VILLAGE
OF
NAHON
24555
S. NAVAJO DRIVE. CHANNAHON, ILLINOIS 604 10-3334
(815) 467-6644
•
FAX 467-9774 swww.channahonPC~~V~D
CLERK’S
OF~I~
August 12, 2004
6 2U04
STATE OF ILL1~Oi~’
~l1ut1onControi~o~-~j
Ms. Dorothy M. Gunn, Clerk
Illinois Pollution Control Board
James R. Thompson Center
100 West Randolph Street Suite 11-500
Chicago, Illinois 60601
Re.
Docket R04-21
~-pC~
Revisions to Radium Water Quality Standards: Proposed New 35 ILL.
Adm. Code 302.307 and Amendments to 35 ILL. Adm. Code 302.207 and
302.525
Dear Ms. Gunn:
The Village of Channahon would like to submit the following comments in support
of the above proposed rulemaking, which would amend the water quality
standard for radium from 1 picocurie per liter to 5 picocuries per liter and change
its applicability to only public and food processing water supplies. The Village of
Channahon owns and operates a public water supply system and a public
wastewater treatment system. The source water for the public water supply is
groundwater pumped from shallow and deep aquifers. The water pumped from
the deep aquifer currently exceeds the maximum contaminant level (MCL) for
combined radium 226 and radium 228. Channahon currently uses two methods
to treat its potable water to comply with the MCL: blending with low radium
content water and coprecipitation with hydrous manganese oxide (HMO) followed
by filtration. Both of these methods were identified in the Village’s Compliance
Commitment Report submitted to the IEPA. The HMO plant is currently in use
after receiving an operating permit from the IEPA.
While the Village does not have any data on the radium levels currently in its
effluent from the wastewater treatment plant, it is generally believed radium
entering the treatment plant is partially deposited in the sludge and partially
released in the effluent. It is important to note that the amount of radium
reaching the wastewater treatment plant after bringing the potable water supply
into compliance with the radium MCL is expected to be the same as it was before
Page 2
Ms. Gunn
August 12, 2004
treatment of the potable water for radium removal. The source water has not
changed and therefore the radium levels should remain as before. The only
difference from what occurred before treatment for radium is that the radium is
removed before entering the distribution system and then recombined with
domestic sewage in the wastewater stream. The blended water continues to
contain radium below the MCL of 5 picocuries per liter, but quite possibly higher
than the existing rule for discharge to surface waters of I picocurie per liter.
This revision is necessary to allow us, and other similarly affected water
treatment facilities, to operate without violation. Also, it would allow potable
water treatment methods for radium removal approved by the IEPA to exist
without the unintended consequence of requiring the wastewater treatment
facility to treat for radium in its effluent or not accept waste containing low levels
of radium at all. Additionally, it is unclear if any danger exists from the discharge
of radium to water other than public water supplies or food processing.
According to information obtained from the Illinois Department of Public Health,
radium is only a danger when ingested. Radiation received externally is
insignificant since the skin blocks the alpha radiation. Again, the Village of
Channahon supports the IEPA’s proposal to revise the current radium water
quality standards.
Sincerely,
Edward S. Dolezal,
Director of Public Works
cc:
Joe Cook, Village President
Village Board of Trustees
David Johnson, Village Administrator