In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and other applicable federal and State laws, the hearing will be accessible to individuals
with disabilities. Persons requiring auxiliary aids and services should contact Dorothy Gunn, Clerk of the Board, at 100 West Randolph St., Suite
11-500, Chicago, Illinois 60601, at telephone number 312/814-6931, fax number 312/814-3669, or TDD number 312/814-6032, five days prior to the
hearing.
ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
October 12, 2000
IN THE MATTER OF:
NATURAL GAS-FIRED, PEAK-LOAD ELECTRICAL
POWER GENERATING FACILITIES (PEAKER PLANTS)
)
)
)
)
)
R01-10
HEARING OFFICER ORDER
The hearings in this matter took place as scheduled: August 23 and 24, 2000, in Chicago;
September 7, 2000, in Naperville; September 14, 2000, in Joliet; September 21, 2000, in
Grayslake; and October 5 and 6, 2000, in Springfield. The complete exhibit list is attached to this
order. The original exhibits are being maintained by the Board’s Clerk in the Chicago office.
The Board is accepting written public comments in this matter. Written public comments
may be submitted through November 6, 2000, and should be sent to the following address:
Dorothy Gunn, Clerk
Illinois Pollution Control Board
100 West Randolph Street, Suite 11-500
Chicago, Illinois 60601
IT IS SO ORDERED.
____________________________
Amy L. Jackson
Hearing Officer
Illinois Pollution Control Board
600 South Second Street, Suite 402
Springfield, Illinois 62704
(217) 524-8507
jacksona@ipcb.state.il.us
ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
October 12, 2000
IN THE MATTER OF:
NATURAL GAS-FIRED, PEAK-LOAD ELECTRICAL
)
)
)
R01-10
POWER GENERATING FACILITIES (PEAKER PLANTS) )
)
EXHIBIT LIST
Exhibit Number
Description of Document
Illinois Commerce Commission
Prefiled testimony of Charles Fisher
Exhibit 1 (8/23/00)
Illinois Environmental Protection Agency
Prefiled testimony of Agency
(Agency) Group Exhibit 1 (8/23/00)
witnesses (Thomas Skinner,
Christopher Romaine, Robert
Kaleel, Greg Zak, Stephen
Nightingale, Richard Cobb, and
Todd Marvel)
Agency Group Exhibit 2 (8/23/00)
Set of 20 documents, beginning with
“Simple Cycle Gas Turbine
Application Diagram,” and including
two oversized maps
Illinois Department of Natural Resources
Prefiled testimony of Brian
(DNR) Exhibit 1 (8/23/00)
Anderson
DNR Exhibit 2 (8/23/00)
Prefiled testimony of Dr. Derek
Winstanley
Indeck Energy Services, Inc.
Prefiled testimony of Gerald Erjavec
(Indeck) Exhibit 1 (8/24/00)
Indeck Exhibit 2 (8/24/00)
Copy of PowerPoint presentation
and Supporting Documentation
Commonwealth Edison Exhibit 1
Prefiled testimony of Arlene Juracek
(8/24/00)
and Steven Naumann
Illinois Environmental Regulatory Group
Prefiled testimony of Dierdre Hirner
(IERG) Exhibit 1 (8/24/00)
Mid-America Interconnected Network, Inc.
Prefiled testimony of Richard Bulley
(MAIN) Exhibit 1 (8/24/00)
Midwest Independent Power Suppliers
Prefiled testimony of Freddi
Coordination Group Exhibit 1 (8/24/00)
Greenberg
Ameren Corporation Exhibit 1 (8/24/00)
Prefiled testimony of Michael
Kearney
Huff & Huff Environmental Consultants
Prefiled testimony of Richard
Exhibit 1 (8/24/00)
Trzupek, with attachments
Citizens Against Power Plants in Residential
CAPPRA Mission Statement
Areas (CAPPRA) Exhibit 1 (9/7/00)
and photographs
CAPPRA Exhibit 2 (9/7/00)
Steven Berning, et al. v. The City
of Aurora, et al., 00-CH-0361,
Second Amended Complaint for
Declaratory Judgment pending in
DuPage County Circuit Court
CAPPRA Exhibit 3 (9/7/00)
Testimony of Michael Warfel
CAPPRA Exhibit 4 (9/7/00)
Testimony of Steve Arrigo
DuPage County Board Exhibit 1 (9/7/00)
Versar Report
DuPage County Board Exhibit 2 (9/7/00)
Map - DuPage County
Municipalities and Unincorporated
Areas
DuPage County Board Exhibit 3 (9/7/00)
Testimony of Paul J. Hoss, Zoning
Manager for DuPage County
Department of Development and
Environmental Concerns
Standard Light and Power Exhibit 1 (9/7/00)
Addendum No. 2 to Application for
Prevention of Significant
Deterioration Construction Permit
for Standard Energy Ventures, LLC
Electrical Generation Facility
BartlettCARE (Citizens Advocating
Testimony of Beverly DeJovine
Responsible Environments) Exhibit 1 (9/7/00)
Susan Zingle (Zingle) Exhibit 1 (9/7/00)
“Peaker” Electrical Generating
Plants Press Coverage – 2000
Zingle Exhibit 2 (9/7/00)
Testimony of Lake County
Conservation Alliance
Zingle Exhibit 3 (9/14/00)
Testimony of Lake County
Conservation Alliance with
attachments
Zingle Exhibit 4 (9/21/00)
Video Tape
Zingle Exhibit 5 (10/6/00)
“Typical Daily Load Curve” of
Reliant Energy
Zingle Exhibit 6 (10/6/00)
“The Status of U.S. Electricity
Deregulation”
Zingle Exhibit 7 (10/6/00)
Arthur Andersen’s “Impact Analysis
Mallory Parcel – Libertyville,
Illinois”
Zingle Exhibit 8 (10/6/00)
“Effects of the Proposed Indeck
Facility on Property Values, Land
Use and Tax Revenue”
Zingle Exhibit 9 (10/6/00)
August 15, 2000 letter from Lake
County State’s Attorney, Michael J.
Waller, to Kenneth L. Larson
Zingle Exhibit 10 (10/6/00)
News Articles, beginning with
“Ordinance Would Place Provisos
on Peaker Plants”
Zingle Exhibit 11 (10/6/00)
“Business Overview – Electrical
Generating Companies”
Sierra Club Exhibit 1 (9/7/00)
Testimony of Connie Sue Schmidt
Dr. Thomas Overbye Exhibit 1 (9/14/00)
“Need for New Peaker Generation
in Illinois” power point presentation
Corn Products Exhibit 1 (9/14/00)
Testimony of Alan L. Jirik
Carol Stark (Stark) Exhibit 1 (9/14/00)
Testimony of Carol Stark
Stark Exhibit 2 (9/14/00)
Newspaper Article
Chicago Legal Clinic Exhibit 1 (9/14/00)
Petition to USEPA requesting
revocation of the Nitrogen Oxides
(NO
x
) waiver
Chicago Legal Clinic Exhibit 2 (9/14/00)
Testimony of Keith Harley
Link Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Statement of State Senator Terry
Link
Lynch Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Comments of Tom Lynch,
Libertyville Township Trustee
Kaiser Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Village of Wadsworth Resolution
R130 and letter of December 21,
1999
Kucera Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Comments on behalf of the Lake
County Public Water District
Lake County Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Testimony of Jim LaBelle,
Chairman Lake County Board
Lake County Exhibit 2 (9/21/00)
Testimony of Sandy Cole, Lake
County Board Member
Lake County Exhibit 3 (9/21/00)
Testimony of Bonnie Thomson
Carter, Lake County Board Member
Lake County Exhibit 4 (9/21/00)
Testimony of Gregory E. Elam,
CEO of American Energy
Solutions, including power point
presentation and Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission article
Lake County Exhibit 5 (9/21/00)
Lake County 2000 – Legislative
Program
Eaton Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Testimony of Larry Eaton on behalf
of Liberty Prairie Conservancy,
Prairie Holdings Corporation, and
Prairie Crossing Homeowners
Association
Concerned Citizens of Lake County (CCLC)
Testimony of Chris Geiselhart,
Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Chairperson
CCLC Exhibit 2 (9/21/00)
Comments of Richard Domanik
during an April 25, 2000 hearing in
Libertyville, with attached articles
Nesvig Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Testimony of E.M. Nesvig
Nesvig Exhibit 2 (9/21/00)
“Electric Power Monthly”
(July 2000 edition)
Nesvig Exhibit 3 (10/5/00)
Written testimony of E.M. Nesvig
Nesvig Exhibit 4 (10/5/00)
Hard copy of Air Permit Public
Hearing Presentation (September
28, 2000) by Elwood Energy II and
Elwood Energy III
Nesvig Exhibit 5 (10/5/00)
“U.S. Electricity Imports and
Exports 1995–1999”
McCarthy Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Correspondence of William
McCarthy, PhD, regarding
proposed Libertyville plant
McCarthy Exhibit 2 (9/21/00)
Guidance for Power Plant Siting and
Best Available Control Technology
McCarthy Exhibit 3 (9/21/00)
“Catalytica” publication regarding
“Xonon Technology”
Sargis Exhibit 1 (9/21/00)
Written comments of Mark R.
Sargis (dated September 7, 2000)
Illinois Department of Transportation
October 5, 2000 letter from James
Exhibit 1 (10/5/00)
V. Bildilli to Chairman Claire A.
Manning
Gregory Exhibit 1 (10/5/00)
Written testimony of Brent Gregory
Monk Exhibit 1 (10/5/00)
Written testimony of James Monk
Monk Exhibit 2 (10/5/00)
“System Peak Load and Capacity –
Historical 1990-2000 & Projected
2001-2003
American Lung Association Exhibit 1 (10/5/00)
Joint Comments of the American
Lung Association of Metropolitan
Chicago and the Illinois
Environmental Council
Dorge Exhibit 1 (10/5/00)
Written comments of Lake County
Conservation Alliance, with
attachments
Dorge Exhibit 2 (10/5/00)
“Peaker” Natural Gas Fired
Turbines – Permits Issued
Dorge Exhibit 3 (10/5/00)
“Peaker” Natural Gas Fired
Turbines Permits Issued – PSD
Dorge Exhibit 4 (10/5/00)
Group of four exhibits, beginning
with “Lake County Conservation
Alliance written comments in
Carlton air permitting proceeding"
____________________________
Amy L. Jackson
Hearing Officer
Illinois Pollution Control Board
600 South Second Street, Suite 402
Springfield, Illinois 62704
(217) 524-8507
jacksona@ipcb.state.il.us