F-li

IN

._.JtJ

V_h_i

c_ILL

•

I

l\

_IIAJfll

1_iLJl

‘F

I

IrII’.

I

LI I

LIL.LL..

..JSC

LLC..J~

.J,.1..10

I LI

0Lt.._ILILI_d

I

.

c_ic_’

Li_i

OFFic

oi~-ooi

E

/4PR

3

02003

ILLINOIS

POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD

~ IAI E OF

ILLINOIS

~oiiution

C

CITY

OF

KANKAKEE,

)

Ofltro/Board

)

PCB 03-1 25

Petitioner,

)

PCB 03-133

PCBO3-134

-

v.

)

PCBO3-135

(consolidated)

COUNTY OF

KANKAKEE, COUNTY

)

(Pollution Control Facility Siting Appeals)

BOARD

OF

KANKAKEE, and WASTE

)

WNAGEMENT OF

ILLINOIS,

INC.

Respondents.

NOTICE OIF FILING

To:

(See attached Service List.)

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on this 30th day ofApril 2003, the following County’s

Motion

to Quash Subpoena

was filed with the

Illinois

Pollution Control Board, attached

and herewith served

upon you.

COUNTY OF

KANKAKEE and

COUNTY BOARD OF KANKAKEE

‘~Q~e

of Its Attome

s

Elizabeth S.

Harvey

SWANSON,

MARTIN & BELL

One IBM

Plaza, Suite 2900

330 North Wabash Avenue

Chicago,

Illinois 60611

Telephone:

(312) 321-9100

Firm

LD.

No. 29558

---

flI

IN

_,IC)

c_h_I

V_ILI

I

I\

._ILiflI

1._il_Il

I

It’ll

S

I

I

1

,I_II_I_I_

_IS c_LL=.Lc_I~~LI

I

I_I

LI.LT_ILJLI

CERTIFICATE

OF SERVICE

I,

the

undersigned,

state

that

I

served

a

copy of the

described

document

in

the

above-

captioned mattervia facsimile (pursuant to verbal

authorization

by the

hearing officer) arid

U.S. Mail

to all

persons listed

on the service list on April

30. 2003.

~1tHarvey’~

~4I

xi

Under penalties

as pn~videdby law

pursuant to 735 ILCS 5/1-109.

I certify

that the statements set forth herein

are true and correct.

---

fli

IN

_.ItI

Li,..)

V_ILI

C.C.

I

I\

._IcIJfll’I_.ILIII

t

nfl

I

III

i_IL.L_L_

._I.LC

_IC..J.

O._’_ICI

I

LI

LI).

nLILILI.’

I

•

Li~T’

Li.,’

SERVICE LIST

KANKAKEE COUNTY/WMIJ

LANDFILL SITING

Bradley

P. Halloran

Hearing Officer

Illinois

Pollution Control Board

100 West Randolph Street

Suite 11-500

Chicago. IL 60601

Charles F. Helsten

Richard Porter

Hin~haw&

Culbertson

100 Park Avenue

P.C. Box 1389

Rockford, IL 61105

Kenneth A. Leshen

One Dearborn Square

Suite 550

Kankakee, IL 60901

Donald Moran

Pedersen & Houpt

161 North Clark Street

Suite 3100

Chicago,

IL 60601-3242

George Mueller

George Mueller,

P.C.

5O1 State Street

Ottawa, IL 61350

L. Patrick Power

956 North Fifth Avenue

Kankakee,

IL 60901

Jennifer J. Sackett Pohlenz

Querry & Harrow, Ltd.

175 West Jackson Boulevard

Suite 1600

Chicago,

IL 60604

Keith Runyon

165

Plum Creek Drive

Bourbonnais, IL 60914

Kenneth A. Bleyer

Attorney at Law

923 West Gordon Terrace, #3

Chicago,

IL 6061 3-2013

Leland

Milk

6903 S. ‘Route 45-52

Chebanse,

IL 60922-5153

Patricia

O’Dell

1242 Arrowhead Drive

Bourbonnais, IL 60914

---

ri

IS

._ICJ

LI._I

L1LI

C.,..)

I

IN

._JVJflI 1._ILII

I

I

IllS

I

LI

I

,I_IL_L_L_

,..JJ.C.

,...IC..I.

C_I_i_It_I

ILL

I_ft.L’t._ILILI_I

I

.

C_I_Il

Li_I

O1~8-Oo1

ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD

CIrYOFKANKAKEE,

)

)

PCB

03-1 25

Petitioner,

)

PCB 03-1 33

PCB 03-1 34

v.

)

PCBO3-135

)

(consolidated)

COUNTY OF KANKAKEE, COUNTY

)

(Pollution Control Facility Siting Appeals)

BOARD

OF

KANKAKEE, and WASTE

)

MANAGEMENT OF

ILLINOIS,

INC.

)

Respondents.

MOTION

TO

QUASH

SUBPOENA

Respondent COUNTY BOARD

OF

KANKAKEE

(“County”),

by fts attorneys

l-finshaw & Culbertson and Swanson,

Martin

& Bell, hereby move the hearing officer to

quash the

subpoena for deposition served

by

petitioner MICHAEL WATSON

(‘Watson”)

on Efraim

Gd.

1.

Watson

has

subpoenaed

Mr.

Gil1

for

his

deposition,

setting

the

deposition

for

today,

April

30,

2003,

at

10:00

a.m.

The

proof of

service

indicates

that

the

subpoena was sent to Mr.

Gil on April

25, 2003, via certified mail and via Federal

Express.

(See subpoena, attached as Exhibit A.)

2.

On

information

and

belief,

Mr.

Gil anc’

his wife were

out of state

until yesterday,

April

29,

2003.

While they were

out

of

state,

Mr.

Gil was

hospitalized for

health

issues related to high blood sugar.

3.

Upon

their return

yesterday,

Mr.

Gil

eceived the

subpoena

for

his deposition.

Mrs.

Gil

informed

counsel late yesterday afternoon

(April 29~2003) that Mr. Gil is

unable to appear for deposition.

Mr.

Gil is a former County

employee.

The

County is providing

a courtesy representation

to

Mr.

Gil,

as

the

subject

of

his

requested

deposition

in

this

matter

arises

from

his

former

employment with the County.

---

fl

IS

i_IC)

C_I_I

LILI

C.._J

I

IS

._IIMflI

1,_Il_il

I

I

ml

S I

£

I

1

A_iI_..I._I_

._m.LC_._mC..L

C_i_I_IC_i

I

4.

Mr.

Gil cannot appear at the

subpoenaed deposition today,

April 30,

2003, as

he

has

a

doctor’s

appointment

in

Chicago.

His

appointment,

which

is

continuing

care for the

medical

problems which caused his recent hospitalization, is with

Dr.

David Edelberg.

5.

Additionally,

on

information

and

belief,

Mr.

Gil’s

health

makes

it

impossible for

him

to

appear for

his

deposition

at

another time

during

this

proceeding;

The

County

will

supplement

this

motion

to

quash

with

documentation

from

Dr.

Edelberg

as soon as possible.

6.

Pursuant

to

Section

101.620(d)

of tie

Board’s

procedural

rules,

the

hearing

officer may quash

a

subpoena ifthat subpoena is unreasonable or irrelevant.

7,

The

County

moves

the

hearing

officer to

quash

the

subpoena

to

Mr.

Gil

as

unreasonable,

given

Mr.

Gil’s

health.

The

subpoena

should

be quashed

as to

the

noticed

deposition

for

today,

April

30,

~s Mr.

Gil

will

be

in

Chicago

at

the

required

appointment

with

Dr.

Edelberg.

Further,

the

subpoena

should

be

quashed as to any deposition of Mr. Gil, on the basis of his health.

WHEREFORE, the

County

moves

that the hearing

officer quash the

subpoena

for

Mr.

Gil’s

deposition,

and

for

such

other

relief

as

the

hearing

officer

deems

appropriate.

Respectfully submItted,

COUNTY OF

KANKAKEE and

COUNTY BOARD OF KANKAKEE

~

ci~

2

---

Charles

F.

Helsten

Richard

Porter

Hi~shaw

& Culbertson

1 O~

Park Avenue

P.O. Box 1389

Ro~kford,

IL 61105-1389

81 51490-4900

Elizabeth S. Harvey

Swanson,

Martin & Bell

One IBM

Plaza,

Suite 2900

330 North Wabash Avenue

Chicago,

IL 60611

312/321-9100

3

---

fli

IS

._IC_I

C_h_I

OI_J~

C_I

I

IS

~_C_iim

mm

i’_i~_iil 11111 5

I hI

I

_~_i,_.

m

._~

,_-‘_,,_,

—

.

.

‘__—.

—

—

~9T

£8~G~

èId~

~PR

~

~803

3:5$

P~1 F~

~H

CHICRG()

051

31~ 54~0578

TO8a511145u

TO:

Before

the

Illinois

Pollution Control Board

)

)

)

)

)

)

Sfraim

C1L

-

9

Dur~tap~

32—1

PC~

~Q3-1~4

)

Con.solidated

With P~3

03—125,

03—~.33,

03—135w

03—144)

)

)

)

)

)

)

~‘ark

Fcres~,

IL

6O66~-1S4~

Pursuant to

Section

5(e)

ofthe Environmental Protection

Act(415

ILCS

~)5(e)

(2002)) and 35

Eli. Adm.

Code

101.622,

yoti

are ordered

to attend and give testimony at

the hear~ng(~on~n

the

sbove~aprio~ed

matter ar__________

~~~rn.on

~pr~1

~n

....__20~-M3-

Ka~k~jcee

City

Sail,

C0un~i1

ai~tbe~,

~85

~.

Oak,

~ka~I11i~j~

.,,_t,~

~

Corrip1ainantiPet~tianer,

V.

cout~r~

SOARD

O~’

~NKAK~

CO~Tr,

rT.,LINOI5,

~

~

MANAG~5NTOE

—

ILLZNOZS,

INC..,

Respondent.

)

SUS?OENA/SUBPOENA DUCES

LECUM

---

rlrr-

iI&~J

ti~J

I~~JOC.~)

rrc~

I1~UI’~

IF115.I

ill

~~LL

~

~

t~Jm~j

iu

~.~‘~t~ILILI_I

I

‘C_I_I

S~9I

£0, 6~~

A~25

p003

3~58PM ~p 3&H CHIcPGO 0S~312 ~40 05?

S TO S~11l49~

P07/07

You are also ordered to bring with

you

docurnec~

r~lc~nt

to the matterurl&

consideration and desi~ated

herein:

j~~

p~

~

~

•~4~(

rT~tc~tLO

~r

tirr,~J’~

L~O1t

~‘d

~

~

~

~.

~

-~

~

-

&

~

~

~-~•

~

p~-~‘2~~

~

r~

44L.~-9~

~

~

~

~

e~pL~c.J-~-

Fatturd tv comply

ith

thi5s~b~oena

willsubject

you

to sanctions

~.tnder

35

LII.

~

~

Z..ôc~~

Adtn, Code lO.622(~ 10l.SO0, and l01..802.

ENTER:

I

d~.

Dorothy

M.

Ounrz, Clerk

Pollution Control Board

Date:

Na~c~

2~Qo~

çjg~iiric~r~

OF

SE~V1CE

I,

JenrLi~er-

Pohl~z

~t~!-Q~.

~,

certify that on this

~

day

of~

Apcil

--

20_03

,lcausedcopie~oftheSUBE~OEN&SUB?OENA

DUCES

TECUM to be

ser~redupon the following:

Efr~im

Gil

1

Ret1.1rT~

by depositing same in UnIt~d

States ~

pre~~Pt

Rec~u~t~d

ax~d.

1,ja

~e~ra1

Ex~re.sa..

*~

TO1~LP~SE.e7

~*

~I?t~Y

1.IIe,1.

I~l~IC~,I~P I~II

**

TOTAL Prn~n~

~

---

-tTc

.Y~J

Uh)

~

r-rc

~wt-1l’1~urN

I11W5I

~I1

A~I~L~t_

_IJ.C

.JCJ.

I~Jl~’t~

LI

I_I.L*._IL)LI.7

I

RECE~.ED

CLERIc’S

oppics

SWANSON, MARTIN

& BELL

30 ~OO3

ONE

IBM PLAZA

-

SUITE 2900

330 NORTH WABASH AVENUE

STATE OF

ILLINOIS

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 60611

Pollution

Control Board

(312) 321.9100

-

FAX

(312

321-0990

FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION

30

Date:

April

~

2003

Pages Transmitted:

(including

coverpage)

User’s Direct Dial

Line: (312) 923-8260

Client No.:

0198-001

Transmitting to:

Brad HaIIoran----(312) 814-3669

Jennifer Pohlenz ~

--

(312) 540-0578

Kenneth A.

Leshen

George Mueller-- (815) 433-4913

L.

Patrick Power

--

(815) 937-0056

Keith Runyon

--

(815) 937-9164

Donald Moran

—

(312) 261-1149

Rick Porter/Charles

F. Heisten

—

(815) 490-4901

Received from:

Elizabeth S.

Harvey

Attached please find the County’s motion to quash subpoena, filed via

facsimile pursuant to verbal authorization

by the hearing officer.

If you do not receive all transmitted pages,

please cell Shel at (312) 321-9100.

This facsimile is intended onlyfor the use of the addressee(s) herein and may contain legally-privileged and

confidential information.

If you arenot the intended recbient of this facsimile, you

are hereby

notif

led that any

dissemination, distribution

or copying of this facsimile is strictly

prohibited.

Ifyou have received this facsimile in

error, please immediately notify us by telephone (if

long-distance, please call collect), and return the original

facsimile to the sender’s attention

at the above address via the United States Postal

Service.

H