~ ~uLuLri~’~
11U,
3 ~ uu.~,
Iu-u:J
RECEIVED
ru~
CLERK~OFFICE
NOV
52003
BEFORE TEE
ILLINOIS
POLLUTION CONTROL BOAI~QATEOF ILLINOIS
BYRON SANIJBERG,
)
Pollution Control Board
)
Petitioner,
)
)
vs.
)
No. PCB
04-33
)
(Third-Party Pollution Control Facility Siting
THE CIT~(OF KANKAKEE, ILLrN0LS, CITY
)
Appeal)
COUNCIL, TOWN AND COUNTRY
)
UTILITIES, INC. and KANKAKEE REGIONAL)
LANDFILL, L.L.C.,
)
)
Respondents,
)
)
WASTE MANAGEMENT OF ILLiNOIS, INC.
)
)
Petitioner,
)
)
vs.
)
)
PCB
04-34
TJ~ CITY OF KANKAXEE, ILLINOIS, CITY
)
(Third-PartyPollution Control Facility Siting
COUNCIL, TOWN AND COUNTRY
)
Appeal)
UflLITIES, INC. and KANKAKEE REGIONAL)
LANDFILL, L.L.C.,
)
).
Respondents,
)
___
_________________
)
)
)
)
COUNTY OF
KANKAKEE, ILLINOIS and
)
EDWARD D. SMITH,
KANKAKEE
COUNTY
)
STATE’S ATTORNEY,
)
Petitioner,
)
PCB 04-35
)
(Third-PartyPollution Control Facility
vs.
)
Siting Appeal)
)
(Consolidated)
TEE CITY OF KANKAKEE, ILLiNOIS, CiTY
)
COUNCIL, TOWN
AND COUNTRY
)
UTJLTflES, INC. ~ndKANKAKEE
REGIONAL)
LANDFiLL,
L.L.C.
)
Respondents.
)
7O3S3~E7v1827i67
~ I~uLuLr
iLiLiI~
d?~.Lii
~~UULi
lu.uLi
CLERK’S OFFICE
NOV
5 2003
STATE OF ILLINOIS
FETITIONER’S
RESPONSE
TO
RESPONDENTS’ MOTIO~p S1~J~o!
Board
INT13~EROGATORJES
NOW
COME
the COUNTY OF
KANKAKEE and EDWARD
D. SMITH, STATE’S
ATTORNEY
OP
KAINKAKEE COUNTY, Petitioners
in. the above
matter, and
in response to
Respondent’s Motion to Strike the Interrogatoxies propounded by the Counly of Kankakee,
illinois, state as follows:
1.
The interrogatories propounded by the County of Kankakee, illinois and Edward
D. Smith should not be stricken
2.
The interrogatories propounded by the County ofKankakee, Illinois and Edward
D. Smith contain 13 questions, 11 of which contain subparts simply seeking more detailed
information concerning the respective interrogatories.
3.
Those subparts do not ask for different information than what is contained in the
interrogatories themselves; therefore, they should not be counted in the total number of
ixiterrogatories because those subparts cannot stand on their own as separate questions.
4.
All
of
the information sought in the interrogatories and subparts of the
interrogatories propounded by the County of Karikakee, Illiripis and Edward IJ. Smith is
necessary for a full and fair presentation of the facts of this case.
5.
This
case
involves a landfill siting hearing involving tens of thousands of
docinuents with the local enviromnent at stake.
6.
This is a situation where it is necessary that there be specific inSorniation received
by Petitioners concerning the fundamental fairness ofthe entire landfill siting hearing.
7.
Without the information sought in each of the interrogations and subparts,
Petitioners will be unduly prejudiced because they wiil be
without
essential information
that
Petitioners cannot elicit from any other source.
7O3835~7V1S271~7
~ ~ULDCMI~LiII
~LIUJ
iU.U~
r.
8.
Requiring Respondents to answer the interrogatories and subparts propounded by
the County ofKankakee, illinois and Edward D. Smith.will not cause prejudice to Respondents.
WHEREFORE, Petitioners, COUNTY
OF
KANKAKEE and EDWARD
D. SMITH,
STATE’S ATTORNEY OF
K.ANKAKEE
COUNTY, request that this Board deny Respondent’s
Motion to Strike 1nten~ogatories.
Dated: November
5,
2003
Respectfully submitted,
EDWARD D. SMITH
KANKAKEE
COUNTY
STATE’S ATTORNEY AND TEIIE COUNTY
OF
KANKAKEE
By:
HINSHAW & CULBERTSON
__
-
One ofIts
Attorneys
HNSHAW AND CULBERTSON
100 Park Avenue
P.O. Box 1389
Rockford~,IL61105-1389
815-490-4900
7O3S~5~7vlS2767
flI~?~
~ LULDI~Jf~
rO~0~
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
~uuj
~
r.uZ’
The
undersigned, pursuant to the
provisions ofSection 1-109 ofthe Illinois Code of Civil
Procedure, hereby
under
penalty of
perjury
under the laws of
the
United States of
America,
certifies that on
November
5,
2003, a copy of
the
foregoing
was served
upon:
DorothyM. Gwm, Clerk
Illinois Pollution ControlBoard
James
K. Thompson Center
100
West Randolph Street, Suite 11-500
Chicago, IL 60601-3218
Attorney George Mueller
501 State Street
Ottawa, IL 61350
(815) 433-4705
(815) 433-4913
FAX
Donald J. Moran
Pederson & Houpt
161 N.
Clark Street, Suite 3100
Chicago,
IL 60601-3242
(312) 261-2149
(312) 261-1149FAX
ElizabethHarvey, Esq.
Swanson, Martin & Bell
One IBM Plaza, Suite 2900
330
North
Wabash
Chicago, IL
60611
(312)
321-9100
(312) 321-0990
FAX
Kenneth
A. Leshen
Christopher W.
Bohlen
Patrick
Power
City
of
Kaxikakee
Corporate Counsel
385
East
Oak
Street
Kankakee, IL
60901-1787
(815) 933-3385
(815) 933-3397
FAX
7Q37’18~3V~~21l67
nhI,,)rI.~w
~ ~ULDcJcI~c’I~
ra?c;ol3—~)—i~Ci
~U~f
Z) ~~UUQ iu;uo
r.ur)
Byron Sandberg
109
Raub
St.
Donovan,
IL 60931
byronsandberg~starband.uet
Aiijanita Dunias,
Clerk
City of
Kankakee
385 E. Oak Street
Kankakee, IL
60901
(815)
933-0480
(815)
933-0482
FAX
ClaireA~Manning
Posegate & Denes, P.C.
111 N. Sixth Street
Springfield, IL
62705
(217) 522-6152
(217)522-6184
FAX
Bradley
P. Hailoran, Hearing
Officer
Illinojs Pollution Control Board
James R. Thompson Center, Suite 11-500
100 W. Randolph Street
Chicago, IL 60601
(312) 814-8917
(312) 814-3669 FAX
By
faxing
a copy thereof, at or before the hour of
10:00 A.M., addressed as above.
BINSHAW &
CUTLBERTSON
100 Park
Avenue
P.O. Box 1389
Rockford,
Illinois
61105-1389
(815) 490-4900
?0377853v1 ~27167
I.,~_fllr1T( C~
~uLLJLrI~)c~I~
I
I.UI.iU~J~J.JU.~
I~U~ ~J ~UUJ
IU.UZJ
r.u.I
• CLERKS OFrICE
~~A~ORNEys
AT
SON
NOV
52003
LAW
CFAM~’A~Q~•~LLJNOLS
100 Park Avenue
STATE OF ILL11~4O~
CH~cAGc,!LL~OI5
P.O. Box 1389
~
FP.A3’CISCO. CAl OI~NIA
Board
CRYSTAL LA~(E,ILLINOIS.
Rockfo-d,
IL
61105.1389
FT. ~
FLORIDA
JoLrer, ILLINOTS
815-490~4900
JACI~SONVXLLE,FLORIDA
LiSLE.
aijr.~oi.~
Facsimile 815-490-4901.
IAjIII, FLORIDA
OIUA. ILLiNoIS
\ww,hin5hawcu1be~oncorn
TAh~A,
FLOkIDA
ROCKFO1W, ILLINOIS
SCHER.ERVULE,
INDIANA
SPP.DIGPIELD,
ILLJNOIS
RPor@1~inshaw~
aw.
corn
Mfl’INnAP0LIS, MNSSOTA
WAUKEGAN, ILLn’loTs
ST.
LOUIS, 1’CSSOTJ1~J
PlIOENIX,ARIZONA
N~WYOE~cNEWYORK
MILWAUKEE,APPL2TON,
WISCONSINW5CONSIN
FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION
TO BE DELTVERED IMMEDIATELY
TO:
COMPANY:
FAX
NO.:
PHONE NO.:
Dorothy M. Gunu
JIPCB
312/814-3620
George Mueller
433-4913
433-4705
Donald J. Moran
Pederson & H~p~
312/261-1149
312/261-2149
KennethA.Leshen
.
933~3397
933-33~
Anjanita Dumas
Clerk
933-0482
933-0480
Swanson, Martin
& Bell
312/321-0990
312/321-9100
~~Denes
217/522-6184
217/522-6152
BradHalloran
LPCB
312/814-3669
312/814-8917
DATE;
November
5,
2003
FROM: Richard S. Porter
USER ID
a4549
MATTER
NAME:
Kankakee
‘
MATTER NO,:
827167
—
NO. OF PAGES (includthg
thL~
Cover):
~,
—
SENDING OJ’ERATOR~
Danita
COMMENTS, IF ~NY:
HARD COPY:
~ Will follow by mail
D Will follow by overnight mail
~ Will not follow
II you do not receive the number of pages listed above,
please
enfl
the number indicated
above.
The documents that accompany this
fRcslnsile
contain ~onfidentla1 and privileged Information and are intended solely for the use of
the
individual orentity to whom this
transmission Is directed. Any disdosure ofthe Information herein is unauthorized
and
strictly prohibited-
If
you are not the intended
recipient of this facsimile, please re~p~ndby facsimile to the number above or
call
the sending operator at our expense immediately so
that we may arrange for the return ofthis document to us at no coat to you. Thank you.
70354293v 513053