Adam Karac (PC #4,650); Louis DeMeo (PC
4651); Priscilla M. DaSilva (PC 4652); Ellis Craft (PC 4653); Brian Sabin (PC
4654); Margot Smith (PC 4655); Rachel Story (PC 4656); Rachel Evans (PC
4657); Stacey Schoenecker (PC 4658); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4659); Erin
Granner (PC 4660); Tidarat Kusub (PC 4661); Rochelle Lingao (PC 4662); Jasna
Colic (PC 4663); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4664); Janics Avery (PC 4665);
Sorana Ursu (PC 4666); Allison Lewis (PC 4667); Jessica Sullnis (PC 4668); Jay
Clemens (PC 4669); Jenni Wilson (PC 4670); Allen Johnston (PC 4671); Cristina
Rodriguez (PC 4672); Mike Lankheet (PC 4673); O. Jenkins (PC 4674); James
Clausen (PC 4675); Melissa Fajardo (PC 4676); Stephen Nichols (PC 4677);
Marvin Thurman (PC 4678); Michael Calmese (PC 4679); Donnie Moore (PC
4680); Kevin Robinson (PC 4681); Jason Sandors (PC 4682); Jerry Owens (PC
4683); Adam H. Kaniewski (PC 4684); Tony Moore (PC 4685); Dan O'Keefe
(PC 4686); J.X. Jin (PC 4687); Ieasha Campbell (PC 4688); Eric Laramore (PC
4689); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4690); McKenzie Maher (PC 4691); Jordan
Murghardt (PC 4692); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4693); Devin Schraff (PC
4694); Daniel Elder (PC 4695); Pam Buess (PC 4696); Denise Roma (PC 4697);
C. Williams (PC 4698); Darren I. Gould (PC 4699)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Brad Moy (PC #4,600); David c. Nance (PC 4601);
Patricia Langton (PC 4602); Sean Smith (PC 4603); Gloria Pettis (PC 4604);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4605); Mitchell Randolph (PC 4606); Joanne
Owens (PC 4607); Leonard Wair (PC 4608); Elliott Harris (PC 4609); Gatzy
Wilson (PC 4610); Jake Rich (PC 4611); Jessica Wright (PC 4612); Kyle
Chriestenson (PC 4613); Indecipherabel Signature (PC 4614); Mike Markham
(PC 4615); Lucia LaBonte (PC 4616); Mike Abedelal (PC 4617); Stephanie
Brausey (PC 4618); D. Phillip Brown (PC 4619); Gregory Burke (PC 4620);
Kostya Nakazuy (PC 4621); Peggy Latiker (PC 4622); Kimberly A. Treuino (PC
4623); Johnny Watkins (PC 4624); Almut Roberts (PC 4625); Chris Alexander
(PC 4626); Jennifer Lindsey (PC 4627); Zerimar Carattini (PC 4628); Jason
Crystal (PC 4629); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4630); Tony Gerard (PC 4631);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4632); Tony Lage (PC 4633); Michael S. Smith
(PC 4634); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4635); Walter Burke (PC 4636); Yanett
Flores (PC 4637); Ray Davidson (PC 4638); Mike Kelly (PC 4639); Charles
Glowacki (PC 4640); Kellie Nichols (PC 4641); June Barker (PC 4642); Brianen
Keihle (PC 4643); Tristan L. Wilson (PC 4644); Stephanie Chen (PC 4645);
Barbara Trinh (PC 4646); John Williams (PC 4647); Alvin Park, Jr. (PC 4648);
Bob and Gail Schermer (PC 4649)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Laura Youngberg (PC #4,550); Vasile Sima (PC
4551); A.J. Furey Jr. (PC 4552); Andrew Kerr (PC 4553); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4554); Doyle Hickey (PC 4555); Polly Richardson (PC 4556);
Deborah Kiddle (PC 4557); John Ingold (PC 4558); Lauren Jacobs (PC 4559);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Cindy Davidson (PC 4560); Melissa Ellis (4561); Gretchen Bellino (PC 4562);
Ruth Nitsche (4563); Arthur Sullivan (PC 4564); Indecipherable Signature (PC
4565); Anne Casey (PC 4566); Molly Larkin (PC 4567); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4568); Emily Lane (PC 4569); Tom & Betty Toser (PC 4570);
Leif Gamrath (PC 4571); Carol Grossman (PC 4572); Paul Strom (PC 4573);
Victor A. Urban (PC 4574); Teresa Veras (PC 4575); Liam Singer (PC 4576);
Vern Blackwood (PC 4577); Ryan Winters (PC 4578); Sirena Rebovich (PC
4579); Ian MacMillan (PC 4580); Michael Hay (PC 4581); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4582); Noveen Roberts (PC 4583); Steve Hoff (PC 4584);
Alderman Joe Moore (PC 4585); R.E. Bruce (PC 4586); Darin Reid (PC 4587);
Jack M. Bertram (PC 4588); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4589); M.A. Lee (PC
4590); Debra Moughamian (PC 4591); Herbert Wichner (PC 4592); Claire Osada
(PC 4593); Barbara Moore (PC 4594); Claudia Rinehart (PC 4595); John Manley
(PC 4596); Lynn Gaffigan (PC 4597); Katie Eveleigh (PC 4598); Joyce Foster
(PC 4599)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Kathy Russo (PC #4,500); Dave Morhewyky (PC
4501); Susan Whitlow (PC 4502); Kimberly Whitlow (PC 4503); Laura Mydock
(PC 4504); Luke Aleckson (PC 4505); Paris Davis (PC 4506); Stephanie
Lindblom (PC 4507); Sarah Brekke (PC 4508); Erica Black (PC 4509);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4510); Harold L. Smalley (PC 4511); Patrick Botts
(PC 4512); Lana Warner (PC 4513); Brendan Piscitelli (PC 4514);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4515); A.G. Sherman (PC 4516); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4517); Andrew Johnson (PC 4518); Jeremy Henderson (PC 4519);
Robert Jauch (PC 4520); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4521); Jospeh Comer (PC
4522); Yahale Yadede (PC 4523); Michael Vasson (PC 4524); Mario Lazzari
(PC 4525); Meli Loeppert (PC 4526); Joe Milius (PC 4527); Lisa Jeans (PC
4528); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4529); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4530);
Keyena Moffrett (PC 4531); Amy R. lopez (PC 4532); Lori Russell (PC 4533);
Arlene Lerner (PC 4534); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4535); Elizabeth Yerkes
(PC 4536); Howard Payne (PC 4537); Barbara Walk (PC 4538); Alysia Raine
(PC 4539); Tony Ragan (PC 4540); Peter Choi (PC 4541); Donna Seaton (PC
4542); John Ridgway (PC 4543); Aleyda R. Ramos (4544); Michael S. Young
(PC 4545); Peter Zalupski (PC 4546); Barbara D. Cole (PC 4547); Nathan L.
Sturm (PC 4548); Lisa Boudreaux (PC 4549);
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Daniel Einstein (PC #4,450); Sade' Washington (PC
4451); Keonta Carson (PC 4452); Mike Meyers (PC 4453); Ezra Hilton (PC
4454); Lindsey DeBruin (PC 4455); David Hellman (PC 4456); Pamela Kohm
(PC 4457); George D. Montanaro (PC 4458); D. Madison (PC 4459); Michael
Cox (PC 4460); Peter W. Zubrzycki (PC 4461); L. Dawson (PC 4462); Anthony
T. Ball, Sr. (PC 4463); Henry Sims (PC 4464); Juliet Walker (PC 4465);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4466); Shanise Starks (PC 4467); Christine Govas
(PC 4468); Robert Barry (PC 4469); Pat Larson (PC 4470); Kim Pollak (PC
4471); Mary Ellen Fitzsimonds (PC 4472); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4473);
Anne Reusche' (PC 4474); Matt Silvers (PC 4475); Kathryn Bauer (PC 4476);
Michael Finnegan (PC 4477); Carol Tyner (PC 4478); S. Pappas (PC 4479);
Craig R. Clarey (PC 4480); Rick Heinzen (PC 4481); Indecipherable Signature
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 4482); Diane Marshall (PC 4483); Alison James (PC 4484); Laura Cohen
(PC 4485); Fran Palmes (PC 4486); Sarah Irwin (PC 4487); Danyela Jovanovic
(PC 4488); Diane Jovanovic (PC 4489); Criss Henderson (PC 4490); Judith
Trusdell (PC 4491); Tom G. Spiandel (PC 4492); Terri Frigo (PC 4493);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4494); Carolyn Eujil (PC 4495); James P. Smith
(PC 4496); Irene Sowell (PC 4497); Deb Honeman (PC 4498); Dewar Family
(PC 4499)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Willy Jefferson (PC #4,400); Richard Lutjens (PC
4401); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4402); Mary Hettzinger (PC 4403);
Catherine Brubaker (PC 4404); Geoff Vincent (PC 4405); Aimee Vincent (PC
4406); James W. Hilton (PC 4407); Tricia L. Murray (PC 4408); Laurel
O'Sullivan (PC 4409); Jessica Clarke (PC 4410); Mike Finnerty (PC 4411); Rios
(RMR) (PC 4412); Maria Morales (PC 4413); William Fischer (PC 4414); Dan
Zakarija (PC 4415); Thomas R. Witt (PC 4416); Kamell Atkinson (PC 4417);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4418); Lyaly Jarvis (PC 4419); Ruth Kane (PC
4420); Betsy Brittsan (PC 4421); John Gorez (PC 4422); Phyllis W. Ziegler (PC
4423); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4424); Laura Gross (PC 4425); Tracy
Whetstone (PC 4426); David Ernst (PC 4427); David Stevenson (PC 4428);
Mary Quaid (PC 4429); Marjorie M. Perschke (PC 4430); Ann Marie Barry (PC
4431); Jamie O'Connor (PC 4432); Patricia Kussy (PC 4433); Missy Hedges (PC
4434); Karl Peters (PC 4435); Linda Karn (PC 4436); A. Sage (P 4437); Ethan
and Mary Cohen (PC 4438); Nan Bloom (PC 4439); Bart Hirsch (PC 4440);
Sylvia Hernandez (PC 4441); Paul Cella (PC 4442); Marjorie Kahle (PC 4443);
Michele Reeve (PC 4444); Pikoutui Grious (PC 4445); Indecipherable Signature
(PC 4446); Jim Park (PC 4447); Katherine Vattos (PC 4448); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4449)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Cindy Weickert (PC #4,350); Mary McNeill (PC
4351); Ben Probst (PC 4352); Janalee Swain (PC 4353); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4354); Jaclyn Steward (PC 4355); Elizabeth Cramer (PC 4356);
Ellen Rieger (PC 4357); Lisa Fowler (PC 4358); Linda Kruhmin (PC 4359); Bob
LeBoeuf (PC 4360); Pat Erhardt (PC 4361); Jim Kelly (PC 4362); Linda M.
Hopkins (PC 4363); Susan Avril (PC 4364); Barbara Agresti (PC 4365);
Margaret Foster (PC 4366); Bernard Quinn (PC 4367); Annie Sanders (PC 4368);
Brian McCarthy (PC 4369); Jacqueline Thompson (PC 4370); Suzanne Lyhus
(PC 4371); Robin Hnrichs (PC 4372); Debora A. Boetcher (PC 4373); Candace
Witt (PC 4374); John Carreon (PC 4375); J. Morgan (PC 4376); Beth Engels (PC
4377); Cheryl Maki (PC 4378); Mark Santecroe (PC 4379); Dr. Cash (PC 4380);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4381); Diane Hertzbeeg (PC 4382); Stephen Prout
(PC 4383); R.R. Cook (PC 4384); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4385); Tracie
Miller (PC 4386); Andy Ressler (PC 4387); Kathy Gerbosi (PC 4388);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4389); R.S. Hudson (PC 4390); Robert Burke (PC
4391); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4392); Monica Thomas (PC 4393); Ana
Cassorlz (PC 4394); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4395); Paul Goodman (PC
4396); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4397); Tom Boyler (PC 4398);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4399)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Brian Acello (PC #4,300); Donna Lofgran (PC
4301); Mariam Brackins (PC 4302); Randy Dewulf (PC 4303); Faith Favale (PC
4304); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4305); Leroy McDonald (PC 4306); Carol
Horton (PC 4307); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4308); Tricia Vold (PC 4309);
Nelly Aguilar (PC 4310); Marilyn Hartman (PC 4311); Margot F. Hamp (PC
4312); Jocelyn McClelland (PC 4313); T. Evans (PC 4314); Bridget Hogan (PC
4315); Katrina Asbury (PC 4316); Linda R. Clum (PC 4317); Sally Jones and
Stan Howell (PC 4318); Dan Robinson (PC 4319); Indecipherable Signature (PC
4320); Anne Ruch (PC 4321); C.R. Vieth (PC 4322); Nathaniel Hodges (PC
4323); John Czyzynski (PC 4324); Matt Horton (PC 4325); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4326); Linda Bell-Wilber (PC 4327); J. Geraghty (PC 4328);
Kystal Herron (PC 4329); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4330); Martin Boughner
(PC 4331); Daniel McCann (PC 4332); Dorothy A. Enzinger (PC 4333); Susan
McMillin (PC 4334); Mary Lou Kinsella (PC 4335); Martin Smith (PC 4336); M.
Reeves (PC 4337); Jack Banofski (PC 4338); Tracy Kidd (PC 4339); Rhonda
Goldstein (PC 4340); Curtis Johnson (PC 4341); Indecipherable Signature (PC
4342); Jay Branstrom (PC 4343); May Anne Nash Sebby (PC 4344); Amanda
Chiarien (PC 4345); Timothy Powell (PC 4346); Anne Jenness (PC 4347); Aaron
Flynn (PC 4348); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4349)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Thomas Yun (PC 4250); Chris Vandervloed (PC
4251); Liz Hemey (PC 4252); Adrienne Manasco (PC 4253); Dee Wesley (PC
4254); Myra Stanley (PC 4255); Christina Wheeler (PC 4256); Andrew Kitchen
(PC 4257); Sharon Hogan (PC 4258); Jane R. Prentis (PC 4259); Vincent
Geckler (PC 4260); Douglas King (PC 4261); Kristy Breitbach (PC 4262);
Jeffery Church (PC 4263); Ed Panar (PC 4264); Karen Draper (PC 4265); Kevin
Spillmar (PC 4266); Somazya Anmad (PC 4267); Philip Wagreich (PC 4268);
Sean Calvin (PC 4269); Marquise Leach (PC 4270); Latoya Thorn (PC 4271);
Sherman Beck (PC 4272); Maria Garcia (PC 4273); Alice Woods (PC 4274);
Gerardo De LaTorre (PC 4275); Janet Rotner (PC 4276); Veronica Ruiz (PC
4277); Bonni A. Barber (PC 4278); Gerald Lee Holman (PC 4279); Shannon Kao
(PC 4280); Darlene Washington (PC 4281); Annie Erickson (PC 4282); Miriam
Block (PC 4283); Elizabeth Ellis (PC 4284); Monica Smith (PC 4285); Amy
Laird (PC 4286); Mehuin Parson (PC 4287); China Calderon (PC 4288); Craig
W. Walden (PC 4289); Thomas McCarthy (PC 4290); Andre Taylor (PC 4291);
Christine Schmid (PC 4292); Matthew Rofert (PC 4293); Maria Hadden (PC
4294); Evan Osar (PC 4295); Matt VanfeWerker (PC 4296); Lauren Lipinski (PC
4297); Ms. Darlene Cook (PC 4298); Xavier Hailey (PC 4299)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Chelsea Wilkerson (PC 4200); Karen Gagich (PC
4201); Julia DeBruicker (PC 4202); Shannon Glenn (PC 4203); Pam Waters (PC
4204); A. Even-Nir (PC 4205); Debra Garner (PC 4206); Leigh Horowitz (PC
4207); Elizabeth Kane (PC 4208); Laurel Silverman (PC 4209); Ropbert
Callahan (PC 4210); Monika Grzeniewski (PC 4211); Somelia Cornwell (PC
4212); James A. Tate (PC 4213); Gina M. Barclay (PC 4214); Erin Langler (PC
4215); Anthony Hamond (PC 4216); Sarah Ball (PC 4217); Sandra Sorani (PC
4218); Chance Bone (PC 4219); Justin R. Romo (PC 4220); Kaitlyn Clark (PC
4221); Joselyn Walker (PC 4222); Katie Topp (PC 4223); Nereida Cole (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
4224); Aaron Sanderlage (PC 4225); Antonille Esposto (PC 4226); Elisaeth
Lowerbeg (PC 4227); Paris Sanders (PC 4228Lindsey Hartley (PC 4229Roger
Mogle (PC 4230); ); ); Eric Biggs (PC 4231); Erik Steffean (PC 4232); Jennifer
Michehe (PC 4233); Elizabeth McDermott (PC 4234); Darren Lofarwick (PC
4235); Marieh Maichee (PC 4236); William Dempsey (PC 4237); Antonio
Marquez (PC 4238); William Van Vogt (PC 4239); Evelyn C. Gass (PC 4240);
Tom Filipski (PC 4241); Evelyn P. Tyner (PC 4242); Richard Seaman (PC
4243); Floyd Bednarz (PC 4244); Narendra Kumar (PC 4245); Shawn Kenkey
(PC 4246); Megan Somers Glenn (PC 4247); Jean Rum (PC 4248); Irene
Vandervloed (PC 4249)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Dave Smith (PC #4,150); Helen Withrow (PC
4151); Kevin F. Scott (PC 4152); Thomas J. Hickey (PC 4153); Ebony Hubbard
(PC 4154); Derrick Morris (PC 4155); Sandra Hudson (PC 4156); Christopher E.
Vadnal (PC 4157); Roland Chiu (PC 4158); Frances Gyras (PC 4159); Vicki
Moor (PC 4160); Julie Barnes (PC 4161); Jeremy Madsen (PC 4162); Bryan
Johnson (PC 4163); Tom Brien (PC 4164); Michael Karpeles (PC 4165); Ella
Harris (PC 4166); Elijah Porter (PC 4167); Cecil Hudson (PC 4168); Lisa Conley
(PC 4169); Carlos Matesanz (PC 4170); A;ekamdrp Aixala (PC 4171); Bernice
Buries (PC 4172); Robert Thomas (PC 4173); Sherri Arrington (PC 4174);
McKenzie Johnson (PC 4175); Anastasia Busiek (PC 4176); Erin Meehan (PC
4177); LaBruce Doty (PC 4178); Patricia Ann Ford (PC 4179); Pearline Monica
Burrows (PC 4180); Sharolyn Turner (PC 4181); Barb Sorensen (PC 4182);
Lutricia Williams (PC 4183); Nicholas Souder (PC 4184); Alvin Byrd (PC 4185);
Kenny D. Soreano-Garcia (PC 4186); Winston Guest (PC 4187); Richard Barron
Burns (PC 4188); Justin Min (PC 4189); Paul Hermany (PC 4190); Kenneth Apa
(PC 4191); Max Connell (PC 4192); Thomas Donaldson (PC 4193); Casey
Hudertz (PC 4194); Matthew Cavanaugh (PC 4195); Adrian LaTrace (PC 4196);
Vincent Fryle (PC 4197); Brian James (PC 4198); Eric Patterson (PC 4199)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Wendy Lehran (PC #4,100); Michael Goode (PC
4101); Fred T. Meyer (PC 4102); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4103); Wenon
Rymord-Richmond (PC 4104); Stephen Katz (PC 4105); Amy Frangipane (PC
4106); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4107); Branden Dashiell (PC 4108); Emir
Yonzon (PC 4109); Kawada Hodges (PC 4110); Beth Mayla Klein (PC 4111);
Stephen Hays (PC 4112); Jay Atkinson (PC 4113); Barbara Wine (PC 4114);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4115); Sharon Hayes (PC 4116); Michael Adams II
(PC 4117); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4118); Chaka B. Floyd (PC 4119);
Martin Dabrowski (PC 4120); David Leonard (PC 4121); Bette Walker (PC
4122); Zach Koppers (PC 4123); Amanda Smith (PC 4124); Jason Robinson (PC
4125); Shaleka Smith (PC 4126); Robert West (PC 4127); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4128); Kyle Fisher (PC 4129); Leonard Zanders (PC 4130); Steve
Corrinus (PC 4131); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4132); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 4133); Carmen Castillo (PC 4134); Frederick Young (PC 4135);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4136); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4137); Adam
Rohaes (PC 4138); Rebecca Ringquist (PC 4139); Colin Chapman (PC 4140);
Randy L. Ramsey (PC 4141); Wendy Nafziger (PC 4142); Melissa Kozarits (PC
4143); Ronald Kozarits (PC 4144); Nicholas Jaruis (PC 4145); Indecipherable
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Signature (PC 4146); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4147); David Fox (PC 4148);
Natashias Rosado (PC 4149)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Greg Hall (PC #4,050); Tudor Sidea (PC 4051);
Janierce Kolhs(PC 4052); Alexis Finch (PC 4053); Annie Rooney (PC 4054);
Caroline Cruz (PC 4055); Ralph Hansen (PC 4056); Meg Fitzgerald (PC 4057);
Mariam Yovnes (PC 4058); Oscar Barron (PC 4059); Nancy Nemeth (PC 4060);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4061); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4062);
Colleen Corning (PC 4063); Frances Canonizado (PC 4064); Willie Taylor (PC
4065); Angela Cooper (PC 4066); Laura Torres (PC 4067); Anne Bostrom (PC
4068); Charlie Salty (PC 4069); Ross McMillen (PC 4070); Theresa Radko (PC
4071); Erich Roeder (PC 4072); Kilah S. Redditt (PC 4073); Jay Pepitone (PC
4074); Jamie Morgan (PC 4075); Rachele Byrd-Townsell (PC 4076); Nira
Fernando (PC 4077); Wade Childress (PC 4078); Thomas Marlow (PC 4079);
Cathy Sullivan (PC 4080); Nicole Waddell (PC 4081); Indecipherable Signature
(PC 4082); Martha G. Clark (PC 4083); Yesenia Arroyo (PC 4084); Cindy
Baxter (PC 4085); Jon Saint (PC 4086); Van Hemphill (PC 4087); Lynn Levy
(PC 4088); L. Peeler (PC 4089); Joshua Engel (PC 4090); Nicole Kovski (PC
4091); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4092); Danielle King (PC 4093); Karl
Nauratil (PC 4094); Win Whelan (PC 4095); Jessica L. Jones (PC 4096); Jon
Reinet (PC 4097); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4098); Spencer Burne (PC 4099)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Alexander Lurie (PC #4,000); Walter Coleman (PC
4001); Darlene Gasior (PC 4002); Nancy Ross (PC 4003); Andrew El-Shark (PC
4004); Matt Olson (PC 4005); Nora El-Shark (PC 4006); Kelly Smith (PC 4007);
George Keaton (PC 4008); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4009); Angela Powell
(PC 4010); Lisa Penelton (PC 4011); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4012);
Michael Dudseon (PC 4013); Ellen O'Rourke (PC 4014); Bethany Babich (PC
4015); John E. Prater (PC 4016); Montrall Young (PC 4017); Chris Prost (PC
4018); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4019); Steve Bickham (PC 4020);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 4021); Jessica Langston (PC 4022); Joel T. Felix
(PC 4023); Tony Morales (PC 4024); Indecipherable Signature (PC 4025);
Alejandra Romo (PC 4026); James R. Romo (PC 4027); Lisa Ramirez (PC
4028); Edwin Ramirez (PC 4029); Adriana Garcia (PC 4030); Eusi Saddyk (PC
4031); Pedro Chavez (PC 4032); Jonathan Adams (PC 4033); Rebecca Engel (PC
4034); Maria Uisel (PC 4035); Max Eisenburger (PC 4036); Patricia Brown (PC
4037); Jennifer Konerko (PC 4038); Crystal Lee (PC 4039); Dinah Isa (PC
4040); Pamela Spann (PC 4041); P.J. Grant (PC 4042); Brandi Bean (PC 4043);
Ed Weirauch (PC 4044); Joseph Pearson (PC 4045); Ebonie Lawrence (PC
4046); Tyrone Knight (PC 4047); Amy M. Greenamyer (PC 4048); Nicholas
Maretta (PC 4049)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Leonie O'Donohue (PC #3,950); Debby Feru (PC
3951); Lisa Bretores (PC 3952); Beth Miles (PC 3953); Indecipherable Signature
(PC 3954); Linda Ricks (PC 3955); Thomas Cline (PC 3956); Jonathan Vehar
(PC 3957); Patrick Hughes (PC 3958); Sharon Mackey (PC 3959); Mary Ann
Egan (PC 3960); Scott Dracker (PC 3961); Shirley Ure (PC 3962); Emil Ulstrano
(PC 3963); Dane Featherstone (PC 3964); Deborah Bradley (PC 3965); Rita M.
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Winger (PC 3966); Goldberg (PC 3967); Jan Nuber (PC 3968); Reginald
Thompson (PC 3969); Robert W. Hessberger (PC 3970); Mike Cascio (PC 3971);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 3972); Michael Carlin (PC 3973); David Abraham
(PC 3974); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3975); Roman Savchenko (PC 3976);
Vania Wang (PC 3977); Leanne Kuchar (PC 3978); Joanne Matik (PC 3979);
Corinna Psomadalas (PC 3980); Meg Paschich (PC 3981); Jill Yurk (PC 3982);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 3983); Morgan Pedolak (PC 3984); Alice Pictor
(PC 3985); Wendy Shelleny (PC 3986); Howard Warso (PC 3987);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 3988); Jackie Durso (PC 3989); G. Williamson (PC
3990); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3991); Michael Shredl (PC 3992); Daniel
Martinez (PC 3993); Jessica Barselow (PC 3994); Brenda Harrison (PC 3995);
Frederick Clemons (PC 3996); Candia Morrison (PC 3997); Bonnie Sampson
(PC 3998); Katie Boyle (PC 3999)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jose Alfaro (PC #3,900); Indecipherable Signature
(PC 3901); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3902); Greg Ouska (PC 3903); Patricia
Goldwell (PC 3904); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3905); Jay Sbarboro (PC
3906); Juliette Zielke (PC 3907); Susan Randhava (PC 3908); Kord Staley (PC
3909); Beth McQuie (PC 3910); Karen Linden (PC 3911); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 3912); Cathy Olsen (PC 3913); Alex Kamilewicz (PC 3914);
Sarah Michaelson (PC 3915); Ian Rogers (PC 3916); Steven W. Albrecht (PC
3917); Velinda Hooranson (PC 3918); Gloria Strom (PC 3919); Nikia Jongbo
(PC 3920); Jameel Young (PC 3921); Warren Hanoy (PC 3922); Devan Moran
(PC 3923); Long Yang (PC 3924); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3925); Mike
Lucia (PC 3926); F. Rosendorn (PC 3927); Lisa Frederick (PC 3928); Patrick
Thomas (PC 3929); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3930); C. Boas (PC 3931);
Jean Kim (PC 3932); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3933); Jenny Vollen (PC
3934); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3935); Art Schmit (PC 3936); Eleanor
Flynn (PC 3937); Greg Britton (PC 3938); Charles J. Hagan (PC 3939);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 3940); Leo Schelbert (PC 3941); Caroline Latta
(PC 3942); Eileen Zehr Gaod (PC 3943); Tim Verrilli (PC 3944); Jackie Grober
(PC 3945); Carol McConnell (PC 3946); Jennifer Linzer (PC 3947); Ann Marie
Dorian (PC 3948); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3949)-
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Erin Nusbaum (PC #3,850); Eric Boughner (PC
3851); Jarmaine Lee (PC 3852); Michael Dunham (PC 3853); Welsey Anderson
(PC 3854); B.A. Church (PC 3855); Tom Mansfield (PC 3856); Kristian Tibbetts
(PC 3857); Nic Norris (PC 3858); Tina Malnati (PC 3859); Angelica Slupnicki
(PC 3860); Mark Such (PC 3861); Patty Templeton (PC 3862); Jana Lakovenko
(PC 3863); Robert Godsey (PC 3864); Melissa Ferruzza (PC 3865);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 3866); Lauren Whitlock (PC 3867); Merle Kaplan
(PC 3868); Sharnell Junious (PC 3869); Patrick Constant (PC 3870); Lorena
Madrigal (PC 3871); Sarah Szostaw (PC 3872); Katie Rolla (PC 3873); Jenna
Wesley (PC 3874); LaQuita Washington (PC 3875); Charlean Mondie (PC
3876); Dan Ryan (PC 3877); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3878); Ana C.
Rodriguez (PC 3879); Elizabeth Morun (PC 3880); Pricilla Maddela (PC 3881);
Stephanie Fript (PC 3882); Christen Connolly (PC 3883); Mary Jo Hetland (PC
3884); Amy Denes (PC 3885); David Morawski (PC 3886); Yesenia Rodriguez
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 3887); Joanna Bautista (PC 3888); Colin Thomas (PC 3889); Camilla
Krueger (PC 3890); Caitun Stich (PC 3891); Andrew Zurawik (PC 3892); Andy
Bulogh (PC 3893); E. Hodges (PC 3894); Caryn M. Fitzsimmons (3895);
Kristina Manalang (PC 3896); Larry D. Hicks (PC 3897); Lucy Morrison (PC
3898); Brian O'Neill (PC 3899)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Lisa Johnson (PC #3,800); Steven Spicer (PC
3801); Michelle Kottke (PC 3802); Betsey Thomas (PC 3803); Matt Cohen (PC
3804); Janet Minis (PC 3805); Aislinn Gagliardi (PC 3806); Heather Panielewicz
(PC 3807); Ed Garren (PC 3808); Brad Wolf (PC 3809); Sean morgan (3810);
Abel DuFrene (PC 3811); Matt Corbin (PC 3812); Robert Reyes (PC 3813); Jim
Bonhaz (PC 3814); Dave Neal (PC 3815); Monica Garcia (PC 3816); Alma
Salgado (PC 3817); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3818); Kristina Winters (PC
3819); Ron Speiser (PC 3820); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3821); Carol Potter
(PC 3822); Charles Sexton (PC 3823); Steve Girard (PC 3824); Paulette Gust
(PC 3825); Joe DeNatale (PC 3826); Julio C. Luna (PC 3827); J.R. Witmer (PC
3828); Matthew D. Cipra (PC 3829); Luke Breckon (PC 3830); Kristin Nerger
(PC 3831); Matthew J. Fisher (PC 3832); Barbara Vo (PC 3833); Augustina
Tevostra (PC 3834); Josh Bernstein (PC 3835); Mike W. Petersen (PC 3836);
Tracy Brown (PC 3837); Jimmy Welsh (PC 3838); Jason Cellarius (PC 3839);
Chris Hoffman (PC 3840); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3841); Phillip Ozaki
(PC 3842); Drew Kigor (PC 3843); Sam Lee (PC 3844); Celeste Peterson (PC
3845); Corey Strange (PC 3846); Joe J. Beck (PC 3847); Seth Farley (PC 3848);
Rori DeClue-Magnusson (PC 3849)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Fran Shaw (PC #3,750); Jan Topolewski (PC
3751); Josh Leigh (PC 3752); J.P. Fanning; Glenn Sullivan (PC 3754); Thomas
S. Schulenberg (PC 3755); Mary Jo Banks (PC 3756); Stephen R. Coats (PC
3757); John Sacelli (PC 3758); Ana Maria Downs (PC 3759); Dennis Smith (PC
3760); Vik Spokas (PC 3761); Eduardo J. Azpeitic (PC 3762); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 3763); Joe Tajan (PC 3764); J. McMasters (PC 3765); Mindy
Virgil (PC 3766); Dennis E. Ervin (PC 3767); Martin Halacy (PC 3768);
Melodee Mann (PC 3769); Michael O'Reilly (PC 3770); Petra C. Flores (PC
3771); G. Graham (PC 3772); Becky O'Brien (PC 3773); John Hansen Sr. (PC
3774); Judy Hansen (PC 3775); Bonnie Coors (PC 3776); Hazel E. Long (PC
3777); Mildred Kanneberg (PC 3778); Adam Ford (PC 3779); Martin Morales
(PC 3780); Carla Tobin (PC 3781); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3782); Nancy
Keller (PC 3783); Angelo Desmerio (PC 3784); Terry M. Figard (PC 3785);
Barry Behler (PC 3786); Jeff Harrison (PC 3787); Brenda Klein (PC 3788); Gay
L. Johnson (PC 3789); Cheryl Janis (PC 3790); Rita Olson (PC 3791); Kandy
Schroeder (PC 3792); Roxie and Ralph Ratta (PC 3793); Will Cramer (PC 3794);
Kathy Downey (PC 3795); Carol Fetzner (PC 3796); Gerald Eisenmenger (PC
3797); Sheryl Gee (PC 3798); Story Kier (PC 3799)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Indecipherable signature (PC #3,700); Betty Giorgi
(PC 3701); David Stein (PC 3702); Tony Jones (PC 3703); Angel Ortiz (PC
3704); Mike Hansen (PC 3705); Michele Hastinger (PC 3706); Wanda Zeman
(PC 3707); Amy England (PC 3708); Jackie Stogsdill (PC 3709); Tamara Smith
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 3710); Jeus Vicente (PC 3711); Michelle Garch (PC 3712); A. Hearst (PC
3713); Valerie Pleshar (PC 3714); Friend of PIRG (PC 3715); Ginny Mathem
(PC 3716); Carey Overstreet (PC 3717); Martin Hajduk (PC 3718); Freddy Coba
(PC 3719); Tobby Fried (PC 3720); Eileen Friestad (PC 3721); Dale Fillippo (PC
3722); Ben Hall (PC 3723); Eric Robinson (PC 3724); Chris Vinai (PC 3725);
Dylan Jordon (PC 3726); D. McLain (PC 3727); Jen Anderson (PC 3728); Friend
of PIRG (PC 3729); Kelly Nieman (PC 3730); Connie ligon (PC 3731); Kevin
Shannon (PC 3732); Lindsay Battle (PC 3733); Indecipherable Signature (PC
3734); Chris Benson (PC 3735); Stephanie Dufford (PC 3736); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 3737); Scott Gunn (PC 3738); Sterling M. Rand (PC 3739);
Elspeth Revere (PC 3740); Wendy Robie (PC 3741); Jeannie Vonhof (PC 3742);
Lance Rantala (PC 3743); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3744); Mark Natanek
(PC 3745); G. Tommy Wilson (PC 3746); Martha Barth (PC 3747); Heriberto
Costillo (PC 3748); Robert Engel (PC 3749);
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Joseph K. Hoereth (PC #3,650); V. Kurch (PC
3651); Keith Schalinio (PC 3652); Queda Dye-Bradford (PC 3653); Clarissa
Miller (PC 3654); Ruth Kearns (PC 3655); H.Y. Krenzifn (PC 3656); Karen and
Michael Grandinetti (PC 3657); Nicole Menacher (PC 3658); Kate Ward (PC
3659); Melissa Gibson (PC 3660); Ana Serrano (PC 3661); Mary Kate Fleming
(PC 3662); Mike Mason (PC 3663); Frank Schabold (PC 3664); Kathy
McNamara (PC 3665); Julie N. Maranto (PC 3666); Jim Gillen (PC 3667);
Laurie Abel (PC 3668); Dottie Fletcher (PC 3669); Steve Baruffl (PC 3670); Jhan
Swanson (PC 3671); Catherine Driscoll (PC 3672); Ezra Sandzer-Bell (PC 3673);
Will Nowak (PC 3674); David Smith (PC 3675); Mary Coleman (PC 3676);
Patricia Lewis (PC 3677); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3678); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 3679); Ms. Doyle-Smith (PC 3680); Don McSherry (PC 3681);
Megan Wells-Paske (PC 3682); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3683); Chris Grey
(PC 3684); Eddie Woods (PC 3685); Brian Gruby (PC 3686); Victor Larkin (PC
3687); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3688); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3689);
Bruce Webster (PC 3690); Jeremy Bohne (PC 3691); Steven Hirschberg (PC
3692); Jerry Brown (PC 3693); Casey Hultz (PC 3694); David Kossy (PC 3695);
Ms. Annette Caldwell (PC 3696); Michael Tsoulos (PC 3697); Jane Kathein (PC
3698); Mallory Porcelh (PC 3699)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jerry Miceli (PC #3,600); Phyllis Aavang (PC
3601); Lonnie Vann (PC 3602); Carol Alfus (PC 3603); John M. Puzzo (PC
3604); Harold and Jeanette Johnson (PC 3605); Fred Tessles (PC 3606); Cindy
Vedda (PC 3607); Kristoe Kieher (PC 3608); Grace Gordon (PC 3609); Ray
Russmann (PC 3610); Killis Pugh (PC 3611); Erick Howenstine (PC 3612);
Elaine L. Heichman (PC 3613); Sheree Morratto (PC 3614); Noelle Zabadneh
(PC 3615); Travis Patterson (PC 3616); Jeanne Y. Nestor (PC 3617); Joe
Bannano (PC 3618); Margaret Czubak (PC 3619); Stuart Hiley (PC 3620); Mr.
F.D. Muzzy (PC 3621); Lillian and Carl Frazier (PC 3622); M. Rinelli (PC
3623); Nisma Ruparllson (PC 3624); David a. Austern (PC 3625); Rose Mary
Mahany (PC 3626); Paul Shadle and Monica Drane (PC 3627); Natalie Holder
(PC 3628); Linda Cheney (PC 3629); Terry Peabody (PC 3630); Karen Pascaal
(PC 3631); James Woods (PC 3632); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3633); Phillip
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Wilkins (PC 3634); Eleanor Frew (PC 3635); Carolyn Geeding (PC 3636);
Raman Sacadev (PC 3637); T. Bustos (PC 3638); Indecipherable Signature (PC
3639); Indecipherable Signature (PC 3640); Judy Leo (PC 3641); Thomas L.
Meyer (PC 3642); Iris Shaffer (PC 3643); Theodis Brown (PC 3644); Melissa
Rendon (PC 3645); Natalie Cimino (PC 3646); Kurt Neubauer (PC 3647); Mara
Morris (PC 3648); B. Stein (PC 3649)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jillian R. Neal (PC 3550); Gary Isaal (PC 3551);
Nancy Enget (PC 3552); Byrne Laurence (PC 3,553); Auzu Du (PC 3554); Ann
Lanelo (PC 3555); Matt Ahearn (PC 3556); Rita D. Mason (PC 3557); Kate
Doehring (PC 3558); Maya Jensen (PC 3559); Margaret Sdsit (PC 3560); Leo
Suarez (PC 3561); Michael O'hara (PC 3562); Ido Ben-Zvi (PC 3563); Callie
Tucker (PC 3564); Jackie Seaman (PC 3565); Noreen Edwards (PC 3566);
Nancy T. Trimble (PC 3567); Jill Leff (PC 3568); Guy Leekley (PC 3569);
Sharena (PC 3570); Kenneth Chan (PC 3571); Pete Sexton (PC 3572); J.C.
Cormack (PC 3573); Sue Jacobson (PC 3574);Janet Sparks (PC 3575); Scott
Waller (PC 3576); Sara Brenner (PC 3577); Rose Thomas (PC 3578); Jon
Kipferberg (PC 3579); Mark Steege (PC 3580); Daniel jBleier (PC 3581); Jim
Amato (PC 3582); Carol Lind (PC 3583); Ross Buchanan (PC 3584);John
Robinson (PC 3585); Frank Rowe (PC 3586); Aneta Wojciwk (PC 3587); Julie
Fitzgerald (PC 3588); Richard Penral (PC 3589); Lynn Altfeld (PC 3590); Rory
MacPhail (PC 3591); Joan Ducayet (PC 3592); Judy Krizmanic (PC 3593);
James P. Nacel (PC 3594); Ed Kovach (PC 3595); Frank Marrese (PC
3596);Toby Edwards (PC 3597);Jennifer Magnus (PC 3598);Varoon S.
Deshmukh (PC 3599)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Janis Michael (PC #3,500);Mark VandeHoy (PC
#3,501); Marge Zivin (PC #3,502); Renee Summers (PC #3,503); Richard C.
Erickson (PC #3,504); Tom Miller (PC #3,505); Carol Heffernan (PC #3,506);
Susan Collier (PC #3,507); A.J. Kane (PC #3,508); Nancy Seheid (PC #3,509);
Georgette Phillos (PC #3,510); Donna Pappo (PC #3,511); D. R. Powers (PC
#3,512); Colleen Mulroe (PC #3,513); Katie Martin (PC #3,514); Barbara Woody
(PC #3,515); Patrick Carroll (PC #3,516); J. Gusppeluz (PC #3,517); Joseph R
Hageman (PC #3,518); Shanti Elliott (PC #3,519); Tom Conroy (PC #3,520);
Nancy Doyle (PC #3,521); Catherine Neary (PC #3,522); Richard Mark (PC
#3,523);Morgan F. Simmons (PC #3,524); Nicole Lipschultz (PC #3,525);
Carmen Wheatcroft (PC #3,526); Liz Eldenberg (PC #3,527); Falimeh Azadi (PC
#3,528); Casey Miller (PC #3,529); Pat Maunsell (PC #3,530); Dan Lambert (PC
#3,531); Tamyola Grebill (PC #3,532); M. Gebhardt (PC #3,533); Charles Racid
(PC #3,534); Nancy Adams (PC #3,535); Gary Manzella (PC #3,536); A. W.
Lynch (PC #3,537);Mollie Vanderkam (PC #3,538); Steven Goldman (PC
#3,539); John Reddington (PC #3,540); Thomas L. Amos (PC #3,541); S.
Kleiman (PC #3,542); Gil Wyngarden (PC #3,543); Juanita Blade (PC #3,544);
Sherneece Mason (PC #3,545); Sharon Nelson (PC #3,546);Samuel Bamidele
(PC #3,547); Raymond Aaron (PC #3,548); Jermaine Ellis (PC #3,549)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Matthew Hartgering (PC 3450); Cydne Gillard (PC
3451); Bruce Mitchell (PC 3452); Julie Froeter (PC 3453); Margie Schaps (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
3454); Caitlyn Cox (PC 3455); Obaid Chhatriwala (PC 3456); Kevin Matthew
(PC 3457); Michelle Gilbert (PC 3458); Roberto Regala (PC 3459); Catherine
Igbal (PC 3460); S. Lechowicz (PC 3461); Lisa Ryno (PC 3462); Bernard Butler
(PC 3463); M Van Geinelt (PC 3464); William MacKendrick (PC 3465); Randy
Hilgers (PC 3466); Robert Cenz (PC 3467); Susan Karanias (PC 3468); Mary
Moran (PC 3469); Therese Gustafson (PC 3470); Ruth E Jaerard (PC 3471);
Kathleen Salerno (PC 3472); Ken Remington (PC 3473); Elizabeth Lipwich (PC
3474); Dennis Blair (PC 3475); Richard Aspell (PC 3476); Michelle Stelcher (PC
3477); Julie Barser (PC 3478); Lisa Bohne (PC 3479); Samantha Rockwood (PC
3480); Mia Ostrowsko (PC 3481); Laura F Nelson (PC 3482); Mertz Savorn (PC
3483); Maureen Sullivan (PC 3484); Andrew Luvington (PC 3485);
indecipherable signature (PC 3486); James Perkins (PC 3487); H C Purcie (PC
3488); William Levin (PC 3489); Pat Barrow (PC 3490); indecipherable
signature (PC 3491); Mike Kelly (PC 3492); Gary Cole (PC 3493); Mary
Vanderbed (PC 3494); Neal Rubin (PC 3495); Mary Welk (PC 3496); Audra
Shropshire (PC 3497); Guadalupe Rubio (PC 3498); Eugene Martz (PC 3499)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Zach Baker (PC 3400); Seth & Patty Baker (PC
3401); John K Wiseman (PC 3402); Richard Silverstein (PC 3403); Gail Mudro
(PC 3404); David Clatch (PC 3405); Tim Hedrich (PC 3406); Rosa Frazer (PC
3407); Martin O'Donnell (PC 3408); Sasha Gerritson (PC 3409); Stephanie A.
Hardesty (PC 3410); Wesley Redford (PC 3411); Etta Graves (PC 3412);
Suzanne R. Dulth (PC 3413); Pat Dervin (PC 3414); L M McCauley (PC 3415);
Rick Fishe (PC 3416); Susan Fallon (PC 3417); Tara Jopp (PC 3418); Barry Ruse
(PC 3419); Don Borley (PC 3420); Dan Ofloy (PC 3421); Mary Mathison (PC
3422); Linda Finkel (PC 3423); Jason Mitchell (PC 3424); Kim Nathanson (PC
3425); Jill Leach (PC 3426); Qaiser Waraich (PC 3427); Brenda Davis (PC
3428); Jane Park (PC 3429); indecipherable signature (PC 3430); Ceil Zabielski
(PC 3431); Diana Horvat (PC 3432); Bonnie Schieber (PC 3433); Joseph Salvato
(PC 3434); Cheryl Jaffe (PC 3435); Linda Neiweem (PC 3436); Kim Deschamps
(PC 3437); William Aravelis (PC 3438); Bernice Weinhorn (PC 3439); Ellen L
Schroud (PC 3440); Michele Russman (PC 3441); Patricia Price (PC 3442);
Harvey Echols (PC 3444); Nolan Michael (PC 3445); Babs H Wauman (PC
3446); Robert Bernce (PC 3447); Jeff Smith (PC 3448); Audrey Twohey (PC
3449)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Loretha Taylor (PC 3350); Abigail Dancey (PC
3351); Demitrius Green (PC 3352); Iban-Abel Leon (PC 3353); William Thayer
(PC 3354); Lisa Ward (PC 3355); Sara Fernandez (PC 3356); Paul H Gobster
(PC 3357); Andrew Kerr (PC 3358); Brad Stanley (PC 3359); Diane L Meyer
(PC 3360); Mary Scruggs (PC 3361); Steve Hedberg (PC 3362); Dorothy
Norwood (PC 3363); Janet Jensen (PC 3364); Joan McGovern (PC 3365); LeRoy
Singleton (PC 3366); James Wade (PC 3367); Mary Kirby (PC 3368); Catherine
Bordenaro (PC 3369); Denter Rather (PC 3370); Nina Cooper (PC 3371); Sophia
Grace Lane (PC 3372); Chloe Lane (PC 3373); G Vasquez (PC 3374); S
Robinson (PC 3375); Kimberly A Myles (PC 3376); Erceal Myles (PC 3377);
Manual Garcia (PC 3378); Mr & Mrs. John Kraus (PC 3379); Benjamin P
Sherman (PC 3380); Travis H Dunncan (PC 3381); Delia Lane (PC 3382); John
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Peterlin (PC 3383); Zelda Blocker (PC 3384); indecipherable signature (PC
3385); Selena Poole (PC 3386); Jesse Cryor (PC 3387); Phyllis M Johnson (PC
3388); indecipherable signature (PC 3389); Bradford Lane (PC 3390); Antwan
Harshaw (PC 3391); Larry Etcitty Jr. (PC 3392); Brandon Flowers (PC 3393);
Robert Landfair (PC 3394); Tara Force (PC 3395); Amblessed Okorie (PC 3396);
Ronnie . Cossom (PC 3397); Michael Rosenberg (PC 3398); Gregory E Ellis (PC
3399)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Chris Slaughter (PC 3300); Fran Cichowski (PC
3301); G. Smath (PC 3302); Paul Brown (PC 3304); Kathy Peric (PC 3305);
Charles E. Payne (PC 3306); Megan Miskiewicz (PC 3307); Kelli Griffis (PC
3308); Don Krueger (PC 3309); Latoya Bright (PC 3310); Zach Mingle (PC
3311); indecipherable signature (PC 3312); V. Smith (PC 3313); Curtis Burr (PC
3314); Jonathan Carow (PC 3315); Caliph Racul (PC 3316); David Liddell (PC
3317); Renee Mehdi (PC 3318); Shawn Rae (PC 3319); Tony Wilson (PC 3320);
Darel White (PC 3321); Samuel Torres Miranda (PC 3322); Susan Spiesroth (PC
3323); Josie A Rivas (PC 3324); Christina Riepel (PC 3325); Chris Havo (PC
3326); Jamel Nelson (PC 3327); Anand Bhandu (PC 3328); Jesse Wallace (PC
3329); Raul Perez (PC 3330); Megan Murphy (PC 3331); Julie Larson (PC
3332); Carol Matz (PC 3333); Marke Zuric (PC 3334); Erica Bright (PC 3335);
Sharon Jackson (PC 3336); Tricia Hersey (PC 3337); Michele Racioppi (PC
3338); Lindsay Hyland (PC 3339); Emma Anderson (PC 3340); Victoria C
Parker (PC 3341); Susan Eissens (PC 3342); Chris Corsale (PC 3343); Lenore
Zeiger (PC 3344); Sheila Watson (PC 3345); Ron Gonser (PC 3346); Linda
Tyson (PC 3347); George Morris (PC 3348); Mitchell Seizor (PC 3349)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Howard Shuman (PC 3250); Barbara Bailey (PC
3251); Doris Gibson (PC 3252); Alan Lin (PC 3253); indecipherable signature
(PC 3254); Charlene Bailey (PC 3255); Debra Clark (PC 3256); Andrea
Jabronski (PC 3257); Clifton Adell (PC 3258); John Jones (PC 3259); Steve
Head (PC 3260); Omodele J Akeredolu (PC 3261); Valerie Brown (PC 3262);
Steven Gordon (PC 3263); K Zimmerman (PC 3264); Amanda Cardona (PC
3265); Cynthia Tarr (PC 3266); Anjali Goel (PC 3267); Charles Benedetti (PC
3268); Margaret Tarr (PC 3269); Elizabeth Harris (PC 3270); Charles Emrich
(PC 3271); Khamsin Tahiri (PC 3272); Shannon Holub (PC 3273); Steve
Hoffman (PC 3274); Stephen Weber (PC 3275); Jeff Grygny (PC 3276); Andy
Wright (PC 3277); Ron P. Wolezyk (PC 3278); Pat Tierrs (PC 3279); Rich
Melone (PC 3280); Mary Guquick (PC 3281); Chaundra Harrison (PC 3282);
Colin Reilly (PC 3283); Therese Butler Bodee (PC 3284); Yolanda Stickland (PC
3285); Tom Evan (PC 3286); indecipherable signature (PC 3287); Phillip Fox
(PC 3288); Theodore Tsantis (PC 3289); Rodney Harrington (PC 3290);
indecipherable signature (PC 3291); Tina Brondstelter (PC 3292); Robbie
Johnson (PC 3293); Kesha K miree (PC 3294); Dotthe A Stuckey (PC 3295);
David Franc (PC 3296); Katherine Franc (PC 3297); Fred Owens (PC 3298);
Veronica Okafor (PC 3299)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Chani Gupta (PC 3200); indecipherable signature
(PC 3201); Jess Lanham (PC 3202); Tanyale Bell (PC 3203); Lesenia Guerrire
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 3204); Carolina Guerrero (PC 3205); Jiha Taylor (PC 3206); Carri Edwards
(PC 3207); David Lin (PC 3208); Eugene Chang (PC 3209); Christian Woil (PC
3210); Neterre Fagerberg (PC 3211); Stephanie Farah (PC 3212); Jean Brennan
(PC 3213); Jesse Brennan (PC 3214); Faye Ward (PC 3215); Daniel Reilly (PC
3216); Meg Huizenga (PC 3217); William Carrera (PC 3218); Elizabeth Rehuba
(PC 3219); John Flynn (PC 3220); Kenneth Andrews (PC 3221); Dana Dillon
(PC 3222); Audrey Weidman (PC 3223); Lauri Buckley (PC 3224); Mary S.
Duncan (PC 3225); Tearra Montgomery (PC 3226); Carmen Mooses (PC 3227);
Ashley Thom (PC 3228); Ines Sonmer (PC 3229); Christine Johnson (PC 3230);
Pat Dugan (PC 3231); Brian Mikes (PC 3232); Sharon Weltman (PC 3233); Dan
Blumenthal (PC 3234); Tisha Tucker (PC 3235); Lois Toolan (pc 3236); Marie
Guandaum (PC 3237); Wayne McKee (PC 3238); Janet Nicoli (PC 3239);
Herman Niu (PC 3240); Melissa Montgomery (PC 3241); Anabell Max (PC
3242); K Kleinfeldt (PC 3243); Carolyn Siliezar (PC 3244); Leon Songer (PC
3245); Ms. Taylor (PC 3246); Mary Laga (PC 3247); Charmayne Tyler (PC
3248); indecipherable signature (PC 3249)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Sarah Wild (PC #3,150); SueDahlman (PC 3151);
Dianne Moriarty (PC 3152); Karla Romero (PC 3153); Phil Burnstine (PC 3154);
Meg Loughran (PC 3155); Wong Cheng (PC 3156); Aria Kinch (PC 3157);
Rachel P. Grainer (PC 3158); Laura Osterlund (PC 3159); Christopher Walher
(PC 3160); Dana Watkins (PC 3161); Jill Weber (PC 3162); Perrin de Jong (PC
3163); Alison Pittas (PC 3164); Jen David (PC 3165); Jeff Citear (PC 3166); Lisa
Eckert (PC 3167); Claire Hieber (PC 3168); Maria DeLuca and Christina Barron
(PC 3169); Michael Fleming (PC 3170); Linda R. Janota (PC 3171); Aunica
Jones (PC 3172); Patricia Szczerba (PC 3173); Veronica Calvillo (PC 3174);
Rebecca Lewis (PC 3175); Kudzai Mdondo (PC 3176); Marshawn Wallce (PC
3177); Konstanta Matokhin (PC 3178); Linda Berko (PC 3179); Gina Berko (PC
3180); Kathryn Rupe (PC 3181); Britteny Townsend (PC 3182); Leanne Hughes
(PC 3183); Samantha Brumby (PC 3184); Pavit Batmia (PC 3185); Lawrence
Smith (PC 3186); Rayl Prua (PC 3187); Anastasia Rogers (PC 3188); Susie
Krsteigre (PC 3189); Brian Johnsten (PC 3190); Felicia Brdigers (PC 3191); Kim
Washington (PC 3192); David Cerny (PC 3193); Lynda Nolan (PC 3194); Mike
Parourek (PC 3195); Brandi Bran (PC 3196); Reid Foster (PC 3197); Lonimaire
Futrell (PC 3198); Brian Kay (PC 3199)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jerome Wankat (PC #3,100); M. Shunt (PC 3101);
Suzanne Saba (PC 3102); Eric Smith (PC 3103); Brian Sly (PC 3104); Branson
Malcom (PC 3105); Trenton Willey (PC 3106); Christopher Brown (PC 3107);
Paul Manuel (PC 3108); Henri D. Parker (PC 3109); Paul Nicholson (PC 3110);
George Wu (PC 3111); Neil Chudgar (PC 3112); Jerome Batton (PC 3113);
Corey Barnes (PC 3114); Jimmy Damon (PC 3115); Monissa Werner (PC 3116);
Mark Nattier (PC 3117); Robert Ballertine (PC 3118); Caturier Anne Lewis (PC
3119); Lisa Garrett (PC 3120); Sara Mariello (PC 3121); Judy Eckberg (PC
3122); Hannah McKenna (PC 3123); Isadora J. Wagner (PC 3124); David
Schalliol (PC 3125); Vivian Tien (PC 3126); Chris Allaun (PC 3127); Katie
Green (PC 3128); Ross Neale (PC 3129); Sibel Islamoglu (PC 3130); Tiara
Morris (PC 3131); Greg Turner (PC 3132); Alysha Thompson (PC 3133);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Maverick Marqueo (PC 3134); Katie Pekara (PC 3135); Syhia Kreyasik (PC
3136); Ana Janic (PC 3137); Akeea Barker (PC 3138); Jeannette Rodriguez (PC
3139); Johniece Davis (PC 3140); Bill Palmer (PC 3141); Tia Liogas (PC 3142);
Shelton R. Watson (PC 3143); Karen Dhadialla (PC 3144); Helene Smith-Romer
(PC 3145); Jason Liebovich (PC 3146); Katherine Overom (PC 3147); Maureen
Peabody (PC 3148); Brittany Steiner (PC 3149)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - John Laurie (PC #3,050); Tammy Li (PC #3051);
Tajwer Shadman (PC #3052); Scoti Corey (PC #3053); Connie Kantutis (PC
#3054); A. Schulte (PC #3055); David Stefani (PC #3056); Marion Kutek (PC
#3057); Delores Johnson (PC #3058); Milde Beaeseke (PC #3059); Ohm Weber
(PC #3060); Kenneth Gunther (PC #3061); Tojo Chorath (PC #3062); Richard
Kim (PC #3063); Fred Engle (PC #3064); J. Leamanczyk (PC #3065); Chris
Tomsheck (PC #3066); Gail Wilson (PC #3067); William Guy (PC #3068);
George Fulgham (PC #3069); Darnila Murphy (PC #3070); Shana Johns (PC
#3071); Rodney Jones (PC #3072); Virginia Butrynski (PC #3073); Keith A
Brown (PC #3074); Marla Gomberg (PC #3075); Matt Sparagin (PC #3076);
McInnis McCormick (PC #3077); Holly Johnston (PC #3078); Jade N. Giacobbe
(PC #3079); Jennifer Smith (PC #3080); J. Lin (PC #3081); Phyllis E. Goodloe
(PC #3082); indecipherable signature (PC #3083); Jan Schwitema (PC #3084);
Martin Kreitman (PC #3085); Shawn Dragman (PC #3086); Lisa Moser (PC
#3087); Sylvia Newman (PC #3088); Donna Bouroudjian (PC #3089); Letty
Hawkes (PC #3090); Rick Schultz (PC #3091); Sue Pinelli (PC #3092); Mary
Salm (PC #3093); Bill Kozuch (PC #3094); Judith Mitchell (PC #3095); Jane
Kozuch (PC #3096); Patricia Leahy (PC #3097); Susan Love (PC #3098); Lynne
Bowman (PC #3099)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Clarence Baldwin (PC #3,000); Jessica Mareles (PC
#3001); Jason Mattaw (PC #3002); Joseph Patterson (PC #3003); Ryan Williams
(PC #3004); Sharon Luckett (PC #3005); Lizette Rubio (PC #3006); Tyrone J.
Long (PC #3007); Edwin E. Jordan (PC #3008); Gregorio Griffin (PC #3009);
Richard Webb (PC #3010); Alex Curry (PC #3011); Mansha Bowie (PC #3012);
Melvin Francis (PC #3013); Eric Stanly (PC #3014); Corisma Gillespie (PC
#3015); indecipherable signature (PC #3016); Michael Noel (PC #3017); G.
David Wright (PC #3018); Ashley M. Fox (PC #3019); indecipherable signature
(PC #3020); Tonya Cleveland (PC #3021); Thihe Kyan (PC #3022); Johnny
Clark (PC #3023); Ryan Bailey (PC #3024); Ashley Cunningham (PC #3025);
Derell Bonner (PC #3026); Ellen Jenkins (PC #3027); Robert Lara (PC #3028);
Alexander Urbe (PC #3029); Ringa Kurniawan (PC #3030); Marlo Evans (PC
#3031); Yasine Scott (PC #3032); Jamie Brouillette (PC #3033); Deandre
Crawford (PC #3034); Vincent Stewart (PC #3035); Margi Patel (PC #3036);
Claude Phillips (PC #3037); Leroy Becney (PC #3038); indecipherable signature
(PC #3039); C. Robbins (PC #3040); Barry Jackson (PC #3041); Taneka Norman
(PC #3042); Tom Thompson (PC #3043); Ulysses Cortes (PC #3044);
Shamontelle Lewis (PC #3045); Julie Brock (PC #3046); Meg Carpenter (PC
#3047); Susan Sand (PC #3048); Michelle McGonan (PC #3049)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Michael Riddle (PC #2950);Indecipherable
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
signature (PC #2951); Timothy Smith (PC #2952); Kelvin Carroll (PC #2953);
Kathie Blackburn (PC #2954); Zack Owens (PC #2955); Mike McGrath (PC
#2956); Britt Cormack (PC #2957); Karen DuVall (PC #2958); Natalie Granger
(PC #2959); Anna Meijer (PC #2960); Jessica Collado (PC #2961); Romit
Punnoose (PC #2962); Linda Ann John (PC #2963); Williams Suarez (PC
#2964); Marcel Streeter (PC #2965); Ron Yokley (PC #2966); Joshua Feliz (PC
#2967); Paris Logan (PC #2968); Indecipherable signature (PC #2969); Christine
Brabender (PC #2970); Indecipherable signature (PC #2971); Audrey Miller (PC
#2972); M.A. Nelson (PC #2973); John Paul Glover (PC #2974); Jay Pearsen
(PC #2975); LaQuisha Hall (PC #2976); Teresita Williams (PC #2977); Rosalyn
Lipp (PC #2978); Evelyn Williamson (PC #2979); Josh Hutter (PC #2980);
Carmille V. Sipp (PC #2981); Tom Ernsting (PC #2982); Keith Judge (PC
#2983); Lisa Mueller (PC #2984); Jan Helpmy (PC #2985); Kayla Haller (PC
#2986); Coonoor Behal (PC #2987); Indecipherable signature (PC #2988); Peter
Roche (PC #2989); Greg Janecka (PC #2990); Ana Morales (PC #2991); Jeremy
Lenzo (PC #2992); Erin Robinson (PC #2993); David Mitchell (PC #2994);
Angela Bradley (PC #2995); David Swanson (PC #2996); Robert Rudnicki (PC
#2997); Joshua Wilson (PC #2998); Catherine Keeling (PC #2999)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Joe Andenoro (PC #2900);Louise P. Smith (PC
#2901); Nathan Frazer (PC #2902); Dwight McIntyden (PC #2903); Meredith
Norris (PC #2904); Emily Pedersen (PC #2905); Francis B. Arthur (PC #2906);
Elizabeth Borys (PC #2907); Cameron Walker (PC #2908); Alyssa Swesso (PC
#2909); Dawn Sangsten (PC #2910); Adalberto Pastrana (PC #2911); Meryl
Meyer (PC #2912); Vernon Young (PC #2913); Kong Prasouk (PC #2914); Julia
Huff (PC #2915); Quentin Martain (PC #2916); Tara Wickey (PC #2917); Leah
Kempinski (PC #2918); Graham Stewart (PC #2919); Tom Skelton (PC #2920);
Jocelyn Watson (PC #2921); Tyler Bubenik (PC #2922); Frank Geary (PC
#2923); Vinvent Cuinngham (PC #2924); Stephanie Jackson (PC #2925);
Precious Allen (PC #2926); Rory Baird (PC #2927); Indecipherable signature
(PC #2928); Cazes (PC #2929); John Czukiewski (PC #2930); Vincent Mueller
(PC #2931); John Miller (PC #2932); Rodger Bell (PC #2933); Dominko Baric
(PC #2934); Erika Coleman (PC #2935); Jakki Harris (PC #2936); Michael
Garrett (PC #2937); L. Sutton (PC #2938); Daniel T.l Sutton (PC #2939); Paul
Downs (PC #2940); Alfredo Harris, Jr. (PC #2941); S. Varvooda (PC #2942);
Robert Mitchell (PC #2943); Anthony Monda (PC #2944); Indecipherable
signature (PC #2945); Melanie Kay (PC #2946); John Doninguez (PC #2947);
Timothy Beck (PC #2948); Vingieng (PC #2949)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Curtis Tate (PC #2850); Leticia Gamboa (PC
#2851); James Pilcher (PC #2852); Indecipherable signature (PC #2853); Hitesh
Aidasani (PC #2854); Tom Miner (PC #2855); Helen Albright (PC #2856); Peter
Albright (PC #2857); David L. Czuba (PC #2858); Ken Arnold (PC #2859);
Nancy Kiolbasa (PC #2860); Kindra Nelson (PC #2861); Tracy McCrillis (PC
#2862); Danielle Gerrior (PC #2863); Kurbanus Bernero (PC #2864);
Indecipherable signature (PC #2865); Loeb (PC #2866); Debbi Pardumlin (PC
#2867); Belen Magallanes (PC #2868); John Brewster (PC #2869); Betty Sayles
(PC #2870); Edith Harris Schturde (PC #2871); John Bickner (PC #2872);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Meredith Weston (PC #2873); Sana Qureshi (PC #2874); Soharb Qureshi (PC
#2875); Indecipherable signature (PC #2876); Michael Levine (PC #2877); W.M.
Meadow (PC #2878); Briwn Digale (PC #2879); Reginald Cornelious (PC
#2880); Deirdra Jordan (PC #2881); Sabrino Robinson (PC #2882); Doris Kontos
(PC #2883); Anthony Juggan (PC #2884); Ron Frederick (PC #2885); Christel
Schulz (PC #2886); Dennis A. Uai (PC #2887); David Nelson (PC #2888);
Colleen H. Bonamarie (PC #2889); Craig J. Cowan (PC #2890); Alex Demtoush
(PC #2891); Elizabeth Harmon (PC #2892); Ken Fisher (PC #2893); James
Bugielski (PC #2894); Willard M. Hunter (PC #2895); Maureen Serkel (PC
#2896); Joe Rytell (PC #2897); Susan Bird (PC #2898); T.P. Albright (PC
#2899)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Tom Shenberger (PC #2800); Steph Schoof (PC
#2801); Joanna Johnson (PC #2802); A. Paremta (PC #2803); The Johnson's (PC
#2804); Leah Kadden (PC #2805); Indecipherable signature (PC #2806); Rick
Bristol (PC #2807); Sean Cord (PC #2808); C. Kretschmer (PC #2809); Kathleen
Hallberg (PC #2810); C.A. Farr (PC #2811); Gene Kowaszewski (PC #2812);
Carleen Fuller (PC #2813); Indecipherable signature (PC #2814); Nancy W.
Rosenheim (PC #2815); Kathy Batton (PC #2816); Robert C. Joehler (PC
#2817); Mary Gambol Lane (PC #2818); Virginia M. Larson (PC #2819); Ryan
Sullivan (PC #2820); Brian Sampwy (PC #2821); Dennis Dalzo (PC #2822);
Leslie C. Kismartoni (PC #2823); Betty McLean (PC #2824); Michelle Jacobs
(PC #2825); Indecipherable signature (PC #2826); John Stallie (PC #2827); Corie
McIntyre (PC #2828); Darl White (PC #2829); Donna Kurtz (PC #2830); John
Kutsch (PC #2831); Terri Reece (PC #2832); Dani Flynn (PC #2833);
Indecipherable signature (PC #2834); Barbara Turley (PC #2835); John D. Kusta
(PC #2836); Stacey Roberts (PC #2837); Araceli Reyes (PC #2838); Veneta
Archer (PC #2839); Caroi Carta (PC #2840); Ramon Hoff (PC #2841); Chris
Jacobs (PC #2842); Catherine Slighton (PC #2843); John Brahm (PC #2844);
Indecipherable signature (PC #2845); Kerry GoForth (PC #2846); John Royski
(PC #2847); Nell McNamara (PC #2848); Paul Lenciori (PC #2849)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - David Marchiors (PC #2750); Sevina Peri (PC
#2751); T. McMahon (PC #2752); Nancy Flitcraft (PC #2753); Lisa Rosenthal
(PC #2754); Indecipherable signature (PC #2755); Nancy Halliday (PC #2756);
Indecipherable signature (PC #2757); Elsino Sullivan (PC #2758); Marina
Burman (PC #2759); Robert Gregg (PC #2760); Mary Munday (PC #2761);
Indecipherable signature (PC #2762); Bob Stamkus (PC #2763); Amy Ide (PC
#2764); Barbara Hill (PC #2765); Remco Dercksen (PC #2766); M.K. Jander
(PC #2767); Cliff Rallins (PC #2768); Lynn Lawson (PC #2769); Peter Clemson
(PC #2770); Indecipherable signature (PC #2771); Melissa Ionezli (PC #2772);
Lisa McCarthy (PC #2773); Jennifer Egen (PC #2774); Abigail B. Sivan (PC
#2775); Diane Christiansen (PC #2776); Janet Rogers (PC #2777);
Indecipherable signature (PC #2778); LaRue Highsmith (PC #2779); Jean A.
Anderson (PC #2780); Robert E. Mann (PC #2781); William Bassin (PC #1782);
Suzanne Robin (PC #2783); Mark Osadjan (PC #2784); Claire Igoe (PC #2785);
John Scott (PC #2786); Katherine Beck (PC #2787); Katherine Muller (PC
#2788); Dedre Gentner (PC #2789); Emilie Dowhan (PC #2790); Susan Wick
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC #2791); Indecipherable signature (PC #2792); Linda Brenner (PC #2793);
Mia A. Brass (PC #2794); Laura Smith (PC #2795); Deppen (PC #2796); Cathy
Hampton (PC #2797); Indecipherable signature (PC #2798); Alicia Smith (PC
#2799)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Chad Roach (PC #2700); John Preus (PC #2701);
Hattie Smith (PC #2702); Eleanor Guralnick (PC #2703); Daniel Schnitow (PC
#2704); Indecipherable signature (PC #2705); Robert Daniel (PC #2706); C.
Dittmer (PC #2707); Mike Gleissner (PC #2708); Tim Fraser (PC #2709); Fran
DuWaldl (PC #2710); Joe Bell (PC #2711); Ana Porter (PC #2712); Ben Smith
Donald (PC #2713); Hattie Smith (Indecipherable signature (PC #2714); James
P. Brobst (PC #2715); Craig Becter (PC #2716); karl Fogel (PC #2717);
Indeciperable signature (PC #2718); Moses Can Pelt (PC #2719); Stacey Kali
(PC #2720); Clem Balanoff (PC #2721); Peter Dorman (PC #2722); Chris Cook
(PC #2723); Kathy Lee (PC #2724);Sarah Doe Osborne (PC #2725); Christine
Marriott (PC #2726); Marsaura Shukla (PC #2727); Richard Hudson (PC #2728);
Joanne Stroud (PC #2729); David Oppenheim (PC #2730); F. Stellas (PC #2731);
Indecipherable signature (PC #2732); Lauren O'Hara (PC #2733); G. White (PC
#2734); Julie McMahon (PC #2735); Tom Durment (PC #2736); Michael Clarke
(PC #2737); Mary McCool (PC #2738); G. Tyrrell (PC #2739); Arthur Collins
(PC #2740); Eric Hille (PC #2741); John Zubrigg (PC #2742); Indecipherable
signature (PC #2743); Derek Fimmen (PC #2744); Dana Edelson (PC #2745);
Mark Potter (PC #2746); K. Leo (PC #2747); Celestina Raineri (PC #2748);
Jeffrey Meneke (PC #2749)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jason Miller (PC #2650); Wanda K. Goin (PC
#2651); Alan Giovacctini (PC #2652); Rivkah Gevinson (PC #2653); Steven
Ananasie, Jr. (PC #2654); Tommy Rivers (PC #2655); Randi Inman (PC #2656);
Frank Mitchell (PC #2657); Beth Eckerty (PC #2658); Nate Simmons (PC
#2659); Emily Zielke (PC #2660); Bruce Joleaud (PC #2661); Melissa Taylor
(PC #2662); Penny G. Hornbilomatis (PC #2663); Margie Jeffords (PC #2664);
Daniel Price (PC #2665); Kate Fitzgiboon (PC #2666); Sabrina Bennett (PC
#2667); Tony Murray (PC #2668); Max Volcral (PC #2699); Ingrid Rojas (PC
#2670); Andrew Denrewitz (PC #2671); Jena Powell (PC #2672); Rosario
Salgado (PC #2673); Saniyyah Hollingsworth (PC #2674); Marsha Allen (PC
#2675); John Jirasek (PC #2676); Margaret Kuss (PC #2677); Berenice Martinez
(PC #2678); Katie Norwell (PC #2679); Zachariah Rouse (PC #2680); Jermaine
Christmas (PC #2681); Lisa Tabor (PC #2682); Dolores M. Lopez (PC #2683);
Jafar Casarella (PC #2684); Nick Miklusak (PC #2685); Indecipherable signature
(PC #2686); Danielle Hamilton (PC #2687); Vivian E. Lande (PC #2688);
Natasha R. Lowe (PC #2689); Jason Eickmeyer (PC #2690); Tracy Williams (PC
#2691); E.H. Santiago (PC #2692); Jonas Boorland (PC #2693); Jet Twinn (PC
#2694); Martha Pomplin (PC #2695); Katrina L. Holland (PC #2696); Lukio
Taylor (PC #2697); Jerry Adams (PC #2698); Lynn Lenert (PC #2699)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Lidya Garcia (PC #2600); Hilary Michalak (PC
#2601); Barbara Schnitzer (PC #2602); Enn Hinchcliff (PC #2603); Allexis
Moretti (PC #2604); Kathleen McDonaugh (PC #2605); Larry D. Williamson
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC #2606); Brad Daugherty (PC #2607); April Krueger (PC #2608); Mary
Jenkins (PC #2609); Claudette Gentle (PC #2610); Aaron Byrne (PC #2611);
Michelle Weber (PC #2612); David Greatrix (PC #2613); Jill Greatrix (PC
#2614); Chip Berry (PC #2615); David Gill (PC #2616); Patrick Labadie (PC
#2617); Ann Higley (PC #2618); Mike Evans (PC #2619); Valerie Moore (PC
#2620); Courtney Melzer (PC #2621); Michele Holloway (PC #2622); Catherine
Banks (PC #2623); Denise Reed (PC #2624); Altagracie Carrasco (PC #2625);
Jacob Lingeman (PC #2626); Linsay Olesak (PC #2627); Indecipherable
signature (PC #2628); Ericka Peyton (PC #2629); J Markowshi (PC #2630);
Bridget Schrieber (PC #2631); Eugene Tobler (PC #2632); LaCherie Jordan (PC
#2633); Barbara Johnson (PC #2634); Qiping Mei (PC #2635); Tameca Robinson
(PC #2636); Gary AKins (PC #2637); Teffany Anderson (PC #2638); Mary
Murray (PC #2639); Alexander Polk (PC #2640); Dylan Walker (PC #2641);
Lisa Scott (PC #2642); Shirley Moriano (PC #2643); Elsy Garcia (PC #2644);
Teresa Morrow (PC #2645); Ana Maria Lopez (PC #2646); Sandra Gregg (PC
#2647); Christopher Strylken (PC #2648); Thurston Lewis (PC #2649)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Gorecki (PC #2,550); Nancy Berjansky (PC
#2551); Kim Diersen (PC #2552); Nancy Stone (PC #2553); Carrie Crane (PC
#2554); Dave Kosak (PC #2555); Mark Greenwald (PC #2556); R. Pat Sloan (PC
#2557); Halgorzata Schlotterbeck (PC #2558); Kara Kolman (PC #2559); Shirley
Berghorn (PC #2560); Vern Pearl (PC #2561); Scott Jenkins (PC #2562);
indecipherable signature (PC #2563); Aquiles Ransel (PC #2564); indecipherable
signature (PC #2565); Jack Herman (PC #2566); William Boskey (PC #2567);
Scott Hinricks (PC #2568); Don Garber (PC #2569); H. Jean Bryan (PC #2570);
Ashley Smith (PC #2571); Gunn T. Parks (PC 2572); Michael Weir (PC #2573);
Joan Smith (PC #2574); Jill White (PC #2575); Daniel Strauss (PC #2576);
James Moir (PC #2577); Nicholas Batsakis (PC #2578); Lisa Lundgren (PC
#2579); Allison Mueller (PC #2580); Lori Plump (PC #2581); Jay Adami (PC
#2582); indecipherable signature (PC 2583); Andrew Flanagan (PC 2584);
indecipherable signature (PC #2585); Lucy Furtson (PC #2586); Carolyn Keams-
Schuch (PC #2587); Dan Douglass (PC #2588); Tom Geiger (PC #2589); Deanna
Collins (PC #2590); Scott Schold (PC #2591); indecipherable signature (PC
#2592); Jeremy Stamp (PC #2593); Bob Bartlett (PC #2594); Jon Hart-Madsen
(PC #2595) Christopher Knutson (PC #2596); Audrey E. Mercer (PC # 2597);
Ron Beier (PC #2598); Charles Hightower (PC #2599)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG -Chris London (PC #2,500); Margaret Jones (PC
#2501); Angel Pu (PC #2502); indecipherable signature (PC #2503);
indecipherable signature (PC #2504); indecipherable signature (PC #2505);
Edward Muhammad (PC #2506); Andino (PC #2507); Barb Keactos (PC #2508);
Laura Roche (PC #2509); Shelly & Chris Bernard (PC #2510); Leesa Albert (PC
#2511); Dorian Byrd (PC #2512); Andrey Kuznetson (PC #2513); Mark Slouka
(PC #2514); Syl Saffold (PC #2515); C. Reiter (PC #2516); Christopher Barnard
(PC #2517); Steven Heyman (PC #2518); E. Louise Cole (PC #2519); Yola
Garate (PC #2520); indecipherable signature (PC #2521); Annette B. Barger (PC
#2522); indecipherable signature (PC #2523); Michelle Reschke (PC #2524); G.
Clark (PC #2525); J. Betts (PC #2526); Mel Furman (PC #2527); indecipherable
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
signature (PC #2528); Don Zeigler (PC #2529); Janelle Billings (PC #2530);
Loretta Sandberg (PC #2531); Arlene J. Wineman (PC #2532); indecipherable
signature (PC #2533); Michelle Beardsley (PC #2534); Sharon Kelley (PC
#2535); Kevin Schroeder (PC #2536); Dealmus Alums (PC # 2537); Latrina
Smith (PC #2538); Rena & Tom Field (PC #2539); R. & T. Flynn (PC #2540);
David Vander Weele (PC #2541); Catherine Augustine (PC #2542); Michael
Carr (PC #2543); Kimberly Cox (PC #2544); Cathy Mothershed (PC #2545);
Justin Lyman (PC #2546); Larry Luis (PC #2547); Carol Brewer (PC #2548);
John Brewer (PC #2549)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Dave DeSmedt (PC #2,450); Olga Steele (PC
#2,451); Ciera Martinez (PC #2,452); Terry Kammes (PC #2,453); Duinyon Potts
(PC #2,454); Brendon Gross (PC #2,455); Indecipherable Signature (PC #2,456);
Syed Ahgan (PC #2,457); Jessica Negrete (PC #2,458); Dewayne R. Jones (PC
#2,459); Michael R. Wilson (PC #2,460); Kelvin Chou (PC #2,461); Kate
Konalek (PC #2,462); Micahel Day (PC #2,463); Roy Suarez (PC #2,464); Victor
Bayenz (PC #2,465); Edward Anderson (PC #2,466); Bruce Chilns (PC #2,467);
Semjue Bell (PC #2,468); Ruth Young (PC #2,469); Nick Kanel (PC #2,470);
Bruce Nelson (PC #2,471); Bruce Hall (PC #2,472); Aaron Lee (PC #2,473);
Roshane Richards (PC #2,474); Jo Bernero (PC #2,475); Kate Puhala (PC
#2,476); Judy Catis (PC #2,477); Sharina Martin (PC #2,478); Mark Watson (PC
#2,479); Richard and Julie Triattucado (PC #2,480); Kevin Gadbois (PC #2,481);
Sharon Bittle (PC #2,482); Mary Margaret Olson (PC #2,483); David Johnson
(PC #2,484); Marcia Levy (PC #2,485); Nina Bremneour (PC #2,486); Kathleen
Stachnik (PC #2,487); Bianca Walter (PC #2,488); Bob Shuford (PC #2,489);
Margaret Myren (PC #2,490); Rodney S. Ruoff (PC #2,491); Lois Farley Stuford
(PC #2,492); Tully Bertoelli (PC #2,493); Jeff Rivera (PC #2,494);Della Aiken
(PC #2,495);Warren L. Howlett (PC #2,496); Sevan Loughran (PC #2,497);
Conall Walsh (PC #2,498);J. Barrett (PC #2,499)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Cameron Banks (PC #2,400); Maria Daniels (PC
#2,401); Raymlas Reynolds (PC #2,402); Molly Dengler (PC #2,403); Allison
Earl (PC #2,404); Felicity Vabulas (PC #2,405); Jacqueline Sanchez (PC
#2,406); Robert M. O'Keefe (PC #2,407); Hector Sariano (PC #2,408); Ernestine
Marshall (PC #2,409); Angela Warren (PC #2,410); David Eckerson (PC
#2,411); Iwian Lager (PC #2,412); Tracey Francis (PC #2,413); Johnny Moore
(PC #2,414); Ashley Mckiney (PC #2,415); Robert Walton (PC #2,416); Kevin
Fox (PC #2,417); Sandy Mikos (PC #2,418); Emily Toweer(PC #2,419);
Emanuel Thomas (PC #2,420); Nakima Sepulued (PC #2,421); Paul Wiggins (PC
#2,422); Lindsey Neltnor (PC #2,423); Sandra Davis (PC #2,424); Betty Fisher
(PC #2,425); Kristi Gninsten (PC #2,426); Hanna Clark (PC #2,427); Tara
Truesdale (PC #2,428); Christopher Boulanger (PC #2,429); Chris Wood (PC
#2,430); Shaun Kim (PC #2,431); Rashida Black (PC #2,432); Gabriel Halle (PC
#2,433); Xicotencatl Ramirez Ruiz (PC #2,434); Stephanie Woodson (PC
#2,436); Angel Thompson (PC #2,437); Karen Schwartz (PC #2,438); Latrica
Clark (PC #2,439); Peter Barnes (PC #2,440); Aneta Galary (PC #2,441); Omid
Ahmadi (PC #2,442); Sarah Zieger (PC #2,443); Dvorah Calamaro (PC #2,444);
Katherine McAndle (PC #2,445); Jose Guzman (PC #2,446); Ausberto Acevedo
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC #2,447); Eric Urbanski (PC #2,448); Geraldo Sangueson (PC #2,449);
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Indecipherable signature (PC #2,350); Jesse
Monestersky (PC 2351); E. Cole (PC 2352); Craig Sampson (PC 2353); Shannan
Wren (PC 2354); Amanda Warfield (PC 2355); Brenna Freskoz (PC 2356); Rick
Clemons (PC 2357); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2358); Jeanne Seidel (PC
2359); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2360); Jennifer Crotty (PC 2361); Nancy
Wick (PC 2362); Maria Callahan (PC 2363); T. Callahan (PC 2364); Romeal
Stephens (PC 2365); Cisi Latasha Godfrel (PC 2366); Lori Krieger (PC 2367)l
Ann McAveeney (PC 2368); Kierstent Todd Litzsinger (PC 2369); Geraldine
Dale (PC 2370); Cindy Levin (PC 2371); Lee Hirsch (PC 2372); Francisco Rada,
Jr. (PC 2373); Jeremy Janes (PC 2374); Ben Wright (PC 2375); Asim Raja (PC
2376); Jenin Musa (PC 2377); Faris Jafar (PC 2378); Alan Baker (PC 2379);
Jennifer Kong (PC 2380); Schan Fatel (PC 2381); Pansy Chung (PC 2382);
Cindy Cramer (PC 2383); Ning Wu (PC 2384); Natasha Karimova (PC 2385);
Adel Fadel (PC 2386); Carrie Willcutt (PC 2387); Colleen McAteer (PC 2388);
John Pirchen (PC 2389); Karen Schmid (PC 2390); Pat Eckerstrom (PC 2391);
Caitlin Moloney (PC 2392); Julie Stevenson (PC 2393); Debra Bermingham (PC
2394); R. Baldwin (PC 2395); Catherine Ahern (PC 2396); Larry McCotter (PC
2397); T.W. Coyce (PC 2398); Mary Andersen (PC 2399)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Ann & Peter Cope (PC #2,300); Marie Weglarz (PC
2301); Proachie Metlta (PC 2302); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2303);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 2304); Johnna Mosbarber (PC 2305); Joyce
Gravele-Bleier (PC 2306); Bruce Himmelblan(PC 2307); Hugh Morsh (PC
2308); Kathleen Warfield (PC 2309); C.W. Juhl (PC 2310); Cindy Edwards (PC
2311); Andrew R. Lotts (PC 2312); Beth Pestka (PC 2313); Auson Crockett (PC
2314); Roycelee J. Wood (PC 2315); Pierre Whittaker (PC 2316); Christine Hall
(PC 2317); G. Myles (PC 2318); Lauri Kamn (PC 2319); Art Dean (PC 2320);
Joe Resman (PC 2321); Cathy Resman (PC 2322); Joe Yagunic (PC 2323);
Tammie Schneiderman (PC 2324); Paul E. DiNardo (PC 2325); Barb Jennings
(PC 2326); Janet Stahl (PC 2327); Robert Forbes (PC 2328); N. Clifford (PC
2329); Kevin Eggedahl (PC 2330); Barb Gonti (PC 2331); Jiu Erickson (PC
2332); Diane Etienne (PC 2333); Jurga Nakovzi (PC 2334); Karen Brush (PC
2335); Peter Mayer (PC 2336); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2337); Fred P.
Walcott (PC 2338); Andrew Snarski (PC 2339); Julie Wolf (PC 2340); Larry
Turczynski (PC 2341); P. Dalin (PC 2342); Sherri Nachtshern (PC 2343);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 2344); Margaret Williams (PC 2345);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 2346); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2347);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 2348); Barbara Papp (PC 2349)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Aaron J. Slahor (PC #2,250); Henry Barnett (PC
2251); Terra Sevy (PC 2252); Kati Scronce (PC 2253); Rhea Tobler (PC 2254);
Justin Dawson (PC 2255); Juan J. Martinez (PC 2256); Erin Kovalsky (PC 2257);
Adrienne Burnett (PC 2258); Nadil Noorani (PC 2259); Hector Santiago (PC
2260); Daniel A. Heslin (PC 2261); Koji Michael (PC 2262); Juanita Thompson
(PC 2263); Jonte Jordan (PC 2264); Laura Fatemi (PC 2265); Mary Young (PC
2266); Michelle Benitez-Driewiecki (PC 2267); Ray Okoniewski (PC 2268);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Nate Heldman (PC 2269); Summer Manuma (PC 2270); Elizabeth Helmkamp
(PC 2271); Christen Steinkuller (PC 2272); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2273);
Maerinet Tsegay (PC 2274); Tamel Marshall (PC 2275); Lisa Ortiz (PC 2276);
Peyee Chen (PC 2277); Justin Maurer (PC 2278); Rosalyn Chambers (PC 2279);
Shannon Ryan (PC 2280); Patty Davis (PC 2281); Sinda Rosenberg (PC 2282);
Rachel Bussey (PC 2283); Chris Minell (PC 2284); Caitlin E. Murray (PC 2285);
Christine Sweigart (PC 2286); John Henry Smith (PC 2287); Aaron Williams
(PC 2288); Kate Polock (PC 2289); Jessica Huss (PC 2290); Indecipherable
Signature (PC 2291); Michael D. Ball (PC 2292); Matt Chambers (PC 2293);
Kelly Bristol (PC 2294); Jabin Chartrand (PC 2295); Kelsey Tate Steele Street
(PC 2296); Leah Rothschild (PC 2297); Barbara A. Elmore (PC 2298); Trishelle
Sutton (PC 2299)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Rebecca Asmussen (PC #2,200); Gina Butcher (PC
2201); Ellen Collar (PC 2202); Chris Crumlish (PC 2203); Halley Kepiro (PC
2204); Sagung Kertayuda (PC 2205); Leeshar Davis (PC 2206); Marletta Farmer
(PC 2207); Alexandra Becker (PC 2208); Timmy Jones (PC 2209); Susan
Murphy (PC 2210); Matthew Novak (PC 2211); Eric P. Anderson (PC 2212);
Kane Blusr (PC 2213); Zakieh McLaurin (PC 2214); Danielle Harrity (PC 2215);
Nina D. Sanchez (PC 2216); Sarah Baraba (PC 2217); Jada Bean (PC 2218);
Charlie Cabahar (PC 2219); Julia Kreger (PC 2220); Byron Samuel (PC 2221);
Arthurine Harris (PC 2222); Karen Gacgacao (PC 2223); Rianne Rothleder (PC
2224); Janita McElroy (PC 2225); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2226); Bristol
Huffmeon (PC 2227); Gregory T. Scott (PC 2228); Indecipherable Signature (PC
2229); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2230); Antonio Ingram (PC 2231); Anthony
Dapkus (PC 2232); Shauna Gardino (PC 2233); Jacob Sanders (PC 2234); Lucas
Kuejunas (PC 2235); Jennifer Black (PC 2236); Eric Christensen (PC 2237); C.
Wayne Dunlap (PC 2238); Louis Mark (PC 2239); Indecipherable Signature (PC
2240); John Leaf (PC 2241); Mary Anne Meyering (PC 2242); David Sigel (PC
2243); Michael Pierce (PC 2244); Juan P. Gvercio (PC 2245); Anthony Battle
(PC 2246); Teddy Yeh (PC 2247); Lindsay Rowland (PC 2248); Dan Faber (PC
2249);
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Yasmeen Musa (PC #2,150);Jason Steuber (PC
2151); Neemh Dosni (PC 2152); Tiffani Menck (PC 2153); Joel Marcus (PC
2154); John Krumen (PC 2155); Janelle Van Driel (PC 2156); Lindsay Noel (PC
2157); Pavel Ivanfchenko (PC 2158); Cortez Peterson (PC 2159); Phillip
Edwards (PC 2160); John Stolfo (PC 2161); Luis Cruzio (PC 2162); Fiora
Noorian (PC 2163); Rob Bondiman (PC 2164); John R. Keevers (PC 2165);
Sunny Singh (PC 2166); Angel Mendez (PC 2167); Indecipherable Signature (PC
2168); Ben Mintz (PC 2169); Ray Ortega (PC 2170); Charles Larimer (PC 2171);
H.H. Rodkin (PC 2172); Gerald Rizzer (PC 2173); Kathleen Barnett (PC 2174);
Adam Jones (PC 2175); C. Seibt (PC 2176); Deana Scharrer (PC 2177); Mary
Romano (PC 2178); Liz Szarek (PC 2179); Brien McNamara (PC 2180); Joel
Rund (PC 2181); Milton Gooelman (PC 2182); Gary Podolner (PC 2183); John
Cummane (PC 2184); Sandy Thomas (PC 2185); Tyler Ruttedge (PC 2186);
Michelle Bradly (2187); Jeff Shapiro (PC 2188); Donald Jacobs (PC 2189); Jim
Murnane (PC 2190); Pat King (PC 2191); Vijay Kavari (PC 2192); Tim Merrick
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC 2193); Mike Johnson (PC 2194); Hyun Jin Seo (PC 2195); B. Rosenberg (PC
2196); J.R. Hinshaw (PC 2197); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2198);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 2199)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jeff Minnis (PC #2,100); Sara Baldwin (PC 2101);
Undecipherable Signature (PC 2102); B. Wignot (PC 2103); Curran Arnold (PC
2104); Ginny Noble (PC 2105); G. Welke (PC 2106); Undecipherable Signature
(PC 2107); Joseph T. Dye (PC 2108); Debbi Gulson (PC 2109); Ashley Maentz
(PC 2110); S. Duttage (PC 2111); Rick Retzhager (PC 2112); David Tazzioli (PC
2113); Kate Bracher (PC 2114); Theresa Thacte (PC 2115); Undecipherable
Signature (PC 2116); Janna Nugent (PC 2117); Lori Romeo (PC 2118); Mike
Eckenrod (PC 2119); D. Irwin (PC 2120); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2121);
SR Burger (PC 2122); Annette Gravesen (PC 2123); Colin Slowik (PC 2124);
Paul Keller (PC 2125);Kim Samuel (PC 2126); Joanne Holmes (PC 2127); Mary
Amory (PC 2128); Jerry Hagman (PC 2129); John Horan (PC 2130); Reggie Von
Bergen (PC 2131); Rosemary C. McGraw (PC 2132); Mr. & Mrs. Robert
Krautsak (PC 2133); Donald Hemmingsen (PC 2134); John Tuman (PC 2135);
Juan M. Carranza (PC 2136); Dan Finch (2137); Penny Mesenbrink (PC 2138);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 2139); Lisa Valadez (PC 2140); Mary Mielko (PC
2141); Carl Jantzen (PC 2142); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2143);
Indecipherable Signature (PC 2144); Linda Ridley (PC 2145); Irene Levin (PC
2146); Indecipherable Signature (PC 2147); Helen Stein (PC 2148); Jeff Baleman
(PC 2149)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jane Jebavy (PC #2,050); Jane Jebavy (PC #2050);
Lisa Volini (PC #2051); Anthony C. Chereck (PC #2052); Dolores Bassett (PC
#2053); Jessica Leighton (PC #2054); Martha Wood (PC #2055); Stefanie Rolek
(PC #2056); Paul Vacenll (PC #2057); Sue Wicks (PC #2058); Cheryl Jackson
(PC #2059); Kim Burns (PC #2060); Carolyn & Ken Wright (PC #2061);
Richard Kucera (PC #2062); K. Blocker (PC 2063); Anne Bert (PC #2064);
Janice Kloss (PC #2065); Dawn Brown (PC #2066); Henry Briggs (PC #2067);
David Kuhn (PC #2068); Phyllis Ruiz (PC #2069); Judy Lazarus (PC #2070);
Carrie S. Masek (PC #2071); Paul Masek (PC #2072); Nick Trausch (PC #
2073); Stephanie Burke (PC #2074); Denise Brezak (PC #2075); Beth Pierson
(PC #2076); Barb O'Neill (PC 2077); Harold Brock (PC #2078); Kristin Ecklund
(PC #2079); Colleen Douglas (PC #2080); David Tornes (PC #2081); Ty
Foreman (PC #2082); Amy Jahr (PC #2083); Amy Zoger (PC #2084); Chris
Haacke (PC #2085); Ben T. Nelson (PC #2086); J.F. Stokes (PC #2087); Thomas
I. Rodhouse (PC #2088); Ellie Crouch Noltoli (PC #2089); Marbot Walters (PC
#2090); Robert Clifford (PC #2091); Blanche S. Hall (PC #2092); D. Banks (PC
#2093); Amy Malcolm (PC #2094); Deborah DeJean (PC #2095); Jane
McClenahan (PC #2096); Steve Erickson (PC #2097); Debra Zare (PC #2098);
Cindy White (PC # 2099)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Laren Dericius (PC #2,000); David Borman (PC
#2001); Isabel Crowder (PC #2002); Carl Weaver (PC #2003); Alan Steinos (PC
#2004); Carol Mellor (PC #2005); Kennie Cotton (PC #2006); Monica Wilson
(PC #2007); Dana Pipia (PC #2008); Rashida Baker (PC # 2009); Rita Jain (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
#2010); Debra D. Whitehead (PC #2011); Indecipherable Signature (PC #2012);
Lubomir Kubis (PC #2013); Sarah Peterson (PC #2014); Nathan Mosel (PC
#2015); Michelle Plaster (PC #2016); Jon Hill (PC #2017); Linda McPherson
(PC #2018); Santora Crawford (PC #2019); Josh Leaming (PC #2020); Alysha
Holland (PC #2021); Indecipherable Signature (PC #2022); Josh Brenger (PC
#2023); Indecipherable Signature (PC #2024); Tim Daly (PC #2025); Melissa
Lutz (PC #2026); Angela Razon(PC #2027); Eliza Wexelman (PC #2028);
Indecipherable Signature (PC #2029); Mark Woosley (PC #2030); Jessica
Maciejenski (PC #2031); Jimmy Hills (PC #2032); Bobby Epinger (PC #2033);
Janet Guido (PC #2034); Edwin Mackell (PC #2035); Christopher Murphy (PC
#2036); Jeff Jackson (PC #2037); Hans Bryant Salavaria (PC #2038); Acela
Martinez (PC #2039); Victoria Guzman (PC #2040); Rose Mui (PC # 2041);
David Phillips (PC #2042); Judi Inslay (PC #2043); Matthew Piedowski (PC
#2044); Indecipherable Signature (PC #2045); Arlene Mejorado (PC #2046);
Ryan Veach (PC #2047); Laura Andersen (PC #2048); Suzette Chandonnet (PC
#2049);
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Kevin J. Brown (PC #1,950); Paul Cherian (PC
#1,951); Yasmin Hilal (PC #1,952); Joanne Marengo (PC #1,953); Carsas E.
Jackson (PC #1,954); Marilyn Malick (PC #1,955); Brett Thurman (PC #1,956);
Travis Lowdes (PC #1,957); Samantha Gray (PC #1,958); Meg Koghin (PC
#1,959); Susan Redman (PC #1,960); Henry Hayes (PC #1,961); Debra Adelson
(PC #1,962); John Paul (PC #1,963); Will Jarvis (PC #1,964); Connie Tillman
(PC #1,965); Mike Ulreich (PC #1,966); Duncan Rogue (PC #1,967); Robert
Meltzer (PC #1,968); Kenneth Addison (PC #1,969); Loretta Jones (PC #1,970);
Paul Lachancer (PC #1,971); Tony Barrout (PC #1,972); Rosalie Defino (PC
#1,973); Alex Duchak (PC #1,974); Ashley Bloxton (PC #1,975); D.E. Yarnell
(PC #1,976); Hugh Amano (PC #1,977); John Thalheimer (PC #1,978); Forest
Cherven (PC #1,979); David Shalen (PC #1,980); Mark Lutz (PC #1,981);
Melissa Zater (PC #1,982); Kevin Bry (PC #1,983); Steve Albertson (PC
#1,984); Craig Steil (PC #1,985); Jin GGillespie (PC #1,986); Charlles Dubois
(PC #1,987); Eileen M. Walsh (PC #1,988); Adam Novak (PC #1,989); John
Robb (PC #1,990); Lester Davidson (PC #1,991); John Kempf (PC #1,992);
Melanie H.ach (PC #1,993); Stefanie Banis (PC #1,994); Norma G. Kanter (PC
#1,995); Kathryn Jonas (PC #1,996); Folasade Onataye (PC #1,997); Jonathan
Maldonado (PC #1,998); Mallory Bernstein (PC #1,999)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Elaine Lemieux (PC #1,900); D.J. Dwyer (PC
#1,901); Dawn Desecki (PC #1,902); Joe Fitzpatrick (PC #1,903); Mari Pineda
(PC #1,904); Matthew Bartry (PC #1,905); Torrie Bogda (PC #1,906);
Christopher Gibbs (PC #1,907); Jack Kent (PC #1,908); Curtis Vosh (PC
#1,909); R.A. Rusenstein (PC #1,910); Andrea Brown (PC #1,911); Stephanie
Tang (PC #1,912); Asma Iobal (PC #1,913); Susan J. Reid (PC #1,915); Timothy
Dietz (PC #1,916); Gene J. Smith (PC #1,917); Garmel Reiman (PC #1,918);
Michael Skorks (PC #1,919Suan Twamley (PC #1,920); ); Anna Felger (PC
#1,921); D.Sullivan (PC #1,922); Magdailene Para (PC #1,923); James Curtis
(PC #1,924); Roy Peabody (PC #1,925); Rinoula Litos (PC #1,926); Dermeth
Davis (PC #1,927); Keyanan Rodgers(PC #1,928); Sara Benal (PC #1,929); Anna
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Balla (PC #1,930); Keith Bacon (PC #1,931); Felicia Filbin (PC #1,932); J.L.
Johnson (PC #1,933); Zwan Huizen (PC #1,934); Harold Teasley (PC #1,935);
Michelle Yu (PC #1,936); Dewy Ferrgosen(PC #1,937); Ben Alagna (PC
#1,938); Julie Jones (PC #1,939); Amy Simmons (PC #1,940); Kris Smith (PC
#1,941); Eric Shakelford (PC #1,942); Michael Laswell (PC #1,943); Devon
Thomas (PC #1,944); Chinyera Moody (PC #1,945); Rafael Rodgers (PC
#1,946); J. Sandoval (PC #1,947); Caven Cocroft (PC #1,948); Jason Abbate (PC
#1,949)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Lori Keller (PC #1,850); Stephanie Baker (PC
#1851); Mary Ann Batts (PC #1852); Darlene Rosenstiehl (PC #1853); Virginia
Branley (PC #1854); Sherrod Williams (PC #1855); Nancy Haddad (PC #1856);
Stephan Vandenbrouche (PC #1857); Donna D. Lenfest (PC #1858);
Indecipherable signature (PC #1859); LaTonya Applewhite (PC #1860); Julie
Lenfest (PC #1861); Indecipherable signature (PC #1862); Ya-Feng Wang (PC
#1863); Mark Hunt (PC #1864); Marvin Gonzalez (PC #1865); Alecia Watkins
(PC #1866); George Brooks (PC #1867); Calvin Woodland (PC #1868); Emily
Twarog (PC #1869); Indecipherable signature (PC #1870); R. Wade (PC #1871);
Cheryl Evers (PC #1872); Nijma Esad (PC #1873); Justin Corpuz (PC #1874);
Don Allison, Jr. (PC #1875); Timothy Zepelak (PC #1876); Mary Armstrong (PC
#1877); Andy Rehberger (PC #1878); Znovan Castillo (PC #1879); Adrienne
Crosby (PC #1880); M. Tuazon (PC #1881); Vimal Soni (PC #1882); Leon
Jackson (PC #1883); Indecipherable signature (PC #1884); Kisha Jones (PC
#1885); Robert Davis (PC #1886); Kim Klyczek (PC #1887); Meredith Rentar
(PC #1888); Tyrone Day-Bookcer (PC #1889); Kelly Niekrease (PC #1890); Jeff
Rubel (PC #1891); Mary A. Grandpre (PC #1892); Erica M. Williams (PC
#1893); Jessica Price (PC #1894); Daniel George (PC #1895); Kelli L. Ward (PC
#1896); R. Bynum (PC #1897); Sarah Jorgenson (PC #1898); Sandra Duarte (PC
#1899)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Indecipherable signature (PC #1,800); Adam
Richmond (PC #1801); Alan Brown (PC #1802); Ashley Cherniawski (PC
#1803); Indecipherable signature (PC #1804); Jillian Cherniawski (PC #1805);
Amy Reitz (PC #1806); Nick Stephen (PC #1807); Yvonne E. Edwards (PC
#1808); Billing Jerry (PC #1809); Erica Steidl (PC #1810); Indecipherable
signature (PC #1811); Nathan Conroy (PC #1812); Semone Green (PC #1813);
Susan Hubbard (PC #1814); Indecipherable signature (PC #1815); Polly Hoover
(PC #1816); Nick Cole (PC #1817); Ben Loh (PC #1818); Indeciperable
signature (PC #1819); Florence Wohlgemoth (PC #1820); William B. Frenk (PC
#1821); Sandy Ryan (PC #1822); Indecipherable signature (PC #1823); Jinna Lee
(PC #1824); Indecipherable signature (PC #1825); Lou Mutty (PC #1826);
Jermaine Robinson (PC #1827); Indecipherable signature (PC #1828); Randall
Anderson (PC #1829); Lucy Bilaxer (PC #1830); J. White (PC #1831); E. Ko
(PC #1832); Zane Sheibley (PC #1833); Laura A. Soderberg (PC #1834); Susan
Nemcek (PC #1835); Edie Kantuack (PC #1836); Renee Klopsen (PC #1837);
Larry Macy (PC #1838); Kim Fogleseng (PC #1839); V. VanCrete (PC #1840);
Michelle Darbro (PC #1841); Kim Karazanjian (PC #1842); Tonja Davis (PC
#1843); Jennifer F. Higgins (PC #1844); Paul Gorbel (PC #1845); John
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Emmerson (PC #1846); Alesia Hollis (PC #1847); Frances Lovelace (PC #1848);
Elizabeth Pappalando (PC #1849)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Joan Kasdagly (PC #1,750); Indecipherable
signature (PC #1751); Dean Hassell (PC #1752); Daniel Fiorek (PC #1753);
Christine Connelly (PC #1754); Larry Leverett (PC #1755); Lori McClain (PC
#1756); Carolyn Davenport (PC #1757); Joanna Zak (PC #1758); Jen Moss (PC
#1759); B. Callier (PC #1760); Diana L. Jacobson (PC #1761); Indecipherable
signature (PC #1762); Audrej Tarlauiski (PC #1763); John Fawcett (PC #1764);
Lorclei Goldman (PC #1765); Michael Anderson (PC #1766); William Van
Buren (PC #1767); Darrell L. Dwyer (PC #1768); Kelly Drew (PC #1769);
Pamm Brown (PC #1770); Kevin Kemp (PC #1771); Taylor Hornung (PC
#1772); Dieter Klagge (PC #1773); Martin Morse (PC #1774); Steve Stuteman
(PC #1775); D. Davis (PC #1776); Yaw Boatang (PC #1777); C. Bolton (PC
#1778); Tara Noonan (PC #1779); Emmanuel Varquez Rivera (PC #1780); Pat
Lemkey (PC #1781); LuQuisha Willis (PC #1782); Amanda Babicz (PC #1783);
John Johnson (PC #1784); Spencer D. Bennett (PC #1785); Sarah Johnson (PC
#1786); Mary Welter (PC #1787); Tomas Esquire (PC #1788); Anthony Baldini
(PC #1789); Kathleen Baldini (PC #1790); Dominick Hart (PC #1791); Adrianna
Abruscato (PC #1792); James Galvin (PC #1793); Albert Anderson (PC #1794);
David Ball (PC#1795); Robert J. Westbrook (PC #1796); Sharon Roland (PC
#1797); Kiara Williams (PC #1798); Nathan Shaffer (PC #1799)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Denisse Montoya (PC #1,700); Jill Glass (PC
#1701); Julia Kogan (PC #1702); J. Gordon Sims (PC #1703); Guathemoc
Machuca (PC #1704); Zach Pierce (PC #1705); Devin Williams (PC #1706);
Danya Bader-Natal (PC #1707); Thea van Houten (PC #1708); Dorcas Joslin (PC
#1709); Rian O'Meara (PC #1710); Jeff Clayborne (PC #1711); Paul Carl Dinato
(PC #1712); Darryl Turnbow (PC #1713); Tania Campos (PC #1714); Maggie
Smith (PC #1715); Raphael Pryor (PC #1716); Clay Goodpastuer (PC #1717);
Indecipherable signature (PC #1718); Vanessa Cisneros (PC #1719); Sherry
Frigge (PC #1720); Rebecca Brown (PC #1721); Sierra Berquist (PC #1722);
Beth RedFearn (PC #1723); Lisa Engler (PC #1724); Sarah Hohschlag (PC
#1725); Richard Straub (PC #1726); Ms. Alfreda Calbert (PC #1727); Dawn &
Rebecca Bohanan (PC #1728); Bill S. Pieth (PC #1729); Julia Marvin (PC
#1730); Chris Houchens (PC #1731); Matthew Lynn (PC #1732); Mildred White
(PC #1733); Valerie Leathers (PC #1734); Tracy Jones (PC #1735);
Indecipherable signature (PC #1736); Melanie Stout (PC #1737); Clifton
Henderson (PC #1738); Edmond Goehring (PC #1739); Mavpard (PC #1740);
Ken Ewing (PC #1741); Yzlixa Garcia (PC #1742); Doug Phillips (PC #1743);
Gerald Miller (PC #1744); Lucio Moreno Jr. (PC #1745); Minchul Choi (PC
#1746); Maggie Ness (PC #1747); Jonathan Zirkle (PC #1748); J.F. Grochot (PC
#1749)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Lillian Pontius-Goldblatt (PC #1,650); Angel K.
Young (PC #1651); Nicholas Crotlon (PC #1652); Edwin Santiago (PC #1653);
Linsey Burritt (PC #1654); Indechiperable signature (PC #1655); L. Derrington
(PC #1656); Josh VanLare (PC #1657); Nichole DeKeuster (PC #1658); Tracey
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Keyes (PC #1659); Indecipherable signature (PC #1660); Cecily Swanson (PC
#1661); John Zeigler (PC #1662); Sam Young (PC #1663); Shenita Ollie (PC
#1664); D. Hill-Kelly (PC #1665); Twana Holloway (PC #1666); Lynetta Brent
(PC #1667); Caroline Oczachowski (PC #1668); Indecipherable signature (PC
#1669); Donnie Ramirez (PC #1670); John Hester (PC #1671); Laura McDougal
(PC #1672); Kirk Irwin (PC #1673); Tony Darnal (PC #1674); David Mullins
(PC #1675); John Stafford (PC #1676); Tracy Johnson (PC #1677); Frederick
Bodem (PC #1678); Daniel Ross-Jones (PC #1679); Brian Cameron (PC #1680);
Keith Hendrix (PC #1681); Latrice Loyd (PC #1682); William A. Cripe (PC
#1683); Caroline Farrow (PC #1684); Marlo Amorese (PC #1685); Whitney
Trumble (PC #1686); Tyrone Harper (PC #1687); Daniel Gordillo Jimenes (PC
#1688); Diane Perkins (PC #1689); Sabrina Bellamy (PC #1690); Mark
Tomkinson (PC #1691); Joesph Camillo (PC #1692); Jacqueline Malcome (PC
#1693); Casa Goldman (PC #1694); Sylvain Baptiste (PC #1695); Bobbie J.
Edward (PC #1696); Stanley Liu (PC #1697); Michelle Akins (PC #1698);
Maxmilian Tolbert (PC #1699)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Bryan Taylor (PC #1,600); Sr. Ryan L. Pelletire
(PC #1601); Tremon Williams (PC #1602); Kevin Banks (PC #1603); Cary D.
Tucker (PC #1604); Keith Thompson (PC #1605); Angelo T. Stath (PC #1606);
Eboni McLean (PC #1607); Michelle Williams (PC #1608); C. Neuman (PC
#1609); Mitch Pollak (PC #1610); Pamela Vogan (PC #1611); Desmond
Williams (PC #1612); Jenny Vogan (PC #1613); Vicky Cundari (PC #1614);
Daniel Gabala (PC #1615); Paul Robinson (PC #1616); Jeanette Benson (PC
#1617); Linda S. Millet (PC #1618); Arlene Williams (PC #1619); Marci
LacLean (PC #1620); Loren Ditzlet (PC #1621); Sean Barnett (PC #1622); Beth
Lecias (PC #1623); James Taylor (PC #1624); Indecipherable signature (PC
#1625); Indecipherable signature (PC #1626); Erin Johnston (PC #1627); Carrie
Tucker (PC #1628); Helesa Agner (PC #1629); Emelie Dorberg (PC #1630);
Lotta Wrede (PC #1631); Katherine Kleese (PC #1632); Fernando Galindo (PC
#1633); Ryan Coates (PC #1634); Timothy M. Igg (PC #1635); Melissa Moz (PC
#1636); Alis Wa (PC #1637); Julie Nelson (PC #1638); Luke Brookner (PC
#1639); David M. Darnell (PC #1640); Colin Heckman (PC #1641); Don Jackson
(PC #1642); Candice Galarza (PC #1643); Kristen Taylor (PC #1644); Quinton
Allen (PC #1645); Gina Davis (PC #1646); Molly Stack (PC #1647);
Indechiperable signature (PC #1648); Helen Smith (PC #1649)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Mark Suillvan (PC #1,550); Jennifer Koncel (PC
#1551); Lindsey Faloona (PC #1552); Jenny Liu (PC #1553); Jackie Devereaux
(PC #1554); Samantha Levine (PC #1555); Roman Rubio (PC #1556); Lisa
Katusin (PC #1557); Devin Schraff (PC #1558); Pat Smith (PC #1559); Marcus
MdInnis (PC #1560); Lauren Lowenstein (PC #1561); Lisa Gilbert (PC #1562);
Judith Dieterle (PC #1563); Aimee Charest (PC #1564); S. Simon (PC #1565);
Latisha Calhoun (PC #1566); Tom Sistler (PC #1567); Janet Schrader (PC
#1568); indecipherable signature (PC #1569); Serge Enk (PC #1570); Kerri
Hatcher (PC #1571); TOM JAREMBA (PC #1572); Katie Henry (PC #1573);
Sergey Segal (PC #1574); Aman Kaur (PC #1575); David Hutchinson (PC
#1576); John Thompson (PC #1577); Susan Richman (PC #1578); Diana Cannett
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
(PC #1579); Laurel B. Mortz (PC #1580); M. Salomon (PC #1581); Dennis
Jamison (PC #1582); Jason Jones (PC #1583); Michael L. Williams (PC #1584);
Amanda Day (PC #1585); Esther Leonard (PC #1586); Cary Jones (PC #1587);
Tehilla Newman (PC #1588); Kelly Kowal (PC #1589); William Lencot (PC
#1590); Hugo F. Zambrano (PC #1591); Iam DeLaRosa (PC #1592); D. J.
Condon (PC #1593); Ruth Vittenson (PC #1594); Cara Kuball (PC #1595);
Rebeca Full (PC #1596); Susan Baker (PC #1597); Patricia J. Smith (PC #1598);
Robert Ray (PC #1599)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Amy Kaufman (PC #1,500); indecipherable
signature (PC #1501); Clara Matignon (PC #1502); Robert Buckman (PCB
#1503); Aruna Khilanani (PC #1504); Elisa A. Juarez (PC #1505); David Smock
(PC #1506); Morgan Andrews (PC #1507); Mark Frazier (PC #1508); Kevin
Millar (PC #1509); Edward L. Follins (PC #1510); Debra L. Rogers (PC #1511);
Dann Smith (PC #1512); Chris Barrett (PC #1513); Corde Rumsden (PC #1514);
Humberto Velasco (PC #1515); C. Becker (PC #1516); Sara Templeton (PC
#1517); Melinda Muto (PC #1518); Dan Rutkanski (PC #1519); indecipherable
signature (PC #1520); Charles Gray (PC #1521); Harold Mitchell (PC #1522);
Gary Scott (PC #1523); Aminah James (PC #1524); Johnny Hampton (PC
#1525); Mark A. Krowiak (PC #1526); Jim Jervis (PC #1527); Christine Roy (PC
#1528); Jennifer Vera (PC #1529); Liam Singer (PC #1530); Megan McDermott
(PC #1531); Nelso Liang (PC #1532); indecipherable signature (PC #1533); Karl
D'Silla (PC #1534); indecipherable signature (PC #1535); Danielle Latarski (PC
#1536); Arin Bass (PC #1537); Candace Nunez (PC #1538); David Hoffman (PC
#1539); Wyvonia Pickett (PC #1540); Jamie Caligan (PC #1541); Ali Jennings
(PC #1542); Charlotte F. Lynch (PC #1543); Cara Gutstein (PC #1544); Shanli
A. Stead (PC #1545); indecipherable signature (PC #1546); Tim Love (PC
#1547); Krissy Shields (PC #1548); John Paul McMcGreal (PC #1549)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Brad Cue (PC #1,450); Paul Satzinger (PC #1,451);
Joan Daugherty (PC #1,453); Norma Hoza (PC #1,454); Barbara Jackson (PC
#1,455); Lacey Connelly (PC #1,456); Val and Andrw Stewart (PC #1,457);
BerniceTynns (PC #1,458); Robert Levy (PC #1,459); Kathleen Rwilrs (PC
#1,460); Don Brown (PC #1,461); Claudia Pineds (PC #1,462); Rocio Santos (PC
#1,463); Elliotte Ewane Ward (PC #1,464); Aaron M. Stoner (PC #1,465); Eric
Golden (PC #1,466); Kathi S. Gant (PC #1,467); Nepthali Mullings (PC #1,468);
Ernesto Abonce (PC #1,469); Liliana Martinez (PC #1,470); Shirley Bryant (PC
#1,471); Curtis Evans (PC #1,472); Lily Cigan (PC #1,473); C. Follmar (PC
#1,474); Alex Murton (PC #1,475); Jason T. Conzemius (PC #1,476); Marsha
Montroy (PC #1,477); Sarah Charipe (PC #1,478); Eric Swanson (PC #1,479);
Chas Kelley (PC #1,480); Sara Mattick (PC #1,481); Richard W. Mattick (PC
#1,482); Jane Fish (PC #1,483); Sarah Giunchedi (PC #1,484); Burnham
Cantooline (PC #1,485); Janice Klear (PC #1,486); Oksana Keaton (PC #1,487);
Tim Lee (PC #1,488); Alex Renko (PC #1,489); Jo Ann Breuisler (PC #1,490);
Geshi Gumarebern (PC #1,491); James E. Ridell (PC #1,492); Ivy White (PC
#1,493); Laura Staton (PC #1,494); Colin Woodrow (PC #1,495); Chakisha S.
Anderson (PC #1,496); Anthony Hicks (PC #1,497); Issiah Duncan (PC #1,498);
Elijah Oliver (PC #1,499)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Adam Cunningham (PC #1,400); Richard Warner
(PC #1,401); Victor Garces (PC #1,402); Lilian Ose (PC #1,403); Marie LeBihan
(PC #1,404); Stuart McDermott (PC #1,405); Hylene Dublin (PC #1,406); Kathy
Gossard (PC #1,407); Jennifer E. Gervasio (PC #1,408); Erin Healy (PC #1,409);
Deniez Klatt (PC #1,410); Micahel Powers (PC #1,411); Cindy Fey (PC #1,412);
Fuson Guder (PC #1,413); Florence Kranz (PC #1,414); Bob Fattore (PC
#1,415); Christopher Claeys (PC #1,416); Carol Jost (PC #1,417); Ron LaLa (PC
#1,418); Agnes McHugh (PC #1,419); Robert S. McVeigh (PC #1,420); Dorothy
Sugrue (PC #1,421); Mary Cornille (PC #1,422); Robert McMahon (PC #1,423);
Kelly Norris (PC #1,424); Jan Jacobson (PC #1,425); Glen Luenshaw (PC
#1,426); Bruce Purkitz (PC #1,427); Harry Kampert (PC #1,428); Lori Osborne
(PC #1,429); Steve Johnson (PC #1,430); Carol Johnson (PC #1,431); Catherine
Nagher (PC #1,432); Tina Bartholomew (PC #1,433); Jack Cooksey (PC #1,434);
Sue Thompson (PC #1,435); Karen Larson (PC #1,436); Jim Skelton (PC
#1,437); Bob Brown (PC #1,438); Catherine Evans (PC #1,439); Heidi Hoppe
(PC #1,440); Bill and Sara Race(PC #1,441); Daniel Fisher (PC #1,442); Lee
Brodne (PC #1,443); Jill Selden (PC #1,444); James Shaeffer (PC #1,445); Julie
Bordo (PC #1,446); Carey Goldenberg (PC #1,447); Jennifer Vinglenis (PC
#1,448); Maria Liccardo (PC #1,449)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Smithe (PC #1,350); Joe Cooper, III (PC #1351);
Sanford McLaughlin (PC #1352); Michelle Cianc (PC #1353); Richard Morgan
(PC #1354); Sarah MacDonald (PC #1355); Ed Reardon (PC #1356); Adam
Fried (PC #1357); Anthony Meuman (PC #1358); Lauren Vallone (PC #1359);
Travis Clanton (PC #1360); Molly Clore (PC #1361); Ian McGrath (PC #1362);
Sigurd Midelfort (PC #1363); Jan Peterson (PC #1364); Drew Hampton (PC
#1365); Lori Petter (PC #1366); Katyana Terrell (PC #1367); Indechiperable
signature (PC #1368); Kevin Fahey (PC #1369); Jeff Frendt (PC #1370); Nichole
Peck (PC #1371); Rasheda Smith (PC #1372); F.C. Wiser (PC #1373); Ad Hall
(PC #1374); Matthew Samuel (PC #1375); Kate Barthel (PC #1376);
Indechiperable signature (PC #1377); Lauren Johnson (PC #1378); Alia Youdell
(PC #1379); David Richards (PC #1380); Indechiperable signature (PC #1381);
Hanny Pei (PC #1382); Daphne O. Regan (PC #1383); Dave Chen (PC #1384);
Scott Cataffa (PC #1385); Jane Angharad (PC #1386); Diego A. Arias (PC
#1387); Elena Ortiz (PC #1388); Indechiperable signature (PC #1389); Carly M.
Morrison (PC #1390); Jeff Kemnitz (PC #1391); Ron Johnson #1392); Janet
Villanueva (PC #1393); Dana Villanova (PC #1394); Dana Lucas (PC #1395);
Nick Calpi (PC #1396); Bradley Labree (PC #1397); T.C. Dumont (PC #1398);
Anne K. Jonnemacher (PC #1399)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Adam Seth Doneson (PC 1300); Steve Levitas (PC
1301); Barbara DeCoster (PC 1302); Courtney Lyons (PC 1303); Mick Vaught
(PC 1304); John Vaught (PC 1305); Anne Marie Williams (PC 1306); Winfred
Hill (PC 1307); Claire Skinner (PC 1308); Alice Rebeutini (PC 1309); Janet
Freise (PC 1310); Dylan Laurino (PC 1311); Indechiperable signature (PC 1312);
Joseph Simpson (PC 1313); Ken Fudala (PC 1314); Terrie Winkates (PC 1315);
Kevin Stanbery (PC 1316); Indechiperable signature (PC 1317); Marie Gogburn
(PC 1318); Rich & Maria Postlethwait (PC 1319); Jon Gasser (PC 1320);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Charlotte Garvey (PC 1321); Corinne H. Hamill (PC 1322); Wellensick (PC
1323); Lorena S. Neal (PC 1324); Weiss Valerie (PC 1325); Costello Nora
(1326); Roberta Friedman (PC 1327); E. Barbel (PC 1328); Richard S. Huszagh
(PC 1329); David Ferster (PC 1330); Meg McGuinness (PC 1331); Leon Ikler
(PC 1332); Karen Wallisky (PC 1333); Femi Odere (PC 1334); Elizabeth Cline
(PC 1335); Angela Pierce (PC 1336); B. Salomon (PC 1337); Mike Buck (PC
1338); Richard Locko (PC 1339); Terence Barthel (PC 1340); Indechiperable
signature (PC 1341); Indechiperable signature (PC 1342); Michaela Stonler (PC
1343); S. Bort (PC 1344); Renee Joster (PC 1345); Dustin Oudin (PC 1346);
Nevs Nadal Pasqual (PC 1347); Carolina Carado (PC 1348); Joylin Roberson
(PC 1349)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Sue Stolzer (PC #1,250); Marilyn Morel (PC
#1,251); Kathy Callahan (PC #1,252); James Spengler (PC #1,253); Susan
Spengler (PC #1,254); Eileen Schutte (PC #1,255); Danielle Young (PC #1,256);
Catherine M. Duebe (PC #1,257); Lynn Ballard (PC #1,258); Patrick Page (PC
#1,259); Steve Frank (PC #1,260); C. Gatt (PC #1,261); Lisa Berghoff (PC
#1,262); Maria Rivera (PC #1,263); Indecipherable signature (PC #1,264); Brett
Sher (PC #1,265); Kathy Murrey (PC #1,266); Margaret Martin-Heaton (PC
#1,267); Diane Fisher (PC #1,268); Ruthmany Gopal (PC #1,269); Ken Karisa
(PC #1,270); Pat O'Neil (PC #1,271); S. Faucett (PC #1,272); Rishmo Merchant
(PC #1,273); Jason Hall (PC #1,274); Jason Andreoli (PC #1,275); Michael Sax
(PC #1,276); John Mansfield (PC #1,277); J. Fishmon (PC #1,278); June Irwin
(PC #1,279); Jim O'Connell (PC #1,280); Madelyn Townsley (PC #1,281); Jim
Kalas (PC #1,282); Michael Bedzyk (PC #1,283); Richard Rioux (PC #1,284);
Sheila Bressler (PC #1,285); William Monter (PC #1,286); Jim Griffin (PC
#1,287); Wendy Fessler (PC #1,288); John A. Favorite (PC #1,289); Everett
Devore (PC #1,290); Monica Frane (PC #1,291); Paul Shadle (PC #1,292); Haley
Pollack (PC #1,293); Indechiperable signature (PC #1,294); Sadie Woolridge (PC
#1,295); Indechiperable signature (PC #1,296); Kerna Ward (PC #1,297); Jessica
Stabosz (PC #1,298); Ian Hosack (PC #1,299)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Patricia A. Budin (PC #1,200); Rosemary
Shellander (PC #1,201); Henk Vanderlinde (PC #1,202); Fay Michaelis (PC
#1,203); Judith O. Royal (PC #1,204); Robin LaBedz (PC #1,205); Joyce Marks
(PC #1,206); Indechiperable signature (PC #1,207); Richard Muhammad (PC
#1,208); Samuel Peter McDermott (PC #1,209); Catharine T. Boykin (PC
#1,210); Nancy Duel (PC #1,211); D.M. Ridge (PC #1,212); Andrew Nawrocki
(PC #1,213); Jean Vanderlinde (PC #1,214); Sandi Carr (PC #1,215); Dorothy K.
Howard (PC #1,216); Robert Callahan (PC #1,217); Susan Martin (PC #1,218);
Cyndi Duda (PC #1,219); B. Wu (PC #1,220); Margaret AuBuchan (PC #1,221);
John Banks (PC #1,222); Indechiperable signature (PC #1,223); Diane Clarke
(PC #1,224); Eric Smolensky (PC #1,225); Mojgan Bowers (PC #1,226); J.
Brunner (PC #1,227); Beth A. Spallone (PC #1,228); Shannon McLone (PC
#1,229); Alex Mysko (PC #1,230); Bernard Ford (PC #1,231); Dennis Clarkson
(PC #1,232); Tonise Paul (PC #1,233); Justin (PC #1,234); Beth Bolger (PC
#1,235); Paige Lunde (PC #1,236); Katie Markey (PC #1,237); Lisa Panozzo (PC
#1,238); Donna Nong (PC #1,239); Michael D. Robertson (PC #1,240); James E.
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Smith (PC #1,241); Renee Poston (PC #1,242); Randy Ruch (PC #1,243); Appi
Preusen (PC #1,244); Mark Douce (PC #1,245); Georgiann Bylinski (PC
#1,246); Lynn Rymarz (PC #1,247); Brian Herner (PC #1,248); Nancy Wedow
(PC #1,249)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Samantha Bruzan (PC #1,150); Willie J. Armwood
(PC #1,151); Alexandre M. de Almeida (PC #1,152); Kathleen Sherrill (PC
#1,153); Miguel Chavez (PC #1,154); Deborah Lynch (PC #1,155); Monique
Heller (PC #1,156); Debra Chalus (PC #1,157); Brandon Zale (PC #1,158);
Jonathan Santano (PC #1,159); Aasia Mohammad (PC #1,160); Patricia
Cunningham (PC #1,161); Melissa Barnhart (PC #1,162); Colin Montgomery
(PC #1,163); Joshua Amagum (PC #1,164); Gregory Lamb (PC #1,165); Thomas
Garsano (PC #1,166); Maribel Rodriguez (PC #,167); Christine Coleman (PC
#1,168); Sarah Beckman (PC #1,169); Helene Kaye (PC #1,170); Josette Coupet
(PC #1,171); Indecipherable signature (PC #1,172); Lara Jenson (PC #1,173);
Rebecca Liu (PC #1,174); Jackie Fenn (PC #1,175); Elizabeth Cleary (PC
#1,176); Quentin Bracey (PC #1,177); Terrell Gatlings (PC #1,178); Annabelle
Werling (PC #1,179); Joured Desecki (PC #1,180); Osuntoka Smith (PC #1,181);
Heather Afra (PC #1,182); Joseph Wendell (PC #1,183); Tinesha Jackson (PC
#1,184); Jeremy Clingerman (PC #1,185); Fuchi Shah (PC #1,86); Indecipherable
signature (PC #1,187); Eric Arpin (PC #1,188); Alexandra Bevan (PC #1,189);
Manar Albaroudi (PC #1,190); Marie Colon (PC #1,191); Ben Mendoza (PC
#1,192); David Stelk (PC #1,193); James B. Drew (PC #1,194); Dan Nugent (PC
#1,195); Darell Bames, Jr. (PC #1,196); Patricia Bell (PC #1,197); Jerard
billingsley (PC #1,198); Tehama Lopez (PC #1,199)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jacob A. Lute (PC #1,100); Elizabeth & Aaron
Rosinski (PC #1,101); Betty Akins (PC #1,102); Karla Martin (PC #1,103); Erick
Lacey (PC #1,104); Sylvester Brown (PC #1,105); Marina Palmer (PC #1,106);
Keith Pruitt (PC #1,107); Kenneth Palmer (PC #1,108); Lorenzo Di Pace (PC
#1,109); Julio Moran (PC #1,110); Elmer Villegas (PC #1,111); Natalina L.
Oliverio (PC #1,112); Gene Duncan (PC #1,113); Liz Spray (PC #1,114); Anne
Rorimer (PC #1,115); Tracy M. Ware (PC #1,116); Bryan DiLoreta (PC #1,117);
Mack Curtis (PC #1,118); Kevin Karl Peterson (PC #1,119); Rajani Guflavalleti
(PC #1,120); Mohamed Shadded (PC #1,121); Shalonda Gay (PC #1,122); Lessie
Allen (PC #1,123); Nick Broste (PC #1,124); Aurora Salustro (PC #1,125);
Travey Pine (PC #1,125); Citlali Diaz (PC #1,127); Tiffany E. Jones (PC
#1,128); Loren Connell (PC #1,129); Indechiperable signature (PC #1,130); Joe
Catone (PC #1,131); Sylvia Hunter (PC #1,132); Maggie Daly (PC #1,133);
Javier Prieto (PC #1,134); Nicholas Green (PC #1,135); Jerome Body (PC
#1,136); Patrick Mulcahy (PC #1,137); Katja Grosch (PC #1,138); Michael
Waterbrook (PC #1,139); Valerie Sanchez (PC #1,140); Beth Ottariani (PC
#1,141); Robin Miller (PC #1,142); James H. Carter (PC #1,143); Conail Walsh
(PC #1,144); Gilles Jones (PC #1,145); Andre McDearmon, Jr. (PC #1,146);
Benjamin Baker (PC #1,147); Glen Cunningham (PC #1,148); LeRoy Gordon
(PC #1,149)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Dave Arden (PC #1,050); John W. Schmarje (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
#1051); Laura A. Hayes (PC #1052); Sandi Glazebrook (PC #1053); Sara Reina
(PC #1054); Jack Pinto (PC #1055); Jill Pinto (PC #1056); Mark
Licmodziejewski (PC #1057); Sydney Rich (PC #1058); Aaron Muhs (PC
#1059); McCauley (PC #1060); Karin Richter (PC #1061); Martha Mayne (PC
#1062); Judith Sriamon (PC #1063); Alma Stealman (PC #1064); Marie Stureis
(PC #1065); Bret James (PC #1066); Tim McQuillen (PC #1067); Marie
McBride (PC #1068); Michael Cweehon (PC #1069); Rachel Prince (PC #1070);
Erin Huizenga (PC #1071); Brian Holtz (PC #1072); Michael Dubenski (PC
#1073); William McGowen (PC #1074); Javier Lopez (PC #1075); Tim Ashin
(PC #1076); David Boddiger (PC #1077); Sean Dacocman (PC #1078); Jin
Dokko (PC #1079); Violit Slain (PC #1080); Zachary Lopez (PC #1081);Robert
Rodemeyer (PC #1082); Chad Gearig (PC #1083); Jerrel Thomas (PC #1084);
Ruth Keken (PC #1085); Amanda Ginn (PC #1086); Daniel White (PC #1087);
Ben Thullen (PC #1088); Fred Leise (PC #1089); Phyllis Hall (PC #1090); Diane
Garvey (PC #1091); Reid Hyams (PC #1092); Ed Peeh (PC #1093); Eugene
Minon (PC #1094); Elizabeth Hoeppel (PC #1095); Diane Ansl (PC #1096);
Mollie K. Dixon (PC #1097); Eiren Caffall (PC #1098); Ann Snyder (PC #1099)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Indecipherable signature (PC #1,000); M. Ludwig
(PC #1001); Dale Wiegman (PC #1002); Julie Magak (PC #1003);Barb Keeling
(PC #1004); Dawn M. Acker (PC #1005); Sandra James (PC #1006); Sandra
Easterline (PC #1007); Ron Erickson (PC #1008); Martin Kvapk (PC #1009);
Paula Jones (PC #1010); Meg Carlson (PC #1011);Michael Lubin (PC #1012);
Ann Hartmann (PC #1013); Isaacson (PC #1014); Kim Kline (PC #1015); Jarod
Kimble (PC #1016); Isaac J. Hedtke (PC #1017); Shawna Bruchert (PC #1018);
Mack Heichman (PC #1019); Ian Scott (PC #1020); Joe Ferrara (PC #1021);
Wilfred Weidler (PC #1022); David Wealwip (PC #1023); Claudia Butterworth
(PC #1024); Shaunessy Kerr (PC #1025); Jennifer Defily (PC #1026); Thonmas
Pickens (PC #1027);Deonn Bartolini (PC #1028); James Altman (PC #1029);
Allan Jay P. Saludo (PC #1030); Monica Koehn (PC #1031); Christy Knill (PC
#1032); Mr. & Mrs. Troutman (PC #1033); MillieC. Lumpkin (PC #1034); Mark
Carter (PC #1035); David Fulghan (PC #1036); Deborah Young (PC #1037);
Cickie Bradley (PC #1038); Alba Blondis (PC #1039); Jeff Courter (PC #1040);
Kathy Dickson (PC #1041); Vivain Zimmerman (PC #1042); Mary Zerhel (PC
#1043); Jack Peterson (PC #1044); Andrew Mine (PC #1045); Sheila Brewer (PC
#1046); Katie Rolla (PC #1047); Edward McClelland (PC #1048); Louise Tigers
(PC #1049)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Bob Wolkoff (PC #950); Jack Gedgi (PC #951);
Jim Janetzko (PC #952); Gary Poole (PC #953); Bill O'Donnell (PC #954); David
Shaw (PC #955); L.M. Overend (PC #956); Don Gibbs (PC #957); Christine
Kunz (PC #958); Cynthia Greco (PC #959); Jerry S. Kriman (PC #960); Robert
Harvey (PC #961); S. Nykaza (PC #962); Muriel M. Cohen (PC #963); Diane
Mues (PC #964); Robert Quinn (PC #965); Jan Scott (PC #966); Colleen Gibbs
(PC #967); Masami Takagaki (PC #968); Jeanne Freeman (PC #969); Carol Liu
(PC #970); Katherine F. Donnelly (PC #971); Scott Paul (PC #972); Rita
Bartolone (PC #973); Meg Carroll (PC #974); Catherine Mays (PC #975); T.E.
Bauman (PC #976); Dorothy W. Smith (PC #977); Alison Rodes (PC #978);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Susan Lieberman (PC #979); John F. Randstrom (PC #980); Dan Hoalund (PC
#981); Peg Duros (PC #982); James Slater (PC #983); Jody & Bob McWilliams
(PC #984); Mark Feldman (PC #985); Andrea Rodriguez (PC #986); Herbert
Johnson IV (PC #987); Enid Baron (PC #988); Carole Smith (PC #989);
Indechiperable signature (PC #990); Janice Printen (PC #991); Daverille Sheb
(PC #992); Kristin Court (PC #993); Viola Heyn (PC #994); Robert Kerls (PC
#995); Sarah Colten (PC #996); Jennifer Rogers (PC #997); Katie Mays (PC
#998); Steve Harker (PC #999)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - G.L. Parsons (PC #900); Carolyn Parson (PC
#901); Paul Israel (PC #902); V. Pierce (PC #903); Michael W. Edwards (PC
#904); Bob Stefko & Holly Roeske (PC #905); Carol King (PC #906); John
Buchanan (PC #907); Pamela Wexler (PC #908); Jason Malik (PC #909); Natalie
Archie (PC #910); Max Wessel (PC #911); Barbara Carmody (PC #912); Rod
McKee (PC #913); Margaret Ann Keene (PC #914); K. Simpson (PC #915);
Kathleen Kuffner (PC #916); Arlene H. Cook (PC #917); Robin Callahan (PC
#918); Bill McCure (PC #919); Carolyn C. Eby (PC #920); Rebecca Rose (PC
#921); Linda Walker (PC #922); Jim & Leslie Cousineau (PC #923); Dennis
Heyck (PC #924); Mike Erdman (PC #925); Bud Mathieu (PC #926); Robert
Arcus (PC #927); Janice Arcus (PC #928); Louise Levy (PC #929); Susan Lee
(PC #930); Carole & David Dibo (PC #931); Melissa Marguerite (PC #932);
Cheryl Lakin (PC #933); Dan Czerwinski (PC #934); Tom Gilroy (PC #935);
Nancy L. Schachman (PC #936); David More (PC #937); Colleen GOlden (PC
#938); Maria Albert (PC #939); Indecipherable signature (PC #940); Vincent
Graham (PC #941); Julie Kaiser (PC #942); Margaret Tilson (PC #943); Martin
von Walten Kirrchen (PC #944); Beth Gomberg Hirsch (PC #945); Eliza Earle
(PC #946); Linda Relias (PC #947); Denise Kirshenbaum (PC #948); Patricia
Piper (PC #949)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jan Lackey (PC #850); Diane Rubens (PC #851); P.
Bowtell (PC #852); Joy Schaad (PC #853); Kevin Salley (PC #854); Brendon
Devine (PC #855); Scott E. Bawinkel (PC #856); Kay Laube (PC #857); Don
Koss (PC #858); Jeff Renda (PC #859); Allan Ledbetter (PC #860); Danielle
Alarcon (PC #861); Joe Alarcon (PC #862); Eileen Pappas (PC #863); Heather
Bond (PC #864); Tousey (PC #865); Ross Barry (PC #866); Jackie Grosse (PC
#867); Lauren Barry (PC #868); Philip Sawicki (PC #869); Kim Beck (PC #870);
Wallace Jones (PC #871); Patricia Vaughan (PC #872); Joyce L. Hodgson-Palcek
(PC #873); Paul Chernak (PC #874); Nicole Hansen (PC #875); Indecipherable
signature (PC #876); Ted & Krista Venegas (PC #877); Leslie Newhuis (PC
#878); William E. Wade (PC #879); Gene Rosie (PC #880); Julie Perry (PC
#881); John Meyer (PC #882); C. Kelly (PC #883); Barbara Graves (PC #884);
Renee Mimica (PC #885); Robert K. Bliese (PC #886); Patricia Callahan (PC
#887); Terri Winkler (PC #888); Jenny Bowen (PC #889); Amy Simmons (PC
#890); Anthony Babimic (PC #891); Paul Ripp (PC #892); Cedric Williams (PC
#893); Roger Townsend (PC #894); Stephen Laskaris (PC #895); C. Russell (PC
#896); Indecipherable signature (PC #897); Cynthia McLean (PC #898); Kay
Carroll (PC #899)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Malcolm Byrd (PC #800); Jill D. Harris (PC #801);
Elsie Graczyk (PC #802); Marlies De Kluyver (PC #803); Anne Atzeff (PC
#804); Alison Hartline (PC #805); Lee Nysted (PC #806); Garth Pearson (PC
#807); Matt Jenkin (PC #808); Lois Shutler (PC #809); Kristin & Jack Welu (PC
#810); Jill Smith (PC #811); Indecipherable signature (PC #812); Maureen
O'Brien-Hufseman (PC #813); Liz Wesel (PC #814); Michelle Hans (PC #815);
Margaret Morrissette (PC #816); Steven Wilson (PC #817); Janett Chocianowski
(PC#818); T. Callahan (PC #819); Indecipherable signature (PC #820); Derek
Hirt (PC #821); Daryle Crewford (PC #822); John Wiggins (PC #823); Jeannette
Lareau (PC #824); Merolin Levon (PC #825); Rochelle Butler (PC #826); Jamie
He (PC #827); Leonora Voigtlander (PC #828); Indecipherable signature (PC
#829); Mary Allan (PC #830); George Stylianou (PC #831); Javier Anids (PC
#832); Chris Harris (PC #833); John H. Davis (PC #834); Franklin Sweetser (PC
#835); K. Owens (PC #836); Ned Rockwell (PC #837); Stephen Murray (PC
#838); S. Hickory (PC #839); Marc Anglin (PC #840); Lamekia Maggitt (PC
#841); Salvador Ayala (PC #842); Michelle Frank (PC #843); Carolyn Grant (PC
#844); Richard Klwaiter (PC #845); James T. Walker (PC #846); Ed Ribio (PC
#847); James Kirby (PC #848); Hadassah Rosen (PC #849)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Erin Meyer (PC #750); George Scott (PC #751);
Brenda Weigand (PC #752); Eric Clement (PC #753); Anthony Macias (PC
#754); Lori Fordon (PC #755); Mac Neil (PC #756); R.M. Roser (PC #757); B.
Levine (PC #758); Mike Meyers (PC #759); Elizabeth Ruihl (PC #760); Dean P.
Muka (PC #761); Keith Trojan (PC #762); Clarice Hart (PC #763);Liz
Oppenhuis (PC #764); John Hoard (PC #765); Paul Dolan (PC #766); Jose
Garcia (PC #767); Peter Eckart (PC #768); James Ryan (PC #769); Stephen J.
Moed (PC #770); Margaret Reeber (PC #771); Michelle Ball (PC #772); Susan
Kuhn (PC #773); Tucker Slough (PC #774); Kaleb Gebremaviam (PC #775);
Walter Anglin (PC #776); Jessica Barazowski (PC #777); Bob Dendler (PC
#778); Justin Doolittle (PC #779); Hans Caltus (PC #780); Michelle Davidson
(PC #781); Jennifer Kosikowski (PC #782); Patricia Mamantov (PC #783); J.
Nykaza (PC #784); Jane Stout (PC #785); Peter Primason (PC #786); D. Jamil
(PC #787); Jackie Budmayr (PC #788); Adam Battrilli (PC #789); Sarah Lisy
(PC #790); Tim Kruegee (PC #791); Martin Stainther (PC #792); Daniel Dimcket
(PC #793); Edna Evans (PC #794); Howard J. Andrews (PC #795); Carol
Johnson (PC #796); Hodges (PC #797); Sherry Nelson (PC #798); F.G. Uriell
(PC #799)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Margaux Hoyda (PC #700); Megan Nelson (PC
#701); Rena Hichs (PC #702); Bethany Parker (PC #703); Arielle Semmel (PC
#704); Dave Lynn (PC #705); Mike Burng (PC #706); Steven Bburns(PC #707);
Taylor McKenzie (PC #708); Tyler Southwell (PC #709); Deborah Benford (PC
#710); Emily Robison (PC #711); Michael McKeaney (PC #712); Whitney
Thomas (PC #713); Brittany Laughlin (PC #714); Nichole Hakis (PC #715); Ed
Contreras (PC #716); Joe Connor (PC #717); Carolyn Ziaja (PC #718); Manuel
Payanu (PC #719); Greg Glennie (PC #720); Aaron Stewe (PC #721); Rob
Cornelson (PC #722); Rebecca Renland (PC #723); Wayne Danner (PC #724);
Edwin Rodriguez (PC #725); Trislyn Hall (PC #726); Kim Cobom (PC #727);
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Catherine Breckenridge (PC #728); Antolia Beach (PC #730); Vicki Dmitruk (PC
#731); Vinny Coborn (PC #732); Victre Dmitruk (PC #733); Den Dmitruk (PC
#734); Allen Sledge (PC #735); Ernest Bellups (PC #736); Laquita Shaw (PC
#737); Omar Salvador (PC #738); Ashley Lushene (PC #739); Sapana Kabarin
(PC #740); Matt Chandler (PC #741); Vito Ingargiola (PC #742); Ronnie M.
Armstead (PC #743); Michael Rechards (PC #744); Celeste Aronoff (PC #745);
Lori Duffy (PC #746); Maria Papachny Santhon (PC #747); Carissa Johnson (PC
#748); James Ingraffia (PC #749)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Sheila Herndon (PC #650); Samuel Adams (PC
#651); Demetrios Bobolos (PC #652); Julisa Seese (PC #653); Rachel Olsen (PC
#654); Neil Millburger (PC #655); Shantiria Harper (PC #656); JIllian Jacobsen
(PC #657); Mike Jolisc (PC #658); Meaghan McIntyre (PC #659); Jonathan
Blake Yarbrough (PC #660); Ramona Finner (PC #661); Richard Brode (PC
#662); Christopher Swan (PC #663); Giancarlo Fiatto (PC #664); Carlos
Alcantan (PC #665); LeAndra Hall (PC #666); Brian Bultana (PC #667); Natalie
Williams (PC #668); Tom Dovthett (PC #669); Arnold Martin (PC #670); Marke
Subasit (PC #671); Sarah O'Connor (PC #672); Lily Fahrrwald (PC #673); Eric
Krall (PC #674); Jose R. Serrono (PC #675); Mark Berlinski (PC #676); Julia
Colon (PC #677); Emily Werth (PC #678); Taylor Erickson (PC #679); Willy R.
Miller (PC #680); Judith Poole (PC #681); Anthony Jones (PC #682); Brian
Albrellet (PC #683); David Martinez (PC #684); Viridiana Carmona (PC #685);
Jennifer Little (PC #686); Alberto Orizanda (PC #687); Jake Little (PC #688);
Roxanne Whitehed (PC #689); Ali Schlereth (PC #690); Dan Hunt (PC #691);
Ken Birch (PC #692); Patrica Carlson (PC #693); Elizabeth Simon (PC #694);
Georgiana Zowack (PC #695); Mark Brown (PC #696); E. Adams (PC #697);
Eric Safwedil (PC #698);Jim Joiner (PC #699)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Jim Grosse (PC #600); Lisa Rome (PC #601);
Daniel Rojas (PC #602); Lisa Barca (PC #603); Ryan Newsome (PC #604);
Richard Northrop (PC #605); Velma Burrell (PC #606); Ruby Swift (PC #607);
Tabea Baader (PC #608); Joseph Greer (PC #609); Michael Smith (PC #610);
Vivian Crosby (PC #611); John A. Farrm (PC #612); W. Vanecko (PC #613); H.
Strauss (PC #614); Edward D. Williams (PC #615); Max Muller (PC #616);
Frances Canonizado (PC #617); Lewis Clason (PC #618); Daniel Rok (PC #619);
Sermara Murphy (PC #620); Melody Johnson (PC #621); Mark Galy (PC #622);
Michael Patrick Cash (PC #623); Belva Miles (PC #624); Alexander Raff (PC
#625); Terri Mitrano (PC #626); Dwayne Wilson Jr. (PC #627); Reginald McGee
(PC #628); MIguel Galaiza (PC #629); MIcahel Reaser (PC #630); Vanessa
Anacano (PC #631); Erica Wasilenko (PC #632); Corinna Psomadakis (PC
#633); Galee Shachar (PC #634); Zac Walton (PC #635); Julia Labadie (PC
#636); Robert Stelle (PC #637); Luke H. (PC #638); Dorothy Olinir (PC #639);
Justin Nevin (PC #640); Alexandra Graves (PC #641); Dawn Trujillo (PC #642);
Kathy Trujillo (PC #643); Brenda Rodriguez (PC #644); Andrew Jamkowski (PC
#645); Henry E. Mareus (PC #646); Kennetha Hardrict (PC #647); Dawn Cortez
(PC #648); Kwabena Nantwi (PC #649)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - India Simerson (PC #550); Erna Mugnaini (PC
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
#551); Earl Callaway(PC #552); Shalese McClain (PC #553); Emily Kelly (PC
#554); Lucy Arias (PC #555); Tasniwa K. Tommey (PC #556); Alber Sohn (PC
#557); Hector Brown (PC #558); Frank H. Mueller (PC #559); Kathleen King
(PC #560); George Moore (PC #561); Willie A. Doss (PC #562); Matt Scott (PC
#563); Reginald Wells (PC #564); Nadia Halim (PC #565); Spencer Ezell (PC
#566); Willard Ehojosky (PC #567); Mary Roche (PC #568); Gabriel Ruualcaba
(PC #569); Walter Pickett (PC #570); Kacie Karasiak (PC #571); Mote Morris
(PC #572); Michael Maillo (PC #573); Maychy Ferenandez (PC #574); Peter
Belitzos (PC #575); Isaac N. Dupre (PC #576); Emili Manion (PC #577);
Luciano Cruz (PC #578); Jared Martz (PC #579); Andrew Offerman (PC #580);
Sherrick Lewis (PC #581); Anthony Colletti (PC #582); David Mayland (PC
#583); Jeff Brown (PC #584); Cynthia Mayland (PC #585); John Onopa (PC
#586.); Roy Rieckenberg Jr. (PC #587.); Patsy Caringado (PC #588.); M. Cozad
(PC #589.); Dominique Nash (PC #590.); Andrew MacDonald (PC #591.);
Becky McNamara (PC #592.); Reno Burden (PC #593.); Oladipo Ajenifujo (PC
#594.); Brian Rozek (PC #595.); Nick Sudbury (PC #596.); Leah Rothschild (PC
#597.); Cora Swenson (PC #598.); Bob Trausch (PC #599.);
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Susan Katz (PC #500); Rik Kristianat (PC #501);
Vanessa Alonso (PC #502); Ken Robinson (PC #503); Klifford Cutler (PC #504);
Paula Stevens (PC #505); Anne and Therese Belveau (PC #506); Mariel
Hummer(PC #507); Steve Weatherspoon (PC #508); Martina Doleys (PC #509);
Michael Thomas (PC #510); Glenn A. Preibis (PC #511); Anthony Dernick
Tooties (PC #512); David Enright (PC #513); Valencia Hempton (PC #514);
Ruby Harris (PC #515); Richard Middleton-Kaplan (PC #516); Clarence M.
BrwsterTreadway (PC #517); David Weiss (PC #518); John Macielenicz (PC
#519); Jean Durand (PC #520); Brian Lobel (PC #521); Kimberlyee Abney (PC
#522); Derell Bonner (PC #523); Benjamin Incao (PC #524); Danielle E.
Henderson (PC #525); Lisa Nackovac (PC #526); Mallory Cooney (PC #527);
Frank Pistell (PC #528); Kevin Reing (PC #529); Georgia Coleman (PC #530);
Patricia Perez (PC #531); Adreinne Kwiatkowski (PC #532); Maryann Stifonski
(PC #533); Charmaine Mariscal (PC #534); Alex Friedman (PC #535); Chris
Davis (PC #536); G. Rodriguez (PC #537); Katie Lindskog (PC #538); Timothy
Zode (PC #539); Lekha Nair (PC #540); Drew McCandle (PC #541); M.
Zeldman (PC #542); C. Jenkins (PC #543); Matt Demo (PC #544); Steve Crowell
(PC #545); Ernesto Marin (PC #546); Chris Swanson (PC #547); Douer Evans
(PC #548); Alyse B. Hammonds (PC #549)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Rhonda Syat (PC #450); Chris Cherek (PC #451);
Ruben Sanchez (PC #452); Maria E. Sanchez (PC #453 ); Ann Meenaghan (PC
#454); Aaron Simmons (PC #455); David Nowacki (PC #456); Margaret E.
Currin (PC #457); F. Manzano (PC #458); Monika Kieic (PC #459); Lorena
Estrada (PC #460); Michaell E. Altman (PC #461); Crystal Ratliff (PC #462);
Rachel Kellett (PC #463); Johan Peeples (PC #464); Manuel Baumann (PC
#465); Nicole L. Eggers (PC #466); Amber F. Ladeira (PC #467); Shannon
Crawford (PC #468); C arlos Ardila (PC #469); Kakis Norfleet (PC #470);
Milton King (PC #471); Ruben Sanchez (PC #472); Sarah Mallory (PC #473);
Kelly Amaloo (PC #474); J. Byrnes (PC #475); Janessa Thiel (PC #476); Steven
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Drink (PC #477); Norma Vazoug (PC #478); Edward Waszak (PC #479); Susie
An (PC #480); Samantha Coulter (PC #481); Andrea North (PC #482); Randy
Hofbarer (PC #483); John D. Buirji (PC #484); Ashley Cunningham (PC #485);
Ronald Redmond (PC #486); Gil Levin (PC #487); Marlen Simmoins (PC #488);
Nicholas L. Wingo (PC #489); Terri Pellino (PC #490); Casey Powell (PC #491);
Johnathan Spindler (PC #492); Alicia Colazo (PC #493); Shawn Montgomery
(PC #494); Lewe Danzy (PC #495); Rose S. Sandy (PC #496); Anthony Elion
(PC #497); Edw. Farnham (PC #498); Turonc Mosby (PC #499);
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Edda Bowlds (PC #400); Elise Zelechowski (PC
#401); Mrs. W. Gensiorski (PC #402); Mary Kowalik (PC #403); James Gillen
(PC #404); Michelle Uting (PC #405); L.J. Avitia (PC #406); Lisa Hamdani (PC
#407); David Meeks (PC #408); Sheila Clark (PC #409); Darlene Lewis (PC
#410); Ed Banasiak (PC #411); Nancy Clifton (PC #412); Bonnie Kistenmacher
(PC #413); Sarah Dunn (PC #414); Gretchen Bystedt (PC #415); Donna Clarke
(PC #416); Pablo Medina (PC #417); John C. Pembor (PC #418); Bennie Dean
(PC #419); Risha Rotkin (PC #420); Ralph rodriguez (PC #421); Patricia E Nu
(PC #422); Maria Guiterrez (PC #423); Johanna Thompson (PC #424); David D.
Reyes(PC #425); Jessica Caldwell (PC #426); Amanda Zych (PC #427); Joseph
Kelly (PC #428); Veronica Milos (PC #429); Melissa Jenrich (PC #430); Joanne
Daniel (PC #431); Jonathan Ernst (PC #432); Michael Sexton (PC #433); Rob
Grund (PC #434); Rick Leawell (PC #435); Pauline Crutia (PC #436); Larry W.
Green (PC #437); Barbara McCord (PC #438); Barbara Araszewsh (PC #439);
Olivia Karas (PC #440); Joanna Zapalowicz (PC #441); Lauren Huffman (PC
#442); Bridget Willis (PC #443); Karen Duncan (PC #444); Dr. Cheryl Magrini
(PC #445); Charles Shanabrach (PC #446); Mr. Anthony Brown (PC #447);
Molly Fitzgibbon (PC #448); Jennifer Cidrowski (PC #449)
5/8/2006
Comments of Illinois PIRG - Rachel Davis (PC #345); Derylle Smith (PC #346);
April Welch (PC #347); Reginald Samuel (PC #348); Marcus D. Johnson Jr. (PC
#349); Chris Wilimas (PC #350); Frank White (PC #351); Anita Inez Lathrop
(PC #352); Madalyne Tregallas (PC #353); Curt Williams (PC #355); Sid Babula
(PC #356); Emilee Clales (PC #357); Clarence Glenn (PC #358); K. Pedroza (PC
#359); William Johnson (PC #360); Debra Weiner (PC #361); Jimmy Hissang
(PC #362); Shraddha Soparanala (PC #363); Mariah Kellan (PC #364); T. Dalton
(PC #365); Bob Schmidtke(PC #366); Tony Calero (PC #367); Alexandra
Kostius (PC #368); Jon E. Wilson (PC #369); Brian Kalchbrenner (PC #370);
courtney Behners (PC #371); Caher Eruay (PC #372); Edward Piehl (PC #373);
Gerald R. Venhart (PC #374); Pat Marshall (PC #375); Vesta Butler (PC #376);
Jose Gonzalez (PC #377); Jackie Brown (PC #378); Joe Rakoczy (PC #379);
Lemuel Askew (PC #380); D. Dzura (PC #381); Gwen Beatty (PC #382);
Emebet Donoghue (PC #383); Vibhuti Kadakia (PC #384); Neeta Paitch (PC
#385); Alfrezo Alantara (PC #386); Sandra Watkins (PC #387); Kim Schaffer
(PC #388); Jeanette Donner (PC #389); Mei M. Alu (PC #390); Lorraine Szot
(PC #391); Janet Salomone (PC #392); Larissa Skyba(PC #393); E.K. Gilbert
(PC #394); Kisha Jazlu (PC #395); Kim Yip (PC #396); Moline Berlley (PC
#397); E. Jason Gremley (PC #398); Anita Ilika (PC #399)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/8/2006
Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coalition: Alejandra Moya (PC #325.101);
Quirino Carlin (PC #325.1102); Kimberly Wesserman (PC #325.103); Brenda
Figuero (PC #325.104); Indecipherable signature PC #325.105); Lorena Lopez
(PC #325.106)
5/8/2006
Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coalition: Ellen Rendulich (PC #325.91);
Maureen Headington (PC#325.92); Walter Esler (PC #325.93); Salvador Silva
(PC #325.94; Carlos Torres (PC #325.95); Daniel Acevedo (PC #325.96); Isabel
GarcGarcia (PC #325.97); Lionel Bottari (PC #325.98); Jean Parosi (PC
#325.99); George G. Macias (PC #325.100)
5/8/2006
Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coalition: Elizabeth Hayes (PC #325.81);
Kathleen Cummings (PC #325.82); Joel Brown (PC #325.83); Jovita Flores (PC
#325.84); Ira Shakman (PC #325.85); Michael Norbeck (PC #325.86); John
Ailey (PC #325.87); Brian Imus (PC #325.88); Teresa Medina (PC #325.89);
David Rolston (PC #325.90)
5/8/2006
Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coalition: Gustavo Tovar (PC #325.71);
Maria Rico (PC #325.72); Pablo Ramirez (PC #325.73); Matt Van Slyke (PC #
325.74); George G. Macias (PC #325.75); Cory Jones (PC #325.76); Meleah
Geertsma (PC #325.77); Michael D. Rodruguiz (PC #325.78); Manuel Figgieres
Jr. (PC #325.79); Jennifer Stevenson (PC #325.80)
5/8/2006
Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coalition: Rosa Garcia (PC #325.61); Maria
Guerez (PC # 325.62); Refugio Fraga (PC # 325.63); James Foley (PC #325.64);
Isadora Sanchez (PC #325.65); Cecilia Vega (PC #325.66); Irma Alforo (PC
#325.67); Sarah Aiby (PC #325.68); Lorraine Garcia (PC #325.69);
Indecipherable signature (PC #325.70)
5/8/2006
Nancy Ayala (PC #325.51); Sandrine Navarro-Artz (PC #325.52); Greg Krol (PC
#325.53); Timothy Artz (PC #325.54); Indecipherable signature (PC #325.55);
Griselda Mata (PC #325.56); Douglas Grew (PC #325.57; Heidi Howerton (PC
#325.58); Juan Komero (PC #325.59); Teresa Merdin (PC #325.60)
5/8/2006
Jose Rodriguez (PC #325.41); Daniel Korn (PC #325.42); Janet Fecreal (PC
#325.43); Al DiFranco (PC #325.44); Abe Costanza (PC #325.45); Karen Sheets
(PC #325.46); Francisco Rodriguez (PC #325.47); Antonio Baeza (PC # 325.48);
Rhonda Williams (PC # 325.49); Antonio Pattan (PC #325.50)
5/8/2006
Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coalition: Modesta Vicente (PC #325.31);
Guillermo Diaz (PC #325.32); Lorena Lopez (PC #325.33); Jumana Vasi (PC
#325.34); Indecipheral signature (PC #325.35); Robert Cepeda (PC #325.36);
Leila Cepeda (PC #325.37); Elias Cepeda (PC #325.38); Patricia Mena (PC
#325.39); Alejandro Mena (PC #325.40
5/8/2006
Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coalition: Maria Fraga (PC#325.1); Sharon
Pierson (PC #325.2); Carlos Fernandez (PC#325.3); Sara Brodinsky (PC#325.4);
Jean Cartter-Hill (PC #325.5); Viviana Fraga (PC#325.6); Paul Orlando (PC
#325.7); Ann Elliott (PC#325.8); Leah Simoni (PC#325.9) Jaclin Paul (PC
#325.10); Iris Young (PC#325.11); David Alexander (PC #325.12); Elda
Godinaz (PC#325.13; Tom Nizinski (PC#325.14); Robin Rodgon (PC #325.15);
Daniella K. Zanin (PC #325.16); Alejandra L. Ibanez (PC #325.17); Sergio
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
Herrara (PC #325.18); Edward Anaya (PC #325.19); Alexandra Gonzalez (PC
#325.20); Walter Esler (PC #325.21); Alvaro Obregon (PC #325.22); Emil
Rosenthal (PC #325.23); Daniel Solis (PC #325.24); Deborah Handler (PC
#325.25); Sarah Wild (PC #325.26); John Otromphe (PC #325.27); Chester Koe
(PC #325.28); John Morris (PC #325.29); Dan Johnson-Weinberger (PC
#325.30)
5/8/2006
*Comments of Chicago Clean Power Coalition: Vicki Cervantes and
indecipherable signature (PC #325)
5/8/2006
40" x 60" two-sided poster board entitled "Protect Kids From Toxic Mercury"
with children's markings and sentiments and names (PC # 275) (You may contact
the Clerk's Office at 312/814-3629 to view it.)
5/8/2006
*Comments of Barbara Flynn Currie, Illinois House Majority Leader, In a Letter
Addressed to Nicholas J. Melas, Illinois Pollution Control Board member (PC
#44)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Patricia Peak (PC # 274)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Tom Hermsen (PC # 273)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Quentin Getty (PC # 272)
5/5/2006
*Comments of George Kaydus (PC # 271)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Lora Fanning (PC # 270)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Kenneth Curry (PC # 269)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Zach Barnes (PC # 268)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Mike Warbez (PC # 267)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Debra Arbet (PC # 266)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Kaylee Kaydus (PC # 265)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Brian Layton (PC # 264)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Bill Beckham (PC # 263)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Cory Morgan (PC # 262)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Julie Smith-Marshall (PC # 261)
5/5/2006
*Comments of James Edwards (PC # 260)
5/5/2006
*Comments of Soot T. Boaig (PC # 259)
5/4/2006
*Comments of Kathleen P. Callahan (PC #258)
5/4/2006
Comments of Jery Herst of Insolar Window Treatments, Inc. (PC #257)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Lisa Nagel (PC # 256)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Ronald E. Jacobsen (PC # 255)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Wendy Glasshof (PC # 254)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Margaret Mahile (PC # 253)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Elliot Zashin (PC # 252)
5/3/2006
*Comments of William Dent (PC # 251)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Lou Strzyzewski (PC # 250)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/3/2006
*Comments of Angela Fitch (PC # 249)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Gretchen reuning (PC # 248)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Dave Mauios (PC # 247)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Mike Rechlin (PC # 246)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Ken Sennert (PC # 245)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Jim Newton (PC # 244)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Philip Brault (PC # 243)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Jessica Burdinsly (PC # 242)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Carol Klinger (PC # 241)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Christine Arango (PC # 240)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Adria Howe Johnson (PC # 239)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Sharon Haas (PC # 238)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Ryan Kingsbury (PC # 237)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Ruben Varela (PC # 236)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Breck Collon (PC # 235)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Samantha Noel Hyde (PC # 234)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Cara Wilson (PC # 233)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Weyla Dunn (PC # 232)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Carolyn Burns (PC # 231)
5/3/2006
*Comments of David L. Waupoose (PC # 230)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Marjorie Woodbury (PC # 229)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Barb Boss (PC # 228)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Jessica Huck (PC # 227)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Stephanie Irvine (PC # 226)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Joe Fitzgibbon (PC # 225)
5/3/2006
*Comments of A. J. Beck (PC # 224)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Christine McAllister (PC # 223)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Carla Newton (PC # 222)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Patrick Pickerill (PC # 221)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Deborah Colley (PC # 220)
5/3/2006
*Comments of David Lyon (PC # 219)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Jeffrey Cornelius (PC # 218)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Jim Sullivan (PC # 217)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Ora Kramer (PC # 216)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Beth Bergstrom (PC # 215)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Joanne Kelly (PC # 214)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Barbara Keer (PC # 213)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/3/2006
*Comments of Traci Hendrix Hart (PC # 212)
5/3/2006
*Comments of Sheila Ritter (PC # 211)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Carole Jacobsen (PC # 210)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Sylvia M. Vassmer (PC # 209)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Arthur T. Kalish (PC # 208)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Robert J. Bacon (PC # 207)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Nancy R. Lloyd (PC # 206)
5/2/2006
*Comments of William Mueller (PC # 205)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Lynn T. Giever (PC # 204)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Kaanenyee Reid (PC # 203)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Linda Sullivan (PC # 202)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Esperanza Hartman (PC # 201)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Aldona Starkus (PC # 200)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Lainey E. Schneider (PC # 199)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Julie Dorfman (PC # 198)
5/2/2006
*Comments of David N. Collignr (PC # 197)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Eileen LeBarre (PC # 196)
5/2/2006
*Comments of June Pasco (PC # 195)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Donna Ducy (PC # 194)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Jim Vaencia (PC # 193)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Marketa Zeleznikova (PC # 192)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Allen Rogers (PC # 191)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Rey Aquino (PC # 190)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Robert J. Neff (PC # 189)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Wendy Treptow (PC # 188)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Michael D. Lavin (PC # 187)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Brigitte & Drtly Schmidt (PC # 186)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Donna L. Thomas (PC # 185)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Louis McCain Vassmer (PC # 184)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Judie Mermsen (PC # 183)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Noelle Hoeffner (PC # 182)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Lim Peterson (PC # 181)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Jeff and Lucy Porter (PC # 180)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Jane Linmar (PC # 179)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Daniel Fritz (PC # 178)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Lawrence Kolesa (PC # 177)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Rebecca Wetzler (PC # 176)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/2/2006
*Comments of Colleen Griffin (PC # 175)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Patricia Fischer (PC # 174)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Dianne Carey (PC # 173)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Erin McElroy (PC # 172)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Maurice Lange (PC # 171)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Roger Ricketts (PC # 170)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Byron Walter (PC # 169)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Sandra Wood (PC # 168)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Dale Albers (PC # 167)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Cecil Whavert (PC # 166)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Steven Schoeffler (PC # 165)
5/2/2006
*Comments of R. Michael Fisher (PC # 164)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Gretchen G. Batz (PC # 163)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Dennis Skaggs (PC # 162)
5/2/2006
*Comments of David Bluhm (PC # 161)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Joy Fritz Walter (PC # 160)
5/2/2006
*Comments of David Gocken (PC # 159)
5/2/2006
*Comments of Neil Jacobsen (PC # 158)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Jennifer Barkley (PC #157)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Kelsey Faiy (PC #156)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Bob Toeth (PC #155)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Kayla Frey (PC # 154)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Ryan White (PC #153)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Pat Murrell (PC #152)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Cheryl Stogdell (PC #151)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Dieanne Fuchar (PC #150)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Roger Batz (PC #149)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Gerry Feeney (PC #148)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Susan M. Champagne (PC #147)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Diane Sims (PC #146)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Lon Reinherr (PC #145)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Cindy Cochrane (PC #144)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Merlin Camozzi (PC #143)
5/1/2006
*Comments William J. Brogan (PC #142)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Ron & Elsie Magnussen (PC #141)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Sara Kildee (PC #138); Ms. L. Hudson (PC #139); and Tad
Scheele (PC #140)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
5/1/2006
*Comments of Therese Jesel (PC #137)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Myra Owczarzak (PC # 136)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Rob Grund (PC # 135)
5/1/2006
*Comments of Leslie Kosar (PC # 134)
4/28/2006
*Comments of Cecelia Ungari (PC #133)
4/28/2006
*Comments of Steven Dick (PC #132)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Ricky Leavell (PC # 131)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Robin Goettel (PC # 130)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Boaz Patwr (PC # 129)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Joseph Kelly (PC # 128)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Elizabeth Wright (PC # 127)
4/27/2006
*Comments of S. Hawkins (PC # 126)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Aaron Anderson (PC # 125)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Gloria Peralta (PC # 124)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Veronica Drantz, Ph.D. (PC # 123)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Gary Schwartz (PC # 122)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Michelle R. Lord (PC # 121)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Dean Wynne (PC # 120)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Amanda Zych (PC # 119)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Roosevelt Murray Sr. (PC # 118)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Craig Key (PC # 117)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Sarah Guernsey (PC # 116)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Nick Wilder (PC # 115)
4/27/2006
*Comments of Erica Davis-Holder (PC # 114)
4/27/2006
*Comments of (Indecipherable Name) (PC # 113)
4/27/2006
*Comments of F. E. Elim#4 (PC # 112)
4/27/2006
*Comments of D'Holyone@y'Israel (PC # 111)
4/27/2006
*Comments of John Knoepfle (PC # 110)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Shelby Seegers-Shafer (PC # 109)
4/26/2006
*Comments of H. F. Parker (PC # 108)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Danielle Estes (PC # 107)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Matthew Romero (PC # 106)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Steve Gough (PC # 105)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Ling C. Brow (PC # 104)
4/26/2006
*Comments of M. J. O'Hara (PC # 103)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Atilio M. Gimenez (PC # 102)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Thomas E. Grant (PC # 101)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
4/26/2006
*Comments of Deborah J. Bouton (PC # 100)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Kim Artita (PC # 99)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Mike Sears (PC # 98)
4/26/2006
*Comments of (indecipherable signature) (PC # 97)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Miranda Mapps (PC # 96)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Jolene Boehler (PC # 95)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Aimee Bennett (PC # 94)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Carol Eaton Brandenburg (PC # 93)
4/26/2006
*Comments of JoAnn / Joseph Schafer (PC # 92)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Ryne Thanp (PC # 91)
4/26/2006
*Comments of MeLissa L. Obermiller (PC # 90)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Dean Huber (PC # 89)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Christel Kazda (PC #88)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Sallie Schramm (PC # 87)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Jan Korzenaskie (PC # 86)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Robert E. Beck (PC # 85)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Alison McCabe (PC # 84)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Diane Schingel (PC # 83)
4/26/2006
*Comments of JoAnn Nelson (PC # 82)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Katherine Poulos (PC # 81)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Elizabeth Hughes (PC # 80)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Judy Ashby (PC # 79)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Joel Fritzler (PC # 78)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Frances Ganzekaufer (PC # 77)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Rafe Kemmis (PC # 76)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Ronald Ray Schmeck (PC # 75)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Dorothy Schachel (PC # 74)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Randall Lee Gunslapp (PC # 73)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Stephanie Eichholz (PC # 72)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Melanie Schmeck (PC # 71)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Mary Lou Tansey (PC # 70)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Fay Michaelis (PC # 69)
4/26/2006
*Comments of Joyce Marks (PC # 68)
4/25/2006
*Comments of George Kollar (PC # 67)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Tom Pilirs (PC # 66)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Christine Williamson (PC # 65)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Ron Newman (PC # 64)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
4/25/2006
*Comments of Erica Yokoi (PC # 63)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Carol McCullough (PC # 62)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Geoffrey Williamson (PC # 61)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Gail Kimura (PC # 60)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Lawrence Todryk (PC # 59)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Sheila Keleher (PC # 58)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Bernadette Blaurock (PC # 57)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Therese Radke (PC # 56)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Bela & Rachel Barner (PC # 55)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Allen E. Blaurock, Ph. D. (PC # 54)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Jen Strauch (PC # 53)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Susan Dickman (PC # 52)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Anne McKibbin (PC # 51)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Marcy Hagio (PC # 50)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Lois Samuels (PC # 49)
4/25/2006
*Comments of 25 persons in the usual postcard format as submitted by Sierra
Club, Chicago, IL (PC #48)
4/25/2006
*Comments of Barbara Flynn Currie, Illinois House Majority Leader, In a Letter
Addressed to Illinois Pollution Control Board Chairman, G. Tanner Girard (PC
#44)
4/24/2006
*Comments of Elizabeth Small (PC #47)
4/24/2006
*Comments of Bob Tyson (PC #46)
4/24/2006
*Comments of David Collignon (PC #45)
4/21/2006
*Comments of Barbara Flynn Currie, Illinois House Majority Leader, In a Letter
Addressed to Illinois Pollution Control Board member Thomas E. Johnson (PC
#44)
4/21/2006
*Comments of Barbara Flynn Currie, Illinois House Majority Leader, In a Letter
Addressed to Illinois Pollution Control Board members (PC #44)
4/20/2006
*Comments of Greg & Sue Stolzer (PC #43)
4/20/2006
*Comments of Benita Kitching (PC #42)
4/20/2006
*Comments of Portia K. Hoekstra (PC #41)
4/18/2006
*Comments of Stephen D. Zaborsky (PC #40)
4/18/2006
*Comments of Jon Wesenberg (PC #39)
4/18/2006
*Comments of Ellen Wolff (PC #38)
4/18/2006
*Comments of Peggy Simonsen (PC #37)
4/17/2006
*Comments of Raymond J. Norkus (PC #36)
4/17/2006
*Comments of Jerry Treppa and Ann Treppa (PC #35)
4/12/2006
Comments of Michael Schmidt (PC #34)
ATTACHMENT B Listing of public comments received in Board rulemaking docket R06-25
4/12/2006
Comments of Connie S. Schmidt (PC #33)
4/11/2006
*Comments of Paul Pocius (PC #32)
4/10/2006
Comments of Barbara Dickerman (PC #31)
4/6/2006
*Comments of Constance M. Beattie (PC #30)
4/3/2006
*Comments of Bruce K. Williams (PC #29)
4/3/2006
*Comments of John and Peg Knoepfle (PC #28)
4/3/2006
*Comments of Cecelia Connerton (PC #27)
3/29/2006
*Comments of Norlyn Dimmitt (PC #26)
3/29/2006
Comments of the Illinois Public Interest Research Group and the Environmental
Law and Policy Center in Support of Fast-Track Rulemaking (PC #25)
3/28/2006
*Comments of Marcia Dimmitt (PC #24)
3/27/2006
*Comments of Denise McCoy (PC #23)
3/27/2006
*Comments of Todd Loid (PC #22)
3/27/2006
*Comments of Sherrill Loid (PC #21)
3/24/2006
*Comments of Jeff Payton (PC #20)
3/23/2006
*Comments of Jochen Schorler (PC #19)
3/22/2006
*Comments of Jacob Reiner (PC #18)
3/21/2006
*Comments of Fran Caffee (PC #17)
3/20/2006
*Comments of Thomas P. Caffee (PC #16)
3/16/2006
*Comments of Elizabeth Higgins (PC #15)
3/14/2006
Comments of Eileen Stoxen (PC #14)
3/14/2006
Comments of Elizabeth Johnson (PC #13)
3/14/2006
Comments of Mrs. Nora Glab (PC #12)
3/14/2006
Comments of Jennifer Reiner (PC #11)
3/14/2006
Comments of Dr. Kathleen McFadden (PC #10)
3/14/2006
Comments of Nancy Cone (PC #9)
3/14/2006
Comments of Martha Jorgensen (PC #8)
3/14/2006
Comments of Joseph A. Laszlo (PC #7)
3/14/2006
Comments of Bob Jorgensen (PC #6)
3/14/2006
Comments of Greg Koch (PC #5)
3/14/2006
Comments of Paul Scholl (PC #4)
3/14/2006
Comments of Michael D. Belsky, Mayor, City of Highland Park (PC #3)
3/14/2006
Comments of Mayor Richard H. Hyde, City of Waukegan (PC #2)
3/14/2006
Comments of Governor Rod R. Blagojevich (PC #1)