BEFORE THE ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
Dynegy Midwest Generation, Inc.
Refurbishment ofLow NOx Burner Unit 3/
Seiparated Overfire Air System
Property Identification Numbers
02-1 0-100-001
TO:
Dorothy Gunn, Clerk
Illinois Pollution Control Board
State ofIllinois Center
100 W. Randolph Street, Suite 11-500
Chicago, Illinois 60601
Steve Santarelli
Illinois Department ofRevenue
101 West Jefferson
P.O. Box 19033
Springfield, Illinois 62794
Date: October
15,
2003
)
)
PCBC)~j~-G(
)
(Tax Certification)
)
)
NOTICE
Donna Redmon
Tax Manager
Dynegy Midwest Generation, Inc.
1000 Louisiana, Suite 5800
Houston, Texas 77002
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that I have today filed with the Office ofthe Pollution Control
Board the APPEARANCE AND RECOMMENDATION of the Illinois Environmental
Protection Agency, a copy of which is herewith served upon you.
ILLINOIS ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
1021 North Grand Avenue East
P.O. Box 19276
Springfield, IL 62794-9276
Telephone: 217/782-5544
Facsimile: 217/782-9807
TDD:
217/782-9143
I__
Robb H. La)~a~’~
Special Assistant Attorney General
ARDC #6205498
THIS FILING IS SUBMITTED
ON RECYCLED PAPER
ocr
BEFORE THE ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
Dynegy Midwest Generation, Inc.
)
Refurbishment ofLow NOx Burner Unit 3/
)
Separated Overfire Air System
)
PCB
Property IdentificationNumbers
)
(Tax Certification)
02-10-100-001
)
Q’1 ~
p~
~
APPEARANCE
Q
(J~
‘2C~ ~/
I hereby file my Appearance in this proceeding on behalf of the Illinois Enviromnenf~l’.&0
s~
Protection Agency.
Robb H. Layman
Special Assistant Attorney General
ARDC
#6205498
DATED: October
15,
2003
ILLINOIS ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
1021 North Grand Avenue East
P.O. Box 19276
Springfield, Illinois 62794-9276
Telephone: 217/782-5544
Facsimile: 217/782-9807
THIS FILING IS SUBMITTED
TDD:
217/782-9143
ON RECYCLED PAPER
BEFORE THE ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
Dynegy Midwest Generation, Inc.
)
Refurbishment ofLowNOx Burner Unit 3/
)
Separated Overfire Air System
)
)
PCB
Property Identification Numbers
)
(Tax Certification)
02-10-100-001
)
04,
)
RECOMMENDATION
Now Comes
the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (“Illinois EPA”), through its
attorneys, and pursuant to Section 125.204 ofthe Illinois Pollution Control Board’s (“Board”)
regulations, files the following Recommendation regarding the tax certification ofair pollution
control facilities pursuant to 35 Ill. Adm. Code 125.204.
1)
On April 29, 2003, the Illinois EPA received a request from DynegyMidwest Generation,
Inc. foran Illinois EPA recommendation regarding the tax certification of air pollution
control facilities pursuant to 35 Ill. Adm. Code 125.204, and noted the request as log
number TC-03-04-29H. (Exhibit A).
2)
The applicant’s address is:
Donna Redmon
Tax Manager
Dynegy Midwest Generation, Inc.
1000 Louisiana
Suite 5800
Houston, Texas 77002
3)
The air pollution control facilities in this request are located at 10901 Baldwin Road, Box
146, Baldwin, Randolph County and consist ofthe following:
Refurbishment of Low NOx Burner Unit 3/ Separated Overfire Air System which
reduces NOx emissions from the existing low NOx system. Because the primary
purpose ofthis system is to reduce or eliminate air pollution, it is certified as a
pollution control facility.
4.
Section 11-10 ofthe Property Tax Code, 35 ILCS 200/11-10 (2000), defines “pollution
control facilities” as: “any system, method, construction, device or appliance appurtenant
thereto or any portion ofany building or equipment, that is designed, constructed,
installed or operated for the primarypurpose of: (a) eliminating, preventing, or reducing
air or water pollution
. . .
or (b) treating, pretreating, modifying or disposing of any
potential solid, liquid or gaseous pollutant which if released without treatment,
pretreatment modification or disposal might be harmful, detrimental or offensive to
human, plant or animal life, or to property.”
5.
Pollution control facilities are entitled to preferential tax treatment, 35 ILCS 200/11-5
(2000).
6.
Based on the information in the application and the purpose ofthe facilities, to prevent,
eliminate or reduce air pollution, it is the Illinois EPA’s engineeringjudgment that the
described facilities may be considered “pollution control facilities,” pursuant to 35 Ill.
Adm. Code 125.200(a), with the primary purpose ofeliminating, preventing, or reducing
air pollution, or as otherwise provided in 35 Ill. Adm. Code 125.200. Therefore, the
facilities are eligible for tax certification from the Board.
7.
Therefore, the Illinois EPA recommends that the Board issue the requested tax
certification.
ILLINOIS ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,
By:
~
Robb H. Layman
c.1
Special Assistant Attorney General
OfCounsel:
Charles E. Matoesian
Assistant Counsel
October
15,
2003
1021 North Grand Ave. E.
P.O. Box 19276
Springfield, Illinois 62794-9276
Telephone:
217/782-5544
Facsimile:
217/782-9807
TDD:
217/782-9143
Illinois
1. NAME OF APPLICANT~•
:
Dynegy Midwest Generation, Inc.
2. PERSON AUTHORIZED TO RECEIVE CERTIFICATION.
Donna Redmon
ADDRESS
(Street, atj’,
State, Zip
Code)
2828 North Monroe Street
Decatut IL
62526
TITLE
Tax Manager
ADDRESS
(Street, City, State, Zip Code)
1000 Louisiana, Suite 5800, Houston, TX 77002
iSSUED
S
~IGNED(Officia1ofStaceAgency)
THIS__DAYOF
19
.
STATE CERTIFICATION NUMBER
TITLE
* U.S. GOVERNMENT~ PRINTING OFFICE: SGI1—720—11i
CNVIMONMENTAL r
n~
i ~
NOTICE OF STATE CERTIFICATION
(Pursuant to Section 169 of the Internal Revenue
Code of
1954,
as amended)
Form Approved
0MB No. 158—.R 0013
UR POLLUTION CONTROL AGENCY OR
EnvironmentalProtection Agency
It Is hereby certified that the control facility described In the attachedapplication is in conformity with State and local programs and
requirements for the control of 0 water pollution ~
air pollution, as required by section 169 of the Internal Revenue Code
of 1954, as
amended, and regulations issued thereunder. According
to the applicant,
this controlfacility
~
was placed
0
will be placelin operation on
December 18, 2001
,
19
In the case of control facility
not yet in
operation, this notice
is
certification only that the control facility, if constructed and operated
in accordance with the application, will be in conformity with State and local programs or requirements for abitement or control of water or
air pollution.
..
3. DESCRIPTION OF CONTROL FACIUTY
S
Refurbishment of Baldwin Energy Complex Unit 3 low-NOx burner/separated overfire air (SOFA) system to
improve the operability and flexibility ofthe existmg low NOx system The refurbishment includes
• Maintenance and refurbishment ofvarious, existing SOFA components;
• Replace existing SOFA tilt drives with new hydraulic tilt drives; and.
• Replace air, SOFA, and coal nozzles for better performance with PRB fuel
6.USE OF THE CONTROL FACILITY CERTIFIED HEREBY IS IN CONFORMITY WITH THE FOLLOWiNG APPLICABLE. STATE
PLAN
OR
• REQUI REMENTS FOR THE CONTROL OF
0
WATER POLLUTION
AIR POLLUT1ON.
35
lilmois Administrative Code 217 Subparts V & W
4. LOCATION OF ~ONTROL FACILITY
(Street, City,
State, Zip
Code)
10901 BaldwinRoad, Box 146, Baldwin, IL 62217
N/A
RECEIVING BODY OR STREAM
•
OF WATER,
;
S
IF
ANY
EPA Form 3300—2 (8—77)
.4
• ~.
U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1977..729—178
Form Approved
0MB No. 158—R0013
U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
S. S
• S
•
•
S
NOTICE OF FEDERAL CERTIFICATION
S
S
•
S
•
S
(Pursuant to Section
16~
of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954, as amendedi
•
S
PLEASE TAXENOTICE that pursuant to section 169 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954, as amended, and Part 20 of Title 40 of the
Code of Federal Regulations. the control facility identified herein
•
•
S
• • •
•
S
S S
•
•
•
El Is ct~rtifled
S
•
0 Will, Ifconstructed, reconstructed, acquired, erected, Installed
•
S
•
S
S
and operated in accordance with the accompanying application,
•
S
S
becertified
•
S
•
••
•
as being in compliance with the applicable regulations of Federal agencies and the general policies of the UnIted States for cooperation with
the States 1st the prevention and abatement of ~
water pollution ~
air pollution under the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as
• amended (33 U.S.C. 1251 et seq.) or the aean Air Act, as amended (42 U.S.C. 1857 et ~qJ. This certification is based on facts furnithed
• by the ap~Iicant,and is valid for purposes of section 169 only to the extent that such facts are complete and accurate.
•
S
EPA Form 3300—3 (8—77)
• •
.
L.NAME OF APPLICANT
S
•.
•
•
Dyne~yMidwest Generation, InC.5
•
•
•
ADDRESS
(Street, City, State, Zip Code)
S
2828 North Monroe Street
•
S
•
•
D
eca
tur
,.
IL 62526
S
• •• •
5
•
•
S
•
S
•
~.
EMPLOYER IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
•
•
5
.
37-1385459
•
3.
PERSON AUTHORIZED TO RECEIVE CERTIFICATION:
S
•
•
S
S
•
S
NAME
•
S
•••
S
•
•
S
•
S
•
S
•
DonnaRedmon
•
ADDRESS
(Street,
City, State, Zip Code)
•
S
1000 Louisiana,
S
• •
Suite
•
5800,
•
HoustOn,
S
•
TX 77002
S
•
••
5
555
•
S
TITLE
• • .
•
S
•
S
•
S
•
•
•
TaxManager
•
S
,.
ijn~~t~iriuijii
~r
‘.,jr~,
1w’.
FACILITY
• •
5
.5
5 5
5
S
5
Refurbishment ofBaldwin Energy Complex Unit 3 low-NOx burner/separated overfire air (SOFA) system to
improve the operability and flexibihty ofthe existing low NOx system The refurbishment includes
‘~
Mainte~ianceand refurbishment ofvarious, existing SOFA components;
S
•
S
• Replace existing SOFA tilt drives withnew hydraulic tilt drives; and
•
• Replace air, SOFA, and coal nozzles for better performance with PRB fuel.
• •
.5
S. LOCATION OF CONTROL FACILITY
(Street,
City,
State, Zip
Code)
5
5
5
5
5
5
10901 Baldwin Road,Box 146,Baldwin, IL
62217
•
S
•
S
•
S
•
•
•
• • • :
6.EFFLUEtIT DISCHARGEDTO
•
•
• •
S
•
•
S
•
•
S
S
N/A:~
....
.
•;••
•,•
5
:
r.
THE CONTROL FACILITY IDENTIFIED HEREIN
0
DOES
El
DOES NOT GENERATE PROFITS THROUGH THE RECOVERY
AND
SALES
OF
WASTES,SOR
OTHERWISE.
S
•
.
S
•
•
S~
5
5 5 5 5
5
5
I.
THE
CONTROL FACILITY IDENTIFIED HEREIN
0
IS
El
IS NOT A BUILDING THE ONLY FUNCTI ON OF WHICH IS ThE ABATEMENT OR
CONTROL OF POLLUTION,AS DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION i~169.2(2) (I) OF THE INCOME TAX REGULATIONS.
~0
A. THE CONTROL FACI LIT’,’ IDENTIFIED HEREIN IS USED ONLY IN CONNECTION WITHPLANTS OR PROPERTiES THAT WERE IN
•
•
•
SERVICEONOR BEFORE DECEMBER 31, 1975
•
•
•
5
5
•
S
•
•
•
•
S
• .
•
•El
B.
.j22_.°1t
OF THE AMORTIZABLE BASISSOF THE FACILITY IS i~LLOCAEILETOITS USE IN CONNECTION WITH PLANTS OR PROP.
•
ERTIESTHAT WERE IN SERVICE ON OR BEFORE DECEMBER 31,1975.
5
5
5
5
5 5 5 5
10.
5
5 5
55
A. THE CONTROL FAd
LITY
PERFORMS NO FUNCTION IN ADDITION TO THE ABATEMENT OR CONTROL OF POLLUTION.
0
a.
‘I.
OF ThESAMORTIZABLE BASIS OF TI-IC CONTROL FACILITY IS ALLOCABLE TO THE ABATEMENT OR CONTROL OF
•
POLLUTION~
S
S
S5
•
S
•
•
5
•
S
ISSUED
.
S
•~
S
S
•
THIS
.
DAYOF
•
,19
•
SIGNATURE
S
•
•
•
S•
.
S
STATE CERTIFICATION NUMBER
S
•
•
•
•
IITLE
5
.
.
SS
5
5
5
5
•
•
.~
U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1977—729—015
Form
Approved
0MB No.
158—R0013
5
5
5
.S
•
•
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
5:
5
S
•
•
•
APPLICATION FOR CERTIFICATION OF POLLUTION CONTROL FACILITY
•
S
S
(Pursuant to Section 169 of the InternaiRevenue Code
of1954. as amended)
S
S
•
NO CERTIFICATION MAY BE
MADE
UNLESS A COMPLETED APPLICATION FORM
HAS
BEEN RECEIVED (26 U.S.C. §169;
40 C.F.R.
PART
20). IF NO CLAIM OF BUSINESS CONFIDENTIALITY ACCOMPANIES THIS INFORMATION WHEN IT IS RECEIVED BY
-EPA, IT MAY BE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC BY EPA
WITHOUT
FURTHER NOTiCE. INFORMATION COVERED BYSA CLAIM
OF CONFIDENTIALITY WILL BE DISCLOSED BY EPA ONLY TO THE EXTENT,
AND
BY MEANS OF THESPROCEDURES, SET FORTH IN
TITLE 40, CODE OF FEDERAL REGULATIONS,
PART
2,41 C.F.R. 26902
et
seq..
SEPTEMBER 1, 1976.
•
5
5
5.
A BUSINESS CONFIDENTIALITY CLAIM COVERING
ALL
OR PART OF
THE
INFORMATION FURNISHED IN OR WITH THIS
APPLICATION MAY BE ASSERTED BY PLACING ON (OR ATTACHING TO) THE INFORMATION AT THE TIME IT IS SUBMITTED To
EPA, A COVER SHEET STAMPED OR TYPED LEGEND, OR OTHER SUITABLE’FOItM OF NOTICE EMPLOYING LANGUAGE SUCH AS
“TRADE SECRET,” “PROPRIETARY,” OR “COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL.” ALLEDGEDLY CONFIDENTIAL PORTIONS OF OTHERWISE
NON-CONFIDENTIAL DOCUMENTS SHOULD BE CLEARLY IDENTIFIED,
AND
MAY BESUBMITTED SEPARATELY TO FACILITATE
IDENTIFICATION
AND HANDLING
BY EPA. IF THE APPLICANT DESIRES CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT ONLY UNTIL A CERTAIN
DATE OR UNTIL
THE
OCCURRENCEOF A CERTAIN EVENT, THE NOTICE SHOULD SO STATE.
•
S
• Application is hereby made for certification of the pollution control facility
-
described herein. The following information is submitted in. accordance, with
provisions of Part 20 of Title 40 of the Code of Federal Regulations and to the best.
of my knowledge and belief is true and correct.
S
S
•
APPLICANT.
•
S S
•~~•
5
5
5
•
Dynegy Midwest
Generation, Inc
DATE
•
•
S•
5
5
5
5
5
April 22,2003
STREET ADDRESS, CITY, STATE. ZIP CODE.
1000 Lousiana Street, Suite 5800
Houston, Texas 77002
SIGNATURE
•
S
•
•
5
5
5
5
TITLE
Director, Environmental
S
•
NOTE: READ ACCOMPANYING INSTRUCTIONS
CAREFULLY PRIOR
TO COMPLETING
FORM,
EPAForm 3300—1 (Rev. 8—77)..
•
:
•
• .
PREVIOUS EDITION IS 03S0LErE
•
S
•
•
S
5
5
5
5
5
PAGE1OF5
‘ORIGINAL
SS
5
5 5
5 5
S
•
SECTION A-
IDENTITY AND LOCATION OF CONTROL FACILITY
S
i.FL.ILL
BUSINESS NAME OF APPLICANT
5
Dynegy.Midwest Generation, Inc.
5
S
555
S~
S
••
.
S
•
2.
TYPE OF OWNERSHIP
S
S
0
INDIVIDUAL
0
OTHER
(Describe,).
•
0
PARTNERSHIP
S
• •
5
El CORPORATION
.
S
5
3. pERSON TO CONTACT REGARDING THIS APPLICATION
~‘Name
and ThleJ
.
TELEPHONE
S
•
Starla Lacy, Director, Environmental
S
5
•
5
•
713-767-8961
AOPRESS
(Street, t’ity, State, Zip Code)
S
S
•
S -
1000 Louisiana,Suite 5800, Houston, TX 77002
.
S
S
à~liRSONAUTHORIZED TO RECEIVE
CERTIFICATION
(Name ‘and Title)
•
.
•
Donna Redmon
.
S S
-
Tax Manager
S
•
5
ADDA
ESS
(Street, CYty,
State, Zip Code) :
.
•
S
S
•
S
S
•
S
1000 Louisiana, Suite 5800, Houston, TX 77002
.
. .
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5 5
5
5. BUSINESS NAME OF PLANT
(If
differentfrom
Item)) (Street, City, State, Zip Code)
•
6.
APPLiCANT’S
SSS
S
•
S
•
5
5
•.
5
5
.
EMPLOYER
Baldwin Energy Complex
5 5
5
5
5
55
IDENTIFICATION NO.
55
10901 Baldwin Road, Box146,Baldwin, IL 62217
S•
•
37-1385459
.
SECTION B
-
DESCRIPTION OF CONTROL FACILITY
•
S
S
1. DESCRIBE
THE FACILITY FOR WHICH CERTIFIcATION IS
SOUGHT. INCLUDE TYPE
OF EQUIPMENT. MANUFACTURER AND MODEL
• NUMBER. SUBMITDESIGN
CRITERIA, ENGINEERING REPORT AND/OR PERFORMANCE SPECIFICATIONS WHICH DESCRIBE
• FUNCTIONAND OPERATIONOF FACILITY:
5
5
5 5
5
•
5
5
5
5
5
Refurbishment of BaldwinEnergy Complex Unit 3 low-NOx burner/separated overfire air (SOFA) system to
improve the operability and flexibihty ofthe existmg low NOx system The refurbishment includes
• Maintenance and refurbishment ofvarious, existing SOFA components;
S
S
• Replace existing SOFA tilt drives with new hydraulic tilt drives; and
• Replace air, SOFA, and coal nozzles for better performance with PRB fuel.
•
S
.2. IS FACILITY IN OPERATION? A. IF ‘~YES’DATE FACILITY
B. IF “NO” DATE FACILITY
.
3. IF FACILITY CONSISTS OF A
S
S
WAS PLACED INOPERATION
•
IS EXPECTEDTO BE
BUILDING, IS ITEXCLUSIVE-
El
YES
•
S
DNo
55
:
.
•
•
PLACED IN OPERATIONS
•
I LV FOR CONTROLOF POLW-
December 2001
TION? ~ YES
fl
NO
~ DOES THE
FACILITY
(installed after December 31, 1975 ONLY)
AFFECT THE
OPERATI
NO
UNIT
(ofthe plan: or other property In connec-
tion with which the facility is.used)
MOST DIRECTLY ASSOCIATED WITH THE FACILITY IN
ANY OF THE FOLLOWING WAYS?
INCREASE THE OUTPUT OR CAPACITYDYES ElNO
EXTEND THE USEFUL LIFE?
0
YES
El
NO
.
.
5
REDUCE THE TOTAL OPERATING COSTS?
0
YES
El
NO
•
S
S
5
555
5
5
a. IF ThE ANSWER TO ANY OF THE ABOVE IS ‘YES’~IS THE PERCENTAGE BY WHICH THE OPERATING UNiT WAS EFFECTED
D50RD~~
5
.5
.5 5 5 5
5.
5 5
.S
5
•
.S.
~
55
b. IF NONE OF THE FOREGOING INCREASES, EXTENSIONS, OR REDUCTIONS EXCEEDING 5 STATE THE RATIONALE AND..
FURNISH THE DATA USED TO ARRI yE ATTHE PERCENTAGE(S) GIVEN IN RESPONSE TO ITEM 4(a).
. .
5
PAGE 2 OF 5
~U.S.
GOVERNMENT PAINTING OFFICE: 1977—720—619
Form Approved
0MB No. 158—R0013
SECTION C. DESCRIPTION OF COMMERCIAL PROCESS OR ACTIVITY
1. DESCRIBE PROCESS OR ACTIVITY. IN CONNECTION WITH WHICH FACILITY IS OR WILL BE USED.
•
S
•
Electric Generating Umt
2. STANDARD INDUSTRIAL
CLASSIFICATION
(SIC) CODE NUMBER
S
5
5
5 5
55
•
4911
:•
55
5S•5
•
S•
•
~
5
5
•
~SS
•5
3 DATE
THAT EACH PLANT
OR OTHER
PROPERTY
IN
CONNECTiON WITH Wi-IICH FACIUTY IS
OR WILL BE
USED, COMMENCE OPERATION.
PLANT OR PROPERTY
5
••
.:
• DATE
A
Baldwm Energy Complex, Unit 3
June 1975
8.
..•.
55
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5-
S
C.
•
S
55
5
5
5
5
‘
S
•
:• EPA Form 3300—) (Rev. 8—77)
.SS
ORIGINAL
Form
Approved
0MB
No.
158—R0013
S S
SECTION C
-
DESCRIPTION OF COMMERCIAL
PROCESS
OR ACTIVITY
S S
4A.
IF FACILITY IS OR WILL BE USED IN CONNECTION WITH MORE THAN ONE PLANT OR PROPERTY, AND IF ONE OR MORE OF THE
PLANTS OR PROPERTIES IN CONNECTION WrrH WHICH THE FACILITY IS OR WILL BE USED WAS NOT IN OPERATION PRIOR TO
JANUARY 1, 1976, STATE THE PERCENTAGE OF THE COST OF FACILITY WHICH IS ALLOCABLE TO THE PLANTIS)OR
.
S
PROPERTY(IES) IN OPERATION PRIOR TO THAT DATE.
N/A
•
S
S
S
SECTION 0. WASTEWATER CHARACTERISTICS (To be completed only in connectiom with
facilities
for
the control of water pollution)
DESCRIBE ThE EFFECT-OF
POLLUTION CONTROL FACILITY IN TERMS OF
QUANTITY AND QUALITY OF EMISSION
AND
OF WASTES
OR BY.PR.ODUCTS REMOVED, ALTERED, DISPOSED OF, OR PREVENTED, iF FEASIBLE,ATTACH
S
PROCESS
FLOW OR SCHEMATIC
DIAGRAM
WITH
MATERIAL BALANCES
OF THE
WASTE OR WASTEWATE•R STREAM
OR
DISCHARGE. REPORT EITHER ON ACTUAL BASIS OR,
IF FACILITY IS NOT YET IN OPERATION, ON DESIGN
BASIS
(Use Standard Units
—
pounds/gallon, g~amsJli:er,ppm. etc.).
•
.
S
•
•
• •
5
5
5
5
1.
HOURS
PLANT OR PROPERTY IS IN OPERATION:
a. Per
Month:
Mm.
Max.
Avg.
—
•
S 5
S•
S
• 5
‘:
b. Per Year:
Min
Max.
AV9;
• S
55
2. WASTEWATER
~S
DISCHARGE IN
(A) GALLONS PER,
MINUTE, (B) MIL.
•UONS OF GALLONS
WITHOUT POLLUTION CONTROL FACILITY
‘WITH POLLUTION CONTROL FACILITY
SS
S
a. Mm.
Max.__•
Avg.
S•
5
.5
555
5
b. Mm.
•~
Max~
Avg.
S
Mm.
Max.
—~---
Avg.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
Mm.
Max.
—
Avg.
•
•
S
3. POLLUTANTS OR WASTE
PRODUCTS
5
•
S~
3.i
•
•
Mm.
55
Max.
•
~•
Avg.
•
.
••
Mm.
Max.
I
Avg.
3b
.
••
• -
Mm.
Max.
Avg.
. •
Mmn.
Max. —
Avg.
3.c
•
S
S~
S
Min.i________ Max.
Avg.
Mm.
—
Max. •
55
Avg.
3.d.
:
. .
Mm.
Max.
Avg.
• •__.
Mm.
•
Max.
—_
Avg.
3.0....
.
Miii. ,_•
Max.
Avg.
•
Mm.
Max.
Avg.
•
•
3i
1
•
Mm.
Max.
Avg..
. •
.
Mm.
Max.
•
.
Avg.
3.g
~‘•
••~
‘
‘
Mm.
•
Max.—
Avg.
•
•
MIn.
Max.
Avg.
3h,
•
•S’•
•‘:
Mm.
Max.
.._.._._..—_
Avg. •
Mm.
Max.
•
Avg.
.
S
3.i
.
• •~
‘
• Mm.
•
Max.
Avg.
.
Mm. —
•
Max.
Avg.
3.;
•
Miii.
Max.
.__•
Avg.
:
Miii.
•
Max.
•
Avg.
* U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1977729620
~DESCRI8E
THE REASONING AND FURNISH THE DATA USED TO ARRIVE ATTHE PERCENTAGE GIVEN IN RESPONSE TO
ITEM4(A).
5
5
5
5
N/A
5
,•
5,
55
•
5
•
S~
BA. IF FACILITY PERFORMS A FUNCTION OR FUNCTIONS IN ADDITION TO THE ABATEMENT OF POLLUTION, STATE
THE.
PERCENTAGES OF THE
COST
OF FACILITY ALLOCABLE TO THE ABATEMENT OF POLLUTION.
N/A
S
S
58. DESCRIBE THE REASONING ‘AND FURNISH THE DATA USED TO ARRIVE AT THE PERCENTAGE GIVEN IN RESPONSE TO
ITEM5(A).
55
55
5’
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
55
5
5
5
.
S
N/A
EPA Form 3300—1 (Rev. I
—757)
•
ORIGINAL
5 5 5 .
PAGE3OF5
*
U.S~GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE; l977~729—62t
•
5 ~S
• 0MBForm
No.
Approved
158—R0013
4. DESCRIBE METHOD (GRAB.OR COMPOSITE AND FREQUENCY OF SAMPLING AND METHODS USED TO DETERMINE QUANTITIES
OF POLLUTANTS.
S
S
S
S• •
5. IS FACILITY A PRETREATMENT FACILITY TO PREPARE WASTEWATER FOR RECEIPT BY ANOTHER FACILITY. PUBLIC 0
PRIVATE, FOR FURTHER TREATMENT? IF “YES”, SKIP ITEMS 6,7 AND BAND IDENTIFY RECEIVING FACILITY.
DYES
-
MO
6. IDENTIFY THE BODY OR STREAM OF WATER INTO WHICH WASTEWATER FROM THE PLANT OR PROPERTY. IN CONNECTION
WITH WHICH THE FACILITY IS USED, IS OR WILL BE DISCHARGED.
S
-
N/A
•
S
7. DESCR IBE LOCATION OF DISCHARGE OR OUTFALL WITH RESPECT TO RECEIVING WATERS.
S
8~IS THE RECEIVING BODY OR STREAM OF WATER A NAVIGABLE WATE AWAY OF THE UNITED STATES OR ATRIBUTARY THEREOP7
D
YES.
0
NO.
IF “NO,”PROCEED TO ITEM 9.
•
•
5 55
5 •
•
S
S
•
S
A. IF “YES” HAS A U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS DISCHARGE PERMIT BEEN APPLIED FOR?
DYES 0
NO
EXPLAIN, THEN PROCEED TO ITEM 9.
•
.•
5 55
5
5
5
5
55 5
IF “NO,”
B. IF ANSWER TO ITEM BA IS “YES” HAS A US. ARMY
CORPS
OF ENGINEERS DISCHARGE PERMIT BEEN ‘ISSUED?
0
YES
0
NO
(1) IF “YES,” ATTACH COPY OR PROVIDE PERMIT NUMBER
.
OMIT ITEM 9.
•~
5
5
(2) IF “NO,” EXPLAIN, GIVING DATES OF ANY OFFICIAL ACTION WITH RESPECT TO APPLICATION.
S
•
EPA Form 3300—1 (Rev.
8—77)
9. IF ITEM 88
HAS
NOT BEEN ANSWERED “YES,” IDENTIFY APPLICABLE STATE AND LOCALSWATER POLLUTION CONTROL
REQUIREMENTSAND STANDARDS.
:•
S
• •
S
S
SECTION E
.
EMISSION CHARACTERISTICS (To be completed only In
connection
with
facilities for the control
of air
pollution)
• DESCRIBE THE EFFECT OF POLLUTION CONTROL FACILITY IN TERMS
OF QUANTITY AND
QUALITY.
OF EMiSSION
AND
OF EMISSION
AND
OF
WASTES
OR BY-PRODUCTS REMOVED, ALTERED. DISPOSED OF, OR PREVENTED. IF FEASIBLE,
ATTACH PROCESS FLOW OR SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM WITH MATERIAL
BALANCES
OF POLLUTANTS IN THE EMISSION
.
S
STREAIVL REPORT EITHER ON ACTUAL BASIS, OR, IF FACILITY IS NOT YET IN OPERATION, ON DESIGNS BASIS.
• . .•
•.
1
HOURS PLANT
OR PROPERTY IS IN OPERATION
a Per Month
Miii
0
Max
Avg
...±~L
b
Per
Year
Mm 5600 Max 8 300 Avg.
2. POLLUTANTS TO
BE CONTROLLED
(Specify each)
•
S
•
,
S
•S
a
-
NOx
•-
S
5
SS•S
S
S
b.
•
SS
S
S
C..
-
‘•
S
SS
S
S
-
d.
•
S
S
3. VOLUMETRIC FLOW
• RATE OFEMIS-
•
S
SON(actualcubic
WITHOUT POLLUTION CONTROLFACILITY
•
WITH POLLUTION CONTROL FACILITY
.
S
S
S
Mmii
S~
000 S2~,000~
306 •
°F
~S
S
Miii.
i~4?~0at
.~?.2L
°F
S5
5
555
5
4. CONCENTRATION
• .g~eotts(in
volumecomponents)
of
-S
SSSSS
-
‘
S~
•5
106
304.
.
.
.
S
5
Mmn._Max.~Avg._at_
°F
.
•
•
65
304
•
S
•
Min._Max._Avg._at
b. MIri._Mex._Avg......_at_
°F
.
Min..~...._.Max._Avg...._.....at
•
•
55-5
•
‘.
c. Min.~Max._Avg._at_
°F.
.
SS
S
•
S
S
-
5
55•S
•
••
•
5
MIn._Max._Avg.at~
0F
d. Mmn._Max.__Avg..
.et___ 0F
• .
Mun._Max....,.Avg._at........._
°F
5.
CONC~NTRATION
(rain:/pu~cfeetof
matter!
•
.‘
55
5
5
5
555
Mun.._.~..Max._Avg..........~
~
°F
.
S
S
5
5
555
5
55
Mun......_... Max._.._Avg._ at
.~_._
°F
SS
6. CONCENTRATION
(grains/cubic feet of
any specific particU-
late
listed
in E-2above)
•
S~
55
5
5
5
.
S
S5
5
Mun._Max.........Avg._
at_____ °F
‘
•
•S
55
5
5
555
5
5
Mmn...........
S S
Max.,_.....Avg............at
S
-
—
S
S
S
ORIc~INAL
PAGE4OF5
* U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE; 1577729—622
•
Form Approved
S
OMBNo.158—90013
7. DESCRIBE METHOD OF DETERMINING RATES, CONCENTRATION AND CHARACTERISTICS OF EMISSIONS.
Volumetric flow rate is reported as presented in the CAAPP Title V permit application...
Concentration (ppmv) is taken from the Continuous Emission Monitor.
B. IDENTIFY APPLICABLE STATE AND LOCAL AIR POLLUTION CONTROL REQUIREMENTS AND STANDARDS.
. S
35
Illinois Administrative Code 217 Subparts V & W
S
SECTION F
.
COST INFORMATION (See Note to
instructions
for this
suction)
S
1. IS THERE ANY BY-PRODUCT OR MATERIAL WHICH, WITHOUT THE CONTROL FACILITY, WOULD BE LOST AND WHICH IS
RECOVEREDTHROUGHTHEUSEOFTHEFACILITY?
DYES S E~1NO
•
5
5 5
A. IFYES,IDENTIFY
.:
•
• •
•
S
•
5
5
5
5
8. INDICATE THE DISPOSITION OF EACH TYPE OF RECOVERED MATERIAL, INCLUDING IFAPPLICABLE,’THE SALE OR
SIMILAR DISPOSITION OF RECLAIMED OR RECOVERED MATERIAL TO INDUSTRIAL WASTE RECOVERY FIRMS OR OTHERS.
S
~•
ORIGINAL. • • •
PAGE 50F5•
2. ANNUAL COST
RECOVERY.
A MATERIALRECOVEREDANDSOLD
$
N/A
sss
5
•
5
5
5
5
5
5
•S.
5
5
5
B.OTHERS
55
5
5
5
5 5
5
555
555
•.
5
5
~
N/A
•
C TOTAL
$
N/A
3. TOTAL AVERAGE ANNUAL MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING COSTS
S
(Not applicableif no cost recovery is reported in Item 2)
•
SS
5
•
-.
SS
$
N/A
EPA Form 3300—1 (Ray. 8—77)
•
IIIIW..fl
IUURI..iJI
~S
LL1t~ ItV.
C.LIUIC.sJ~.J~)U
5
5 S~
ILLINOIS
POLLUTiON CONTROL BOA.RD
Apnl 3, 2003
S
~•.•r.~•S
S
••
S5
5
.S
~YNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION, LILC )
(Refurbished Low NOx Burner i-Trait
)
WSeparated Overfire System
(Property
)
S
Idc~ific on
mbet-02-10-100-001)),
S
)
•
S
p
)
$
Petitioner,
)
~5•55
S
)S~S
S•
v
)
PCBO3-176
)
(Tax Certification)
S
S
~rJ1~O$SENVIRONMENTAL
55
5
)
S
S
S
•
~tQ•TECT1QNAGENCY,
S
S
5
•
•S
5
•
55
)
Respondent
)
~R~ER
Q1~
Ti3E
BOARD (byT E
Johnson)
j
On March 3~,2003, the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency(Agency)
iecouunended that theBoard certif~rcertain facihties~ofDynegyMidwest Generation, LLC
(Dyi~egyMidwest) as ~pollution
control facilities”
for
preferential taxtreatment under the
1~opertyTax Code 35 ILCS 200/11-5
et seq
(2002) The Agency filed the recommendation
upderPart
125
of
the Board’s procedural nales 35111 Adin
Code 125
In this
order,
theBoard
4pscjibes the legal framework for tax
certifications, discusses theAgency’s recommendation,
td ~ertifiesthat Dynegy Midwest’s facilities are pollutioncontrol facihtaes
LEGAL FRAMEWORK
ie Property Tax Code, “it is the policy ofthis State that pollubon control
i be vaIned~at 33 1/3 ofthe fair cash
value of
their economic productivity
to
Lers” 35 ILCS 200/11-5 (2002),
see al.~o
35 Iii Adin Code 125 200(a)(2) “:For tax
pothition control facilities shall be certified as suchby the Pollution Control Board and
•~S~4by theDeparti~erit
of Revenuer’
35IL~S
200/11-20(2002);
s~e
also
35
IlL
Code 125 200(a)
Under Section 125 202 oftheBoard’sprocedural rules, a person may submit an
LtiOII
for
tax certification
to
the Agency.
35
111. Adim Code 125.202. lIthe Agency
~satax certification application, the Agency must file with the ~oard a recommendation
application, unless the applicant withdraws the application. 35fl1.Actm. flode 125.204(a).
hertl~ii~gs,the Agency’s filing must recommend that theBoard
issue or deny ta~~
~5flL Mm. Code 125~204(a)(4);IftheBoard finds “that the claimed
facIlity
Or
i
thereof
is a pollution
control facility
,the Pollution Control Board
shall
an4issue a certificate to that effect.” 35 ILCS 200/11-25 (2002); s~e
also 35
Ill.
Code
12~2
16(a)
S~
•
S
~:
•~
•~:~
S
~•
HrK—Lu—~uUi IrlU Lk~.IU f11L~It~CIJI
iuv~1~1
S 5
Fr1A I’IU..
2
SS
S
5
5
AGENCY RECOMMENDATIO~
The Agency states that it received a tax certification application from Dynegy Midwest
on
Sàptember I 5,2002. Agency
Recommendation (AgencyRec.) at
1. On March 31, 2003, the
Agen~yfiled a recommendation on the
application with
the Board The
Agency’s
recoiqinendation
identifies
the facilities at issue R.efurbishment ofLow NOx Burner Unit
S
3I$~prate4.Qver~eAir System.. Agency Rec. at l~The Agency’s recommendation further.
d~cr,4besthe facilities reduces NOx emissions from the
existing
low NOx system
Id
at 1-2
The
4gency’s
recommendation alsoidentifies the location
of
the facilities 10901 Baldwin
Roa4~Baldwm,Randolph County
Id
at 1
“The Agency recommends that the Board certify that the identified facilities are pollution
co~1rolfacilities as definedi-n Section 11-10 ofthe PropertyTax Code
(35
ILCS 200/11-10
(2~02))because the
primary purpose of
the facilities as eliminating, preventing,
or
reducing air
p.~jlut~onAgencyRec
at
2
~
,.~ .~
S
TAX CERTIFICATE
S
S
S
The Board finds and certifies that DynegyMidwest’s facilities identified
in
this order are
control facilities underthe Property Tax Code
35
ILCS 200/11-10 (2002) Under
11-25 ofthe Property Tax Code, the effective date ofthis certificate
is
“the date ~f:
Dfl for
the certificate
or
the date
of
the construction
of
the facility, whichever
is
later”
~20O/11~25
~2OQ2);se~also:35lll.Adm.
Code 125.216(a). Section 125.216(d) ofthe
~açe4~. r~i1essates that the Clerk “will provide the applicant and the Agencywith a
~Boerd’s order setting forth
the Board’sfindingsand certificate, ~any”
35111 Adm
~6(4~~quotingin
italics
35 ILCS
2001l
1-30 (2002)).. The Clerktherefore will
DynegyMidwest andtheAgency with a
copy
ofthis order
IflS SO ORDERED
Section 41(a) ofthe Environmental Protection Act provides that final Board ordersmay
ealed’dircctlyto the illinois Appellate.Courtwithin
35
days after the
Board
serves the
415 ILCS
5141~a~
~2002);
see
also
35
I1LAdm. Code lOL300~d~(2~,101.906,102.706.
Supreme COurt Rule 335 establishes fihingrequiremezns that apply when the illinois
pellate Court. by statute, directly reviews administrative orders. 172111. 2d R. 335. The
~sproced~ralrules provide thatmotions forthe Board to reconsider or modify its final
s
maybe filed with the Board within 35 days after the order is received 35 jlJ A4iu Code
se~
also
35 Ill Adm Code 101 902, 102 700, 102 702
,.
~uS
S
1rU~yU.)
IflU
U~.i1 VII UIi’iC~.ZI IIWVJC.iJI
rrin
i~u,
~iioi~uuu
5
3
5
•S
,~ I. Dorothy M Gunn Clerk ofthe Illinois Pollution Control Board, certify that the Board
S
a~ptedthe above order
on
April 3, 2003, by a vote of7-0.
fS 5
SS
5
DorothyM. Gunn, Clerk
Illinois Pollution Control Board
S
P
~SS5
SS~
f. It.
S~•S
•S~5
5?’
~
S~~S
PROOF OF SERVICE
I, the undersigned, certify that I have served the attached APPEARANCE AND
RECOMMENDATION upon the person to whom it is directed, by placing them in an envelope
addressed to:
TO:
Dorothy Gunn, Clerk
S
Illinois Pollution Control Board
State ofIllinois Center
100 W. Randolph Street, Suite 11-500
Chicago, Illinois 60601
Steve Santarelli
Illinois Department ofRevenue
101 West Jefferson
S
P.O. Box 19033
Springfield, Illinois 62794
Donna Redmon
Tax Manager
DynegyMidwest Generation, Inc.
1000 Louisiana, Suite 5800
Houston, Texas 77002
and mailing it by First Class Mail from Springfield, Illinois on October
15,
2003, with sufficient
postage affixed.
74H~
Robb H. Layman
S
Special Assistant Attorney General
ARDC
#6205498
THIS FILING IS SUBMITTED
ON RECYCLED PAPER