CROWNLINE BOATS, INC. POST HEARING RESPONSE
Exhibit A
CROWNLINE BOATS, INC.
REVISED ADJUSTED STANDARD LANGUAGE
Crownline Boats, Inc.Monthly Emissions Summary12-Month Rolling Total

~C~Vi~©

CL~RK~S

OFF~CE

ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD

MAY

200’i

May

2004

STATE CF ~LUNO~S

IN THE MATTER OF:

)

Contro~

Board

)

PETITION OF CROWNLINE BOATS, INC.

)

AS 04-01

FOR AN ADJUSTED STANDARD FROM

)

(Adjusted Standard)

ILL. ADM. CODE 215.301

)

CROWNLINE BOATS, INC. POST HEARING RESPONSE

On April 23, 2004, a

hearing in

this matter was held at the City Hall in West Frankfort,

Illinois.

At the conclusion of the hearing, the representative from the

Illinois Pollution Control

Board, Ms. Alisa Liu, requested Crownline Boats, Inc. (“Crownline”)

to provide three additional

pieces of information.

This pleading shall provide the additional information requested from

Crownline at the hearing.

First, Miss Liu requested Crownline

to provide definitions

for the terms used in

the monthly

MACT compliance spreadsheets attached to the pleading Crownine

entered into

evidence at the

hearing entitled “Responses of Crownline Boats, Inc. to Questions

Hearing Officer Order of

April

6, 2004.”

As explained at the hearing, the terms used in the spreadsheets were taken from the

federal rule entitled

“National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants for Boat

Manufacturing”, 40 CFR Part 63, Subpart VVVV (the “MACT Standard”).

Attached at Exhibit A

are pages 44233-44235 from the August 22, 2001, Federal Register when the MACT Standard was

finalized, which sets forth the definitions of the

terms used in Crownline’s MACT compliance

spreadsheets.

Second, at the

hearing Crownline presented to

the Court revised language for its proposed

Adjusted Standard, which IEPA also expressed their support for at the hearing.

Attached at Exhibit

B is a copy of Crownine’s

revisedAdjusted

Standard language.

1837122

Third, in its pleading “Responses of Crownline Boats, Inc. to

Questions

in Hearing

Officer’s

Order of April

6, 2004”, Crownline stated that its emissions

of Hazardous Air Pollutants (“HAPs”)

prior to complying with the

MACT standard were approximately 204 tons per year.

Crownline also

estimated that it had reduced its HAP

emissions by approximately

50 tons per year

(a reduction

approximately 25)

by complying with the MACT Standard.

(See responses

to questions 2(b)

and

7(a)).

At the hearing, Miss Liu asked if Crownline could provide additional information regarding

the 50 ton/25

reduction in HAPs.

Attached hereto and labeled as Exhibits C and D are two

spreadsheets showing 12-month rolling total air emissions.

Exhibit C identifies that as

of December

2003,

Crownine’s

12-month rolling I-lAP emissions were 153.91

tons.

This amount represents

Crownine’s

estimated actual emissions on a 12-month rolling average

as of December 2003 while

being in

compliance with the MACT Standard.

Exhibit D is an estimate of what Crownline’s

emissions would have been if it made the exact same number of boats and boat models as in

Exhibit

C, but was not complying with the MACT Standard.

Exhibit D identifies that Crownline’s 12-

month rolling HAP emissions would have been approximately 204.18 tons per year if it had not

been complying with the MACT Standard.

The above information should satisfy the requests made of Crownline at the April 23, 2004

hearing.

1837122

BRYAN CAVE, LLP

By:

re,

Dale A.

Guariglia

Bryan Cave LLP

One Metropolitan Square

Suite

3600

St. Louis, MO

63102

314/259-2606

daguariglia(~brvancave

corn

Attorneys for Crownilne Boats, Inc.

1837122

CERTIFICATE

OF SERVICE

It is hereby certified that true copies of the foregoing response were mailed, first class,

May

13, 2004, to each of following persons:

Carol Sudman, Hearing Officer, Illinois Pollution

Control Board,

1021

North Grand Avenue East, P.O. Box 19274, Springfield, IL

62794-9274;

Dorothy M. Gunn, Illinois Pollution

Control Board, James R. Thompson Center,

100 W. Randolph

Street, Suite 11-500, Chicago, IL

60601, and Charles

Matoesian, Assistant Counsel, IEPA,

1021

North Grand Avenue East, P. 0. Box 19276, Springfield, IL

92794-9276.

Dal~TA.Guariglia

1837122

—1-

Apr11

23,

2UU4

Exhibit A

Federal

66,

No.

163/Wednesday,

August

22,

2001/Rules

and

Regulations

44233

(d) This subpart does not apply to

aluminum coating operations on

aluminum boats intended for

commercial

or military

(nonrecreational) use, antifoulant

coatings,

assembly adhesives,

fiberglass

hull

and deck coatings,

research and

development activities, mold

sealing

and

release agents, mold stripping

and

cleaning

solvents, and wood coatings as

defined

63.5779.

This

subpart does

not apply to materials contained in

handheld aerosol cans.

63.5686

How do

I demonstrate that my

facility is not a major source?

You can demonstrate that your facility

not a major source by

using the

procedures in

either paragraph

(a) or (b)

of this section.

(a)

Emission option.

You must

demonstrate that your facility does not

emit,

and does not have the potential to

emit

as defined in

§ 63.2, considering

federally enforceable permit limits,

9.1

megagrams

(10

tons) or more per year

a single

HAP

22.7

megagrams

(25

tons) or more per year of a combination

of HAP.

To calculate your facility’s

potential to emit, you must include

emissions from theboat manufacturing

facility and all

other sources that are

collocated and under common

ownership or control with the boat

manufacturing facility.

(b)

Material consumption option.

This

option can be used if you manufacture

either fiberglass boats or aluminum

recreational boats at your facility. You

must

meet the criteria in paragraph

(b)(i),

(2),

(3)

of this section and

comply with the requirements in

paragraph

section. Ifyou

initially rely on the limits and criteria

specified in paragraph

(b)(1),

(2),

(3)

of this section to become an area source,

but then exceed the relevant limit

(without

first obtaining and complying

with other limits that keep your

potential

to emit

HAP below major

source

levels), your facility will then

become a major source, and you must

comply

with all applicable provisions of

this

subpart beginning on the

compliance date specified

§ 63.5695.

Nothing in this paragraph

is intended to

preclude you from limiting your

facility’s potential to emit

through other

federally enforceable mechanisms

available through your permitting

authority.

(1)

Ifyour facility is

primarily a

fiberglass boat manufacturing facility,

you must demonstrate that you consume

less than

45.4

megagrams per rolling

12-

month

period of all

combined polyester-

and vinylester-based resins and gel

coats (including tooling and production

resins and gel coats, and clear gel coats),

and you must demonstrate that at least

percent of total annual HAP

emissions

at the facility (including

emissions

from aluminum recreational

boat manufacturing

or other source

categories) originate from the fiberglass

boat manufacturing materials.

(2)

Ifyour facility is primarily an

aluminum recreational boat

manufacturing facility, you must

demonstrate that

it consumes less than

18.2

megagrams per rolling 12-month

period of all

combined surface coatings,

aluminum wipedown

solvents,

application gun cleaning solvents, and

carpet and fabricadhesives; and you

must demonstrate that at least

percent

of total

annual HAP emissions

at the facility (including emissions from

fiberglass boat manufacturing or other

source

categories) originate from the

aluminum recreational boat

manufacturing materials.

(3)

Ifyour facility is a fiberglass boat

or an aluminum recreational boat

manufacturing

facility, you must

demonstrate that the boat manufacturing

materials consumed per rolling

12-

month period contain a total

ofless than

4.6

megagrams of any single HAP and

less than

11.4

megagrams of all

combined HAP, and you must

demonstrate that at least

percent of

total annual HAP

emissions at the

facility (including emissions from other

source categories) originate from these

boat manufacturing materials.

consumption

option described

paragraph

(b) of this section to

demonstrate that you arenot

a major

source, you must comply with the

requirements of paragraphs

(c)(1)

through

(3)

of this

section.

(1)

Ifyour facility has HAP emissions

that

do not originate from boat

manufacturing

operations or materials

described

in paragraph

(b), then you

must keep any records necessary to

demonstrate that the

percent

criterion

is met.

(2)

A rolling

12-month period

includes the previous

months of

operation.

You must maintain records of

the total

amount

of materials described

in paragraph

(b) of this section used

each month,

and, if necessary, the HAP

content of each material

and the

calculation of the total

HAP consumed

each month.

Because records are needed

for a 12-month period,

you must keep

records beginning

no laterthan

months before the compliance date

specified

63,5695,

Records must be

kept

for

years after they arecreated.

(3)

In determining whether the

percent criterion included in paragraph

(b) of this section

is met, you do not

need to include

materials used in

routine janitorial, building, or facility

grounds maintenance; personal

uses by

employees or other persons; or products

used for maintaining motor vehicles

operated by the facility.

63.5689

What parts of my facility are

covered by this subpart?

The affected source (the portion of

your boat manufacturing facility

covered by this

subpart)

is the

combination of all

of the boat

manufacturing operations listed

paragraphs

(a) through

(1)

of this section.

(a) Open molding resin and gel coat

operations

(including pigmented gel

coat, clear gel coat, production resin,

tooling gel coat, and tooling resin).

(b)

Closed molding resin operations.

operations.

(d) Resin and gel coat application

equipment cleaning operations.

(e) Carpet and fabric adhesive

operations.

(f) Aluminum hull and deck coating

operations, including solvent

wipedown

operations and paint spray gun cleaning

operations,

on aluminum recreational

boats.

63.5692

How do

I know if my

boat

manufacturing facility is a new source or an

existing source?

(a) A boat manufacturing facility is

new source if it meets the criteria

paragraphs

(a)(1) through

(3)

of this

section.

(1)

You commence construction

ofthe

affected source after July 14,

2000.

(2)

It is amajor source.

(3)

It is

a completely new boat

manufacturing affected source where no

other boat manufacturing affected

source existed prior to the construction

ofthe new source.

(b) For the purposes ofthis

subpart,

an existing source

is anysource that is

not

a new source.

63.5695

When must

I comply with this

subpart?

You

must comply with the standards

in this subpart by the compliance

dates

specified in Table

to this subpart.

Standards for Open

Molding Resin

and

Gel Coat Operations

63.5698

What

emission limit must

meet

for open molding resin

and gel coat

operations?

(a) You must limit

organic HAP

emissions from the five open molding

operations listed in paragraphs

(a)(1)

through

(5)

of this section to the

emission limit specified in

paragraph

Ib)

of this

section. Operations listed

paragraph

(d) are exempt from this

limit.

(1)

Production resin,

44234

Federal

66,

No.

163/Wednesday,

August

22,

2001/Rules

and

Regulations

(z)

Pigmented gel coat.

(3) Clear gel

coat.

(~)

Tooling resin.

(5)

Tooling gel coat.

(b)

You must limit

organic HAP

emissions

from open molding

operations to

the limit specified

equation I

of this section, based

on a 12-

month

rolling

average.

HAP Limit

=46(MR)+l59(MpG)+291(McG)+54(MTR)+214(MTG)

(Eq.

Where:

HAP

Limit= total allowable organic

HAP that can be emitted from the

open molding operations,

kilograms.

Mft

mass of production resin used in

the past 12

months, excluding any

materials exempt under paragraph

(d)

of this section, megagrams.

M1~0

mass of pigmented gel coatused

the past 12

months, excluding

any materials exempt under

paragraph

(d) of this section,

megagrams.

Mco

mass of clear gel coat used

in the

past

12 months, excluding any

materials exempt under paragraph

(d) of this section, megagrams.

MTR

mass of tooling resin used

in the

past 12 months, excluding any

materials exempt under

paragraph

(d) of this

section, megagrams.

MTG

mass of tooling gel coat used in

the past 12

months, excluding any

materials exempt under paragraph

(d)

of this

section, megagrams.

is the same for both new and existing

sources.

Cd) The materials specified in

paragraphs (d)(1) through (3)

of this

section

are exempt from the open

molding emission limit specified in

paragraph

(b) of this

section.

(1) Production resins (including skin

coat resins) that must meet

specifications

for use in

military vessels

or must be approved by the U.S. Coast

Guard

for use in the construction of

lifeboats,

rescue boats, and other life-

saving appliances approved under 46

CFR subchapter

or the construction

small passenger vessels regulated by 46

CFR subchapter T. Production resins for

which this

exemption is used must be

applied with nonatomizing

(non-spray)

resin application equipment. You must

keep a record of the resins for which

you are using this exemption.

(2) Pigmented, clear, and tooling gel

coat used

for part or mold repair and

touch up.

The total

gel coatmaterials

included

in this exemption must not

exceed

1 percent by weight of all

gel

coatused at your facility

on a 12-month

rolling-average basis.

You must keep a

record of the amount

of gel coats used

per month for which you are using this

exemption and copies of calculations

showing that the exempt amount

does

not exceed

1 percent of all gel coatused.

(3) Pure,

100 percent vinylester resin

used

for skin coats. This exemption

does not apply to blends of vinylester

and polyester resins used for skin coats.

The total resin materials included in the

exemption cannot exceed 5 percent by

weight of all resin used at your facility

on a 12-month rolling-average basis.

You must keep a record of the amount

of 100 percent vinylester skin coat resin

used per month

that is eligible

for this

exemption and copies of calculations

showing that the exempt amount does

not exceed 5 percent of all resin used.

63.5701

What are my options for

complying with the open molding

emission

limit?

You must use one or more of the

options listed

paragraphs (a) through

to meet the emission

limit in

63.5698 for theresins and gel

coats used

in open molding operations

at your facility.

(a)

Maximum

achievable control

technology (MACTI model point value

averaging (emissions averaging) option.

(1) Demonstrate that emissions

from

the open molding resin and gel coat

operations that you average meet the

emission limit in

63.5698

using the

procedures described

63.5 710.

Compliance with

this option

is based on

a 12-month rolling

average.

(2) Those operations

and materials not

included in the emissions average must

comply with either paragraph

(b)

or (c)

of this

section.

(b)

Compliant materials option.

Demonstrate compliance by using resins

and gel coats that meet the organic HAP

content requirements in Table

to this

subpart. Compliance with this

option

based on a 12-month rolling average.

(c)

Add-on control option.

Use an

enclosure and add-on control device,

and demonstrate that theresulting

emissions

meet the emission limit in

63.5698. Compliance with this option

is based on control

device performance

testing

and control

device monitoring.

63.5704

What

are the general

requirements for complying with the open

molding emission limit?

(a)

Emissions averaging option.

For

those open molding

operations and

materials complying

using the

emissions

averaging option,

you must

demonstrate compliance by

performing

the steps in paragraphs

(a)(I) through (5)

of this

section.

(1) Use the methods specified

63.5758 to determine the organic HAP

content of resins and gel coats.

(2)

Complete the calculations

described

63.5710

to show that the

organic HAP emissions do

not exceed

the limit specified in

63.5698.

(3)

Keep records as specified in

paragraphs (a)(3)(i) through (iv) of this

section

for each resin and gel coat.

(i) Hazardous air pollutant content.

(ii) Amount of material

used per

month.

(iii) Application method used

for

production resin and tooling resin. This

record is not required if all

production

resins and tooling resins are applied

with nonatomized technology.

(iv) Calculations performed to

demonstrate compliance based

MACT model point values,

as described

§ 63.5710.

(4) Prepare and submit the

implementation

plan described

§ 63.5 707

to theAdministrator and keep

it up to date.

(5) Submit

semiannual compliance

reports to

theAdministrator as specified

63.5764.

(b)

Compliant materials option.

For

each open molding operation complying

using the compliant materials option,

you must demonstrate compliance by

performing the steps in paragraphs

(b)(i) through (4)

of this

section.

(1) Use the methods

specified in

§ 63.5758 to determine the organic HAP

content of resins and gel coats.

(2) Complete

the calculations

described

63.5713 to show that the

weighted-average organic HAP content

does not exceedthe limit

specified

Table

2 to this

subpart.

(3) Keep records as specified

paragraphs

(b)(3)(i) through (iv) of this

section

for each resin and gel coat.

(i) Hazardous air pollutant content.

(ii) Application method

for

production resin and tooling resin. This

record is not required if all

production

resins and tooling resins are applied

with nonatomized

technology.

(iii) Amount ofmaterial

used per

month. This

record is not required for

an operation if all

materials used for

that operation comply with the organic

HAP

content requirements.

Federal

66,

No.

163/Wednesday,

August

22,

2001/Rules

and

Regulations

44235

(iv) Calculations

performed, if

required, to demonstrate compliance

based

on weighted-average organic HAP

content

as described

63.5713.

(4)

Submit semiannual compliance

reports to the Administrator as specified

63.5764.

(c)

Add-on control

option.

Ifyou are

using

an add-on control device, you

must demonstrate compliance by

performing the steps in paragraphs

(c)(I)

through

(5)

of this section.

(1) Conduct a performance test of the

control

device

as specified

in §~

63.5719

and 63.5722

demonstrate initial

compliance.

(2) Usethe performance test results to

determine control

device parameters to

monitor after the performance

test as

specified in

§ 63.5725.

(3) Comply with the operating limits

specified in

§ 63.5715 and the control

device and emission capture system

monitoring requirements specified

§ 63.5725

to demonstrate continuous

compliance.

(4) Keep the records specified in

§ 63.5767.

(5)

Submit to

theAdministrator the

notifications

and reports specified

§~

63.5761 and 63.5764.

63.5707

What is an implementation plan

for open molding operations and when do

I need to prepare one?

(a) You must prepare an

implementation

plan for all

open

molding operations for which you

comply by using the emissions

averaging

option described in

§ 63.5704(a).

(b) The implementation plan must

describe the steps you will

take to bring

the open molding operations

covered by

this subpart into compliance. For each

operation included in the emissions

average, your implementation plan

must

include the elements listed in

paragraphs

(b)(1) through

(3)

of this

section.

(1)

A description of each operation

included in the average.

(2) The maximum organic HAP

content of thematerials used, the

application method used (if any

atomized resin application methods are

used

in the average), and any other

methods used to

control emissions.

(3)

Calculations showing that the

operations covered by theplan will

comply with the open molding emission

limit

specified in § 63.5698.

implementation plan to the

Administrator with the notification of

compliance status specified

§ 63.5761.

(d) You must keep the

implementation

plan on site and

provide

it to the Administrator when

asked.

(e) Ifyou revise the implementation

plan, you must submit the revised plan

with your next semiannual compliance

report specified in

§ 63.5764.

63.5710

How do

I demonstrate

compliance using emissions averaging?

(a) Compliance using the emissions

averaging option is demonstrated

on a

12-month rolling-average basis and is

determined

at the end of every month

(12

times per year). Thefirst 12-month

rolling-average period begins

on the

compliance date specified in

§ 63.5695.

(b) At the end ofthe twelfth month

after your compliance date and at the

end of every subsequent month, use

equation

of this

section to

demonstrate

that the organic HAP

emissions from

those operations included in the average

do not exceed the emission limit in

63.5698

calculated for the same

12-

month period.

(Include terms in

equation

1 of

63.5698 and equation

of this section for only those operations

and materials included

in the average.)

HAP emissions

(PVR )(M

)

+ (PVPG )(M

)

+ (PV~0

)(M

)

+ (PVTR )(MTR

)

+ (PVTG

)(MTG

)

(Eq.

Where:

HAP emissions= Organic HAP

emissions calculated

using MACT

model point values for

each

operation included

in the average,

kilograms.

PVC=

Weighted-average MACT

model

point value

for production resin

used

in the past

months,

kilograms

per megagram.

MR= Mass of production resin used in

the past

months, megagrams.

PV50= Weighted-average MACT model

point value for pigmented gel coat

used in

thepast

months,

kilograms per megagram.

M~0=

Mass of pigmented gel coatused

in the past 12

months, megagrams.

PVcorr Weighted-average MACT model

point value for clear gel coat used

in the past

months, kilograms

per megagram.

MCG=

Mass of clear gel coatused in the

past

12 months, megagrams.

PVTR=

Weighted-average MACT model

point value for tooling resin used in

the past

months, kilograms

per

megagram.

MTR=

Mass of tooling resin used in the

past 12 months, megagrams.

~(M

P1/1)

Where:

n=number of different open molding

resins and gel coats used within

operation in the past

months.

PV=the MACT model point value for

resin or gelcoat i used

within an

operation in

thepast

months,

kilograms of HAP per megagram of

material

applied.

(d) You must use the equations in

Table

to this subpart to

calculate the

MACT model point value (PV1) for each

resin and gel coat used in each

operation in the past

12 months.

(e) Ifthe organic HAP emissions, as

calculated in paragraph

(b)

of this

section, are less than the organic HAP

(Eq.

limit

calculated

in §63.5698(b)

for the

same

12-month period, then you are in

compliance with the emission limit in

§ 63.5698 for those operations and

materials included in

the average.

63.5713

How do

I demonstrate

compliance

using compliant materials?

(a) Compliance using the organic HAP

content requirements listed in Table

this

subpart is based on

a 12-month

rolling averagethat is

calculated at the

end ofevery month.

Thefirst 12-month

rolling-average period begins on the

compliance date specified

§ 63.5695.

PVTG=

Weighted-average MACT model

point value

for tooling gel coatused

in the past 12 months, kilograms

per megagram.

MT0= Mass of tooling gel coat used in

the past

months, megagrams.

equation

of this

section to compute

theweighted-average MACT model

point value for each open molding resin

andgel coatoperation included in the

average.

PVopweighted-average MACT model

point value for each open molding

operation

(PVR,

PV~0,

PVco,

PVPVTR,

and PVPVTO) included in

the average, kilograms of HAP per

megagram of material applied.

M1=mass

of resin

or gel coat i used

within

an operation in the past 12

months, megagrams.

-1-

April 23, 2004

Exhibit

CROWNLINE BOATS, INC.

REVISED ADJUSTED

STANDARD LANGUAGE

alternative

compliance with

the

8 lb/hr

Rule found

IAC

~ 215.301,

this

adjusted

standard

allows Crownline

limit

its

discharge

of organic material

into

the

atmosphere

from

its

boat manufacturing operations

by operating in

full

compliance with the National Emission Standard

for Hazardous

Air

Pollutants

for New and

Existing Boat Manufacturing

Facilities,

set

forth at

CFR ~63 Subpart VVVV, as may be amended in

the future, and with the following conditions:

Crownine

shall continue

investigate boat production methods

with a reduced VOM

content and, where practicable,

shall substitute

current coatings with

lower

VOM content

coatings

as long as

such substitution does not result in a net increase in

VOM emissions.

Crownline shall be

required

any reasonable

test

of new

technologically or

economically

reasonable

production

methods

or materials applicable to

the

open-mold fiberglass boat manufacturing industry which may

reduce

VOM

emissions

at Crownline’s

facility

which

the

Illinois

EPA

Bureau

of Air

specifically

requests

writing that

they do.

annual report summarizing

the

activities and results

of these

investigatory

efforts

shall be

prepared

Crownine

and submitted

the

Illinois

EPA

Bureau of

Air,

Compliance and Enforcement Section.

The

relief

granted in

this

proceeding

shall

limited

the

emission

activities

at the

Crownline West Frankfort facility

as of the date of

this

filing

Nothing in

this

adjusted

standard

shall relieve Crownline

its

duty

operate in

full

compliance with the Clean

Air

Act,

its CAAPP, the Illinois Environmental Protection Act and other

applicable regulations not otherwise discussed herein.

1817792

F-

5/13/04

Exhibit

Crownline Boats, Inc.

Monthly Emissions Summary

12-Month

Rolling Total

Dec-03)

Nov-03)

Oct-03)

Sep-03)

Aug-03)

Jul-03)

Jun-03)

May-03)

Apr-03)

Mar-03)

Feb-03)

Jan-03)

Dec-02)

Monthly

VOM (tons)

6.101

11.801

16.381

19.42)

17.44)

15.29)

17.87)

21.97)

20.03)

19.24)

17.73)

16.80)

13.39)

HAP

(tons)

5.45)

10.84)

12.96)

16.00)

14.03)

12.29)

15.42)

18.36)

15.84)

17.42)

15.30)

14.59)

11.77)

12-Month Rolling Total

VOM

(tons)

183.27)

193.97)

210.88)

211.69)

205.76)

210.18)

208.86)

209.29)

207.27)

204.28)

199.21)

195.68)

191.10)

HAP

(tons)

153.91)

163.05)

176.91)

179.11)

174.90)

180.03)

179.54)

179.90)

178.43)

177.55)

172.36)

169.65)

165.66)

Boats Made

Monthly

238

271

435

388

409

354

390

473

374

375

355

361

278

12-Month Rolling

Total

4062.00)

4185.00)

4505.00)

4338.00)

4204.00)

4118.00)

4087.00)

4097.00)

4076.00)

4022.00)

3952.00)

3866.00)

3752.00)

Dec-03)

Nov-03)

Oct-03)

Sep-03)

Aug-03)

Jul-03)

Jun-03)

May-03)

Apr-03)

Mar-03)

Feb-03)

Jan-03)

Dec-02)

Monthly

Styrene(tons)

4.55)

8.01)

9.62)

10.63)

10.65)

8.87)

10.99)

14.41)

11.52)

13.38)

11.39)

10.37)

9.50)

MMA(tons)

0.79)

2.51)

2.17)

3.16)

2.77)

2.16)

3.25)

2.75)

3.25)

2.98)

2.72)

2.57)

1.62)

12-Month Rolling Total

Styrene (tons)

114.02)

119.84)

130.41)

132.80)

130.73)

135.44)

135.61)

124.62)

110.21)

98.69)

85.31)

73.92)

63.55)

MMA(tons)

28.51)

30.29)

31.71)

31.56)

30.11)

30.42)

30.02)

26.77)

24.02)

20.77)

17.79)

15.07)

12.50)

Dec-03)

Nov-03)

Oct-03)

Sep-03)

Aug-03)

Jul-03)

Jun-03)

May-03)

Apr-03)

Mar-03)

Feb-03)

Jan-03)

Dec-02)

Monthly

Toluene

(tons)

Hexane

(tons)

0.05)

0.23)

0.83)

1.88)

0.26)

0.85)

0.83)

0.87)

0.67)

0.76)

0.78)

1.27)

0.44)

0.01)

0.011

0.00)

0.02)

0.00)

12-Month

Rolling Total

Toluene (tons)

Hexane (tons)

8.01)

9.23)

10.50)

10.46)

9.80)

9.95)

9.82)

8.99)

8.12)

7.45)

6.69)

5.91)

4.64)

0.04)

0.05)

0.04)

0.03)

0.01)

5/13/04

Exhibit

Dec-03)

Nov-03)

Oct-03)

Sep-03)

Aug-03)

Jul-03)

Jun-03)

May-03)

Apr-03)

Mar-03)

Feb-03)

Jan-03)

Dec-02)

Monthly

DMP (tons)

DBP

(tons)

0.01)

0.16)

0.01)

0.15)

0.01)

0.08)

0.01)

0.24)

0.01)

0.15)

0.01)

0.12)

0.02)

0.18)

0.01)

0.09)

0.02)

0.23)

0.01)

0.08)

o.oo)

0.05)

12-Month Rolling Total

DMP (tons)

0.13)

0.14)

0.13)

0.12)

0.10)

0.09)

0.07)

0.06)

DBP

(tons)

1.40)

Dec-03)

1.48)

Nov-03)

1.69)

Oct-03)

1.65)

Sep-03)

1.60)

Aug-03)

1.64)

Jul-03)

1.48)

Jun-03)

1.33)

May-03)

1.21)

Apr-03)

1.03)

Mar-03)

0.94)

Feb-03)

0.71)

Jan-03)

0.63)

Dec-02)

Monthly

Xylene (tons)

0.01)

0.09)

0.07)

0.16)

0.05)

oil)

0.05)

0.05)

0.11)

0.04)

0.10)

o.o9)

MEK (tons)

0.04)

0.08)

0.07)

0.07)

0.09)

0.09)

0.06)

0.13)

0.14)

0.07)

0.12)

0.18)

0.07)

12-Month Rolling Total

Xylene (tons)

0.75)

0.84)

1.01)

0.98)

0.92)

0.94)

0.83)

0.78)

0.73)

0.62)

0.58)

0.48)

MEK (tons)

0.96)

Dec-03)

1.10)

Nov-03)

1.30)

Oct-03)

1.35)

Sep-03)

1.38)

Aug-03)

1.35)

Jul-03)

1.36)

Jun-03)

1.30)

May-03)

1.17)

Apr-03)

1.03)

Mar-03)

0.96)

Feb-03)

0.84)

Jan-03)

0.66)

Dec-02)

Monthly

Cumene (tons)

o.oi)

0.01)

o.oi)

0.01)

0.10)

0.00)

Other (tons)

0.00)

12-Month Rolling Total

5/13/04

Exhibit

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

Jun-02

May-02

Apr-02

Mar-02

Feb-02

Jan-02

15.32

17.19

13.49

21.86

13.97

18.30

19.95

17.04

14.17

14.20

12.22

12.93

15.16

11.79

19.16

11.80

15.78

16.89

14.96

12.23

12.59

10.60

313

268

254

323

400

452

320

305

269

247

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

9.08

12.01

8.56

15.36

9.04

2.31

2.02

1.71

3.08

1.76

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

1.06

0.79

1.22

0.41

0.72

0.01

0.00

___________

—

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

0.01

0.02

0.16

0.12

0.10

0.12

0.08

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

0.09

0.06

0.07

0.10

0.07

0.21

0.12

0.10

0.06

0.10

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

0.01

0.00

5/13/04

Exhibit C

5/13/04

Dec-03)

Nov-03)

Oct-03)

Sep-03)

Aug-03)

Jul-03)

Jun-03)

May-03)

Apr-03)

Mar-03)

Feb-03)

Jan-03)

Dec-02)

Monthly

VOM

(tons)

10.11)

17.33)

23.53)

27.07)

23.95)

18.69)

20.42)

25.79)

23.27)

23.77)

20.18)

19.25)

13.39)

HAP

(tons)

9.45)

16.38)

20.11)

23.65)

20.53)

15.94)

19.22)

23.08)

19.21)

20.45)

16.16)

15.63)

11.77)

12-Month

Rolling Total

VOM (tons)

234.11)

243.25)

254.63)

248.29)

234.71)

232.62)

227.90)

225.78)

219.94)

213.71)

204.11)

198.13)

191.10)

HAP (tons)

204.18)

210.36)

218.68)

213.73)

201.87)

200.50)

196.36)

192.92)

186.73)

182.48)

174.26)

170.69)

165.66)

Boats Made

Monthly

238

271

435

388

409

354

390

473

374

375

355

361

278

12-Month

Rolling Total

4062.00)

Dec-03)

4185.00)

Nov.03)

4505.00)

Oct-03)

4338.00)

Sep-03)

4204.00)

Aug-03)

4118.00)

Jul-03)

4087.00)

Jun-03)

4097.00)

May-03)

4076.00)

Apr-03)

4022.00)

Mar-03)

3952.00)

Feb-03)

3866.00)

Jan-03)

3752.00)

Dec-02)

Monthly

Styrene(tons)

8.56)

13.54)

16.77)

18.29)

17.25)

12.21)

14.26)

18.58)

14.36)

15.89)

12.21)

11.37)

9.50)

MMA(tons)

0.79)

2.51)

2.17)

3.16)

2.67)

2.47)

3.79)

3.30)

3.78)

3.49)

2.76)

2.62)

1.62)

12-Month Rolling Total

Styrene

(tons)

161.92)

164.73)

169.77)

165.01)

155.28)

153.39)

150.22)

135.96)

117.38)

103.02)

87.13)

74.92)

63.55)

MMA

(tons)

30.89)

Dec-03)

32.72)

Nov-03)

34.14)

Oct-03)

33.99)

Sep-03)

32.54)

Aug-03)

32.95)

Jul-03)

32.24)

Jun-03)

28.45)

May-03)

25.15)

Apr-03)

21.37)

Mar-03)

17.88)

Feb-03)

15.12)

Jan-03)

12.50)

Dec-02)

Monthly

Toluene (tons)

0.05)

0.23)

0.83)

1.88)

0.26)

0.85)

0.83)

0.87)

0.67)

0.76)

0.78)

1.27)

0.44)

Hexane (tons)

0.01)

0.00)

0.02)

0.00)

12-Month Rolling Total

Toluene (tons)

8.01)

9.23)

io.so)

10.46)

9.80)

9.95)

9.82)

8.99)

8.12)

7.45)

6.69)

5.91)

4.64)

Hexane

(tons)

0.04)

0.05)

0.04)

0.03)

0.01)

1This chart was

prepared

to estimate what Crownhine’s air emissions would have been if

it made the

same number

and models of boats as it did in the

months shown, but Crownline was not complying with 40 CFR Part 63,

Subpart

VVVV (the “MACT”).

Crownline Boats, Inc.

Monthly Emissions Summary

If Crownilne Was Not Complying with

MACT1

12-Month Rolling Total

Exhibit

5/13/04

Exhibit D

Dec-031

Nov-03)

Oct-03)

Seo-031

Auci-03)

Jul-03)

Jun-03)

May-03)

Aor-03)

Mar-03)

Feb-03)

Jan-03)

Dec-02)

Monthly

DMP

(tons)

0.01)

o.oi)

0.01)

o.oi)

0.02)

0.01)

0.02)

0.01)

0.00)

DBP (tons)

0.16)

0.15)

0.08)

0.24)

0.15)

0.12)

0.18)

o.og)

0.23)

0.08)

0.05)

12-Month Rolling Total

DMP

(tons)

0.13)

0.14)

0.13)

0.12)

0.10)

o.og)

0.07)

0.06)

DBP (tons)

1.40)

1.48)

1.69)

1.65)

1.60)

1.64)

1.48)

1.33)

1.21)

1.03)

0.94)

0.71)

0.63)

Dec-03)

Nov-03)

Oct-03)

Sep-03)

Aug-03)

Jul-03)

Jun-03)

May-03)

Apr-03)

Mar-03)

Feb-03)

Jan-03)

Dec-02)

Monthly

Xylene (tons)

0.01)

0.09)

0.07)

0.16)

0.05)

0.11)

0.05)

0.11)

0.04)

0.10)

0.09)

MEK (tons)

0.04)

0.08)

0.07)

0.09)

0.06)

0.13)

0.14)

0.07)

0.12)

0.18)

0.07)

12-Month Rolling Total

Xylene (tons)

MEK (tons)

0.75)

0.84)

1.01)

0.98)

0.92)

0.94)

0.83)

0.78)

0.73)

0.62)

0.58)

0.48)

0.96)

1.10)

1.30)

1.35)

1.38)

1.35)

1.36)

1.30)

1.17)

1.03)

0.96)

0.84)

0.66)

Dec-03)

Nov-03)

Oct-03)

Sep-03)

Aug-03)

Jul-03)

Jun-03)

May-03)

Apr-03)

Mar-03)

Feb-03)

Jan-03)

Dec-02)

Monthly

Cumene (tons)

0.01)

0.10)

0.00)

Other (tons)

0.00)

o.oo)

0.00)

12-Month Rolling Total

Cumene

(tons)

0.10)

0.20)

0.19)

0.18)

0.17)

0.16)

0.15)

0.14)

0.04)

Other (tons)

0.00)

5/13/04

Exhibit D

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

15.32

17.19

13.49

21.86

13.97

12.93

15.16

11.79

19.16

11.80

313

268

254

323

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

9.08

12.01

8.56

15.36

9.04

2.31

2.02

1.71

3.08

1.76

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

1.06

0.79

1.22

0.41

0.72

0.01

0.00

--~.-.-

---.--.

—-

----

5/13/04

Exhibit D

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

0.01

0.02

0.16

0.12

0.10

0.12

0.08

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

0.09

0.06

0.07

0.10

0.07

0.21

0.12

0.10

0.06

0.10

Nov-02

Oct-02

Sep-02

Aug-02

Jul-02

0.01

0.00

1~~