1
BEFORE THE ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
2
ORIGINAL
4 ILLINOIS AYERS OIL COMPANY,
5
Petitioner,
6 vs.
No. PCB 03-214
CLERK’S OFFICE
DEC - 9 20U3
7
ILLINOIS ENVIRONMENTAL
(UST Appeal)
STATE OF ILLINOIS
8
PROTECTION AGENCY,
Pollution Control
Board
9
Respondent.
10
11
12
13
Proceedings held on December 3, 2003 at 9:00 a.m., at the
14 Illinois Pollution Control Board Hearing Room, 1021 North Grand
15 Avenue East, Springfield, Illinois, before Hearing Officer Carol
16
Sudman.
17
18
19
20
Reported by: Darlene M. Niemeyer, CSR, RPR, CCR
Illinois CSR License No. : 084-003677
21
Missouri CCR License No.: 866
22
JO
ELAINE
FOSTER & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
P.O. Box 138
23
Glen Carbon, Illinois 62034-0138
(618) 877—7016
24
(618) 655-0660 (fax)
1
JO ELAINE FOSTER & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
618-877—7016
1
APPEARANCES
2
3
ILLINOIS ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
BY: John J. Kim
4
Assistant Counsel
Division of Legal Counsel
5
1021 North Grand Avenue East
Springfield, Illinois 62794—9276
6
On behalf of the Illinois EPA.
7
MOHAN, ALEWELT, PRILLAMAN & ADAMI
BY:
Fred C. Prillaman
8
Attorney at Law
1 North Old
Capitol Plaza, Suite 325
9
Springfield,
Illinois
62701—1323
On behalf of Respondent.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
2
JO ELAINE FOSTER & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
618—877—7016
1
PROCEEDINGS
2
(December 3, 2003; 9:00 a.m.)
3
HEARING OFFICER SUDMAN: Good morning. My name is Carol
4 Sudman. I am a Hearing Officer with the Pollution Control Board.
5 This is the hearing for PCB 03-214, Illinois Ayers Oil Company
6 versus IEPA. It is December 3rd, 2003, and we are beginning at
7 9:00 a.m.
8
I will note for the record that there are no members of the
9 public present.
10
At issue in this case is the Agency’s modification of the
11 high priority corrective action plan regarding Petitioner’s
12 underground storage tank located at 310 State Street, in
13 Beardstown, Cass County. This hearing was noticed pursuant to
14 the Act and the Board’s rules and will be conducted pursuant to
15 Sections 101.600 through 101.632 of the Board’s procedural rules.
16
At this time I would like to ask the parties to please make
17 their appearances on the record.
18
MR. PRILLAMAN: Fred Prillaman, representing the
19 Petitioner, Illinois Ayers Oil Company.
20
MR. KIM: John Kim for the Respondent, Illinois
~l Environmental Protection Agency.
22
HEARING OFFICER SUDMAN: Thank you. Are there any
23 preliminary matters to discuss?
24
MR.
PRILLAMAN:
Yes, Madam Hearing Officer. On behalf of
3
JO ELAINE FOSTER & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
618—877—7016
1 the Petitioner, we would ask that the matter be continued until
2 the 7th of January, 2004, at 8:30 a.m., and we are today filing
3 our waiver of deadline for decision so that the Board’s decision
4
will not be due in this case until May the 5th of 2004 or
5 earlier.
6
HEARING OFFICER SUDMAN: Thank you. Does the Respondent
7 have any objection?
8
MR. KIM: No objection.
9
HEARING OFFICER SUDMAN: Okay. Well, the motion is
10 granted, and we will continue this hearing on January the 7th at
11 8:30 a.m. Are there any further matters before we go off the
12 record?
13
MR. KIM: No.
14
MR. PRILLAMAN: No.
15
HEARING OFFICER SUDMAN: Okay. At this time I will recess
16 this proceeding. Thank you.
17
MR. KIM: Thank you.
18
MR. PRILLAMAN: Thank you.
19
(The proceedings concluded at 9:07 a.m.)
20
21
22
23
24
4
JO ELAINE FOSTER & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
618-877-7016
1 STATE OF ILLINOIS
SS
2
COUNTY OF MONTGOMERY)
3
CERTIFICATE
4
5
I, DARLENE M. NIEMEYER, a Notary Public in and for the
6 County of Montgomery, State of Illinois, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that
7 the foregoing 4 pages comprise a true, complete and correct
8 transcript of the proceedings held on the 3rd of December A.D.,
9 2003, at The Illinois Pollution Control Board Hearing Room, 1021
10 North Grand Avenue East, Springfield, Illinois, in the case of
11 Illinois Ayers Oil Company v. Illinois Environmental Protection
12 Agency, in proceedings held before Hearing Officer Carol Sudman,
13 and recorded in machine shorthand by me.
14
IN WITNESS WHEREOF I have hereunto set my hand and affixed
15 my Notarial Seal this 5th day of December A.D., 2003.
1 6
.~.
.•.
OFFIC,~
.•.,~.•,.
17
~cs~T~~s
Notary Public and
20
Certified Shorthand Reporter aTnd
Registered Professional Reporter
21
CSR License No. 084-003677
22 My Commission Expires: 03—03-2007
23
24
5
JO ELAINE FOSTER & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
618-877—7016
Word Index
0
03-03-2007
1 5:22
03-214
2 1:6 3:5
084-003677
2 1:20 5:21
1
1
(1 2:9
101.600
(1 3:15
101 .632
(1 3:15
1021
(3 1:14 2:5 5:9
138
1 1:22
2
2003
(5 1:13 3:2 3:6 5:9 5:15
2004
~
4:2 4:4
3
6
618
(2 1:23 1:24
62034-0138
1 1:23
62701-1323
1 2:9
62794-9276
(1 2:6
655-0660
11 1:24
7
7th
(2 4:2 4:10
8
866
(1 1:21
877-7016
1 1:23
8:30
(2 4:2 4:11
9
9:00
(3 1:13 3:2 3:7
9:07
1 4:19
A
Action
1 3:11
AD
2 5:8 5:15
ADAM I
1 2:7
Affixed
1 5:14
Agency
4 1:8 2:3 3:21 5:12
Agency’s
1 3:10
ALEWE LI
1 2:7
Appeal
1 1:7
Appearances
1 3:17
Assistant
1 2:4
AS C IATES
1 1:22
Attorney
1 2:8
Avenue
3 1:15 2:5 5:10
Ayers
4 1:4 3:5 3:19 5:11
B
B ea rd
St
own
1 3:13
Beginning
1 3:6
Behalf
3 2:6 2:10 3:24
Board
4 1:1 1:14 3:4 5:9
Board’s
(3 3:14 3:15 4:3
Box
(1 1:22
C
Capitol
(1 2:9
Carbon
(1 1:23
Carol
3 1:15 3:3 5:12
Case
3 3:10 4:4 5:10
Cass
1 3:13
CCR
2 1:20 1:21
Certified
(1 5:20
CERTIFY
(1 5:6
Commission
1 5:22
Company
(4 1:4 3:5 3:19 5:11
Complete
1 5:7
Comprise
1 5:7
Concluded
(1 4:19
Conducted
1 3:14
Continue
1 4:10
Continued
(1 4:1
Control
(4 1:1 1:14 3:4 5:9
Correct
(1 5:7
East
3 1:15 2:5 5:10
ELAINE
1)1:22
Environmental
(4 1:7 2:3 3:21 5:11
EPA
1)2:6
Expires
111 5:22
Fax
(1 1:24
Filing
(1)4:2
Foregoing
(15:7
FOSTER
(1 1:22
Fred
F21 2:8 3:18
Glen
(1)1:23
Grand
(3 1:14 2:5 5:10
Granted
1
4:10
H
Hand
1 5:14
Hearing
14)1:141:153:33:43:53:13
3:22 3:24 4:6 4:9 4:10 4:15 5:9
5:12
Held
3)1:135:85:12
HEREBY
115:6
Hereunto
(1 5:14
High
1)3:11
IEPA
(113:6
Illinois
(20)1:1 1:41:71:141:151:20
1:232:32:62:62:93:53:193:
205:1 5:65:95:105:11 5:11
Issue
1)3:10
Machine
1)5:13
Madam
1 3:24
Matter
1)4:1
Matters
2)3:234:11
Members
1 3:8
Missouri
(1 1:21
Modification
(1 3:10
MOHAN
(1 2:7
Montgomery
(2 5:2 5:6
Morning
(1 3:3
Motion
1 4:9
Name
(113:3
Niemeyer
2)1:205:5
North
4 1:14 2:5 2:9 5:10
Notarial
1 5:15
Notary
(2)5:55:19
Note
1)3:8
Noticed
1)3:13
0
Objection
(2 4:7 4:8
Officer
9)1:153:33:43:223:244:64:
9 4:15 5:12
Oil
4 1:4 3:5 3:19 5:11
Old
1)2:9
P.C.
(11:22
P.O.
p
Index Page 1
111:22
Pages
1)5:7
Parties
1)3:16
PCB
211:63:5
Petitioner
3)1:53:194:1
Petitioner’s
1 3:11
Plan
1 3:11
Plaza
1)2:9
Pollution
4)1:1 1:143:45:9
Preliminary
1 3:23
Present
1)3:9
Prillaman
7)2:72:83:183:183:244:14
4:18
Priority
(13:11
Procedural
11
3:15
Proceeding
1 4:16
Proceedings
4)1:134:195:85:12
Professional
(1 5:20
Protection
(4)1:8 2:3 3:21 5:11
Public
(3 3:9 5:5 5:19
Pursuant
2 3:13 3:14
R
Recess
1 4:15
Record
3 3:8 3:17 4:12
Recorded
(1 5:13
Regarding
1
3:11
Registered
15:20
Reported
1 1:20
Reporter
2 5:20 5:20
Representing
(1)3:18
Respondent
4)1:92:103:204:6
Room
211:145:9
RPR
(1)1:20
Rules
2 3:14 3:15
Seal
(115:15
Sections
1)3:15
Set
1 5:14
Shorthand
2 5:13 5:20
Springfield
(4 1:15 2:6 2:9 5:10
SS
Ml 5:1
ILLINOIS AYERS OIL COMPANY VS. IEPA
Corrective
(1 3:11
Counsel
(2)2:42:5
County
3 3:13 5:2 5:6
CSR
F31 1:20 1:20 5:21
J
D
January
2 4:2 4:10
JO
1)1:22
John
2 2:4 3:20
Darlene
2)1:205:5
Deadline
Kim
1)4:3
December
5 1:13 3:2 3:6 5:8 5:15
Decision
(6 2:4 3:20 3:20 4:8 4:134:17
I..aw
2 4:3 4:3
Discuss
12:8
Legal
1
3:23
12:5
Division
License
1 2:5
3)1:201:21 5:21
Due
Located
1)4:4
(1)3:12
EM
3
(2 1:13 3:2
310
1 3:12
325
(1 2:9
3rd
(2 3:6 5:8
4
4
1 5:7
5
5th
~21
4:4 5:15
F
G
N
A. m.
2 3:7 4:11
Act
(1 3:14
S
185 Unique
Words
FOSTER & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
From 03-03-2007
to
SS
Word Index
ILLINOIS AYERS OIL COMPANY VS. IEPA
Index Page 2
State
3 3:12 5:1 5:6
Storage
1)3:12
Street
1 3:12
Sudman
8 1:163:33:43:224:64:94:
155:12
Suite
1 2:9
I
Tank
1) 3:12
Today
1 4:2
Transcript
1 5:8
True
1 5:7
U
Underground
1 3:12
UST
(1 1:7
V
Versus
1 3:6
Vs
1 1:6
W
Waiver
1) 4:3
WHEREOF
15:14
WITNESS
(15:14
185
Unique Words
FOSTER & ASSOCIATES,
P.C.
From State to WITNESS